Professional Documents
Culture Documents
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: We performed a comprehensive safety assessment of a probiotic based on the whole genome sequence and
Received 9 June 2011 corresponding phenotypes. This was performed on Lactobacillus plantarum JDM1, a widely used commercial
Received in revised form 3 November 2011 probiotic strain in China. The minimal inhibitory concentrations (MICs) of sixteen antibiotics and the biogen-
Accepted 6 November 2011
ic amine production of JDM1 were tested to supplement a traditional oral toxicity test. In total, fifty-one
Available online 12 November 2011
antibiotic resistance-associated genes, one hundred twenty-six virulence-associated genes, and twenty-
Keywords:
three adverse metabolism-associated genes were found in JDM1. However, there were no toxin or hemolysin
Safety encoding genes, and safety-associated genes were rarely transferable. This approach can be generalized to
Probiotics provide a deep safety investigation of novel probiotic strains and greatly reveal the potential danger determi-
Genome nants and their molecular mechanisms. However, this kind of analysis reveals the theoretical maximum risk
Antibiotic resistance level as not all genes are efficient depending on environmental conditions.
Gene transfer © 2011 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
⁎ Corresponding author. Tel./fax: + 86 21 64453285. The resistance to sixteen antibiotics was analyzed by disc diffusion
E-mail address: microbiology@sjtu.edu.cn (X.-K. Guo). and E-test methods as previously described (Liu et al., 2009b).
0168-1605/$ – see front matter © 2011 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.ijfoodmicro.2011.11.003
Z.-Y. Zhang et al. / International Journal of Food Microbiology 153 (2012) 166–170 167
According to the results of disc diffusion, the minimum inhibitory 3. Results and discussion
concentration (MIC) of each of the following antimicrobial agents
to JDM1 was measured by E-test (AB Biodisk, Solna, Sweden): 3.1. General genome comparison of L. plantarum JDM1 and WCFS1
amoxicillin (AC, 0.016–256 mg/L), amikacin (AK, 0.016–256 mg/
L), ampicillin (AM, 0.016–256 mg/L), bacitracin (BA, 0.016– The complete genome of L. plantarum JDM1 contains a single, cir-
256 mg/L), cephalothin (CE, 0.016–256 mg/L), ciprofloxacin (CI, cular chromosome of 3,197,750 bp coding 2948 proteins (Fig. 1).
0.002–32 mg/L), chloramphenicol (CL, 0.016–256 mg/L), cefotaxime Compared with WCFS1, an isolated strain from saliva, the genome
(CT, 0.016–256 mg/L), erythromycin (EM, 0.016–256 mg/L), gentamy- of JDM1 was smaller and encoded fewer genes (Table 1). By genomic
cin (GM, 0.016–256 mg/L), imipenem (IP, 0.002–32 mg/L), rifampicin comparison, there were 416 unique genes in WCFS1 and 307 unique
(RI, 0.016–256 mg/L), streptomycin (SM, 0.016–256 mg/L), tetracycline genes in JDM1. Most of these genes were prophage associated genes
(TC, 0.016–256 mg/L), trimethoprim/sulphamethoxazole (TS, 0.002– and hypothetical protein-coding genes. Many exopolysaccharide
32 mg/L), and vancomycin (VA, 0.016–256 mg/L). MICs were measured biosynthesis protein and phosphotransferase system (PTS) coding
after anaerobic incubation at 37 °C for 24 h with MRS. Each experiment genes were absent. JDM1 grew in rich, nutritional medium long-
was performed in triplicate. The breakpoints were calculated as previous- term, so that the genome might degenerate gradually.
ly described (Ammor et al., 2007; Liu et al., 2009b; von Wright, 2005). However, JDM1 had many cell surface protein-coding genes
uniquely, such as JDM1_0663, JDM1_1104, and JDM1_2368. These
genes might be associated with the adhesion ability, which was
2.4. Identification of safety-associated genes important to probiotics.
Fig. 1. Genome-atlas view of the L. plantarum JDM1 chromosome. The six circles (outer to inner) show the following. Circles 1 and 2 are color coded according to the COG classi-
fication of the genes present on the forward and reverse strands. Circle 3 (purple) shows the GC percentage of the CDSs on the genome. Circle 4 (light blue and green) represents the
GC skew (step by 500 bp); the origin and terminus are clearly marked by the change in GC skew. Circle 5 shows the tRNA genes (blue) and the rRNA regions (red). Circle 6 shows
the IS elements (dark green) and prophage fragments (orange).
