You are on page 1of 11

See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/340006105

ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT ACCOUNTING SUPPORT TO ISO 14001


IMPLEMENTATION IN SERBIA: A CASE STUDY

Article  in  Fresenius Environmental Bulletin · March 2020

CITATIONS READS

0 122

3 authors:

Dejan Jovanovic M. Todorovic


University of Kragujevac University of Kragujevac
40 PUBLICATIONS   103 CITATIONS    40 PUBLICATIONS   69 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE SEE PROFILE

Ivana Medved
University of Novi Sad
12 PUBLICATIONS   3 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

KEY PREDICTORS OF INTERNAL SUPERVISION OF FINANCIAL STATEMENTS View project

MANAGEMENT ACCOUNTING View project

All content following this page was uploaded by Dejan Jovanovic on 18 March 2020.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.



   !    
 


#!!"!
"!!  !! 
  !"%

).&128&128-'-4.&1&!2(2428-'8&1&)(8)( 


46H?GLB96BAB@<6F,A<I8EF<GLB9"E4:H=8I46HE8'H64E4*G4EB: "E4:H=8I46*8E5<4

46H?GLB96BAB@<6F,A<I8EF<GLB9%BI<*47*8:87<AF><CHG   *H5BG<64*8E5<4


 !! 2 3 I8EL<@CBEG4AGFBHE68B9<A9BE@4G<BA?<8F<A
 8AI<EBA@8AG4?466BHAG<A: 
+;8@4<A:B4?B9BHEE8F84E6;<FGBCB<AGGB58A AI<EBA@8AG4? 466BHAG<A: 8A6B@C4FF8F F8I
89<GF B9 G;8 <@C?8@8AG4G<BA B9 *&   FG4A74E7 8E4?G86;A<DH8F4A7GBB?F78F<:A87GB;8?C6B@C4A<8F
4A7G;8EB?8B9466BHAG<A:<A9BE@4G<BA<AG;8CEB68FF <78AG<9L4A7@4A4:8G;8<E8AI<EBA@8AG4?<@C46G2
B9 8AI<EBA@8AG4? @4A4:8@8AG  +;8 E8F84E6; <F 3  AI<EBA@8AG4? @4A4:8EF HF8 466BHAG<A: <A9BE
@8G;B7B?B:<64??L54F87BAG;84CC?<64G<BAB94@H? @4G<BA 8FC86<4??L 8AI<EBA@8AG4? @4A4:8@8AG 46
G<C?8 64F8 FGH7L B9 F<K 6B@C4A<8F J;<6; <F <A ?<A8 6BHAG<A: $ <A9BE@4G<BA GB @BE8 899<6<8AG?L
J<G; G;8 CE8I<BHF E8F84E6; 64EE<87 BHG 4A7 G;8 4F 8I4?H4G886BAB@<64FC86GFB98AI<EBA@8AG4?<@C46G
FH@CG<BAFHA78E?L<A:G;<F@8G;B7 +;8E8F84E6;E8 BA6B@C4ALC8E9BE@4A68 <I8AG;4G4A<A6E84F<A:
FH?GF<A7<64G8G;4GG;86B@C4A<8FE86B:A<M8G;8 <@ AH@58E B9 6B@C4A<8F ;4I8 <@C?8@8AG87 G;8 *&
CBEG4A68B9<@C?8@8AG<A: G;8 *&   FG4A74E7  FG4A74E7E8F84E6;8EFR<AG8E8FGGB<78AG<9LG;8
< 8 FGE4G8:<6<@C?<64G<BAFB9G;88AI<EBA@8AG4?@4A 58A89<GFB9<GF<@C?8@8AG4G<BA<F8KC86G87GB:EBJ2
4:8@8AGCEB68FF BJ8I8EG;8>8LCEB5?8@<FG;4G 3 ?FB584E<A:<A@<A7G;8<@CBEG4A68B9<A
G;8L7BABGE86B:A<M84A77BABGHA78EFG4A7G;8EB?8 9BE@4G<BA 9BE G;8 FH668FF9H? <@C?8@8AG4G<BA B9 G;8
B9466BHAG<A:FHCCBEG<AG;8CEB68FFB98AI<EBA@8A *&  FG4A74E7G;8<AG8E8FGB9E8F84E6;8EFGB<A
G4?@4A4:8@8AG  I8FG<:4G8 G;8 EB?8 4A7 <@CBEG4A68 B9 466BHAG<A: <A
 G;8 8AI<EBA@8AG4?@4A4:8@8AG CEB68FF <F :EBJ<A:
 2   3  +;8 45BI8@8AG<BA87 FGH7<8F @4<A?L
%$  9B6HF BA 78I8?BC87 86BAB@<8F J;<?8 F<@<?4E E8
AI<EBA@8AG4? $4A4:8@8AG *&   AI<EBA@8AG4? F84E6;<A78I8?BC<A:6BHAGE<8F<FF64E68 8A68G;8
$4A4:8@8AG66BHAG<A: FH5=86GB9BHEE8F84E6;<FG;88K4@<A4G<BAB9G;8EB?8
 B9 466BHAG<A: 8FC86<4??L @4A4:8@8AG 466BHAG<A:
 <A G;8 8AI<EBA@8AG4? @4A4:8@8AG CEB68FF <A G;8
!"! 64F8 B9 *8E5<4 5BG; GE4AF<G<BA4? 4A7 78I8?BC<A:
 6BHAGEL $BE8FC86<9<64??LG;8E8F84E6;B5=86G<I8<F
BE @4AL L84EF 6B@C4A<8F ;4I8 6BAF<78E87 GB <78AG<9L G;8 58A89<GF B9 <@C?8@8AG<A: G;8 *&
8AI<EBA@8AG4?47IB64G8FG;8<E8A8@<8F4A78AI<EBA   FG4A74E7 4A7 G;8 EB?8 B9 466BHAG<A: <A9BE
@8AG4??8:<F?4G<BAFB@8G;<A:GB9<:;G4:4<AFG4F?BA: @4G<BA<AG;88AI<EBA@8AG4?@4A4:8@8AGCEB68FF  A
4F CBFF<5?8  *H6; 4A <A6BEE86G 4GG<GH78 58:4A GB 466BE74A68J<G;BHE4<@FG;86BA6?HF<BA<F78E<I87
6;4A:8<A?4G8  F9<EFG<A?4E:8<A7HFGE<4?6B@C4 9EB@G;8E8FH?GFB984E?<8EG;8BE8G<64?4A78@C<E<64?
A<8FOG;8?4E:8FGCB??HG8EF2 3  A4A899BEGGB6BHA E8F84E6;5LI4E<BHF4HG;BEF784?<A:J<G;G;<F<FFH8
G8E46GG;8A8:4G<I86BAF8DH8A68F4A7@<A<@<M8G;8<E 8FC86<4??L <A G;8 9<8?7 B9 466BHAG<A: 4A7 @4A4:8
A8:4G<I8 8AI<EBA@8AG4? <@C46G ?B64??L E8:<BA4??L @8AG2  34FJ8??4FG;8E8FH?GFB5G4<A87
4A7:?B54??L@4AL6B@C4A<8F4E8<AGEB7H6<A:6BE 5L4A4?LM<A:G;8@H?G<C?864F8FGH7LB9F<K6B@C4
CBE4G8F8?9E8:H?4G<BACE46G<68<A6?H7<A:G;8<@C?8 A<8F<A*8E5<4 
@8AG4G<BAB9G;8 *&  AI<EBA@8AG4?$4A4:8 &HEFGH7L6BAGE<5HG8FGBG;8E8?8I4AG?<G8E4GHE8
@8AG *LFG8@F $* FG4A74E7  *H668FF9H? <@C?8 <A F8I8E4? J4LF  66BE7<A: GB G;8 4HG;BEFR
@8AG4G<BAB9G;8 *&  FG4A74E7F;BH?7<@CEBI8 >ABJ?87:8<A*8E5<44A7E8:<BAG;8E8<FABF<@<?4E
G;88AI<EBA@8AG4?@4A4:8@8AGCEB68FFE87H68G;8 E8F84E6; .8GE<87GBCE8F8AGG;8@BFGHCGB74G8<A
A8:4G<I8<@C46GFB95HF<A8FFBC8E4G<BAFBAG;88AI< 9BE@4G<BA  A G;<F E8:4E7 BHE FGH7L E8CE8F8AGF G;8
EBA@8AG 4A7 <@CEBI8 8AI<EBA@8AG4? C8E9BE@4A68  ABI8?GL4A76BH?758B9<@CBEG4A689BEG;8G;8BE8G<
99<6<8AG@4A4:8@8AGE8DH<E8F<78AG<9<64G<BA6B??86 6<4AF4A7CE46G<G<BA8EF<AG;89<8?7B98AI<EBA@8AG4?
G<BA4FF8FF@8AG4??B64G<BA4A74A4?LF<FB98AI<EBA @4A4:8@8AG  78AG<9L<A:G;8>8L58A89<GFB9<@C?8
@8AG4?6BFGF4FJ8??4F9<A4A6<4?4A7ABA9<A4A6<4? @8AG<A: G;8 *&   FG4A74E7 F;BH?7 8A6BHE4:8
<A9BE@4G<BA E8?4G87 GB @4G8E<4? 4A7 8A8E:L 9?BJF <GF J<78E 4CC?<64G<BA  +;8 8@C;4F<F BA 466BHAG<A:
<A9BE@4G<BAFHCCBEG$<AC4EG<6H?4EGBG;8 *&

 

   !    
 

