You are on page 1of 4

744901

research-article2017
SRIXXX10.1177/1553350617744901Surgical InnovationMarkatos et al

History of Innovation
Surgical Innovation

Ambroise Paré (1510-1590) and His


2018, Vol. 25(2) 183­–186
© The Author(s) 2017
Reprints and permissions:
Innovative Work on the Treatment of sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.nav
DOI: 10.1177/1553350617744901
https://doi.org/10.1177/1553350617744901

War Injuries journals.sagepub.com/home/sri

Konstantinos Markatos, MD, PhD1  , Anna Tzivra, MD, PhD2,


Spyridon Tsoutsos, MD, PhD2, Gerasimos Tsourouflis, MD, PhD3,
Marianna Karamanou, MD, PhD1, and Georgios Androutsos, MD, PhD1

Abstract
The purpose of this study is to summarize the innovations of Ambroise Paré (1510-1590) on the treatment of war
wounds and improving amputation technique through ligature in arteries and veins. Ambroise Paré debunked the
widely accepted idea that gun powder was poisonous for wounds. He also minimized the use of cautery of wounds by
his dressing methods and the application of ligature during amputations. All these innovative rationales revolutionized
the practice of war surgery during the Renaissance and paved the way for the introduction of modern surgery.
Nevertheless, although his wound dressing innovations became widely accepted, the same did not happen with ligature
and amputation; those techniques could become widely applicable if one could somehow control bleeding until the
blood vessels had been tied. This became possible much later in the 18th century when Jean Louis Petit invented the
first useful and efficient tourniquet.

Keywords
history of medicine, orthopedic surgery, surgical education

Introduction Barber-surgeons had earned the right to be taught anatomy


and surgery in the medical school of Paris and shortly after
Ambroise Paré (1510-1590) (Figure 1) was one of the they could take the official master-barber’s examination; in
most prominent surgeons of his time. For many, he is this way they became accepted and recognized in the aca-
considered as the “Father of Modern Surgery.” The son of demic circles as a distinct professional class.1-3
a barber-surgeon and a trained barber-surgeon himself, he Ambroise Paré became an apprentice barber-surgeon
managed to overcome the obstacles of not having signifi- at an early age; later on he became barber-surgeon at the
cant academic education that he was not provided with. Hotel Dieu, Paris, and surgeon in the army of Francis I
He was one of the most significant innovators of the (1536-1538). He reenlisted on the French army multiple
Renaissance in the fields of military operation, bandages, times, and in 1545 he began the study of anatomy at Paris,
wound healing, bloodletting, close blood vessels tech- under François-Jacques Dubois (Sylvius). He was
niques, and cesarean section.1 appointed as a field surgeon by Marshal Rohan, and in
The purpose of this study is to summarize his innova- 1552, he was named surgeon to King Henry II.2,3
tions on treating war wounds and improving amputation For the next decade, he followed the French Army where
technique through ligature in arteries and veins. he acquired a significant experience in traumatology. He

The Biography of Ambroise Paré 1


Biomedical Research Foundation of the Academy of Athens, Athens,
Ambroise Paré was born in 1510 in Bourg-Hersent in Greece
2
Kapandriti Medical Center, Oropos, Attiki, Athens, Greece
northwestern France. At the age of 19, he was admitted at 3
National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, Athens, Greece
the Hotel-Dieu Hospital of Paris where the most famous
barber-surgeon school of the time was active. There, he Corresponding Author:
Konstantinos Markatos, Biomedical Research Foundation of the
studied and worked for 4 years. By the time Paré entered
Academy of Athens, 4 Soranou Ephessiou Street, Athens 11527,
the Hotel Dieu, the University of Paris had started to use Greece.
barber-surgeons and their expertise in its education system. Email: gerkremer@yahoo.gr
184 Surgical Innovation 25(2)

Nevertheless, although he is considered the father of


modern surgery, just like his contemporaries and col-
leagues, he did not enjoy the same esteem and respect
that surgeons do today. Surgeons at the time had a lesser
education and they were working mainly with their
hands; therefore, they were considered somehow inferior
to physicians, who practiced pure and intellectually supe-
rior medicine. Paré’s publications were constantly criti-
cized by physicians and he personally was damned for
entering their fields and daring to write about topics
beyond his education and area of specialization.2,3

