Professional Documents
Culture Documents
MAIN TOPICS
THE CONSTITUTION
FEDERALISM
3
THE
CONSTITUTION
4
AP AMERICAN GOVERNMENT STUDY GUIDE
CONSTITUTIONAL UNDERPINNINGS
THE CONSTITUTION
TYPES OF GOVERNMENT
TYPE DESCRIPTION
Power is vested in hereditary kings and queens who govern in the
MONARCHY interest of all.
Natural law is the law of God. Under natural law people were born
free and equal. Law is acknowledged through human sense and
JOHN LOCKE reason. He also argued for rights (Life, Liberty, Property) and
(1632--1704)
obligated people to rebel against kings that did not respect the right
of the governed. (Social Contract Theory)
JEAN--JACQUES The social contract: It is the agreement of free and equal people to
ROUSSEAU abandon certain natural rights in order to find freedom in a single
(1712--1778) body politic committed to the general good.
--The philosopher most likely to be on the AP test is John Locke. His words greatly influenced Thomas Jefferson as he wrote the
Declaration of Independence.
5
AP AMERICAN GOVERNMENT STUDY GUIDE
CONSTITUTIONAL UNDERPINNINGS
THE CONSTITUTION
ROOTS OF A NEW NATION
PHASE DESCRIPTION
● In the early 17th century, colonists came to the New World for
economic opportunity and to escape religious persecution.
ENGLISH ● Most colonists agreed the king ruled by divine right. The
monarch gave colonists much more freedom (such as
COLONIES self--government, religious practices, economic organization) than
FORM subjects at home (because they were across the ocean and there were
no things like planes, phones, or internet). Things were OK for almost
140 years.
6
AP AMERICAN GOVERNMENT STUDY GUIDE
CONSTITUTIONAL UNDERPINNINGS
THE CONSTITUTION
DECLARATION OF INDEPENDENCE
SECTIONS DESCRIPTIONS
God gives people the right to break away
FIRST PARAGRAPH from a government.
7
AP AMERICAN GOVERNMENT STUDY GUIDE
CONSTITUTIONAL UNDERPINNINGS
THE CONSTITUTION
THE ARTICLES OF CONFEDERATION: GOVERNMENT SET--UP
MAIN TOPIC DESCRIPTION
The nation was considered a “firm league of friendship”.
SOVEREIGNTY
Each state had ultimate authority within its territory.
8
AP AMERICAN GOVERNMENT STUDY GUIDE
CONSTITUTIONAL UNDERPINNINGS
THE CONSTITUTION
CONSTITUTIONAL CONVENTION: COMPROMISES
GENERAL TOPIC DESCRIPTION
All of the framers (55 delegates) are called the Founding Fathers.
FATHER OF THE But James Madison is referred to as the Father of the Constitution.
CONSTITUTION His buddy Thomas Jefferson, who was serving as ambassador in
France, sent him a lot of European books on government.
9
AP AMERICAN GOVERNMENT STUDY GUIDE
CONSTITUTIONAL UNDERPINNINGS
THE CONSTITUTION
CONSTITUTIONAL CONVENTION: COMPROMISES
ONE SIDE THE OTHER
THE PROBLEM THE COMPROMISE
WANTED WANTED
Virginia Plan: New Jersey Plan:
Powerful central Strengthening the THE GREAT COMPROMISE
government with 3 Articles, not (CONNECTICUT PLAN):
branches. replacing them. Bicameral Legislature:
(2 house legislature)
Two--house Creating a
legislature with one--house 1) House of
one house legislature with one Representatives had
elected directly vote for each state members based on
THE by the people, the and with population (also directly
REPRESENTATION other chosen representatives elected by the people).
OF THE STATES from persons chosen by state 2) The Senate would have
IN nominated by the legislatures. members equal for each
CONGRESS state legislatures. state.
Giving Congress the
A legislature with power to raise Dividing power between the
the power to revenue from duties nation and state
select the and imports and from governments, national
executive and postal service fees. power would be supreme.
judiciary.
