Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 1 of 58
Ms. R. Lakshmi, SRC Convener
Mr. Divanshu Gupta
--
The Chairman welcomed all and specially the new members of the
Academic Senate. The Chairman also informed the Academic Senate
that three outside experts have been nominated. They are Professor
S. Bandyopadhayay, Director, ISI Kolkata, Professor Damodar
Acharya, Former Director, IIT Kharagpur and Professor Malashri
Lal, Former Professor and Head, English Department, University of
Delhi. Due to inadequacy of the time, these members could not
attend the meeting. However, we may welcome their nomination and
their presence in the next meeting.
Senate 18.29.02 Confirmation of the Draft Minutes of the 27th Meeting of the
Academic Senate held on December 12, 2017.
Draft Minutes of the 27th Meeting of the Academic Senate held on December
12, 2017 were circulated to all the members and requested the members to
convey the observations/comments, if any. No observations have been received.
Accordingly it is requested that the Minutes of the 27th Meeting of the
Academic Senate held on December 12, 2017 may be confirmed. Minutes
placed at Page No. 48-96 of the agenda.
Decision: Confirmed.
Senate 18.29.03 Action Taken report on the Draft Minutes of the 27th Meeting of the
Academic Senate held on December 12, 2017.
Action taken report on the Draft Minutes of the 27th Meeting of the Academic
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 2 of 58
Senate of IISER Mohali held on December 12, 2017 at 3.00 p.m. at IISER
Mohali, Sector- 81, Mohali.
Item No. Agenda Action taken
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 3 of 58
17.27.11 Students with CPI<4
Senate CNR Rao Foundation Prize Approved and prizes distributed during
17.27.13 for the Best Performance 1st Republic Day Celebrations in January
Year Student of the BS-MS 2018.
Programme 2017-18, 1st
Semester.
Approved.
A) Fellowship/Scholarship to
remain (already suspended
w.e.f. June 2017)
Approved.
B) Fellowship/Scholarship to
be suspended w.e.f. January
2018
Senate Fellowship/Scholarships to be Approved.
17.27.16 restored w.e.f. 1st January
2018
Noted.
1. a) Overall Performance of
the Int. Ph. D Students in the
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 4 of 58
Year 2017-18, 1st Semester
suspended (Scholarship
suspended w.e.f. June 01,
2017)
Noted.
f) Current Activities of
Int.Ph.D. Students who have
completed their
comprehensive examination.
Noted.
b) Warning Cases of PhD
students with CPI<7.0
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 5 of 58
students
f) Number of students who Noted.
have submitted thesis: 12
Decision:
Noted.
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 6 of 58
Senate 18.29.04 Confirmation of the Draft Minutes of the 28th Meeting of the
Academic Senate held on January 5, 2018.
Draft Minutes of the 28th Meeting of the Academic Senate held on January 05,
2018 were circulated to all the members and requested the members to convey
the observations/comments, if any. No observations have been received.
Accordingly it is requested that the Minutes of the 28th Meeting of the
Academic Senate held on January 05, 2018 may be confirmed. Minutes placed
at Page No. 104-111 of the agenda.
Decision: Confirmed.
Senate 18.29.05 Action Taken report on the Draft Minutes of the 28th Meeting of the
Academic Senate held on January 05, 2018.
Action taken report on the Draft Minutes of the 28th Meeting of the Academic
Senate of IISER Mohali held on January 5, 2018 at 3.00 p.m. at IISER Mohali,
Sector- 81, Mohali.
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 7 of 58
considerations.
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 8 of 58
Senate Request of a Student Mr. Decision noted for
18.28.5 Taranpreet Singh MS12044 compliance.
Decision: Noted.
For Reporting
Senate 18.29.06 Drop from the semester:
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 9 of 58
Approved.
Decision:
For Consideration and Approval
Senate 18.29.07 Candidates from IISER Mohali, applied for Direct admission into the
Ph.D. Programme:
CPI
PhD
Sr. (After
Name Reg. No. Major Category applied to
No. 10th
Deptt.
Sem)
Kriti Kamal
1 Gupta MS13022 Physics General 9.2 Physics
2 Akhil Bhardwaj MS13041 Physics General 8.3 Physics
3 Ujjawal Singhal MS13055 Physics General 8.2 Physics
4 Amala Raj MS13068 Chemistry General 9.2 Chemistry
5 Praveen Kumar V MS13071 Biology OBC 8.0 Biology
6 Megha MS13083 Biology General 8.5 Biology
7 Asish Moharana MS13094 Physics General 8.4 Physics
8 Pranav Kukreti MS13100 Physics General 8.2 Physics
9 Amruta Rajarajan MS13119 Biology General 8.2 Biology
10 Alkit Gugalia MS13143 Chemistry General 8.4 Chemistry
11 Shreyan Ganguly MS13149 Physics General 9.6 Chemistry
12 Swathi Jayaram Ms13150 Biology General 9.0 Biology
13 Sunil Kumar MS13012 Chemistry ST 7.0 EES
Mathemati Mathemati
14 Diksha Mukhija MS13103 cs General 8.5 cs
Decision: Admit, but only those who qualify national level test and meeting any
cut-offs imposed by respective departments will be entitled for
fellowship.
Senate 18.29.08 i) Students under the BS-MS dual degree program, fulfilling the
requirements for the award of the BS-Degree.
1. A student of the BS-MS programme may opt to leave the programme with
a BS degree providing that she/he fulfils the following requirements:
a. The student has completed at least five years in the programme.
b. The student has received a grade in all core courses.
c. The student has received a grade in a list of courses whose credits total
up to not less than 139.
d. The student has a weighted grade-point average of not less than 5.0 in
the courses listed above.
