Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Background. Previous studies have shown that preser- preserved papillary muscles and the mitral annulus in all
vation of the chordae tendineae improves early and late patients. One patient had adhesions between the pre-
postoperative left ventricular function after mitral valve served chordae and the stent of the tissue valve. The
replacement. This report describes the results of represer- chordal attachments were preserved during insertion of
vation of the chordae tendineae during redo mitral valve the second valve in all patients. The incidence of low
replacement in patients who had their chordae tendineae output syndrome and operative mortality in the chordae
preserved during their initial operation. group was 16.7% and 7.4%, respectively. In the nonchor-
Methods. Fifty-four patients undergoing reoperative dae group, the incidence of low output syndrome was
mitral valve replacement with preservation of their 27.3% (p -- 0.112 compared with the chordae group) and
chordal annular attachments (chordae group) were com- the operative mortality was 13.4% (p = 0.236 compared
pared with 187 patients who had redo mitral valve with the chordae group). In patients with double-valve
replacement without preservation of the chordae (non- replacement, represervation of the chg~dae was associ-
chordae group). The interval between the initial opera- ated with a reduction in low output syndrome (0% versus
tion and the reoperation was 8.7 - 4.4 years in the 24%; p = 0.034) and mortality (6.7% versus 15.5%; p =
chordae group and 8.6 - 4.9 years in the nonchordae 0.374).
group (p = 0.315). Seventy,three patients underwent Conclusions. Preservation of the chordal attachments
aortic valve replacement during their redo mitral valve between the papillary muscles and the mitral annulus
replacement compared with 168 patients who had mitral can be accomplished during reoperative mitral valve
valve replacement alone. There were 15 patients who had replacement. Represervation of the chordae tendineae
their chordal attachments represerved during redo dou- may reduce postoperative low output syndrome, espe-
ble-valve replacement. cially in high-risk patients undergoing redo double-
Results. In the chordae group, intraoperative assess- valve replacement.
ment revealed excellent chordal connections between the (Ann Thorac Surg 1996;62:179-83)
i,° 5
remnant papillary muscle base to the mitral annulus with
the aid of artificial Gore-Tex sutures. We encountered
little difficulty in preserving the chordae during repeat
operation. In most patients, the sewing ring of the pros-
0 thetic valve was carefully excised from the mitral annulus
and a new valve inserted without dissection of the
OM LOS OM LOS chordae. When a mechanical valve was inserted, we were
MVR M V R and AVR careful to ensure that the mechanical poppet did not
Fig 1. Effects of chordal preservation on postoperative low ou~Jut entrap any portion of the native subvalvular structures.
syndrome (LOS) and operative mortality (OM). (AVR = aortic In patients who received a monoleaflet valve, the major
valve replacement; MVR = mitral valve replacement.) orifice was oriented upward to avoid interference from
the posterior chordae. Implanting the St. Jude Medical
bileaflet valve was easier than the Sorin valve when the
chordae tendineae were being preserved.
factors for operative mortality. The Hosmer-Lemeshow The operative mortality was similar in the two groups.
goodness of fit p value for this model was 0.1160, indicat- We found no difference in preoperative predictors of
ing that the regression model is valid for this patient postoperative mortality. Patients in the nonchordae
population (goodness of fit p value > 0.05); however, the group had a greater number of previous cardiac proce-
predictive power of the model was poor, with an area dures. However, multiple previous operations did not
under the receiver operating characteristic curve of 64%. predict either mortality or the development of low output
The independent predictors for postoperative low out- syndrome.
put syndrome were preoperative angina (odds ratio = The incidence of postoperative low output syndrome
2.23; 95% confidence interval = 0.869 to 5.710) and male was less in patients undergoing chordae-sparing proce-
sex (odds ratio = 1.77; 95% confidence interval = 0.95 to dures; however, this too failed to reach statistical signif-
3.27). The Hosmer-Lemeshow goodness of fit p value for icance. In a high-risk subset of patients undergoing
this model was 0.101, with an area under the receiver simultaneous aortic and mitral valve replacement during
operating characteristic curve of 59%. their reoperation, the incidence of low output syndrome
Preservation of the chordal apparatus failed to emerge was reduced by preservation of the chordae tendineae
as an independent predictor of either postoperative low (chordae 0% versus nonchordae 24%; p = 0.034).
output syndrome or operative mortality. The power of the present study in detecting a differ-
ence in operative mortality or low output syndrome was
24% and 68%, respectively. If we had more patients in our
Comment
study, we may have found a significant improvement
More than a decade has passed since the revival of the with chordal preservation. For the observed difference in
chordae-sparing mitral valve replacement [1, 10]. Preser- operative mortality (7% versus 13%) and low output
vation of the subvalvular apparatus during operation has syndrome (17% versus 27%), we would have required 391
become the preferred technique when feasible. We re- and 268 patients per group, respectively, to achieve
cently presented the late results of a randomized trial statistical significance at a = 0.05.
comparing preservation of the chordae tendineae with no Preservation of the chordae tendineae and papillary
preservation [18]. Our results indicate that even 7 years muscles is now a standard procedure during mitral valve
postoperatively, those patients with preserved chordae replacement [22]. We believe that preservation of the
and papillary muscles had better left ventricular function chordae ~endineae is technically feasible and may im-
when compared with patients who underwent resection prove outcomes after reoperative mitral valve replace-
of the subvalvular apparatus. This finding corresponds to ment.
other reports of improved left ventricular function after
papillary muscle preservation [16, 17]. Olinger [21] pub-
Supported by the Heart and Stroke Foundation of Canada.
lished a case report of preservation of the chordae Doctor Rao is a Pharmaceutical Roundtable Research Fellow of
tendineae during repeat mitral valve replacement in the Heart and Stroke Foundation of Canada, Dr Weisel is a
1992. The present article reports the morphologic appear- career investigator of the Heart and Stroke Foundation of
ance of the preserved chordae and papillary muscles Ontario, and Dr Ikonomidis is a Research Fellow of the Heart
and Stroke Foundation of Ontario.
found at reoperation in a series of patients up to 22 years
Ann Thorac Surg RAO ET AL 183
1996;62:179-83 REPRESERVATIONOF CHORDAETENDINEAE