Creating a Supreme 3 branches of government
Court with members
appointed for life
--They also agreed that Congress could stop the importation of slaves for 20 years after the Constitution was ratified. Also agreed to have an
extradition clause that addressed how states would handle runaway slaves. Also compromised on having a single president.
10
AP AMERICAN GOVERNMENT STUDY GUIDE
CONSTITUTIONAL UNDERPINNINGS
THE CONSTITUTION
BASIC PRINCIPLES OF THE CONSTITUTION
BASIC PRINCIPLE DESCRIPTION
Power is separated between 3 branches:
--Legislative Branch: creates laws
SEPARATION OF POWERS --Executive Branch: enforces (executes) laws
--Judicial Branch: interprets laws
Learn these now. There will be tons of questions on the AP test concerning checks and balances. Plus you have to know all this
information for our unit that covers Government Institutions.
11
AP AMERICAN GOVERNMENT STUDY GUIDE
CONSTITUTIONAL UNDERPINNINGS
THE CONSTITUTION
ARTICLES WITHIN THE CONSTITUTION
ARTICLE MAIN TOPIC IMPORTANT ITEMS
--Establishing justice
--Insuring domestic tranquility
PREAMBLE Purpose of Government --Providing for the common defense
--Promoting the general welfare
--Securing the blessings of liberty
--Enumerated powers
ARTICLE I The Legislative Branch -Necessary and Proper Clause
(implied powers)
--Presidential qualifications
ARTICLE II The Executive Branch
--Presidential roles (jobs)
--The AP test expects you to know in which Article you can find specific items.
12
AP AMERICAN GOVERNMENT STUDY GUIDE
CONSTITUTIONAL UNDERPINNINGS
THE CONSTITUTION
RIGHTS FOUND IN THE ORIGINAL CONSTITUTION
MAIN TOPIC DESCRIPTION
Habeas Corpus is when a person under arrest is brought
NO SUSPENDING
before a judge (chance to show unlawful detention). The Constitution
HABEAS CORPUS says it can only be suspended during wartime.
NO RELIGIOUS
There is no religious qualification in order to run for office.
QUALIFICATIONS
ENTITLEMENT OF
States cannot discriminate against people from other
PRIVILEGES & states.
IMMUNITIES
RIGHT TO JURY
For federal crimes, people have the right to a jury trial.
TRIAL
-People were upset that there was not originally a Bill of Rights, but the rights listed above were stated throughout the original
Constitution.
Passage by ¾ of state
It has been used 26 times.
legislatures.
RATIFY
Passage by ¾ of special
It has been used 1 time.
state conventions.
--Note that the amendment process reflects federalism (national government and state government both have power).
--The only amendment ratified by special state conventions was the 21st amendment which repealed Prohibition.
13
AP AMERICAN GOVERNMENT STUDY GUIDE
CONSTITUTIONAL UNDERPINNINGS
THE CONSTITUTION
RATIFICATION OF THE CONSTITUTION: WHEN IS IT IN EFFECT?
MAIN TOPIC DESCRIPTION
ACCORDING TO
Article VII stated that the Constitution would be the
THE
Supreme Law of the Land when 9 states ratified it at
CONSTITUTIONAL state conventions.
CONVENTION
-Nine states did ratify the Constitution but was it enough? New York and Virginia had yet to ratify and 40% of the nation’s
population lived there.
--Two groups or parties formed: The Federalists (Ratification supporters) debated the Anti--Federalists (Ratification opponents).
-Rhode Island ratified the Constitution one year after George Washington became the first president of the United States.
--The last states only ratified when the Federalists promised to add a Bill of Rights (Federalist Papers also influenced some).