 FG4A74E7<@C?8@8AG4G<BA6BAGE<5HG8FGB@BE8 6BAG<AHBHF <@CEBI8@8AG B9 G;8 E8?4G<BAF;<C GB G;8


899<6<8AG<@C?8@8AG4G<BAB9G;8 *&  FG4A74E7 8AI<EBA@8AG 99<6<8AG$*<@C?8@8AG4G<BAFG<@H
BAF8I8E4?54F8F <EFGB94??<G<FA868FF4ELGBBE:4A ?4G8FG;86B@C4ALGB47BCG4CEB46G<I8P:E88AQ<AAB
<M84A7BC8E4G8@H?G<7<F6<C?<A4ELG84@FG;4GA887GB I4G<BA FGE4G8:L  +;<F FGE4G8:L 64A 5E<A: 58A89<GF GB
<@C?8@8AGG;8 *&  FG4A74E74A7G;8ACB<AGGB 6B@C4A<8FG;4G7<998E8AG<4G8G;8<ECEB7H6GF4A7G;HF
CBG8AG<4?$@8G;B7B?B:<64?FB?HG<BAF9BEG;8CHE :4<A46B@C8G<G<I847I4AG4:82 3 +;8E89BE8<A6BE
CBF8 B9 @84FHE<A: G;8 58A89<GF B9 FG4A74E7 <@C?8 CBE4G<A: 4A 8AI<EBA@8AG4? FGE4G8:L <AGB 4 5HF<A8FF
@8AG4G<BA  BE E8F84E6;8EF BHE FGH7L CEBI<78F 4 FGE4G8:L 4A7 899<6<8AG 8AI<EBA@8AG4? @4A4:8@8AG
FG4EG<A:CB<AG9BE9HEG;8E4A4?LF<F ?G;BH:;*8E5<4A 5E<A:F4AH@58EB958A89<GFGB6B@C4A<8FE8?4G87GB
86BAB@<6 8AI<EBA@8AG <F ABG HA78E 6BAF<78E4G<BA J4FG8E87H6G<BA6BFGE87H6G<BA<A6E84F876HFGB@8E
J8@HFG8@C;4F<M8G;4GBHE4A4?LF<F<F6BA7H6G87<A F4G<F946G<BA 8@C?BL88 6B@@<G@8AG CEB7H6G 4A7
6BA7<G<BAFB9GE4AF<G<BA4A778I8?BC<A:86BAB@<8F  CH5?<6E8?4G<BAF<@CEBI8@8AG23 
+;8E89BE8G;8E8F84E6;64A5858A89<6<4?GB6B@C4 +;8 CBG8AG<4? 58A89<GF B9 <@C?8@8AG4G<BA 4E8
A<8F<AF<@<?4E86BAB@<8F  G;8@BFG<@CBEG4AG@BG<I4GBE9BEG;8<@C?8@8AG4G<BA
+;8C4C8E<FFGEH6GHE87<AG;E88C4EGF +;89<EFG B9$*4F<A7<64G875L4E8I<8JB9FGH7<8FCEBI<787
C4EGB9G;8C4C8ECE8F8AGF4G;8BE8G<64?4FC86GB9G;8 <A+45?8 4F87BAG;8E8F84E6;E8FH?GFCEBI<787<A
E8F84E6; J<G;<A J;<6; G;8 FGE4G8:<6 <@CBEG4A68 B9 +45?8  G;8 58A89<GF B9 $* <@C?8@8AG4G<BA 64A
8AI<EBA@8AG4?@4A4:8@8AG4A7G;8EB?8B9466BHAG :8A8E4??L58FH@@4E<M87<AG;E88:EBHCF<@CEBI8
<A: <A C?4AA<A: <@C?8@8AG4G<BA 4A7 8I4?H4G<BAB9 @8AGB98AI<EBA@8AG4?C8E9BE@4A68899<6<8A6L4A7
8AI<EBA@8AG4?<@C46GFJ<??58;<:;?<:;G879B??BJ87 CEB9<G45<?<GL23  G<FB5I<BHFG;4G@BFGB9G;858A8
5LG;8E8FH?GFB9CE8I<BHFE8F84E6; +;88@C;4F<F<A 9<GF4E88KCE8FF87<AG8E@FB9I4?H8<A7<64GBEF<A8I<
G;8F86BA7C4EGB9G;8C4C8EJ<??58BAG;8E8F84E6; G45?L?847<A:G;8 <FFH8B9 G;8<E@84FHE8@8AG GBG;8
@8G;B7B?B:LJ;<?8G;8G;<E7C4EGJ<??F;BJG;8E8 466BHAG<A: 7B@4<A  +;8 946G G;4G 466BHAG<A: 784?F
F84E6;E8FH?GF4FJ8??4FG;84A4?LF<FB9G;8B5G4<A87 J<G;G;8<FFH8B9G;86B@C4ALRF9<A4A6<4?E8FCBAF<
E8FH?GF  5<?<GL@4L4G9<EFG:?4A68?847GBG;86BA6?HF<BAG;4G
 G;8E84E8BA?L98JCB<AGFB96BAG46G58GJ88AG;88A
 I<EBA@8AG4? 4FC86G B9 7B<A: 5HF<A8FF BA G;8 BA8
!!" ;4A74A7466BHAG<A:CEB98FF<BABAG;8BG;8E BJ
 8I8EG;<FFG4G8@8AG<F7<99<6H?GGB4668CGF<A68<G<F
+;84J4E8A8FFB9G;8A868FF<GLB98AI<EBA@8A B5I<BHFG;4G466BHAG<A:BE466BHAG4AGFC?4L4F<:A<9
G4?@4A4:8@8AG<FHFH4??LABGFH99<6<8AG9BEG;86B@ <64AGEB?8<A<@C?8@8AG<A:4A7@84FHE<A:G;858A8
C4ALGB7B<G ??BJ<A:6B@C4A<8FGBCHEFH84A8A 9<GFB9$*<@C?8@8AG4G<BA 
I<EBA@8AG4?CB?<6LBAG;8<EBJA7B8FABGL<8?7F4G<F 8AA8GG4A7!4@8F2 3<78AG<9LF<K4E84FJ<G;
946GBEL E8FH?GF 5864HF8 G;8 CE8FFHE8 B9 FB6<8GL 4A7 G;8 E8?4G<BAF;<C 58GJ88A G;8 8AI<EBA@8AG 4A7 46
6BAFH@8EF <F ABG FH99<6<8AG?L 6B@CE8;8AF<I8 4A7 6BHAG<A:FG4G<A:G;4G8AI<EBA@8AG4?466BHAG<A:64A
6BAF<FG8AG  9G;86B@C4AL<@C?8@8AGF4:BB78AI< ;8?C<@CEBI8G;8@4A4:8@8AG899<6<8A6L<AG;89B?
EBA@8AG4?CB?<6L<G<FCE<@4E<?L7H8GBG;86B@C4AL ?BJ<A:J4LF<78AG<9L<A:J4LFGBE87H686BFGF78
@4A4:8@8AG 2 3 J;<6; ;4F 78I8?BC87 8AI<EBA G8E@<A<A: CE<BE<G<8F B9 8AI<EBA@8AG4? 46G<BAF 8A
@8AG4? 4J4E8A8FF 4 F8AF8 B9 E8FCBAF<5<?<GL 9BE G;8 ;4A6<A:G;8CEB7H6GF4?8FCE<68CB?<6L<@CEBI<A:G;8
<@C?8@8AG4G<BAB9?8:<F?4G<BA4A746?84E?L789<A87 I4?H89BE6HFGB@8EF<FB?4G<A:9HGHE8<AI8FG@8AG4A7
I<F<BA B9 6B@C4AL 78I8?BC@8AG 4A7 :EBJG;  +;8 BG;8E786<F<BAFJ<G;?BA:G8E@6BAF8DH8A68F4A74F
@BG<I8FGB<A6BECBE4G88AI<EBA@8AG4?CB?<6L<AGBG;8 F8FF<A: G;8 86B899<6<8A6L 4A7
BE FHFG4<A45<?<GL B9
6B@C4ALRF FGE4G8:L J;<6; 4E8 @BFG B9G8A ?<FG87 <A G;86B@C4AL 
G;8?<G8E4GHE84E8FGE4G8:<6@4A4:8@8AGB96B@C4AL .<?@HF;HEFG4A7EBFG2 3FG4G8<AG;8<EFGH7L
E8CHG4G<BAFG4>8;B?78ECE8FFHE8@BG<I4G<BAB98@ G;4G466BHAG<A:64AC?4L4F<:A<9<64AGEB?8<AG;8FH6
C?BL88F6BFGE87H6G<BA4A7<@CEBI8@8AGB9BI8E4?? 68FF9H?<@C?8@8AG4G<BAB9$*5L<AGEB7H6<A:GE4
C8E9BE@4A68 CEB@BG<BA B9 6B@C4AL C;<?4AG;EBCL 7<G<BA4?466BHAG<A:9HA6G<BAF<AGBG;8CEB68FFB98A
8G6 2 3 ?G;BH:;?<G8E4GHE8B998EFG;8I<8JG;4G8A I<EBA@8AG4?@4A4:8@8AG *C86<9<64??L466BHAG4AGF
I<EBA@8AG4?CB?<6L4A78AI<EBA@8AG4?C8E9BE@4A68 A887GBCBFF8FFG;8F><??FA868FF4EL9BEG;878I8?BC
F;BH?75845BI8?8:4?E8:H?4G<BA2 39BE4I4FG@4 @8AG4A79HA6G<BA<A:B9$*E8?4G87GBG;8E86BE7
=BE<GL B9 5HF<A8FF8F ?8:4? E8:H?4G<BA <A G;<F 4E84 <F <A: E8CBEG<A: 7<F6?BFHE8 4A7 I8E<9<64G<BA B9 6B@
A868FF4EL  ?FB 4FFH@<A: G;4G G;8 CBG8AG<4?
46GH4? C4ALC8E9BE@4A68<A6?H7<A:8AI<EBA@8AG4?C8E9BE
64HF4G<I8 4:8AG B9 8AI<EBA@8AG4? 74@4:8 64A <A @4A68  AG;<FE8:4E7466BHAG<A:4F46B@CE8;8A
FB@8 64F8F 58E8?84F87 9EB@ 6;4E:8F;4F6E84G874 F<I8FLFG8@F;BH?76BAGE<5HG8GBG;8 4J4E8A8FFBA
A8879BEG;8<AGEB7H6G<BAB94FG4A74E7<M874A7J8?? <AI8FG@8AG<A8AI<EBA@8AG4?CEBG86G<BAG;8@4AA8E
7B6H@8AG87 8AI<EBA@8AG4? @4A4:8@8AG FLFG8@ B9<GFFLFG8@4G<M4G<BAG;8E8FCBAF<5<?<G<8F4A789986GF
$*  B9 G;<F <AI8FG@8AG 2 3  F 4 E8FH?G <G 64A 58 8K
$*<A6?H78FGBB?F9BE@4A4:<A:G;88AI<EBA C86G87G;4G4A466BHAG4AGJ<??588A6BHE4:87GB:8G
@8AGJ<G;4;<:;78:E88B9HA<9<64G<BA4A79BE@4?< <AG8E8FG87 <A 8I4?H4G<A: 786<F<BAF J<G; 8AI<EBA
M4G<BA  +;8 @4<A E8DH<E8@8AG B9 $* <F G;8

 

   !    
 