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 10 of 58
2. The grade sheet given to such a student will reflect all grades obtained by
the student except where such a grade has been replaced due to repetition of the
course or due to substitution of an elective course by a different elective course.
3. The format of the BS degree will be identical to the BS degree that is
awarded to graduating BS-MS students except that no Major will be
mentioned in the degree. The student will not be awarded an MS degree.
4. The student can exercise this option after the finalization of the grades of the
10th semester completed by the student. A student who chooses this exit option
will not be allowed to return to the BS-MS programme.
5. The Institute may decide to award BS degree if a student meets the
requirements at the end of 7 years.
S.No Name Reg. No.
1 Kausal Kumar MS13047
2 Rakesh Kumar Saini MS13106
The following 109 students have completed the requirements (as per Senate
decision14.15.08) of BS-MS dual degree programme:
a) 36 core courses.
d) 4 seminar courses.
The senate is requested to approve the award of the BS & MS degree to the
following students.
MS 2012 Batch:
S.No. Reg. No. Name Subject CPI
1 MS12060 Himanshu Yadav MATHEMATICS 6.2
2 MS12071 Mukesh Kumar PHYSICS 6.0
MS 2013 Batch:
S.No. Reg. No. Name Subject CPI
1 MS13002 Shahina PHYSICS 8.2
2 MS13003 Ankit Labh PHYSICS 6.7
3 MS13004 Vishavdeep PHYSICS 8.7
4 MS13006 Agrim Gupta PHYSICS 6.5
5 MS13007 Prakhar Gahlot BIOLOGY 7.9
6 MS13008 Reshma R BIOLOGY 9.2
7 MS13009 Km Pragya Verma CHEMISTRY 8.8
8 MS13010 Simran S Tinani MATHEMATICS 9.8
9 MS13011 Anuj Kumar PHYSICS 7
10 MS13012 Sunil Kumar CHEMISTRY 7
11 MS13014 Pragnya Das MATHEMATICS 6.9
12 MS13015 Virender Singh CHEMISTRY 7.4
13 MS13016 Anupama Pavithran BIOLOGY 7.4
14 MS13017 Aswin. G.S MATHEMATICS 8.5
15 MS13019 Saloni Rose BIOLOGY 9.9
16 MS13020 Parvathy S MATHEMATICS 9
17 MS13022 Kriti Kamal Gupta PHYSICS 9.2
18 MS13023 Gokul Jagannadh PHYSICS 7.6
19 MS13024 Km Bharti Singh PHYSICS 5.9
Shah Parth
20 MS13025 Dharmendrabhai CHEMISTRY 7.5
21 MS13026 Saurabh Hanuman Mhatre CHEMISTRY 8.1
22 MS13027 Guru Gaurav PHYSICS 6
23 MS13028 Arsha Sreekumar BIOLOGY 7.9
24 MS13032 Shubham Dilip Verma PHYSICS 8.5
25 MS13033 Sweetu Susan Sunny BIOLOGY 9
26 MS13034 Akshai J. Kurup BIOLOGY 8.6
27 MS13035 Karan Bhatt BIOLOGY 6.4
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 12 of 58
28 MS13038 Rahul Rana PHYSICS 7.1
29 MS13040 Teena V. John PHYSICS 8.1
30 MS13041 Akhil Bhardwaj PHYSICS 8.3
31 MS13043 Vaibhvi BIOLOGY 8
32 MS13045 Manish Yadav PHYSICS 8.1
33 MS13046 Ishita Katyal PHYSICS 7.1
34 MS13048 Meghanad Kayanattil CHEMISTRY 8.4
35 MS13049 Neelima P.R CHEMISTRY 8.3
36 MS13051 Sai Praveen Madireddi MATHEMATICS 8
37 MS13052 Amol Madhukar Amodkar MATHEMATICS 7.7
38 MS13053 Varsha Jayaswal BIOLOGY 6.9
39 MS13054 Jayesh Kumar S BIOLOGY 9.2
40 MS13055 Ujjawal Singhal PHYSICS 8.2
41 MS13056 Divita Gupta CHEMISTRY 9.4
42 MS13057 Kalik Kumar Vishisth CHEMISTRY 6.8
43 MS13059 Shailesh Kumar PHYSICS 7.0
44 MS13060 Keshav Nagpal PHYSICS 7.5
45 MS13061 Lisha Loitongbam CHEMISTRY 8.6
46 MS13062 Ashima MATHEMATICS 7.9
47 MS13064 Aatashi Dhiman BIOLOGY 6.8
48 MS13065 Lalit Yadav PHYSICS 8.4
49 MS13066 Sujeesh. P.T CHEMISTRY 7.9
50 MS13067 Jyoti Tanwar MATHEMATICS 5.4
51 MS13068 Amala Raj CHEMISTRY 9.2
52 MS13069 Neeraj Maan PHYSICS 6.4
53 MS13070 Harleen Kaur CHEMISTRY 6.9
54 MS13071 V Praveen Kumar BIOLOGY 8
55 MS13077 Ankit PHYSICS 7.1
56 MS13078 Rimpy Dhanda BIOLOGY 8
57 MS13080 Prabhsimrandeep Kaur BIOLOGY 6.9
58 MS13083 Megha BIOLOGY 8.5
59 MS13086 Taseng Mancheykhun PHYSICS 7.2
60 MS13087 Abhay Kasera MATHEMATICS 8.3
61 MS13089 Swathy Lekshmy. V.S CHEMISTRY 9
62 MS13090 Sonali Maurya PHYSICS 7.2
63 MS13091 Abhishek Verma CHEMISTRY 7.8
64 MS13092 Ankit Somani CHEMISTRY 8
65 MS13093 Nitya Singh CHEMISTRY 8.5
66 MS13094 Asish Moharana PHYSICS 8.4
67 MS13095 Shreya Khandal CHEMISTRY 7.7
68 MS13097 Somya Singh MATHEMATICS 8.3
69 MS13098 Silpa. M.P PHYSICS 5.9
70 MS13100 Pranav Kukreti PHYSICS 8.2
71 MS13101 Daimiota Takhellambam CHEMISTRY 6.7
