Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Reflections on
Responses to
COVID-19
REUTERS/KYUNG-HOON The Global Risks Report 2021 72
COVID-19 has revealed key lessons about authority, risk financing, information
how the global community responds to collection and sharing, and equipment
crisis. Despite some remarkable examples and vaccines.
of determination, cooperation and
innovation, most countries struggled with at Institutional authority
least some aspects of crisis management— Response to risks like a pandemic requires
and the world has not yet come together effective global cooperation, information
to mitigate the fallout. While it is too early to sharing and coordination. The H1N1 and
draw definitive lessons, this chapter distils Ebola outbreaks in the 2010s highlighted
some early observations across different the need to strengthen the World Health
response areas. Organization (WHO)’s competencies,2 yet
some areas of weakness have intensified.
If the lessons drawn from this crisis inform The WHO lacks independent investigative
decision-makers only how to better powers and also lacks the ability to sanction
prepare for the next pandemic—rather than non-compliant member states (by design
enhancing the processes, capabilities, and and charter); its authority has been further
culture for galvanizing effort around other challenged in recent years by nationalist
major concerns—the world will have fallen behaviours in many countries. Throughout
into the familiar risk management trap the crisis, the WHO’s advice at times
of planning for the last crisis rather than competed with that of several governments.
anticipating the next (see Box 6.1). This conflict reiterated the challenges
that, at times of urgency, the multilateral
system faces to function in a way that is
Global cooperation commensurate to the scale of global crises.
The Global Risks Report has frequently discussed the risk Risk financing
of pandemics to health and livelihoods. The 2020 edition The WHO’s annual budget—US$2.4
flagged how health systems across the world were generally billion6—is far outweighed by the economic
stretched; the 2018 and 2019 editions highlighted biological and development costs of the pandemic
threats and antimicrobial resistance; and the 2016 edition so far. In the early stages of the pandemic,
stressed that the Ebola crisis would “not be the last serious delivery of supplementary crisis funding
epidemic” and that “public health outbreaks are likely to proved to be a slow process. It took two
become ever more complex and challenging”. months to meet an initial funding goal
of US$675 million.7 International finance
The report has also explored aspects of managing risk and organizations were faster to mobilize to
building resilience to crises: the 2018 and 2019 editions, help low- and middle-income nations
for example, looked at the impacts of complexity and prepare healthcare services and support
cognitive bias on risk assessment and response. The households during lockdowns. However,
experience of COVID-19 so far offers an opportunity to here too greater preparedness is needed:8
update our understanding. although funding was available in March or
80
74.5
60
40 37.5
28.5 29.0
23.1
20
7.9
2.7 2.9
0.0
0
February March April May June July August September October
Source: Segal, S., Henderson, J. and Gerstel, D. 2020. CSIS Economics Program, data from a collection of international
finance institutions press releases. 24 November 2020, https://www.csis.org/analysis/international-financial-institutions-covid-
19-funding-rebounds-september-remains-below
FIGURE 6.2
Measures
Source: World Bank. “COVID-19 Trade Policy Database: Food and Medical Products.” Brief. https://www.worldbank.org/en/topic/trade/brief/coronavirus-covid-
19-trade-policy-database-food-and-medical-products
REUTERS/FLYNN
Viet Nam
0
Pakistan
Indonesia
S. Korea
Nigeria Ireland
Finland
Australia
Denmark US
-5
Switzerland Sweden
Japan Qatar Brazil
Germany Netherlands
New Zealand Chile
Canada
UAE
Singapore South Africa Colombia Belgium
Mexico
Greece
-10 France UK
India
Italy
Agentina
Spain
Peru
-15
0 5 10 15
Cumulative deaths/100k population
Source: Johns Hopkins University & Medicine. “Mortality Analyses.” Coronavirus Resource Center. https://coronavirus.jhu.edu/
data/mortality (accessed on 1 December 2020); International Monetary Fund. “Real GDP growth”. Oct. 2020. https://www.imf.
org/external/datamapper/NGDP_RPCH@WEO/OEMDC/ADVEC/WEOWORLD/SRB (accessed on 1 December 2020); World
Bank. “World Bank Country and Lending Groups”. 2020. https://datahelpdesk.worldbank.org/knowledgebase/articles/906519-
world-bank-country-and-lending-groups (accessed on 1 December 2020)
Note: EAP = East Asia and the Pacific; EO = Europe; LAC = Latin America and the Caribbean; MENA = Middle East and North
Africa; NA = North America; SA = South Asia; SSA = Sub-Saharan Africa.
41%:
sharp downturn in economic output,
endangering jobs and businesses.
Wealthier countries sought to define
and deliver relief packages (see
Chapter 1, Global Risks 2021) for the
most-affected groups and supported
adults in the US who delayed or employers in their efforts to retain
employees.36 However, the phasing
avoided medical care out of support will leave many
businesses with difficult employment
decisions (see Chapter 5, Imperfect
Markets). Rapidly rising unemployment
Many countries struggled with testing, in the second half of 2020 began to put
tracking and contact tracing,30 even additional pressure on other welfare
though these were seen as critical to system provisions and exacerbated
keeping outbreaks under control and mental health challenges. Developing
economies open.31 Such systems were economies with limited public finances
often slow to identify where infections often faced the difficult choice between
were spreading: from international travel, lockdowns with no or little financial
meat packing facilities, large social assistance for those who lost their
gatherings, or accommodation for livelihoods and keeping their economies
migrant construction workers.32 open at the risk of rapid spread of the
virus and overwhelmed health systems.
Lockdown management In many economies, informal markets
National lockdowns had some successes: also complicated the distribution of
for example, the shielding of vulnerable financial assistance.