Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Effective Trading in Financial Markets Using Technical Analysis
Effective Trading in Financial Markets Using Technical Analysis
This book provides a comprehensive guide to effective trading in the financial markets
through the application of technical analysis through the following:
The book will be essential for scholars and researchers of finance, economics and management
studies, as well as professional traders and dealers in financial institutions (including banks)
and corporates, fund managers, investors, and anyone interested in financial markets.
Smita Roy Trivedi is Assistant Professor, International Banking and Finance Group at the
National Institute of Bank Management, Pune, India. She has been engaged in teaching,
training, and research in international banking, technical analysis, and algorithmic trading.
Her publications include the book Financial Economy: Evolutions at the Edge of Crises
(co-authored with Sutanu Bhattacharya, 2018). Her research has been published in Empirical
Economics, Economic Papers, and Asia-Pacific Financial Markets.
Ashish H. Kyal is Founder of Waves Strategy Advisors, based in Mumbai, India, a Chartered
Market Technician (CMT) and member of CMT-USA. He has worked with leading invest-
ment banks such as Lehman Brothers and Nomura Holdings. His articles have appeared in
newsletters of CMT-USA, International Federation of Technical Analysts (IFTA-London)
Reuters, and Bloomberg and a research paper in the Journal of the Society of Technical Analysts.
He is a frequent speaker on CNBC TV18, ET NOW, Bloomberg Quint, Rajya Sabha TV,
and National Institute of Bank Management.
‘Investors ignore technical analysis near the end of bull markets, when buy and hold
is in vogue. Today the approach is at a nadir of interest, just when people need it
most. Get ahead of the next rush to understand and apply technical analysis. In
their comprehensive overview, Roy Trivedi and Kyal first introduce you to the key
terms of financial markets and then elucidate all established aspects of the technical
analysis field. If you start with this book, you will have a foundation for deciding
the next step to take in expanding your knowledge.’
– Robert R. Prechter, Elliott Wave theorist, author and
co-author of 14 books, including Elliott Wave Principle,
and Conquer the Crash (New York Times best seller, 2002)
‘There are lots of books about technical analysis available, but almost all of them are
written by practitioners. Thus, a collaboration of academic and practitioner, as seen
in this book, is rare but welcome. The lacking interest of academics in technical
analysis is driven by the wide acceptance of the efficient market hypothesis. It seems
very intuitive that financial market actors trade on the information available to
them and that this leads to adjusted prices. Any other behavior would be irrational.
Moreover, such behavior would be punished by future price developments of
financial prices so that these markets reinforce rational behavior.
Seen from this perspective, the price of a financial asset depends on its future returns,
discounted by interest rates and considering its riskiness. The role of fundamental anal-
ysis is then trying to learn about these determinants. In this world, there is no role for
technical analysis. What should we learn from looking backwards if the price is only
determined by future developments? At least this is the world of finance as it should
be in principle. In reality, however, we know that markets are imperfect. This book
rightly discusses in its Chapter 1, imperfections which may “justify” the use of techni-
cal analysis. Overall, there are good theoretical and empirical reasons why technical
analysis can be a useful tool to forecast financial market developments (e.g., Hsu et al.,
2016). However, as is true for fundamental analysis, the use of an analytical tool – and
technical analysis is such a tool – requires expertise. This book provides some academic
background in the beginning and then introduces and explains the main concepts of
technical analysis. The presentation is clear and applied, providing many examples and
also links to programming. Thus, I highly welcome this book which contributes to
compile and spread expertise on technical analysis in financial markets.’
– Lukas Menkhoff, head of department, International Economics,
DIW Berlin (the German Institute for Economic Research)
‘Those who dismiss technical analysis as unscientific have to confront the long and
consistently profitable track records of legendary traders such as Linda Raschke.
Whether you are studying technical analysis as a skeptic or a believer, Roy Trivedi
and Kyal’s book will serve as a comprehensive guide. The chapter on algorithmic
trading is particularly helpful to those who plan to implement technical analysis in
an automated program.’
– Ernest P. Chan, author of Quantitative Trading, Algorithmic Trading:
Winning Strategies and Their Rationale and Machine Trading:
Deploying Computer Algorithms to Conquer the Markets
‘In the last four decades, “Technical Analysis” (TA) has become an important tool
in the hands of analysts, researchers and practitioners in any financial /commodity
markets. While fundamental analysis continues to be the mainstay of traditional
market analysts, advent of technology has made the role of TA as important as that
of fundamental analysis, if not more.
Given this trend, I feel that the book on TA by Smita and Ashish will be a very
handy guide to any intending market specialist. The USP of this book is that it
helps the reader in climbing up the learning curve on the subject in a smooth glide
path but at the same time, without compromising on the thoroughness. Start-
ing from the basic principles, the book traverses through a large canvas which
includes study of patterns (reversal and continuation), candlesticks, moving aver-
ages, momentum, volume, and volatility indicators and finally concludes with a
glimpse of algorithmic trading. The authors employ a very simple and lucid style
to explain even difficult concepts with appropriate illustrations. I am sure the book
will evoke an enthusiastic response from the readers.’
– G. Mahalingam, whole time member, Securities and
Exchange Board of India, and former executive director,
Reserve Bank of India
‘Smita and Ashish have put together a comprehensive piece of work on how to
effectively use technical analysis (TA) in today’s financial markets. The book is
thoroughly researched, and a lot of references and credits are made to academic
studies and well-respected technical analyses by authors throughout. They start with
laying out the groundwork and foundations of financial markets and trading (infra)
structure, especially in India, before even touching on analyses techniques which
give the reader a solid foundation for understanding the TA concepts further on.
The main part of the book on TA, covers the most important and popular
approaches in the field. Starting with various charting formats, then moving on to
more subjective analyses tools like trends, price patters, indicators and even Elliott
Wave, to finish with more quantitative tools and rules-based trading using tools like
Excel and Python.
Although the majority of examples and explanations are geared towards the
Indian markets, the language of technical analysis is universal. I recommend this
book for every aspiring Technical Analyst who wants to get a solid understand-
ing of the general TA framework and the various technical analysis tools that the
authors discuss.’
– Julius de Kempenaer, senior technical analyst at Stockcharts.com,
director of RRG Research, and the creator of Relative
Rotation Graphs(R)