72 MS13103 Diksha Mukhija MATHEMATICS 8.5
73 MS13104 Iswarya Sitiraju MATHEMATICS 8.1
74 MS13105 Aditya Kumar Singh MATHEMATICS 6.1
75 MS13107 Sandeep Badhan CHEMISTRY 8.7
76 MS13108 Harpreet Kaur BIOLOGY 8.3
77 MS13109 Aditya Mishra PHYSICS 8.4
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 13 of 58
78 MS13111 Sumanjit Datta BIOLOGY 9.6
79 MS13112 Geethu Venugopal CHEMISTRY 7.6
80 MS13113 Madhuvanthi G Athani PHYSICS 8.3
81 MS13114 Avinash Gupta PHYSICS 6.3
82 MS13115 Sukhraj Kaur PHYSICS 7.3
83 MS13116 Priyanka Bansal CHEMISTRY 9.2
84 MS13117 Suhani Gupta PHYSICS 7.6
85 MS13118 Rhythm Shukla BIOLOGY 7.5
86 MS13119 Amruta Rajarajan BIOLOGY 8.2
87 MS13120 Joyal Davis CHEMISTRY 6.9
88 MS13121 Dantuluri Sriharsha BIOLOGY 6.8
89 MS13123 Pratibha Songara BIOLOGY 8.1
Subhashree Shubhrasmita
90 MS13124 Sahu BIOLOGY 7.5
91 MS13127 Nayana Shibu Deepthi MATHEMATICS 8.2
92 MS13129 T. Harshavardhan BIOLOGY 8.2
93 MS13132 Vaishnavi S CHEMISTRY 9.3
94 MS13135 Vidhya . S PHYSICS 7.6
95 MS13137 Ankit Kumar Pandey PHYSICS 5.7
96 MS13139 Anjoom Thahir. A.V BIOLOGY 7.8
97 MS13140 Vinayak Aswal CHEMISTRY 6.1
98 MS13142 Sreelakshmi. C BIOLOGY 8.3
99 MS13143 Alkit Gugalia CHEMISTRY 8.4
100 MS13145 Shubham Pal BIOLOGY 6.7
101 MS13146 Kushalpal Kaur PHYSICS 5.9
102 MS13147 Om Prakash CHEMISTRY 7.5
103 MS13148 Haritha. A PHYSICS 7.9
104 MS13149 Shreyan Ganguly PHYSICS 9.6
105 MS13150 Swathi Jayaram BIOLOGY 9
106 MS13151 Anjaly S. Menon PHYSICS 9.3
107 MS13153 Rupendra Kumar PHYSICS 6.1
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 14 of 58
Registration: August 2015
Schizosaccharomyces pombe
i) Dr Satyajit Jena
ii) Dr. H.K. Jassal
iii) Dr. K. Lochan
Date of MS Thesis Submission (final version) : 20/04/18
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 15 of 58
Name of Supervisor: Dr. R. Vijaya Anand
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 16 of 58
MS Thesis Evaluation Committee:
Title of the MS Thesis: Novel role of the homeotic gene deformed (dfd) in
progenitor fate
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 17 of 58
Title of the Thesis: Sex, and Its tentacles: The impact of sexual conflict on
reproductive and life history trait evolution and reproductive isolation among
populations
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 18 of 58
iv) Dr. Kenneth Norman, Albany Medical Centre, USA (External)
Based on the recommendation of thesis examination committee viva-voce was
conducted on March 13, 2018
Viva-voce Committee:
i) Dr. Kavita Babu, IISER Mohali (Convener)
ii) Dr. Thomas Pucadyil, IISER Pune, Maharashtra (External Examiner)
iii) Dr. Samarjit Bhattacharyya
iv) Profeesor Anand K Bachhawat
The viva-voce committee has recommended that the PhD degree be awarded.
The viva-voce committee has recommended that the PhD degree be awarded.
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 19 of 58
4) Name of Student: Ms. Kanupriya Verma
Studies"
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 20 of 58
Date of Thesis Submission: August 8, 2017
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 21 of 58
Viva-voce Committee:
i) Dr. Goutam Sheet, IISER Mohali (Convener)
ii) Professor Arindam Ghosh , Indian Institute of Science (IISc), Bangalore
(External Examiner)
iii) Dr. Yogesh Singh
iv) Dr. Sanjeev Kumar
The viva-voce committee has recommended that the PhD degree be awarded.
7) Name of Student: Ms. Saryu Garg
Title of the Thesis: Source apportionment of black carbon and PM10 aerosol
using optical
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 22 of 58
Name of Supervisor: Prof. Sudesh Kaur Khanduja
The viva-voce committee has recommended that the PhD degree be awarded.
The viva-voce committee has recommended that the PhD degree be awarded.
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 24 of 58
Name of Supervisor: Dr. Kavita Dorai & Dr. N.G. Prasad
Viva-voce Committee:
i) Dr. Kavita Dorai (Convener)
ii) Dr. N.G. Prasad (Convener)
iii) Professor H S Atreya, IISc Bangalore (External)
iv) Professor Arvind
v) Dr. Manjari Jain
The viva-voce committee has recommended that the PhD degree be awarded.