@8AG4? <@C46GF 4A7 J<?? G;8E89BE8 58 <AIB?I87 <A PG;8E84E84G?84FGGJBE84FBAFJ;L@4A4:8@8AG46


$*2 3  6BHAG4AGF F;BH?7 58 6BA68EA87 45BHG G;8 E87H6G<BA
-4F<?84A7$4A2 3FG4G8G;4GG;86B@C4ALJ<?? B9 B<? CB??HG<BA <A G;8 BC8A F84 58F<78F ;<F BE ;8E
FH668FF9H??L <@C?8@8AG 8AI<EBA@8AG4? 466BHAG<A: HFH4? E84FBAF 4F 4 6BA68EA87 6<G<M8A B9 G;8 JBE?7 
G;EBH:; G;8 6BBC8E4G<BA B9 GJB :EBHCF B9 8KC8EGF +;<F<FE89?86G87<AG8E@FB946B@CEB@<F858GJ88A
A4@8?L P466BHAG<A:E8FGBE4G<BAQ4A7PCE864HG<BA4EL<AI8FG
 66BHAG<A::EBHC466BHAG4AGFJ;BF8E8 @8AGQE8FGBE4G<BA64A5878F6E<5874F6BFGF4FFB6<
FCBAF<5<?<GL<FGB 8I4?H4G8 <AFC86G4A7E8:<FG8EG;8 4G87J<G;6BEE86G<A:G;8A8:4G<I88AI<EBA@8AG4?<@
F4?8 B9 CEB7H6GF <ACHGBHGCHG E8I8AH8F 9EB@ G;8 C46GBAG;846G<I<G<8FB9G;89<E@FJ;<?8G;8CE864H
F4?8B9CEB7H6GF5LFC86<9<6BE:4A<M4G<BA4?HA<GFCEB G<BA4EL<AI8FG@8AGJ<??4<@GB@<A<@<M8G;8E<F>B94
6HE8@8AG6BFGF8G6  A8:4G<I8<@C46GBAG;88AI<EBA@8AG 
 +86;AB?B:L :EBHC G86;AB?B:<FGF J;BF8 +;8E89BE8<ABE78EGB8K4@<A8G;88AI<EBA@8A
E8FCBAF<5<?<GL <F GB 78I8?BC 8?45BE4G8 54?4A68F 9BE G4?<@C46GB95HF<A8FFBC8E4G<BAF<G<FA868FF4EL9BE
@4G8E<4?FJ4G8E8A8E:LJ4FG88@<FF<BAFB9;4E@ G;8466BHAG<A:<AC4EG<6H?4E$GB<AG8:E4G8G;8
9H?:4F8F8KCE8FF87<AC;LF<64?HA<GF4A7I4?H8<78A 6BECBE4G8 8AI<EBA@8AG 4A7 5HF<A8FF CB?<6L 4A7 <A
G<9L8@<FF<BA6BFGF<ABE78EGB<AGEB7H686?84A8EG86; G;4GJ4LCEBI<78:H<78?<A8F9BE5H<?7<A:FHFG4<A45?8
AB?B:L8FG<@4G8G;8AH@58EB9JBE><A:;BHEF4A7 5HF<A8FF  $ FG8@@87 9EB@ G;8 A887 GB HF8
G;8?<>8  5BB>>88C<A: @8G;B7F GB <A6?H78 @4A4:8@8AG 89
.;<?8.<?@F;HEFG4A7EBFG2 3<A7<64G8G;4G 9BEGF<AG;8CEB68FFGBB5G4<AE8?8I4AG<A9BE@4G<BABA
G;8EB?8B9466BHAG4AGF4E8?<@<G87J<G;<A$*BG;8E <AI8FG@8AG <A CE8I8AG<BA 4A7 8AI<EBA@8AG4? <@
4HG;BEF FH::8FG G;4G FH668FF9H? <@C?8@8AG4G<BA B9 CEBI8@8AG4FJ8??4FG;8<@C46GB95HF<A8FF8FBAG;8
$* <F 7<99<6H?G GB C8E9BE@HA?8FF 466BHAG4AGF 4E8 8AI<EBA@8AG  G <A6?H78F G;8 <78AG<9<64G<BA 4??B64
C4EGB9G;8G84@E8FCBAF<5?89BEG;8<@C?8@8AG4G<BA G<BA4A74A4?LF<FB9@4G8E<4?9?BJF4A7G;8<EE8?4G87
B9 $*  HEE<GG 4A7 <5FBA 2 3 4?FB 4E:H8 G;4G 64F; 9?BJF GB CEBI<78 4A <AF<:;G <AGB G;8 8AI<EBA
@8AG4?<@C46GB99<A4A6<4?C8E9BE@4A682 3 


!
)1)*-65*420 -03/)0)16&6-21  
*GH7<8F $*  * ' ' *  (   '  * )* )* '
AA8G4?  2 3             
;<A4A7'HA 2 3             
@<?FFBA4A7=8?@ 
             
2 3
4IEBAF><8G4?  2 3             
<??4EL 2 3             
H<8G4?  2 3             
#<A>4A7%4I8; 2 3              
$8?AL>8G4?  2 3             
$8?AL>8G4?  2 3             
$BAG45BA8G4?  2 3             
'47@48G4?  2 3             
'4A 2 3             
'8GEBA< 2 3             
'B>F<AF>48G4?  23             
)BA7<A8??<4A7-4FG4: 
             
23
*6;L?4A78E4A7$4EG<AHMM<
             
 23
+4A 23             
0<A4A7*6;@8<7?8E 23             
0<E<7B88G4?  23             
18A:8G4?  23             
1HGF;<4A7*B;4? 2 3             
+BG4?              
*BHE68$B7<9<8723
*L@5B?@84A<A:$4E>8GF;4E8O$*KCBEGO*4?8F4A7F4?8F:EBJG;O*'EB9<G45<?<GLO' @CEBI8@8AGB9G;86B@
C8G<G<I8CBF<G<BA
6B@C8G<G<I847I4AG4:8O ' @CEBI8@8AGB9FLFG8@4G<M4G<BA<@CEBI8@8AGB97B6H@8AG4G<BAJBE>CEB68
7HE8F6?4E<GLB9JBE><@CEBI<A:466BHAG45<?<GLO *99<6<8A6LCEB7H6G<I<GL6BFGF4I<A:FE87H6G<BAB98EEBEF4A7CEB68FF<A:
F;BEG8EG<@8<@CEBI87@4A4:8@8AG6BAGEB?O'EB7H6G
F8EI<68DH4?<GL<@CEBI8@8AGO(  @4:8<@CEBI8@8AGO @
C?BL88C8E9BE@4A68<@CEBI8@8AG@BG<I4G<BAF4G<F946G<BAG84@F6B@@HA<64G<BA>ABJ?87:8O'  @CEBI8@8AGB96HF
GB@8EF4G<F946G<BAE87H6G<BAB96B@C?4<AGF8G6 O * @CEBI8@8AGB9E8?4G<BAFJ<G;FHCC?<8EFO )* @CEBI<A:E8?4G<BAF
J<G;4HG;BE<G<8F4A7BG;8EFG4>8;B?78EFO'&*AI<EBA@8AG4?C8E9BE@4A68O' 

 

   !    
 

?4E:8 AH@58EB9FHEI8LFBI8E G;8?4FG G;E88 FGH7LB9F<K6B@C4A<8F +;8E8FH?GFB5G4<A87<AG;8


786478F;4I8588A78IBG87GBABE@4G<I84E:H@8AGF FHEI8L<A7<64G8G;4GG;8CE46G<68B9?<A><A:G;8@84F
4A7 6B@@8AGF ;<:;?<:;G<A: G;8 58A89<GF :4<A87 5L HE8@8AGB986B899<6<8A6L4A7$<A9BE@4G<BA<F
<AG8:E4G<A: G;8 8AI<EBA@8AG4? 7<@8AF<BA <AGB @4A <A6B@C?8G8 4A7 G;4G 86B899<6<8A6L <A9BE@4G<BA <F
4:8@8AG466BHAG<A:J;<?84F@4??5HG:EBJ<A:464 HA78EHF87 
78@<6899BEG9B6HF8FBAG;8E8F84E6;B98AI<EBA@8A 'E46G<64?8K4@C?8F4E87<I8EF84A7<GF88@FG;4G
G4? 466BHAG<A: <A CE46G<68 23  ?G;BH:; G;8BE8G<64? G;8 A887 9BE 9HEG;8E E8F84E6; 4A7 <@CEBI8@8AG B9
8KC?4A4G<BAF 9BE G;8 6HEE8AG ?8I8? B9 78I8?BC@8AG $<F<A7<FCHG45?8<96B@C4A<8FJ4AGGBBC8E4G8<A
4A74CC?<64G<BAB98AI<EBA@8AG4?466BHAG<A:FG<??7B 466BE74A68J<G;G;86BA68CGB986B899<6<8A6LBE<9
ABG8K<FG@4ALE8F84E6;8EF<AG;8JBE?7GELGBCB<AG G;8LJ4AGGB8AFHE8FHFG4<A45?84A7FB6<4??LE8FCBA
BHGBAG;854F<FB98@C<E<64?E8F84E6;946GBEF<A9?H F<5?8 5HF<A8FF  +;8 8K<FG8A68 B9 AH@8EBHF BC8A
8A6<A:G;8<@C?8@8AG4G<BA4A758A89<GFB94CC?L<A: DH8FG<BAF4A74@5<:H<G<8F<FG;8@BFG<@CBEG4AG@B
8AI<EBA@8AG4? 466BHAG<A: <A C4EG<6H?4E $  ,A G<I89BE6BA7H6G<A:BHEE8F84E6; 
?<>8G;8ABE@4G<I84E:H@8AGFG;4GCEB@BG8$<A 
G;8:?B54?5HF<A8FF6B@@HA<GL8@C<E<64?8I<78A68 
FH::8FGFG;4GG;8?8I8?B9HF8<ACE46G<68<FI8EL7< ! ! 
I8EF8 +;8E84E8AH@8EBHF64F8FGH7<8FG;4G7E4J4G 
G8AG<BAGBG;858A89<GFB9HF<A:$2  3  84E<A: <A @<A7 G;8 E8FH?GF B9 CE8I<BHF E8
A477<G<BAAH@8EBHFFGH7<8F:8A8E4??LFHCCBEGG;8 F84E6;4FJ8??4FG;8946GG;4GG;<F<F4A<FFH8G;4G<F
I<8JG;4GJ;8A5HF<A8FF8F7BABGE86B:A<M84A78K <AFH99<6<8AG?L 8KC?BE87 <A 7B@8FG<6 CE46G<68 G;<F
C?4<A G;8 8AI<EBA@8AG4? <@C46GF 4FFB6<4G87 J<G; FGH7L <F 54F87 BA G;8 @8G;B7 B9 4 @H?G<C?8 64F8
G;8<E46G<I<G<8FG;8LE<F>G;8BCCBEGHA<GLGB<@CEBI8 FGH7L  AFC<G8B96E<G<6<F@FG;<F@8G;B7B?B:L<FI8EL
86BAB@<6 4A7 8AI<EBA@8AG4? C8E9BE@4A68 2  CEB@<A8AG <A E8F84E6; <A G;89<8?7 B9 FB6<B;H@4A
3 $4ALE8F84E6;8EFCB<AGBHGG;4GG;8?BJ?8I8?B9 <FG<6 F6<8A68F 4A7 AH@8EBHF4HG;BEF CB<AGBHG G;4G
47BCG<BAB9$<FB9G8A466B@C4A<875LG;8I<8J <GFE8=86G<BA5864HF8<G7B8FABG58?BA:GBG;8P4C
G;4GG;858A89<GFB9<GF<@C?8@8AG4G<BA7BABG=HFG<9L CEB46;GBDH4AG<G4G<I8@8G;B7B?B:<8FQ<FHA9BHA787
G;86BFGF2 3 I8A<AFGH7<8FJ;8E86B@ 2 3 
C4A<8F6?4<@GB<@C?8@8AG$@BE878G4<?87G8FG @H?G<C?864F8FGH7L<F6BAF<78E874FH<G45?8
<A:E8I84?FG;4G<G<F4A<FB?4G87GBB?<@C?8@8AG4G<BA E8F84E6;@8G;B7B?B:L<A<AFH99<6<8AG?L<AI8FG<:4G87
<A6BAGE4FGGBPFLFG8@4G<64A76B@CE8;8AF<I8<@C?8 4E84F J;8E8 G;8E8 <F AB 8AI<45?8 AH@58E B9 CE8I<
@8AG4G<BAQ23 *H6;CEBB9<FFHECE<F<A:<AI<8JB9 BHF?L6BA7H6G87FGH7<8F23< 8 9BE:8GG<A:<A
G;8$*8KC4AF<BABI8EG;8C4FG98JL84EFFH6;4F 78CG; 4A7 9<EFG;4A7 HA78EFG4A7<A: B9 4 C4EG<6H?4E
*&  4A7$*G;4GE8DH<E8G;86B??86G<BAB9 F<GH4G<BA2 3 +;864F8FGH7L@8G;B7<FCBF<
<A9BE@4G<BAP9BE4FF8FF@8AG4A76BAGEB?B9G;8FLF G<I8?L8I4?H4G875864HF8<G4??BJF6B@CE8;8AF<I8E8
G8@Q23  A:8A8E4?G;8I<8JF4E8G;4GG;858A89<GF F84E6;I4E<BHFFBHE68F4A774G49B6HFBAG;8<A7<
B9<@C?8@8AG<A:$7BABG=HFG<9LG;86BFGF23 I<7H4?4A7<FI8ELC8A8GE4G<A:4A78?4FG<6J<G;4E8
4A7G;8E84E84?FB47IB64G8FJ;B8@C;4F<M858A89<GF F84E6;9B6HFBAC4FG6HEE8AG4A79HGHE864F8F23 
B9$2 3  ?FB4@H?G<C?864F8FGH7L<A6BAGE4FGGBG;8<A7<
B@C4A<8F;4I8G;858A89<GB9<A6?H7<A:$ I<7H4? FGH7L 4??BJF 9BE 788C8E 4A7 58GG8E HA78E
<A8AI<EBA@8AG4?@4A4:8@8AG466BE7<A:GBG;8A FG4A7<A:B968EG4<ACEB5?8@FCEBI<78F9BEG;88KC4A
I<EBA@8AG4? 'EBG86G<BA :8A6L 2 3  *C86<9<64??L F<BA4A76BAA86G<BAB9<A7<I<7H4?64F8F6BAGE<5HG8F
8A8E4?$BGBEF;4FE87H687<GFJ4FG87<FCBF4?6BFGF GB84F<8E<78AG<9<64G<BAB958;4I<BHEC4GG8EAF4A758G
5L @<??<BA7B??4EF5L8FG45?<F;<A:@H?G<HF86BA G8E789<A<G<BAB9G;8G;8BE8G<64?E8F84E6;9E4@8JBE>
G4<A8EFJ<G;<GFFHCC?<8EF ?FBB@@BAJ84?G;7 23 
<FBAE84?<M8F @<??<BA7B??4EFB99<A4A6<4?58A89<GF *GH7<8FB998EABF<A:?8I<8JBAG;858FGAH@58E
G;EBH:; @BE8 899<6<8AG HF8 B9 E8FBHE68F  A78EF8A B964F8FGB58<A6?H787<AG;84A4?LF<FBEG;8AH@58E
BECBE4G<BA;4F<@C?8@8AG87F8I8E4?CEB:E4@FG;4G B964F8FBAJ;<6;GB54F84@H?G<C?8FGH7L 66BE7
E87H68J4FG84G<GFFBHE684A7;4I8<AG8EA4?E4G8FB9 <A:GBBA84CCEB46;G;8BCG<@H@AH@58EB9B5F8E
E8GHEAG;4G8K6887  'H5?<6*8EI<68?86GE<64A7 I4G<BA HA<GF 6B@C4A<8F <F 58GJ88A 9BHE 4A7 G8A
4FB@C4AL;4FF4I87@BE8G;4A @<??<BA7B??4EF 2 3  BE G;8 CHECBF8F B9 <@C?8@8AG<A: 4 @H?G<C?8
5L @B78EA<M<A: <GF <AI8AGBEL @4A4:8@8AG CEB68FF 64F8FGH7L<AG;<FFHEI8LF<K?4E:86B@C4A<8FJ<G;
23  ?FB G;8 ABACEB9<G :EBHC %&)$ <AI8FG< G;8 *&  FG4A74E7<@C?8@8AG87;4I8588AF8
:4G87 6B@C4A<8F<AG;8BE:4A<66;8@<64?<A7HFGEL ?86G87 +;86;4E46G8E<FG<6FB9G;8F8?86G876B@C4A<8F
<A 4A7  4A79BHA7G;4GG;84I8E4:84AAH4? 4E8F;BJA<A+45?8 
F4I<A:FC8ECB??HG<BACE8I8AG<BA CEB=86G <ACEB7H6 +;8 6B@C4A<8F <A G;8 F4@C?8 ;4I8 588A G4E
G<BA J;8E8 G;8 74G4 J4F 4I4<?45?8 J8E8 BI8E :8G875864HF8G;8L;4I8<@C?8@8AG87G;8 *&  
  7B??4EF2 3  FG4A74E7 BAF<78E<A:G;4G4F@4??AH@58EB96B@
HEE<GG4A7*4>42 3CB<AGGBG;8E8?4G<BAF;<C58 C4A<8F<A*8E5<4C4L4GG8AG<BAGB6BECBE4G8FB6<4?E8
GJ88A $ 4A7 86B899<6<8A6L @84FHE8F <A !4C4 FCBAF<5<?<GL4A76E84G84E8CBEGBAFHFG4<A45<?<GLG;8
A8F86B@C4A<8F +;8E8F84E6;J4F54F87BA464F8 4A4?LF<F <A6?H78F G;E88 6B@C4A<8F G;4G 6E84G8 G;8



