Professional Documents
Culture Documents
NOURAH ALMASHAN
NABIL ISMAEL
Civil Engineering Department, Kuwait University, P. 0. Box 5969, Safat 13060 Kuwait
Key Terms: Surface Sands, High-Density Polyethylene sion tolerance. Large amounts of HDPE bits shred
(HDPE) Bits, Shear Strength, Compressibility, Recy ded from damaged, scrap, or faulty double-wall cor
cled Materials rugated pipes require reuse or recycling in the State of
Kuwait. One possible use of this material to consider is
ABSTRACT as an additive (in small quantities) to the local surface
sands of Kuwait (soils obtained from test pits of 0.5-
Large amounts of shredded high-density polyethylene to 3-m depth). The amended soil may then be used as
(H DPE) plastic bits are generated in Kuwait as a by an engineering construction material. As such, it can
product of the production of plastic pipes. To find ben help protect the environment and conserve resources
eficial uses for this waste material, an extensive labo (Hejazi et al., 2012).
ratory testing program was carried out on two local sur Recent studies focused on the reuse of waste HDPE
face sands of Kuwait amended with shredded H DPE bits bits with soil or soil-cement fly ash to increase the sta
in amounts varying from 0 percent to 15 percent (by bility of the subgrade for road construction (Sobhan
weight). Laboratory tests included sieve analysis, modi and Mashnad, 2002, 2003) and its durability (Bueno
fied proctor compaction, direct shear, consolidation, and et al., 1997). Meera and Hashifa (2015) and Patidar
permeability tests. The testing measured the effect of in and Mahiyar (2014) investigated the effect of HDPE
creased H D PE content on the different soil properties. fibers on the shear strength of black cotton soils.
The results indicate a reduction of the maximum den They noted that the angle of internal friction, c|>, in
sity of about 20 percent and a substantial increase in the creased with increasing HDPE fiber content. Nsaif
permeability and compressibility. The strength param (2013) studied the influence of the HDPE fibers mixed
eters, namely the cohesion, C, and the angle of inter with two different soils, sandy and clayey soils, at
nal friction, <f>, increased with increasing H D PE content. fiber percentages of 2, 4, 6, and 8 percent by weight.
Therefore, the use of H DPE plastic bits as an additive to Compaction and direct shear testing indicated that the
the local soils in Kuwait is beneficial for many practical maximum dry density decreased and the angle of in
applications, such as lightweight fill, embankment con ternal friction increased with no change in the co
struction, and as a drainage layer in the construction of hesion, C. Similar findings were observed by Fauzi
landfills. et al. (2016) from tests on a clayey soil, except that
the cohesion value decreased with increasing HDPE
bits.
INTRODUCTION
To explore the possible uses of shredded HDPE bits
High-density polyethylene (HDPE) is widely used in Kuwait, an extensive laboratory testing program
in the production of plastic pipes. The HDPE is con was carried out using two local soils, namely silty sand
sidered a recycled material, one that is chemical and and clayey sand, and shredded HDPE bits as an addi
corrosion resistant and environmentally friendly. Or tive in the amount of 0 to 15 percent by weight. Test
man (1994) reported that HDPE is resistant to many ing included basic properties, compaction, direct shear,
organic substances, unaffected by soil-borne bacteria consolidation, and permeability. Based on test results,
and fungi, and possesses superior chemical and abra several practical applications are recommended. These
include earth fill, embankment construction, road sub
grade construction, and use of the bits as a drainage
*Corresponding author email: Ziad06@outlook.com layer.