EFFECTIVE TRADING IN
FINANCIAL MARKETS
USING TECHNICAL
ANALYSIS
2.3.4 Candlesticks 23
2.3.5 Heinken Ashi candlestick 23
2.4 Dow Theory and its application 26
2.4.1 Basic tenets of technical analysis 26
2.4.2 Main criticisms of Dow Theory 28
2.5 Trend analysis 29
2.5.1 Definition of trend 29
2.5.2 Drawing trend lines 29
2.5.3 Support and resistance 32
2.5.4 Potential support and resistance patterns 32
2.6 Use of trend analysis in trading 34
2.6.1 Fan principle 34
2.6.2 Channel line 35
2.6.3 Retracements 37
2.6.4 Case studies 39
2.7 Key takeaways 42
6.4 MACD 122
6.5 Stochastics 124
6.6 HA Stochastic 125
6.7 Case studies: framing trading strategies with momentum
indicators 127
A. State Bank of India 127
B. Nifty 50 128
6.8 Key takeaways 133
11 Conclusion 246
References254
Index260
FIGURES
5.3 AMA and EMA on the Euro. Created with Eikon, Refinitiv 101
5.4 Moving average as support and resistance. Created with Eikon,
Refinitiv104
5.5 Comparing AMA, centred moving average, and EMA. Created
with Eikon, Refinitiv 104
5.6 Double crossover on the State Bank of India (30-minute chart).
Created with Eikon, Refinitiv 107
5.7 Sideways movement and moving averages. Created
with Eikon, Refinitiv 107
5.8 Triple crossover. Created with Eikon, Refinitiv 108
5.9 Using moving averages: EUR/USD (daily chart). Created with
Eikon, Refinitiv 110
5.10 Gold futures in INR (daily chart). Created with Amibroker 111
6.1 Movement of prices reflected by moving average and momentum 116
6.2 Moving average and momentum on the GBP (daily chart).
Created with Eikon, Refinitiv 117
6.3 RSI: negative divergence. Created with Eikon, Refinitiv 121
6.4 RSI: positive divergence. Created with Eikon, Refinitiv 121
6.5 MACD. Created with Eikon, Refinitiv 123
6.6 MACD with MACD forest. Created with Eikon, Refinitiv 124
6.7 %D and %K line on EUR chart. Created with Eikon, Refinitiv 125
6.8 SBI combined analysis. Created with Amibroker 127
6.9 Nifty 50 index (monthly chart). Created with Eikon, Refinitiv 129
6.10 Nifty daily chart analysis (May–July 2019). Created with Eikon,
Refinitiv129
6.11 Nifty 50 Index (weekly chart). Created with Amibroker 130
6.12 Nifty daily chart analysis (July 2019–April 2020). Created with
Amibroker131
6.13 Nifty 50 Index (hourly chart). Created with Amibroker 132
7.1 Moving average envelopes. Created with Eikon, Refinitiv 137
7.2 Bollinger Bands (EUR hourly chart). Created with
Eikon, Refinitiv 139
7.3 Bollinger Bands overbought and oversold levels
(EUR hourly chart). Created with Eikon, Refinitiv 140
7.4 Bollinger Bands (Nifty daily chart). Created with Amibroker 141
7.5 ATR (EUR hourly chart). Created with Eikon, Refinitiv 142
7.6 Volume and volume ROC on SBI (daily chart). Created with
Eikon, Refinitiv 144
7.7 Chaikin Money Flow Index on SBI (daily chart). Created with
Eikon, Refinitiv 145
7.8 Reliance industries (daily chart). Created with Amibroker 146
7.9 Nifty 50 (daily chart). Created with Amibroker 148
8.1 The basic pattern 152
8.2a Wave 2 completely retraced wave 1: not allowed 153
xvi Figures
8.2b Wave 3 is the shortest among impulse waves: not allowed 153
8.2c Wave 4 enters the territory of wave 1: not allowed 154
8.3 Degrees of waves 155
8.4 Wave 3 extended and subdivided 156
8.5 Impulse pattern (Nifty hourly chart). Created with Amibroker 156
8.6 Ending diagonal pattern 157
8.7 Ending diagonal pattern (Nifty daily chart). Created
with Amibroker 158
8.8 Fifth failure pattern 159
8.9 Fifth failure pattern (Maruti weekly chart). Created
with Amibroker 160
8.10 Zigzag pattern 161
8.11 Zigzag pattern (Nifty daily chart). Created with Amibroker 162
8.12 Double zigzag pattern 163
8.13 Triple zigzag pattern 163
8.14a Flat pattern correcting up move 164
8.14b Flat pattern correcting down move 165
8.15a Irregular flat correcting up move 166
8.15b Irregular flat correcting down move 166
8.16 Running flat correction 167
8.17a Double flat correction 168
8.17b Double flat correction 168
8.17c Triple flat correction 169
8.18 Double zigzag correction (EUR/USD weekly chart). Created
with Amibroker 169
8.19 Triangular pattern 170
8.20a Triangular pattern with an irregular wave B 171
8.20b Irregular triangle pattern in a bear market 172
8.21 Triangle pattern (ICICI Bank weekly chart). Created
with Amibroker 172
8.22a Bow-Tie Diametric pattern in a bear market 173
8.22b Diamond-shaped Diametric pattern in a bull market 174
8.23 Bow-Tie Diametric pattern (Facebook daily chart). Created
with Amibroker 174
8.24 Alternation between wave 2 and wave 4 175
8.25a Double combination pattern 176
8.25b Double combination pattern 176
8.26a Triple combination pattern 177
8.26b Triple combination pattern 177
8.26c Triple combination pattern 178
8.27 Triple zigzag pattern (Nifty daily chart). Created with Amibroker 178
8.28 Channels (Maruti weekly chart). Created with Amibroker 181
8.29 Application of an Elliott wave (DJIA weekly chart). Created
with Amibroker 181
Figures xvii
8.30 Impulse pattern (DJIA weekly chart). Created with Amibroker 182
9.1 Characteristic of cycles 187
9.2 Nested cycles 190
9.3 Time cycles (Nifty daily chart). Created with Amibroker 191
9.4 Cyclicality (DJIA weekly chart). Created with Amibroker 192
9.5 Cyclicality with momentum indicator (DJIA weekly chart).
Created with Amibroker 193
9.6 Detrending using a ratio of price to a 39-month centred
moving average (DJIA monthly chart). Created with Amibroker 194
9.7 39-week centred moving average with 20% envelope (Alcoa
weekly chart). Created with Amibroker 195
9.8 109-day time cycle with a 55-day envelope and detrended
oscillator (Nifty daily chart). Created with Amibroker 196
9.9 86-week time cycle and an Elliott Wave pattern (USD/INR
weekly chart). Created with Amibroker 197
9.10 164-week time cycle and Elliott Wave pattern (Berger Paints
weekly chart). Created with Amibroker 198
9.11 Time cycles and Elliott Waves (USD/INR weekly chart).
Created with Amibroker 199
9.12 Time cycles and Elliott Waves (Nifty daily chart). Created
with Amibroker 201
1 0.1 Accessing data from Eikon: flow chart 221
10.2 Downloading Python from Anaconda: flow chart 222
10.3 Python output (INR open prices) 236
10.4 Python output (HDFC adjusted close and open prices) 238
10.5 Python output (HDFC adjusted close, EMA 30, EMA 40) 239
10.6 Python output (HDFC adjusted close, EMA 30, EMA 40
using loc) 240
11.1 Global indices at a glance, 2009–2020 (monthly chart).
Created with Amibroker 247
1 1.2 Crude oil (monthly chart). Created with Eikon, Refinitiv 247
11.3 EUR/USD (monthly chart). Created with Eikon, Refinitiv 248
11.4 The DJIA and the Nifty 50 (daily chart). Created with Amibroker 249
11.5 The DJIA (daily chart) technical outlook before the crash
of October 1987. Created with Amibroker 250
11.6 DJIA (daily chart) technical outlook before the crash of
February 2020. Created with Amibroker 251
11.7 Relative performance of US sectors during 2008 fall. Created
with Amibroker 252
11.8 Relative performance of Indian sectors during 2020 fall.
Created with Amibroker 252
TABLES
It is but human nature to look for patterns. From the movement of the earth to
the starry patterns in the sky, from the waves in the sea to the cycles of life, it is the
quest for pattern, rhythm, and cycles which distinguishes the human relationship
with nature. Is it surprising then that we look for such patterns in our economies
and financial markets? The existence of patterns or the lack thereof (a random
walk, perhaps?) form the core of our analysis of financial markets. Technical analysis
is a quest for such patterns, patterns in the past which would allow us to look into
the future with more certainty. To predict the future movement of the markets, we
look into the canvas of the past for hidden designs. Not surprisingly, Charles Dow,
whose writings lie at the genesis of technical analysis, compared trends of varying
time frames to the tides, waves, and ripples of the sea (Dow and Sether 2009). In
financial markets, it is the existence of these patterns that brings in a structure for
trading decisions. In this book, we take you on a journey to identify those struc-
tures, enabled by the myriad approaches to technical analysis.
Globally, financial markets have faced sharp movements and seemingly unpre-
dictable turns in the last few years. The last 10 years have seen an economic down-
turn, a trade war, and, finally, a pandemic play out in the financial markets. It is
useful to tell ourselves the power of patterns remains undiminished even amongst
the seeming chaos. If you look at the Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA) from
the 1987 crash and the chart of the Nifty Index for 2020 so far, the precipitous fall
remains uncannily similar (for relevant charts, see the Conclusion of this book).
Technical analysis in this scenario can give the much-needed tools to traders for
navigating the labyrinth of the volatile financial markets.
That said, there are several books available on technical analysis. From tomes
that every technical analyst has grown up reading, such as John Murphy, Martin
Pring, Robert Prechter, to newer books by Kirkpatrick and Dahlquist, Ernest P
Chan (on algorithmic trading), this book stands on the solid foundation laid by
Preface xxi
other technical analysts. The book owes to the academic research on technical
analysis by economists such as Lukas Menkhoff, Mark P. Taylor, Christopher J.
Neely, George E. Pinches, and Peter Saacke.
Why then this volume? First, this book brings forth a juxtaposition of the aca-
demic and practitioner perspectives on technical analysis. We have combined in
this book a focus on the conceptual clarity associated with each technical approach,
case studies which underline the practical application of these technical analysis
concepts, and snippets of academic research that put the technical analysis approach
in a bigger perspective.
Second, there is always more to say on technical analysis than is available. Each
day brings in newer applications and case studies and a better understanding of what
works in the markets. With the present global pandemic, we have put together
cases from different asset classes and markets demonstrating the purposeful applica-
tion of technical tools.
Third, in our role as teachers, we have felt a need for a structured approach to
learning technical analysis covering each important domain including the backtest-
ing of the technical analysis strategies. This book has a rounded approach to learn-
ing technical analysis to keep up with the changing skill sets required.
We have underlined the practical application by using as many cases as possible
and relating them with the overall context of the market. We showcased trend fol-
lowing methods that traders can adopt to ride the trend, using simple but effective
methods. Last but not least, we have combined advanced methods like the Elliott
Wave with time cycles and other technical indicators in an easy, understandable,
and systematic fashion along with a few trade set-ups.
covers in detail the analysis of trend through the definition of trend lines, the draw-
ing of trend lines, and the identification of support and resistance patterns. Focused
case studies on recent market movement are brought in to underline the applica-
tion of trend analysis.
Chapter 3 takes up classical technical analysis which stems from the broad
notion underlying Dow Theory. The classical patterns embody the essentials of
technical analysis, with a belief that patterns are repetitive and can be used to pre-
dict the future price movement. The visual patterns are formations appearing on
the charts, which can help us to predict a reversal or a continuation in the trend.
Price forecasting requires a careful understanding of the prior movement and the
reason behind the formation of the pattern to be able to predict future prices cor-
rectly. The chapter considers in detail the important reversal and continuation pat-
terns with recent case studies.
