Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/314865076
The Effect of Core Stability Exercise Program on the Balance of Patients with
Multiple Sclerosis
CITATIONS READS
8 1,309
3 authors, including:
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
The Effect of Combined Core Stability and Neuromuscular Training on Postural Control in Students with Congenital Hearing Loss View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Ali Asghar Norasteh on 07 July 2018.
*Corresponding author:
MSc Student, Faculty of Physical Copyright © [2016] Caspian Journal of Neurological Sciences. All rights reserved.
Education, University of Guilan,
Rasht, Iran Please cite this paper as:
Farid R, Norasteh AA, Hatamian H. The Effect of Core Stability Exercise Program on the
Email: Raziyeh.farid@yahoo.com
Balance of Patients with Multiple Sclerosis. Caspian J Neurol Sci 2016; 2(4):9-17.
Introduction
M
ultiple sclerosis (MS) is one of the cord, and optic nerves (1). There are 250000-
most common neurological 350000 people with MS in America,
diseases that mainly affects young increasing by about 200 new cases diagnosed
adults and more commonly women. It is a every week (2). Based on the statistics from
chronic inflammatory disease characterized Iran Multiple Sclerosis Society, there are
by demyelinating lesions in the brain, spinal 30000 patients with MS in Iran till now (3).
9
Caspian J Neurol Sci 2016 March; 2(4): 9-17
The term of multiple sclerosis refers to two interested in exercises which strengthen and
the features of the disease: the multiple areas stabilize the core area of the body to improve
affected in the brain and spinal cord known as the patients' balance. This area includes waist-
plaques or sclerotic areas causing multiple hips-thighs and muscles surrounding them,
neurological symptoms over time. and its stability is highly important because
Furthermore, the clinical course can vary the anatomic center of gravity is located in
from totally benign to progressive and this area, where movements are initiated (12).
debilitating (4). MS is a young people's Core stability is recognized as motor control
disease, mostly diagnosed in people of 20 to and muscle capacity in the core area for
40 years old (4), although it may also be maintaining stability in different postures and
found in younger or older people. The mean against external forces (13). In fact, stability
age at diagnosis is 30 years, and women are of the core area is affected by three closely
affected two to three times more than men (5, interactive and related systems including
6). passive systems of bones and ligaments and
Some common symptoms of MS include active systems of muscles and also the
reduced balancing and walking ability, nervous system, and any impairment in one
together with muscle weakness and fatigue. system is compensated by the others (13).
These symptoms affect not only people's Previous studies have demonstrated the role
general health, but also their ability to of core stability in improving athletic
perform daily motor activities (7). Balancing performance and preventing damage. Clark et
ability is crucial to independence in daily al. argue that core stability prevents wrong
activities. Impaired postural control leads to patterns of movement by maintaining postural
loss of stability, which can profoundly affect alignment and correct body position, and thus
daily lives of people with central nervous improve athletic performance (14). Leetun et
system diseases. Loss of stability can lead to al. considers core instability as an important
loss of functional independence, spreading factor associated with lower extremities
disability and also greater risk of falls (8). In injuries (15). The results obtained by Cosio -
these people, loss of balance can be caused by Lima et al. showed that 5 weeks of core
impairment in the brain or cerebellum and stability exercises on Swiss ball and on the
also movement pathways. Other impairments floor have similar effects in improving
and lack of sufficient movement can also balance (16). In a study of the effect of core
affect these people secondarily due to loss of exercises on balance, Eric et al. reported its
strength and fluctuating balancing ability (9). significant effect on balance in healthy people
Balance is an inseparable part of all daily after 4 weeks of trunk muscles strengthening
activities and a key part of sports activities program (17). The results obtained by White
(10); it is a complex motor skill that defines et al. showed that endurance exercise
postural dynamics of the body in avoiding program can improve walking and power in
falls (11). A variety of exercises are used to lower extremities in MS patients (7). Kileff
improve balance, including proprioception and Ashburn showed that aerobic exercises
exercises and use of balancing board. In can enhance walking ability, improve
recent years, some investigators in physical balance, and reduce reported fatigue and
medicine and rehabilitation have become disability by the individual in MS patients
10
Core Stability Exercises in Multiple Sclerosis Farid R. et al.
