Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
Increasing the share of renewables in the energy mix at the expense of non-renewable sources, which account for a major
part of base load power generation units, adversely affects the stability of power systems. In order to maintain stability, there
is a need to develop electric energy storage. One solution is to store surplus energy in the form of hydrogen. At present
hydrogen is mainly obtained in the processes of using non-renewable fuels. However, it may also be obtained through an
electrolysis process, powered by electricity produced from renewable energy sources. This article presents the principle of
operation of various types of electrolyzers and presents selected characteristics for alkaline electrolyzers.
M
ke = (3)
n·F
The above relationships based on Faraday’s laws show
that the mass of hydrogen produced by electrolysis of wa-
ter is directly proportional to the current passing through the
electrolyte and the duration of the electrochemical reaction.
The number of ions involved in the reaction is n = 2.
Hydrogen is produced by water electrolysis due to the re-
action occurring at the cathode and anode of the electrolyz-
ers. Electricity is used in this case to break the water into
two basic elements—hydrogen and oxygen [6, 7]. The ox-
idation process occurs at the anode and the reduction pro-
cess at the cathode. Electrolyzer is constructed from a stack
of connected cells responsible for the water electrolysis pro-
Figure 1: Schematic an of alkaline water electrolyzer
cess. One electrolyzer does not necessarily have to consist
of only one stack of cells. Electricity and heat must be sup-
plied to maintain the electrolysis process. At low temperature
the heat for the reaction is generated by the flow of current In this type of device water with electrolyte is located on
through the electrolyzer. both sides of the electrodes. Cathode and anode are sepa-
The reactions at the anodes and cathodes differ accoring rated by a thin polymeric membrane. This membrane is pen-
to types of of electrolyzers, of which there are several [8]. etrated by OH- ions, which result from the reaction occurring
The most popular are alkaline water electrolyzers or elec- at the cathode. Hydrogen is obtained from the cathode, and
trolyzers with a polymeric membrane (PEM water electrolyz- water with a small amount of oxygen from the anode. Elec-
ers). trolyzers of this type are characterized by long durability and
lifetime.
2.1. Alkaline water electrolyzers
This is the most common technology used in water elec- 2.2. PEM water electrolyzers
trolysis. The efficiency of electrolysis in such devices can
Proton exchange membrane (PEM) electrolyzers produce
reach 82% [9, 10]. Alkaline electrolyzers are character-
hydrogen of very high purity and require very pure water with
ized by high efficiency and affordable price. The purity of
low conductivity of about 1 µS/cm [9]. Water is supplied
hydrogen obtained by electrolysis using this type of equip-
only on the anode side, where it is separated into hydrogen
ment is very high, ranging from 99.7% to 99.9%. In this
and oxygen ions. The membrane allows only hydrogen ions,
process, water should be provided with a conductivity of
which are then reduced at the cathode. Oxygen with mois-
less than 5 µS/cm [9]. The reaction occurring at the
ture are obtained from the anode whereas from the cathode
cathode (HER—Hydrogen Evolution Reaction) and anode
hydrogen is obtained with a small amount of moisture that
(OER—Oxygen Evolution Reaction) are shown by equations
might penetrate through the membrane. In this type of elec-
(4) and (5) while the overall reaction is shown in equation
trolyzer there is a very thin polymeric membrane separating
(6) [9, 10].
the cathode and anode. The chemical reactions for these
Cathode (-)
devices are shown by equations: (7) for the anode (8) for the
cathode and (9), representing the total reaction [9–11].
2H2 O + 2e− → H2 + 2OH − (4)
Anode (+)
Anode (+)
1
H2 O → 2H + + 2e− + O2 (7)
1 2
2OH − → O2 + H2 O + 2e− (5)
2 Cathode (-)
1
H2 O → H2 + O2 (6) 2H + + 2e− → H2 (8)
2
A typical electrolyzer of this type consists of two electrodes
immersed in the electrolyte and separated by a membrane. 1
H2 O → H2 + O2 (9)
The role of the solution is to maximize ionic conductivity. It 2
contains mostly KOH. The operating temperature of the pro- The oxidation process at the anode produces free hydro-
cess ranges from 40◦ C to 90◦ C [10]. A solution of NaCl or gen ions and oxygen, while at the cathode hydrogen ions
NaOH can also be used as the electrolyte, but they are less are reduced. A disadvantage of these devices is progressive
common. A schematic diagram of the device is shown in consumption of the membranes during work. Fig. 2 shows
Fig. 1. a schematic diagram of the PEM water electrolyzer.
