You are on page 1of 12

What Is Reading?

The Psycholinguistic Model of Reading (Kenneth Goodman)


Reading is defined as a cognitive process that involves decoding symbols to arrive Goodman regards meaning construction as a continuous process of testing the reading text.
at meaning. The reader strives to predict, to sample and to confirm or to change previous predictions, and
consequently tests and samples the text again. In this model of reading comprehension, using
Reading is an active process of constructing meanings of words. all of the existing textual hints is not required for the skilled reader. If the reader is able to
make suitable and related guessing, the less confirmation via the text is required, that is, the
Reading with a purpose helps the reader to direct information towards a goal and
less visual perceptual information the reader needs. The basic psycholinguistic model was
focuses their attention. clarified by Coady (1979). He suggested a model in which reader’s conceptual abilities and
The first keyword is interactive. This keyword refers to two different conceptions: (1) strategies act together with his background knowledge to understand the text.
the interaction that occurs between the reader and the text, whereby the reader In the early 1960s Kenneth S. Goodman began studying the reading of authentic texts
constructs meaning based partly on the knowledge drawn from the text and partly by urban and rural young people. His earliest miscue research, published in 1965, is
from the existing knowledge that the reader has; and (2) the interactivity occurring probably the most widely replicated study in reading research history. But it was his
simultaneously among the many component skills that results in comprehension. As article, "Reading: a Psycholinguistic Guessing Game" (1967), that began a revolution
Grabe (1991) notes, the interactive reading processes involve “both an array of low- moving away from a view of reading as rapid accurate sequential word recognition to
level rapid, automatic identification skills and an array of higher-level an understanding of reading as a process of constructing meaning - making sense - of
comprehension/interpretation skills” print.
Another keyword is processes. A number of processes are at work when people read.      Goodman defined reading as: �a receptive psycholinguistic process wherein the
Grabe (2009) identifies “lower-level processes, including word recognition, syntactic actor uses strategies to create meaning from text� (Goodman, 1988).  Basically, the
parsing and meaning encoding as propositions” and “higher-level processing, study of reading looks at translating a linguistic surface representation (text) into
including text-model formation (what the text is about), situation-model building thought.  Goodman based much of his theory on analysing miscues (mistakes) in texts
(how we decide to interpret the text), inferencing, executive-control processing (how being read-aloud.  He believed that efficient readers minimize dependence on visual
we direct our attention), and strategic processing” detail, but focused his theories on the interactions of reader and text.  Basic physical
sensory information (the physiological process) is cycled into deeper levels of
Also critical is knowledge. Actually, perhaps knowledges would be more accurate. cognitive processes.
This includes knowledge of the language (e.g., the writing system, grammar, Cycles� readers move from text to understanding through cycles of deeper
vocabulary), knowledge of the topic of the text, knowledge of the author, knowledge processing, moving from optical, to perceptual, to syntactic, to meaning
of the genre (e.g., editorial in a newspaper, a romance novel), and knowledge of the Cognitive Processes of the brain used in reading are:
world, including experiences, values, and beliefs. People use all of these knowledges  recognition / initiation � the brain must recognise text and initiate reading
to build, to create, and to construct meaning. Readers all have different knowledge.
 prediction � anticipates and predicts as it seeks order and significance of
input
 confirmation � verification of predictions or disconfirmation
 correction � reprocessing when it finds inconsistencies or disconfirmations
 termination � formal ending of reading act
N.B.:  Goodman treats these processes as sequential, whereas later models may not
language and they could be authentic texts "adapted" to contain or highlight certain
Text in language classrooms: TALO, TAVI and TASP features of language.