(18). In a comprehensive study, Romberg et course) and minimum of two months should
al. showed long term effect of exercise- have passed since their last relapse (if they
therapy on functional impairments and health- had). If a relapse occurred in the course of
related quality of life in MS patients (19). In study the patient would excluded from the
contrast, DeBolt & McCubbin results did not study. They should have no history of
confirm the effect of endurance (aerobic) cardiovascular disease, epilepsy, metabolic
exercises on balance and movement in MS diseases, psychological diseases, visual
patients (20). Kasser et al. studied the effect impairments and orthopedic diseases and the
of 12 weeks balancing exercises on stability other comorbidities making participation in
control in 4 patients with MS, using Pro the exercise harmful. They should have no
Balance Master for both exercise and participation in regular exercise activities in
assessment of patients, and found 10% to the last two months. A questionnaire and
64% improvement in stability range test in medical records were used to find disease
participating MS patients after the history and patients' problems. Finally 15
intervention (21). female patients were selected according to
All previous studies agree that MS patients convenient sampling and considering
show improvement after a graded exercise exclusion and inclusion criteria.
program, and that as an important part of
rehabilitation, exercise therapy can leave Study Phases
positive effects on these patients. Some Patients were invited to participate in a
previous studies have shown that core meeting where necessary explanations were
stability exercises improve balance in various provided. Then, based on inclusion and
people; yet very few studies have been exclusion criteria eligible patients were
conducted on the effect of core stability selected and completed written consent forms
exercises on MS patients. Hence, the present for participation in 8 weeks of core stability
study aimed to investigate the effect of these exercise program (3 sessions per week) in
programs on the balance in MS patients. groups in the gym from 9 am to 10 am in
summer 2015.
Materials and Methods Based on the Jeffreys protocol (2002),
Study design and participant exercise sessions lasted 45 minutes to 50
minutes each. Prior to exercise program,
This study was a quasi-experimental participants underwent static and dynamic
pretest-posttest investigation (with no control balance tests, which were repeated and results
group). The study population consisted of all were recorded after completion of the 8
20-45 year-old patients with multiple weeks exercise program.
sclerosis confirmed disease by a neurologist
and disability score according to EDSS less Measurement Cases and Methods
than 4.5 who have presented to the Multiple Stork balance test:
Sclerosis Society of Guilan Province. They This was performed for measurement of
should have ability to regularly take part in static balance with open eyes, on dominant
exercise sessions (maximum allowable and non-dominant feet. Training was
absence was 5 sessions in each exercise provided before the test on how to assume the
11
Caspian J Neurol Sci 2016 March; 2(4): 9-17
test position by placing hands on the waist as possible with the other leg in the direction
and sole of the non-dominant foot on the the examiner choose, and return to their initial
inside of the supporting leg. The subject position. To eliminate the effect of learning,
maintains this position on the ball of the foot each participant practiced each direction 6
for as long as possible. The test ends if the times with 15 Seconds rest. After 5 minutes
heel of the dominant foot touches the floor, rest, the participant began the test in a
hands come off the waist, or non-dominant direction randomly chosen by the examiner,
foot loses contact with the knee of supporting and the distance from the contact point of the
leg. During the test, the subject stares at a foot to the center of the star was measured by
sign 4 meters away in front of his face. Each the examiner in centimeters. Each participant
participant attempted the test twice with 15 repeated the test twice, and the best distance
second rest (to eliminate the effect of learning reached was divided by the length of the leg
and warming up), and the best time was and multiplied by 100 to find the reach
recorded as their score. The standing time on distance for the length of the leg. Using the
one foot was measured and recorded in reaching foot as support, movement of the
milliseconds from assuming the position and other foot in the center of star or loss of
simultaneously raising the heel of the balance meant elimination of the test, and
dominant foot from the floor until the position participant was asked to repeat the test.
was lost using a stopwatch. The best time Before the test, participant's supporting leg
recorded in the two attempts was taken as was determined. If the supporting leg was on
participant's score. The test was repeated for the right side, the test was performed
the non-dominant foot as for the supporting counterclockwise, otherwise clockwise (23).
