Accelerat ing t he world's research.

Building information modeling

Flavia Rodrigues de Souza

ASHRAE Journal

Cite this paper Downloaded from Academia.edu 

Get the citation in MLA, APA, or Chicago styles

Related papers Download a PDF Pack of t he best relat ed papers 

A BIM-enabled informat ion infrast ruct ure for building energy Fault Det ect ion and Diagnost ics
Zheng Oneill, Zhengwei Li

Full Mast er T hesis "Framework for t he t ransfer of building mat erials dat a bet ween t he BIM and t her…
Anna Shadrina

Early Design Energy Analysis Using Building Informat ion Modeling Technology
Annet t e St umpf
 Gaining
Monientum
Building Information Modeling
By Gordon V.R. Holness, RE., Fellow/Life Member ASHRAE because it allows all interested parties to,
transparently and in real time, share, ap-
ply and update information about build-

T
his article reviews recent developments in building information modeling
ings. ASHRAF can play a significant role
(BIM) and interoperability and the impact of this technology on ASHRAE. in this effort, if it is prepared to commit
resources and develop specific goals in
Clearly, sustainabiiity is a major focus of the Society through its 2006 Strategic establishing basic HVAC terminology,
data dictionaries, rule sets, and schema
Plan and all subsequent developments: Vision 2020, Proposed Standard 189, for its Handbook and standards to sup-
port ihe building industry in electronic
Standard for the Design of High-Performance Green Buildings Except Low-Rise data exchange.
The establishment of an ASHRAE
Residentiai Buildings, the Advanced Energy Design Guide series, etc. However,
Building Information Modeling and
Interoperability Steering Committee
paralleling these efforts is recognition that issues such as integrated building
under the Technology Council is an ex-
cellent start. It indicates recognition by
design play a critical role if we, as an industry, are to succeed. Sustainabiiity and
ASHRAE of the role technology can play
in the development of better buildings
many other issues associated with building design, construction, commissioning,
(whether better is defined as sustainable,
and operation are interwoven and interdependent such that everyone involved with more energy efficient, safer or less cost-
ly). As ASHRAE rolls out educational
buildings must work together if individual objectives are to be fully realized. programs, seminars, white papers, and
other publications on BIM, including a
BIM is the process of using intelligent members. BIM encompasses the use of planned ASHRAE BIM guide, it needs to
graphic and data modeling software to three-dimensional, real-time, intelligent
create optimized and integrated building and dynamic modeling, and can be a About the Author
design solutions, as defined by the 2007 valuable tool in facilitating successful Gordon V.R, Holness, RE., is a consulting engi-
ASHRAE Handhook^tiVAC Applica- coordination and collaboration. This is neer in Detroit. He is also treasurer on ASHRAE's
tions. More importantly to ASHRAE critical to integrated building design Board of Directors.

