You are on page 1of 5

Mini-Review

Drug Dosing in Renal Disease


*Matthew P Doogue,1,2 Thomas M Polasek1
1
Department of Clinical Pharmacology, Flinders University, 2Flinders Medical Centre, Bedford Park, SA 5042, Australia.
For correspondence: Dr Matt Doogue, matt.doogue@health.sa.gov.au

Abstract
Renal disease alters the effects of many drugs, particularly when active drug moieties are renally cleared. Drug doses should
usually be reduced in renal disease in proportion to the predicted reduction in clearance of the active drug moiety. Patient factors
to consider in adjusting drug doses include the degree of renal impairment and patient size. Drug factors to consider in adjusting
doses include the fraction of the drug excreted unchanged in urine and the drug’s therapeutic index. Estimates of renal function
are useful to guide dosing of renally cleared drugs with medium therapeutic indices, but are not precise enough to guide dosing
of drugs with narrow therapeutic indices. This article discusses principles of drug dose adjustment in renal disease.

Introduction estimate renal function, in diagnosing renal disease and


Renal disease alters the effects of many drugs, sometimes are also used to estimate renal drug clearance. Some active
decreasing their effects but more often increasing their drug moieties are wholly or partly cleared from the body
effects and thus potential toxicity. Many of these changes are by the kidneys and this is the physiological rationale for
predictable and can be mitigated by changing drug doses. using eGFR to estimate drug clearance. Similar to serum
drug concentration, serum creatinine is dependent on both
Renal disease interacts with drugs in three main ways. creatinine production (equivalent to drug dose) and creatinine
Firstly, patients with renal disease may be more vulnerable clearance (equivalent to renal drug clearance).
to a given drug effect (patient susceptibility). Secondly, a
drug effect may be exaggerated or attenuated in patients Serum creatinine is the most commonly used analyte in the
with renal disease (pharmacodynamic change). Thirdly, evaluation of renal function, and equations using serum
and most importantly, some drugs have higher steady-state creatinine concentration are the basis of most estimates of
concentrations when given at usual doses to patients with renal GFR (as discussed in detail elsewhere in this issue).1 Estimated
disease (pharmacokinetic changes). This article describes GFR (eGFR) has the units mL/min/1.73m2,2 whereas
how to adjust drug dose to account for the pharmacokinetic creatinine clearance and drug clearance are both measured in
changes that occur in renal disease. mL/min. To avoid confusion, units should be carefully noted
and their implications considered. This is discussed in more
This can be summarised in one sentence: The drug dose detail below.
should be reduced proportionally to the predicted reduction
in drug clearance. Drug Dosing
The units of drug dose are amount per unit time e.g. 500
Increased drug clearance results in lower drug concentrations, mg twice daily. For most drugs, prescribing information
while decreased drug clearance results in higher drug recommends a standard dose and provides some guidance
concentrations and hence greater drug effects. To avoid harm on when this should be changed.3 The advice is necessarily
when drug clearance is significantly decreased, the dose of imprecise as most drugs have large inter-individual variability
renally cleared drugs should usually be reduced in patients in clearance and response. Consequently, dose adjustment is
with renal disease. crude for most drugs in most circumstances, for example by
doubling or halving doses. This is reflected in the available
Estimates of GFR Based on Creatinine drug preparations, with most provided in a limited number of
Estimates of glomerular filtration rate (GFR) are used to strengths which limits dose adjustment options. In most cases