one. Johnson & Nelson (1986) reported
reliability of the test 0.87 (22). Core stability exercise program:
The protocol was performed for the trial
Star balance test: group in 3 thirty-minute sessions per week
The dynamic balance was assessed using (every other day), over 8 weeks. The protocol
Y Balance Test (YBT), which is the modified included specific spinal stabilization
version of Star Excursion Balance Test exercises, lumbar-pelvic proprioception
(SEBT). In this test, 3 directions (anterior, retraining, and abdominal maneuvers (holding
internal posterior and external posterior) are the abdomen in) and multifidus muscle
drawn at 135 degrees from each other. Since contraction, followed by maintaining
star balance test is significantly related to the stabilization maneuver using dynamic
length of the leg, for normalizing the data, the stability achieved in different positions
actual length was measured from the anterior (supine, prone, and squatting) and addition of
superior iliac spine (ASIS) to inner ankle in dynamic elements (limb movement, use of
the supine position (23). The necessary Swiss ball) in later stages. These exercises
explanations about the test were provided by were based on core stability exercises
the examiner, and to learn how to perform the proposed by Jeffreys, and included three
test, each participant practiced the test 6 levels. Level 1 involved static contractions in
times. A participant should stand in the center a fixed position, which progressed with slow
of the star on one leg, and try to reach as far movement in an unstable setting. Level 2
12
Core Stability Exercises in Multiple Sclerosis Farid R. et al.
Table 1: Comparison the results of the pretest and posttest static balance of studied MS patient
Variable Mean± SD* p-value t-value Degree of freedom
Static balance in supporting leg Pretest 3.56 ±1.81 0.0001 -5.04 14
Posttest 11.17±6.36
Static balance in non-supporting leg Pretest 3.67±1.89 0.0001 -12.12 14
Posttest 9.42±2.94
*Standard deviation
13
Caspian J Neurol Sci 2016 March; 2(4): 9-17
14
Core Stability Exercises in Multiple Sclerosis Farid R. et al.
patients and confirmed the positive effect of awareness of the body which leads to
exercise on walking ability in patients (37). improved balance (42).
The effect of stabilization exercises on
balance can be explained by the fact that Conclusion
contraction of core muscles before movement
Core stability exercise program showed a
of the limb is a positional feed forward
positive and significant effect on static and
response by the central nervous system to
dynamic balance in patients with multiple
avoid positional impairments, and achieve
sclerosis. It appears that these exercises can
dynamic balance. Hence, exercise program
be used as a non-invasive therapy along with
probably improves anticipation of action, and
medication in MS patients. Given study
thus reduces the misplacement and volatility
limitations, further studies are required to
of the center of gravity (38). According to
confirm these results.
previous studies, the weakness of the core
area of the body causes instability in
Acknowledgements
performing lower limb movements (39).
Strengthening core muscles due to core We thank University of Guilan and the
stability exercises improves neuromuscular Multiple Sclerosis Society of Guilan for
system, reduces displacement of center of supporting this study, and also all
gravity from supporting surface, and reduces participating patients for their cooperation.
its fluctuations, resulting in improved
positional control, which will strengthen Conflict of Interest
lower limbs muscles, causing better muscle The authors have no conflict of interest.
stability. Therefore participants can better
neutralize the generated torques during a References
reach action and thus achieve greater distance
1. Bizzoco E, Lolli F, Repice AM, Hakiki B,
(23). Given the huge stress exerted on the Falcini M, Barilaro A, et al. Prevalence of
abdominal and lumber muscles by core Neuromyelitis Optica Spectrum Disorder and
stability exercise program, improved Phenotype Distribution. J Neurol 2009;
endurance and coordination in these muscles 256(11): 1891-8.
resulted in better balance in participants, 2. Bainbridge JL, Corboy JR, Gidal BE.
Multiple Sclerosis. In: DiPiro JT, Talbert RL,
because these muscles have the greatest role Yee GC, et al. (eds.). Pharmacotherapy: A
in maintaining balance and orientation of Pathophysiological Approach. 5th ed. New
postural muscles in this area (40). In their York, NY: McGraw-Hill; 2002: 1019-30
study, Marshall and Murphy argued that 3. Lotfi J. Disability in MS and Comprehensive
Swiss ball exercises involve greater number Guide to Living with Multiple Sclerosis. MS
message 2007; 1(1): 7-12. [Text in Persian]
of pelvic-lumber muscles (41). In this study, 4. Ryan M, Piascik P. Providing Pharmaceutical
the unsteady surface of the Swiss ball was Care to the Multiple Sclerosis Patient. J Am
used in exercises, which forced patients to Pharm Assoc 2002; 42(5):753-66.
maintain their balance more than before, 5. Sluder JAD, Newhouse P, Fain D. Pediatric
which in turn led to improved balance. and Adolescent Multiple Sclerosis. Adolesc
Med 2002; 13(3):461-5.