14
AP AMERICAN GOVERNMENT STUDY GUIDE
CONSTITUTIONAL UNDERPINNINGS
THE CONSTITUTION
FEDERALISTS VERSUS ANTI--FEDERALISTS
OPINION ON THE
GROUP RATIFICATION OF KEY MEMBERS
THE CONSTITUTION
They supported it because --James Madison
FEDERALISTS they saw a need for a strong --Alexander Hamilton
central government. --John Jay
15
AP AMERICAN GOVERNMENT STUDY GUIDE
CONSTITUTIONAL UNDERPINNINGS
THE CONSTITUTION
BILL OF RIGHTS
AMENDMENT DESCRIPTION
--Freedom of Speech
--Freedom of Religion
AMENDMENT I --Freedom of Press
--Freedom to Assembly
--Freedom to Protest (or petition)
--Indictment
-Double jeopardy
AMENDMENT V --Protection against self-incrimination
-Due process (From national government)
16
FEDERALISM
17
FEDERALISM
SYSTEMS OF GOVERNMENT
SYSTEM DESCRIPTION EXAMPLES
--United Kingdom
Local and regional
--France
UNITARY governments derive authority
--Italy
from the national government.
--Japan
--Alternative definitions of federalism: The division between a central government and regional governments. Basically central and national
are the exact same things. Also regional and state governments are the exact same things.
--Federal almost always means the division of national and state. But in society (and occasionally on the AP test) Federal Government is
often a term for the national government. Be careful about that.
Most scholars agree that the 10th Amendment has not been that far reaching. The Supremacy Clause has had more of an impact in
terms of national & state tensions. But the AP test wants you to know both.
18
AP AMERICAN GOVERNMENT STUDY GUIDE
CONSTITUTIONAL UNDERPINNINGS
FEDERALISM
FEDERALISM IN THE UNITED STATES
TYPE OF
POWER HOLDER EXAMPLE OF POWERS
POWERS
--Coin money
NATIONAL --Regulate interstate & foreign trade
NATIONAL --Raise & maintain armed forces
(ENUMERATED)
GOVERNMENT --Declare war
POWERS --Govern US territories & admit states
--Conduct foreign relations
19
AP AMERICAN GOVERNMENT STUDY GUIDE
CONSTITUTIONAL UNDERPINNINGS
FEDERALISM
CONSTITUTIONAL INTERPRETATIONS
WOULD
BELIEF ON
LATER
HOW
FORM
GROUP CONSTITUTION LEADERS
WHICH
SHOULD BE
POLITICAL
INTERPRETED
PARTY
LOOSE
Federalists Loose or broadly Hamilton & Adams
CONSTITUTIONALISTS
STRICT Democratic Jefferson & later
Literally or strictly
CONSTITUTIONALISTS Republicans Madison
--George Washington who would warn against political factions as he exited his presidency usually agreed with the Federalists.
STATE POWERS
Article I, Section 10 Treaties and impairing contracts
DENIED
SUPREMACY
Article VI Supremacy of the national government
CLAUSE
People have more rights than listed in the
MORE LIBERTY 9th Amendment
Constitution
20
AP AMERICAN GOVERNMENT STUDY GUIDE
CONSTITUTIONAL UNDERPINNINGS
FEDERALISM
GOVERNMENT ACTION ON FEDERALISM: BEGINNING--RECONSTRUCTION
HISTORICAL
TYPE OF
FIGURE ITEM DESCRIPTION
FEDERALISM
INVOLVED
Jefferson thought the Alien and Sedition
Thomas Acts violated liberty. The Kentucky and
Kentucky &
Jefferson Virginia Resolutions declared the states’
Virginia right to nullification (declare null and void)
against John
Resolutions any federal law if a state thought the law
Adams
violated the Constitution. (This has never
been found to be constitutional)
Supreme Court ruled that Congress could
FEDERALISM create a national bank because the
(WHAT DOES IT McCulloch v.
Necessary and Proper Clause gives
LOOK LIKE?) Maryland (1819) them implied powers so they can carry
out expressed powers.
Justice
John Marshall Congress and New York were both
licensing ships to use on the Hudson
Gibbons v.
River. The Supreme Court ruled that
Ogden (1824) Congress had the power to regulate
commerce and commercial activity.
DUAL Justice
Even after the Civil War
FEDERALISM: Roger B. Taney Amendments (13--15) gave more
Plessy v.