   !    
 

E8CBEGGJB6B@C4A<8F4F4F8C4E4G8E8CBEGBA86B@ E8FCBAF<5?8 6B@C4AL 9B??BJ87 5L 6BFG E87H6G<BA


C4ALJ<G;<AG;84AAH4?E8CBEG4A7G;E886B@C4A<8F 4A7 8@C?BL88 @BG<I4G<BA G;8 @4A4:8@8AG B9 G;8
G;4G7BABG6E84G8G;4GE8CBEG  G;E886B@C4A<8F4A4?LM87CB<AGFBHGG;8F858A89<GF 
BEG;8CHECBF8FB96B??86G<A:74G4G;84HG;BEF +;8E8FH?GFB5G4<A874E86BAF<FG8AGJ<G;G;8E8FH?GFB9
HF87 G;8 FHEI8L 4A7 <AG8EI<8J @8G;B7  +;8 FHEI8L G;8CE8I<BHFE8F84E6;F88+45?8  ?FBG;84A4?L
J4F6BA7H6G87<A  +;8G4E:8G:EBHCB9E8FCBA7 F<FB9G;8@4A4:8@8AGRFE8FCBAF8<A7<64G8FG;4GG;8
8AGF <A6?H787 @4A4:8@8AG B9 6B@C4A<8F A4@8?L @4A4:8@8AG B9 G;8 6B@C4A<8F <A G;8 F4@C?8 C4E
7<E86GBEF6B@@8E6<4?7<E86GBEFG86;A<64?7<E86GBEF G<4??LE86B:A<M8FG;8EB?8B9466BHAG<A:<AG;8<@C?8
4A7 9<A4A6<4? 7<E86GBEF  %<A8 7<E86GBEF J8E8 <AG8E @8AG4G<BA B9 G;8 *&   FG4A74E7 584E<A: <A
I<8J87<A6B@C4ALJ;<?8<AG;8E8@4<A<A:6B@ @<A7G;4G4??E8FCBA78AGF<AG;<FDH8FG<BAA4<E8:<I8
C4A<8FG;89<A4A6<4?4A7:8A8E4?@4A4:8EJ8E8<AG8E G;8E4G<A:C4EG?L4:E88GBG;<F<FFH85HGABFHE
I<8J87 J;<6; <@C?<8F G;4G 4 GBG4? B9  7<E86GBEF I8L876B@C4AL;4F478I8?BC87466BHAG<A:F8:@8AG
J8E8<AG8EI<8J87  784?<A:J<G;8AI<EBA@8AG4?<FFH8F 
4I<A: <A @<A7 G;8 E8F84E6; B5=86G<I8 G;8 +45?8:<I8F4ABI8EI<8JB9G;8E8FCBA78AGFR
DH8FG<BAA4<E8J4F<AG8A787GBCEBI<784AFJ8EFGBG;8 4AFJ8EFGBG;8DH8FG<BAB9G;88KG8AGGBJ;<6;8AI<
9B??BJ<A:DH8FG<BAF EBA@8AG4?<A9BE@4G<BA<F<@CBEG4AG9BEG;86B@C4AL
 .;4G58A89<GF7B8FG;86B@C4AL46;<8I85L 4A7<AJ;<6;5HF<A8FFF8:@8AGF<G<FHF87 
<AGEB7H6<A:G;8 *&  FG4A74E7 ,A?<>8 CE8I<BHF E8F84E6; J8 <A6?H787 <A G;8
 .;<6;5HF<A8FFF8:@8AGFG4>8<AGB6BAF<7 4A4?LF<FG;8<FFH8B9HF<A:<A9BE@4G<BABA8AI<EBA
8E4G<BA8AI<EBA@8AG4?<A9BE@4G<BA @8AG4?CEBG86G<BA<A5HF<A8FFBC8E4G<BAFJ;<6;<F4A
 .;4G <F G;8 EB?8 B9 4A 8AI<EBA@8AG4? 46 <@CBEG4AG6BAGE<5HG<BAB9BHEE8F84E6; L4A4?LM<A:
6BHAG4AG<AG;88AI<EBA@8AG4?@4A4:8@8AGCEB68FF G;8E8FCBAF8F:<I8A<A+45?8<G64A58ABG<687G;4G
4A7J;<6;5HF<A8FFF8:@8AGFF;BH?7<AIB?I8G;846 G;8<A9BE@4G<BAJ<G;4A8AI<EBA@8AG4?6B@CBA8AG<F
6BHAG4AG B9:E84G<@CBEG4A68<AG;85HF<A8FFB9@BFG6B@C4
+;8 E8F84E6; DH8FG<BAA4<E8 <F 54F87 BA 6BA A<8F +;8BA?L8K68CG<BA<FG;86B@C4AL +;<F<F
68CGF <78AG<9<87 <A F<@<?4E E8F84E6; C4C8EF ?<FG87 <A 8KC86G87:<I8AG;4G6B@C4AL<F4FG4G86B@C4AL
G;8 ?<G8E4GHE8 E8I<8J  +;8 DH8FG<BAA4<E8 6BAF<FGF B9 G;4G<F<AG;8CEB68FFB9E8FGEH6GHE<A:4A7J;<6;;4F
 DH8FG<BAF G;8 4A4?LF<F 9B6HF<A: BA 4AFJ8EF E8 588A E86BE7<A: CBBE E8FH?GF 9BE @4AL L84EF  ?FB
?4G87 GB G;8 *&   FG4A74E7 G;8 HF8 B9 <A9BE 6B@C4AL7B8FABGHF8G;8@8AG<BA87<A9BE@4G<BA
@4G<BABA8AI<EBA@8AG4?CEBG86G<BA<AG;86B@C4AL <AC?4AG@4<AG8A4A686BFG466BHAG<A:C8E9BE@4A68
BC8E4G<BAF4A7G;8EB?8B9466BHAG<A:<AG;8<@C?8 @84FHE8@8AG 4A7 E8CBEG<A: J;<?8 6B@C4AL RF
@8AG4G<BAB9G;8 *&  FG4A74E7 (H8FG<BAF<A @4A4:8@8AG<FABGFHE8B9G;8F<:A<9<64A68B9G;8<A
G;8DH8FG<BAA4<E84E8B9BC8A4A76?BF87GLC8  AG;8 9BE@4G<BA <A G;8F8 F8:@8AGF  B@C4AL RF E8
DH8FG<BAA4<E849<I8CB<AG#<>8EGF64?8<FHF87<A7< FCBAF8F64A58=HFG<9<875LG;8946GG;4G<G<F46B@
64G<A:G;878:E88B94:E88@8AGB96B@C4AL@4A4: C4ALG;4G7B8FABG;4I8478I8?BC87F8:@8AGB9FHF
8EF J<G; G;8 BHG?<A87 I<8JF  +;8 B998E87 4AFJ8EF G4<A45?878I8?BC@8AGE8CBEG<A:C?4AA<A:GB<@CEBI8
E4A:89EB@ O FGEBA:?L7<F4:E88GBO 6B@C?8G8?L G;8@8AG<BA875HF<A8FFF8:@8AG<AG;8HC6B@<A:C8
4:E88  E<B7 ?FB4??FHEI8L87@4A4:8EFFG4G8G;4GG;86B@
 C4ALRF <@C46G BA G;8 8AI<EBA@8AG <F 6BAF<78E87
 J;8A<@C?8@8AG<A:46BFG58A89<G4A4?LF<F 
 "!  A <@CBEG4AG E8F84E6; F8:@8AG <F 78IBG87 GB
 G;8 4A4?LF<F B9 @4A4:8@8AG 4GG<GH78F BA 8AI<EBA
A BE78E GB 7E4J 6BA6?HF<BA 45BHG G;8 EB?8 B9 @8AG4?<FFH8F4A7G;8EB?8B9466BHAG<A:<A8AI<EBA
466BHAG<A: <A G;8 8AI<EBA@8AG4? @4A4:8@8AG CEB @8AG4? @4A4:8@8AG  *C86<9<64??L G;8 6B@C4AL
68FF 4A <A7<I<7H4? 4A4?LF<F B9 G;8 F8?86G87 6B@C4 @4A4:8EF J8E8 FHCCBF87 GB FG4G8 9BE 846; B9 G;8
A<8FJ4F64EE<87BHG +;89<EFGC4EGB9G;84A4?LF<FE8 :<I8A<G8@F:<I8A<A+45?8J;8G;8EG;8L4:E887BE
98EFGBG;84GG<GH78B9@4A4:8@8AGBAG;858A89<GFB9 ABG 5L 6<E6?<A: 4A 4AFJ8E BA G;8 9<I8CB<AG #<>8EG
<@C?8@8AG<A: *&  +45?8:<I8F4ABI8EI<8J F64?8 +45?8F;BJFG;84E<G;@8G<6@84AB9G;8@4A
B9@4A4:8EFRE8FCBAF8BAG;858A89<GFB9<@C?8@8AG 4:8EFR4GG<GH78FBA8AI<EBA@8AG4?<FFH8F4A7G;8EB?8
<A:G;8 *&  FG4A74E7<AF<K4A4?LM876B@C4 B9466BHAG<A:<A8AI<EBA@8AG4?@4A4:8@8AG 
A<8F  +;8 E8FH?GF CE8F8AG87 <A +45?8  <A7<64G8 G;4G
4F87 BA G;8 <A9BE@4G<BA :<I8A <A +45?8  <G G;8I<8JFB9G;8@4A4:8@8AGB9G;8FHEI8L876B@
64A 58 ABG87 G;4G G;8 @4A4:8@8AG B9 4?? 4A4?LM87 C4A<8F4E8ABGHA<9BE@ I8A@4A4:8EF58?BA:<A:GB
6B@C4A<8F 4:E88F G;4G G;8 @4<A 58A89<GF B9 <@C?8 G;8F4@86B@C4AL7BABG;4I84HA<9BE@CBF<G<BABA
@8AG<A:G;8 *&  FG4A74E74E858GG8E6B@C4AL 4??<FFH8F  BAF8AG8K<FGFJ<G;E8:4E7GBG;8HA78E
E8CHG4G<BAC8E9BE@4A68<@CEBI8@8AG8AI<EBA@8A FG4A7<A:B9G;8FGE4G8:<6<@CBEG4A68B9G;88AI<EBA
G4?E8FCBAF<5<?<GL4A75H<?7<A:G;8<@4:8B94FB6<4??L @8AG4?@4A4:8@8AGCEB68FF4A7G;8<A6BECBE4G<BAB9
8AI<EBA@8AG4?CB?<6L<AGBG;85HF<A8FF