28 ASHRAE Journal ashrae.org June 2008

be cognizant of the bigger picture: the potential impact of BIM (BSA) (www.buildingsmartalliance.org) believes that
on almost everything it does as a technical society, not just on BIM has the potential to save more than $200 billion per year
technology associated with buildings, btit the actual process of in construction costs.
design, construction, commissioning, and operation. Clearly, the use of BIM technology has gained wider acceptance
As disctissed in this paper, a significant amount of work is be-
in the past two yeai-s. A recent McGraw-Hill Constaiction 2007
ing done worldwide on software tool and protocol developments Interoperability SmartMarket^^^ RepoH of the building industry
by government agencies, nonprofit and research organizations, (www.mcgraw-hiil.com/releases/construction/20071024.shtml)
as well as commercial entities, to facilitate and promote BIM indicatesBIM is used by approximately 20% of designers. However,
technology. Also discussed are developments in application the responses also indicate a projected use of 80% withinfiveyears
software. The good news is that many, if not most, of these and 100% within 10 years. Although tliose numbei-s may seem
developments will provide greater interoperability. optimistic, it indicates the potential of BIM having a significiint
impact on. and creating a considerable opportunity for. ASHRAE
Overview of BIM members, whether they are in the design, construction, or manu-
BIM is the assembly of a single database of fully integrated facturing side of tlie industry. BIM technology already has proven
and interoperable information that can be used seamlessly and to ijicrease collaboration between design disciplines and between
sequentially by all members of the design and construction team designers and constructors. It also allows others who are involved in
and. ultimately, by owners/op- the process such as lenders, owners,
erators throughout a facility's life and dev elopers to better understand
cycle. The desired result is a B!M buildings and more effectively
model where three-dimensional participate and contribute.
(3D) graphical imaging carries Intelligent modeling technol-
real-time (i.e., immediate and ogy can start with direct data
dynamic access) data, and where transfer from the design calcula-
c\cry line and every object car- tion software and spreadsheets,
ries real-life intelligent physical into graphic layouts (for systems
and performance data. such as structural steel, fire
The technology of BIM is protection, or other modular
rapidly evolving and, although elements). Alternatively, it can
some interoperability issues still use the graphic layouts as direct
need to be addressed, little doubt input to load calculations (such
exists that this will cause a fianda- as pipe sizing, duct sizing, etc.).
mcntal change in how buildings Figure I: Typical BIM model systems coordination. BIM models also can link di-
are designed, constructed, and operated. The technology will rectly to specifications and manufacturers" Web sites for data
bring greater collaboration between design disciplines, as well input. Building information modeling technology extends into
as within the construction industry. Statistics from the Con- fully integrated 4D (adding the fourth dimension of time, e.g.,
struction Industry Institute (CU) (www.construction-institute. scheduling or sequencing programs such as Primavera®) and
org) under its benchmarking and metrics studies indicate that 5D modeling (adding the fifth dimension of cost for estimating
construction industry productivity has decreased 25% during and budget control using programs such as Sage Timberline
the past 15 years, compared to manufacturing industries, which Office). The building design development can continue with
have increased 125% during that same period. Similarly, and the provision of automatic bilts of material and generation of
of greater concern, white manufacturing industries have taken automatic shop drawings for everything from structural steel
advantage of technology and are at 66% value-added and 26% to sheet metal duct fabrication, to fire protection and piping
waste, the construction industry is at an alt-time low of 10% fabrication, to electrical cabling and bus duct layouts, etc.
value-added and 57% waste. This represents a tremendous
untapped resource in the S1.5 trillion U.S. and $4.8 trillion
Tool and Software Protocol Developments
worldwide building industry; a resource that when tapped can
A major key to the success of these efforts is establishing
provide needed revenue to support initiatives leading toward
common software protocols. The National Institute of Building
better buildings. Studies done for CII by NIST (www.nist.gov)
Sciences' Facility Information Council (www.facilitylnforma-
indicate that resolution of interoperability issues alone could
tioncouncil.org) working in conjunction with such groups as
save SI5.8 billion per year. In fact, the buiidingSMART Alli-
FIATECH (www.fiatech.org), the buiidingSMART Alliance and
June 2008 ASHRAE Journal 29
the International Alliance for Interoperability (IAl) at (www. through Industry Foundation Classes (IFC) to IFC.XML2 ISO
iai-na.org) has developed the National Building Information 10303-28, which incorporate HVAC schemas compatible with
Modeling Standard Version 1.0 to address this issue. The stan- ifcXML - IFC2X3 code (ISO 10303-11), as well as data ele-
dard is available at (www.facilityinformationcouncil.org/bim). ments that represent entire portions of a building or system.
The mission of lAl can be found on its Web site, which also Worthwhile reading is the new Journal of Building Information
provides information on programmable language XML data A/o(ye/m5'(www.wbdg.org/pdfs/jbim_spring08.pdf).
models for information transfer between disparate software Although not widely used in the U.S.. lATs International
packages. It also offers intelligent and universal data models Council has established the European Integrated Project called
inPro, Open Infonnation Environment for
Knowledge-Based Collaborative Process-
es Throughout the Lifecycle of a Building
(European Project No. 026716-2).
The buiidingSMART Alliance, previ-
ously organized as the I AI Noith American
Chapter, has been established as a coun-
cil of the National Institute of Building
Sciences and is specifically intended to
Steam and Hot Water address interoperability issues and foster
collaboration among the individuals, or-
"Flexible Tube" Boilers ganizations, and entities associated with
the building industry. ASHRAE has a
representative on the Alliance board of
Exclusive "Flexible directors and the vice chair of the Alliance
is on the ASHRAE BIM steering commit-
Water Tube" design tee. The Alliance is still in the formative
Full non-prorate(j stages. Although it has developed a vision
and mission, its short-term activities are
25 Year Warranty
lo identify what is needed to fully realize
protection against building SMART in the U.S. Work is being
thermal shock done to satisfy the vision and mission and
then identify and helpfillthe gaps needed
High efficiency for success.
performance
Of particular interest is the work being
Simplified maintenance done by tlie FIATECH (a nonprofit con-
sortium established by the Construction
• 15 to 300 lbs. Industry Institute and supported by NIST)
working pressure towards fully integrated and automated
design and construction technologies. Its
• 6 to 500 HP Capita! Projects Technology Roadmap
(CPTR) presents its strategy for the capiUil
Oil, Gas, Dual Fuel projects industry in developing "a consensus
Electric vision for the capital projects industry and a
unifying initiative to achieve the vision."
Contact us for
complete information Commercial Application Software
Developments