Candlesticks, traditionally used by traders of the East, go back a long way in his-
tory, to the legendary Munehisa Homma, who used the candlesticks for trading in
the Japanese rice market during the late 18th century. With their introduction to
the Western world, the popularity of the candlestick patterns has immensely grown.
What lies behind the popularity of candlesticks is that it brings in the simplicity of
the patterns with a rich understanding of market psychology. In Chapter 4, we
consider in detail the concept of candlesticks and reversal and continuation pat-
terns. The patterns are supplemented by case studies to explain how candlesticks
patterns can be traded effectively.
Prices demonstrate a tendency to move towards the mean values historically
so that mean reversion is one of the commonly observed phenomena of financial
markets. If prices do indeed tend to move towards the mean, it is important to
understand how this can be used to generate effective trading signals. Chapter 5
details the concept of ‘mean’ or ‘average’ and its use in trading. Moving averages are
frequently used to understand the general trend in the market and act as dynamic
support and resistant to the price movement. The chapter discusses in detail the
various kinds of moving averages and their use in trading. The chapter takes up
the crossover methodology for generating trade signals, discussing the Double and
Triple Crossover strategies as well as the use of moving averages of different time
frames with recent case studies.
This chapter takes up momentum indicators and stochastics, one of the most
popular technical analysis indicators. If moving average shows the direction of the
trend, Momentum gives the strength of the trend. Chapter 6 begins with a dis-
cussion of the concept of Momentum and how it shows the strength in the trend,
by considering a simple momentum indicator: the Rate of Change (ROC). The
chapter then takes up two of the most popular momentum-based indicators: the
Relative Strength Index (RSI) and the Moving Average Convergence Divergence
(MACD). Stochastics which use the position of price in a range to generate trad-
ing signals are discussed next. Stochastics show whether prices are in the upper or
lower end of the trading range and are therefore much suited for swing recognition
and reversal confirmations. Chapter 6 puts together in the last section detailed cases
Preface xxiii
studies on recent market movement to show how the various momentum indica-
tors can be used effectively for trading.
Chapter 7 takes up the volatility indicators most popularly used by traders,
namely Bollinger Bands and the average true range (ATR). Furthermore, the
understanding of volatility is combined with the knowledge of how to use volume
for trading, as there is strong support to the link between volume and volatility.
Chapter 7 takes up two important volumes-based indicators, the volume oscillator
and the Chaikin Money Flow Index, which can help us refine the trading deci-
sions. Chapter 7 ends with recent case studies showing the effective use of volatility
indicators for trading.
Chapter 8 takes up one of the most intriguing technical analysis approaches,
the Elliott Wave theory, which uses the concept of the fractal nature to form an
in-depth understanding of the trend in a market over a long period. Developed by
Ralph Nelson Elliott in the 1930s, in an Elliott Wave, the smallest of the waves
combine together to form higher-degree wave patterns which, in turn, combine
to make a much higher-degree wave construction. This leads to high forecasting
ability of Elliott Wave Theory stretching years ahead. Chapter 8 starts with the
concepts and principles of Elliott Wave Theory. The understanding of impulse and
corrective waves is taken up next, supplemented with cases with detailed analysis
of the patterns. Detailed case studies are used for showing the application of Elliot
Wave techniques.
Chapter 9 gives comprehensive coverage of time cycles and their effective use
for trading. The cycle periodicity can change requiring a trader to keep tweak-
ing the cycle length from time to time to keep it in sync with changing market
dynamics. There are recurring cycles in financial markets, and by identifying the
cyclicality, one can forecast the possible tops or bottoms and accordingly take trad-
ing positions. In this chapter, the foundation is laid with an in-depth understanding
of the concept of time cycles: the characteristic of cycles, left and right translation,
principles of cycles, and detecting the cycle. Chapter 9 then takes up the combin-
ing of time cycles with Elliott Wave Principles, with pertinent case studies, which
correctly used, can be one of the most effective tools for a trader.
The effectiveness of trading on the basis of visual analysis is reduced to the
extent emotions impacts the trader. Algorithmic trading refers to the automation
of the trading process, whereby the generation of buy or sell signals and the execu-
tion of such signals as trades happen on the basis of programmed instructions or
algorithms. It is not surprising therefore that popularity of algorithmic trading has
grown in recent years amongst not only institutional but also retail traders. While
algorithmic trading may be based on either fundamental or technical analysis or
both, the chapter focuses on trading algorithms based on technical analysis, given
the purview of the book. First, a detailed look at the basic concepts behind algo-
rithmic trading is taken up. Chapter 10 then takes up backtesting of trading strate-
gies with Microsoft Excel and Python, two software tools which rank high in terms
of utility and simplicity. For each, the basics of the software are taken up first with
examples, before moving on to the backtesting of trading strategies. The chapter is
xxiv Preface
supplemented with a number of rich eResources which have been crafted keeping
in view the reader who may not have prior knowledge of the two software tools,
Excel and Python.
How best to progress on the journey of learning the technical trading tools? For
the novice trader or new student of technical analysis, we recommend a sequential
read of the chapters. The order of the chapters has been decided by keeping in
mind the escalation of the level of difficulty and time required to master that par-
ticular technical analysis approach. As you learn the concepts in each chapter, we
suggest continued practice on live charts for a thorough understanding.
For the trader experienced in technical trading, we suggest reading Chapters 1
and 2 first for an understanding of the fundamentals of technical analysis. This will
help in getting the maximum out of the book as basic concepts have been clari-
fied in these two chapters to set a strong foundation to the rest of the book. The
remaining chapters in the book can be read standalone as each technical indicator
or approach can be a journey in itself. That said, Chapter 10 (on backtesting and
the introduction to algorithmic trading) requires a knowledge of technical analysis
indicators, so covering Chapters 5, 6, and 7 are prerequisites to its understanding.
Although the book has used a large number of charts for concepts and cases,
charts being the mainstay of technical trading, there are always more resources that
we would want to share with our readers. An understanding of Chapter 10 requires
readers to go through the Excel and Python notebook files which have been used
as examples, included in the eResource on this book’s page on the Routledge
website: www.routledge.com/9780367313555.
An understanding of technical analysis is a continuous process, a journey along
which each application teaches something anew. The process of writing the book
has been elating for us as we appreciated time and again the technical skills required
for recognizing patterns and trends in the market. We hope you find the journey
through the book as exciting!
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Our book stands on the foundation of a rich literature on technical analysis: aca-
demic research, books and articles. We stand in deep appreciation to the legacy of
such work which have shaped our own conception of technical analysis. We find
it extremely encouraging to have received feedback and support from stalwarts in
the field of technical analysis.
We thank Robert R. Prechter (Elliott Wave theorist and author of Elliott Wave
Principle, and Conquer the Crash) for his uncanny observation and guidance espe-
cially for shaping up the Elliott Wave chapter and his minute observations on the
charts. We are touched by his modesty and eagerness to share his knowledge. His
hand-holding during the phase of the book is inspirational for us and vindicates the
fact that we are on correct path and importance of technical analysis is only going
to increase in an impulsive third wave for decades to come!
We thank Lukas Menkhoff (professor and head of department, International
Economics, DIW Berlin, the German Institute for Economic Research) for his
valuable guidance on research directions in technical analysis and his kind support
for the book. His research on technical analysis has remained core to shaping our
understanding of the deeper roots of technical trading profitability as well as helped
to put technical analysis in the bigger perspective of financial market research.
We thank G. Mahalingam (whole time member, Securities and Exchange Board
of India, and former executive director, Reserve Bank of India) for his support and
encouragement for the book. His views and analysis of market events have always
helped to appreciate the underlying currents that shape financial markets. His guid-
ance and mentorship are deeply appreciated.
We thank Ernest P. Chan (author of Quantitative Trading, Algorithmic Trading:
Winning Strategies and Their Rationale and Machine Trading: Deploying Computer
Algorithms to Conquer the Markets) for his encouraging comments on the book.
The future of trading is closely linked to its automation through algorithmic
xxvi Acknowledgements
trading, and his books have guided our perception of application of technical
trading in this field.
We thank Mark Galasiewski (chief equity analyst for Asia and Emerging Markets,
Elliott Wave International), Kamlesh Jain (founder, Innovation India In and The
Attention Institute), Julius de Kempenaer (senior technical analyst at Stockcharts.
com, director of RRG Research, and creator of Relative Rotation Graphs(R)) for
their valuable feedback and review about the book.
A big thank-you to the editorial team of Routledge. Thanks to Shoma
Choudhury for her support and guidance throughout the revision and restruc-
turing of the book. Thanks to Rimina Mohapatra for her patience and prompt
response to our many queries and her constant support through the revision pro-
cess. Thanks to Brinda Sen and Anvitaa Bajaj for their support and cooperation.
Charts in the book have been made using charting tools of Eikon, Refinitiv and
Amibroker: comments on the chart represents the authors’ views. We thank the
anonymous referee(s) for the constructive suggestions which helped immensely
in strengthening the manuscript. Errors, if any, are ours.