In this approach, a reading text is used purely for language input.  It may contain, for
One of the enormous benefits of the Internet has been the accessibility of loads and
example, grammatical items which form the target of this part of the teaching programme
loads of English texts for teachers to use with their learners. But the gap between a or lexis in a particular field of interest to the learners.
teacher finding a text and successfully using it in class can be quite large. How should The approach involves mining the text for these language items (with most of the hard
teachers use texts? How have they used them in the past? digging done by the teacher, usually) and then focusing on them for further clarification
and practice.  Examples of tasks using texts for this purpose will include activities such
Texts in language classrooms: A brief trip through time as:
Texts have been used in language classrooms for a long time. Their exploitation, Find and underline all the words in the text to do with crime and divide them into three
lists: person who does the crime, the crime and the verb
however, has changed over the years.
Find all the ways in the text where the writer is recommending what should happen next. 
 A hundred years ago, a teacher would bring a text, usually literary, into class Make a list from strongest to weakest suggestions.
and would translate it word for word and sentence for sentence with the
students, drawing attention to similarities and differences between English and This is not using the text to develop reading skills, of course, except incidentally.
the students' L1. This was part of the grammar translation approach. Some sample TALO activities are:
 Fifty years ago, teachers were also using texts. These texts would be
considerably different from the literary texts mentioned earlier. For a start,  Find all the examples of X in a text (for example, a grammar pattern, function
they were most often presented in dialogue form. The text had been written words, a particular verb form…)
specifically to highlight a language point. Students would read the text  Find all the words in the text that are connected to X (words that are topically
silently, then repeat parts of the dialogue after the teacher before practising it linked, or lexical sets)
together in pairs. This is an example of the Audiolingual method.  Decide why certain forms were chosen over others (why was a conditional
 Fifteen years ago,The Communicative Approach to language teaching also used, for example)
used texts, but authentic texts were preferred. In this approach, the teacher
would be focussing much more on the meaning of the text as a whole. Ex. We can see that this text contains a lot of verbs in past simple. Therefore, it can
Students would be urged "not to try and understand every word" but to read a easily be used as the object for reinforcing the teaching of the simple past tense. The
text to get at the content and the overall meaning, rather than just the teacher can prepare for the lesson by making it a gap-fill text by taking out the past
language. tense verbs: ’thought’, ‘rushed’, ‘married’, etc. and by finding a picture illustrating
these verbs. The pictures need to be handed around the classroom and as students
As John and Davies (1983) have phrased it, there are three ways to handle a text in the read out the text loudly, they have to pay attention to the gaps and show the picture
modern EFL classroom: use it as TAVI, TALO or TASP. These acronyms stand for the the signification of which fits into that particular gap. Doing this activity, the learners
following concepts and imply the below-listed purposes as Clandfield (2010) has simultaneously master the skill of scanning and skimming as they need to keep
elaborated on them: paying attention to which words have been used and which ones are to be still placed
into the gaps.
TALO - A TALO text is used for language work, specifically grammar or vocabulary. They
are written especially with a pedagogical purpose in mind; they could be authentic texts
the teacher has chosen because they contain lots of examples of a particular feature of
TAVI: Text as a vehicle for information Creative reordering
A TAVI text has a different focus. Information within the text is seen as more
important than the language. Students should understand the overall meaning of a text For the second reading of the text, the class is divided into groups and they have to
instead of (or at least before) the finer points of detail. work together on drawing pictures related to the text: picture of a dog, of cushions,
purple jar, bookcase, etc. The winning group has the most images drawn. Once the
In this approach, the text is being used to develop the strategies that learners need to whole class joins together, they have to select the best picture by voting. After doing
deploy to unlock the writer's meanings and attitudes.  The theory is that this approach this, they have to reorder the images in the chronological order as the words follow
will lead to the development of cognitive strategies which learners can then use one another in the text.
independently to access the meaning of any text they encounter.
Tasks typical of a TAVI approach to reading are, for example: Point of order (Collie; Slater, 1991)
Is the writer strongly or only weakly opposed to tolls on main roads?
What does the writer say about his childhood in general?  Did he have a normal Following the first two activities, students get one sentence each from the text. They
childhood in your opinion? have to stick the sentences on their chest and sit down on a chair. After the teacher
It is a TAVI approach that is considered here because we are concerned with has explained that their task is to unscramble the text, students stand up, check each
language skills rather than language systems development. other’s sentences and in the form of cooperative group work they sit down in an order
that corresponds to the text.
 TAVI texts:
o can be chosen because they are motivating TASP: Text as a springboard for production
o can be ones that the teacher would hope the students would like to read Another text acronym is TASP. TASP stands for Text as a Stimulus for Production.
anyway This means using a text as a springboard for another task - usually a reading or
o can be authentic texts. writing task. TASP approaches also fit well with the communicative approach.

