Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2018 9
Yessi Travolta
University of Bengkulu,
travoltayessi@gmail.com
Mulyadi
University of Bengkulu,
ladunimulyadi@gmail.com
Imranuddin
University of Bengkulu,
imranulama@gmail.com
ABSTRACT
The objectives of this research were to investigate whether there were any significant
differences between introvert and extrovert students on their listening score and to find
out which of the students who have better in English listening scores. This research was a
descriptive comparative research. The samples of this research were 66 students
consisting of 33 introvert students and 33 extrovert students at the fourth semester
students of English education study program in Bengkulu University. The instruments of
this research were personality questionnaire by Laney (2002) was used to determine the
introvert and extrovert personality, and TOEIC Listening simulation was used to find out
the students’ listening scores. The researcher used SPSS Independent Group t-test with
significant level 0.05. The result of the analysis indicated that Sig. P (2-tailed) was 0.003 >
0.05. Furthermore, the computation showed that the mean score of introvert was
364.39, and the mean score of extrovert was 322.12. Therefore, the mean score of
introvert group was higher than extrovert group. It could be concluded that the results of
the research were: (1) There was significant difference between introvert and extrovert
students on their English listening scores, (2) The introvert students have better in English
listening score than the extrovert students.
Keywords: Descriptive comparative research, personality, introvert and extrovert,
listening.
treatment and training from the lecturers. and those who used the song technique. The
Now on, however, in listening III at the students who have extrovert personality are
fourth semester, there was still a significant better than the students who have introvert
different among the students’ scores in personality in English listening skill.
classroom. Truthfully, they both have been From the previous studies, this study
studying English for two years and through wanted to conduct the research at English
listening major in the class for twice. study program at University level without
As students of English language study considerate the gender and age of students.
program, they must have good listening This study would focus only on listening skill
ability in order to compete the global at fourth semester because several
challenge and as the different from other considerations. By considering that fourth
study programs. Therefore, they should semester have learned and trained deeper
measure their listening ability level. To find listening class at second and third semester
out the level in English foreign language, the so that they have ability and same level in
students can take a standardized test. There listening skill. The other was college students
are several kinds of standardized tests such have capability to determine their
as TOEIC, TOEFL, and EILTS. The researcher personality. Furthermore, this research
has asked the students about the would adopt the difference introvert-
standardized tests. Truthfully, they have not extrovert questionnaire from previous study,
been already taken one of the standardized and used TOEIC listening simulation test as
tests yet. They ought to take TOEIC test as second instrument. The reason behind
least. Then, this study preferred to choose choosing TOEIC as the instrument, it was
TOEIC listening test to measure the students’ because the sample has already learnt about
scores rather than TOEFL or EILTS. It was the kinds of questions in TOEIC test.
because the level of TOEIC test is lower and Based on explanation above, this
appropriate for the sample. research presented the research questions
Furthermore, this study has several as below:
previous studies which were relevant to the 1) Are there any significant differences
present research. Andriyani (2016) found between introvert and extrovert
that students with introvert personality have students in their listening scores
better in the reading comprehension than based on Laney’s theory (2002)?
extrovert students. In contrast result by 2) Which students of introvert and
Mall-Amiri & Nakhaie (2013) with the title extrovert are better in English
Comparing the Performance of Extrovert listening scores?
and Introvert Intermediate Female EFL
Learners on Listening and Reading Tasks. The METHOD
result indicated that introverts perform The design of this research was a
significantly better in listening tasks than descriptive comparative research.
extroverts. Another one came from Descriptive comparative research is a
Muharrami (2013) compared the introvert research that compares one or more
and extrovert students in listening variables on two or more difference
achievement. It proved that introvert measurements, or on difference time
personality has better achievement in (Sugiyono, 2016, p. 36). In this research, the
listening ability. But, contrary to researcher compared the significant
Ratminingsih (2012) indicated that there was difference between introvert and extrovert
no significant difference between the group groups of the fourth semester students in
of students who used the game technique English education study program of
Journal of English Education and Teaching (JEET) Vol.2.No.2.2018 12
Bengkulu University and their achievement used to analyze the data. From the result of
in TOEIC listening scores. There were two analysis, the researcher found that all items
variables that have been organized in this of TOEIC listening scores was valid proved by
research: the dependent and independent the score of items’ validity was more than
variables. 0.3. Then, the Cronbach Alpa was 0.959
The population of the research was meant the TOEIC had high reliability to be
including all fourth semester students in used. Therefore, there were 100 questions
English Study Program of Bengkulu as the second instrument.