Belief it is best to rights to African Americans, the
Ferguson (1896) Supreme Court ruled
have separate
“separate but equal” was constitutional.
and equally (and up to the states to deal with)
powerful national
and state After Supreme Court struck down the
governments Republican 16th Amendment Income Tax Act of 1894, Congress
(AKA: Layer Cake (anti--slavery) (1913) proposed the 16th Amendment
Federalism) allowing income taxes.
Congress
resisted against Took power away from state legislatures
17th Amendment
state powers by now having citizens from each state
(1913) vote for their senators.
21
AP AMERICAN GOVERNMENT STUDY GUIDE
CONSTITUTIONAL UNDERPINNINGS
FEDERALISM
GOVERNMENT ACTION ON FEDERALISM: NEW DEAL--GEORGE W. BUSH
HISTORICAL
TYPE OF
FIGURE ITEM DESCRIPTION
FEDERALISM
INVOLVED
Grants--in--aid programs to often defined
federal/state relationships and made the
national government a major player in
Franklin D.
COOPERATIVE New Deal domestic policy. Categorical Grant:
FEDERALISM Roosevelt (FDR) Congress appropriates funds for specific
Intertwined purposes (often states must match some
of the money).
relationship
among national, Southern states were blamed for
state, and local perpetuating discrimination. So national
governments funds were held unless states would act
Lyndon B. Great Society &
(AKA: Marble Cake like the national government wanted. The
Federalism)
Johnson (LBJ) War on Poverty spending in 1960’s on urban renewal,
education, and poverty programs had not
been seen since the New Deal.
22
AP AMERICAN GOVERNMENT STUDY GUIDE
CONSTITUTIONAL UNDERPINNINGS
FEDERALISM
CIVIL WAR
National government gains power. DUAL FEDERALISM
AMENDMENTS
POST
State governments gain power. DUAL FEDERALISM
RECONSTRUCTION
COOPERATIVE
NEW DEAL National government gains power.
FEDERALISM
COOPERATIVE
CIVIL RIGHTS National government gains power.
FEDERALISM
--The Constitution also says that any disputes between two states will go directly to the Supreme Court (original jurisdiction).
--The Constitution gives states complete power when creating local governments within the state's’ borders.
23
AP AMERICAN GOVERNMENT STUDY GUIDE
CONSTITUTIONAL UNDERPINNINGS
FEDERALISM
STATE GOVERNMENTS
ITEM DESCRIPTION
The state constitutions were written before the Constitutional
STATE CONSTITUTIONS
Convention in 1787. State constitutions are easier to amend.
-They are the elected chief executive. Like a President of the state…
budget powers, signing legislation, and appointing officials.
--LINE ITEM VETO: Veto a portion of a spending bill (Signs rest)
--CLEMENCY POWERS FOR BREAKING STATE LAW:
GOVERNORS Pardon: Forgive someone entirely for a crime.
Commute: Reducing the length of a prison sentence
Reprieve: Postpone a prison sentence.
Parole: Release a prisoner before sentence is complete with
conditions that must be met as part of the release.
ELECTIONS & Nonpartisan elections: State/local officials often downplay all party
POLITICAL PARTIES ties. Diverse candidates have had more success in recent years.
State constitutions grant certain types of powers for each state. So not all states have the same forms of local governments and direct
democracies. Only 23 States have direct democracy elements. Only 18 states have recall elections. You really have to look it up per state.
24
AP AMERICAN GOVERNMENT STUDY GUIDE
CONSTITUTIONAL UNDERPINNINGS
FEDERALISM
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
ITEM DESCRIPTION
A court ruling that stated local governments do not have any inherent
DILLON’S RULE
sovereignty. Thus, states can create, regulate, and destroy local governments.
There are 87,000 local governments in the United States that fall within four
main categories:
--Counties: (also called parishes and boroughs) They have very broad
responsibilities, created by the State for welfare & environmental programs,
courts, registration of land, births, and deaths.