Clin Biochem Rev Vol 32 May 2011 I 69


Doogue MP & Polasek TM

having a means to identify when drug dose should be halved the steady state plasma concentration (Cp) at a given dose
or doubled is important, whereas a 20% change in dose is (Equation 1 and Figure). CL has the units of volume/time and
usually impractical or unnecessary. However there are several F is dimensionless (%). Note that CL is not the same as drug
drugs for which small changes in dose or concentration may elimination (which, like dose, has units of amount/time and
have an important effect, commonly known as a narrow becomes equal to dose at steady state).
therapeutic index.
Equation 1:
Therapeutic Index units of equation 1:
minimum toxic dose
The therapeutic index =
minimum effective dose
From Equation 1 it can be seen that if CL is halved, drug dose
should be halved to keep the drug concentration the same.
For drugs with narrow therapeutic indices (Table 1), a small Thus, if a drug is 100% renally cleared and renal function
change in drug concentration can cause toxicity or loss of is half-normal, the drug dose should be halved, all other
efficacy. Narrow therapeutic index drugs should be dosed using things being equal. However, many drugs are inactivated by
robust biomarkers, as estimates or empirical calculations of metabolism (in the liver predominantly), and hence doses of
dose are not reliable enough to be safe. For example, lithium metabolised drugs do not usually require changing in renal
is a renally cleared drug with a narrow therapeutic index; disease.
therapeutic drug monitoring is used together with clinical
response to guide dosing. Warfarin is a narrow therapeutic
index drug that is metabolised rather than renally cleared;
international normalised ratio (INR) is used as a biomarker
to guide dosing.

Conversely, for drugs with a wide therapeutic index, even


large changes in drug clearance may have only a modest
impact on response, and therefore dose adjustments are less
important. Beta-lactam antibiotics constitute a class of renally
cleared drugs with wide therapeutic indices.

Drugs with narrow therapeutic indices should be dosed using Figure. Pharmacokinetics: the relationship between drug dose,
biomarkers of effect and/or therapeutic drug monitoring. drug concentration and pharmacokinetic variables. Adapted
from Begg.4 CL = (apparent) clearance; F = bioavailability;
Drug Clearance Cp = steady state plasma concentration; Vd = (apparent)
Drug clearance (CL) and bioavailability (F) (the fraction of volume of distribution; k = elimination rate constant; t½ =
the drug dose that reaches the systemic circulation) determine elimination half-life.

Table 1. Examples of drugs with narrow therapeutic indices.

Renally Cleared Metabolised

Aminoglycosides amikacin Anticoagulants warfarin (INR)*


gentamicin Anticonvulsants lamotrigine
Glycopeptides vancomycin phenytoin
Other digoxin Cardiac drugs amiodarone
lithium perhexiline
morphine 6-glucuronide Hormones insulin (glucose)*
thyroxine (TSH)*
Immunosuppressants mycophenolate
tacrolimus

*items in brackets represent recommended biomarker for dose titration.


Doses of these and other narrow therapeutic index drugs should be based on clinical response, biomarkers of effect and/or drug
concentrations; empirical dose estimates are not sufficiently robust. Note that these are examples only and that this is not a
comprehensive list.

70 I Clin Biochem Rev Vol 32 May 2011


Drug Dosing in Renal Disease

There are some drugs that are partially cleared by the estimates of renal function are used to estimate the renal
kidneys and partially metabolised (e.g. low molecular weight clearance of the drug in question. When evaluating estimates
heparins). For these drugs the dose reduction needed in renal of renal function for prescribing guidelines it is important
disease is less than that for drugs that are 100% renally cleared. to consider the gold standard of drug effect or, alternatively,
For example, in a patient with half-normal renal function, the drug concentration. Pharmacokinetic studies in patients with
dose of a drug that is half renally cleared and half metabolised renal disease are usually conducted as part of preregistration
would typically need to be reduced by a quarter. evaluation. While not all these studies are published in peer-
reviewed journals, the results can usually be obtained from
Fraction Excreted Unchanged the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) databases.5
The fraction excreted unchanged (fe) is the proportion of the
active drug cleared renally in an average healthy person. The Patient size is a particularly important factor to consider
doses of drugs with fe ≥0.5 (50% or more renally cleared) when using creatinine-based estimates of renal function. The
should usually be reduced in patients with renal disease. units of drug clearance are volume/time (mL/min), whereas
This is particularly important for drugs with an intermediate the units of eGFR for chronic renal disease are volume/time/
therapeutic index (Table 2). standard size (mL/min/1.73m2). How to consider the effect of
size in drug dosing is discussed in detail elsewhere and has
Equation 2: been the subject of interventional studies.6-8 This aspect is a
patient dose = major limitation in using eGFR for drug dosing.
usual dose x ((1 – fe) + fe x
In many other respects the limitations of using creatinine-
based measures both for drug dosing and for monitoring renal
From Equation 2 it follows that dose should be reduced in disease are similar. For example, creatinine-based estimates
proportion to a patient’s relative renal function for drugs that of renal function are not reliable in pregnancy. Methods of
are 100% renally cleared, all other things being equal. The estimating renal function are discussed elsewhere in this
calculated dose can usually be rounded to the nearest whole journal.1,9
or half tablet or the dose interval can be changed.
Drug Product Information
Estimates of Renal Function Each drug is registered with product information for
For chronic kidney disease, estimates of renal function are prescribers which encapsulates large amounts of research
used to predict disease outcome. However for drug dosing, specific to that drug. When dosing advice for renal impairment

