Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1995 - A Direct Relationship Between Thyroid Enlargement and Breast Cancer
1995 - A Direct Relationship Between Thyroid Enlargement and Breast Cancer
3
Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism Printed in U.S.A.
Copyright 0 1996 by The Endocrine Society
Endocrine Laboratory, Departments of Medicine and Therapeutics and Surgery, St. Vincent’s Hospital,
University College, Dublin, Ireland
screening
of controls
The control populations
program carried
consist of women
out at University
participating
College Dublin,
in a health
during
between the two disorders. Associations of breast cancer 1988/1989. Those with a history of breast disease were excluded from
with hypothyroidism (2-5), T, replacement therapy (6), hy- the study. Age matching was achieved by selecting from the control
perthyroidism (7,8), and thyroiditis (9) have been reported, populations only those patients whose ages fell within the age ranges of
patient groups. Subjects were not matched for height or body weight.
whereas no significant relationship has been observed by
Both patient and control groups came from the same catchment area and
others (10-14). Increased breast cancer incidence in areasof represented a reasonable cross-section of an adult female urban/rural
endemic goiter have been reported (15-l@, but no change population of varied socioeconomic status.
occurred when goiter rate decreasedafter iodine prophylaxis
(4, 8). Finally, an increased breast cancer mortality was re-
ported by Goldman et al. (19) in patients who had nontoxic Coincidence of breast and thyroid disease
nodular goiter and were receiving T, suppression therapy. Patients and controls were assessed for both breast and thyroid dis-
Thus, the significance of the simultaneous occurrence of thy- ease by the same surgical team, and any history of previous thyroid
roid diseaseand breast cancer remains to be elucidated. The disease was recorded. Where such a history was present, classification
as hyperthyroidism, hypothyroidism, or nontoxic goiter was made on
objective of the present study was to investigate whether the
the basis of the original diagnosis.
availability of high resolution diagnostic ultrasound could
permit the detection in patients with breast cancer of more
subtle changes in thyroid volume. Breast cancer
Two hundred consecutive patients, aged 28-89 yr (mean 2 SE, 57.2
Subjects and Methods 2 1.4 yr; median, 57 yr) had thyroid scans over a 5-yr period (19881993).
Histological classification of breast cancers was made in the Department
Selection of patients of Pathology, St. Vincent’s Hospital (Dublin, Ireland). Information on
Patients under study were attending a specialist breast clinic at histologically measured tumor size made according to Union Interna-
St. Vincent’s Hospital (Dublin, Ireland). tionale Contre le Cancer criteria was available for 191 patients; 7 were
classified TO (not palpable), 57 Tl (c2.0 cm), 94 T2 (2.0-5.0 cm), and 33
T3 or T4 (>5.0 cm). One hundred were studied retrospectively, in that
Received July 21,1995. Revision received October 25,1995. Accepted they had received both surgical and medical therapy before being sub-
November 2, 1995. jected to thyroid ultrasound scans. The remaining 100 patients, termed
Address all correspondence and requests for reprints to: Dr. P. P. A. the prospective group, had thyroid scans at the time of excision biopsy
Smyth, Endocrine Laboratory, Department of Medicine and Therapeu- before the diagnosis of breast malignancy.
tics, Woodview, University College Dublin, Dublin 4, Ireland.
* Presented in part at the American Thyroid Association Meeting,
Boston, MA, September 11-15, 1991, and at the European Thyroid Older controls
Association Clinical Symposium: The Female Thyroid In Health and
Disease, Dublin, Ireland, June 20-25,1992. This work was supported by Two hundred nonhospitalized women, aged 22-84 yr (mean, 53.0 ?
the Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland Research Committee. 0.67 yr; median, 52 yr) served as controls for the breast cancer group.
937
938 SMYI’H ET AL. JCE & M . 1996
Vol81 . No 3
TABLE 2. Mean values Ifr SE for serum T,, T,, TSH, and PRL in patients with breast cancer or BBD and control groups
T4 T, TSH PrL
Group NO. (nmol/L) fnmol/L) (mu/L) (ng/mL)
Breast cancer 190 111 k 2.9 2.1 ? 0.05 2.1 ? 0.10 5.0 t 0.40
Older controls 182 116 2 2.0 2.3 2 0.08 1.9 ? 0.08 4.7 ? 0.29
BBD 124 117 ? 2.4 2.2 -c 0.04 2.4 k 0.09 5.8 2 0.30
Younger controls 95 119 t 2.1 2.3 k 0.05 1.9 ? 0.11 5.0 2 0.45
Blood samples were not available from all patients who had thyroid ultrasound scans and results of thyroid function tests from patients with
uncontrolled thyroid disease (2 hypothyroid and 1 hyperthyroid from the breast cancer group) were excluded from the study.
