Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1: 23-31, 2020
ISSN 2598-1269
Diterima 24 Maret 2020 Essential oil of nutmeg (Myristica fragrans houtt) is one of the many
Disetujui 26 April 2020 potentials of nutmeg that has a high economic value although in North
Sulawesi it has not been exploited to its full potential. This research was
Key word: conducted to compare the yield and properties of Nutmeg oil extract from
nutmeg essential oil the seeds and mace of Talaud and North Minahasa -North Sulawesi. The
nutmeg oil oil extract was obtained by distillation and was further characterized in
North Sulawesi terms of color, solubility in ethanol, density, optical rotation, refractive
physico-chemical properties
index. Results of this research exhibited that oil of the mace of nutmeg
from Talaud had a lighter appearance in color compared to that from
*e-mail: emmamoko@unima.ac.id
*Telp: +62 82231939278 North Minahasa, while the density of oil extracted from North Minahasa
was more densed compared to Talaud in both seed and mace (0.923 and
0.938 respectively at 25°C). The reflective index of nutmeg oil from North
Minahasa was slightly higher than of Talaud both from seed and mace
(1.4834 and 1.493 at 25°C), while the optical rotations of oil extracted from
the mace were between +6.90° to +9.80° and from the seed were +20.73° to
+22.30°.9.
as a flavor enhancer should not be more than temperature, very soluble in ethanol but not
0.08%, beyond that may induce intoxication. water soluble [12]. Asside of oil, nutmeg
Nutmeg oil is also known for other properties, contains a buttery lipid regarded as oleoresin or
such as insecticide, fungicide, and antibacterial. nutmeg butter. The main constituent of this
A study on the anti-oxidative activities of butter are oleoresin, and especially trimyristicin
nutmeg seeds in comparison with BHT, ascorbic [12].
acid and α-tocopherol. Results of the work of
Nutmeg oil composition consists of 61-
indicated that nutmeg essential oil had a very
88% hydrocarbons (monoterpen), 5-15%
strong anti-oxidative characteristic, which was
oxygenated hydrocarbon and 2-18% aromatic
due to synergism of each components of the
ether, and other smaller compounds in minute
essential oil [6].
compositions [3]. The largest constituent of
Nutmeg oil in the pharmaceutical monoterpen hydrocarbons are the α-pinene
industry has been utilized as abdominal (17,2%), β-pinene (23,9%) and sabinene,
medications, diarrhea and bronchitis; meanwhile the myristicin are also considered as
moreover, nutmeg may be useful for treating one of the main components especially from the
flatulence, increasing metabolism, treating aromatic esther fractions, this includes miristic
dysentery (infectious diarrhea), stomach acid that was also found in smaller ammounts.
inflammation, a remedy of vomiting, The distinct fragrant aroma of the oil is mainly
constipation, bloating and rheumatism. 2-18% caused by the aromatic compound, in this case
of the aromatic compounds of myristicin, are the myristicin (16,2%), safrole (3,9%) and
elimicin, and safrole contained in the seed and methyl eugenol (1,8%), furthermore there are 25
flowers has the ability to induced hallucination identified components of nutmeg oil (92,1% of
[7]. Consumption of up to 5 grams of nutmeg the total oil), that was all obtained by
powder or oil may cause intoxication diagnosed hydrodestillation.
by vomiting, headaches and dry mouth [8-10]
One of the quality parameters of
Nutmeg is also a known aphrodisiac, industrially collected nutmeg oil is determined
stomachic, carminative while Guenther, (1952), by the myristin content, since myristicin
also noted that nutmeg has the function as a contributes to specific fragrant aroma of the
stimulant (tonic), nervous stimulant, aromatic, nutmeg [9]. Myristicins are derivatives of the
narcotic, astringent, holypolipidemic, anti- phenilepropanoid compounds, a clear to
thrombotic, anti-fungi, anti-dysentry and anti- opaque liquid that is not soluble in water but
inflammation [11, 12]. Nutmegs are also organic solvents, it has a distinct sharp herbal
reported to be very useful in treating paralysis aroma, and is very volatile. With a molecular
and help to improve blood circulation [13]. The weight of 192 g/mol, the other name of
Nutmeg also exhibited anti-oxidative characters myristicin is 5-alil-1-methoxi-2,3 methilene
[6, 14]. dioxibenzene or 5-metoxi saphrole [9].