Ashish H. Kyal
I would like to thank CMT Association as had it not been for them, I would not
have been known in the field of technical analysis. My special thanks to Bob Pre-
chter, whose work has continued to inspire me even now. His perception about
the social causality called socionomics, with a very different way of looking at
cause and effect in financial world, has always intrigued me. Martin Pring, Ralph
Acampora, and Walter Murphy had been instrumental for shaping up my technical
analysis career by acting as guides and mentors at every aspect. I would not have
the knowledge or understanding about financial markets without learning from
Martin’s books. How can I not thank Mark Galasiewski who has again been a
mentor to me, a guide, and, above that, a friend during difficult market situations.
I would like to thank my students, my mentees and subscribers for believing
in me and my work during various phases of market and trusting my ability with
complete faith and acceptance, especially during times like this of pandemic when
the volatility is at historical levels. They have been inspirational for me to keep
going and exploring various aspect of technical analysis.
I would like to bow towards my Guru – Sadhguru Jaggi Vasudev – who has
been a guiding force that has raised my capability to manage multiple facets of
life during the demanding situations without losing the balance. It is rightly said
that without the blessings and grace of my parents we cannot exist. My father –
Harishanker Kyal – has been an epitome of inspiration who has taught me to
never give up and to always keep moving forward irrespective of the situations.
Words cannot describe the compassion and care of a mother – Kiran – who always
pushed me towards being a better human being above everything else. This book
would not have been possible without the support and understanding of my wife –
Munmun, and I would not have seen myself growing in this field if she would not
have been with me when I was too engrossed in technical analysis over anything
else. I worked relentlessly to make this book happen, but without the support of
my entire family, it would not have been possible. I would like to thank my brother,
Somesh, and sister-in-law, Neeta, who have always inspired and pushed me towards
my goals and exploring my full potential. My children – Jash and Pratyush and my
nieces Pritika and Aarna – have taught me how to be joyful while working which
is very important to create anything with best quality.
1
INTRODUCTION TO TECHNICAL
ANALYSIS
approach, the analysis of price and volume data involves visualization on charts
and/or calculation of various statistical measures of the data. At the core of tech-
nical analysis is the idea that the market movement of an asset in the future is
predictable on the basis of the past, and price (and volume) data alone suffice for
such prediction. Fundamental analysis of assets, on the contrary, would juggle with
several variables for predicting prices. The focus on price (and volume) frees us
from the cacophony of other variables, undoubtedly, adding to the popularity of
technical analysis.
Placing a successful trade requires an understanding of where prices are heading.
Trading effectively is all about forecasting correctly the future price movement.
A trader will buy the security, the price of which is expected to move up and sell
the one, whose price is expected to fall. Similarly, traders in the foreign exchange
market will buy the currency expected to appreciate and sell the one expected to
depreciate.
Traders commonly use fundamental analysis or technical analysis or a combina-
tion of both to forecast the future market movements. Fundamental analysis is a
systemic study of the factors that can impact the price of an asset to predict the
future price of the asset. Investment or trading in an asset class requires a knowl-
edge of the economic factors that move the asset. For equities, the valuation will
majorly depend on company-specific factors, most importantly the financials of the
company and macroeconomic factors that impact the specific industry. For curren-
cies, a host of macroeconomic factors (economic and non-economic) impact the
appreciation or depreciation of the currency. The factors impacting the assets are
frequently modelled and used to forecast future prices. Contrasted with this, tech-
nical analysis is the methodological study of charts and price movement to forecast
prices in any market. It considers market action as reflected in chart patterns and
predicts the future movement of prices based on a specific assumption regarding the
previous patterns. The most important assumption underlying such a prediction is
that the chart patterns seen are repetitive in nature and therefore they can be used
to successfully predict the future movement.
Thus, while fundamental analysis delves into why the market moved the way it
did, technical analysis is unconcerned about the causes of market movement. Fun-
damental analyses of markets thus look at the reasons why the markets have moved.
For example, fundamental analysis of foreign exchange markets considers all the
factors that can impact exchange rate determination while that for equity markets
looks at the macroeconomic variables and company-specific factors relevant to that
stock. This is in contrast to technical analysis which is not concerned about why
markets have moved in the way they have. Technical analysis asks, ‘If markets have
moved as can be seen from the charts, can we predict the way it will move in the
future?’
In this chapter, we present a comprehensive view of the technical analysis para-
digm. We will look at the evidence on the use of technical analysis by profession-
als and research on the profitability of technical analysis. The empirical evidence
on technical analysis lends support to the widespread use of technical analysis by
Introduction to technical analysis 3
professionals. With this we also place technical analysis in the context of the Effi-
cient Market Hypothesis (EMH). To aid our understanding of technical analysis,
and its effective use, we wrap up this chapter with a discussion on the financial
market infrastructure required for trading.
majority of them use technical analysis but that at a forecasting horizon of weeks,
technical analysis is also the most important form of analysis and considered more
important than fundamental analysis.
Technical analysis seems to largely dominate over fundamental analysis in shorter
trading horizons (Allen and Taylor, 1990; Cheung and Chinn, 2001; Gehrig and
Menkhoff, 2006; Menkhoff, 2010). Gehrig and Menkhoff (2006) show that charts
are used for shorter-term forecasting horizons while flows dominate at the shortest
term and fundamentals at a longer horizon. Cheung and Wong (2000), in a survey
covering the forex market in Hong Kong, Tokyo, and Singapore, report 40% of the
respondents saying that technical trading is the major factor determining exchange
rates in the medium run. This study contends that short-run exchange rate dynam-
ics depend on a host of non-fundamental forces in addition to technical trading
(bandwagon effects, overreaction to news, and excessive speculation).
Traders hardly neglect the fundamental factors even when following technicals
staunchly. In fact, technical and fundamental analysis may be more complementary
than initially thought (Cheung et al., 2004; Cheung and Wong, 2000; Gehrig and
Menkhoff, 2006). Cheung et al. (2004), covering the UK-based dealers, iterated
that there was little evidence of a systematic difference of opinion between chartists
and fundamentalists. Gehrig and Menkhoff (2006) point out that professionals rely
on both fundamental and technical analysis, in addition to flow analysis. Cheung
and Wong (2000) argue for combining fundamentals and non-fundamentals in a
unified model for both short-run and long-run exchange rate dynamics. In the
present global economic system with integration in financial markets, news events
often have a destabilizing impact on the financial markets. An awareness of what
goes on behind the chart movement is crucial even when trading on the basis of
technicals alone. While fundamentals and technicals have different approaches to
understanding market movement, for the trader, the use of both is concerned with
how to predict future prices.
1997). Shleifer and Vishny (Ibid) point out that as arbitrage requires capital, it entails
risk. With arbitrage being conducted by specialized professionals with resources of
outside investors (referred to as ‘performance-based arbitrage’), it would be difficult
to take ‘extreme’ positions which lead to a situation of ‘limited arbitrage’. With
prices swaying away from fundamental value, technical analysis is better placed to
understand market movement.
In the context of technical analysis profitability, the role of central bank interven-
tions also needs to be considered. Central banks frequently intervene in forex markets
to curb volatility (Roy Trivedi, 2019), and a host of studies show that the presence
of intervention is strongly associated with profits from technical analysis indicators
(Silber, 1994; Szakmary and Mathur, 1997; Neely, 1998; Roy Trivedi, 2020a). The
analysis of Bundesbank interventions with high-frequency data (Frenkel and Stadt-
mann, 2004) and daily data (Neely and Weller, 2001) shows technical trading rules
are most profitable on the day before interventions take place. Neely (Ibid) points out
that official interventions are usually during periods of sharp market movement, that
is when markets are trending, which also makes technical analysis profitable. Again,
central bank intervention may increase market volatility in shorter horizons (Roy
Trivedi, 2019), and the presence of market volatility may, in turn, contribute to the
creation of trends. Central bank intervention in that case would introduce noticeable
trends into the exchange rate movement, making it possible for market participants
to gain from trading (LeBaron, 1999; Saacke, 2002; Roy Trivedi, Ibid).
The discussion of the profitability of technical analysis in the presence of central
bank intervention helps to underline an important aspect of technical analysis. The
success of technical analysis indicators in this environment comes from the ability
to effectively use trend creation. As Menkhoff (2010) points out, economic pro-
cesses need time to unfold and technical analysis may be a ‘proper instrument’ to
anticipate price development in the sense of Hellwig (1982).
Prechter (2016)4 opines that technical analysis essentially rejects the idea of mar-
ket shocks and reaction to news as determining the movement of the market. In
fact, for technical analysts, the ideas of shocks and discounting and over- or under-
reaction to news are intimately related to the impact-and-response view of market
pricing embraced by the random walk theorists and practitioners of fundamental
analysis (Prechter, 2016). Prechter challenges each one of those concepts and argues
that stock market fluctuations express changes in social mood, which is active and
internally regulated rather than reactive to external forces. According to him, the
socionomic theory offers the only internally and externally consistent basis for the
technical analysis profession: if markets were priced rationally on external factors,
technical analysis would be impossible; if markets are priced non-rationally accord-
ing to patterned waves of social mood, technical analysis – which investigates senti-
ment, momentum, volume, and price behaviour – is valid analysis (Prechter, 2016).