Town meeting: Form of local government in which all eligible voters are invited
to attend a meeting at which budgets and ordinances are proposed and voted on.
--Mayor: An elected chief executive of a city.
--City council: The legislature in a city government.
--Manager: A professional executive hired by a city council or county board to
manage daily operations and then recommend policy changes.
--District--based election: Election in which candidates run for an office that
EXECUTIVES &
represents only the voters of a specific district within the jurisdiction.
LEGISLATURES
--At--large election: Election in which candidates for office must compete
throughout the jurisdiction as a whole.
--Commission: Form of local government in which several officials are elected
to top positions that have both legislative and executive responsibilities.
--Public corporation (authority): Government organization established to
provide a particular service or run a particular facility that is independent of
other city or state agencies and is to be operated like a business.
25
AP AMERICAN GOVERNMENT STUDY GUIDE
CONSTITUTIONAL UNDERPINNINGS
FEDERALISM
STATE BUDGET
SEGMENT OF
DESCRIPTION
BUDGET
SALES TAX Regressive: Tax not based on earnings.
OTHER N/A
LOCAL BUDGET
SEGMENT OF
DESCRIPTION
BUDGET
OTHER N/A
26
AP AMERICAN GOVERNMENT STUDY GUIDE
CONSTITUTIONAL UNDERPINNINGS
FEDERALISM
GRANTS--IN--AID PROGRAMS
ITEM DESCRIPTION EFFECT ON FEDERALISM
--Grants-in--aid programs: Refer to money that the national government gives to the states in the forms of grants.
--Conditions of aid: Terms set by the national government that states must meet if they are to receive certain federal funds.
--States prefer block grants because it gives them more freedom.
27
US Government AP Exam FRQ’s
Unit 1: Constitutional Underpinnings of U. S. Government
(2005 Q 2) The power of the federal government relative to the power of the states has increased since the
ratification of the Constitution.
1. Describe two of the following provisions of the Constitution and explain how each has been used
over time to expand federal power.
a. The power to tax and spend
b. The “necessary and proper” or “elastic” clause
c. The commerce clause
2. Explain how one of the following has increased the power of the federal government relative to the
power of state governments.
a. Americans with Disabilities Act
b. Civil Rights Act of 1964
c. Clean Air Act
http://apcentral.collegeboard.com/apc/members/repository/_ap05_sg_gopo_us_46636.pdf
http://apcentral.collegeboard.com/apc/public/repository/ap_usgovandpol_apcent_47328.pdf
http://apcentral.collegeboard.com/apc/members/repository/_ap05_comm_gopo_us_47180.pdf
http://apcentral.collegeboard.com/apc/public/repository/_ap_qa05_gopo_us_47367.pdf
(2007 Q 4) The framers of the United States Constitution created a federal system.
1. Define federalism.
2. Select two of the following and explain how each has been used to increase the power of the
federal government relative to the states.
• Categorical grants
• Federal mandates
• Selective incorporation
3. Select two of the following and explain how each has been used to increase the power of the
states relative to the federal government.
• Welfare Reform Act of 1996
• Block grants
• Tenth Amendment
http://apcentral.collegeboard.com/apc/public/repository/_ap07_us_go_po_sgs_final.pdf
http://apcentral.collegeboard.com/apc/public/repository/ap07_usgopo_q4.pdf
http://apcentral.collegeboard.com/apc/public/repository/ap07_us_govpol_qa.pdf
(2014 Q 1) 1. The United States Constitution’s ratification resulted from a political process that required
compromise between the Federalists and Anti-Federalists. Many of the debates in government today continue to
reflect the concerns of each perspective.
(a) Compare the positions of Federalists and Anti-Federalists regarding the power of the national
government.
(b) Describe two features of the original Constitution that have led to a growth in the power of the
national government.
(c) Explain how each of the following additions to the Constitution addressed Anti-Federalist concerns.
First Amendment
Tenth Amendment
(d) Explain how one of the following clauses of the Fourteenth Amendment has altered the balance of
power between the state and national governments.
