Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1 Rata Veterinary Surgery, Bristol, United Kingdom Address for correspondence Andrew B. Scrimgeour, BVSc, BPhil(Vet),
2 Southwern Counties Veterinary Specialists, MANZCVS(Surgery), MVM(Surgery), Rata Veterinary Surgery,
Ringwood, United Kingdom 9 Stanley Road, Bristol BS6 6NP, United Kingdom
(e-mail: andrew@ratavetsurgery.co.uk).
Vet Comp Orthop Traumatol 2017;30:453–460.
Abstract Objectives To assess screw loosening and pelvic narrowing following the use of
locking implants to stabilise ilial body fractures in cats and small dogs.
Methods Review of clinical records and post operative and follow up radiography of
12 cats and five small dogs to evaluate accuracy of fracture reduction, screw purchase
Keywords and subsequent screw loosening and reduction in pelvic diameter.
► fracture repair Results No screw loosening or reduction in pelvic diameter was observed at follow up.
Surgical Procedure minuted and the remainder were simple fractures. Ipsilateral
Patients were positioned in lateral recumbency. A standard ischial and pubic fractures were present in 11/17 cases, and
lateral surgical approach was made to the ilium involving contralateral sacroiliac luxation in 4 cases. Two cases had
‘roll-up’ of the gluteal muscles.12 Fracture reduction was concurrent sacral body fractures and an ipsilateral acetabular
facilitated where necessary by the manipulation of frag- fracture occurred in one case. Concurrent orthopaedic injuries
ments through the application of bone holding forceps to not including the pelvis were recorded in three cases (one
the greater trochanter or the ischiatic tuberosity. Where tarsal luxation, one ipsilateral hip luxation and one case with
possible, reduction of the fracture was maintained by the use multiple metatarsal fractures of the contralateral limb). These
of self-centring bone forceps or pointed reduction forceps. A cases are detailed in ►Appendix Table 1.
2.0- or 2.4-mm locking T-plate (Securos) with the appro- Mean time to surgery from injury was 3 days (range 1–15
priate number of screw holes as determined by the surgeon days) and follow-up radiography ranged from 28 to 270 days
was approximately contoured and applied to the ilium, and with a mean of 42 days.
the appropriate length locking screws were placed through The 2.4-mm locking T-plates were used in five cases
the plate into the bone. The orientation of the cross section of (three dogs and two cats). One was a five-hole plate, three
the T-plate, whether placed cranially or caudally, was accord- were six-hole plates and one was a seven-hole plate. The
ing to surgeon choice. T-section of the plate was caudally orientated in four cases
Where fracture stabilization using bone holding forceps and cranially orientated in one case. In the remaining
was not feasible, the plate was first applied to the caudal 12 cases, 2.0-mm locking T-plates were used, ranging in
fragment of the fracture, then temporary fracture fixation size from four-hole plates to eight-hole plates, with a mean
was achieved through the use of a 1.0-mm Kirschner wire of six holes. The T-section of the plate was orientated
No minor or major complications were recorded for any loid fractures included one feline case.15 This case also
case in this study, and all ilial fractures had achieved radio- suffered screw loosening.
graphic union at follow-up radiography. Screw loosening and loss of construct stability can allow
pelvic canal narrowing. It has been suggested that pelvic
narrowing of 45% or greater during postoperative healing of
Discussion
the ilial fracture was associated with a high risk of recurrent
The most commonly reported complication of repair of ilial constipation.13 The mean change in sacral index of the 18
fractures with non-locking lateral bone plating is screw cases in this study was 0 (range: –2.2 to þ6.1%).
loosening. Screw loosening was reported in 5/10 cases Non-locking bone plates rely on friction between the plate
repaired with a single laterally placed dynamic compression and underlying bone to confer stability to a fracture repair. The
plate, compared with 1/13 cases repaired with a single friction attained is a product of the coefficient of friction of the
locking plate and 0/11 cases where a double locking plate implant and the compressive force on the bone of the screws
construct was used.14 A case series using non-locking tibial inserted through the plate.16 Placing screws with increased
plateau levelling osteotomy plates to repair ilial supracoty- torque will increase the friction applied to the plate and should
lead to a more durable fixation. Studies in other species suggest retightened adequately, suggesting screw loosening, rather
a screw insertion torque in excess of 3 Nm is required to than pull-out, had occurred. When locking triple pelvic osteot-
provide adequate friction between plate and bone to provide a omy plates and screws were used to secure the ilial osteotomy
stable construct.16 To our knowledge, these data have not been during triple pelvic osteotomy surgery, no screw loosening
ascertained for lateral plate fixation of small animal ilial was observed.18 Low torque resistance may limit the genera-
fractures, but an experimental study found stripping of screws tion of sufficient torque during screw placement to provide an
inserted into the cranial ilial wing of dogs occurred frequently adequate degree of plate–bone friction, and ensure construct
at a torque of 1.8 Nm.11 This was a study using cadaveric bone, durability throughout the period of fracture healing.