Thus, technical analysis profitability, backed as it is by evidence, has links to
the essentials underlying technical analysis paradigms – the ability to gauge market
sentiments and social moods. The understanding of trend generation that tech-
nical analysis brings is indeed a hallmark of technical trading. As we discuss in
Introduction to technical analysis 7
later chapters, trend generation and reversal are central to most technical analysis
approaches. Effective trading indeed starts from understanding the trend, which
shall remain the focus through the rest of the book.
Money markets: These markets are for the short-term debt securities with
maturity of a year or less. The assets traded in this market include Treasury
bills, commercial papers, and certificates of deposits. They embody liquidity
with both low risk and return.
Capital markets: Markets for securities with maturity of more than one year is
called capital markets. Capital markets include markets for long-term debt
securities and stocks.
Long-term debt securities (bonds) are issued by both governments and corporates.
Investors in bonds get coupon payments (interest income) at regular intervals and
principal at maturity. The secondary market for debt securities gives liquidity to
the owners of these securities as the assets can be bought and sold any time before
maturity. Debt instruments characterize low risk and return.
Stocks represent equity ownership in companies that issue stocks or shares via
the primary market. Equity owners get a part of profits as dividends but are ranked
below debt holders for residual claims. This means that if for some reason the
company goes out of business, debt holders would be paid first and then equity
holders would have claims to the residual assets. Equity holders have a claim on a
company’s assets but only when the other liabilities of the company are paid for.
Equity holders nevertheless are looking for a maximization of shareholder wealth
and therefore expect management to work towards that goal. Voting rights are
Introduction to technical analysis 9
given to the owners of common shares and provide shareholders with the opportu-
nity to participate in major corporate governance decisions such as the election of
the company’s board of directors. The secondary market provides an opportunity
for equity holders to trade their stocks, leading to capital gains (or losses) (Box 1.1).
Foreign exchange market: This is the market for the purchase and sale of cur-
rencies. It is one of the most vibrant financial markets, with a huge turnover and
liquidity. While all commodities are bought and sold with money as the numer-
aire, for the currency market one currency is used to value the other. Forex mar-
kets cater to the end users who need foreign currency for business (exporters and
importers), travel, education, or investment. Additionally, currencies are traded by
both institutional and retail entities to make profits from the appreciation or depre-
ciation of the currencies. The main participants in the foreign exchange market are
retail clients (end users), commercial banks (who take buy/sell orders from their
retail clients and buy/sell currencies on their own accounts, known as proprietary
trading), foreign exchange brokers (who help dealers to find counterparties, lower-
ing transaction costs), and, finally, the central bank (which maintains the exchange
rate regime of the country, as also acts as the custodian of the foreign exchange
reserves) (Box 1.2).
Every forex transaction involves a currency pair, and the forex price (or
exchange rate) is the price of one currency in terms of the other. Of the two
10 Introduction to technical analysis
currencies in the pair, one is called the base currency and the other, the quot-
ing currency. The base currency is the currency that is priced and quoting
currency is the currency that prices the base currency, thus acting as money.
Thus, a currency quote is essentially the price of the base currency in units of
quoting currency.
In the book, we will refer to all currencies by their International Organiza-
tion for Standardization (ISO) codes. USD (United States dollar) is the ISO
code for the currency of the United States. The ISO codes of currencies featur-
ing in this book appear in the list of abbreviations. Conventionally, in writ-
ing a currency pair, the base currency is always written first. Thus, GBP/USD
means GBP (Great Britain pound) is the base currency and USD is the quoting
currency.
Commodity markets: Commodity markets are for the purchase and sale of
homogeneous primary commodities as opposed to manufactured products, includ-
ing precious metals (gold, silver), natural resources (oil, gas, metals or minerals),
animal products, and so on. Commodities can be traded directly or indirectly
(through the derivative markets). While investments in commodity markets is done
to diversify the portfolio, the evidence on commodity exposures increasing portfo-
lio returns is mixed (Baker et al., 2018).
Derivative markets: The markets for derivatives involve contractual agreements
which derive their value from an underlying. Financial assets that have been used as
an underlying include equities or equity index, fixed-income instruments, foreign
currencies, commodities, credit events, and other derivative securities. The value
of the derivative contract is derived from the corresponding equity prices, inter-
est rates, exchange rates, commodity prices, and the probabilities of certain credit
events (Bank of International Settlements, 2012).
In this book, we discuss technical analysis with examples from the equity and
foreign exchange markets only. While technical analysis is equally applicable to
bond, commodity, and derivatives markets, the unique features of these markets
require a separate study for the application of technical analysis in these markets
which is beyond the scope of this book.
1.5.3 Infrastructure of trading
While the primary market for financial assets leads to the creation of financial
assets, the secondary market facilitates buyers and sellers to trade in such assets.
Secondary markets therefore provide liquidity and enable price discovery. The
infrastructure of the market allows trading to happen. While the infrastructure of
different financial markets differs, the underlying structure common to all financial
markets is discussed here.
Introduction to technical analysis 11
1.5.3.1 Intermediaries
Exchanges
Historically, exchanges were physical places (floor or pit) where traders met to
arrange their trades. With the development of communication and technology, the
need for a physical place to conduct and arrange for trades is redundant. Advances
in communication and technology have allowed exchanges to completely automate
their trading systems (Harris, 2002). Exchanges, like brokers, arrange trades based
on the orders’ brokers and dealers submit to them. However, exchanges, unlike
brokers, regulate the behaviour of members in relation to the trades conducted in
their exchange (Fuhrmann and Lamba, 2011).
Clearing-houses
Clearing-houses arrange for final settlement of trades for their members, facilitat-
ing the process of transferring money from the buyer to the seller while transferring
12 Introduction to technical analysis
securities from the seller to the buyer. For the smooth operation of the clearing
process, members need to have adequate capital. Margins and limits are imposed
by the clearing-houses on the aggregate net (buy minus sell) quantities that their
members can settle. Non-member brokers and dealers must arrange to have a
clearing-house member settle their trades (Fuhrmann and Lamba, 2011).
Strong settlement systems in financial markets address counterparty risk and
ensure liquidity because it enhances the number of counterparties with whom a
trader can safely arrange a trade. Clearing and settlement systems follow a hierarchy,
of which, at the first tier, brokers and dealers guarantee settlement of the trades for
their retail and institutional customers. The clearing-house members guarantee set-
tlement of the trades of their customers at the second tier. At the third and topmost
tier, clearing-houses guarantee settlement of all trades presented to them by their
members, even when a clearing-house member fails to settle a trade. In the case of
a failure on part of a clearing-house member, the clearing-house settles the trade
using its own capital (Fuhrmann and Lamba, 2011).
In the clearing and settlement process, two more entities play a vital role: clear-
ing banks, responsible for making funds available for net payment obligation credit/
debit, and depositories, responsible for making securities available for net security
obligation credit/debit. Depositories hold securities on behalf of their clients in
electronic or dematerialized form, just as a bank holds cash for the customer as a
deposit. Dematerialization of securities helps to address risks arising from the theft,
loss, or mutilation of physical certificates.
1.5.3.2 Positions
A position in an asset is the quantity of a financial instrument owned or owed by an
entity. Long positions are assets owned by an entity while short positions represent
assets which are sold, even though they are not owned. Long positions are profit-
able when there is an increase in price. Short positions are profitable when there is
a decrease in the prices of the assets as short sellers can then repurchase the assets
at lower prices.
It is important to note here that for long positions, the profits are unlimited,
while losses are limited. For a short position, the losses are unlimited while profits
are limited. For example, let us suppose you have bought a security for Rs 100
(long position) and hope to gain from its price rise. The price can go up to any
level, so theoretically your profits are unlimited, while the minimum it can fall to is
zero, in which case, the loss would be 100%. In case, you have sold a security you
did not have at Rs 100 (short position), you expect its price to fall. If it falls to zero,
the profits would be 100%, but again, it can rise up to any level in which case you
would face unlimited losses.
1.5.3.3 Orders
Orders are instructions used by the buyers and sellers to communicate with the
brokers, exchanges, and dealers for transacting traders. To trade, we must specify
Introduction to technical analysis 13
the financial instrument that we want to trade, the amount we want to trade, and
the position to be taken. These instructions are classified into execution instruc-
tions, validity instructions, and clearing instructions (Fuhrmann and Lamba, 2011).
Execution instructions specify to the broker or dealer or exchange ‘how to fill the
order’, validity instructions specify to the broker or dealer or exchange ‘when the
order may be filled’, and clearing instructions indicate the specifications on the ‘final
settlement of the trade’ (Fuhrmann and Lamba, Ibid).
Execution instructions
Market orders tell the broker or exchange to obtain the best price immediately
available when filling the order. While filling market orders, the broker or exchange
will try to get the best price immediately available. This means that the actual trans-
acted price may not be the same that the trader was looking for while putting the
trade, especially for a fast-moving market. For a volatile market, this means that the
buy (sell) price may be higher (lower) than expected.