BRYAN BOILERS fhe first challenge facing private and

commercial enterprises in developing
integrated information modeling is the
Bryan Steam LLC — Leaders Since 1916
limited size of the marketplace. Unlike
Indiana 46970 U.S.A.
basic office software where a word pro-
cessing program may sell tens of millions
of copies, building modeling programs
(of far greater sophistication) may sell
only a few hundred thousand. The second
www.info.hotims.com/16013-10
30 ASHRAE Journal June 2008
 challenge facing the industry is developing a commonality of
program protocols that enable a free exchange of data between
disparate software systems. Here, the work being done by NIBS
and IAI to develop an overall integrated program under the
umbrella of the buiidingSMART Alliance shows great promise
in combining BIM technology with Information for the Con-
struction global ISO standards to ISO/PAS 16793.
One of the most important recent advances has been the de-
velopment of open meld protocols that allow the integration of
disparate software programs. These programs have the ability
to more easily manage, view, and integrate disparate software
programs providing real-time navigation, collaborative com-
munication, and presentation of 3D and 4D BIMs.
Of even greater benefit in the United States, is the advance-
ment in software protocols and communication that has been
lead by Green Building Studio's gbXML (www.gbxml.org).
According to its Web site.,
"The Green Building XML schema, referred to as gbXML,
Go ahead, get more was developed to facilitate the transfer of information stored
in CAD building information models, enabling integrated
green this year. interoperahility hetn-een design models and. a wide variety of
engineering analysis tools and models available today. Today,
gbXML has the industry support and wide adoption by the
Sure, Carlyle compressors are green, but did you
leading CAD vendors Autodesk, Graphisoft. andBentley. With
know using Carlyle can also lead to more green
the development of export and import capabilities in several
in your pocket—as much as Si 5,000 per store?
major engineering model tools. gbXML has become a defacto
Carlyle's reliability means more than just a longer
industiy.standard.schema. Its use dramatically streamlines the
lasting compressor (a recent study of
transfer of building information to and from engineering mod-
supermarket refrigeration racks showed our
els, eliminating the need for time con.suming plan take-offs.
average life span is 9.9 years versus 5.2 years for
This removes a significant cost barrier to designing resource
the leading competitor), it means reduced
efficient buildings and specifying associated equipment. It
downtime, less scrap waste going into the
enables building design teams to truly collaborate and realize
environment, and significant savings in repair
the potential benefits of Building Injormation Modeling."
and replacement costs. And for supermarket
Green Building Studio (www.greenbuildingstudio.eom)
applications Carlyle offers our Compound
offers open gbXML schema for direct data exchange offering
Cooling compressor, the most energy efficient
Web-based building energy analysis tools integrating data from
low temperature compressor in the industry.
the BIM into DOE-2, BLAST, TRACE™ 700, EnergyPlus 1.4,
etc.. and exporting the results back into the BIM. Many software
companies use gbXML in related products that are focused
So why not consider the option that allows you
on the HVAC market, including: Carmel Software's Loadsoft;
to save time, money and the environment?
Trane's TRACE 700; Carrier's HAP; CADIine's Cymap: Elite
There's never been a better time to go green.
Software s Chvac; Square One's ECOTECT; I ES. Etd. s <Viitual
Environment>; Autodesk's AutoCAD MEP®, Revit® Arehi-
For more information regarding Carlyle's teeture, and Revit^' MEP: Graphisoft"s ArchiCAD"^'; Bentley's
reliability data and the cost savings per store, Bentley Architecture and Bentley Building Mechanical Sys-
visit www.CarlyleCompressor.com. tems; and EDSUs Tas. Although still not seamless, these tools
have significantly improved software interoperability,
Wrightsoft Corporation (www.wrightsofit.com) offers a fully
integrated HVAC design package, Right-Suite® Universal, which
supports residential and commercial applications, and includes
an object-oriented, drag-and-drop CAD interface for thermal