168 Z.-Y. Zhang et al. / International Journal of Food Microbiology 153 (2012) 166–170
Table 1 genes, it has become the consensus that bacteria used as probiotics
General feature comparison between JDM1 and WCFS1. for humans or additives for animal feed should not carry transferable
Feature JDM1 WCFS1 antimicrobial resistance genes (von Wright, 2005). Because most
LABs were intrinsically resistant to many antimicrobial agents, no
Size (bp) 3,197,759 3,308,274
Plasmid 2 3 particular safety concern was associated with this intrinsic type of
G + C content (%) 44.67% 44.50% resistance. However, the intrinsic antibiotic resistance genes on the
Protein-coding genes chromosome should not be flanked by transposable elements, such
With assigned function 2273 2120
as integrase and transposase.
Conserved and hypothetical 684 932
Total 2951 3052
Transfer RNA 62 62
3.3. Virulence factors
Ribosomal RNA
23S 5 5
16S 5 5 One hundred twenty-six genes related to virulence were identi-
5S 6 6 fied in JDM1. Most of these were defensive, or non-classical, virulence
Insertion sequences 11 18 factors, such as thirty-five transporter protein genes, seventeen of
which were genes associated with iron, magnesium, and manganese
uptake. There were nineteen genes associated with carbohydrate syn-
Fifty-one antibiotic resistance genes were identified in the
thesis and modification, seventeen genes involved in protein synthe-
genome using BLAST searches with the ARDB. Most of these genes in-
sis and modification, fifteen transcriptional regulator genes, eight
cluded drug export proteins (25), an undecaprenyl pyrophosphate
genes involved in DNA metabolism, six stress protein genes, three
phosphatase, and genes associated with resistance to VA (13), quater-
antibiotic resistance genes, and two adhesion protein genes. Twelve
nary ammonium (3), TS (3), CL (2), TC (1), SM (1), fusidic acid (1),
genes were duplicates of previously identified antibiotic resistance-
quinolone (1), and penicillin (1) (bracketed numbers reflect the inci-
associated genes.
dence of each drug-associated gene) (Table S.1).
Virulence factors mainly included bacterial toxins, cell surface
Compared with other molecular methods employed to search
proteins that mediate bacterial attachment, cell surface carbohy-
for antibiotic resistance genes, such as PCR and DNA array (Burton
drates and proteins that protect a bacterium, and hydrolytic enzymes
et al., 2006; Hummel et al., 2007), determination of the entire
that may contribute to the pathogenicity of the bacterium (Chen
genome sequence could provide more direct information. However,
et al., 2005). Though many genes correlated with virulence factors
it takes longer and is more expensive.
were found in JDM1, they did not represent as really harmful. No in-
L. plantarum was thought to be intrinsically resistant to vancomy-
vasion or toxin proteins, which are actually offensive virulence fac-
cin due to its peptidoglycan precursors; they are composed of D-
tors, were identified. Some genes, such as the fibrinogen-binding
lactate rather than D-alanine at the C-terminus. The VA resistance
protein and bile salt hydrolase encoding genes, are important to the
genes in JDM1 encode a D-ala-D-ala dipeptidase (VanX), four essen-
characteristics of probiotics and should not be considered offensive
tial dehydrogenases (VanH), a D-alanine:D-lactate ligase (VanD),
virulence factors.
six response regulators (VanR), and one histidine kinase (VanS).
JDM1_0636 (vanX) was an essential precursor of the cell wall and
highly specific for hydrolyzing D-ala-D-ala dipeptides. vanX was rare- 3.4. Putatively adverse metabolites
ly transferable, without any flanking transfer elements.