Environmental & Engineering Geoscience, Vol. X X V . No. 3, A ugust 2019, pp. 213-221 213
Abdelsalam, Almashan, and Ismael
BASIC PROPERTIES OF SOIL SAMPLES employed in the test were 0, 5. 10. and 15 percent, by
AND SH R ED D ED HDPE BITS weight. The shredded bits used passed sieve No. 4, with
an opening size of 4.75 mm. Table 2 summarizes the
The soil samples used are two common Kuwaiti raw material properties of the shredded HDPE plastic
soils, namely a silty sand and a clayey sand. The grain bits, including the following: density, tensile and elon
size distribution. Atterberg limits, specific gravity, and gation properties, flexural modulus, modulus of elas
compaction characteristics were assessed in this study ticity, carbon black content, melt flow index, shore
to measure the basic soil properties. Figure 1 shows hardness D, co-efficient of linear thermal expansion,
the grain size distribution curves of the soil samples Vicat softening point, and oxidation induction time
used in this study. The test was conducted according (OIT). These data were obtained from Abdelsalam
to ASTM D422 (ASTM. 2007). The soil was classi (2015).
fied according to the Unified Soil Classification Sys
tem (USCS), as recommended by the ASTM D2487
(ASTM. 2017). The Atterberg limits and specific grav SAMPLE PREPARATION
ity of the soils were tested according to ASTM D4318
(ASTM, 2010) and ASTM C128 (ASTM, 2015), re Samples for direct shear, consolidation, and perme
spectively. The modified proctor test was used in this ability tests were prepared in four layers by tamping
study to determine the compaction characteristic of to reach the required density. The size of the sam
soil according to ASTM D1557(ASTM, 2012). Table 1 ples was determined by the size of the mold of the
describes the basic properties of soils. standard laboratory test equipment used. All sam
The shredded HDPE plastic bits were used in this ples were compacted to the maximum dry density
study as additives. The amounts of HDPE plastic bits and optimum moisture content. The soil samples were
Soil Type Specific Gravity. Gs Liquid Limit Plastic Limit Plasticity Index Gravel Sand Silt and Clay » o p t. (%) Pdm ax (kg/m3)
Silty sand 2.65 Non-plastic 0 89.2 10.8 8.50 2.030
Clayey sand 2.67 27 20 7 0 70.7 29.3 10.1 2,060
214 Environmental & Engineering Geoscience, Vol. XXV, No. 3, August 2019, pp. 213-221
Shredded High-Density Polyethylene (HDPE)
Table 2. Raw material properties o f the shredded HDPE plastic bits cent, the purpose being to examine the effect of HDPE
(Abdelsalam, 2015).
additive on the strength parameters C and 4>, where C
Test Name Results is the cohesion and 4> the angle of shearing resistance.
The tests were conducted according to ASTM D3080
Density @ 23°C 947.32 kg/m3 (ASTM, 2011). The specimens were remolded to the
Tensile strength at yield 23.85 MPa
Ultimate elongation at break 730.0% maximum dry density (2,030 kg/m 3 for silty sand and
Flexural modulus 879.97 MPa 2,060 kg/m 3 for clayey sand) and optimum water con
Melt Flow Index @ 190°C 5 kgf 0.389 g/10 min tent (8.5 percent and 10.1 percent for silty and clayey
Modulus of elasticity @ 25°C 810 MPa sand, respectively).
Modulus of elasticity @ 40°C 680 MPa The specimens were directly remolded into the di
Carbon black content 2.09%
Shore hardness D 63.80
rect shear box with a diameter of 63 mm and a height
Co-efficient of linear thermal expansion 0.180% of 20.6 mm in four layers. Each compacted layer was
Vicat softening point 128.5°C scratched by knife at the top to ensure the homogene
Oxidation induction time @ 200°C 50 min ity of the specimen. The specimens were assembled to
the direct shear test apparatus, and three different nor
mal stresses (31.5, 62, and 125 kPa) were applied under
a shearing rate of 0.35 mm/min. The ELE DS7 soft
mixed with the HDPE bits at a percentage of 0. 5, ware was attached with the apparatus to establish the
10, and 15 percent by soil weight. Each mixture per Mohr-Coulomb failure envelope. The shear strength
centage was repeated in triplicate to increase test result parameters were obtained from the failure envelope
accuracy. curve. The slope of the envelope curve is referred to
as the internal of angle friction, and the intersection of
PROGRAM OF LABORATORY TESTING curve and shear stress axis is considered to represent
cohesion.