^Carlyle zoning and automatie dimensional takeoif. It includes all six

current North American load calculation methods, three duct
design and layout methods (including the current ASHRAE duct
database), radiant panel design and layout., automated bill of
www.info.hotims.com/16013-12
32 ASHRAE Journal June 2008
 Organization Description Web Site

International Alliance for Development of a universal framework

www.iai-na.org
Interoperability for information sharing

National Institute of Umbrella organization for IAI and the

www.nibs.org
Building Sciences buiidingSMART Alliance
Development of interoperable technology for wwwbuildingsmartalliance.org
buiidingSMART Alliance™
design and construction

National Institute of Standards Advanced Technology Program (ATP) and www.atp.nist.gov

and Technology (NIST) Standard Reference Data (SRD) www.nist.gov/srd

The organization's goal is to "foster wide-

Capital Facilities Industry XML spread, practical, cost-effective use of XML www.cfixml.org
in the capital facilities industry"
Capital Projects Technology Roadmap
(CPTR) standard XMLs for the manufacturing www.fiatech.org/projects/roadmap/cptri.htm
FIATECH
industry and model library
for systems to ISO 15926
World Wide Web Consortium Internet standard XML
(W3C) schemai.1 structures for XML

Unified Modeling Language'" and Global

Object Management Group www.omg.org
Regulatory Information Database

Building systems-related software for evalu- wwvi/.eere.energy.gov/buildings/too!s_di rectory

U.S. Department of Energy
ating energy efficiency and sustainabiiity

International Building Performance Building performance simulation www.ibpsa.org

Simulation Association for HVAC systems

Table I: Stmrves of general information.