Table 2. Examples of drugs with fraction excreted unchanged (fe) ≥0.5.

Intermediate therapeutic index drugs fe

acyclovir and related antivirals 0.6–1


allopurinol 1 (oxypurinol)
atenolol 1
dabigatran 0.9
DPP-IV inhibitors* (e.g. sitigliptin) 0.8–1
gabapentin and pregabalin 1
low molecular weight heparins 0.7
metformin 1
morphine-6-glucuronide** 1

Wide therapeutic index drugs


ACE inhibitors† 1
beta-lactam antibiotics†† 0.7–1
carbapenems 0.6–1

* Dipeptidyl peptidase-IV inhibitors, used in treating type 2 diabetes.


** The major active metabolite of morphine.

Most angiotensin-converting enzyme (ACE) inhibitors are prodrugs (suffix -pril, e.g. enalapril) of a renally cleared active
moiety (suffix -prilat, e.g. enalaprilat).
††
With some exceptions e.g. ceftriaxine with fe ~ 0.5.

Clin Biochem Rev Vol 32 May 2011 I 71


Doogue MP & Polasek TM

is provided in the product information, it is important to Compliance


know what method of defining renal impairment is used in No discussion on drug dosing is complete without a mention
that particular product information if a patient’s dose is to be of compliance. Compliance is the greatest cause of therapeutic
reviewed. In most cases it is calculated creatinine clearance failure in the treatment of chronic diseases.12 In prescribing
using the Cockcroft and Gault equation,10 as for many years any drug, the possibility of current or future non-compliance
this has been recommended by the FDA for pharmacokinetic with the prescribed regimen should be considered. For
calculations.11 Although this situation may change, at the time example, a low digoxin concentration may be due to either
of writing the Cockcroft and Gault equation underpins the underdosing or appropriate dosing with poor compliance.
majority of drug product information. An estimate of GFR together with the digoxin concentration
helps to discriminate between these two possible causes of
It should also be noted that product information sheets often treatment failure.
have only crude dosing guidelines for renal impairment
and sometimes specifically exclude patients with renal Other Information
impairment (usually because these patients were excluded The effects of other variables that may influence drug dosing
from the primary studies). In these situations, applying first in renal disease, such as changes in urine pH and the role
principles is the only option if the drug is to be used, and of drug transporters for secretion, are beyond the scope
such considerations allow for more appropriate prescribing in of this article. Further information can be found in clinical
many situations. For example, a small change in creatinine pharmacology textbooks (such as Begg,4 Goodman and
clearance (or eGFR) from 31 mL/min to 29 mL/min may Gilman,13 and Cervelli14) or the primary literature. Online
appear to cross a treatment threshold (of 30 mL/min) but be resources are increasingly available for further learning.15-17
due solely to imprecision of measurement. Applying the letter
of the product information may result in a large change in Conclusion
dose or stopping the drug altogether, whereas in reality the Important variables relevant to prescribing decisions are often
dose may not need changing. not recognised in clinical care. The primary message of this
article is that renal function is an important physiological
Examples variable that predictably affects the pharmacokinetics and
Lithium is used primarily in the treatment of bipolar disorder thus clinical effectiveness of some drugs. Recognition of
and is 100% renally cleared. It has a narrow therapeutic index. renal function as a prescribing issue is more important than
An estimate of renal function helps select a starting dose for the precision of different estimates of renal function. When
treatment. Subsequent dosing should be guided by measured prescribing for a patient with decreased renal function the
drug concentrations and clinical response. Estimates of renal characteristics of both the patient and the drug should be
function can also be helpful in interpreting drug concentrations considered.
(e.g. assessing whether a low concentration is due to under-
dosing or poor compliance). Principles that can be applied to any drug dosing situation
have been described in this article. These are predicated on
The anti-gout drug allopurinol is the prodrug of oxypurinol pharmacokinetic principles, patient physiology and skill in
which is 100% renally cleared. It has an intermediate utilising drug information. Drug prescribing protocols do not
therapeutic index. An estimate of renal function as an estimate cover all scenarios. Understanding and applying principles
of drug clearance provides useful guidance to dosing and can of good prescribing, such as those outlined above, allow
be used together with clinical and biochemical measures of recognition of potential problems, avoidance of drug toxicities
effect (e.g. serum urate concentration). and improvements in treatment efficacy.