The mixture samples were tested in this study to
determine the compaction, shear strength, and com
pressibility parameters. The direct shear test was con One-Dimensional Consolidation Test
ducted to measure the shear strength parameters of
mixtures, such as the internal angle of friction and The one-dimensional consolidation test was carried
cohesion. The one-dimensional consolidation test was out on samples with HDPE contents of 0, 5, 10, and
used to determine the compression and swelling in 15 percent. The samples were compacted to maximum
dices of mixtures. dry density and optimum moisture content. The com
pression index (Cc) and swelling index (Cs) were deter
Compaction Test mined form one-dimensional consolidation test using
an odometer apparatus. The tests were carried out ac
The compaction characteristics, such as maximum cording to ASTM D2435 (ASTM, 2011).
dry density (Pdm) and optimum moisture content (w) The specimens were remolded into the consolida
of the mixture specimens, were measured according to tion cell at maximum dry density (2,030 kg/m 3 for
ASTM D1557 (ASTM, 2012) on samples measuring silty sand and 2,060 kg/m 3 for clayey sand) and op
101.6 mm in diameter and 116.4 mm in height. The timum water content (8.5 percent and 10.1 percent for
mixture specimens were compacted into five equal lay silty and clayey sand, respectively). The dimension of
ers using a 2.5-kg hammer dropped from a 305-mm consolidation cell is 75 mm in dimeter and 18 mm in
height at a rate of 25 blows per layer. Each top com height. The specimens were compacted into four lay
pacted layer was scratched by knife to prevent the sep ers, ensuring the homogeneity of specimen layers by
aration of layers. Each mixture was repeated four times scratching the top of each compacted layer. The con
with a variation in moisture content to generate the solidation cell was assembled in the odometer appa
dry density against moisture content curve. The com ratus. Five vertical pressure increments were applied
paction properties for each mixture then were obtained (i.e., 25, 50, 100, 200, and 400 kPa) at the loading
from the plotted curve. stage. The unloading stage was perfumed after the end
of maximum load pressure was achieved. The square
Direct Shear Test root time method was considered in the analysis, fol
lowing ASTM D2435 clause 12.3.2 (Procedure). The
Direct shear tests were performed on samples com attached software ELE DS7 was used to calculate the
pacted to maximum density and optimum moisture compression and swelling indices from the odometer
content with HDPE contents of 0, 5, 10, and 15 per apparatus.
Environmental & Engineering Geoscience. Vol. XXV, No. 3, August 2019, pp. 213-221 215
Abdelsalam, Almashan, and Ismael
Atterberg Limits
Soil Passing No. 200 Sieve (%) Dfto Djo Djo Cu Co Liquid Limit Plastic Limit Plasticity Index Soil Classification
Silty sand 10.89 0.4 0.21 0.075 5.3 1.3 Non-plastic SP-SM
Clayey sand 26.27 28 19 9 SC
“The diameter corresponding to 60%, 30% and 10% finer in the particle-size distribution.
Falling Head Permeability Test silty sand and clayey sand are shown in Figures 2
and 3, respectively. As the percent of HDPE bit con
Falling head permeability tests were conducted on tent increased in the mixture, the maximum dry den
samples prepared at maximum dry density and opti sity decreased, with minimal effect on the optimum
mum moisture content. The samples were 100 mm in moisture content. With 15 percent HDPE additive, the
diameter and 130 mm in height. maximum dry density decreased from 2,020 kg/m 3 to
RESULTS 1,610 kg/m 3 and from 2,060 kg/m 3 to 1,590 kg/m 3
for the silty sand and clayey sand specimens, re
The silty sand and the clayey sand employed in the spectively. The measurements indicate a significantly
testing program were classified as poorly graded silty lighter weight material with the addition of HDPE
sand (SP-SM) and Clayey Sand (SC), respectively, plastic bits. This is to be expected, since the density
according to the USCS. Table 3 shows the calculation of the shredded HDPE bits is less than half the maxi
of the coefficient of uniformity, Cu, and coefficient mum dry density of silty sand and clayey sand. Table 4
of curvature, Cc, values, which were used for soil summarizes the compaction properties of HDPE bits
classification. The curve for the HDPE bits is also su mixed with silty and clayey sand.
perimposed on Figure 1, and the material is classified
as SP or poorly graded sand according to the USCS.