Title of the Thesis: New Molecular Topologies from Main Group Elements:
P/N, B/N and Al/N Containing Macrocycles and Pyridinophanes
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 25 of 58
iv) Professor Ashoka Samuelson, Indian Institute of Science,
Bangalore(External)
Based on the recommendation of thesis examination committee viva-voce was
conducted on May 11, 2018
Viva-voce Committee:
i) Dr. Sanjay Singh (Convener)
ii) Professor Anil J. Elias, Indian Institute of Technology, Delhi (External)
iii) Dr. R. Vijaya Anand
iv) Dr. Debashis Adhikari
The viva-voce committee has recommended that the PhD degree be awarded.
The viva-voce committee has recommended that the PhD degree be awarded.
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 26 of 58
Registration: July 2011
The viva-voce committee has recommended that the PhD degree be awarded.
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 27 of 58
iv) Dr. Amitabha Bandyopadhyay, Indian Institute of Technology, Kanpur
(External)
Based on the recommendation of thesis examination committee viva-voce was
conducted on May 14, 2018
Viva-voce Committee:
i) Dr. Lolitika Mandal (Convener)
ii) Dr. Amitabha Bandyopadhyay, Indian Institute of Technology, Kanpur
(External)
iii) Dr. Sudip Mandal
iv) Dr. Shashi B. Pandit
The viva-voce committee has recommended that the PhD degree be awarded.
The President’s Gold Medal is awarded to the student having the highest
CPI vide Senate Agenda item No.12.11.12(c) of the graduating class.
• Ms. Saloni Rose, Registration No. MS13019, CPI 9.9
is recommended for President’s Gold Medal this year.
Decision: Approved.
Decision:
Approved.
vii) Certificate of Academic Excellence
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 28 of 58
Academic Excellence Prize in Mathematical Sciences
Reg. No. Name CPI
MS13010 Ms. Simran S Tinani 9.8
Decision:
Approved.
Senate 18.29.9 Performance of the BS-MS Students in 2017-18, 2nd Semester
MS17 Batch
≥ 9.0 26 ≥ 9.0 25
MS16 Batch
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 29 of 58
• Total number of students: 175
≥ 9.0 23 ≥ 9.0 30
MS15 Batch
BIOLOGY MAJORS
SPI Number of CPI Number of
students students
≥ 9.0 15 ≥ 9.0 06
≥ 8.0 and < 9.0 21 ≥ 8.0 and < 9.0 14
≥ 7.0 and < 8.0 12 ≥ 7.0 and < 8.0 18
≥ 6.0 and < 7.0 04 ≥ 6.0 and < 7.0 13
≥ 5.0 and < 6.0 06 ≥ 5.0 and < 6.0 07
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 30 of 58
≥ 4.0 and < 5.0 ≥ 4.0 and < 5.0
< 4.0 < 4.0
Incomplete (Grade I) Incomplete (Grade
I)
Total 58 Total 58
CHEMISTRY MAJORS
SPI Number of CPI Number of
students students
≥ 9.0 12 ≥ 9.0 04
≥ 8.0 and < 9.0 10 ≥ 8.0 and < 9.0 05
≥ 7.0 and < 8.0 05 ≥ 7.0 and < 8.0 14
≥ 6.0 and < 7.0 05 ≥ 6.0 and < 7.0 07
≥ 5.0 and < 6.0 01 ≥ 5.0 and < 6.0 03
≥ 4.0 and < 5.0 ≥ 4.0 and < 5.0
< 4.0 < 4.0
Incomplete (Grade I) Incomplete (Grade I)
Total 33 Total 33
MATHEMATICS MAJORS
SPI Number of CPI Number of
students students
≥ 9.0 02 ≥ 9.0 02
≥ 8.0 and < 9.0 02 ≥ 8.0 and < 9.0 05
≥ 7.0 and < 8.0 02 ≥ 7.0 and < 8.0 03
≥ 6.0 and < 7.0 03 ≥ 6.0 and < 7.0 04
≥ 5.0 and < 6.0 02 ≥ 5.0 and < 6.0 05
≥ 4.0 and < 5.0 02 ≥ 4.0 and < 5.0
< 4.0 06 < 4.0
Incomplete (Grade I) Incomplete (Grade I)
Total 19 Total 19
PHYSICS MAJORS
SPI Number of CPI Number of
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 31 of 58
students students
≥ 9.0 12 ≥ 9.0 09
≥ 8.0 and < 9.0 19 ≥ 8.0 and < 9.0 13
≥ 7.0 and < 8.0 11 ≥ 7.0 and < 8.0 17
≥ 6.0 and < 7.0 07 ≥ 6.0 and < 7.0 11
≥ 5.0 and < 6.0 02 ≥ 5.0 and < 6.0 02
≥ 4.0 and < 5.0 01 ≥ 4.0 and < 5.0 02