Amoxicillin is a beta-lactam antibacterial drug that is 100% Competing Interests: None declared.
renally cleared. It has a wide therapeutic index. It is usually
used acutely i.e. short-term. Most dosing guidelines do References
not discriminate on the basis of renal clearance except for 1. Florkowski CM, Chew-Harris JSC. Methods of
patients with end-stage renal disease. Estimates of renal estimating GFR – different equations including CKD
function are helpful in identifying patients who may need -EPI. Clin Biochem Rev 2011;32:75-9.
shorter dose intervals (high clearance) or may be adequately 2. Levey AS, Bosch JP, Lewis JB, Greene T, Rogers N,
Roth D. A more accurate method to estimate glomerular
treated with smaller dose amounts or longer dose intervals
filtration rate from serum creatinine: a new prediction
(low clearance).
equation. Modification of Diet in Renal Disease Study
Group. Ann Intern Med 1999;130:461-70.

72 I Clin Biochem Rev Vol 32 May 2011


Drug Dosing in Renal Disease

3. Australian Medicines Handbook. 11th ed. Adelaide; 2010. Drug Administration, Center for Drug Evaluation and
4. Begg EJ. Instant Clinical Pharmacology. 2nd edition. Research, Center for Biologics Evaluation and Research.
Wiley-Blackwell; 2007. May 1998 BP 3. http://www.fda.gov/downloads/
5. US Food and Drug Administration. http://www.fda.gov Drugs/GuidanceComplianceRegulatoryInformation/
(Accessed 11 February 2011). Guidances/ucm072127.pdf (Accessed 1 November
6. Janmahasatian S, Duffull SB, Ash S, Ward LC, Byrne 2010).
NM, Green B. Quantification of lean bodyweight. Clin 12. World Health Organization (WHO). Adherence to
Pharmacokinet 2005;44:1051-65. long-term therapies: evidence for action. Geneva,
7. Anderson BJ, Holford NH. Mechanistic basis of using Switzerland: WHO; 2003.
body size and maturation to predict clearance in humans. 13. Goodman and Gilman’s The Pharmacological Basis
Drug Metab Pharmacokinet 2009;24:25-36. of Therapeutics. 12th edition. Brunton L, Chabner B,
8. Barras MA, Duffull SB, Atherton JJ, Green B. Knollman B, eds. McGraw-Hill; 2011.
Individualized compared with conventional dosing of 14. The Renal Drug Reference Guide. 1st edition. Cervelli
enoxaparin. Clin Pharmacol Ther 2008;83:882-8. MJ, ed. 2007.
9. Jones GRD. Estimating renal function for drug dosing 15. Interactive Clinical Pharmacology. http://www.icp.org.
decisions. Clin Biochem Rev 2011;32:81-8. nz (Accessed 11 February 2011).
10. Cockcroft DW, Gault MH. Prediction of creatinine 16. NIH Clinical Center: Principles of Clinical
clearance from serum creatinine. Nephron 1976;16:31-41. Pharmacology. http://www.cc.nih.gov/training/training/
11. Guidance for Industry. Pharmacokinetics in patients principles.html (Accessed 11 February 2011).
with impaired renal function - study design, data 17. Pharmacokinetic and Pharmacodynamic Resources.
analysis, and impact on dosing and labeling. U.S. http://www.boomer.org/pkin/ (Accessed 11 February
Department of Health and Human Services, Food and 2011).

Clin Biochem Rev Vol 32 May 2011 I 73

You might also like