Note that both soils and HDPE bits have no gravel Direct Shear Test
size particles. Direct shear tests were performed on samples com
Compaction Test pacted to maximum density and optimum moisture
content with HDPE content of 0, 5, 10, and 15
The maximum dry density and optimum water con percent, the purpose being to examine the effect of
tent for the mixtures of shredded HDPE bits with HDPE additive on the strength parameters C and 4>.
2200
2050
CO
jE
ao
“ 1900
1/1
C
O)
9c . 1750
Q
i 1600
1450
0 5 10 15
H D P E (%)
Figure 2. Maximum dry density for the silty sand and clayey sand mixed with various percentages of shredded HDPE bits.
216 Environmental & Engineering Geoscience, Vol. XXV, No. 3, August 2019. pp. 213-221
Shredded High-Density Polyethylene (HDPE)
Figure 3. Optimum moisture content for the silty sand and clayey sand mixed with various percentages of shredded HDPE bits.
Figure 4 shows the peak shear stress of the silty sand One-Dimensional Consolidation Test
and clayey sand mixed with various percentages of
shredded HDPE bits under normal stress of 31.5, 63, Consolidation tests were carried out on samples
and 125.9 kPa. The peak stress of the silty sand and with HDPE content of 0, 5, 10, and 15 percent. The
clayey sand mixed with various percentages of shred samples were compacted to maximum dry density
ded HDPE bits increased with the HDPE bit con and optimum moisture content. The compression and
tent. This can be attributed to the HDPE bits lead swelling indices amended with various percentages of
ing to a reduction of sliding between particles and shredded HDPE bits are shown in Figures 7 and 8
an increase in angle of internal friction. Table 5 sum for the silty sand and the clayey sand, respectively.
marizes the shear strength and consolidation test re Table 5 summarizes the compression index and
sults for silty and clayey sand mixed with shredded swelling index results for silty and clayey sand mixed
HDPE bits. As shown, the shear strength parameters with shredded HDPE bits. The void ratio at different
C and cj) increased substantially with the addition of percentages of shredded HDPE shows a decrease at
HDPE bits up to 10 percent. However, with a further initial stress due to a decrease in suction. Moreover,
increase to 15 percent HDPE content, no increase in a similar trend can be observed for clayey sand in Fig
4* for the clayey sand was seen, but a slight decrease ure 8; this trend can be attributed to the fact that the
for the silty sand was measured. The corresponding capillary surface tension increased and did not allow
values of C further increased for the silty sand and the void ratio to change (Vanapalli et al., 1996). The
slightly decreased for the clayey sand. Figures 5 and swelling indices for silty sand and clayey sand mixed
6 show the failure envelopes for the silty sand and the with shredded HDPE bits are insignificant, given that
clayey sand soils with HDPE additives of 0, 5, 10. and the Kuwaiti soils are classified as unexpansive soils
15 percent. (Ismael et al.. 1996).
Shredded HDPE Max. Dry Density. Opt. Water Content. Max. Dry Density. Opt. Water Content.
Content (%) Pm d (kg/m 3) ..■(%) Pm d (kg/m 3) »r (%)
0 2.020 8.9 2,060 10.1
5 1.830 9.2 1,750 11.9
10 1.700 9.6 1,670 11.2
15 1.610 9.9 1.590 9.2
Environmental & Engineering Geoscience, Vol. XXV, No. 3, August 2019, pp. 213-221 217
Abdelsalam, Almashan, and Ismael
200
150
aj
100
l—
4—*
OO
<D
-C
CO
50
10 15
HDPE (%)
Figure 4. Peak shear stress with various normal stress for the silty sand and clayey sand mixed with various percentages of shredded HDPE
bits.