materials generation, cost estimating, operating cost calculations.,
proposal generation, project tracking, geothermal loop sizing,
and saies presentation. These modules are completely integrated.
Designers can try different scenarios because the entire thermal
and HVAC system is a live model. For example, building changes
are immediately reflected in onscreen duct sizes as calculations
ripple through loads, ducts, and bill of materials. The software
can read and write files in a number of de facto standard formats
compatible wilh popular applications such as AutoCAD and
Excel. gbXML support will be added later.
Certainly the European community, particularly, and to some
extent Australia, are further ahead of the United States in the
widespread applieation of BIM. Europe is heavily committed
to development of integrated building design technology with
extensive work being done in the UK, Norway, Sweden, Finland,
Germany, and the Netherlands,
Major players in the field include Autodesk, Bentley Systems
and Nemetschek Group (which owns Graphisoft. VectorWorks,
and Allplan).
Autodesk (www.autodesk.eom) has software that can export
to load calculations software such as TRACE and input results
back to the software. This is done with gbXML. Revit also uses
the integrated IES tools for load calculations. AutoCAD MEP
design and construction documentation software is built for
meehanical, electrical, and plumbing engineers, designers, and
drafters. According to the manufacturer. "Revit *" MEP software
is an intuitive design too! that works the way engineers think, ft
can minimize coordination errors between mechanical, electri-
cal, and plumbing engineering design teams; collaborate with
architects and structural engineers using ihe Revit^ platform
and building infonnation modeling workliows: and gain better
building performance analysis support for engineers."
Bentley Solutions (www.bentley.eom) with MicroStation
as the primary product for building design, construction and
operation. Recent enhancements include interface with gbXML
for energy analysis using Trace 700 and tie into pipe and duct
sizing, the latter using ddXML.
Nemetschek, NA, offers programs such as VectorWorks
Fundamentals, which is an architectural building program that
can plug into Graphisoft AutoCAD and CATIA. VectorWorks
Landmark for site planning and VectorWorks Spotlight for
lighting design. HVAC Building Services and 3D Viewer (plus
Nemetschek's Allplan [www.allplan.co.uk] for architectural
design and modeling software).
In 2006 Oracle launched a new collaborative building in-
formation management platform (CBIM) and is working with
Graphisoft to fully integrate building modeling tools with design
collaboration, visualization, life-cycle management, and other
applications.
The Mayo Foundation (under the Mayo Clinic) is developing
Mayo Graphical Integrated Computer Aided Design using Magi-
CAD* software. MagiCAD, developed by Progman Oy of Sweden,
is IFC compliant and used widely in Scandanavla. It is aimed pri-
marily at duct design and equipment manufacturing. However, it

34 ASHRAE Journal ashrae.org June 2008

 Organization Product Web Site

Bentley Systems MicroStation. AutoPIPE, TriForma www.bentley com

www.autodesk. com
Autodesk AutoCAD, Revit" (including Revit MEP)
www.autoCAD.com
Graphisoft ArchiCAD www graphisott.com
Oracle CBIM wvvw.oracle.com/global/uk/pressroom/2006/613.html
Granlund RIUSKA- www.granlund.fi
Viewers
NavisWorks JetStream www.navisworks.com
IFC Viewer www.nemetschek.com
Nemetschek www.allplan.com
AHplan
Newforma Newforma Project Center www.newlorma.com
Solibri Solibri IFC Optimizer www.solibrt.com
Mayo Graphical Integrated CAD
Mayo Clinic www.progman.fi
MagiCAD*
Model Checking and Code Compliance
Solibri Solibri IFC Optimizer/Solibri Model Checker www.solibri.cam
www. corenet. gov. sg
CORENET e-Plan and Fornax Viewer
www.aecbytes.com
AEC3 UK Xabio www.aec3.com
Octaga Octaga Player www.octaga.com
www.doe.gov
U.S. Department of Energy COMcheck'"
www.energycodes.gov/comcheck/ez_download.sbn
Project Management
Bentley ProjectWise www.bentley.com
e-Builder: Enterprise. Collaborator, and Pro-
e-Builder www.e-builder.net
fessional Versions
Primavera Primavera P6 www.primavera.com
Autodesk Buzzsaw" www.autodesk.com
Other
ANSYS CFX (CFD software) www.ansys.com
Leica Geosystems HDS (3D Laser Scanning Software) www. ieica-geosystsms. com
Table 2: Key developments in current commercial application software.