 TAVI type activities include: Using texts in this third way may involve a good deal of TALO use first because the
o predicting the content of the text, discussing questions or statements text may be used as a model to analyse before the learners embark on constructing
that relate to the text their own texts following the same generic staging and using similar circumstances
o marking things in the text that you knew/didn't know before and verbal processes.  Such a procedure would be typical of a genre approach (new
tab) to teaching writing skills.
o answering comprehension questions
This approach to reading texts may be much simpler, using the text purely as stimulus
o summarizing the main points of a text
for discussion, role-play or a speaking activity.  Texts are frequently used this way in
o putting events in order conversation-driven classes typified by, e.g., Dogme.
Typical tasks in a TASP approach might be, for example:
Ex. Prior to reading, as the topic of the lesson, a discussion can be elicited about Circle the paragraphs which set the scene of the story.  Put a box around the
students’ opinions on keeping domestic animals. They can also get involved in a complication in the story.
discussion focusing on their personal experiences with animals. After the discussion, Underline the verbs phrases which refer to actions and highlight the verbs which
one group of the class has to scan through the first paragraph, the other one has to refer to relationships.
scan through the second paragraph. Each group has to predict what beginning or end Make a note of the three reasons the writer dislikes piped music.  How far do you
is implied in the text. Once they get back into forming the whole class again, they agree?  Talk to your group to see how much agreement there is.
discuss among one another what the beginning and the end is. Thus, pyramid reading
is done.
 TASP type activities could be: that, the teacher opens up a box, a time capsule, which the students have to
o doing a role play based on the text put their written endings into. They seal the capsule for up until the next
o discussing issues raised by the text session when the teacher brings in the whole original text and has the class
o having a debate about the points of view presented in the text see which group has had the closest guess as to the ending.
o writing a similar text about something the students know about
o writing a response to the text. Word Recognition

Ex. Based on this text, the teacher can jump start a very engaging and Word recognition is the act of seeing a word and recognizing its
productive task. Firstly, the class has to agree on a title of this excerpt. pronunciation immediately and without any conscious effort. If reading
Secondly, after reading the text, students are put into groups or pairs. The words requires conscious, effortful decoding, little attention is left for
partners working in the same group or pair have to find a fictitious comprehension of a text to occur. Since reading comprehension is the
character. They have to write an article about him or her in a fictitious ultimate goal in teaching children to read, a critical early objective is to
newspaper. They are required to use a lot of adjectives as Virginia Woolf ensure that they are able to read words with instant, automatic recognition
does in this excerpt. The teams have to produce this imagined piece of (Garnett, 2011). What does automatic word recognition look like?
writing for an imagined newspaper. They also have to verbally express Consider your own reading as an example. Assuming you are a skilled
their feeling towards their own created ‘hero’. reader, it is likely that as you are looking at the words on this page, you
cannot avoid reading them. It is impossible to suppress reading the words
Visual text associations that you look at on a page. Because you have learned to instantly
recognize so many words to the point of automaticity, a mere glance with
no conscious effort is all it takes for word recognition to take place.
For the second round of reading the text, the material is cut up into pieces
Despite this word recognition that results from a mere glance at print, it is
of three sentences. Each group gets a card with only three sentences on it.
critical to understand that you have not simply recognized what the words
They have to draw a picture which they think best associates with the
look like as wholes, or familiar shapes. Even though we read so many
given paragraph. They then have to place the pictures on the board with
words automatically and instantaneously, our brains still process every
bluetack. Once it is done, the paragraphs are collected and given out so
letter in the words subconsciously. This is evident when we spot
each group will get a different paragraph this time. They have to match the
misspellings. For example, when quickly glancing at the words in the
parts of the text with the picture drawn by some other group. Following
familiar sentences, “Jack be nimble, Jack be quick. Jack jamped over the
that, teacher elicits a discussion on why they have chosen to draw that
canbleslick,” you likely spotted a problem with a few of the individual
particular image associated with the paragraphs and what the rest of the
letters. Yes, you instantly recognized the words, yet at the same time you
class thinks of that choice.
noticed the individual letters within the words that are not correct.
 
Research-Supported Vocabulary-Learning Strategies
Sealing the times capsule (Collie; Slater, 1991)
Students need a wide range of independent word-learning
strategies. Vocabulary instruction should aim to engage students in
 
actively thinking about word meanings, the relationships among words,
and how we can use words in different situations. This type of rich, deep
The groups have to read the text again and have to work out  a possible
instruction is most likely to influence comprehension (Graves, 2006;
ending of the text. They need to write it down and once they are done with
McKeown and Beck, 2004).
Student-Friendly Definitions Applying the Target Words

The meaning of a new word should be explained to students rather than Applying the target words provides another context for learning word
just providing a dictionary definition for the word—which may be difficult meanings. When students are challenged to apply the target words to their
for students to understand. According to Isabel Beck, two basic principles own experiences, they have another opportunity to understand the
should be followed in developing student-friendly explanations or meaning of each word at a personal level. This allows for deep processing
definitions (Beck et al., 2013): of the meaning of each word. 