218 Environmental £ Engineering Geoscience. Vol. XXV, No. 3, August 2019, pp. 213-221
Shredded High-Density Polyethylene (HDPE)
coefficient of earth pressure, will be reduced, since both Figures 7 and 8. The Cc increased from 0.013 for the
y and K will be smaller because of the higher angle of silty sand to 0.031 when 15 percent HDPE additive
internal friction, cj>. was used. The swell index also increased from 0.005 to
Lightweight fill containing HDPE shredded bits 0.008. The corresponding increase of Cc for the clayey
may also be used in low-lying areas where soft or sand was from 0.026 to 0.036; and for Cs the increase
marginal soil conditions exist in order to raise the was from 0.006 to 0.008 (Table 5). However, since all
ground level prior to road construction or placement values are small, the increase in compressibility is in
of culverts and pipelines. The applied overburden pres significant for all practical applications.
sure will be smaller, resulting in lower elastic and con From examination of the results of the permeabil
solidation settlement than are associated with the cor ity tests in Table 6, note that the value of K increased
responding values if the local sandy soils are employed. more than three times where 5 percent HDPE addi
The compressibility was observed to be greater tive was used and more than tripled when 10 percent
when HDPE additive was employed, as shown from and 15 percent HDPE were used. The HDPE amended
Environmental & Engineering Geoscience, Vol. XXV, No. 3, August 2019, pp. 213-221 219
Abdelsalam, Almashan, and Ismael
Figure 7. Compression index for the silty sand and clayey sand amended with various percentages of shredded HDPE bits.
soil can be used in practice as a drainage layer in em 1. Using 15 percent (by weight) HDPE plastic bits as
bankment and highway construction and to provide a additive to two local soils resulted in lightweight
drainage layer for landfills. material with a maximum compacted density mea
suring 20 percent lower for the silty sand and 23 per
CONCLUSIONS cent lower for the clayey sand.
2. Direct shear tests revealed an increase in both shear
The geotechnical properties of two local soils in strength parameters C and cj>with increasing HDPE
Kuwait, namely, silty sand and clayey sand, amended content. The values of C and <(>for the silty sand in
with HDPE plastic bits were examined through a lab creased from 26 kPa and 37° to 45 kPa and 46°, re
oratory testing program. Based on test results, the fol spectively, as the HDPE content increased from 0 to
lowing conclusions were reached: 15 percent. For the clayey sand the corresponding
HDPE(%)
Figure 8. Swelling index for the silty sand and clayey sand amended with various percentages of shredded HDPE bits.
220 Environmental & Engineering Geoscience, Vol. XXV, No. 3, August 2019, pp. 213-221
Shredded High-Density Polyethylene (HDPE)
Table 6. Permeability fo r stabilized soils with shredded H D PE hits. ASTM D4318. 2010, Standard Test Methods fo r Liquid Limit. Plas
tic Limit, and Plasticity Index o f Soils: ASTM International,
Soil Type Shredded HDPE Bits (%) Permeability, k (cm/second) West Conshohocken. PA.
ASTM CDS, 2015. Standard Test M ethod fo r Relative Density
0 7.9 x i(r8
(Specific Gravity) and Absorption o f Fine Aggregate: ASTM
Silty sand 5 2.69 x I0^7 International, West Conshohocken, PA.
10 9.3 x I 0 '6 ASTM D2435-11.2011. Standard Test M ethod fo r One-Dimensional
15 3.5 x 10-5 Consolidation Properties o f Soils: ASTM International, West
Conshohocken, PA.
ASTM. D3080-11. 2011. Standard Test M ethod fo r Direct Shear
Test o f Soils Under Consolidated Drained Conditions: ASTM
values were 45 kPa and 34° and 56 kPa and 41.9°, International. West Conshohocken. PA.