— 150 —
Journal of Power Technologies 96 (3) (2016) 149–156
— 151 —
Journal of Power Technologies 96 (3) (2016) 149–156
— 152 —
Journal of Power Technologies 96 (3) (2016) 149–156
main control unit opens the outlet valve at the end of the individual electrolyzers. Nominal power of this power sup-
hydrogen generator. The entire start-up process of the hy- ply is 1500 W and nominal voltage is 48 V. The efficiency
drogen generator from cold state takes about 5–6 minutes. of the tested AC/DC converter was determined as the ratio
A Coriolis flow meter was installed in the hydrogen gen- of output DC power (PE1.2 ) to input AC power (P(AC)1.2 ) and
erator’s measuring system to measure the flow of hydrogen calculated by equation (10).
produced. Table 2 gives a summary of the operating modes
of the generator (values are given for the nominal operating ηAC/DC =
PE1.2
(10)
point of the device). P(AC)1.2
where: ηAC/DC —AC/DC converter efficiency;
PE1.2 —output DC power, W; P(AC)1.2 —input (AC) power,
5. Reaserch results W.
Fig. 7 shows the efficiency of the tested AC/DC converter
5.1. Analysis of supply electrolyzers system according to the output power measured for stabilized volt-
The electrolyzers subject to analysis are powered by the age value of 30 V, calculated by equation (10).
AC mains through an AC/DC converter. In view of need
to use the converter in the power supply module, there is The efficiency of the tested power supply ranged from
some loss of electricity. The energy conversion efficiency about 80% for small values of the load (about 10% of rated
in these devices depends on the power, and ranges from power) to about 90%. The efficiency obtained for voltages
70% for a low load to 90% for the nominal device power. So, greater than 30 V was only slightly higher. The voltage of
any power transformation reduces the efficiency of the sys- operating electrolyzers is load-dependent and in the range
tem [6]. For large AC/DC converters, efficiency can reach 30-34 V. Fig. 8 shows the efficiency of the AC/DC converter
95% for nominal device power. for different values of output voltage for a constant value of
The first stage of the study was to determine the char- output current of 30 A (nominal current value), calculated by
acteristics of power supplies responsible for the supply of equation (10).
— 153 —
Journal of Power Technologies 96 (3) (2016) 149–156
Figure 8: Efficiency of AC/DC converter for different values of voltages at Figure 10: Efficiency of the electrolysis process as a function of the power
a constant current value delivered to electrolyzers
— 154 —
Journal of Power Technologies 96 (3) (2016) 149–156
∆Pη(AC/DC) was calculated using the value of AC/DC con- Hydrogen has many qualities that may qualify it as the fuel
verter efficiency (eq. 10) and power delivered to electrolyzers of the future. However, it should be emphasized that this pa-
(eq. 12) and defined by equation (15). per concerns hydrogen obtained in processes using renew-
able energy sources. It is worth noting that hydrogen is cur-
1
∆Pη(AC/DC) = PE(DC) · ( − 1) (15) rently obtained mainly from the gasification of coal or refin-
ηAC/DC ing of natural gas, which is associated with the use of energy
The characteristics of hydrogen generator efficiency at from non-renewable fossil fuels. The Energy Returned on
measured points as a function of the electrolysis process Energy Invested (ERONEI) coefficient for hydrogen is about
power supply (DC) are shown in Fig. 11. 0.8 which is far below the value of 1 [14]. Hydrogen produc-
tion is only justified when this process is supplied by energy
Another important parameter is electrical consumption. from renewable energy sources.
This parameter shows how much energy is needed to pro- Increasingly, hydrogen is being produced by water elec-
duce a certain product stream. The next step of research trolysis involving electrolyzers powered directly from renew-
was to determine electrical consumption for the hydrogen able sources of energy. Technological progress has made
generator and electrolysis process. Electrical consumption it possible to create a device in which the efficiency of the
was determined as a ratio of power delivered to generator electrolysis process is often above 80%, and the purity of
or electrolysis process to volumetric hydrogen performance. hydrogen obtained is close to 100%. Electrolyzers used in
Electrical consumption was calculated according to equation alkaline hydrogen generators are a perfect example of this.
(16). The hydrogen generator subject to analysis is equipped
with two alkaline AEM electrolyzers and the KOH solution
Pi
EC = (16) satisfies the role of the working solution. The article presents
V̇H2 the characteristics of the electrolyzers studied and of the en-
where: E C —electrical consumption of hydrogen generator tire hydrogen generator. The maximum performance of the
or electrolysis process, kWh/m3 n ; Pi —power delivered to hy- device was about 440 dm3 n /h and the highest efficiency of
drogen generator or electrolysis process (for generator Pi is the electrolysis process is about 81%. The highest efficiency
equal PG(AC) from eq.(14) and for electrolysis process Pi is of the electrolysis process was received for the lowest hydro-
equal to PE(DC) from eq.(12), W; V̇H2 —hydrogen volumetric gen volumetric performance. The temperature of the KOH
performance, m3 n /h. solution during measurement was about 40◦ C. After turning
Fig. 12 shows the characteristics of electrical energy con- from a cold state, hydrogen appears at the outlet of the gen-
sumption in the electrolysis process and amount of electrical erator (with the currently installed system control algorithm)
energy consumption by the entire generator for different hy- after about 6 minutes.