< 4.0 02 < 4.0 00
Incomplete (Grade I) Incomplete (Grade I)
Total 54 Total 54
Student who has not been allotted major
Sr No Name Reg. No. SPI CPI No. of ‘F’
grades in
core
courses
1 Preeti MS15048 3.8 4.5 04
2 Abhijit Sahoo MS15059 3.4 4.5 05
3 Ishan MS15072 04
Chagainu 5.8 5
4 Nitesh Bhatt MS15085 3.3 4.6 04
5 Farzana N MS15145 6.6 6.1 02*
BIOLOGY MAJORS
SPI Number of CPI Number of
students students
≥ 9.0 18 ≥ 9.0 02
≥ 8.0 and < 9.0 11 ≥ 8.0 and < 9.0 11
≥ 7.0 and < 8.0 07 ≥ 7.0 and < 8.0 14
≥ 6.0 and < 7.0 02 ≥ 6.0 and < 7.0 10
≥ 5.0 and < 6.0 02 ≥ 5.0 and < 6.0 05
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 32 of 58
≥ 4.0 and < 5.0 03 ≥ 4.0 and < 5.0 02
< 4.0 01 < 4.0
Incomplete (Grade I) Incomplete (Grade
I)
Total 44 Total 44
CHEMISTRY MAJORS
SPI Number of CPI Number of
students students
≥ 9.0 14 ≥ 9.0 06
≥ 8.0 and < 9.0 13 ≥ 8.0 and < 9.0 16
≥ 7.0 and < 8.0 11 ≥ 7.0 and < 8.0 15
≥ 6.0 and < 7.0 13 ≥ 6.0 and < 7.0 14
≥ 5.0 and < 6.0 08 ≥ 5.0 and < 6.0 10
≥ 4.0 and < 5.0 06 ≥ 4.0 and < 5.0 05
< 4.0 01 < 4.0
Incomplete (Grade I) Incomplete (Grade I)
Total 66 Total 66
MATHEMATICS MAJORS
SPI Number of CPI Number of
students students
≥ 9.0 03 ≥ 9.0 02
≥ 8.0 and < 9.0 02 ≥ 8.0 and < 9.0 02
≥ 7.0 and < 8.0 02 ≥ 7.0 and < 8.0 06
≥ 6.0 and < 7.0 04 ≥ 6.0 and < 7.0 03
≥ 5.0 and < 6.0 04 ≥ 5.0 and < 6.0 04
≥ 4.0 and < 5.0 02 ≥ 4.0 and < 5.0 04
< 4.0 05 < 4.0 01
Incomplete (Grade I) Incomplete (Grade I)
Total 22 Total 22
PHYSICS MAJORS
SPI Number of CPI Number of
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 33 of 58
students students
≥ 9.0 09 ≥ 9.0 05
≥ 8.0 and < 9.0 10 ≥ 8.0 and < 9.0 07
MS13 Batch
• Total number of students whose programme is not completed: 19
BIOLOGY MAJORS
S. No. Name Reg. No SPI CPI
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 34 of 58
CHEMISTRY MAJORS
S. No. Name Reg. No SPI CPI
MATHEMATICS MAJORS
S. No. Name Reg. No SPI CPI
CHEMISTRY MAJORS
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 35 of 58
S. No. Name Reg. No SPI CPI
MS 2016 Batch
Sr. No. Regn. No. Name CPI
1 MS16100 Siddharth 3.5
MS 2017 Batch
Sr. No. Regn. No. Name CPI
1 MS17189 Bobby 3.6
2 MS17111 Vaibhav Kumar 3.8
3 MS17103 Vishal Kataria 3.9
4 MS17130 Diksha Singh Gautam 3.9
5 MS17196 Ravi 3.9
Decision: Approved.
2015 Batch:
Sr No Name Reg. No. SPI CPI No. of ‘F’
grades in
core courses
1 Preeti MS15048 3.8 4.5 04
2 Abhijit Sahoo MS15059 3.4 4.5 05
3 Ishan Chagainu MS15072 5.8 5 04
4 Nitesh Bhatt MS15085 3.3 4.6 04
2014 Batch:
Sr No Name Reg. No. SPI CPI No. of ‘F’ grades
in core courses
1 Sukhpal MS14094 3.8 4.6 03
Decision: Approved.
ii) Termination cases (on account of CPI <4 in two semesters in a row)
MS 2014 Batch
Sr.
No. Regn. No. Name CPI
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 36 of 58
1 MS14008 Sutikshna Singhdeo 3.6
2 MS14018 Navjot Singh 3.8
MS 2016 Batch
Sr.
No. Regn. No. Name CPI
1 MS16108 Nitika Devi 3.4
2 MS16153 Sachin Bhatt 3.4
3 MS16147 Chetan 3.8
MS 2017 Batch
Sr.
No. Regn. No. Name CPI
1 MS17137 Shalika 2.6
2 MS17129 Ajinkya Sakhare 2.9
3 MS17024 Himanshu Patel 3
Virendra Kumar
4 MS17207 Meena 3.1
5 MS17041 Nishant 3.3
6 MS17016 Shuvajit Das 3.4
Aishwarya Kumar
7 MS17086 Priye 3.5
Shubham Kumar
8 MS17127 Sinha 3.9
Decision:
Approved.
Senate 18.29.12 CNR Rao Foundation Prize for the Best Performing 1 st year student of the
nd
BS-MS Programme in the 2017-18, 2 semester:
CNR Rao Foundation Prize:
S.N
o Reg No. Name SPI
1 MS17034 Achuthan Raja Venkatesh 10
2 MS17106 Abhimanyu Sharma 10
3 MS17108 Abhigyan Writwik Medhi 10
Approved.