 Characterize the word and how it is typically used. Analyzing Word Parts
 Explain the meaning using everyday language—language that is accessible
and meaningful to the student. The ability to analyze word parts also helps when students are faced with
unknown vocabulary. If students know the meanings of root words and
Sometimes a word’s natural context (in text or literature) is not affixes, they are more likely to understand a word containing these word
informative or helpful for deriving word meanings (Beck et al., 2013). It is parts. Explicit instruction in word parts includes teaching meanings of
useful to intentionally create and develop instructional contexts that word parts and disassembling and reassembling words to derive meaning
provide strong clues to a word’s meaning. These are usually created by (Baumann et al., 2002; Baumann, Edwards, Boland, Olejnik, and
teachers, but they can sometimes be found in commercial reading Kame'enui, 2003; Graves, 2004).
programs.

Defining Words Within Context

Research shows that when words and easy-to-understand explanations are


introduced in context, knowledge of those words increases (Biemiller and
Boote, 2006) and word meanings are better learned (Stahl and Fairbanks,
1986). When an unfamiliar word is likely to affect comprehension, the
most effective time to introduce the word’s meaning may be at the
moment the word is met in the text.

Using Context Clues

Research by Nagy and Scott (2000) showed that students use contextual Sem
analysis to infer the meaning of a word by looking closely at surrounding antic Mapping
text. Since students encounter such an enormous number of words as they
read, some researchers believe that even a small improvement in the Semantic maps help students develop connections among words and
ability to use context clues has the potential to produce substantial, long- increase learning of vocabulary words (Baumann et al., 2003; Heimlich
term vocabulary growth  (Nagy, Herman, and Anderson, 1985; Nagy, and Pittleman, 1986). For example, by writing an example, a non-
Anderson, and Herman, 1987; Swanborn and de Glopper, 1999). example, a synonym, and an antonym, students must deeply process the
word persist.
Word Consciousness

Word consciousness is an interest in and awareness of words (Anderson


and Nagy, 1992; Graves and Watts-Taffe, 2002). Students who are word
conscious are aware of the words around them—those they read and hear Problems in Syntax
and those they write and speak (Graves and Watts-Taffe, 2002). Word-
conscious students use words skillfully. They are aware of the subtleties of
word meaning. They are curious about language, and they enjoy playing
with words and investigating the origins and histories of words.

Teachers need to take word-consciousness into account throughout their


instructional day—not just during vocabulary lessons (Scott and Nagy,
2004). It is important to build a classroom “rich in words” (Beck et al.,
2002). Students should have access to resources such as dictionaries,
thesauruses, word walls, crossword puzzles, Scrabble® and other word
games, literature, poetry books, joke books, and word-play activities.

Teachers can promote the development of word consciousness in many


ways:

 Language categories: Students learn to make finer distinctions in their word


choices if they understand the relationships among words, such as synonyms,
antonyms, and homographs. 
 Figurative language: The ability to deal with figures of speech is also a part
of word-consciousness (Scott and Nagy 2004). The most common figures of
speech are similes, metaphors, and idioms.

Once language categories and figurative language have been taught,


students should be encouraged to watch for examples of these in all
content areas.
Strategies for Reading

The process of comprehending text begins before children can read, when
someone reads a picture book to them. They listen to the words, see the
pictures in the book, and may start to associate the words on the page with
the words they are hearing and the ideas they represent.

Using Prior Knowledge/Previewing

When students preview text, they tap into what they already know that
will help them to understand the text they are about to read. This provides
a framework for any new information they read.

Predicting

When students make predictions about the text they are about to read, it
sets up expectations based on their prior knowledge about similar topics.
As they read, they may mentally revise their prediction as they gain more
information.

Identifying the Main Idea and Summarization

Identifying the main idea and summarizing requires that students


determine what is important and then put it in their own words. Implicit in
this process is trying to understand the author’s purpose in writing the text.

Questioning

Asking and answering questions about text is another strategy that helps
students focus on the meaning of text. Teachers can help by modeling both
the process of asking good questions and strategies for finding the answers
in the text.