Due process clause
Equal protection clause
http://media.collegeboard.com/digitalServices/pdf/ap/ap14_united_states_government_and_politics_%20scoring_guidelines.pdf
http://media.collegeboard.com/digitalServices/pdf/ap/apcentral/ap14_us_govt_and_politics_q1.pdf
http://media.collegeboard.com/digitalServices/pdf/ap/apcentral/ap14-us-gov-pol-qa.pdf
(2015 Q 2) The framers of the Constitution devised a federal system of government that affected the relationship
between the national and state governments.
(a) Compare state sovereignty under the Articles of Confederation and under the Constitution.
(b) Explain how each of the following has been used to expand the power of the federal government over the
states.
• Commerce clause
• Mandates
(c) Explain how each of the following has played a role in the devolution of power from the national government to
the states.
• Block grants
• Supreme Court decisions
https://secure-media.collegeboard.org/digitalServices/pdf/ap/ap15_united_states_government_and_politics_sg.pdf
https://secure-media.collegeboard.org/digitalServices/pdf/ap/apcentral/ap15_us_go_po_q2.pdf
https://secure-media.collegeboard.org/digitalServices/pdf/ap/ap15-us-gopo-student-performance-qa.pdf
CHAPTER 1
Throughout the chapter, readers are directed to consider the purpose of the established
democratic government. The diversity of the government, how it works, and the complexity of the
ideas and experiences that have evolved since its establishment contribute to an increasingly
challenged government and its policies. What form of government then exists in the United States
and in other nations of the world? The chapter focuses on discussion of pure democracy and
limited, or representative, democracy. Another key question is, What kind and how much power is
held by the public and by government in the United States and in other nations of the world?
Finally, the question of who rules is considered, and the chapter “sets up” answers to all of these
questions by pointing to the need to seek further information provided in the rest of the book.
CHAPTER THEMES
· The meaning of politics and political science
· Politics is “who gets what, when, and how”
· Government compared to social organizations
· Purposes of government
· Uses of law by government for the public
· Meanings of democracy
· Democracy in other nations
· Direct democracy versus representative democracy
· Paradox of democracy: majority rule or individual freedoms
· Sources of power to rule: elitism versus pluralism
· Conflict between the ideal of democracy and the reality of government
1
Copyright © 2009 Pearson Education, Inc. Publishing as Longman
CHAPTER OUTLINE
CHAPTER THEMES
· The American political culture is based on sets of widely shared values.
· One of the major shared values is the right of individuals to express their different beliefs,
attitudes, and values.
· Equality is a fundamental American shared value, but the concept of equality is a source of conflict.
· Equality of opportunity and equality of birthright are not the same.
· Diversity of economic and political cultures prompts dissent.
· Inequity of income distribution is a major source of conflict.
· The distribution of income leads to challenges of government to resolve concerns of income
inequality.
· There are many different approaches toward resolving this inequality, including different
political and economic beliefs about the role of government in the management of inequality.
· American’s religious versus secular beliefs are commonly aligned with the intensity of their
religious commitments but often clash with their belief in separation of religion from politics.
· Liberalism and conservatism represent two widely diverse approaches toward management of
issues of inequality.
· Dissent, structured into the American political system, has created a diversity of political and
economic ideologies.
· Immigration, race, and ethnicity are important factors in America.
1
Copyright © 2009 Pearson Education, Inc. Publishing as Longman
CHAPTER OUTLINE
I. Political Culture
A. The term political culture refers to widely shared ideas of who should govern, for what ends,
and by what means.
1. Values are culturally shared ideas about what is good and desirable.
2. Values provide standards of what is right and wrong.
3. Beliefs are shared ideas about what is true.
B. In political culture, values and beliefs are often related.
1. Beliefs can justify values.
2. Shared beliefs and values are the basis of the American political culture.
3. Variations in values and beliefs exist within a society as subcultures.
C. In the American political culture, there are many contradictions between values and conditions.
1. The words “all men are created equal,” and the practice of slavery and segregation
exemplify the “American dilemma.”