Limit orders also give the same instruction but with stipulations. In the case of
a buy-limit order, the stipulation is to not accept a price higher than the specified
limit price. In the case of a sell-limit order, the stipulation is not to accept a price
lower than a specified limit price when selling. Limit orders therefore may not
get executed if prices move quickly in the opposite direction to that expected by
trader.
Limit orders are said to be aggressively priced if they are given closer to the
market price (and therefore likely to trade) and less aggressively if priced otherwise.
The highest bid in the market is the best bid, and the lowest ask in the market is
the best offer. The difference between the bid and the offer is the market bid–ask
spread (Box 1.3). An increase in the bid–ask spread is taken as an indicator of
increased volatility in the financial markets (Fleming and Remolona, 1999).
Validity instructions
Validity instructions indicate when an order may be filled. A day order is valid for
the trading day on which it is submitted and expires if not filled by end of trading
day. Good-till-cancelled orders are valid till cancelled by the trader. Immediate-
or-cancel orders (or ‘fill-or-kill’ orders) are good only for immediate execution by
the broker or exchange; otherwise, they are cancelled immediately. Good-on-close
orders become valid at the close of trading.
Stop orders are validity instructions which become effective when the price
reaches a certain threshold. The buy-stop order becomes activated when the price
rises above a certain threshold, and a sell-stop order becomes activated when the
price falls below a threshold. Traders frequently use stop orders to contain their
losses, hence the name ‘stop-loss’ order. For example, let us suppose a trader has
taken a long position at Rs 100 and expect prices to rise. If the market moves in
the other direction, she may want to quit the position and minimize the loss. In
this case, she will put a stop-loss sell order at, say, 98. If the price starts to fall, the
moment it falls below 98, the order to sell becomes valid and is executed at the best
possible price. Similarly, if the trader has short sold at Rs 100, she may want to put
a buy-order stop loss at 110, which implies that if the price goes above 110, the buy
order would be immediately executed at the best possible price.
Stop-loss orders may be market or limit orders. For a stop-loss market order,
once the stop condition is valid, the broker should try to get the best possible price
Introduction to technical analysis 15
Clearing instructions
Clearing instructions guide on the final clearing and settlement of trades, including
indicating which entity is responsible for clearing and settling the trade. The clear-
ing function decides what members are due to deliver and what members are due
to receive on the settlement date. Settlement is a two-way process which involves
a transfer of funds and securities on the settlement date. The entity responsible for
clearance is the customer’s broker in the case of retail trades and a custodian or another
broker in the case of institutional trades (Fuhrmann and Lamba, Ibid, NSE, 2020).
In this chapter, we have presented a snippet view of the financial markets, focus-
ing on the structure of financial markets which enable the trading process. We have
discussed the academic viewpoint on technical analysis profitability and what can
explain technical analysis being an effective tool for the trading process. The idea
of trend generation as central to technical analysis is carried forward in the next
chapter. The success of technical analysis indicators, we recognize, comes from the
ability to reflect the sentiment in the market and thereby recognize trend creation.
The basic premise of technical analysis is that market move in trends which can
be recognized through suitable indicators and utilized for trading. Throughout the
remainder of the book, we will see that the different technical analysis approaches
presented give differing thought processes for understanding this basic tenet of
trend generation in the market. Chapter 2 takes up the building blocks of technical
analysis, its basic assumptions, and, finally, trend analysis, the cornerstone of techni-
cal analysis theory.
1.6 Key takeaways
1 Financial markets allow the smooth flow of financial capital between those
who save and those who need finance.
2 Money markets are for the short-term debt securities with maturity of a year
or less.
3 Capital markets are for securities with maturity of more than one year.
4 A foreign exchange market is a market for the purchase and sale of currencies,
with one currency being priced in terms on another.
16 Introduction to technical analysis
5 Commodity markets are the markets for the purchase and sale of homogenous
primary commodities as opposed to manufactured products.
6 Derivative markets are for contractual agreements which derive their value
from an underlying (a stock, bond, currency, and commodity).
7 Financial intermediaries mobilize savings, reduce the cost of external finance
to firms, lower information costs, and provide liquidity in the economy.
8 The primary market for the financial assets leads to the creation of these assets,
while the secondary market help buyers and sellers to trade in these financial
assets.
9 The infrastructure of financial markets includes the intermediaries (who facili-
tate the trading, clearing, and settlement of securities), positions (which reflect
the quantity of financial instrument owned or owed by an entity), and orders
(which represents communications between traders and intermediaries).
10 Traders commonly use fundamental analysis and/or technical analysis to fore-
cast the future market movement.
11 Technical analysis is the methodological study of charts and price movement
to forecast prices.
12 Empirical studies have confirmed that technical analysis is an important tool
for market practitioners, enabling effective trading decisions.
Notes
1 The title of the book by Mohamed A. El-Erian (2016) on the global financial system and
the role of the central banks is also a fitting adage for the fascination of our times with
trading and use of technical analysis in the financial markets
2 ‘Jobbing’ refers to the use of continuous buy and sell orders by traders in order to make
substantial profits in ‘small increments’ (Cheung and Chinn, 2001).
3 We are grateful to Dr. Lukas Menkhoff for his viewpoints which form the basis of the
arguments presented in this section.
4 We are grateful to Robert Prechter for his inputs on why technical analysis is better
placed to gauge market sentiments.
5 See Perez (2002) and Roy Trivedi and Bhattacharya (2018) for a discussion on the demar-
cation between production and financial capital and its implications.
References
1 Dow, C. (1900, December 14). Review and outlook, as cited in Dow, C., and Sether, L.
(2009). Dow theory unplugged: Charles Dow’s original editorials & their relevance today, Traders
Press.
2 In software systems frequently used for technical analysis, blue or white bars represent up
moves and red or black bars represent down moves.
3 Nifty 50 is the National Stock Exchange’s (NSE’s) diversified 50 stock index accounting
for 13 sectors of the economy.
1 Bogle, J. (2015). The Clash of the cultures in Investing: Complexity versus Simplicity is the title
of his Keynote Speech at The Money Show, Disney Coronado Springs Resort, February 3,
1999, which leaned for simplicity in investing, Bogle, J. (2015). John Bogle on investing:
The first 50 years. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons, p. 17.
1 Nison, S. (1991). Japanese candlestick charting techniques: A contemporary guide to the ancient
investment techniques of the Far East. New York: New York Institute of Finance.
1 Soros, G. (2015). The alchemy of finance. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons.
2 We are using the EMA here for the double crossover method. While other moving aver-
ages can be used for the double crossover method, the use of the EMA is most pertinent
as discussed earlier. The use of the EMA implies that we give the greatest emphasis to the
most recent price movement.
1 Italics in original. Shiller, R. J. (2016). Irrational exuberance (3rd ed., p. 2). Princeton, NJ:
Princeton University Press.
2 An MACD histogram is denoted as MACD Forest in the Eikon, Refinitiv charting
system.
3 Roy Trivedi, S (2020b), Technical analysis using Heiken Ashi Stochastic (HASTOC): To
catch a trend, use a HASTOC, International Journal of Finance and Economics.(Forthcoming)
4 Roy Trivedi, S (2020b), Technical analysis using Heiken Ashi Stochastic (HASTOC): To
catch a trend, use a HASTOC, International Journal of Finance and Economics. (Forthcoming)
1 Taleb, N. N. (2001). Fooled by randomness: The hidden role of chance in life and in the markets.
New York: Penguin Random House LLC.
2 Normal distribution is a continuous probability distribution frequently used for repre-
senting random variables whose distribution is not otherwise known. Standard normal
distribution is a normal distribution with mean 0 and the standard deviation 1. For a vari-
able with the standard normal distribution, 68% of the observations lie within ±1 stand-
ard deviation of the mean of 0 and 95% lie within ±2 standard deviations of the mean.
1 Prechter, R. (1990). The major works of R. N. Elliott (2nd ed., p. 3). Gainesville, GA: New
Classics Library.
2 Prechter, R., and Frost, A. (2005). Elliott wave principle (10th ed.). Gainesville, GA: New
Classics Library.
3 NEoWave™ (1995). Conference and Workshop
1 Abramovitz, Moses. (1961, April 30). The nature and significance of Kuznets cycles. Eco-
nomic Development and Cultural Change, 9(3), 225–248, Essays in the Quantitative Study
of Economic Growth, Presented to Simon Kuznets on the Occasion of His Sixtieth
Birthday, by His Students and Friends. Retrieved May 6, 2020, from www.jstor.org/
stable/1151797, p. 1.
1 Harari, Y. N. (2016). Homo Deus: A brief history of tomorrow (p. 319). London: Penguin
Random House.
2 For all such references, see eResource on this book’s page on the Routledge website:
www.routledge.com/9780367313555
3 https://opensource.org
4 An IDE is a software suite that consolidates basic tools required to write and test software.
Some IDEs are open source, while others are commercial offerings. An IDE can be a
standalone application, or it can be part of a larger package. https://realpython.com/
python-ides-code-editors-guide/
5 www.scipy.org/
6 https://alpha-vantage.readthedocs.io/
7 www.quantopian.com/home
1 Strevens, M. (2009). Bigger than chaos: Understanding complexity through probability (p. 3).
London: Harvard University Press.