which may not reflect the true resistance of ilial bone to screw The mode of loading of the pelvis is cantilever bending
stripping in vivo, but it does suggest that a durable bone– and the tension aspect of the ilium is the ventral aspect
implant interface sufficient to allow uncomplicated fracture during weight bearing. All fractures in our case series and in
healing may be difficult to achieve in the cranial ilial wing. previous studies were transverse fractures or oblique frac-
Premature implant loosening when a non-locking plate is tures orientated in a cranioventral to caudodorsal direc-
applied to stabilize an ilial fracture may therefore be inevitable tion.5,13 When ilial fracture fixation is performed with
in some cases. A study of implant stability following triple lateral non-locking plating, load sharing between the frac-
pelvic osteotomy surgery found that premature screw loosen- ture fragments and implants in these fracture configurations
ing occurred in 57% of cases.17 All of these screws could be is limited to that provided by friction between fragments
(and only in a situation of anatomical reduction and com- that historically a proportion of pelvic fractures have been
pression). Thus, the implants are required to sustain the successfully managed conservatively.21 The most serious
majority of forces acting on the repair during healing of ilial complication of pelvic narrowing is constipation leading to
fractures, in contrast to fracture patterns where load sharing obstipation and megacolon.13 Management of this condi-
between implants and fracture fragments is achieved. tion may involve surgery and carry a poor prognosis.22,23
Screws applied from lateral to medial across the ilium engage Our results suggest that, as the degree of pelvic canal
bone which has thin cortices that are close together, short- narrowing was not affected by the accuracy of reduction
ening the working length of the screw. The latter factor was of the fractured ilium, the intraoperative priority should be
highlighted by the finding in our study that screws placed in to establish adequate pelvic diameter rather than anatomi-
the cranial segment had less screw purchase than those in cal reduction of the fracture.
the caudal segment. These factors are considered important In addition to the cases reported as a single study pre-
in screw loosening following lateral plating of ilial fractures. viously, the use of locking plates for the repair of pelvic
Loosening of screws may result in patient discomfort and fractures has been described as part of a series of fracture
pelvic canal narrowing and is therefore to be avoided.5 repairs with different implant systems.24–26 There were not
Locking plates and screws do not rely on the screw–bone any recorded complications with these repairs, although
interface or avoidance of toggling (the mechanism of screws specific analysis on the fracture repairs was not provided.
pivoting within the screw holes during loading) to maintain There are major limitations to our case series as it was a
stability and may therefore be beneficial in situations of poor retrospective study without a control group or use of alter-
bone rigidity and short screw working lengths. nate implant systems for fracture repair to allow comparison
The results of this study suggest that the risks of premature with differing locking plate systems.
7 Hulse DA, Vangundy TE, Johnson S, et al. Compression screw 16 Egol KA, Kubiak EN, Fulkerson E, Kummer FJ, Koval KJ. Biomecha-
stabilisation of oblique ilial fractures in the dog. Vet Comp Orthop nics of locked plates and screws. J Orthop Trauma 2004;18(08):
Traumatol 1989;4:162–167 488–493
8 Bowlt KL, Shales C. Repair of a transverse ilial fracture in a cat 17 Bogoni P, Rovesti GL. Early detection and treatment of screw loosen-
using an intramedullary pin. Vet Comp Orthop Traumatol 2010; ing in triple pelvic osteotomy. Vet Surg 2005;34(03):190–195
23(03):186–189 18 Rose SA, Bruecker KA, Petersen SW, Uddin N. Use of locking plate and
9 Burton NJ. Composite fixation of comminuted ilial wing fractures screws for triple pelvic osteotomy. Vet Surg 2012;41(01):114–120
in cats: three cases. J Feline Med Surg 2011;13(05):376–382 19 Koch D. Screws and plates. In: Johnson AL, Houlton JEF, Vannini R,
10 Fitzpatrick N, Lewis D, Cross A. A biomechanical comparison of ed. AO Principles of Fracture Management in the Dog and Cat.
external skeletal fixation and plating for the stabilization of ilial Davos, Switzerland: AO Publishing; 2005:26–51
osteotomies in dogs. Vet Comp Orthop Traumatol 2008;21(04): 20 Troger JC, Viguier E. Use of T-plates for the stabilisation of supra-
349–357 cotyloid ilial fractures in 18 cats and five dogs. Vet Comp Orthop
11 Case JB, Dean C, Wilson DM, Knudsen JM, James SP, Palmer RH. Traumatol 2008;21(01):69–75
Comparison of the mechanical behaviors of locked and nonlocked 21 Denny HR. Pelvic fractures in the dog: a review of 123 cases.
