‘COMMENT. COMPLIANCE STATEMENT REV ‘CONSULTANT COMMENTS \WALLTECH RESPONSE |i cacultion shal te submited wits cordinted lupdate shop dravings to reflect changes prevent jection of submission duet incomplete informatio. lreeably feloning load path. [al commen mentioned herein shal be applicable ‘sila cendisone [Any effects of such comments onthe stress and oading calculations tall be cai through the tected toad path in ealculation process. Outcome of enginecrng verifications such a steel, profi sizes, se-out nzerialength shall be coordinated and presented in drawing loodeting Se wil notte reviewed. Fajade conzactor stall esure input an ouspat be cel represented oa [sialon submission. [wre actions and forces are called out, refermce [pages reo be incited. [peas try why stick system and gas calalton have not ben included in this report. Provide updated sick system calculation addressing comments rom previous revisions. [All cletstions sal be provided in logical sequence} Gener! Comens ee Noted [FT As por approves catcuaton in Rev OmaTione Jace hanged from top bracket However as per up- lated shop drawings and ste candeion mulions are staked at bttom bracket At door location end mul lions are stacked but mulion on doors franged wich wit lead excassve load on ransom Jabove door due to buling movements. Hence mul- lion above door shall be released in dead lad and ransom shall be verifed for longer span above [door [Comments we resouon for Stick Curtin wall |Calculcion already provided in revision 1 and its lpproved, Refer aached document Revision submission was only fr the commen of perortod [panes [All calculations shal be eubmited with cordinated updated shop drawings o reflect changeso prevent ‘eton of eabmission det incomplete information, [Revised deal tached de legible delals Aso en re ected in shop drawings. a changes willbe re- Please cnity why supports are provided at his location Stand model revised by eng perforations and ‘lamin abe sears of 25 3 SHS with moment of| Inertia stacked Sel.veight and Full wind load spied [Revised analysis atached. Revise perforation pattern hall be created in mode "Noted, Refer comment 3 Please carity how fixing llows thermal expansion of stun panel ‘Panels re fixed betvoen mulion and transom smi class panel fixation sing gskcted pressure plate fixation. Exposed thermal expaion for the panel i 1.9R6nen. Expansion Provision provide fe mm. Please provide refrence snapshots fr applied load |Soapsot taced for le epi ious. Retr page nero[why 0.4 factor have bee considered? the pecvious Stand analysis was dose fo the complete pana without ay porfraions. So the salsis considering te actual Site elent plates with plate weght wil be ample To aan the aera condition, perforation wight reduced and given a slf weight reductive factor of 06, The Stand model erevised with exfrations hence self weight factor of 1 00s given, iu tease create pecoration in mode! and aply fll oad lo verity sities of pane dw prfrtion pater Stand mode! revised by adding preations and sominiam ike stifenreof25 3 SHS with moment of nerin ached Selfveigh and Full wind loud applied. Seengh and serviveabilyveriSction stached. fl tease incude the moment of inet ofthe stiffer in afuminium tbe tifeners of25x3SHS i rested othe ‘Stand mode. Moment of inertia ofthe siflener inthe {modal property is tached io the Page No: 8 u |provice veritcation of al connecon. Also provide |vrifcaton of eacing end iteaer. \Penel and stifener- Pane sn the stiffeners ae bonded together by suctral| (bonding estant ‘Stftensr Verifcation- etd fer suength and serviceability. Suteners to vera frame = Steers and veial perimeter fumes ae joined together with 5.518 serews at both ends, whichis eid and stached. ststener we] Fe 2 Joc mode with pnet incorrect o model steer seperately, Sifener should Steers are modeled along withthe perforated panel and verified for sengh nd servicsbty. ite |The ends offence shal be connected wo the end sme to atch the calculation asamption supers are connoced to the perimeter fame with 5.5 [ameter screws a both ends. Verification fire screws atached fe review:STRUCTURAL CALCULATION SOP-8.5-F3, REV 0, 10/09/2015 MANGROVE ROTANA RESORT wie po PEVORATED PANEL FORBALL ROOMNOOF SCREEN | erety [A Goptamer INTRODUCTION ‘This chapter includes analysis and design of perforated panel & stiffener verification for ball room roof screen. Panel is modelled as plate elements as in figure. ‘The panel is 1500mm width and 300mm height. Stiffeners are provided at every 500mm. SA H tenn sde—ramemy | Fig5:1 Stand Model nottom—pxeyee_| aa Mee ew este: EOE at Joy} Node 2: 0.903 peta cba leosly y): LIFDOOI matt ay) = = comms jn | weds: Gai, Steartran Yn): OAS gage Zi Materot Show AmainZ 0); C0515 watz cu >] Page 8 of 19STRUCTURAL CALCULATION SOP-8.5-F3, REV 0, 10/09/2015 4G Waltech ‘Project Name | MANGROVE ROTANA RESORT Ret.No. | SC-W120.193.07 Project No. | WI20-193 ‘STICK CURTAIN WALL SYSTEM PODIUM LEVEL & ‘eam PERFORATED PANEL FOR BALL ROOM ROOF SCREEN Prepared By | Arya Gopakumer 3. cheek Stiffeners are connected to the perimeter frame by 5.Sscrews at each end. Length x Effective Width x Thickness x density Dead load on screw = 1.2DL = Wind load on screw = 1.2WL = ‘Number of screws Dead Load ‘Shear Load 1.5m x 0.5m x 3mm x 2.72 0.61KN 0.73KN Length x Effective Width x Wind Load 1.5m x 0.5m x 2kN/m2 1.5kN 1.8KN 2 0.36kN 0.90KN [Repeated comment #71 Please provide verification of all lconnections. Also provide verification of |connection between cladding and stiffener. }1.Comment has partially addressed. Verification of sealant lbond between stiffener and cladding have not been veri- ied, Conclusion: Provide 5.5mm serews at both ends Page 14 of 19