Professional Documents
Culture Documents
aspects of the phenomenon. [10] These definitions also entail different approaches and understandings
of language, and they also inform different and often incompatible schools of linguistic theory.
[11]
Debates about the nature and origin of language go back to the ancient world. Greek philosophers
such as Gorgias and Plato debated the relation between words, concepts and reality. Gorgias
argued that language could represent neither the objective experience nor human experience, and
that communication and truth were therefore impossible. Plato maintained that communication is
possible because language represents ideas and concepts that exist independently of, and prior to,
language.[12]
During the Enlightenment and its debates about human origins, it became fashionable to speculate
about the origin of language. Thinkers such as Rousseau and Herder argued that language had
originated in the instinctive expression of emotions, and that it was originally closer to music and
poetry than to the logical expression of rational thought. Rationalist philosophers such
as Kant and Descartes held the opposite view. Around the turn of the 20th century, thinkers began to
wonder about the role of language in shaping our experiences of the world – asking whether
language simply reflects the objective structure of the world, or whether it creates concepts that it in
turn impose on our experience of the objective world. This led to the question of whether
philosophical problems are really firstly linguistic problems. The resurgence of the view that
language plays a significant role in the creation and circulation of concepts, and that the study of
philosophy is essentially the study of language, is associated with what has been called the linguistic
turn and philosophers such as Wittgenstein in 20th-century philosophy. These debates about
language in relation to meaning and reference, cognition and consciousness remain active today. [13]