plate/screw fixation applied to experimentally induced rotational J Small Anim Pract 1978;(19):151–166
osteotomies in canine ilia. Vet Surg 2012;41(01):103–113 22 Schrader SC. Pelvic osteotomy as a treatment for obstipation in
12 Johnson KA. The pelvis and hip joint. In: Piermattei’s Atlas of cats with acquired stenosis of the pelvic canal: six cases (1978-
Surgical Approaches to the Bones and Joints of the Dog and Cat. 1989). J Am Vet Med Assoc 1992;200(02):208–213
5th ed. St Louis, MO: Elsevier Saunders; 2014:317–320 23 Matthiesen DT, Scavelli TD, Whitney WO. Subtotal colectomy for
13 Hamilton MH, Evans DA, Langley-Hobbs SJ. Feline ilial fractures: the treatment of obstipation secondary to pelvic fracture mal-
assessment of screw loosening and pelvic canal narrowing after union in cats. Vet Surg 1991;20(02):113–117
lateral plating. Vet Surg 2009;38(03):326–333 24 Tan CJ, Johnson KA. Stabilisation of periarticular fractures and
14 Schmierer PA, Kircher PR, Hartnack S, Knell SC. Screw loosening osteotomies with a notched head locking T-plate. Aust Vet J 2016;
and pelvic canal narrowing after lateral plating of feline ilial 94(10):377–383
Case Species Age (y) Sex Breed Weight Injury Concurrent Time to
(kg) injuries surgery
(d)
1 Canine 2 FN JRT 8.7 Right oblique ilial Right ischial and 2
fracture pubic fractures
2 Canine 3 FN JRT 6.1 Right oblique ilial Right ischial and 1
fracture pubic fractures
3 Feline 2 MN DLH 5.7 Right oblique ilial Left sacroiliac 4
fracture luxation
4 Feline 2 MN DSH 3.4 Right oblique ilial S1 transverse 1
fracture, fracture
moderate (previous
comminution contralateral mid
femoral limb
amputation)
5 Feline 1 MN DSH 2.8 Right oblique ilial Left sacroiliac 3
fracture luxation
6 Canine 3 FN JRT 6.1 Right oblique ilial Left sacroiliac 2
fracture luxation, tarsal
Abbreviations: DLH, Domestic Longhair cat; DSH, Domestic Shorthair cat; FN, female neutered; JRT, Jack Russell Terrier; MN, male neutered; YT,
Yorkshire Terrier.
Case Plate used and Other surgical Pelvic alignment Number Screw Number Screw Days to Postopera- Change in Loss in
orientation for procedures following of screws purchase of screws purchase follow-up tive sacral sacral screw
repair of ilial performed fracture repair in cranial (mm) in caudal (mm) index index (%) purchase
fracture fragment fragment (mm)
1 7-hole 2.4 mm Good 3 13.5 3 19.3 28 1.03 1.0 0
T caudal
2 6-hole 2.4 mm Good 3 11.4 3 20.8 28 1.02 0 0
T cranial
3 5-hole 2.4 mm Transilial pin Near anatomic 2 17.8 2 13.0 28 0.93 6.1 0
T caudal
4 8-hole 2.0 mm Good 4 28.0 3 27.8 28 0.94 0 0
T caudal
T caudal
6 6-hole 2.4 mm Sacroiliac screw, Good 3 22.1 3 15.2 42 0.96 0 0
Vol. 30
T caudal pantarsal arthrodesis
7 6-hole 2.0 mm 5-hole 2.0-mm PAX Fair 3 13.4 3 17.6 56 1.07 0 0
T caudal plate on acetabulum
No. 6/2017
8 5-hole 2.0 mm External fixator to Anatomic 2 17.2 2 12.2 28 1.00 2.0 0
T caudal repair metacarpal
Scrimgeour et al.
fractures
9 6-hole 2.0 mm Good 2 11.0 2 17.2 56 0.80 0 0
T caudal
10 6-hole 2.4 mm Anatomic 2 9.9 2 10.8 56 0.98 0 0
T cranial
11 6-hole 2.0 mm Anatomic 3 18.6 2 13.9 42 0.94 -2.2 0
T caudal
12 7-hole 2.0 mm Sacroiliac screw Fair 3 18.6 2 13.0 70 0.91 4.2 0
T caudal
13 6-hole 2.0 mm Fair 3 18.1 3 17.9 56 0.99 0 0
T caudal
14 7-hole 2.0 mm Anatomic 3 17.1 2 12.6 42 0.93 0 0
T cranial
15 4-hole 2.0 mm 6-hole 2.0-mm PAX Anatomic 2 8.5 2 10.5 42 0.99 0 0
T caudal transilial plate
16 6-hole 2.0 mm Good 2 9.5 2 10.5 60 0.85 0 0
T caudal
17 7-hole 2.4 mm Femoral head and Fair 2 12.5 3 19.0 56 1.04 0 0
T cranial neck ostectomy