Decision:
Senate 18.29.13 Certificate of Academic Excellence forndthe Best performing students(II, III
& IV year of BS-MS) in the 2017-18, 2 semester:
MS16
S.No Reg. No. Name SPI
1 MS16028 Dipannita Ghosh 10
2 MS16034 Shradha Sapru 10
3 MS16036 Rahul Ramesh 10
4 MS16060 Gautam Neelakantan M 10
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 37 of 58
5 MS16075 Satvik Singh 10
6 MS16082 Soumya Panyam 10
7 MS16184 Puneeth Deraje 10
MS15 Biology
S.No Reg. No. Name SPI
1 MS15043 Shreya D Kumar 10
2 MS15050 P Prathibha 10
3 MS15143 Sunandini Ramnarayanan 10
4 MS15170 Karthik T 10
5 MS15181 Tisya Banerjee 10
6 MS15204 Trirupa Tapas Chakraborty 10
MS15 Chemistry
S.No Reg. No. Name SPI
1 MS15017 Parmeet Kaur Dhindsa 10
2 MS15021 Anjana R Kammath 10
MS15 Mathematics
S.No Reg. No. Name SPI
1 MS15152 Kabeer Manali Rahul 9.6
MS15 Physics
S.No Reg. No. Name SPI
1 MS15042 Yash Rana 10
2 MS15125 Hayman Gosain 10
MS14 Biology
S.No Reg. No. Name SPI
1 MS14090 Ravi Kumar Yadav 10
2 MS14123 Manjushree Sarda 10
3 MS14148 Aswathy Joji 10
4 MS14155 Greeshma. P. Bose 10
5 MS14157 Archi Sharma 10
6 MS14173 Avneet Kaur 10
7 MS14181 J Ashwin Kumar 10
MS14 Chemistry
S.No Reg. No. Name SPI
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 38 of 58
1 MS14026 Virinder Bhagat 10
2 MS14053 Rishabh Gupta 10
3 MS14180 Lejish V P 10
MS14 Mathematics
S.No Reg. No. Name SPI
1 MS14030 Ramandeep Singh Arora 10
MS14 Physics
S.No Reg. No. Name SPI
1 MS14024 Shruti Jose Maliakal 10
Approved.
Decision:
nd
Senate 18.29.14 Fellowship Suspension of BS-MS students in the End of 2017-18, 2
semester:
A) Fellowship/Scholarship to remain suspended (Scholarship suspended
w.e.f. January 2018).
1. Muskaan, MS14072 (CPI=5.9)
2. Nitin Burman, MS14073 (CPI=5.4)
3. Sayan Biswas, MS14075 (CPI=4.9)
Decision: Approved.
B) Fellowship/Scholarships to be restored w.e.f. 1st June, 2018:
Decision: Approved.
C) Fellowship/Scholarship to be suspended w.e.f. 1st June 2018:
2014 Batch:
Sr. No. Reg. NO. Name CPI
1 MS14003 Harsh Pruthi 4.7
2 MS14008 Sutikshna Singhdeo 3.6
3 MS14009 Kakade Kunal Madhukar 5.5
4 MS14018 Navjot Singh 3.8
Shubham Dnyanobarao
5 MS14020 Bhojane 5.3
6 MS14031 Avinesh Kumar 5.6
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 39 of 58
7 MS14036 Parikshit Parihar 4.9
8 MS14037 Kapil Yadav 4.9
9 MS14040 Vasudev 5.8
10 MS14054 Apoorv Alawada 5.9
11 MS14055 Manish Kumar Yadav 4.8
12 MS14068 Vandana Verma 5.2
13 MS14079 Aman Dhiman 4.3
14 MS14080 Ankuj Kumar 4.2
15 MS14082 Pranshu Kalson 5.8
16 MS14087 Ravi Kumar 4.7
17 MS14091 Ajay Kumar 5.1
18 MS14092 Mohit Kumar 5
19 MS14094 Sukhpal 4.6
20 MS14095 Komal Meena 5.2
21 MS14096 Neeraj Meena 4.8
22 MS14105 Isabella Antony K J 5.7
23 MS14109 Dipali Singh 5.6
24 MS14112 Dharmendra Kumar 5.7
25 MS14119 Amrutha Ajikumar 4.1
26 MS14120 Naman Kumar Bharti 5.8
27 MS14126 Renu Meena 4.1
28 MS14139 Vaishali Singh 5.1
29 MS14140 Prabhat Singh Rana 5.7
30 MS14142 Ishant Sandil 5.6
31 MS14144 Vinita Kumari 5.9
32 MS14165 Goverdhan Gouri Laxmikant 5.2
33 MS14167 Sushmita Nahar 5.3
34 MS14179 Shakshi 4.8
35 MS14186 Tambe Indrajeet Manik 5.5
36 MS14187 Chavan Aniket Laxman 4.8
2015 Batch:
Sr. No. Reg. NO. Name CPI
1 MS15008 Abhishek Meena 5.7
2 MS15015 Somoshree Barik 5.2
3 MS15023 Jithin. R 5.9
4 MS15048 Preeti 4.5
5 MS15056 Athul R Ramesh 5.5
6 MS15059 Abhijit Sahoo 4.5
7 MS15066 Alan Babu 5.5
8 MS15072 Ishan Chagainu 5
9 MS15077 Vaibhav Kumar Singh 4.8
10 MS15081 Asif Mohammed L 5.7
11 MS15082 Himanshu 5.3
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 40 of 58
12 MS15085 Nitesh Bhatt 4.6
13 MS15106 Sahil Kaushal 5.8
14 MS15123 Vishwas Kamal 5
15 MS15141 Tamanna 5.8
16 MS15147 Krishna Kanth T.G 5.5
17 MS15148 Deepak Potyan Negi 5.3
18 MS15150 Sachin C S 5.6
19 MS15151 Satnaam Singh 4.6
20 MS15173 Rajesh Kumar Bajiya 5.9
21 MS15179 Harpreet Kaur 5.7
22 MS15198 Shivansh 5.2
23 MS15207 Mohit Baswal 4.7
2016 Batch:
Sr. No. Reg. No. Name CPI
1 MS16005 Aritram Dhar 5.6
2 MS16022 Harshath Amal 5.3
3 MS16025 Anubhav Kumar Srivastava 5.8
4 MS16033 Asrith Krishna. R 5.7
5 MS16042 Reena 5.4
6 MS16045 Kshitiz 3.5
7 MS16048 Utkarsh Pathak 5.5
8 MS16082 Soumya Panyam 4.6
9 MS16107 Liz Maria Luke 5.1
10 MS16110 Salman Faris. K 5.7
11 MS16116 Deepanshu Aggarwal 5.7
12 MS16119 Anuthariq A V 5.8
13 MS16120 Deepraj Verma 5.9
14 MS16126 Subhamoy Deb 5.6
15 MS16127 Rishi Gangadhar G 5
16 MS16128 Vishnu. P.V 4.9
17 MS16177 Ashirbad Mishra 4.4
18 MS16180 Jerin Saji 3.4
19 MS16185 Anshul Nagar 5.3
20 MS16188 Parvathi Valsalan 5.9
Approved.