Petroleum ether extract of the flesh of The nutmeg oil is commonly obtained by
Myristica fragans exhibited anti-diarrhea, while the simple steam destillation method or
extracts by n-hexane has been reported to have hydrodestillation. Extractions by those methods
the capacity to improve memory in rats [15]. will yield about 5% to 15% [16]. Destillation of
Nutmeg appears to have anti-bacterial activities the nutmeg oil is commonly from the seeds and
towards Staphylococcus aureus, Proteus vulgaris mace of the nutmeg. The seeds that are mostly
and Klebsiella pneumonia, but was not active used for oil extraction are usually the younger
towards Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Salmonella seeds due to the fact that the oil content would
typhimurium and Bacillus subtilis [6]. be higher than the older seeds, where the oil
would be more pale yellow in color, very
The nutmeg oil appears clear and a little
volatile and extends a very distinct fragrant
yellowish, faintly green at certain species and
note [2].
has a mild delicate aroma specific to nutmeg.
Nutmeg oil is very sensitive towards light and Aside of the distillation methods
24
Rahardiyan, D., Poluakan, M., Moko, E. M., 2020
commonly used such as steam/water distillation on a flat bamboo tray where the base section
or a combination of steam and water distillation was partially perforated due to the spaces
method, it is also common to find a method of between the bamboo weavings. This is
distillation also with water known as the necessary that the samples would receive ample
cohobation method, unfortunately this method is aeration during the drying. Drying the sample
less popular due to the quality of the oil wasn’t executed under any source of direct heat
obtained varies below the standards [3]. source, not even direct sunlight, only by placing
the trays of samples in a cool dry area with
Yield and quality of the distillation
ample wind.
results depends on factors of source material to
be extracted, method and conditions of the Destillation Nutmeg Oil
distillation, the installation of the distillatory,
The destillation of the nutmeg oil was
continue that nutmeg oil in Indonesia are most
conducted with a simple steam destillation
commonly originated from the seeds aging
method as described by Adewole and Marzuki
about 3-4months with a good yield of 8-17% but
with modification to adapt the apparatus to
at a very low quality, while the older seeds has
develop a simple apparatus that can be made
a lower yield of 8-13% but a higher quality of
industrial at the farmer level [14, 21].
oil [17].
Physcochemical Analysis
Nutmeg oil can also extracted from the
mace and leaves, while from the mace it is still The nutmeg essential oil physicochemical
achievable to extract between 4-17% but from analysis begins from the oil yield, visual
the leaves only could only yield up to 1.7%, thus appearances, and solubility in alcohol, density,
trying to extract oil from the leaves would be optical rotation and refraction indexes; where
very uneconomical, even though chemically the all were done accordingly to the SNI (Standard
characteristics of the oil from the seed, mace Nasional Indonesia).
even the leaves were similar quality-wise the
leaves were less [18, 19]. Scientifically, Color analysis of the oil was done
advancements in the extraction of nutmeg oil empirically, by observing the physical
components have moved from simple steam appearances of the oil obtained by distillation.
and water to the utilization of super critical The yield percentage of the oil was calculated as
CO2, or the supercritical fluid with a cellulose the proportion of nutmeg oil in sample volume,
acetate reverse osmosis membrane [17, 20]. as the formula as follow:
Materials
The main material of this research is the Solubility in alcohol was conducted
nutmeg itself which consists of the mace, and according the method of guenther, where 1 ml
seed. Samples were obtained at Talaud Regency essential oil was added ethanol a drop at a time
and North Minahasa Regency, North Sulawesi. [12]. With each addition of ethanol drop it the
mixture was shaken and observed if the oil is
Sample Preparation
soluble or not. The addition of ethanol
The nutmeg samples obtained from both continues until a clear solution is obtained.
regencies were cut up in pieces and separated
Density was done with a method as
between the mace and seeds. The nutmeg
carried out by Guenther which was simply
samples used in this research were fruits that
using a picnometer [12]. The Picnometer was
are young but physiologically mature at about
washed and cleaned with ethanol and
5-6 months after the bloom.
