Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Precision Engineering
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/precision
A R T I C L E I N F O A B S T R A C T
Keywords: Micro electric discharge machining (μ-EDM) is a widely used process for machining of difficult to machine
Micro EDM materials. The occurrence of arcing and short circuiting in micro electric discharge drilling (EDD) is a common
Tool geometry problem which limits the aspect ratio achieved during the process. The present study is focused on the im-
MRR provement in response characteristics by eliminating the occurrence of arcing and short circuiting. These pro-
TWR
blems can be addressed by modifying the tool electrode geometry. Although, EDD using shaped tool electrodes
Aspect ratio
Hole quality
improve response characteristics as proven by the previous studies, but time spent in electrode fabrication must
also be considered as it affects the overall productivity. Considering the literature related to EDD using shaped
tool electrodes, the proposed electrode has been found to have minimum electrode fabrication time i.e. 9 min for
an electrode length of 3.2 mm. Therefore, the proposed electrode is capable of producing holes of high aspect
ratio with minimum electrode fabrication time. The proposed electrode was also found to be effective in
eliminating the accumulation of debris in the machining zone. Moreover, the need of flushing during the process
has been totally eliminated making it a self-flushing electrode. The mechanism of removal of debris is well
explained based on the images captured using a high speed camera. The performance of the proposed electrode
was evaluated with respect to response characteristics such as material removal rate, tool wear rate, aspect ratio,
taper angle and corner radius of the drilled hole. A substantial increase of 300% in aspect ratio was recorded
using the designed electrode as compared to the solid cylindrical electrode for the hole diameter of 0.8 mm.
1. Introduction pulses (arc pulses and short circuit pulses), the aspect ratio is limited in
case of holes produced by micro EDM.
Titanium alloy (Ti6Al4V) is widely used in many engineering ap- A solid cylindrical electrode is generally used in Micro electric
plications like automobile, aerospace and defense due to its properties discharge drilling (EDD) process to fabricate the holes along with suf-
of low specific density and high specific strength. It comes in the ca- ficient amount of flushing to flush out the debris. But as the tool ad-
tegory of difficult-to-machine materials due to high toughness and low vances deeper into the workpiece, the influence of flushing goes on
thermal conductivity. Machining with conventional methods results in reducing. At a critical depth, the flushing becomes ineffective and the
high tool wear and low surface integrity. Micro hole machining is fur- debris find it difficult to evacuate from the machining zone. The ac-
ther a challenging task, therefore, there is an imminent need to focus on cumulation of debris in the discharge gap results in the phenomenon of
the development of unconventional machining processes. Micro electric arcing and short circuiting resulting in higher machining time and low
discharge machining (EDM) is a process that is widely used for such aspect ratio. The high initial pressure of the gaseous bubbles offer
type of difficult-to-machine materials as it removes the material irre- strong resistance to the flow of dielectric oil, thus leading to limited
spective of its hardness. EDM being an electro thermal process removes aspect ratio. During discharge, bubbles are generated in the discharge
the material by a series of electrical discharges with the aid of dielectric gap and maximum debris move out of the discharge gap following the
flushing that removes the debris from the sparking zone. Flushing is a excluded bubbles [1,2]. Beyond the critical depth, the high initial
key factor in achieving the hole of desired aspect ratio and surface pressure of bubbles reaches equilibrium with the viscous resistance of
finish. Improper flushing causes the accumulation of debris in the the dielectric oil in the side gap and the surface tension of the bubbles
machining zone resulting in the occurrence of arcing and short cir- in the discharge gap [3]. Bubbles cannot flow out of the hole, and their
cuiting. Short circuiting is a discharge-less state which slows down the accumulation isolates the dielectric flow into the machining area. The
machining rate or even stops it. Because of these abnormal discharge absence of dielectric flow in discharge area results in frequent short
☆
This paper was recommended by Associate editor Prof. Chung Chung Choo
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: ravi87.r@gmail.com (R. Kumar).