Generally, the genotype and phenotype did not completely coin- The metabolic activity of bacteria in food matrix or culture media
cide. For example, chloramphenicol O-acetyltransferase (JDM1_ is easily characterized and reflected in traditional taxonomic
1505) is the determinant gene of CL resistance (Murray and Shaw, approaches based on metabolic profiles. However, the metabolic
1997), but JDM1 was sensitive to CL. The penicillin and TC resistance activity in various gastrointestinal tracts within one person's body
genes of JDM1 (JDM1_1841 and JDM1_0084) encode targets of drugs, is relatively hard to characterize. Several enzymes involved in the
but not real antibiotic resistance genes. formation of putatively adverse metabolites or side effects include
With increasing apprehension that food and/or communal bacte- beta-glucosidase (GS), arylsulphatase (AS), beta-glucuronidase
ria may act as potential reservoirs for antimicrobial resistance (GN), nitroreductase (NR), azoreductase (AR), D-lactate dehydroge-
nase (DLD), amino acid decarboxylase (AD), conjugated bile salt
hydrolase (CBSH), and bile salt-7-hydroxylase (BHX) (McBain and
Table 2 Macfarlane, 1997). The hydrolases, GS, and various glycosidases
Antibiotics resistance of JDM1 by E-test.
influence the bioavailability of a variety of toxicants and phase 2 me-
Antibiotics Short E-test tabolites, which are more readily absorbed upon removal of the glu-
Form curonic acid or sugar moeity (John et al., 1999). CBSH possesses bile
UI mg/L MIC mg/L
salt deconjugase activity and may lead to deconjugation in the small
Cefodizime CT 0.016–256 0.047
Amoxicillin AC 0.016–256 0.064 intestine. AR and NR activity may be associated with undesirable tox-
Ampicillin AM 0.016–256 0.064 icological effects, especially with respect to carcinogen activation.
Trimethoprim/ DLD is involved in D-lactate production, and consumption of Lactoba-
Sulphamethoxazole TS 0.002–32 0.19 cillus spp. tablets has also been associated with D-lactic acidosis (Ku
Rifampicin RI 0.016–256 0.25
et al., 2006). Eleven GS genes, four CBSH genes, four NR genes, two
Cephalothin CE 0.016–256 0.5
Imipenem IP 0.002–32 0.6 AR genes, and two DLD genes were identified in JDM1 (Table 3)
Erythromycin EM 0.016–256 0.75 (details in Table S.2). Being both flexible and adaptive, L. plantarum
Chloramphenicol CL 0.016–256 1 has encountered many different environmental niches and thus has
Tetracycline TC 0.016–256 1.5
a relatively large number of metabolic enzymes. There is no evidence
Gentamicin GM 0.016–256 48
Amikacin AK 0.016–256 >256 for any adverse reactions to JDM1. If these genes were not overex-
Bacitracin BA 0.016–256 >256 pressed, it is hard to determine whether they may contribute to
Ciprofloxacin CI 0.002–32 >32 adverse reactions.
Streptomycin SM 0.016–256 >256 Besides these genes, a bile acid 7-alpha-dehydratase (lp_0874),
Vancomycin VA 0.016–256 >256
which could function as a BHX, is found in WCFS1 but is absent in
Z.-Y. Zhang et al. / International Journal of Food Microbiology 153 (2012) 166–170 169
JDM1. This suggests that JDM1 might have a less substantial effect on 3.7. Conclusions
the host secondary bile acid biosynthesis than WCFS1.
There has been an increased focus on the bio-safety of food and
3.5. Biogenic amine production medicine. Probiotics actively evolve to adapt to nutritionally rich en-
vironments. Traditional achievements for assessing the safety of
Biogenic amines have been implicated in food poisoning incidents, probiotics seem to be limited. Additional evidence regarding the func-
usually from the consumption of fermented foods. These amines are tional mechanism and potential side effects of probiotics can be ex-
mainly produced by microbial decarboxylation of amino acids, partic- plored by complete genome sequencing and data mining. Although
ularly tyrosine, histidine, and tryptophan to tyramine, histamine and all the predictions are made in the basis of annotation, it reveals the
tryptamine respectively. maximum potential risk.
The ability of JDM1 to produce biogenic amine products had been For comparative study, we identified the safety-associated genes
tested qualitatively by decarboxylase plates containing six precursor of WCFS1 in the same way. Sixty-six antibiotic resistance genes and
amino acids. JDM1 could not produce enough tyramine, histamine, 162 virulence factor genes were found, which were a little more
putrescine, cadaverine, spermine or tryptamine to change the color than JDM1 and still without actually offensive virulence factors and
of the plates. There was only one amino acid decarboxylase present, antibiotic resistance determinant. The similar results were found in
a glutamate decarboxylase. Therefore, no toxic biogenic amines ST-III, another L. plantarum isolates from kimchi (Wang et al., 2011).
could be produced, which was confirmed by phenotype. It confirmed the GRAS status given for L. plantarum. However, wheth-
There is only one amino acid decarboxylase in JDM1, glutamate er other strains are with genomic safety still need further study. With
decarboxylase (JDM1_2723). It evidenced JDM1 can't produce bio- more and more complete genomes published, this method will be
genic amine based on genome. improved.
