Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Giles M. Foody
School of Geography
University of Nottingham
giles.foody@nottingham.ac.uk
Background
Need for accuracy assessment established.
but is actually:
Occurs because ground data set is imperfect:
e.g.
- Underestimate producer’s accuracy.
- Typically overestimate prevalence (e.g. amount of
change).
difference.
Sample size determination
Often based on precision to estimate proportion
p(1 − p)
p ± h = p ± zα/2(SE) SE =
n
zα2 / 2 P(1 − P)
n=
h2
BUT
Aim is often not to estimate accuracy to a given
precision but to use in a comparative analysis
- comparison against a target
- comparison against another accuracy
(e.g. classifier comparison)
BUT
often inappropriate &
pessimistically biased
Comparative analysis
Comparative analyses often based on hypothesis
testing.
e.g. Ho – no difference in accuracy
H1 – the accuracy values differ
Is 0.8 adequate ?
2
e.g. P2 − P1 n − − zα / 2 2 P Q
P2 − P1
zβ =
P1Q1 + P2 Q2