   !    
 

! 
)1)4&/,&4&'6)4-56-'52* )/)'6)(203&1-)5
B@C4AL *<M8 %H@58EB98@C?BL88F 6G<I<GL
   #4E:8  $4AH946GHE8B9BG;8E@8G4?CEB7H6GF
   *@4??  $4AH946GHE8B9BG;8E@8G4?CEB7H6GF
  *@4??   $4AH946GHE8B98?86GE<64?;BHF8;B?74CC?<4A68F
  *@4??  $4AH946GHE8B96BEEH:4G8764E75B4E74A7C4C8E4A764E75B4E76BAG4<A8EF
 #4E:8  $4AH946GHE8B968@8AG
 #4E:8  $4AH946GHE8B968@8AG
 #4E:8   $4AH946GHE8B9@46;<A8EL9BE@<A8FDH4EE<8F4A76BAFGEH6G<BA
 #4E:8  $4AH946GHE8B9<A7HFGE<4?:4F8F
 #4E:8  $4AH946GHE8B9BG;8E54F<6BE:4A<66;8@<64?F
*BHE68HG;BEFR64?6H?4G<BA

!

)1)*-65*4206,)03/)0)16&6-212*   6&1(&4(
      
8GG8EE8CHG4G<BAB9G;86B@C4AL      
BFGE87H6G<BA      
'8E9BE@4A68<@CEBI8@8AG      
$BG<I4G<A:8@C?BL88F      
)8FCBAF<5<?<GLGBG;88AI<EBA@8AG      
H<?7<A:G;8<@4:8B94FB6<4??LE8FCBAF<5?86B@C4AL      
@84AFG;4GE8FCBA78AGF6B@C?8G8?LBEC4EG<4??L4:E88J<G;G;8<G8@@84AFG;4GE8FCBA78AGF4E8ABGFHE8
*BHE68HG;BEFR64?6H?4G<BA

! 
"5)2*1*240&6-212118-4210)16&/426)'6-21-1203&1975-1)55
      
HF<A8FFE<F>4FF8FF@8AG      
4C<G4?5H7:8G<A:      
AG8EA4?E8CBEG<A:      
FG<@4G87<AI8FG@8AG      
'?4AA<A:CEB68FF      
$4<AG8A4A68B9G;8C?4AGBEBI8E;4H?      
BFG66BHAG<A:      
'8E9BE@4A68@84FHE8@8AG      
)8CBEG<A:45BHGG;86B@C4ALC8E9BE@4A68      
@84AFG;4GE8FCBA78AGF6B@C?8G8?LBEC4EG<4??L4:E88J<G;G;8<G8@@84AFG;4GE8FCBA78AGF4E8ABGFHE8
*BHE68HG;BEFR64?6H?4G<BA

! 
66-67()52*6,)&1&+)0)162118-4210)16&/557)5&1(6,)2/)2*''2716-1+-118-4210)16&/
&1&+)0)16
      
AI<EBA@8AG4?64E8<FC4FF<A:94F;<BA       
AI<EBA@8AG4?<FFH8F4E8ABG4A4E849BEG;8466BHAG4AG       
@C46GFCBF<G<I84A7A8:4G<I8B96B@C4A<8FBAG;88AI<EBA@8AGF;BH?758DH4AG<9<874A7<A6?H787<AG;8
       
9<A4A6<4?FG4G8@8AGF 
+;8466BHAG4AGF;BH?76BAGE<5HG8GB8A45?8@BE8899<6<8AG8AI<EBA@8AG4?@4A4:8@8AGB9G;86B@C4AL          
+;8466BHAG4AG;4F4CEB98FF<BA4?B5?<:4G<BAE8FCBAF<5<?<GLGB47IB64G84A8AI<EBA@8AG4?CEBG86G<BACEB
      
:E4@J<G;<AG;89<A4A6<4?4FC86GFB96BECBE4G8:BI8EA4A68 
AI<EBA@8AG4?<A9BE@4G<BA<F<@CBEG4AGGBHF8EFB94AAH4?E8CBEGF        
AI<EBA@8AG4?CEBG86G<BAF;BH?75846B@CH?FBEL6B@CBA8AGB94AAH4?E8CBEGF         
AI<EBA@8AG4?7<F6?BFHE8<9CBFF<5?8F;BH?758DH4AG<G4G<I8<AA4GHE8        
BFGFB98AI<EBA@8AG4?CEBG86G<BAJ;<6;6HEE8AG?L7BABG;4I8@4E>8GI4?H8F;BH?758<A6?H787<AFB@8
      
J4L<AG;8<A6B@8FG4G8@8AG 
+;86B@C4ALF;BH?7CE8C4E88AI<EBA@8AG4?<A9BE@4G<BA4A7CH5?<6?L7<F6?BF8<G        
+;88AI<EBA@8AG4?C8E9BE@4A68B9G;86B@C4AL49986GFG;89<A4A6<4?C8E9BE@4A68B9G;86B@C4AL         
AI<EBA@8AG4??L<A899<6<8AG6B@C4AL<F4?FB86BAB@<64??L<A899<6<8AG        
*BHE68HG;BEFR64?6H?4G<BA

FGE4G8:L B9 G;8 6B@C4AL  BJ8I8E G;8 EB?8 B9 46 F4I<A:F E8FH?G<A: 9EB@ $* <@C?8@8AG4G<BA 5HG
6BHAG<A:<AG;88AI<EBA@8AG4?@4A4:8@8AGCEB68FF FG<??7BABGE86B:A<M8G;858A89<GFB94CC?L<A:8AI<
<F ABG HA78EFGBB7 <A G;8 E<:;G J4L  )8FCBA78AGF EBA@8AG4?6BFG466BHAG<A: 
;<:;?<:;GG;8<@CBEG4A68B9<A9BE@4G<BABA6BFGF4A7 



   !    
 