University in class year of 2015/2016. It The data were analyzed using SPSS 21
consisted of two classes: A and B class with to find out whether the hypothesis was
76 students. After the numbers of introvert rejected or accepted. Independent t-test
and extrovert students were known from two-tailed with the level of significance =
the result of the questionnaire, the 0.05 was used. The proposed hypothesis
researcher got 66 students as the sample. was:
The researcher used total sampling H0 = There is no significant difference
technique because all of the populations between introvert and extrovert students
were taken as samples. with their scores of listening.
In collecting the data, this research has H1 = There is significant difference
two kinds of instruments; Personality between introvert and extrovert students
Questionnaire from Laney (2002) and TOEIC with their scores of listening.
listening simulation test. Laney personality The criteria were:
questionnaire (LPQ) was used to find out the H1 is accepted : (H1 : sig. p < 0.05)
students’ personality. Laney personality H0 is accepted : (H0 : sig. p > 0.05)
questionnaire (LPQ) was originally consisted Before testing the hypothesis of this
of 30 items. To check the validity and research, the researcher would like find out
reliability of the Laney Personality the normality and homogeneous data.
Questionnaire (LPQ), the researcher used According to Arikunto (2010), to analyze the
three experts and tried out. The three data using interval ratio, the data should be
experts were one Psychology lecturer and normal and homogeneous. Therefore, the
two English lecturers. Laney personality normality and homogeneity of the data were
questionnaire was tried out to 31 students tested firstly.
at the sixth semester who have the same
characteristics with the sample of the RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
research. The result of try out was analyzed a. Laney Personality Questionnaire
through the Stastical Package for Social The personality questionnaire was
Science (SPSS 21). The result showed that done to classify the sample into two groups:
LPQ had high validity proved by 33 item’s introvert and extrovert group. Laney
validity was more than 0.355 and high Personality Questionnaire (LPQ) was
reliability in which the value of Cronbach answered by 76 students by choosing four
Alpa was 0.844. possible answers: Never, Sometimes, Often,
The second instrument was TOEIC and Always. From the result of the average
listening simulation. TOEIC Listening percentage between introvert and extrovert
simulation was used to find out the items, out of 76 students who followed
students’ scores. Furthermore, to find out Laney Personality Questionnaire, 40
the validity and reliability of TOEIC listening students were from class A and 36 students
simulation, the researcher tried out to 10 were from class B. Class A, there were 21
students of fourth semester. SPSS 21 was introvert students and 19 extrovert
Journal of English Education and Teaching (JEET) Vol.2.No.2.2018 13
After finding the normality of the data, (2-tailed) < a (0.003 < 0.05). To answer the
this research analyzed the homogeneity test first research question of this present
using ANOVA ONE WAY in SPSS 21, the research, based on the results, it could be
result is below: concluded that the H1 is accepted since Sig.
Table 4. The result of homogeneity data P < 0.05, so that there is significant
Levene df1 df2 Sig. different between introvert and extrovert
Statistic group in English listening score.
.098 1 64 .755 Furthermore, to answer the second
question which one of the two groups has
From the table 4 above, this research
better in English listening scores. The
found that Sig. P was 0.755. As criteria of
difference could be seen from the mean
hypotheses is if Sig. P > 0.05 so that H1 is
scores both of groups as table below:
accepted, the data is homogeneous. From
Table 6. The mean scores of Introvert and
the result in table above, Sig. P was 0.755 >
Extrovert groups
0.05 so that H1 was accepted, both of
Group N Mean
introvert and extrovert group were
Introvert 33 364.39
homogeneous. Score
d. Hypothesis Test Extrovert 33 322.12
The hypothesis testing using SPPS 21 From the mean score table 6 above,
which has been established, the the researcher found the mean score of
independent t-test with two-tailed can be introvert group was 364.39, while the mean
continued. With the 5% significance criteria score of extrovert group was 322.12. It
are as follows: meant that the mean score of introvert
Sip. P > 0.05 = H0 is accepted; H1 is group was 364.39, it was higher than
rejected, there is no significant difference extrovert group was 322.12. It could be
between introvert and extrovert group in concluded that the introvert group has
English listening score. better achievement than extrovert group in
Sip. P < 0.05 = H0 is rejected; H1 is English listening scores.
accepted, there is significant difference
between introvert and extrovert group in DISCUSSION
English listening score. This research discussed some
Table 5. The result of Independent t-test interesting findings dealing with the
t-test for equality of mean students’ personality questionnaire, the
Sig. (2- students’ English listening scores
t df represented by TOEIC listening results, and
tailed)
the comparative between introvert and
Equal 3.407 64 0.003
extrovert group in English listening scores as
variances
the main result of this research.
assumed
From the result of the Questionnaire,
Equal 3.407 63.671 0.003
this research found that the totals of
variances
introvert students that exist at the fourth
not
semester are more than total of extrovert
assumed
students. It meant that students with the
The result of computation showed that introvert personality are mostly dominant
the Sig. (2-tailed) was 0.003. It meant that than students with extrovert personality at
students’ score of introvert and extrovert the fourth semester students in English
group was significantly difference since Sig. Study Program of University Bengkulu.