Paré and His Groundbreaking


Treatment of Gunshot Wounds
Perhaps the most important innovation of Paré was his
technique and contribution to the treatment of gunshot
wounds. Up to this point in the history of medicine, such
wounds were treated by means of cautery by applying
burning iron or potential cautery through the use of scald-
ing oil. This was done in order to destroy the so-called
poison and to forestall putrefaction according to the most
accepted views of the era.1
Paré described an incident when he was a novice sur-
geon in Italy in 1537 on a military campaign of the French
Figure 1.  Portrait of Ambroise Paré (1510-1590).
Army. When he ran out of oil he had to improvise in order
to treat the wounded soldiers. He made a healing salve
was a great reformer of surgery at a time when most sur- consisting of egg-white, rose-oil, and turpentine. The fol-
geons supported the advantages of blood loss for trauma lowing night he could not sleep feeling guilty for the
patients. His contribution was acknowledged in 1554 when patients whose wounds he had not cauterized because of
he became a fellow of the College of Surgeons of Saint- lack of oil, so he got up early to pay them a visit in dis-
Come.1,2 In 1563, after the siege of Rouen, he was appointed tress. He was surprised to see that those treated with the
first surgeon and named chamberlain to King Charles IX, salve suffered little pain, had no inflammation or swell-
later also serving Henry III and Catherine de Medici.3 ing, and they had a quiet, relatively painless night.
He was accepted as the king’s barber-surgeon in 1552 Moreover, those treated with burning oil suffered from
under Henry II of France, and although he failed to cure high fever with aches and inflammation around the
him from a head injury that occurred during a tournament wound. Therefore, he resolved never again to burn
in 1559, he remained in the service of the kings of France patients suffering from shot wounds.2-4
with the assistance and supervision of Andreas Vesalius Thus, Paré managed to dissolve the widely accepted
(1514-1564) until his death in 1590. He served under myth that gunpowder and gunshots were poisonous. He
Henry II, Francis II, Charles IX, and Henry III.3 thereafter started treating gunshot wounds through the
According to Henry IV’s Prime Minister, Sully, Paré application of the salve he had invented that day made of
was a Huguenot, and on August 24, 1572, the day of the egg, oil of roses, and turpentine.3
St. Bartholomew’s Day Massacre, the King, in order to
save him from the Massacre, had him confined in a Paré and the Use of Ligatures in
clothes closet. Henry IV was so fond of him and appraised
his services constantly and in every chance given. Paré
Amputations
died in Paris in 1590 from natural causes in his 80th year. One of the most groundbreaking innovation that Paré had
While there is evidence that Paré may have been inclined to offer in the history of surgery was the use of ligatures
to the Huguenot movement and their religious beliefs, he in the procedures of limb amputations. This technique is
seems to have kept his distances by accepting the Catholic described in detail in his Ten Books of Surgery. Paré had
dogma in order to avoid prosecutions. He was married to rediscover the use of ligatures, and he used a thread-
twice, he had a Catholic funeral, and he had his children like or wire material used with a needle to constrict blood
baptized into the Catholic faith.2,3 vessels (arteries and veins as well) in patients and stop
Markatos et al 185