Decision:
Senate18.29.15 Overall performance of the Integrated PhD and PhD students in the Year
2017-18, 2nd semester:
(i) Overall performance of the Int. Ph.D. students in the year 2017-18, 2nd
semester:
MP17 Batch:
• Total number of students: 14
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 41 of 58
• Subject wise details:
BIOLOGY
MP16 Batch:
• Total number of students: 20
BIOLOGY
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 42 of 58
2 MP16014 10 9.3
3 MP16015 8 7.6
4 MP16018 10 8.9
5 MP16019 8.7 8.8
6 MP16020 10 9.3
CHEMISTRY
Noted.
Decision:
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 43 of 58
(ii) Certificate of Academic Excellence for the Best Performing Students (I
and II year of Int. Ph.D.) in the 2017-18, 2nd semester:
MP17 Physics
MP17 Chemistry
MP17 Maths
1 MP16013 Sharanya P 10
2 MP16014 Anupa T Anil 10
3 MP16018 Prateek Chawla 10
4 MP16020 Shashi Prakash Yadav 10
MP16 Physics
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 44 of 58
MP17
Decision: Approved.
MP16 Mathematics:
Decision:
Approved.
(v) Int. Ph.D. students who have completed 88 credits with a CPI of >6.0
and eligible for comprehensive examination:
Int. PhD Students who have completed 88 credits with a CPI of ≥ 6.0 and
eligible for comprehensive examination
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 45 of 58
8. MP16009 Pratibha PHY 8.4
9. MP16007 Tanmoy Pandit PHY 8.4
10. MP16012 Kaushalendra Patel CHM 8.5
11. MP16019 Vibhu Mishra BIO 8.8
12. MP16004 Debjit Basu MTH 8.8
13. MP16018 Prateek Chawla BIO 8.9
14. MP16002 Soumyadeep Chakrabortty CHM 9
15. MP16014 Anupa T Anil BIO 9.3
16. MP16020 Shashi Prakash Yadav BIO 9.3
17. MP16005 Pankaj Seliya CHM 9.5
18. MP16013 Sharanya P BIO 9.7
19. MP16016 Vassu Doomra PHY 9.7
Decision: Noted.
(vi) Current activities of Int. Ph.D. students who have completed their
comprehensive examination:
Biological Sciences: 10
Chemical Sciences: 19
Physical Sciences: 11
Mathematical Sciences: 03
Decision: Noted.
(vii) Overall performance of the Ph.D students doing course work in the
year 2017-18:
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 46 of 58
• Total number of students whose comprehensive examination is pending: 03
• Total number of students whose comprehensive examination is not cleared after first attempt:
01
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 47 of 58
2. PH17067 9.3 9.3
PHYSICS
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 48 of 58
≥ 8.0 and < 9.0 16 ≥ 8.0 and < 9.0 17
≥ 7.0 and < 8.0 1 ≥ 7.0 and < 8.0 5
< 7.0 1 < 7.0 00
Incomplete (Grade 00 Incomplete (Grade 00
I) I)
Total 29 Total 29
CIAB
NABI
Noted.
(viii) Warning Cases of PhD students with CPI<7.0:
S.No Reg. No. Name Subject CPI
1. PH17085 Mohammad Umer Lone CHM 4.3
2. PH17088 Asis Kumar Khuntia BIO 4.3
3. PH17081 Nitish Chhetri PHY 5.7
Decision: Approved.
(ix) Termination cases of students with CPI<7.0 (already given warning
last time)
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 50 of 58
28. PH17029 Swati Singh BIO 9
29. PH17032 Aabeer Kumar Basu BIO 9
30. PH17059 Rajat Pandey CHM 9
31. PH17008 Sonam Sharma CHM 9.2
32. PH17011 Dipayan Mukherjee PHY 9.2
33. PH17037 Esha Haldar BIO 9.2
34. PH17041 Manu Adhikari CHM 9.3
35. PH17025 Anindya Chaudhuri BIO 9.5
36. PH17028 Mekhla Rudra BIO 9.7
37. PH17043 Suneel Kumar MTH 9.7
38. PH17048 Kavita Rani CHM 9.7
39. PH17030 Eshita Paul BIO 9.8
40. PH17063 Pardiwalla Yezad HSS 9.8
Keki Daisy
41. PH17031 Meghna Suhag BIO 10
42. PH17042 Niranjan MTH 10
43. PH17204 Shikha Sharma INST 8
44. PH17214 Khushboo Rani INST 8
Singh
45. PH17207 Rimple Kalia INST 8.3
46. PH17210 Avinash Chandra INST 8.3
Kushwaha
47. PH17201 Vianni Chopra INST 8.7
48. PH17202 Gaurav Kumar INST 8.7
49. PH17203 Aakriti Singh INST 8.7
50. PH17206 Manju Sharma INST 8.7
51. PH17208 Tanmay Goswami INST 9
52. PH17213 Mujeeb Alam INST 9
53. PH17205 Gurpreet Kaur INST 10
54. PH17212 Ankush INST 7.7
55. PH17301 Varun Kumar CIAB 8.3
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 51 of 58
56. PH17304 Priyanka Pal CIAB 7
57. PH17401 Vinita Sharma NABI 8
Noted.