Journal of English Education and Teaching (JEET) Vol.2.No.2.2018 15
Wijaya (2016) stated that personality level 100 questions. It is one of reasons why
mostly dominated by introvert personality in extrovert students in the fourth semester of
the college life in Indonesia. For more the English Education Study Program are not
specific, Salihah (2016) found out that better than introvert students in listening
personality that existed at the seventh scores.
semester of English Education Study The other one is the way they express
Program in Universitas Bengkulu was highly their feeling or emotion. Introverts prefer to
Introvert. From the same finding of the work alone than in a group, they do not like
previous studies, it can be said that all of the being in the center of attention (Burrus and
introvert and extrovert personality traits Kaenzig, 1999). They feel uncomfortable to
grow more influenced by age. interact with a lot of people in order that
The main result is about the they love spend time by themselves like
comparison between introvert and extrovert reading a book, listening a music or writing a
group in English listening scores. The story. They enjoy doing something by
researcher used IBM SPSS 21 in analyzing themselves. On the other hand, extrovert
the data. Then, independent t-test with students work best in classrooms that allow
significant level 0.05 was used to compare time for discussion, talking or working with a
the TOEIC listening scores on introvert and group (Lestari, 2013). They like involving in a
extrovert students at fourth semester of crowd, group or activities outside
English Education Study Program in themselves. Therefore, asking them to stay
Bengkulu University. It revealed that there and hear the TOEIC listening make them get
was significant difference between introvert pressure and like living under a thick of
and extrovert group in English listening cloud. Thus, the introvert students at the
scores. From the mean score of TOEIC fourth semester of English Education Study
listening simulation test, it proved that Program have higher scores than the
introvert students have better scores in extrovert students.
English listening test than extrovert ones. The findings in this present research
This research assumed that it happened are in line with the several previous studies.
because of several reasons that exist in The first was conducted by Mall-Amiri &
introvert and extrovert personality. Nakhaie (2013) which indicated that there
The first reason comes from the was significant difference between introvert
different characteristics between them. and extrovert students with listening tasks,
Introvert students would rather listen than but there was no significant difference with
talk, and tend to be more concentrated and reading tasks. He found that the introvert
detailed in doing something. While the students were better than extrovert
extrovert students do not like to stay too students in listening skill at Soodeh
long in doing something because they are Language School and Kish Institute. The
impatient and quick to feel bored (Laney, second came from Muharrami (2013) who
2002). Extrovert prefers direct action found that there was significant difference
involving the physical and energetic. between introvert and extrovert group in
Therefore, it does not suit with the learning listening achievement at the first grade of
listening skill that requires high SMA Kartika Metro. Introvert group has
concentration and patience, as well as high higher score in listening tasks than extrovert
accuracy in capturing and interpreting the group. Furthermore, the result of this
information obtained. When answering present study is also similar to Alavinia
TOEIC listening questions, the students need (2012) which indicated that there was a
to focus and stay for long time in hearing the significant relationship between listening
Journal of English Education and Teaching (JEET) Vol.2.No.2.2018 16
ability with the students’ personality: teaching lessons. Meanwhile, this present
extroversion vs. introversion. It showed that research conducted at the fourth semester
the more introvert the subjects, the better students of English Education Study Program
their performance on listening. in Bengkulu University.