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.precisioneng.2017.10.008
Received 24 April 2017; Received in revised form 6 September 2017; Accepted 13 October 2017
Available online 16 October 2017
0141-6359/ © 2017 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
R. Kumar, I. Singh Precision Engineering 51 (2018) 529–535
circuiting, leading to extreme tool wear and significant dropping in wire was moved depending upon the width of the slot required.
machining speed. To overcome these problems, several approaches
have been attempted by researchers, such as flushing, planetary 2.2. Experimental setup
movement of the electrode, ultrasonic vibration of the electrode and
geometry of the electrode. From the literature review, the geometry of All experiments were conducted on a micro EDM machine unit
the tool electrode has been found to be very helpful in preventing the (Make: Synergy Nano Systems, Model: Hyper-15, India) as shown in
accumulation of debris in the machining zone, thereby, eliminating the Fig. 2. The attachments of EDD and WEDM can be mounted on the
occurrence of arcing and short circuiting. The slots fabricated into the machine column, whenever required. The wire electric discharge
cylindrical electrode provides a pathway for the debris to be easily grinding (WEDG) attachment, consists of a wire of diameter 0.2 mm
removed from the inter-electrode gap increasing the machining effi- which can travel at variable speed between the spools. Mounting of tool
ciency. Till date, only a handful of attempts have been reported re- electrode on the spindle always lead to minimum amount of eccen-
garding control of the arcing and short circuiting in the EDM process tricity due to clamping errors. WEDG is a much-needed process in micro
using different electrode geometries and tool profiles. Wang et al. [4] EDD in eliminating the eccentricity and achieving the required dia-
investigated the effects of cylindrical electrode and a helical electrode meter by fabricating the tool on the machine prior to the experiments.
on the micro EDM performance and concluded that helical electrode
provides higher MRR and lower TWR. Hung et al. [5] used a helical 3. Experimental procedure
micro-tool electrode for micro-EDM combined with ultrasonic vibration
and reported a significant reduction in the EDM gap, taper and ma- The drilling of holes of diameters 0.8 mm using tool electrode fea-
chining time for deep micro-hole drilling. Plaza et al. [6] proposed a tured with inclined micro slots was carried out using three processes i.e.
new helical shaped electrode and reported a reduction of 37% in ma- WEDM, WEDG and EDD as shown in Fig. 3(a–c). The fabrication of
chining time using electrode with a helix angle of 45° and flute depth of micro slots has been explained in section on fabrication of tool elec-
50 μm. Nastasi and Koshy [7] designed tool electrodes with different trode (Fig. 3(a)). After fabricating the slot, the electrode is then
geometric features (helices and longitudinal slots) to promote tool ro- mounted on the spindle of the EDD attachment. To remove the eccen-
tation-induced debris removal. The designed electrodes were compared tricity as well as to achieve the diameter of 0.8 mm, WEDG was per-
with the solid cylindrical electrode for maximizing MRR. Zhiqiang et al. formed (Fig. 3(b)). A CCD camera was used for the measurement pur-
[8] designed a double helix electrode for the micro electric discharge poses. Ti6Al4 V workpiece was fixed on the table and EDD was
drilling. The authors reported that double helix electrode improved performed using input parameters as shown in Table 2 (Fig. 3(c)). The
material removal efficiency and depth to diameter ratio of micro hole as objective of the experimental investigation is to compare the perfor-
compared to a flat faced electrode. Liu et al. [9] designed a two-stage mance of the tool electrode with inclined micro slots and solid cylind-
cylindrical electrode, the first stage having a solid cylindrical shape rical electrode at a constant discharge energy. The voltage and capa-
whereas the second stage having a helical shape of larger diameter. The citance were kept constant whereas slot inclination, slot width and tool
second stage with helical groove was used for grind machining with SiC speed were varied. Tool wear in micro EDM can hardly be measured by
particles and found effective in improving the surface quality of the measuring the weight difference of the tool electrode even using a
hole. Wansheng et al. [10] carried out EDM hole drilling provided with highly sensitive weighing scale. A general approach to measure the
ultrasonic vibrations using a notched tool electrode and recorded an wear of a micro tool is by allowing the electrode to make an electric
improvement in machining efficiency and hole taper. Yan et al. [11] contact at a datum point before and after the experiment. The change of
used a notched electrode in their experimental study and concluded Z value denotes the wear length. The MRR and TWR were calculated by
that a tool electrode with a notch can improve the debris evacuation. dividing the removed volume by the machining time (Eq. (1)).