Median % Enlarged
Volume (ml) > 18.0 ml
60 -
N.S.
% 40 -.
Frequency
n BBD 13.1 17.2%
30 ._
20
10
0
1 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50
FIG. 1. Percent frequency distribution of ultrasound-measured thy- Thyroid Volume (ml)
roid volumes in breast cancer (Br CA) and older control groups.
FIG. 2. Percent frequency distribution of ultrasound-measured thy-
TABLE 3. Thyroid volumes in 191 breast cancer patients roid volumes in patients with BBD and younger control groups.
classified according to pathologically measured tumor size
W Initial Volume
H Repeat Volume
< Volume Decreased > Volume Unchanged > Volume Increased >
Patient l-l 5 Patient 16 - 22 Patient 23 - 39
TABLE 4. Comparison of mean thyroid volumes ? SE and The consequences of thyroid enlargement for the gen-
percentage of individual patients with enlarged thyroid glands in esis or natural history of breast cancer remain unknown,
patients scanned after (retrospective group) and before
(prospective group) commencement of therapies for breast cancer
although one report (19) showed increased mortality (stan-
dardized mortality ratio, 2.8) in breast cancer patients who
Mean age Thyroid vol No >18.0 mL had nontoxic nodular goiter and were receiving T, sup-
2 SE (yr) (ml) (70) pression therapy. Although the significance of the asso-
Control 200 53.0 t 0.7 13.2 t 0.5 21(10.5) ciation between thyroid enlargement and breast cancer
Breast cancer 200 57.2 i 1.4 21.1 k 1.4 83 (41.5) demonstrated in the present study remains to be eluci-
Retrospective 100 58.0 k 1.5 20.8 2 1.3 43 (43.0)
Prospective 100 56.3 i 1.2 21.4 i 1.6 40 (40.0) dated, it may be of value to establish whether the phe-
nomenon exists in populations from different genetic
might be interpreted as reflecting improvements in dietary pools or dietary iodine intakes. Perhaps the most impor-
iodine intake. However, a previous iodine deficiency cannot tant outcome of the association will be to emphasize the
provide the sole answer for these age differences in the pa- importance of raising the consciousnessof the coincidence
tient groups, as such differences were not observed in con- of both disorders.
trols.
Thus, the underlying cause of the finding of enlarged Acknowledgments
thyroids in such a high proportion of patients with breast The authors gratefully acknowledge the contribution in making this
cancer (41.5%) compared to age-matched controls without work possible of Nurse F. Hanley-Leahy for expert phlebotomy; Sr.
evidence of breast disease(8.6%) remains unknown. The fact Josepha, Nurse K. Murray, and the staff of St. Anthony’s Rehabilitation
Center; the staff of the Department of Surgery, University College
that there is a direct association between the two conditions, Dublin; and Ms. A. M. Hetherton for expert technical assistance.
rather than thyroid enlargement occurring as a consequence
of various therapies for breast cancer, is supported by the References
finding of a concurrence between results obtained in patients
1. Beatson GT. 1896 On the treatment of inoperable cases of carcinoma of the
studied retrospectively or prospectively. Repeat thyroid mamma: suggestions for a new method of treatment, with illustrative cases.
scansshowed that there were no significant trends in thyroid Lancet. 2104-107.
enlargement or involution. The largest changes in thyroid 2. Loeser AA. 1954 A new therapy for prevention of post-operative recurrences
in genital and breast cancer: a six-years study of prophylactic thyroid treat-
volume (-18.0, +10.8, and +13.6 mL occurred in patients ment. Br Med J. 2:1380-1383.
with significantly enlarged glands (96.0, 45.2, and 33.8 mL, 3. Stoll BA. 1965 Breast cancer and hypothyroidism. Cancer. 18~1431-1436.