Johnson et al. suggested that core stability
exercises can increase proprioceptive
15
Caspian J Neurol Sci 2016 March; 2(4): 9-17
6. Marrie RA. Enviromental Risk Factors in 18. Kileff J, Ashburn A. A Pilot Study of the
Multiple Sclerosis Aetiology. Lancet Neurol Effect of Aerobic Exercise on People with
2004; 3(12):709-18. Moderate Disability Multiple Sclerosis. Clin
7. White LJ, McCoy SC, Castellano V, Gutierrez Rehabil 2005; 19(2):165-9.
G, Stevens JE, Walter GA, et al. Resistance 19. Romberg A, Virtanen A, Ruutiainen J, Aunola
Training Improves Strength and Functional S, Karppi SL, Vaara M, et al. Effect of a 6-
Capacity in Persons with Multiple Sclerosis. Months Exercise Program on Patient with
Mult Scler 2004; 10(6): 668-74. Multiple Sclerosis: a Randomized Study.
8. Shamway-Cook A, Woollacoatt MH. Motor Neurology 2004; 63(11):2034-8.
Control Theory and Paractical Application. 3 rd 20. DeBolt LS, McCubbin JA. The Effects of
ed. Philadelphia: Lippincott Williams & Home-Based Resistance Exercise on Balance,
Wilkins; 2001:167-261. Power, and Mobility in Adults with Multiple
9. Heydari-Nik H, Noshir A, Rafei MM. Sport Sclerosis. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 2004;
and Disabeld .1st ed. Tehran: Sport 85(2): 290-7.
Publishing; 2013:82-4. [Text in Persian] 21. Kasser SL, Rose DJ, Clark S. Balance
10. Punakallio A. Balance Abilities of Workers in Training for Adults with Multiple Sclerosis:
Physically Demanding Jobs: With Special Multiple Case Studies. JNPT 1999; 23(1):5-
Reference to Firefighters of Different Ages. J 12.
Sports Sci Med 2005; 4 (Suppl 8):1-47. 22. Reimam MP, Manske RC. Functional Testing
11. Woollacott MH, Shumway-Cook A. Changes in Human Performance. Champaign, IL:
in Posture Control across the Life Span—a Human Kinetics Publishers; 2009.
Systems Approach. Phys Ther 1990; 70 23. Gribble P, Hertel J. Consideration for
(12):799-807. Normalizing Measures of Star Excursion
12. Hodges PW, Richardson CA. Contraction of Balance Test, Measures Phy Edu Exer Sci
the Abdominal Muscles Associated with 2003; 7:89-100.
Movement of the Lower Limb. Phys Ther 24. Jeffreys I. Developing a Progressive Core
1997; 77(2):132-42. Stability Program. Strength Cond J 2002;
13. Panjabi M, Abumi K, Duranceau J, Oxland T. 24(5):65-73.
Spinal Stability and Intersegmental Muscle 25. Dursine JL, Painter P, Franklin BA, Morgan
Forces: A Biomechanical Model. Spine 1989; D, Pitetti KH, Roberts SO. Physical Activity
14(2):194-200. for the Chronically Ill and Disabled. Sports
14. Clark MA, Fater D, Reuteman P. Core Med 2000; 30(3):207-19.
(Trunk) Stabilization and Its Importance for 26. Romberg A, Virtanen A, Ruutiainen J. Long–
Closed Kinetic Chain Rehabilitation. J sport Term Exercise Improves Functional
rehabilitation 2000; 13:54-66. Impairment but Not Quality of Life in
15. Leetun DT, Ireland ML, Willson JD, Multiple Sclerosis. J Neurol 2005;
Ballantyne BT Davis, IM. Core Stability 252(7):839-45.
Measures as Risk Factors for Lower 27. Cattaneo D, Jonsdottir J, Zocchi M, Regola A.