does include HVAC, piping, and electrical design and application
software (running on an AutoCAD platform). These have the ability
to feed data into EnergyPlus using Olof Granlund/LBNL-devcloped
BS Pro COM server middleware (with IFC-based 3D RIM).
Other Developments
Although BIM technology is maturing, significant parallel
efforts are being made in the development of software for model
viewing, model checking, energy analysis and simulation, facili-
ties management, ete., to support various use cases associated
with building information. A use case is the task to which the
information in Ihe BIM is applied. Cost estimating, schedul-
ing, and conflict resolution between structural and mechanical
components of a building are examples of use cases. A signifi-
cant component to support visualization of any use case is the
development of model checking software. One particular use
case is focused on compliance with eodes, standards, regulations
or other criteria, whether mandated or market driven.
In the U.S. the International Code Council (ICC) (www.
iccsafe.org) is supporting a use ease to check for compliance
with eodes, standards, rules, regulations, etc., through its
SMARTcodes"^" initiative. By putting codes, standards and
other criteria in a smart format that can be understood and
applied by model checking software it is possible to identify
and prevent conflicts between the building, as represented by
the BIM, and the eodes or other criteria. Initial SMARTcode
demonstrations have taken place with the 2006 International
Energy Conservation Code. The 2006 lECC is anticipated for
availability for the purpose of automated code compliance
checking in early 2008.
ICC anticipates creating SMARTcodes for a significant por-
tion of all building, life safety and fire protection requirements

36 ASHRAE Journal ashrae.org June 2008

in Ihe ICC eodes by the end of 2008. and then working with
federal, state, and local agencies to put their amendments to
the ICC eodes in a smart format for aeeess and use with ICC's
SMARTcodes. Those SMARTcodes then would be used by
model checking software to identify conflicts or code com-
pliance problems associated with the BIM. This allows the
designer to consult software for code compliance assistance
and software to augment the review and approval functions of
Rely On The Proven Expertise
Of Stellar Energy Systems,
We design, fabricate and install energy systems that meet today's demands.
Greener. Greater efTiciency. More reliable. We leave notti'mg to chance —
you shouldn t either. Rely on Stellar Energy Systems.
For more information call Stellar at 904.899.9309 or visit stetlar.net
stellar
Taking St^utions Further.'
www.info.hotims.comn 6013-42
38 ASHRAE Journal
federal, state, and local government. It also provides a founda-
tion for evaluating building designs for conformancc to other
criteria established by voluntary seetor entities.
ASHRAE Related Activities
ASHRAE needs to look ahead at the role its Handbook,
standards, guidelines, etc., play in the process and establish
a viable path moving forward. The Society uses XML source
files for publishing the Handbook, how-
ever, examination of the basic structure
and development of SMART XMLs is
needed so that all of these documents
(particularly standards) have built-in rule
sets that can be read by design and model
L'hecking/compliance software.
ASHRAE needs to revisit the basie
terminology used in its documents to
ensure overall consistency and a common
set of identities. Although the Handbook
does provide basic terminology listings,
these cannot be used for information or
data transfer. The Society needs to estab-
lish a common set of terms, definitions,
properties, and enumerations, applicable
for each document type.
ICC has produced a data dictionary
covering energy components. This project
is being coordinated with the Construc-
tion Specifications Institute {Omni-
Class^'^' Construction Classification
System numbers) that is being considered
as part of an International Framework for
Dictionaries (IFD) and global dictionary.
However, the overall program needs to be
expanded into mechanical and electri-
cal systems and incorporated into all of
ASHRAE's document development and
the results coordinated at the global level
so IFDs will fully support BIM use cases
of relevance to ASHRAE members.
The Society needs to take a step back
and look at where the ASI IRAE Guideline
Project Committee 20: XML Definitions
for HVAC&R. is going. The Society needs
to go beyond the establishment of sets
of use eases and data objects within the
guideline and determine a recommended
HVAC schema and XML (i.e.. gb.xml, aec.
xml and ife.xml). In doing so, ASHRAE
needs to look at the work being done by the
Hydronic Institute. API. ISA, and others to
Energy Systems support electronic data exchange and the
ability to share, import, and export XML.
IFC and other files in different formats.
Guideline Project Committee 20 is spon-
June 2008
 we connect