Abramovitz, M. (1961, April 30). The nature and significance of Kuznets cycles. Economic
Development and Cultural Change, 9(3), 225–248, Essays in the Quantitative Study of Eco-
nomic Growth, Presented to Simon Kuznets on the Occasion of His Sixtieth Birthday, by
His Students and Friends. Retrieved May 6, 2020, from www.jstor.org/stable/1151797
Allen, H. L., and Taylor, M. P. (1990). Charts, noise and fundamentals in the London For-
eign exchange market. Economic Journal, 100, 49–59.
Baker, H. K., Filbeck, G., and Harris, J. H. (2018). Commodities: An overview. In H. K.
Baker, G. Filbeck, and J. H. Harris (Eds.), Commodities: Markets, performance, and strategies
(p. 4). New York: Oxford University Press.
Balvers, R., Wu, Y., and Gilliland, E. (2000). Mean reversion across national stock markets
and parametric contrarian investment strategies. The Journal of Finance, LV(2), 745–772.
Bank of International Settlements. (2012). Data requirements for monitoring derivative transac-
tions. Irving Fisher Committee on Central Bank Statistics, IFC Bulletin, no 35, Proceed-
ings of the workshop organized by the People’s Bank of China and the Irving Fisher
Committee, Zhengzhou, 27–29 September 2010.
Bedford, L. (2012). Charting secrets: Stop reading start practicing. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley &
Sons.
Bencivenga, V. R., and Smith, B. D. (1991). Financial intermediation and endogenous
growth. Review of Economics Studies, 58, 195–209.
Bessembinder, H. (1994). Bid-ask spreads in the interbank foreign exchange markets. Journal
of Financial Economics, 35, 317–348.
Bishop, G. (1961). Evolution of the Dow Theory. Financial Analysts Journal, 17(5), 23–26.
Bogle, J. (2015). John Bogle on investing: The first 50 years. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons.
Bollinger, J. (2019). Bollinger band rules. Retrieved July 9, 2019, from https://www.bol
lingerbands.com/
Brock, W., Lakonishok, J., and LeBaron, B. (1992). Simple technical trading rules and the
stochastic properties of stock returns. Journal of Finance, 47, 1731.
CandleScanner. (2020). Bearish Engulfing. Retrieved March 12, 2020, from https://www.
candlescanner.com/candlestick-patterns/bearish-engulfing/
Chan, E. P. (2009). Quantitative trading: How to build your own algorithmic trading business, The
Wiley trading series. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons.
Chan, E. P. (2013). Algorithmic trading: Winning strategies and their rationale. Hoboken, NJ:
John Wiley & Sons.
Chari, A. (2007). Heterogeneous market-making in foreign exchange markets: Evidence
from individual bank responses to central bank interventions. Journal of Money, Credit and
Banking, 39(5), 1131–1162.
Chen, J. (2010). Essentials of technical analysis for financial markets. John Wiley & Sons.
Cheung, Y.-W., and Chinn, M. D. (2001). Currency traders and exchange rate dynamics:
A survey of the US market. Journal of International Money and Finance, 20, 439–471.
Cheung, Y.-W., Chinn, M. D., and Marsh, I. (2004). How do U.K.-based foreign exchange
dealers think their market operates? International Journal of Finance and Economics, 9,
289–306.
Cheung, Y.-W., and Wong, C. Y.-P. (2000). A survey of market practitioners’ views on
exchange rate dynamics. Journal of International Economics, 51(2), 401–419.
Debroy, B. (2018, January). First post (2nd ed.), Interview: Budget and Beyond. Retrieved
from www.firstpost.com/business/budget-and-beyond-i-want-everything-to-come-under-
gst-there-should-be-no-exemptions-bibek-debroy-tells-firstpost-4283895.html
Demirgüç-Kunt, A., and Levine, R. (1995). Stock market development and financial intermediar-
ies: Stylized facts. Policy Research Working Paper Series, no. 1462, pp. 1–52. The World
Bank. Retrieved March 27, 2009, from www.wds.worldbank.org.servlet.WDSCon
tentServer.WDSP.IB.(1995).05.01.000009265_3961019111757.Rendered.PDF.multi_
page.pdf
Dimson, E., and Mussavian, M. (1998, March). A brief history of market efficiency. Euro-
pean Financial Management, 4(1), 91–193.
Domingos, P. (2015). The master algorithm: How the quest for the ultimate learning machine will
remake our world. Basic Books.
Dormeier, B. P. (2011). Investing with volume analysis: Identify, follow, and profit from trends.
Upper Saddle River, NJ: FT Press.
Dow, C. (1990, December 14). Review and outlook, as cited in Dow, C., and Sether, L.
(2009). Dow theory unplugged: Charles Dow’s original editorials and their relevance today.
Greenville, SC: Traders Press.
Dreger, C., and Stadtmann, G. (2008). What drives heterogeneity in foreign exchange rate
expectations: Insights from a new survey. International Journal of Finance & Economics,
13(4), 360–367.
Duong, H. N., Kalev, P. S., and Tian, X. (2018, August 18). Short selling, trading activity and
volatility in corporate bond market. 31st Australasian Finance and Banking Conference 2018.
http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3234262
El-Erian, M. A. (2016). The only game in town: Central banks, instability, and avoiding the next
collapse. London: Yale University Press.
Encyclopaedia Britannica. (2020). Charles Henry Dow. Retrieved January 20, 2020, from
https://www.britannica.com/biography/Charles-Henry-Dow
Evans, M. D., and Lyons, R. K. (2002). Order flow and exchange rate dynamics. Journal of
Political Economy, 110(1), 170–180.
Evans, M. D., and Lyons, R. K. (2008). How is macro news transmitted to exchange rates?
Journal of Financial Economics, 88, 26–50.
Fama, E. F. (1970). Efficient capital markets: A review of theory and empirical work. The
Journal of Finance, 25(2), 383–417, Papers and Proceedings of the Twenty-Eighth Annual
Meeting of the American Finance Association New York, NY.
Fama, E. F., and Thaler, R. H. (2016). Discussion on market efficiency. Retrieved from https://
review.chicagobooth.edu/economics/2016/video/are-markets-efficient
Fleming, M. J., and Remolona, E. M. (1999). Price formation and liquidity in the U.S.
Treasury market: The response to public information. The Journal of Finance, 54(5),
1901–1915.
Frenkel, M., and Stadtmann, G. (2004). Trading rule profitability and central bank inter-
ventions in the Dollar-Deutsch mark market. Journal of Economics and Statistics, 224(6),
653–672.
Fuhrmann, R. C., and Lamba, A. S. (2011). Overview of equity securities. In M. G. McMil-
lan, J. E. Pinto, L. P. Wendy, and G. V. Venter (Eds.), Investments: Principles of portfolio and
equity analysis. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
Galati, G. (2000). Trading volumes, volatility and spreads in Foreign exchange markets:
Evidence from emerging market countries, Bank for International Settlements. Retrieved
May 26, 2018, from www.bis.org/publ/work93.htm
Gehrig, T., and Menkhoff, L. (2006). Extended evidence on the use of technical analysis in
foreign exchange. International Journal of Finance & Economics, 11(4), 327–338.
Grafton, C. (2011). Mastering Hurst cycle analysis: A modern treatment of Hurst’s original system
of financial market analysis. Great Britain: Harriman House Limited.
Greenwood, J., and Jovanovic, B. (1990). Financial development, growth, and the distribu-
tion of income. Journal of Political Economy, 98, 1076–1107.
Harari, Y. N. (2016). Homo Deus: A brief history of tomorrow. London: Penguin Random
House.
Harris, L. (2002). Trading and exchanges: Market microstructure for practitioners. New York:
Oxford University Press.
Hellwig, M. F. (1982). Rational expectations equilibrium with conditioning on past prices:
A mean-variance example. Journal of Economic Theory, 26(2), 279–312.
Hilpisch, Y. (2018). Python for finance. Sebastopol, CA: O’Reilly.
Hsu, P.-H., Taylor, M. P., and Wang, Z. (2016). Technical trading: Is it still beating the For-
eign exchange market? Journal of International Economics, 102, 188–208.
Hurst, B., Ooi, Y. H., and Heje, L. (2017). A century of evidence on trend-following invest-
ing. Journal of Portfolio Management, 44(1), 15–29.
Hurst, J. (2000). The profit magic of stock transaction timing. Greenville, SC: Traders Press.
Itskevich, J. (2020). What caused the stock market crash of 1987? Retrieved March 2, 2020,
from https://historynewsnetwork.org/article/895
Jones, C. M., Kaul, G., and Lipson, M. L. (1994). Transactions, volume, and volatility. The
Review of Financial Studies, 7(4), 631–651. https://doi.org/10.1093/rfs/7.4.631
Kahneman, D. (2011). Thinking, fast and slow. London: Penguin.
Kaufman, P. J. (1995). Smarter trading: Improving performance in changing markets. New York:
McGraw Hill Professional.