?FBBHEE8FH?GF<A7<64G8G;4G6B@C4AL@4A4: G;<F<AI8FG@8AG BJ8I8E78FC<G8AH@8EBHFG;8BE8G


8EFJ;B6E84G8FHFG4<A45<?<GLE8CBEG:4I8F<@<?4E4A <64?C4C8EFG;4G;<:;?<:;GG;858A89<GFB9HF<A:$
FJ8EF6B@C4A<8F4A7J;<?8G;8@4A4:8@8AG 4@BE878G4<?878K4@<A4G<BA;4F9BHA7G;4GG;8E8<F
B9 E8FGEH6GHE<A: 6B@C4AL  CEBI<787 E8FCBAF8F ABPFLFG8@4G<64A76B@C?8G8<@C?8@8AG4G<BAQ23
G;4G7<998EF?<:;G?L9EB@BG;8EFHEI8L87@4A4:8EF  G B9G;<F@4A4:8@8AGGBB?<ACE46G<68 
F;BH?758CB<AG87BHGG;4GG;8<G8@J<G;J;<6;4??G;8 +;8E8FH?GFB9BHEE8F84E6;<A7<64G8G;4GG;84A
<AG8EI<8J87 @4A4:8EF 4:E887 <F G;4G G;8 6BA68EA 4?LM876B@C4A<8FE86B:A<M8G;8<@CBEG4A68B98AI<
45BHGG;88AI<EBA@8AG<F4A<FFH8GBJ;<6;6B@C4 EBA@8AG4? @4A4:8@8AG <A 46;<8I<A: 4 58GG8E 6B@
A<8FF;BH?7C4L4GG8AG<BAGB<AG;89HGHE84A7G;4GG;<F C8G<G<I8CBF<G<BA4A76E84G<A:G;8<@4:8B94FB6<4??L
<FABG4C4FF<A:94F;<BA ?FB@BFG@4A4:8EF9H??L E8FCBAF<5?8 6B@C4AL J;<6; <F <A ?<A8 J<G; F<@<?4E
BEC4EG<4??L4:E88G;4G8AI<EBA@8AG4?7<F6?BFHE8F<9 E8F84E6;64EE<87BHGJBE?7J<782 3 $4A
CBFF<5?8 F;BH?7 58 DH4AG<G4G<I8 <A A4GHE8 G;4G G;8 4:8@8AGCB<AGFBHGG;4GG;858A89<GFB9<@C?8@8AG<A:
6B@C4ALF;BH?7CE8C4E88AI<EBA@8AG4?<A9BE@4G<BA *&  FG4A74E74E858GG8E6B@C4ALE8CHG4G<BA
4A7CH5?<6?L7<F6?BF8<G4A7G;4GG;88AI<EBA@8AG4? C8E9BE@4A68<@CEBI8@8AG5H<?7<A:G;8<@4:8B94
C8E9BE@4A68B946B@C4AL<@C46GF<GF9<A4A6<4?C8E FB6<4??LE8FCBAF<5?86B@C4AL4A78AI<EBA@8AG4?E8
9BE@4A68 A<AG8E8FG<A:946G<FG;4G4??E8FCBA78AGF FCBAF<5<?<GL )8FH?GFFLFG8@4G<M87<AG;<FJ4L7BABG
<AJ;B?8BE<AC4EG4:E88J<G;G;8I<8JG;4G8AI<EBA 78I<4G8 F<:A<9<64AG?L 9EB@ G;8 E8FH?GF B9 F<@<?4E E8
@8AG4? C8E9BE@4A68 49986GF G;8 9<A4A6<4? C8E9BE F84E6;F88+45?8   GF;BH?74?FB58ABG87G;4G4?G
@4A68B9G;86B@C4AL (H4AG<G4G<I88I<78A68<AFHC ;BH:;G;84A4?LM876B@C4A<8F7BABG;4I8478I8?
CBEGB9G;<F6?4<@<FABG:<I8A4A7G;8<FFH8<GF8?9<F BC87466BHAG<A:F8:@8AG784?<A:J<G;8AI<EBA@8A
DH8FG<BA45?8 :<I8A G;8 CE8I<BHF E8F84E6;  *C86<9< G4?<FFH8FG;8LHF8G;8C;LF<64?4A7@BA8G4EL<A9BE
64??L45BHGB9FGH7<8FCB<AGBHGG;4GG;8E8<F4 @4G<BA G;8LE868<I8 9EB@ G;8466BHAG<A:4A78AI<
CBF<G<I8 <@C46G 45BHG  B9 FGH7<8F 6?4<@ G;4G EBA@8AG4?F86GBE<AG;84FF8FF@8AGB95HF<A8FFE<F>
G;8E8 <F 4 A8:4G<I8 <@C46G J;<?8   B9 FGH7<8F 64C<G4? 5H7:8G<A: <AG8EA4? E8CBEG<A: <AI8FG@8AG
6?4<@G;4GG;8E84E8AB8AI<EBA@8AG4?<@C46GFBA9< 8I4?H4G<BA C?4AA<A: CEB68FF C?4AG @4<AG8A4A68 BE
A4A6<4? C8E9BE@4A68 2 3  A G;<F E8:4E7 'BEG8ERF BI8E;4H? 6BFG 466BHAG<A: C8E9BE@4A68 @84FHE8
6?4<@ G;4G 8AI<EBA@8AG4? E8:H?4G<BAF 64A ?847 GB 4 @8AG4A7C8E9BE@4A68E8CBEG<A: ?FBG;8E8FH?GFB9
PJ<AJ<AQF<GH4G<BA<AJ;<6;5BG;FB6<4?4A7CE<I4G8 BHEFGH7L<A7<64G8G;4GG;84A4?LM876B@C4A<8FFG<??
58A89<GFB96B@C4A<8F4E8<A6E84F<A:2 3F;BH?758 7BABG9H??LE86B:A<M8G;8EB?8B9466BHAG<A:<AG;8
8@C;4F<M87 +;<F<F4?FB6BA9<E@875LG;88@C<E<64? 8AI<EBA@8AG4?@4A4:8@8AGCEB68FFBEG;4GG;8L7B
E8F84E6;B92 34A7BG;8EF &HEE8F84E6;;4F ABG E86B:A<M8 G;8 58A89<GF B9 $ <A G;<F CEB68FF
BC8A87G;<F<FFH89BE9HGHE8E8F84E6;  2 3 *H6;4A4GG<GH78<F8KC86G87:<I8A
 G;8946GG;4G*8E5<4<F<AGE4AF<G<BA4A7<F<AG;8CEB
 68FFB94668FF<BAGBG;8HEBC84A,A<BA &A8B9G;8
"  E8DH<E8@8AGF<AG;8,4668FF<BACEB68FF<FGB<@
 CEBI88AI<EBA@8AG4?CEBG86G<BA ??4A4?LM876B@
@CEBI8@8AGB9 G;8 GE84G@8AG B9 G;8 8AI<EBA C4A<8F4:E88G;4G<A9BE@4G<BABA8AI<EBA@8AG4?<@
@8AG 5L E87H6<A: A8:4G<I8 8AI<EBA@8AG4? <@C46GF C46GFB96B@C4A<8FF;BH?758CH5?<6?L7<F6?BF87<A
4A7 <@CEBI<A: 8AI<EBA@8AG4? C8E9BE@4A68 64AABG 4AAH4?E8CBEGF:<I8AG;8<E<A6E84F<A:<@CBEG4A689BE
5846;<8I87<96B@C4A<8F94<?GBE86B:A<M8G;8FGE4G8 FG4>8;B?78EF  +;8 4A4?LF<F 4?FB F;BJF G;4G G;8 E8
:<6 <@CBEG4A68 B9 G;8 8AI<EBA@8AG4? @4A4:8@8AG FGEH6GHE<A:6B@C4AL@4A4:8EFJ;8E8G;8FG4G8<FG;8
CEB68FF4A77BABG<AG8:E4G88AI<EBA@8AG4? CEBG86 @4=BE<GL BJA8E ;4I8 4 FB@8J;4G 7<998E8AG 4GG<GH78
G<BACB?<6<8F<AGBG;8<E5HF<A8FF FGE4G8:L +;<F<AG8 4A758?<8I8G;4G4A8AI<EBA@8AG4??L<A899<6<8AG6B@
:E4G<BA<F54F87BAE4<F<A:8AI<EBA@8AG4?4J4E8A8FF C4AL 64A 58 86BAB@<64??L 899<6<8AG  +;<F CBF<G<BA
J<G;<A846;9HA6G<BA<AG;86B@C4AL HF89H?GBB? 64A58=HFG<9<875LG;8946GG;4G<G<F46B@C4ALG;4G
9BE<AG8:E4G<A:8AI<EBA@8AG4?<AGBG;85HF<A8FFFGE4G ;4FABG588A45?8GB474CGGB6;4A:8FBAG;8@4E>8G
8:L B9 G;8 6B@C4AL <F G;8 *&   FG4A74E7  4A7;4F588A<AG;8CEB68FFB9E8FGEH6GHE<A:9BE@4AL
6;<8I<A: 4 54?4A687 E8?4G<BAF;<C 58GJ88A 9HA6 L84EF 
G<BAF 4<@87 4G <@CEBI<A: 8AI<EBA@8AG4? C8E9BE 'BF<G<I8 6;4A:8 <F G;4G <A G;8 ?4FG 9<I8 L84EF
@4A684A7E87H6<A:8AI<EBA@8AG4?<@C46GF<F7<99< 6B@C4A<8FJ<G;9BE8<:A64C<G4?4FJ8??4F7B@8FG<6
6H?GGB46;<8I8<9G;8E8<FAB6BBC8E4G<BA58GJ88A8A FH668FF9H??L CE<I4G<M87 6B@C4A<8F F88 CEB:E8FF
I<EBA@8AG4?@4A4:8EF4A7466BHAG4AGF  A477<G<BA J;<6; <F 8FC86<4??L CB<AG87 BHG 5L G;8 946G G;4G 4A
G;8G;8BELFH::8FGFG;4G466BHAG<A:<F<@CBF874F4A <A6E84F<A:AH@58EB96B@C4A<8FCH5?<F;46BECBE4G8
HA4IB<745?8E8FBHE68<ACEBI<7<A:<A9BE@4G<BAG;4G FB6<4? E8FCBAF<5<?<GL E8CBEG 23  HEG;8E <@CEBI8
J<??CEBI<78G;86B@C4AL@4A4:8@8AGJ<G;4E8?8 @8AG<AG;<F4E84<FABGCBFF<5?8J<G;BHG46B@CE8
I4AG 54F<F 9BE @4A4:<A: 4A7 <@CEBI<A: G;8 ?<I<A: ;8AF<I8 4A7 FLFG8@4G<6 BC8E4G<BA 45BI8 4?? <A G;8
4A7 JBE><A: 8AI<EBA@8AG  A G;<F E8:4E7 466BHAG 9B??BJ<A:7<E86G<BAF
<A:< 8 $F;BH?76E84G8G;8<A9BE@4G<BABA<A 
I8FG@8AG<A8AI<EBA@8AG4?CEBG86G<BAG;8@4AA8EB9 
<GFFLFG8@4G<M4G<BAG;8E8FCBAF<5<?<G<8F4A789986GFB9



   !    
 