Honeywell Analytics
introduces the industry's
most flexible demand-
controlled ventilation
solution: lAQPoint. It's
multilingual, it speaks
your language.
lAQPoint is the only indoor
air quality monitor you will need to satisfy
all of your demand-controlled ventilation bid
requirements. It integrates easily with virtually
any building automation system through its
BACnet, LonWorks, FLN. Modbus or analog
outputs. lAQPoint produces three sensor
outputs {COj. temperature and humidity) for
the price of a typical single-sensor device.
Honeywell designed the lAQPoint to install
quickly and easily with a small and sleek
enclosure that utilizes a simple snap-fit
mounting bracket. Each unit is configured
and calibrated in the factory meaning you will
spend less time installing the units. lAQPoint
is ideal for large commercial buildings,
schools, office towers or any environment
where money can be saved through greater
energy efficiency. Think of us as your partner
for Indoor Air Quality / Demand Control
Ventilation solutions. Honeywell Analytics.
Figures 2a-2c: Pipe fabrication and detailing capability. Experts in gas detection.

soring research project n54-RP. Common Data Definitions for

HVAC&R Imliistiy Application.s, to identity existing data group
developments, which may provide us with some guidance mov- Honeywell
ing forward. ASHRAE needs to establish consistent basic HVAC
terminology, a full data dictionary, rule sets, and schema to sup-
port the industry in electronic data exchange. ASHRAE needs to
look at the work of AlA ACC on integrated project delivery; the
work in the ICC dictionary; the manufacturing industries" project
information model; as well as the new ANSI standard.
Related ASHRAE technical and project committees include:
' TC 1.5, Computer Applications To learn more, call 1-800-563-2967, visit www.vulcaininc.com
• TC 1.6. Terminology {Environmental Analysis of or email detectgas@honeywell.com for a free copy of
Gas Book, our 84-page guide to gas detection.
HVAC&R Terminology) C JOOH Honep>^tWI IrilBrnatlonal Inq. All r