Then, the next, previous studies were in Because the samples of the seventh
different skills of the present research. previous study were elementary students
Qomaruddin (2010) studied about who did not have background of English
correlation between extraversion listening skill, so that they might get
personality and English writing skill. The difficulties in catching the information. As
result showed that there was a positive Alavinia (2002) said that older students and
correlation between extrovert and introvert higher grade students get more probability
students with their writing skill. It meant the in obtaining higher scores. After all, it might
more introverted someone, the higher be predictable that older students may enjoy
writing scores that they had. Then, Andriyani more powerful abstract thinking which may
(2016) showed that there was a significant lead to more cogent reasoning while
difference between introvert and extrovert listening. On the other hand, the older
students. She proved that the introvert students have turned the maturational
students got better results in reading process so that the personality has formed
comprehension test than the students with strongly. Since the personality occurs
extrovert personality. because of maturational processes (Wan,
Furthermore, Lestari (2013) who 2011).
found a moderate correlation between the Throwing back to the same findings
extrovert-introvert personalities dimensions with the five previous studies, in could be
with the students’ speaking performance. concluded that the special characteristics of
The extrovert students have better introverts: like high concentration, good
performance in speaking skill. However, the attention to detail, their eagerness to listen
other one is contradictory to the result of rather than to speak make them easier to
this present study. It comes from obtain the information. Then, they have
Ratminingsih (2012) who indicated that learnt and familiarized with the kind of
there was no significant difference in the questions in the TOEIC listening test were
listening skill between the students who administered could help them to achieve
learn using the game technique and the song better scores than extroverts in doing
technique. The students who have extrovert listening test. The difference of English
personality got better than introvert listening scores outcomes in the two groups
personality. The difference findings between is due to the difference characteristics in
this present research and the fifth previous each group. Extrovert students with all of
study can be caused by several aspects. the characteristics led them into the outside
The first aspect is the instruments of world, and the other side is introvert
the research. Ratminingsih used games and students who lead them into inside of
songs as listening test, while this present themselves have impacts on the listening
research used TOEIC listening simulation to learning process. Based on the same and
measure the students’ listening scores. The difference findings from previous studies,
other aspect is the difference samples from the researcher concluded that introvert
this present study. She conducted at SD Lab students have better performance in
UNDIKSHA Singaraja in the first semester in listening, reading, and writing skills, while
the 2009/2010 academic year for six months extrovert students have better in speaking
with the total number of 12 effective skill.
Journal of English Education and Teaching (JEET) Vol.2.No.2.2018 17
This present research was related to significant difference between introvert and
some limitations. Since this research focus extrovert group in English listening scores.
on the students’ listening scores, focusing a Furthermore, the result of the mean
study in other sub-skills could be have score both of introvert and extrovert group
different result. The researcher conducted showed that the introvert students got
the personality questionnaire from Laney higher mean score than the extrovert
(2002) to determine the introvert and students. Thus, the researcher draws a
extrovert personality, and TOEIC listening conclusion that the introvert students have
simulation to find out the students’ listening better performance in English listening
scores. Therefore, this research has scores than the extrovert students at the
recommendations for further researches. fourth semester students of the English
Further researches may look for other skills Education Study Program in Bengkulu
or sub-skills in conducting the next research. University.
The researcher also recommends conducting
further research is not only in English SUGGESTIONS
department, but also in difference Related to the result of this research, it
department. is suggested that the English lecturers should
After finding that the introvert and give more attention to the extrovert
extrovert personality was one of factors students in teaching listening. Lecturers can
which can influence the students’ scores in create playful activities that involve physical
English listening skill, the lecturer and and action in teaching English listening skill.
teacher should consider them in teaching It is because the extrovert students work
and learning process. The lecturer must best when they can speak up. Therefore,
realize that every student is unique. They lecturers should speak more when teaching
have their own ways in learning English listening skill. Speaking and listening is
which gives strengthens and weaknesses integrated skills, they cannot be separated.
during the process. The educators should Thus, in teaching listening lecturers should
not expect students to have the same result combine speaking and listening in order to
on different language skills. It is because all make introvert and extrovert students get
the external and internal conditions are not better in acquiring listening achievement.
the same. To get more precise assessment of Furthermore, for the students, they
the students’ results, the students’ should know their personality so that they
psychological aspects should be taken into can establish the appropriate techniques or
serious consideration in English teaching and strategies in learning English listening. The
learning process. students should understand themselves,
especially in what skill they are good at, and
CONCLUSIONS what skill they lack. Then, they should more
Referring to the discussion of the concern and also spend more time to master
research in the previous part, the result English skill that they are lack off. Thus, they
showed that there is any significant can improve themselves to achieve success
difference between introvert and extrovert in mastering all the English skills.
students personality in English listening This research found that introvert
scores by using TOEIC listening simulation students got better result on listening score
test. The difference is significant enough than extrovert students. For further
which can be seen from Sig. (2-tailed) was research, the researcher suggests to analyze
higher than 0.05, it means that there is why introvert and extrovert personality can
influence speaking skill. It is because
Journal of English Education and Teaching (JEET) Vol.2.No.2.2018 18