4. Backwinkel K, Jackson A. 1964 Some features of breast cancer and thyroid
respectively) and may reflect the difficulty in accurately mea- deficiency. Cancer. 17~1174-1176.
suring thyroid volume in such patients (24, 25). 5. Takatani 0, Okumoto T, Kosano H, et al. 1989 Relationship between the levels
The absence of a trend in alterations in thyroid volume of serum thyroid hormones or estrogen status and the risk of breast cancer
genesis in Japanese women. Cancer Res. 9:3109-3112.
over the time period investigated suggeststhat thyroid en- 6. Kapdi CC, Wolfe J. 1976 Breast cancer: relationship to thyroid supplements
largement either preceded or paralleled the breast lesion. The for hypothyroidism. JAMA. 236:1124-1127.
striking associationbetween thyroid enlargement and breast 7. Wanebo HJ, Benua RS, Rawson RW. 1966 Neoplastic disease and thyrotox-
icosis. Cancer. 19:1523-1526.
cancer leads us to speculate on the possibility of the endo- 8. Moossa AR, Price Evans DA, Brewer AC. 1973 Thyroid status and breast
crine and other growth stimuli identified in the thyroid ex- cancer; reappraisal of an old relationship. Ann R Co11 Surg Lond. 53:178-188.
9. Itoh K, Mamchi N. 1975 Breast cancer in patients with Hashimoto’s thyroiditis.
erting a simultaneous action on the breast (26). How such Lancet. 2:1119-1121.
stimuli could exert their effect on mammary tissue is un- 10. German CA, Becker D, Greenspan FS, et al. 1977 American Thyroid Asso-
known, although the recent demonstration of extrathyroidal ciation statement: breast cancer and thyroid hormone therapy. Ann Intern
Med. 86~502-503.
loci for the TSH receptor (27-301,in particular in fatty tissue, 11. Wallace RB, Sherman BM, Bean JA, Leeper J. 1978 Thyroid hormone use in
may have significance for the breast. patients with breast cancer: absence of an association. JAMA. 239:958.
THYROID VOLUME IN BREAST CANCER 941
12. Brinton LA, Hoffman DA, Hoover R, rraumeni JF. 1984 Relationship of Neto G, Gaitan E, eds. Frontiers in thyroidology. New York: Plenum Press; vol
thyroid disease and use of thyroid supplements to breast cancer risk. J Chronic 2:1021-1031.
Dis. 37~877-883. 23. Hetherton AM, Smyth PPA. 1993 Status of iodine deficiency in Ireland. In:
13. Kalache A, Vessey P, McPherson K. 1982 Thyroid disease and breast cancer: Delange F, Dunn JT, Glinoer D, eds. Iodine deficiency in Europe: a continuing
findings in a large case-control study. Br J Surg. 69:434-435. concern. New York: Plenum Press; 317-322.
14. Hedley AJ, Jones SI, Spiegelhalter DJ, et al. 1981 Breast cancer in thyroid 24. Berghout A, Wiersinga WM, Smits NJ, Touber JL. 1988 The value of thyroid
disease: fact or fallacy. Lancet. 1:131-133. volume measured by ultrasonography in the diagnosis of goitre. Clin Endo-
15. Spencer JGC. 1954 The influence of the thyroid in malignant disease. Br J crinol (0x0. 28:409-414.
Cancer. 8:393-411. 25. Gutekunst R, Martin-Teichert H. 1993 Requirements for goitre surveys and
16. Bogardus GM, Finley JW. 1961 Breast cancer and thyroid disease. Surgery. the determination of goitre size. In: Delange F, Dunnand JT, Glinoer D, eds.
49461-468. Iodine deficiency in Europe, a continuing concern. New York: Plenum Press;
17. Eskin BA. 1970 Iodine metabolism and breast cancer. Tram NY Acad Sci. 109-118.
11:911-947. 26. Dumont JE, Maenhaut C, Pirson I, Baptist M, Roger PP. 1991 Growth factors
18. Adamopoulos DA, Vassilarus S, Kapolla N, Papadiamantis J, Georgiakodis controlling the thyroid gland. Baillieres Clin Endocrinol Metab. 5727-753.
F, Michalkis A. 1986 Thyroid disease in patients with benign and malignant 27. Roselli-Rehfuss L, Robbins LS, Cone Rd. 1992 Thyrotropin receptor mes-
mastopathy. Cancer. 57~1255128. senger ribonucleic acid is expressed in most brown and white adipose tissue
19. Goldman MB, Monson RR, Maloof F. 1990 Cancer mortality in women with in the guinea pig. Endocrinology. 130:1857-1861.