• TC 4.1, Load Calculation Data and Procedures

vmw.info.hotims.com/T 6013-25
June 2008 ASHRAE Journal 39
 • TC 4.2, Climatic Information construction tools, shows wider application today. Although the
• TC 4.7, Energy Calculations Society has seen companies fully integrate structural design and
• TC 7.1, Integrated Building Design (originally TC 4.12) analysis programs into those architectural models, only a few-
• GPC 20, XML Definitions for HVAC&R companies are able to demonstrate BIM model tie-ins that can
• SPC 166P, Proposed Standard tor HVAC&R Terminology llilly integrate, dynamically and seamlessly, HVAC-rclatcd design
Also of interest is the work of SSPC 140, Standard Method programs (such as load calculation programs, pipe and duct sizing
of Test for Evaluation of Building Energy Analysis Computer programs, building energy modeling/analysis programs such as
Programs, and SPC 183, Peak Cooling and Heating Load Cal- DOE-2, EnergyPlus, BLAST, IBLAST TRACE 700. etc.).
culations in Buildings Except Low-Rise Residential Buildings. There are few companies that have fully integrated build-
since this could also tie into the BIM model. ing owning, operations and maintenance programs for facili-
ties management. And few companies have fully integrated
Issues and Benefits natural daylighting design programs (such as Supcriite I.OI.
Of course, development and use of all of this technology does not LUMEN, or Radiance 3.4, or illumination design programs
come without cost. Experience on large industrial projects (S75 to such as AutoLUX, AG132. ESP Vision. Autodesk Lightscape,
SI 50 million) indicates that the added design cost represents a 5% Lightcalc+Art or ALADAN™) into BIM models. Yet the spatial
to 10% premium on the architect-engineers (A-E) fees (or roughly planning, modeling and orientation technology embedded in
0.25% to 0.5% on construction eost). The A-E cost premium ean 3D, 4D, and 5D models seems a logical input database for such
be higher on smaller projects. More than offsetting this are all of programs and recipient of the output.
the cost savings outlined previously. Immediate savings of 3% to Despite this, the tremendous oppoitunities for improved effi-
7.5% have been seen through improved coordination and reduced ciency by integration of the design and constmction process coupled
conflicts, (The Construction Industry Institute analysis indicated with the building owner/developer seeing the economic advantages
a potential savings of 7% for this element alone.) This can only over the long haul will continue to drive the technology forward.
increase as more trades come on board and BIM capabilities, such Tlie infonnation technology required for these processes is com-
as automatic shop drawings and quantity takeoffs, are realized. plex and difficult lo implement and is straining the limits of design-
Increased use of shop fabrication and elimination of waste ers" current hardware, software, and staff capabilities. More work
is, itself, expected to produce savings of at least 7.5% to 10%. must be done to enable the technology to be applied on a daily basis.
Recent experience in the construction of major automotive plants However, the industry is much closer to having an interoperable
shows that it is possible to eliminate 20% of sheet metal waste, system that can enable fully integrated system design. The great-
develop programs 15% to 25% faster, reduce RFIs by 50%, est opportunity lies witb fully integrated multidisciplinary A-Es
eliminate 25% of all change orders, and reduce construction cost practices and where BIM integration is being done as a continuum
by 4% to 10%. The greatest potential savings may come from of the design process, as well as the construction process.
the application of value-added and lean construction techniques BIM is gaining considerable momentum as the technology
that BIM enables. In the interim. A-Es must convince owners evolves and greater interoperability occurs between disparate
that this added investment justities increased fees. It is clear that software systems. The rapidly emerging goals of green building/
the economic driver is the building owner/developer. If they can sustainable design, towards net zero-energy buildings, coupled
bc shown that by having a BIM they can get the building up and with goals for carbon dioxide emissions reduction, requires
leased sooner with less hassle and save money on construction whole building, fully integrated design and construction as a
cost, then they may see the benefit associated with paying ad- dynamic process. BIM can help provide that integration.
ditional fees up front to have the AEC team use BIM.
To achieve all of the benefits of BIM, more work is needed. Bibliography
The interoperability of software components is still not fully Ba2Janac. V 2003. "Improving building energy performance simula-
there, requiring separate and distinct input and output data. Suc- tion with software interoperability." International Building Perfonnance
cessful widespread implementation of BIM for fully integrated Simulation Association Conference. http://tinyurl.com/641zMm.
Hoffmann, T. 2003. "Interoperability: present trends and future
design depends on the ability of architects and engineers, as a
roles." ASHRAE Journal 45(2):40-4i.
design team, to easily input and exchange data. The key is for
Holness, G.V.R. 2003. "Smart images for project management."
the integrated system to continually and dynamically model
ASHRAE.hmrnal 45( 1 ):22-27.
the building and all of its systems, through daily and seasonal
Holness, G.VR. 2006. "Building intbrination modeling: ihe fUture
operational cycles. This allows the "what if" scenarios to be
direction of the design and construction Industry." ASHRAE Journal
played out using different systems and components and allows 48(8):38 46.
them to be evaluated on afirstcost, operating cost, and life-cycle Holness. G.V.R. 2007, "Building information modeling: technology
cost basis. The industry is far from that point. for fully integrated design and construction," CLIMA.
Laine. T. 2007. "Benefits of building information models in energy
Conclusion analysis." CLIMA.
Research into engineering firms specifically for infonnation Malin, N. 2007. "Building information modeling and green design."
related to their experience with BIM programs as design and Environmcnial Building News (5),*

40 ASHRAE Journal ashrae.org June 2008