ASTM. I) 1557-12e 1. 2012. Standard Test Methods fo r Labora
respectively. tory Compaction Characteristics o f Soil Using Modified Effort
3. The soil compressibility increased with HDPE con (56,000 ft-lb f/Jt3 (2,700 k N -m /m 3)): ASTM International.
tent. The Cc increased from 0.013 to 0.031 for the West Conshohocken. PA.
silty sand as HDPE increased from 0 to 15 percent. ASTM, D2487. 2017. Standard Practice fo r Classification o f Soils
The corresponding values for the clayey sand were fo r Engineering Purposes ( Unified Soil Classification System):
ASTM International. West Conshohocken, PA.
0.026 and 0.036. Bueno. B. D. S.: L ima. D. C.: T eixeira. S.: and M inette, E.. 1997,
4. The coefficient of permeability increased 3.4 times The mechanical response of reinforced soils using short ran
when 5 percent HDPE was used as an additive to domly distributed plastic strips. In M. S. Almeida (Editor). Re
the silty sand and increased significantly with fur cent Developments in Soil and Pavement Mechanics: Balkema,
ther increase in the HDPE content. Rotterdam, The Netherlands, pp. 401^407.
F auzi. A.: D jauhari. Z.; and F auzi. U. J.. 2016, Soil engineer
5. Several practical applications for the local sands ing properties improvement by utilization of cut waste plastic
with HDPE additives are recommended. These in and crushed waste glass as additive: International Journal En
clude use of the amended soil as lightweight fill gineering Technology, Vol. 8, No. 1, p. 15.
in embankment and highway construction and H ejazi. S. M.; Sheikhzadeh . M.: A htahi. S. M.: and Z adhoush .
as a drainage layer in landfill and embankment A., 2012. A simple review of soil reinforcement by using natu
ral and synthetic fibers: Construction Building Materials , Vol.
construction. 30. pp. 100-116.
M eera, S. and H ashifa. P.. 2015. Experimental investigation on
the effect of HDPE fibers on the subgrade strength of black
ACKNOWLEDGMENT cotton soil: International Journal Engineering Technology, Vol.
4. No. 10. pp. 360-367.
The authors would like to acknowledge Kuwait Uni N saif. A. L. M. H., 2013, Behavior o f soils strengthened by plastic
versity for use of the facilities of the Soils Labora waste materials: Journal Engineering Development. Vol. 17. No.
4. pp. 182-194.
tory of the Civil Engineering Department. The authors O rman. M. E.. 1994. Interface shear-strength properties of rough
are grateful to the Kuwait International Advanced In ened HDPE: Journal Geotechnical Engineering, Vol. 120. No.
dustries Company (KAI) for providing the shredded 4, pp. 758-761.
HDPE plastic bits employed in the testing program. P atidar , A. and M ahiyar. H., 2014. An experimental study on
stabilization of black cotton soil using HDPE wastage fibers,
stone dust & lime: International Journal Advanced Scientific
Technical Research, Vol. 6. No. 4. pp. 90-98.
REFERENCES Sobhan . K. and M ashnad. M.. 2002. Tensile strength and tough
ness of soil-cement-fly-ash composite reinforced with recycled
A bdelsalam. Z.. 2015. H D PE Double Wall Corrugated Pipes high-density polyethylene strips: Journal Materials Civil Engi
Tests Report: Kuwait. KW. Center of Engineering Laborato neering, Vol. 14. No. 2. pp. 177-184.
ries for Testing and Calibration. Kuwait University. CELTC Sobhan . K. and M ashnad. M.. 2003. Fatigue behavior of a pave
071215045, pp. 1. ment foundation with recycled aggregate and waste HDPE
ASTM D422-63.2007, Standard Test M ethod fo r Particle-Size Anal strips: Journal Geotechnical Geoenvironmental Engineering,
ysis o f Soils: ASTM International. West Conshohocken, PA. Vol. 129. No. 7. pp. 630-638.
Environm ental & Engineering Geoscience, Vol. XXV. No. 3, August 2019, pp. 213-221 221
Copyright of Environmental & Engineering Geoscience Journal is the property of Association
of Environmental & Engineering Geologists and its content may not be copied or emailed to
multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission.
However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use.