Making Inferences

In order to make inferences about something that is not explicitly stated in


the text, students must learn to draw on prior knowledge and recognize
clues in the text itself.
Visualizing Vocabulary: The vocabulary is subject-specific and appropriate for
advanced readers. Key terms are woven into the text, not highlighted with
Studies have shown that students who visualize while reading have better special formatting or referenced in a glossary. In some cases you can
recall than those who do not (Pressley, 1977). Readers can take advantage figure out the important information from context; in others, you may need
of illustrations that are embedded in the text or create their own mental to look up a word or two to understand the article.
images or drawings when reading text without illustrations.
Purpose: The author may make a claim, develop an argument, or share an
opinion. Look for this in the article’s title and abstract (the introductory
summary paragraph).
Reading Journal Articles
Research: The focus is usually research—either the author’s own or the
Reading any college-level text can be challenging and time-consuming. work of other scholars on the subject. The text is likely to include many
The amount of reading assigned and the level of difficulty significantly references to other researchers.
increase from high school to college. Many students find that the skills
they needed and used in high school are not as effective in college. Specificity: The author may explore a narrow, highly specific topic or
Understanding and using effective active reading strategies can transform perspective within a larger subject.
reading and study time from frustrating and confusing to meaningful,
purposeful, and successful. Using active reading strategies can improve Formatting: Content may be presented in standardized sections. These
comprehension and ensure that you actually retain the information you include Abstract, Background or Literature Review, Methods, Results,
read. Discussion, Conclusion, and Reference sections.

Journal articles bring their own set of challenges. Since journal articles are Lack of visuals: The text may include few or no visual aids (graphs,
usually signifijuscantly different from other texts, it’s even more important illustrations, charts)—only text. There may be few or no subheadings or
to have a good understanding of active and effective reading strategies, other content delineations.
especially ones that are specific to journal articles. This handout provides
several strategies for reading journal articles effectively and connects you How to read journal articles effectively
with resources for reading texts in general.
Before reading
How are journal articles uniquely challenging?
Ask your professor for guiding questions or key topics to keep in mind
Journal articles differ from other texts in many significant ways. It is while reading. These suggestions and insights can guide your reading and
important to understand the unique features of journal articles before note taking.
starting to read one so that you can better understand it while and after you
read. Begin with the abstract (or first page) and the conclusion (or final page)
for an overview of topics. These help provide a framework for
Background knowledge: Both the author and the intended audience are comprehension.
likely to be experts on the subject. The author assumes readers are already
familiar with basic ideas, terms, and background knowledge.
Think about why your professor might have assigned the article. Limit your highlighting and underlining. Many students use this strategy,
Brainstorm how the content might relate to what you’ve learned in class so but it does not require much thinking or help you remember what you
far. The article will make more sense if you have some context and read. Instead of over-highlighting as you read, wait until you finish a
purpose before you read. paragraph or section. Then, determine the main ideas and supporting
details in that section and highlight only those.
Convert headings and topics into simple questions. Jot these down and
read for answers. Use these to guide your note taking. Try annotating while you read as an alternative to heavy highlighting and
underlining. Make symbols to mark questions, main ideas, unknown
If needed, build a foundation with simpler, shorter sources of information, words, and definitions that you encounter while reading. Reading a digital
such as dictionaries, encyclopedias, and reputable websites. Gathering text? Printing on paper or to PDF can facilitate annotation by hand or with
background information will help you process details and identify main PDF annotation software.
ideas more efficiently. Try looking up a different article on the same topic
or an article that was referenced multiple times by the article you are After reading
reading.
Revisit the article at a later date. You are likely to make connections that
Create a supportive learning environment. Think about what type of weren’t obvious during your first read.
setting enables you to concentrate best and avoid distractions. Clear your
study area of distracting noises and tempting technologies, and choose a Try some active study strategies such as paraphrasing the article or writing
location that is comfortable. a short summary from memory to engage in deeper learning and to better
understand the information.
During reading
Explain and share what you read with a friend—or at least out loud to
Feel free to read sections out of order or to focus only on a few sections. yourself—in your own words. Answer any questions provided in the text,
In some classes, your professor may be more interested that you by your professor, or on the syllabus. If your class is remote or online, try
understand the context (Background/Lit Review) and the outcomes using Zoom or another online meeting space to connect with classmates
(Results and Discussion), whereas in others they may want you to think and discuss readings.
critically about the methods used in the study.
Create flashcards, concept maps, or an outline to critically think through
Make a habit of condensing and paraphrasing what you read. As you the material and test yourself.
finish each section or page, how well can you explain key terms and ideas
without reproducing the author’s words? Use the note-taking template to
reduce an article to a single page of summaries.

Finish an entire page or section before taking notes. If there are no breaks,
create your own stopping points.

Take note of your thoughts and questions as you read. Don’t let them slip
away! Incorporate them into class discussions and assignments.

You might also like