afterwards flushed with ether. Once dried it
The sample cuts were then spread evenly was weighed on a digital scale, following the
25
Rahardiyan, D., Poluakan, M., Moko, E. M., 2020
picnometer was then filled with ddH2O until the light and the dark and when the lines meet and
given mark and closed. The Picnometer filled crosses is the refraction indexes are read. The
with distilled water was left for a while before it refraction indexes will then be formulized as
was weighed once more. Water equivalent follow:
picnometer was the weight of the picnometer
ntD = nt1D + 0.00046 (t1-t)
filled substracted with the empty weight. This
method was then conducted with the nutmeg where:
oil and the density was calculated with the
ntD = oil refraction indexes at a certain temperature
following formula:
and density
density of numeg oil nt1D = oil refraction indexes at temperature (t10C) and
Density (t0C) = density D
density of ddH2 O
t = comparison temperature
Density (250C) = d + 0.00082 (t-250C) D = oil density
t1 = temperature test conducted on
where: 0.00046 = refraction correction factor at each 10C
t = temperature
d= density of nutmeg oil at temperature (t0C) Results and Discussion
0.00082 = nutmeg oil correction factor
The nutmeg oil that was obtained yield as
distillation results were 2.41% and 3.66%
Optical rotation was conducted with the
respectively for the seeds and the mace. These
polarimeter also following what was done by
yields were confirmed a work on the dry seeds
Guenther (1952) [12]. This was done by filling
of the North Sulawesi Islands (Sangihe, Talaud
the polarimeter tube with nutmeg oil sample
and Siau) and the North Sulawesi mainland
and then placed under the apparatus to be
(Minahasa Utara, Minahasa Tenggara and
checked between polarity and analizer. The
Minahasa Induk) where the results not far off
analizer was then turned slowly until half is
with what was obtained in this research where
seen through the telescope, and the light
the seeds of the off shore islands of North
intensity appears as bright as the light source.
Sulawesi mainly 4.89-5.11% were about while
At the proper adjustments accordingly to the
the on the mainland are about 4.08-5.01% [22].
right or left rotation based on the rightness on
The highest yield destillated from the islands of
the fields. Determination of the direction of
Siau were 5.11% and the lowest were from
rotation were as to where the analizer was
Southwest Minahasa (4.08%). Other researches
rotating; counter-clockwise from zero was
that was conducted in Papua exhibitited a lower
named levo (-), while clockwise dextro (+). After
yield of 3.11%, while of the seeds of Banda
the determination of the direction of rotation the
island was in the range of 8-12% [23]. Kartini
analizer was rearranged until the light intensity
also collected a yield of 2.25-3.35% from Papua
was again equal for the both areas. Observation
nutmegs [24].
was conducted through the scopes while
rotating the analizer, then the lines between the The color of nutmeg maces of Talaud
two fields becomes clear and thus the value was were yellowish to brownish in color, the North
read. The blanks were also conducted through Minahasa maces were more brownish in color,
the same procedure. while nutmeg oil obtained from the seeds from
Talaud or North Minahasa are more yellowish
Optical Rotation = sample readout – blanks readout
(Fig 1.). The color of the nutmeg oil of seeds and
The refractive indexes were carried out maces produced all were basically pale yellow,
using a refractometer. The nutmeg oil sample and was within the standard of SNI No. 06-
was placed on the prism of the refractometer at 2388-2006 (Indonesian National Standard) that
about 2-3 drops to cover the surface of the has set the standards that the color of nutmeg
prisms; the prisms were then closed together oil was pale yellow to clear, with a distinct
and left aside for a while for the oil temperature fragrant note of the nutmeg.