A safety-associated gene database specifically for probiotics is
3.6. Genome stability of JDM1 needed. With the development of high-throughput sequencing tech-
nology and the decreased cost, complete genome sequencing would
Genome stability is affected by many transition elements, such as be an indispensable way to evaluate the safety and control the quality
plasmids, insertion sequence (IS), and prophages. A comparison with of probiotic strains.
the reference strain, WCFS1, showed the relative stability of JDM1.
JDM1 contained only two cryptic plasmids that do not encode any es-
Acknowledgements
sential proteins, and three prophage elements. All three of the pro-
phages are incomplete sequences and have lost their lysogenicity.
This work was supported by grants from the National Natural Sci-
The prophage sequences and locations within JDM1 and WCFS1
ence Foundation of China (30770111, 30900051, and 30970125), the
were highly variable. Eleven repeated sequences, designated ISP2,
National Key Program for Infectious Diseases of China (2008ZX10004,
were found in the chromosome of JDM1. These sequences were iden-
and 2009ZX10004), the Program of Shanghai Subject Chief Scientist
tified as a class of transposase-encoding regions, representing mobile
(09XD1402700), the Program of Shanghai Research and Develop-
genetic elements in WCFS1.
ment (10JC1408200), and the Program of Shanghhai Jiao Tong Uni-
Three genes associated with virulence and antibiotics mentioned
versity (YZ 1017).
above, JDM1_0448, JDM1_1119 and JDM1_1629, are flanked by IS
elements, indicating a relatively greater possibility for transfer.
JDM1_0448 encodes a lysyl-tRNA synthetase, and the other two Appendix A. Supplementary data
genes both encode transport proteins. The other safety-associated
genes nearby the IS elements or prophage sequences were mostly Supplementary data to this article can be found online at doi:10.
transporters or transcription regulators. Therefore, the potential safe- 1016/j.ijfoodmicro.2011.11.003.
ty genes, such as those encoding enzymes associated with antibiotic
resistance or adverse metabolites, had fewer chances to transfer to References
other organisms.
Ammor, M.S., Florez, A.B., Mayo, B., 2007. Antibiotic resistance in non-enterococcal lac-
Mutations, which may cause genetic changes in multiple regions tic acid bacteria and bifidobacteria. Food Microbiology 24, 559–570.
of the genome, play only a minor role in the development of resis- Bernardeau, M., Vernoux, J.P., Henri-Dubernet, S., Gueguen, M., 2008. Safety assess-
tance and virulence. Horizontal transfer enhances evolution in micro- ment of dairy microorganisms: the Lactobacillus genus. International Journal of
Food Microbiology 126, 278–285.
bial communities by transferring genes across species and genus Bhardwaj, A., Kapila, S., Mani, J., Malik, R.K., 2009. Comparison of susceptibility to op-
borders through conjugative plasmids, transposons, integrons, sonic killing by in vitro human immune response of Enterococcus strains isolated
170 Z.-Y. Zhang et al. / International Journal of Food Microbiology 153 (2012) 166–170
from dairy products, clinical samples and probiotic preparation. International Jour- plantarum WCFS1. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United
nal of Food Microbiology 128, 513–515. States of America 100, 1990–1995.
