Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Geierthiomersal Oltás
Geierthiomersal Oltás
Figure 2. (A) Neurodevelopment disorders and heart disease conditions reported following thimerosal-containing DTwcP in
comparison to thimerosal-free DTaP vaccines for increasing mercury dosage that children received from thimerosal; (B) Control
adverse events reported acutely following thimerosal-containing DTwcP in comparison to thimerosal-free DTaP vaccines for increasing
mercury dosage from thimerosal
guidelines for the oral ingestion of containing DTaP vaccines slightly raised DTaP vaccines for different mercury doses.
methylmercury, ranging from 2.7 to 37-fold the rate of adverse events compared to We found that administration of
at a given age. thimerosal-free DTaP vaccines, but the thimerosal-containing DTwcP vaccines
Figure 1A plots the relative risk of increased relative risks did not correlate significantly raised the rate of adverse
speech disorders, autism, and heart arrest with the total amount of mercury the events compared to thimerosal-free DTaP
reported after thimerosal-containing DTaP children received. vaccines, but the increased relative risks did
in comparison to thimerosal-free DTaP Figure 2A shows the relative risk of not correlate with the total amount of
vaccines for increasing doses of mercury. speech disorders, autism, and heart arrest mercury the children received.
We found that the data points for each reported after thimerosal-containing Figures 3A-B show the prevalence of
condition closely followed exponential DTwcP in comparison to thimerosal-free autism and speech disorders as a function of
distributions. DTaP vaccines for increasing dosage of the mercury dose that children received
Figure 1B plots the relative risks of mercury. We found that the data points from thimerosal contained in their child-
febrile seizure, fever, pain, edema, and hood vaccines. We found that the condi-
closely followed exponential distributions.
vomiting reported after thimerosal- tions analyzed closely followed linear
Figure 2B shows the relative risk of distributions with an increase of about one
containing DTaP in comparison to febrile seizure, fever, pain, edema, and case of autism per 100,000 children for
thimerosal-free DTaP vaccines. We found vomiting after thimerosal-containing every microgram present in childhood
that administration of thimerosal- DTwcP in comparison to thimerosal-free vaccines and about one case of speech
disorders per 1,000 children for every 3 µg thimerosal-containing DTaP and DTwcP ments, as shown in Figure 3C.
of mercury present in childhood vaccines. have higher rates of speech disorders, The lack of correlation between acute
Figure 3C shows the prevalence of the autism, and heart arrest overall, but also events and increasing mercury exposure
control disabilities of visual impairment, that the relative risk of each of these levels in the VAERS data argues against
deaf-blindness, and orthopedic impairment disorders correlated with increasing doses reporting bias or differences in the vaccines
as a function of the mercury dose that of mercury contained in childhood themselves and argues for the specific
children received from thimerosal con- vaccines, as illustrated in Figures 1A and effects of thimerosal on neurodevelopment
tained in their childhood vaccines. We 2A. Figures 1B and 2B show that exposure disorders and heart disease. Likewise, the
found that the prevalence of these condi- to increasing doses of mercury is not lack of correlation between visual impair-
tions did not correlate with the increasing correlated to acute vaccine adverse events ments, deaf-blindness, or orthopedic
total amount of mercury the children including febrile seizures, fever, pain, impairments and the increasing mercury
received. edema, or vomiting. exposure levels in the US Department of
Our demonstration of a significant Education data also argues for the specific
Discussion overall increase in the relative risks of acute effects of thimerosal in childhood vaccines
It is clear from our analysis, shown in adverse events following DTwcP vaccine on the prevalence of autism and speech
Table 1, that US infants are exposed to when compared to thimerosal-free DTaP disorders.
mercury levels from their childhood vaccine is not surprising since our previous As an additional epidemiological
immunization schedule that far exceed the studies have shown that DTwcP vaccines confirmation of our findings, we analyzed
EPA and FDA-established maximum are far more reactogenic than DTaP the CDC's Phase I Thimerosal Vaccine
permissible levels for the daily oral vaccines.1 5 , 1 However,
6
we observed that Safety Datalink (VSD) data.1 7 We found
ingestion of methylmercury. The fact that only those events for which causation by this data showed that the increasing relative
mercury in the vaccines is given by thimerosal is biologically plausible were risk of developmental neurologic disorder,
injection rather than by oral ingestion only found to be correlated with the mercury autism, speech disorder, and attention
makes the exposure levels worse because levels children received in their vaccines. deficit disorder all closely followed
Geier et al. showed that the distribution of Our analyses of a completely independ- exponential distributions with increasing
foreign particles in mice reached several- ent source, the US Department of mercury levels from the thimerosal that
logs higher concentration in organs Education's report on the prevalence of children received as part of their childhood
following intravenous or intramuscular various childhood disease among school immunizations.
injections than via oral ingestion.1 4 children of various ages, showed autism We conducted a MEDLINE (1966-
Our previous studies comparing DTaP and speech disorders were correlated with 2003) search for the terms merthiolate and
with and without thimerosal have shown a increasing mercury from childhood thimerosal and found almost 1,500
statistically and clinically significant vaccines, as shown in Figures 3A-B. No references, primarily about various adverse
increase in neurodevelopment disorders in correlation was seen between increasing outcomes following exposure. Of particu-
those vaccinated with thimerosal- mercury exposure from childhood vaccines lar interest, Bernard et al. have compared
containing vaccines.8 Our current study not and the prevalence of visual impairments, the similar biological abnormalities
only shows that those vaccinated with deafness-blindness, or orthopedic impair- commonly found in autism and the