Hsue and Chang [12] proposed a synchronous micro-EDM grinding
Removed volume
process using a helical shaped electrode co-deposited with fine diamond MRR or TWR =
Machining time (1)
abrasives. The electrode was found effective eliminating the need of a
separate grinding process to fabricate precision micro-holes.
In the present experimental investigation, a novel tool electrode was 4. Results and discussion
designed by cutting an inclined micro slot into the cylindrical tool
electrode with an objective to assist the removal of debris from the 4.1. Mechanism of debris evacuation
machining zone. The influence of featured micro slot was investigated
at two different angles of inclination with the horizontal i.e. 60° and The performance of the proposed electrode was analyzed through
75°. The variation of slot width and tool speed has also been in- experimental tests, by comparing machining time and aspect ratio with
vestigated with an objective to improve the response characteristics. those obtained using the solid cylindrical electrode. The effect of the
inclined micro slot was observed in eliminating the accumulation of
2. Materials and methods debris up to a depth equal to the height of the slot. The presence of
inclined micro slot provided a pathway to the generated bubbles as well
2.1. Fabrication of tool electrode as to the debris to leave out from the cavity by providing them a wider
path to move through (100–200 μm of slot width instead of 20–40 μm
Two types of electrodes (featured with inclined micro slots) have of side gap). Fig. 4(a) shows a schematic representation of evacuation of
been fabricated using the WEDM process (Fig. 1) with the variation in bubbles and debris through the inclined micro slot. During the EDM
slot angle and slot width. The objective of the featured slot is to provide process, the centrifugal force generated by the rotating electrode forces
a path for the debris to escape easily from the machining zone using the the bubbles away from the center of the electrode. Their collision makes
rotation of the electrode. To fabricate the proposed electrode, a solid them bigger in size (bubble expansion). The expanded bubble faces a
cylindrical tungsten carbide rod of 1 mm diameter was taken and fixed resistance from the hole surface and electrode wall surface which
on the machine table. Using wire EDM, slots of width 50, 100, 150 and lowers its speed of traveling out. The proposed electrode provides a
200 μm were cut into the tungsten carbide rod at angles of 60° and 75° pathway for the bubbles to move out easily. Evacuation of bubbles leads
to the horizontal with a depth equal to the radius of the rod. The to evacuation of debris [1,2], as shown in the images captured using
parameters used in the WEDM process are shown in Table 1. As the wire high speed camera (Fig. 4(b)). The debris is distributed near the surface
used in WEDM was of diameter 50 μm, the slot width of 50 μm was cut of the bubble and within the bubble. The rotation of the electrode
with a single pass only. To cut the slot width of more than 50 μm, the works in picking up the maximum amount of bubbles from around the
530
R. Kumar, I. Singh Precision Engineering 51 (2018) 529–535
531
R. Kumar, I. Singh Precision Engineering 51 (2018) 529–535
Fig. 3. Processes used in experimental work (a) WEDM (b) WEDG (c) EDD.
Table 2
Process parameters for micro EDD.
Parameters Value
Variables
Slot inclination (degrees) 60, 75
Slot width (μm) 50, 100, 150, 200
Speed (rpm) 500, 1000, 1500
Constant parameters
Voltage (V) 100
Capacitance (pF) 10,000
Feed (μm/s) 3
Electrode diameter (mm) 0.8
Electrode material Tungsten carbide
Polarity Positive
Electrode base Slot base
Fig. 5. Variation of machining time with depth of hole for different electrodes.
improving the MRR and aspect ratio as well as reducing the TWR.
Moreover, the quality of the drilled holes need to be analyzed to as-
certain the effectiveness of slotted electrode over solid electrode. The
drilled holes were cut in half using WEDM (Fig. 9) and their taper angle
and corner radius were measured. Taper angle was measured using Eq.