Bhardwaj, A., Gupta, H., Kapila, S., Kaur, G., Vij, S., Malik, R.K., 2010. Safety assessment Ku, W., Lau, D., Huen, K., 2006. Probiotics provoked D-lactic acidosis in short bowel
and evaluation of probiotic potential of bacteriocinogenic Enterococcus faecium KH syndrome: case report and literature review. Hong Kong Journal of Paediatrics
24 strain under in vitro and in vivo conditions. International Journal of Food Micro- (New Series) 11, 246–254.
biology 141, 156–164. Liu, B., Pop, M., 2009. ARDB—Antibiotic Resistance Genes Database. Nucleic Acids Re-
Burton, J.P., Wescombe, P.A., Moore, C.J., Chilcott, C.N., Tagg, J.R., 2006. Safety assess- search 37, D443–D447.
ment of the oral cavity probiotic Streptococcus salivarius K12. Applied and Environ- Liu, C., Zhang, Z.-Y., Guo, X.-K., 2009a. Screening of biogenic amine-producing lactic
mental Microbiology 72, 3050–3053. acid bacteria. Chinese Journal of Microecology 21 (5), 427–429.
Chen, L., Yang, J., Yu, J., Yao, Z., Sun, L., Shen, Y., Jin, Q., 2005. VFDB: a reference database Liu, C., Zhang, Z.Y., Dong, K., Yuan, J.P., Guo, X.K., 2009b. Antibiotic resistance of probi-
for bacterial virulence factors. Nucleic Acids Research 33, D325–D328. otic strains of lactic acid bacteria isolated from marketed foods and drugs. Biomed-
Commission, C.P. (Ed.), 2010. Pharmacopoeia of the Peoples Republic of China, Vol. 3. ical and Environmental Sciences 22, 401–412.
People's Medicine Publishing House. McBain, A.J., Macfarlane, G.T., 1997. Investigations of bifidobacterial ecology and oligo-
Donohue, D.C., 2006. Safety of probiotics. Asia Pacific Journal of Clinical Nutrition 15, saccharide metabolism in a three-stage compound continuous culture system.
563–569. Scandinavian Journal of Gastroenterology. Supplement 222, 32–40.
FAO/WHO, 2001. Report on joint FAO/WHO expert consultation on evaluation of health Murray, I.A., Shaw, W.V., 1997. O-Acetyltransferases for chloramphenicol and other
and nutritional properties of probiotics in food including powder milk with natural products. Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy 41, 1–6.
live lactic acid bacteria. [Online]. Available at http://www.fao.org/es/ESN/Probio/ Posfai, G., Plunkett III, G., Feher, T., Frisch, D., Keil, G.M., Umenhoffer, K., Kolisnychenko,
probio.htm. V., Stahl, B., Sharma, S.S., de Arruda, M., Burland, V., Harcum, S.W., Blattner, F.R.,
Hummel, A.S., Hertel, C., Holzapfel, W.H., Franz, C.M., 2007. Antibiotic resistances 2006. Emergent properties of reduced-genome Escherichia coli. Science 312,
of starter and probiotic strains of lactic acid bacteria. Applied and Environmental 1044–1046.
Microbiology 73, 730–739. von Wright, A., 2005. Regulating the safety of probiotics—the European approach. Cur-
John, O.B., Ross, C., Arthur, C.O., Seppo, S., 1999. Safety evaluation of probiotics. Food rent Pharmaceutical Design 11, 17–23.
Science & Technology 10, 418–424. Wang, Y., Chen, C., Ai, L., Zhou, F., Zhou, Z., Wang, L., Zhang, H., Chen, W., Guo, B., 2011.
Kiwaki, M., Sato, T., 2009. Antimicrobial susceptibility of Bifidobacterium breve strains Complete genome sequence of the probiotic Lactobacillus plantarum ST-III. Journal
and genetic analysis of streptomycin resistance of probiotic B. breve strain Yakult. of Bacteriology 193, 313–314.
International Journal of Food Microbiology 134, 211–215. Zhang, Z.Y., Liu, C., Zhu, Y.Z., Zhong, Y., Zhu, Y.Q., Zheng, H.J., Zhao, G.P., Wang, S.Y., Guo,
Kleerebezem, M., Boekhorst, J., van Kranenburg, R., Molenaar, D., Kuipers, O.P., Leer, R., X.K., 2009. Complete genome sequence of Lactobacillus plantarum JDM1. Journal of
Tarchini, R., Peters, S.A., Sandbrink, H.M., Fiers, M.W., Stiekema, W., Lankhorst, R. Bacteriology 191, 5020–5021.
M., Bron, P.A., Hoffer, S.M., Groot, M.N., Kerkhoven, R., de Vries, M., Ursing, B., de
Vos, W.M., Siezen, R.J., 2003. Complete genome sequence of Lactobacillus