2. Despite contradictions, professed values still have worth.
3. Eliminating gaps between values and conditions can become motivation for change.
D. The civil rights movement can be seen as the effort to resolve contradictions derived from
the gap between values and conditions.
E. The idea of political culture does not mean an absence of conflict.
1. Much of politics revolves around conflict over fundamental values.
2. Ultimately, Americans share common ways of thinking about politics.
In the more than 200 years since the Constitution’s adoption, there have been many changes
to the meaning of federalism, with power shifting between states and national government. In the
twentieth century, the shifts of power became largely associated with the national government’s
ability to provide increased funding sources. With funding more available, the national
government has expanded its impact on all areas of states’ governments. This increased power has
had many advocates and many detractors, each with justifications for strong support.
CHAPTER THEMES
· There are a variety of alternatives to federalism.
· The constitutional design of federalism allowed for the resolution of problems that existed in
the design of the confederation.
· Development of the American federal system of government has prompted the initiation of a
diversity of government programs.
· Federalism has both advocates and detractors.
· There have been many forms of federalism in the 200 years since it was instituted.
· Federalism may have been “revised” by recent Supreme Court decisions.
1
Copyright © 2009 Pearson Education, Inc. Publishing as Longman
CHAPTER OUTLINE
4
Copyright © 2009 Pearson Education, Inc. Publishing as Longman
2. Congress widened the definition of interstate commerce.
a. Interstate transportation, particularly railroads, was to be regulated by Congress.
b. Communications, expanded with development of both the telephone and telegraph,
were to be regulated by Congress.
3. Interstate business expanded with increased industrialization.
a. The Sherman Antitrust Act of 1890 was designed to prevent monopolies and encourage
competition.
b. The 1930s saw expanded interstate commerce decisions establishing the principle that
production and distribution of goods and services for a national market fell under
interstate commerce interests.
K. In 1954, with Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka, the Court began the call for full
assertion of national authority on behalf of civil rights.
1. Despite the Court’s decisions, southern states avoided compliance with the Court’s decisions.
a. In 1957, Arkansas tried to prevent integration of high schools, but President
Eisenhower sent in the National Guard.
b. In 1962, Kennedy forced integration using a military response when Mississippi tried to
prevent integration at the University of Mississippi.
L. Voting Rights Act (1965) and Bush v. Gore (2000): Federal Oversight of Elections
V. Federalism Revived? (In recent years, the U.S. Supreme Court has become more respectful of
the states’ powers.)
A. U.S. v. Lopez (1995): The Court found that the Federal Gun Free School Zones Act was
unconstitutional because it exceeded Congress’s powers under the Interstate Commerce
Clause.
B. Seminole Tribe v. Florida (1996): The Eleventh Amendment shields states from lawsuits by private
parties that seek to force states to comply with federal laws enacted under the commerce power.
C. Alden v. Maine (1999): States were also shielded in their own courts from lawsuits in which
private parties seek to enforce federal mandates.
D. Printz v. U.S. (1997): Provision of the Brady law was invalidated. The law’s mandate that local
police conduct background checks on gun purchases violated “the very principle of separate State
sovereignty.”
5
Copyright © 2009 Pearson Education, Inc. Publishing as Longman
VIII. Coercive Federalism: Preemptions and Mandates
A. Increasingly, Congress has undertaken direct regulation of areas traditionally reserved to
states, thereby restricting states’ authority.
1. Federal preemptions vary, but may be total or partial.
2. Mandates by the federal government are direct orders to states to perform certain
activities or services, such as:
a. Age Discrimination Act (1986)
b. Asbestos Hazard Emergency Act (1986)
c. The Safe Drinking Water Act (1986)
d. Clean Air Act (1990)
e. Americans with Disabilities Act (1990)
f. National Voter Registration Act (1993)
g. No Child Left Behind (2001)
h. Homeland Security Act (2002)
i. Help America Vote Act (2003)
j. Real ID Act (2005)
B. Unfunded mandates are those activities ordered by federal law, but without
supportive funding.