(2).
Change in diameter ⎤
Taper angle (θ) = tan−1 ⎡
⎢
⎣ 2*Length ⎥
⎦ (2)
Fig. 10 compares the taper angle values recorded for the solid and
the slotted electrodes (with different slot widths) at the critical depth
which is 1.5 mm for solid electrode and 3.2 mm for the slotted electrode
(75° slot angle). It can be seen that the taper angle of the hole drilled by
Fig. 6. MRR and TWR at 1.5 mm depth for different electrodes.
the slotted electrode is less as compared to the hole drilled by the solid
electrode. In case of solid electrode, the movement of the debris
through very narrow side gap causes additional side sparking resulting corner radius of the holes drilled using solid and slotted electrode at the
in a tapered hole. But, in case of electrode featured with an inclined respective critical depths. The electrode with a slot width of 100 μm
micro slot, the maximum movement of the debris is through the in- records minimum corner radius. The corner radius of a hole drilled
clined slot (Fig. 4) which eliminates the formation of additional using solid electrode is 0.164 mm at a depth of 1.5 mm (critical depth)
sparking resulting in lower value of taper angle. Fig. 11 shows the whereas, it is 0.181 mm using slotted electrode (slot width of 100 μm)
532
R. Kumar, I. Singh Precision Engineering 51 (2018) 529–535
533
R. Kumar, I. Singh Precision Engineering 51 (2018) 529–535
through the slot is the key in achieving continuous machining. For this electrode. The authors reported a fabrication time of 15 min for 2 mm
purpose, the position of the slots was so arranged that slot 1 and slot 2 electrode length for the electrode diameter of 0.3 mm. The fabrication
together provide a continuous path for the bubbles to move out as time for the present electrode (type II) is 9 min for 3.2 mm electrode
shown in Fig. 15(a). The movement of bubbles towards slot 2 is based length for the electrode diameter of 0.8 mm (slot inclination of 75°) and
on the same fact that bubbles find it easier to move through the wider will further be lower for the smaller electrode diameter. Therefore, the
opening (150 μm of slot width instead of 20–30 μm of side gap). proposed electrode is capable of producing holes of high aspect ratio
Keeping the fact in mind, multiple slots were cut in an electrode of with minimum cycle time.
diameter 0.8 mm (Fig. 15(b)) with an objective to achieve maximum
possible aspect ratio. The electrode before and after machining is shown 5. Conclusions
in Fig. 15(c). It was observed experimentally that the electrode can now
machine upto a depth of 6 mm providing an aspect ratio of 7.5. The In the present experimental investigation, the process performance
findings of the experimental work have been summarized in Table 3. of electric discharge drilling using electrodes with featured micro slots
The critical depth that was achieved using solid and multiple slotted has been analyzed. A novel class of electrodes has been fabricated by
electrodes was 1.5 mm and 6 mm, respectively. This corresponds to cutting inclined micro slots in the solid cylindrical electrode with an
300% increase in aspect ratio compared to the solid electrode. The objective to improve the machining performance. Blind holes were
selection of the electrode type shown in Table 3 depends upon the as- drilled in Ti6Al4V workpiece to evaluate the effectiveness of the de-
pect ratio of the hole to be drilled. Type II electrode can be used to drill signed electrodes. The effect of slot angle, slot width and tool speed on
a hole with aspect ratio of 4. Type III electrode is more productive and MRR and aspect ratio was also evaluated. The following conclusions
can be used where machining time is a limitation compromising with a can be drawn from the present experimental investigation;
higher electrode fabrication time. Type IV electrode can be used where
the major concern is high aspect ratio and not the productivity. Type IV • The idea of using an inclined micro slot for eliminating the accu-
electrode has higher fabrication time and lower MRR but provides a mulation of debris during micro EDD process was found to be suc-
hole with high aspect ratio. cessful.
• The slotted electrodes generate tool rotation induced debris re-
moval, thereby eliminating the occurrence of arcing and short cir-
4.6. Economics of electrode fabrication cuiting.
534
R. Kumar, I. Singh Precision Engineering 51 (2018) 529–535
535