Paré also constructed limbs for the amputee soldiers he


had treated. His main innovation was that he demanded
them to be functional, not just stopgap solutions. Paré was
an accomplished anatomist taught by Sylvius, and so when
he designed limbs, he attempted to make them work the
way biological limbs worked. The legs he designed carried
a mechanical knee that could be locked when standing and
bent at will. He designed an arm that could be bent with a
pulley that mimicked arm muscles. Paré had the idea to use
the progress in robotics that occurred in his period to create
prostheses that worked with the mechanical devices
invented for robotic toys or clocks. After all the mechani-
cal revolution was at hand and every major innovator tried
to implement its teachings in his work.6,7
His mechanical hand was operated by multiple catches
Figure 2.  Ambroise Paré performing a leg amputation of a and springs, which simulated the joints and movements
wounded soldier in the field of battle. of a biological hand. When he showed his design to his
colleagues, it was accepted by such enthusiasm that they
worked up a prototype, and in 1551, a movable prosthesis
bleeding during amputations (Figure 2). Other writers designed by Paré was worn into battle by amputees.6,7
before him had proposed ligature for blood loss manage- Nevertheless, in cases of extensive amputations the
ment during amputation, but Paré was the one who solved great number of ligatures required made the presence of a
the practical problems and established this technique as trained assistant mandatory (in the case of a thigh ampu-
safe and usable.1,4,5 tation at least 53 ligatures are necessary under this proce-
At the time, the usual method of sealing wounds was by dure). Therefore, this method could become widely
cauterization with a red-hot iron, which often failed to applicable if one could somehow control bleeding until
arrest the bleeding and caused patients to die of shock. the blood vessels had been tied. This became possible
Paré, for the ligature technique, designed the “Bec de much later in the 18th century when Jean Louis Petit
Corbin,” which had a similar use to modern hemostats. invented the first useful and efficient tourniquet.2,6
Although ligatures had often been criticized for spreading Ambroise Paré summarized his massive experience
infections, they were still an important innovation in surgi- and innovations in the treatment of war injuries in his
cal practice. Paré described in detail the technique of using textbook titled The Method of Curing Wounds Made by
ligatures to prevent hemorrhaging during amputation in his Gunshot.4,7
1564 book Treatise on Surgery. One of the most notable
clinical observation of Paré, during his work with injured
soldiers, was the pain experienced by amputees, which Conclusion
they perceive as sensation in the “phantom” amputated The achievement of Paré was literally groundbreaking for
limb and it could last for weeks and months after the ampu- his time; he debunked the widely accepted idea that gun
tation. Paré believed that phantom pains occur in the brain powder was poisonous for the wounds. He also minimized
(the consensus of the medical community today) and not in the use of cautery of wounds by his dressing methods and
remnants of the limb, so he described it as a neurologically the application of ligature during amputations. All these
based side-effect of the amputation.4,5 innovative rationales revolutionized the practice of war
Paré, in a letter he wrote to Etienne Gourmelen, in surgery during the Renaissance and paved the way for the
defense of his choice to use ligature instead of cautery, introduction of modern surgery. Paré remained surpris-
refers to the instructions of Hippocrates and later Galen, ingly humble and timid with the revolution he provoked in
Celsus, and their Arab follower Aviccena, who recom- surgery. At the siege of Metz in 1552, having witnessed all
mended the use of tying around a vessel or limb to stop the deaths and surgical failures during military campaigns,
bleeding. In addition, he mentions the recommendations after his first successful amputation of the leg of an officer
of his contemporaries like Vezalius, Guy de Chauliac, with ligature, he expressed his moderate character through
Hollier, Jean de Vigo, Tagault, Pierre de Argellata of his historic phrase: “I dressed him and God healed him.”1,2,5
Boulogne, John Andreas a Cruce, D’Alechamp, and Bec
de Corbin Calmetheus, who all suggest tying vessels and Author Contributions
limbs with ligature to stop massive and lethal bleeding Study concept and design: Konstantinos Markatos, Anna
during amputations and major traumatic conditions.4,5 Tzivra, Spyridon Tsoutsos
186 Surgical Innovation 25(2)

Acquisition of data: Konstantinos Markatos, Anna Tzivra, References


Spyridon Tsoutsos, Gerasimos Tsourouflis
1. Kennedy MT. A Brief History of Disease, Science and
Analysis and interpretation: Konstantinos Markatos, Marianna
Medicine. Mission Viejo, CA: Asklepiad Press; 2004.
Karamanou, Gerasimos Tsourouflis
Study supervision: Georgios Androutsos 2. Porter R. The Greatest Benefit to Mankind: A Medical
History of Humanity. New York, NY: WW Norton; 1999.
Declaration of Conflicting Interests 3. Hernigou P. Ambroise Paré’s life (1510-1590): part I. Int
Orthop. 2013;37:543-547.
The author(s) declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect
4. Paré A. Oeuvres d’Ambroise Paré. Paris, France: J-B
to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.
Baillière; 1840-1841.
5. Hernigou P. Ambroise Paré II: Paré’s contributions to
Funding
amputation and ligature. Int Orthop. 2013;37:769-772.
The author(s) received no financial support for the research, 6. Renner C. The tourniquet of Jean-Louis Petit [in French].
authorship, and/or publication of this article. Hist Sci Med. 2014;48:125-130.
7. Hernigou P. Ambroise Paré III: Paré’s contributions to sur-
ORCID iD gical instruments and surgical instruments at the time of
Konstantinos Markatos  https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5753-1927 Ambroise Paré. Int Orthop. 2013;37:975-980.

You might also like