Kaufman, P. J. (2013). Trading systems and methods. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons.
Kirkpatrick II, C. D., and Dahlquist, J. A. (2011). Technical analysis: The complete resource for
financial market technicians. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Education, Inc.
Kuepper, J. (n.d.). Heikin-Ashi: A better candlestick. Retrieved July 5, 2019 from www.
investopedia.com
Kuznets, S. (1940, June). Schumpeter’s business cycles. The American Economic Review, 30(2),
Part 1, 257–271.
LeBaron, B. (1999). Technical trading rule profitability and foreign exchange intervention.
Journal of International Economics, 49(1), 125–143.
Levine, R. (2005). Finance and growth: Theory and evidence, handbook of economic
growth. In P. Aghion and S. Durlauf (Ed.), Handbook of economic growth (1 ed., Vol. 1,
chapter 12, pp. 865–934). Oxford, UK: Elsevier.
Levine, R., and Zervos, S. (1996). Stock market development and long-run growth. P olicy
Research Working Paper Series, 1582, Finance and Private Sector Development Divi-
sion, The World Bank, pp. 1–34. Retrieved March 23, 2011, from http:// ideas.repec.
org.p.wbk. wbrwps.1690.html
Lim, A. M. (2015). The handbook of technical analysis + test bank: The practitioner’s comprehensive
guide to technical analysis. Singapore: John Wiley & Sons.
Link, M. (2003). High-probability trading. McGraw-Hill Education.
Lo, A. (1994). Data-snooping biases in financial analysis. In H. Russell Fogler (Ed.), Blending
quantitative and traditional equity analysis (pp. 59–66). Charlottesville, VA: Association for
Investment Management and Research.
Makridakis, S. et al. (1983). The accuracy of major extrapolation (time series) methods. London:
Wiley (in press).
Makridakis, S., Andersen, A., Carbone, R., Fildes, R., Hibon, M., Lewandowski, R., New-
ton, J., Parzen, E., and Winkler, R. (1982). The accuracy of extrapolation (time series)
methods: Results of a forecasting competition. Journal of Forecasting, 1(2), 111–153.
Makridakis, S., and Winkler, R. L. (1983). Averages of forecasts: Some empirical results.
Management Science, 29(9), 987–996.
Meese, R., and Rogoff, K. (1983). Empirical exchange rate models of the seventies: Do they
fit out of sample? Journal of International Economics, 14, 3–24.
Menkhoff, L. (2010). The use of technical analysis by fund managers: International evi-
dence. Journal of Banking & Finance, 34(11), 2573–2586.
Menkhoff, L., and Schlumberger, M. (1995). Persistent profitability of technical analysis on
foreign exchange markets? Banca Nazionale del Lavoro Quarterly Review, 48(193), 189–215.
Menkhoff, L., and Taylor, M. P. (2007). The obstinate passion of Foreign exchange profes-
sionals: Technical analysis. Journal of Economic Literature, 45(4), 936–972.
Microsoft Office. (2020). https://www.microsoft.com
Miner, R. C. (2008). High probability trading strategies: Entry to exit tactics for the forex, futures,
and stock markets. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley.
Murphy, J. (1999). Technical analysis of financial markets. New York: Penguin Group.
Neely, C. J. (1998). Technical analysis and the profitability of U.S. Foreign exchange inter-
vention. Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Review, 80(4), 3–17.
Neely, C. J., and Weller, P. A. (2001). Technical analysis and central bank intervention. Jour-
nal of International Money and Finance, 20(7), 949–970.
Neely, C. J., Weller, P. A., and Dittmar, R. (1997). Is technical analysis in the foreign
exchange market profitable? A genetic programming approach. Journal of Financial and
Quantitative Analysis, 32, 405–426.
Neely, G. (1990). Mastering Elliott wave. New York: Elliott Wave Institute.
NEoWave™. (1995). Conference and Workshop. Retrieved from https://www.neowave.
com/glenn-neely-video.asp
Neo Wave Inc. (2005). What is a NEoWave diametric formation? Retrieved January 5, 2020,
from https://www.neowave.com/qow/qow-archive-3.asp
Nison, S. (1991). Japanese candlestick charting techniques: A contemporary guide to the ancient
investment techniques of the far east. New York: New York Institute of Finance.
Northington, K. (2009). Volatility-based technical analysis: Strategies for trading the invisible
(Vol. 396). Wiley Trading, Wiley & Sons.
Oberlechner, T. (2001). Importance of technical and fundamental analysis in the European
foreign exchange market. International Journal of Finance and Economics, 6(1), 81–93.
OECD Glossary of Statistical Terms. (2019). Financial intermediation. Retrieved from https://
stats.oecd.org/glossary/detail.asp?ID=972
Omrane, B. W., and Hafner, C. H. (2015). Macroeconomic news surprises and volatility
spillover in foreign exchange markets. Empirical Economics, 48(2), 577–607.
Perez, C. (2002). Technological revolutions and ‘financial capital’: The dynamics of bubbles
and golden ages. Northampton, MA: Edward Elgar Publishing Inc.
Pinches, G. E. (1970). The random walk hypothesis and technical analysis. Financial Analysts
Journal, 26(2), 104–110.
Prechter, R. (1990). The major works of R. N. Elliott (2nd ed.). Gainesville, GA: New Clas-
sics Library.
Prechter, R. (2016). Socionomic theory of finance. Gainsville, GA: Socionomics Institute Press.
Prechter, R., and Frost, A. (2005). Elliott wave principle (10th ed.). Gainesville, GA: New
Classics Library.
Pring, M. J. (2014). Technical analysis explained (5th ed). Mc Graw Hill: New Delhi
Pruitt, G. (2016). The ultimate algorithmic trading system toolbox. John Wiley & Sons.
Rajan, R. G., and Zingales, L. (1998). Financial dependence and growth. American Economic
Review, 88(3), 559–586.
Ramakrishnan, R. T. S., and Thakor, A. (1984). Information reliability and a theory of
financial intermediation. Review of Economic Studies, 51, 415–432.
Rockefeller, B. (2002). The global trader: Strategies for profiting in foreign exchange, futures, and
stocks, Wiley Trading Advantage, Volume 104 of Wiley Trading. John Wiley & Sons.
Roy Trivedi, S. (2019). The Moses effect: Can central banks really guide foreign
exchange markets? Empirical Economics. 58, pp. 2837–2865. https://link.springer.com/
article/10.1007/s00181-019-01671-y
Roy Trivedi, S. (2020a), ‘“Manna from heaven”: Does central bank intervention make technical
analysis profitable?’, European Journal of Economics and Economic Policies (EJEEP). (Forthcoming)
Roy Trivedi, S (2020b), Technical analysis using Heiken Ashi Stochastic (HASTOC): To
catch a trend, use a HASTOC, International Journal of Finance and Economics. (Forthcoming)
Roy Trivedi, S., and Bhattacharya, S. (2018). Financial economy: Evolutions at the edge of crises.
UK: Taylor & Francis.
Saacke, P. (2002). Technical analysis and the effectiveness of central bank intervention. Jour-
nal of International Money and Finance, 21, 459–479.
Schwert, W. (1989). Why does stock market volatility change over time? Journal of Finance,
44(5), 1115–1153.
Shiller, R. J. (2016). Irrational exuberance (3rd ed.). New Jersey: Princeton University Press.
Shleifer, A., and Vishny, R. (1997). The limits of arbitrage. Journal of Finance, 52(1), 35–55.
Silber, W. L. (1994). Technical trading when it works and when it doesn’t. The Journal of
Derivatives, 1(3), 39–44.
Soros, G. (2015). The alchemy of finance. John Wiley & Sons.
Strevens, M. (2009). Bigger than chaos: Understanding complexity through probability. London:
Harvard University Press
Surajaras, P., and Sweeney, R. J. (1992). Profit-making speculation in foreign exchange markets.
Boulder: Westview Press.
Szakmary, A. C., and Mathur, I. (1997). Central bank intervention and trading rule profits
in foreign exchange markets. Journal of International Money and Finance, 16, 513–535.
Taleb, N. N. (2001). Fooled by randomness: The hidden role of chance in life and in the markets.
Penguin Random House LLC.
Thaler, R. H. (2014). Response to the question, what scientific idea is ready for retirement?
Retrieved from www.edge.org/response-detail/25293
Thaler, R. H. (2015). Misbehaving: The making of behavioural economics. London: Penguin.
Thomsett, M. C. (2015). A technical approach to trend analysis: practical trade timing for enhanced
profits. FT Press.
Tudela, F. (2010). Trading triads: Unlocking the secrets of market structure and trading in any market.
West Sussex, UK: Wiley.
Tulchinsky, I. (2019). Finding alphas: A quantitative approach to building trading strategies. Corn-
wall, UK: John Wiley & Sons.
Vortelinos, D. I. (2015). The effect of macro news on volatility and jumps. Annals of Econom-
ics and Finance, 16(2), 425–447. Retrieved from www.maynardkeynes.org/keynes-the-
speculator.html
https://alpha-vantage.readthedocs.io/
https://docs.scipy.org
https://opensource.org
https://www.quantopian.com/home