 AI<EBA@8AG4?@4A4:8@8AGF;BH?7ABG58  
6BAF<78E87 4 A868FF<GL 4A7 ?HKHEL 5HG 4F 4 A887 
J<G;BHGJ;<6;<G<F7<99<6H?GGBFGE4G8:<64??L4A7<AG;8 2 3 XEA=4E $  XEA=4E "    *HFG4<A45?8 8
?BA:EHAC?4AG;878I8?BC@8AG I8?BC@8AG$4A4:8@8AG6BAB@<6F6B?B:L
 66BHAG4AGFF;BH?7;4I8F><??FE8DH<E879BE AI<EBA@8AG4?'EBG86G<BA &C4G<=446H?GLB9
G;878I8?BC@8AG4A7<@C?8@8AG4G<BAB9$*E8?4G +BHE<F@ 4A7 BFC<G4?<GL $4A4:8@8AG <A
<A:GBG;8E86BE7<A:E8CBEG<A:7<F6?BFHE84A7I8E< &C4G<=4,A<I8EF<GLB9)<=8>4 <AEB4G<4A 
9<64G<BA B9 6B@C4AL C8E9BE@4A68 <A6?H7<A: 8AI< 2 3 HEE<GG ) #  *4>4     AI<EBA@8AG4?
EBA@8AG4?C8E9BE@4A68 @4A4:8@8AG 466BHAG<A: 4CC?<64G<BAF 4A7 86B
 *GE8A:G;8AG;86BBC8E4G<BA4A746G<I8E8?4 899<6<8A6L4F8FGH7<8F9EB@!4C4A !BHEA4?B9
G<BAF;<C 58GJ88A 46478@<6 4A7 CEB98FF<BA4? 46 ?84A8E'EB7H6G<BA      
6BHAG4AGF 4A7 @4A4:8EF 8FC86<4??L <A G;8 4E84 B9 23 ;E<FG" # HEE<GG) #  AI<EBA@8AG4?
@HGH4?GE4AF98EB9>ABJ?87:84A7F><??F @4A4:8@8AG 466BHAG<A: G;8 F<:A<9<64A68 B9
 A6E84F8 G;8 AH@58E B9 87H64G<BA4? F8@< 6BAG<A:8AG I4E<45?8F 9BE 47BCG<BA  !BHEA4? B9
A4EF9BE466BHAG4AGF4A76B@C4AL@4A4:8EFGBHA ?84A8E'EB7H6G<BA     
78EFG4A7G;8<@CBEG4A684A7EB?8B9@4A4:8@8AG46 23 0<A) "  4F8*GH7L)8F84E6;8F<:A
6BHAG<A: 4A7 6BFG 466BHAG<A: <A G;8 8AI<EBA@8AG4? 4A7$8G;B7F ,**4:8'H5?<64G<BAF  A6 
@4A4:8@8AGCEB68FF8G6  23 *6;4?G8::8E* HE<GG) '8G8EFBA  
84E<A:<A@<A7G;4G<A*8E5<4G;8E8<FI8EL?<G A AGEB7H6G<BA GB BECBE4G8 AI<EBA@8AG4?
G?8 E8F84E6; BA G;<F GBC<6 G;<F E8F84E6; 64A 58 78 $4A4:8@8AG*GE<I<A:9BE*HFG4<A45<?<GL *;89
F6E<587 4F BA8 B9 G;8 C<BA88E<A: CEB=86GF  +;8 E8 9<8?7E88A?849'H5?<F;<A: 
F84E6;E8FH?GF;4I8F<:A<9<64AGG;8BE8G<64?4A7CE46G< 23 <??4EL)   AI<EBA@8AG4?@4A4:8@8AG
64?<@C?<64G<BAF +;8E8FH?GFB9G;8E8F84E6;<A7<64G8 FLFG8@F 4A7 G;8 F@4??8E 8AG8ECE<F8  !BHEA4? B9
G;8 <@CBEG4A68 B9 <@C?8@8AG<A: G;8 *&   ?84A8E'EB7H6G<BA    
FG4A74E74FJ8??4FG;8946GG;4G6B@C4AL@4A4:8EF 23 #<A>* %4I8;  *G4A74E7<M4G<BA4A7
FG<??7BABG9H??LE86B:A<M8G;8EB?8B9466BHAG<A:<A 7<F6E8G<BA7B8FG;88AI<EBA@8AG4?FG4A74E7 *&
G;<FCEB68FF BAF<78E<A:G;4GG;8E84E84F@4??AH@   ?847 GB C8E9BE@4A68 58A89<GF 
58E B9 FGH7<8F <A G;<F 4E84 <A 78I8?BC<A: 6BHAGE<8F +E4AF46G<BAF BA A:<A88E<A: $4A4:8@8AG 
G;<FE8F84E6;9<??F<AG;8:4CF<A?<G8E4GHE8;<:;?<:;G    
<A:G;858A89<GF4A7<@CBEG4A68B9466BHAG<A:<AG;8 23 478AA8  #  "8AA87L !  $6"8I<8E  
8AI<EBA@8AG4?@4A4:8@8AGCEB68FF #<A><A:8@C<E   A @C<E<64? *GH7L B9 AI<EBA@8AG4?
<64?E8F84E6;E8FH?GFJ<G;8K<FG<A:E8F84E6;E8FH?GF<A J4E8A8FF 4A7 'E46G<68F <A *$F  !BHEA4? B9
G;8JBE?7CB<AGFGB68EG4<A:H<78?<A8FG;4G64A;8?C HF<A8FFG;<6F   
@4A4:8EF <@CEBI8 G;8 CEB68FF B9 8AI<EBA@8AG4? 23 +4E<! ! $B?<A4MBE<A!  8E4F  
@4A4:8@8AG B@C4A<8FF;BH?7F888AI<EBA@8AG4? 8A89<GFB9G;8 *& 4A7 *&  FG4A7
CEBG86G<BA 4F <AI8FG@8AG <A G;8 9HGHE8 584E<A: <A 4E7F  ?<G8E4GHE8 E8I<8J  !BHEA4? B9 A7HFGE<4?
@<A7G;858A89<GFB9<@C?8@8AG<A: *&  FG4A7 A:<A88E<A:4A7$4A4:8@8AG    
4E7G;4GF;BH?7588KCE8FF875BG;DH4?<G4G<I8?L4A7 2 3.<?@F;HEFG+  EBFG )  +;8)B?8
DH4AG<G4G<I8?L &HEFGH7LCEBI<78F4F<:A<9<64AG6BA B966BHAG<A:4A7G;8 466BHAG4AG<A G;8AI<
GE<5HG<BAGBG;86B@C4ALRF5HF<A8FFCB?<6L8@C;4 EBA@8AG4?$4A4:8@8AG*LFG8@ HF<A8FF*GE4G
F<M<A:G;4G<AC8E<B7FB96BAFG4AG6;4A:8G;8FH668FF 8:L4A7G;8AI<EBA@8AG   O  
B946B@C4AL<F?4E:8?L6BA7<G<BA875L<GFE8FCBAF< 2 304>BH$ BEJ8<?8E-  AI<EBA@8A
5<?<GL GB G;8 8AI<EBA@8AG  +;8 E8FH?GF 4?FB <A7<64G8 G4? 66BHAG<A: A FF8AG<4? B@CBA8AG B9
G;4G6B@C4A<8F<A*8E5<44A7F<@<?4E86BAB@<8FA887 HF<A8FF *GE4G8:L  HF<A8FF *GE4G8:L 4A7 G;8
GB ?BB> @BE8 6?BF8?L 4G 6B@C4A<8F <A 78I8?BC87 AI<EBA@8AG   
86BAB@<8F  2 3-4F<?8  $4A$   HEE8AG7<@8AF<BA
<A4??L G;8 4HG;BEF 4E8 4J4E8 B9 G;8 CBFF<5?8 B98AI<EBA@8AG4?@4A4:8@8AG466BHAG<A: 'EB
?<@<G4G<BAFB9G;8E8F84E6;6BA68EA<A:G;8F<M8B9G;8 687<4*B6<4?4A78;4I<BE4?*6<8A68F  O
F4@C?84??G;8F;BEG6B@<A:F4FFB6<4G87J<G;G;864F8  
FGH7L @8G;B7 4A7 G;8 CBG8AG<4? FH5=86G<I<GL B9 G;8 2 3)BA7<A8??< -4FG4:  +;8I4?H8B9
4HG;BEF4A7E8FCBA78AGF<AG;8E84?<M4G<BAB9G;8E8 *&   8AI<EBA@8AG4? @4A4:8@8AG FLF
F84E6;  A9HGHE8E8F84E6;<GJBH?75878F<E45?8GB<A G8@F  HEBC84A $4A4:8@8AG !BHEA4?  
6E84F8 G;8F4@C?8 4A7 <A477<G<BAGB?4E:8 6B@C4  
A<8FGB<A6?H785BG;@87<H@4A7F@4??BA8F8K4@ 2 3'4?8A58E:$ )8<A<6>8. .<GG8! $  
<A8 G;8 E8?4G<BAF;<C 58GJ88A 8AI<EBA@8AG4? 4A7 9< +E8A7F<A%BA9<A4A6<4?)8CBEG<A: ,A<G87%4
A4A6<4? C8E9BE@4A68 4CC?L FG4G<FG<64? G86;A<DH8F G<BAF AI<EBA@8AG 'EB:E4@@8  8E?<A ?B54?
G;4G JBH?7 <A7<64G8 G;8 E8?4G<BAF;<C 58GJ88A G;8 'H5?<6'B?<6L AFG<GHG8 
6B@C4ALF<M84A7G;8<A7HFGELBAG;8BA8;4A74A7 
@4A4:8@8AG466BHAG<A:GBB?FHF87<A8AI<EBA@8AG4? 
@4A4:8@8AGCEB68FFBAG;8BG;8E;4A7 



   !    
 

2 3'BV8:4 U  %8><W   "E4=4ABI<W     2 3$8?AL> *  *EBH98 )  4?4AGBA8 )   