drogen performance. Hydrogen generators cooperating with renewable energy
sources and fuel cells are attracting more research interest,
It is possible to describe the correlation between efficiency as they can provide an interesting solution for storing large
and electrical energy consumption. This correlation is pre- amounts of energy [15–17]. The use of renewable energy
sented by equation (17). sources to power electrolysis could resolve the problem with
the stochastically varying amounts of energy these installa-
1
η= · HHVH2 (17) tions to the power system. Surpluses of energy resulting
Ec from the operation of renewable energy sources would be
where: η—electrolysis process/hydrogen generator ef- used to produce hydrogen through water electrolysis, which
ficiency; E C —electrical consumption of hydrogen genera- would then be stored. The stored hydrogen could then be
tor/electrolysis process, kWh/m3 n , HHV H2 —hydrogen high readily converted to electricity during shortages in the en-
heating value, kWh/m3 n . ergy system. This would lead to greater stability in power
— 155 —
Journal of Power Technologies 96 (3) (2016) 149–156
Acknowledgements
The results presented in this paper were obtained from
research work financed by the National Center of Re-
search and Development in the framework of program
GEKON—Energy storage in the form of hydrogen in salt cav-
erns, realized in years 2015-2016.
References
[1] D. Wecel, W. Ogulewicz, Identification influence of the electrolyser
power supply method on efficiency hydrogen fuel production, RYNEK
ENERGII (4) (2010) 77–82.
[2] J. Kotowicz, M. Jurczyk, Efficiency of diabatic caes installation, Rynek
119 (4) (2015) 49–56.
[3] D. Wecel, W. Ogulewicz, J. Kotowicz, M. Jurczyk, Dynamic of elec-
trolyzers operation during hydrogen production, Rynek Energii 122 (1)
(2016) 59–65.
[4] W. Ogulewicz, D. Wecel, G. Wiciak, H. Lukowicz, The concept of test
installation of the system: Photovoltaic cell-hydrogen generator fuel
cell, Rynek Energii (2) (2010) 108–112.
[5] P. Millet, S. Grigoriev, Water electrolysis technologies, Renewable Hy-
drogen Technologies: Production, Purification, Storage, Applications
and Safety.
[6] A. Godula-Jopek, Hydrogen Production: By Electrolysis, John Wiley &
Sons, 2015.
[7] Kotowicz J., Ogulewicz W., Wecel ˛ D., Jurczyk M.: Analysis of hydro-
gen electrolyzer work. The19th Annual International Conference En-
ergy and Environment 2015, Ostrava, 2015, s. 44-47.
[8] J. Milewski, G. Guandalini, S. Campanari, Modeling an alkaline elec-
trolysis cell through reduced-order and loss-estimate approaches,
Journal of Power Sources 269 (2014) 203–211.
[9] A. Ursua, L. M. Gandia, P. Sanchis, Hydrogen production from water
electrolysis: current status and future trends, Proceedings of the IEEE
100 (2) (2012) 410–426.
[10] Smolinka T., Gunther M., Garche J.: Stand und Entwicklungspotenzial
der Wasser elektrolysezur Herstellung von Wasserstoffaus Regenera-
tiven Energien. Fraunhofer ISE, 2011.
[11] Millet P.: Hydrogen production by polymer electrolyte membrane water
electrolysis. Compendium of Hydrogen Energy: Hydrogen Production
and Purification, chapter 9. A volume in Woodhead Publishing Series
in Energy , 2015, s.255-286.
[12] Bertuccioli L., Chan A., Hart D., Lehner F., Madden B.: StandenE.:
Study on Development of water electrolysis in the European Union,
Final Report 2014. New Energy World fuel cells and hydrogen for sus-
tainability.
[13] M. Carmo, D. L. Fritz, J. Mergel, D. Stolten, A comprehensive review
on pem water electrolysis, International journal of hydrogen energy
38 (12) (2013) 4901–4934.
[14] W. Ogulewicz, D. Wecel, ˛ G. Wiciak, H. Łukowicz, J. Kotowicz,
T. Chmielniak, Pozyskiwanie energii z ogniw paliwowych typu pem
chłodzonych ciecza, ˛ Wydawnictwo Politechniki Ślaskiej,
˛ Gliwice.
[15] L. Bartela, J. Kotowicz, K. Dubiel, Technical - economic comparative
analysis on energy storage systems equipped with a hydrogen gener-
ation installation, Journal of Power Technologies 96 (2) (2016) 92–100.
[16] S. Lepszy, T. Chmielniak, P. Mońka, Storage system for electricity ob-
tained from wind power plants using underground hydrogen reservoir,
VI Konferencja Naukowo - Techniczna Energetyka Gazowa, Zawiecie
2016, 59-76.
[17] A. Skorek-Osikowska, L. Bartela, J. Kotowicz, K. Dubiel, Use of a gas
turbine in a hybrid power plant integrated with an electrolyser, biomass
gasification generator and methanation reactor, Journal of Power Tech-
nologies 96 (2) (2016) 73.
— 156 —