Decision:
Biological Sciences: 87
Chemical Sciences: 65
Earth and Environmental Sciences:08
Humanities and Social Sciences: 14
Mathematical Sciences: 13
Physical Sciences: 66
Nano Science: 68
CIAB: 01
Decision: Noted.
Decision: Noted.
(3) Number of students subject-wise who are currently JRF:150:
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 52 of 58
Decision: Noted.
Decision: Noted.
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 53 of 58
Kumar Pal Ordering Transitions at the
Liquid Crystal-Aqueous
Interface
7. Pranay Deep PH15021 PHY Prof. Sudeshna Synchronization in
Rungta Sinha Networks of Bistable
Systems
8. Archana Sangwan PH12118 PHY Harvinder Kaur Observational constraints
Jassal on dark
energy parameters
9 Hema M. Swasthi PH12148 CHM Prof. Smarat Insights into the Formation
Mukhopadhyay of a Functional Amyloid
from Biofilm Forming
Intrinsically Disordered
Curli Subunits
Noted.
Decision:
Decision:
Noted.
(7) Following students have resigned from the PhD programme:
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 54 of 58
2. PH17068 Rahul Hooda
3. PH17215 Anjali Pant
4. PH16068 Palvinder Singh
5. PH17211 Pradyot Kumar Roy
6. PH16234 Ravi Pratap Singh Bhadoriya
7. PH16211 Ashish Kumar Mohapatra
8. PH17027 Nitish Tayal
9. PH17022 Ravi Umadi
10. PH17064 Mohamed Musthafa Iqbal
Decision:
Approved.
(xii) The students opted for Majors:
MS16 Batch:175
The breakup is as follows:-
Biology: 53
Chemistry:45
Mathematics: 23
Physics: 54
Decision: Noted.
Senate18.29.16 New Courses:
Decision:
Approved.
Senate18.29.17 Convocation 2018
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 55 of 58
Noted.
Senate18.29.18 Mid-Sem. Exams: One Mid-sem exam per semester in lieu of two:
Prof. Anand K Bachhawat, Professor & Head, Deptt. of Biology has requested
that there should be one midsem exam per semester in lieu of two midsem
exams. Copy of letter dated April 23, 2018 is placed at page no. 127.
Decision:
The Academic Senate deliberated on this issue. Since the proposal is
from one Department, other Departments also discussed the issue
and suggestions if any may be brought to the Academic Senate.
Prof. Anand K Bachhawat, Professor & Head, Deptt. of Biology has requested
for course restricting in Int. Ph.D Biology programme. Copy of letter dated
May 1, 2018 is placed at page no. 128-130.
It was decided that we may attach the Lab course number instead of
Decision:
Research Lab Project.
Prof. Anand K Bachhawat, Professor & Head, Deptt. of Biology has requested
for adding one new book, and modifying the content. Email placed at page no.
131-132 of the agenda.
Decision:
Academic Senate deliberated on the issue and decided that the final
version of the proposal be placed to the next Senate meeting.
Senate18.29.21 Bio 411 and Bio 629 (Bioinformatics courses: mandatory and elective):
Prof. Anand K Bachhawat, Professor & Head, Deptt. of Biology has requested
for changing contact hours from Lab 3+3 to Lab 2 + Theory 2 + Lab tutorial 1
(overall contact hours remains same). Placed at page no. 133.
Decision:
The proposal approved but to have the total number of hours it
should be = lab 3+ Theory 2 + Lab tutorial 1.
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 56 of 58
Senate18.29.22 Reports of Prevention of Academic Misdemeanor Committee
Decision: Approved.
Decision: Approved.
Proposal: Allow a student to drop a course one week prior to End Semester.
Proposed by : Kapil Paranjape
Justification:
From the point of view of the student, this avoids an ‘F’grade in their transcript.
From the point of view of the instructor, this avoids un-necessary agonising
over award of poor grades to students who have demonstrated lack of
interest/ability in the course.
The secondary purpose is merely punitive. To indicate that the approach of the
student to the course is wrong and will not lead to them meeting its
requirements.
In both cases, these two aspects are already clear to the student at the proposed
time(one week before End Semester). No one will argue that the instructor
receives vicarious pleasure in awarding an ‘F’grads as a punishment for poor
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 57 of 58
approach.
Decision: All the departments may come out after discussion in their respective
departments and can back again to the Senate..
Decision:
His candidature has been considered based on his representations.
The Academic Senate decided that he be advised to change his major
to continue in the programme for BS-MS. However, while
continuing if he opt for BS degree no change of major he has
required.
-Sd/-
Registrar/Secretary
Academic Senate, IISER Mohali
-Sd/-
Chairman
Academic Senate, IISER Mohali
Minutes for the 29th Meeting of the Academic Senate, 16.5.2018 at 3.00 P.M. Page 58 of 58