AI<EBA@8AG4?'EBG86G<BA'B?<6L<AG;8)8CH5 FF8FF<A:G;8<@C46GB98AI<EBA@8AG4?@4A4:8
?<6 B9 EB4G<4 49G8E 668FF<BA GB G;8 HEBC84A @8AG FLFG8@F BA 6BECBE4G8 4A7 8AI<EBA@8AG4?
,A<BA+E4AF<G<BA   <A*8E5<4A  C8E9BE@4A68  !BHEA4? B9 &C8E4G<BAF $4A4:8
2 38AA8GG$ !4@8F'  AI<EBA@8AGE8 @8AG    
?4G87 @4A4:8@8AG466BHAG<A:6HEE8AGCE46G<68 2 3$BAG45BA   $8?AL> *  *EBH98 )  4?4A
4A79HGHE8GE8A7F E88A8E$4A4:8@8AG AG8EA4 GBA8 )    *&   4FF8FF<A: <GF C8E
G<BA4?   O  68<I87<@C46GBA6BECBE4G8C8E9BE@4A68 !BHE
2 3HEE<GG ) #  4;A +  *6;4?G8::8E *    A4?B9*HCC?L;4<A$4A4:8@8AG *CE<A:  
+BJ4E7F46B@CE8;8AF<I89E4@8JBE>9BE8AI< 2 3'47@4' 4A8F;# )4=8A7E4A  
EBA@8AG4?@4A4:8@8AG466BHAG<A:O#<A>F58 FGH7LBAG;8 *&  68EG<9<64G<BA4A7BE:4A
GJ88A5HF<A8FF46GBEF4A78AI<EBA@8AG4?@4A <M4G<BA4? C8E9BE@4A68B9 A7<4A @4AH946GHE<A:
4:8@8AG466BHAG<A:GBB?F HFGE4?<4A66BHAG 9<E@F 8A6;@4E><A:A AG8EA4G<BA4?!BHEA4? 
<A:)8I<8J      
2 3HEE<GG) # <5FBA"  66BHAG<A:9BE 2 3'4A! %   6B@C4E4G<I8FGH7LBA@BG<
G;8 8AI<EBA@8AG  66BHAG<A: 9BE G;8 8AI<EBA I4G<BA 9BE 4A7 8KC8E<8A68 J<G; *&   4A7
@8AG HFGE4?<4A66BHAG4AG !H?L   *&   68EG<9<64G<BA 4@BA: 4E 4FG8EA
2 3*G88?8 ' 'BJ8??! )  AI<EBA@8AG4? 6BHAGE<8F  A7HFGE<4?$4A4:8@8AG4A74G4*LF
66BHAG<A:CC?<64G<BAF9BE#B64?HG;BE<G<8F G8@F   
GB(H4AG<9L AG8EA4? 4A7 KG8EA4? BFGFB9? 2 3'8GEBA<     8I8?BC<A: 4 @8G;B7B?B:L
G8EA4G<I8 .4FG8 $4A4:8@8AG *GE4G8:<8F AI< 9BE4A4?LF<FB958A89<GF4A7F;BEG6B@<A:FB9 *&
EBA@8AG4? $4A4:8@8AG 66BHAG<A: %8GJBE>  E8:<FGE4G<BA?8FFBAF9EB@8KC8E<8A68B94
HEBC8 <9G; AAH4? BA98E8A68 #BH68FG8E ?4E:8 @46;<A8EL @4AH946GHE8E  !BHEA4? B9
F;<E8HF<A8FF*6;BB?  ?84A8E'EB7H6G<BA   
2 3AA 14<?4A<* .4;<7%  FGH7L 23'B>F<AF>4 4;?:44E7! >?HA7!  
BA G;8 <@C46G B9 8AI<EBA@8AG4? @4A4:8@8AG @C?8@8AG<A: *&   <A*J878A@BG<I8F
FLFG8@$*68EG<9<64G<BAGBJ4E7F9<E@FRC8E 58A89<GF4A76B@C4E<FBAFJ<G; *&  AG8E
9BE@4A68<A$4?4LF<4 $4A4:8@8AGB9AI<EBA A4G<BA4?!BHEA4?B9(H4?<GL4A7)8?<45<?<GL$4A
@8AG4?(H4?<GL    4:8@8AG    
2 3;<A" 'HA"  46GBE<A9?H8A6<A: *& 23)BA7<A8??<    -4FG4:     '4A4684
  <@C?8@8AG4G<BA <A CE<AG87 6<E6H<G 5B4E7 6B@@BAF8AF8BE=HFG4?458?+;8I4?H8B9 *&
@4AH946GHE<A:<A7HFGEL<ABA:"BA: !BHEA4?  8AI<EBA@8AG4?@4A4:8@8AGFLFG8@F H
B9 AI<EBA@8AG4? '?4AA<A: 4A7 $4A4:8@8AG  EBC84A$4A4:8@8AG!BHEA4?   
    23*6;L?4A78E   $4EG<AHMM<     *&
2 3@<?FFBA* =8?@&   @C?8@8AG4G<BA   O KC8E<8A68F 89986GF 4A7 9HGHE8 6;4?
B9FG4A74E7<F878AI<EBA@8AG4?@4A4:8@8AGFLF ?8A:8F 4 A4G<BA4? FGH7L <A HFGE<4  HF<A8FF
G8@F<A *J87<F;?B64?4HG;BE<G<8F E84FBAF8K *GE4G8:L4A7G;8AI<EBA@8AG    
C86G4G<BAF 4A7 FB@8 BHG6B@8F  AI<EBA@8AG4? 23+4A #    @C?8@8AG<A: *&   <F <G
*6<8A684A7'B?<6L   58A89<6<4?9BE9<E@F<AA8J?L<A7HFGE<4?<M87$4
2 34IEBAF>< 8EE8E '4<I4   *& ?4LF<4!BHEA4?B9?84A8E'EB7H6G<BA  
  68EG<9<64G<BA <A E4M<? @BG<I4G<BAF 4A7   
58A89<GF !BHEA4?B9?84A8E'EB7H6G<BA   230<A   *6;@8<7?8E '    .;L 7B FG4A7
  4E7<M87 *&  8AI<EBA@8AG4?@4A4:8@8AG
2 3<??4EL)  AI<EBA@8AG4? @4A4:8@8AG FLFG8@F ?847 GB ;8G8EB:8A8BHF 8AI<EBA@8AG4?
FLFG8@F 4A7 G;8 F@4??8E 8AG8ECE<F8  !BHEA4? B9 BHG6B@8F  HF<A8FF *GE4G8:L 4A7 G;8 AI<EBA
?84A8E'EB7H6G<BA     @8AG   
2 3H< ;4A 'HA"  FGH7LB9G;8 230<E<7B8   ?4E> !  $4E8GG   BE7BA ) 
8AI<EBA@8AG4? @4A4:8@8AG FLFG8@ <@C?8@8A H<A>8E '    *&   $* FG4A74E7
G4G<BACE46G<68F !BHEA4?B9?84A8E'EB7H6G<BA  E8:<FGE4G<BA 786<F<BAF 4@BA:4A47<4A BE:4A<
   M4G<BAF :E<5HF<A8FF   
2 3#<A>* %4I8;  *G4A74E7<M4G<BA4A7 2318A:* / +4@ - +4@- . 0 8A:1 
7<F6E8G<BA B8F G;8 8AI<EBA@8AG4? FG4A74E7  +BJ4E7F <@C?8@8AG4G<BA B9 *&  
*&  ?847GBC8E9BE@4A6858A89<GF  8AI<EBA@8AG4?@4A4:8@8AGFLFG8@F<AF8?86G87
+E4AF46G<BAFBA A:<A88E<A:$4A4:8@8AG  <A7HFGE<8F<A;<A4 !BHEA4?B9?84A8E'EB7H6
    G<BA   
2 3$8?AL> *  *EBH98 )  4?4AGBA8 )  $BAG4 2 31HGF;<   *B;4?     AI<EBA@8AG4?
5BA  FF8FF<A:G;889986G<I8A8FFB9,* @4A4:8@8AG FLFG8@ 47BCG<BA 5L HFGE4?4F<4A
IB?HAG4EL 8AI<EBA@8AG4? CEB:E4@@8F 4A 8@ BE:4A<F4G<BAF'4EG )84FBAF58A89<GF4A7<@
C<E<64? FGH7L  AG8EA4G<BA4? !BHEA4? B9 'EB7H6 C87<@8AGF +86;ABI4G<BA   
G<BA)8F84E6;    



   !    
 

2 3'BEG8E $      @8E<64F :E88A FGE4G8:L  23$<?=8I<W$  $8G;B7B?B:LB9*6<8AG<9<6


*6<8AG<9<6@8E<64A    .BE>  '4?8 46H?GL B9 ';<?BFBC;L ,A<I8EF<GL
2 3HEE<GG ) #  8EM<:   +478B      B94FG*4E4=8IB <A*8E5<4A 
AI<EBA@8AG4? @4A4:8@8AG 466BHAG<A: 9BE 23B:<W8I<W$<?<><W !4A<W<=8I<W% '8G>BI<W
6?84A8ECEB7H6G<BA+;864F8B94';<?<CC<A8E<68 $    )$ <A GE4AF<G<BA 6BAB@<8F +;8
@<??  !BHEA4? B9 ?84A8E 'EB7H6G<BA     4F8B9*8E5<4 *BHG;4FGHEBC84A!BHEA4?B9
  6BAB@<6F4A7HF<A8FF   
23<5FBA"  $4EG<A   8@BAFGE4G 234:B *    $4A4:8@8AG <A9BE@4G<BA 9BE
<A: -4?H8 G;EBH:; G;8 ,F8 B9 AI<EBA@8AG4? 86B?B:<64??LBE<8AG87786<F<BA@4><A:8464F8
$4A4:8@8AG66BHAG<A: AI<EBA@8AG4?(H4? FGH7L B9 G;8 <AGEB7H6G<BA B9 6B:8A8E4G<BA <A
<GL$4A4:8@8AG    8?8I8A*C4A<F;6B@C4A<8F 66BHAG<A:BEH@ 
23<GM   )4A:4A4G;4A !  4A>F )          
E88A#87:8EF4F8*GH7<8F<ABECBE4G8AI< 23<F8A;4E7G" $ E485A8E$   +;8
EBA@8AG4?66BHAG<A: .4F;<A:GBA.BE?7 BEL5H<?7<A:9EB@64F8F&CCBEGHA<G<8F4A76;4?
)8FBHE68F AFG<GHG8  ?8A:8F +;86478@LB9$4A4:8@8AG!BHEA4? 
23"BA4E* B;8A$   B8FG;8@4E>8G     
I4?H8 8AI<EBA@8AG4? C8E9BE@4A68 )8I<8J B9 2 3<F8A;4E7G"   8GG8E*GBE<8F4A78GG8E
6BAB@<6F4A7*G4G<FG<6F    O   BAFGEH6GF +;8 4F8 9BE )<:BE 4A7 B@C4E4
23*64IBA8 $  ;4??8A:8F<A<AG8EA4?8A G<I8 #B:<6  6478@L B9 $4A4:8@8AG )8I<8J 
I<EBA@8AG4? @4A4:8@8AG E8CBEG<A: <A E:8A    
G<A4  !BHEA4? B9 ?84A8E 'EB7H6G<BA    2 3BEI4G;BI4   +;8<@C46GB9 8AI<EBA
  @8AG4? C8E9BE@4A68 BA 9<E@ C8E9BE@4A68
234EGB?B@8B$ 8AA8GG$ BH@4! ! 8L *;BEGG8E@ 6BFGF 4A7 ?BA:G8E@ 58A89<GF 6B
7>4@C '  .B?G8EF +    AI<EBA@8AG4? ?B:<64?6BAB@<6F   
@4A4:8@8AG 466BHAG<A: <A HEBC8 6HEE8AG 2 3"<A:    #8ABK $ !    B8F <G E84??L
CE46G<68 4A7 9HGHE8 CBG8AG<4?  HEBC84A 6 C4LGB58:E88AA8@C<E<64?FGH7LB99<E@8A
6BHAG<A:)8I<8J     I<EBA@8AG4?4A79<A4A6<4?C8E9BE@4A68 !BHEA4?
23$4F4A8G#?B7E4 $ !    AI<EBA@8AG4? B9 A7HFGE<4?6B?B:L     
@4A4:8@8AG466BHAG<A:64F8FGH7LE8F84E6; 23?+HJ4<=E< *  ;E<FG8AF8A +   H:;8F 
BA<AABI4G<I8FGE4G8:L !BHEA4?B9HF<A8FFG; "   +;8E8?4G<BAF4@BA:8AI<EBA@8AG4?
<6F    7<F6?BFHE8 8AI<EBA@8AG4? C8E9BE@4A68 4A7
238EE8<E4   $BH?4A:   8A7EB     86BAB@<6 C8E9BE@4A68  F<@H?G4A8BHF 8DH4
AI<EBA@8AG4?@4A4:8@8AG466BHAG<A:4A7<A G<BAF4CCEB46; 66BHAG<A:&E:4A<M4G<BAF4A7
ABI4G<BA 4A8KC?BE4GBEL4A4?LF<F 66BHAG<A: *B6<8GL   
H7<G<A: 4A7 66BHAG45<?<GL !BHEA4?   23BF4E$  4E5BA9BBGCE<AG<A74G468A
 O  G8E  64F8 FGH7L  E8F8A  AI<EBA  H??  
2 3AI<EBA@8AG4? 'EBG86G<BA :8A6L   +;8    
#84A 4A7 E88A *HCC?L ;4<A  'E46G<64? 23 I4ABI<WZH><W $    'EB@BG<A: BECB
H<78 9BE $4G8E<4?F $4A4:8EF 4A7 *HCC?L E4G8*B6<4?)8FCBAF<5<?<GL<A*8E5<4 *B6<B?B:L 
;4<A$4A4:8EFGB)87H68BFGF4A7 @CEBI8    <A*8E5<4A 
AI<EBA@8AG4?'8E9BE@4A68 ,A<G87*G4G8FA 
I<EBA@8AG4?'EBG86G<BA:8A6L&99<68B9CB??H 
G<BA 'E8I8AG<BA 4A7 +BK<6F .4F;<A:GBA   
;GGC

JJJ 8C4 :BI  


2 3*G8I4ABI<W +  '8GEBI<W)4AY8?BI<W $  
)47H><W *    AI<EBA@8AG4? BFG $4A )')-8)(     
4:8@8AG<A&E78EGB @CEBI8G;8AI<EBA@8AG4? '')36)(    
'8E9BE@4A68B9B@C4A<8F66BHAG<A:  
  <A*8E5<4A  
2 3$8EE<4@ *     (H4?<G4G<I8 E8F84E6;   "!
:H<78GB78F<:A4A7<@C?8@8AG4G<BA E787 *4A 
E4A6<F6B !BFF8L4FF  8&1&)(8)(
23$8L8E   64F8<A64F8FGH7L@8G; 46H?GLB96BAB@<6F
B7B?B:L <8?7$8G;B7F     ,A<I8EF<GLB9%BI<*47
23*G4>8 )     +;8 4EG B9 64F8 FGH7L E8
*8:87<AF><CHG 
F84E6; +;BHF4A7&4>F *4:8  *H5BG<64  O*8E5<4
234KG8E '  !46> *    (H4?<G4G<I8 4F8

*GH7L $8G;B7B?B:L *GH7L 8F<:A 4A7 @C?8 8@4<?<I4A489 HAF 46 EF
@8AG4G<BA9BE%BI<68)8F84E6;8EF +;8(H4?<G4
G<I8)8CBEG   



View publication stats

You might also like