to adjust evenly. The slides where then
arranged to observe a clear line between the
26
Rahardiyan, D., Poluakan, M., Moko, E. M., 2020
extracted from the nutmeg’s mace originating Density 0.880 0.870 0.883 0.863 0.860 0.870
from Talaud and North Minahasa that was
Refraction 1.480 1.472 1.475 1.471 1.469 1.472
measured at 250C were 0.9459 and 0.9538 Indexes
were 0.9099 and 0.9230. In comparison with Solubility 1:6 1:6 1:6 1:6 1:6 1:6
in Alcohol
previous research on nutmeg off the of shore Solubl Solubl Solubl Solubl Solubl Solubl
islands and mainland North Sulawesi (Table 2), e e e e e e
27
Rahardiyan, D., Poluakan, M., Moko, E. M., 2020
28
Rahardiyan, D., Poluakan, M., Moko, E. M., 2020
(α-pinene, β-pinene, sabinene, carene, and Science advancements in this field have
terpinene) and thus would give a more positive moved to a more concentrated focus of the bio
rotational response. This would mainly be due activity of the components of nutmeg, such as
to the conditions of fixed oil contents and the antioxidant capacities and the antimicrobial
polymerization results of the trimyristin, where activities of the macelignans, a bioactive
trimyristin contains longer carbon chains and compound that was isolated and studied on its
tends to be more assymetric. This nature inhibitory activities against vegetative cells of
correlates to the carbon symmetric carbon Bacillus cereus [32]. Further studies on
structure of the oxygenated hydrocarbons and nutmeg’s macelignans and its future
the assymetric carbon structure of the aromatic applications in the industries might as well be
hydrocarbons [30]. In which positive optical the future of advancements of the nutmeg and
rotation would exhibit a spin of the polarization also might endorse a new horizon on the
field to the right while on the other hand a economic value of nutmeg.
negative rotation are to the left [31].
Acknowledgment
Solubility in ethanol would a physical
A special acknowledgment of gratitude is
trait that would correspond with the polarity
addressed to the Ministry of Research,
and purity of the essential oil. An essential oil
Technology and Higher Education of The
that contains more polar components would be
Republic of Indonesia (KEMENRISTEKDIKTI)
more soluble in polar solvents [27]. All our
for funding this research.
findings concluded that the nutmeg oil of
Talaud and North Minahasa, both from the seed
and mace all are soluble in 90% ethanol with a Conclusion
ratio of 1:1, this is in accordance also with the The North Sulawesi nutmegs in the
SNI standard of solubility in the range of 1:1 – findings of this research remained consistent
1:3. with previous researches, while also remained
within standard with the standards set by the
The perfect solubility in ethanol indicates
National Indonesian Standards. The oil of the
that the oils had identical polarity with ethanol,
mace from nutmeg from Talaud had a lighter
thus also indicates the ability of the samples to
appearance in color compared to that from
completely be dissolved in ethanol. The
North Minahasa, while the density of oil
solubility in ethanol is much influenced by the
extracted from North Minahasa was more
polarity of the components contained within the
densed compared to Talaud in both seed and
sample, the more of the larger components with
mace (0.923 and 0.938 respectively at 25°C). The
similar polarity with ethanol the quicker the
reflective index of nutmeg oil from North
samples would dissolve in ethanol. While if
Minahasa was slightly higher than of Talaud
otherwise indicated the more concentration of
both from seed and mace (1.4834 and 1.493 at
ethanol required to dissolve the nutmeg oil then
25°C), while the optical rotations of oil extracted
the more difficult it would be for the oil to be
from the mace were between +6.90° to +9.80°
fully soluble in ethanol [31].
and from the seed were +20.73° to +22.30°.9.
Solubility of an essential oil in ethanol Although in terms of myristicin content the
would be in conjunction with the chemical North Sulawesi nutmegs indicated higher
components in the oil itself [12]. Compounds concentrations of myristicin compared to
such as oxygenated terpene, α-terpineol and nutmeg oil from neighbouring islands of Banda
terpinen-4-ol are mainly found within the and Papua, therefore the North Sulawesi
nutmeg oil of the flesh. Oxygenated terpen nutmegs are prone to exhibit stronger fragrant
containing oil would be more soluble in ethanol aroma distinctive of the nutmeg, thus provides
then terpen containing oils, thus the higher the a certain economic aspect of value that may be
terpen concentration the lower the solubility exploited by the farmers of North Sulawesi
because un-oxygenated terpen are non-polar other than just selling nutmeg seeds in the local
compounds with no functional groups [22]. markets. Although the myristicin is still the
29
Rahardiyan, D., Poluakan, M., Moko, E. M., 2020
31