Extremity Injury in Athletes. Med Sci Sports Effects of Balance Exercises on People with
Exerc 2004; 36(6):926-34. Multiple Sclerosis: a Pilot Study. Clin Rehabil
16. Cosio-Lima LM, Reynolds KL, Winter C, 2007; 21(9):771-81.
Paolone V, Jones MT. Effects of Physioball 28. Zalewski K. Exploring Barriers to Remaining
and Conventional Floor Exercises on Early Physically Active: a Case Report of a Person
Phase Adaptations in Back and Abdominal with Multiple Sclerosis. J Neural Phys Ther
Core Stability and Balance in Women. J 2007; 31(1):40-5.
Strength Cond Res 2003; 17(4):721-5. 29. Atashzadh SF, Shiri H, Sanii M. Effect of
17. Gayle GW, Pohlman RL. Comparative Study Exercise on the Ability to Perform Daily
of the Dynamic, Static, and Rotary Balance of Living Activities of Women with Multiple
Deaf and Hearing Children. Percep Mot Skills Sclerosis Reffered to Multiple Sclerosis
1990; 70(3): 883-8. Society of Iran in the Year of 1380-81. J
Rafsanjan Med Sci 2004; 2:30-40.
16
Core Stability Exercises in Multiple Sclerosis Farid R. et al.
30. Bolouchi R, Ghyasi A, Naderi A, Sedoghi H. 36. Freeman JA, Gear M, Pauli A, Cowan P,
The Effect of Cawthorne and Cooksey Finnigan C. The Effect of Core Stability
Exercises on the Quality of Life, Balance and Training on Balance and Mobility in
Fatigue in Patient with Multiple Sclerosis. Ambulant Individuals with Multiple Sclerosis:
Scientific Journal of Ilam University of a Multi-Center Series of Single Case Studies.
Medical Sciences 2013; 21(7):43-53. [Text in Mult Scler 2010; 16(11):1377-84.
Persian] 37. Snook EM, Molt RW. Effect of Exercise
31. Cantalloube S, Monteil I, Lamotte D, Mailhan Training on Walking Mobility in Multiple
L, Thoumie P. Strength, Postural and Gait Sclerosis: a Metaanalysis. Neurorehabil
Changes Following Rehabilitation in Multiple Neural Repair 2009; 23(2):108-16.
Sclerosis: a Preliminary Study. Rehabil J 38. Panjabi MM. The Stabilizing System of the
2006; 49(4):143-9. Spine. Part I: Function, Dysfunction,
32. Giesser B, Beres-Jones J, Budovitch A, Adaptation and Enhancement. J Spinal Disord
Herlihy H, Harkema S. Locomotor Training 1992; 5:383-9.
Using Body Weight Support on a Treadmill 39. Willson JD, Dougherty CP, Ireland ML,
Improves Mobility in Persons with Multiple Davis IM. Core Stability and Its Relationship
Sclerosis. Rehabil J 2007; 13(2):224-31. to Lower Extremity Function and Injury. J
33. Pouretezad M, Babadi M, Negahban Soiuki Am Acad of Orthop Surg 2005; 13(5):316-25.
H, Majdi Nasab N. A Comparison of Two 40. Sandrey MA, Mitzel JG. Improvement in
Exercise Therapy Programs on Functional Dynamic Balance and Core Endurance after a
Balance in People with Multiple Sclerosis.
6-Week Core-Stability-Training Program in
Jundishapur J Health Res 2012; 3:283-91.
High School Track and Field Athletes. J Sport
34. Moradi M, Sahraeian MA, Kordi MR. The
Rehabil 2013; 22(4):264-71.
Effect of 8 Weeks of Resistance Training on
41. Marshall PW, Murphy BA. Core Stability
Functional Mobility of Men with Multiple
Exercises on and off a Swiss Ball. Arch Phys
Sclerosis. J Sport Med Rev 2012; 11:125-36.
Med Rehabil 2005; 86(2):242-9.
35. Marandi M, Shayegan Nejad V, Shanazari Z,
42. Johnson EG, Larsen A, Ozawa H, Wilson CA,
Zolaktaf V. Acomparison of 12 Weeks of
Kennedy KL. The Effects of Pilates-Based
Pilates and Aquatic Training on the Dynamic
Exercise on Dynamic Balance in Healthy
Balance of Women with Multiple Sclerosis.
Adults. J Bodyw Mov Ther 2007; 11(3):238-
Int J Med 2013; 4(1):110-17.
42.
17