You are on page 1of 7

APPENDIX 24

DESIGN RULES FOR CLAMP CONNECTIONS

24-1 SCOPE those shown in Figs. 24-1 and 24-2, and for clamps
consisting of more than two circumferential segments.
(a) The rules in this Appendix apply specifically to
The design formulas used herein may be modified when
the design of clamp connections for pressure vessels
designing clamp connections of shape differing from
and vessel parts and shall be used in conjunction with
those shown in Figs. 24-1 and 24-2, provided that the
the applicable requirements in Subsections A, B, and
basis for the modifications is in accordance with U-
C of this Division. These rules shall not be used
2(g). However, the requirements of (f) below shall be
for the determination of thickness of supported or
complied with for all clamp connections.
unsupported tubesheets integral with a hub nor for the
(f) Clamps designed to the rules of this Appendix
determination of thickness of covers. These rules provide
shall be provided with a bolt retainer. The retainer shall
only for hydrostatic end loads, assembly, and gasket
be designed to hold the clamps together independently in
seating.
case of failure of the primary bolting [see UG-35(b)].
(b) The design of a clamp connection involves the Multiple bolting (two or more bolts per lug) is an
selection of the gasket, bolting, hub, and clamp geome- acceptable alternative for meeting this requirement.
try. Bolting shall be selected to satisfy the requirements Clamp-hub friction shall not be considered as a retainer
of 24-4. Connection dimensions shall be such that the method.
stresses in the clamp and the hub, calculated in accord-
ance with 24-6 and 24-7, do not exceed the allowable
stresses specified in Table 24-8. All calculations shall 24-2 MATERIALS
be made on dimensions in the corroded condition.
Calculations for assembly, gasket seating, and operating (a) Materials used in the construction of clamp con-
conditions are required. nections shall comply with the requirements given in
(c) It is recommended that either a pressure energized UG-5 through UG-14.
and /or low seating load gasket be used to compensate (b) Hubs made from ferritic steel and designed in
for possible nonuniformity in the gasket seating force accordance with the rules herein shall be given a
distribution. Hub faces shall be designed such as to normalizing or full-annealing heat treatment when the
have metal-to-metal contact outside the gasket seal thickness of the hub neck section exceeds 3 in. (76 mm).
diameter. This may be provided by recessing the hub (c) Cast steel hubs and clamps shall be examined
faces or by use of a metal spacer (see Fig. 24-1). The and repaired in accordance with Appendix 7.
contact area shall be sufficient to prevent yielding of (d) Hubs and clamps shall not be machined from
either the hub face or spacer under both operating and plate.
assembly loads. (e) Bolts and studs shall comply with UG-12. Mini-
(d) It is recognized that there are clamp designs mum diameter shall be 1⁄2 in. (13 mm). Nuts and
which utilize no wedging action during assembly since washers shall comply with UG-13.
clamping surfaces are parallel to the hub faces. Such
designs are acceptable and shall satisfy the bolting and
corresponding clamp and hub requirements of a clamp 24-3 NOTATION
connection designed for a total included clamping angle The notation below is used in the formulas for the
of 10 deg. design of clamp-type connections (see also Figs. 24-1
(e) The design method used herein to calculate and 24-2).
stresses, loads, and moments may also be used in Ap outside diameter of hub, in. (mm)
designing clamp connections of shapes differing from AbLp total cross sectional area of the bolts per clamp

460

COPYRIGHT American Society of Mechanical Engineers


Licensed by Information Handling Services
APPENDIX 24 — MANDATORY Fig. 24-1

1/ in. (6 mm) min. radius Hub 1/ in. (6 mm) min. radius


4 4

h T h T

g2 g2
r A r A

hn hn
g1 g1
go go

N N
B B

(a) (b)

hn T hn T

We HG We hG
A A
C C HG
hD hT hD hT
g1 = go Hp or Hm g1 = go Hp or Hm
HD HD
HT HT
G G
N
B N B
(c) (d)

Clamp
B [see Note (1)] B [see Note (1)]
Bc A

Neutral axis
La Neutral axis

Clamp lug W/2 W /2


A
X
Cg We Cw
Ci /2 C
Lh r

m
eb c Ct
ci
Section A–A
(e) (f)

NOTE:
(1) See Fig. 24-2 for Section B-B

FIG. 24-1 TYPICAL HUB AND CLAMP

461

COPYRIGHT American Society of Mechanical Engineers


Licensed by Information Handling Services
24-3 2001 SECTION VIII — DIVISION 1 24-3

FIG. 24-2 TYPICAL CLAMP LUG CONFIGURATIONS

lug using the smaller of the root diameter of p W m1 /2Sb


the thread or least diameter of unthreaded por- Am2p total cross-sectional area of bolts per clamp lug
tion, sq in. (mm2). Cross-sectional area of bolt at root of thread or section of least diameter
retainer shall not be included in calculation of under stress, required for gasket seating, sq in.
this area. When multiple bolting is used in lieu (mm2)
of bolt retainer, the total cross sectional area of p W m2 /2Sa
all the bolts per clamp lug shall be used. Am3p total cross-sectional area of bolts per clamp lug
Acp total effective clamp cross-sectional area, sq in. at root of thread or section of least diameter
(mm2) under stress, required for assembly conditions,
p A1+A2+A3 sq in. (mm2)
A1p partial clamp area, sq in. (mm2) p W m3 /2Sa
p (Cw−2Ct )Ct AmLp total required cross-sectional area of bolts per
A2p partial clamp area, sq in. (mm2) clamp lug taken as the greater of Am1, Am2, or
p 1.571Ct2 Am3, sq in. (mm2)
A3p partial clamp area, sq in. (mm2) bp effective gasket or joint-contact-surface seating
p (Cw−Cg )lc width, in. (mm) (see Table 2-5.2)
Am1p total cross-sectional area of bolts per clamp lug bop basic gasket or joint-contact-surface seating
at root of thread or section of least diameter width, in. (mm) (see Table 2-5.2)
under stress, required for the operating condi- Bp inside diameter of hub, in. (mm)
tions, sq in. (mm2) Bcp radial distance from connection center line to

462

COPYRIGHT American Society of Mechanical Engineers


Licensed by Information Handling Services
24-3 APPENDIX 24 — MANDATORY 24-3

center of bolts, in. (mm) [see Fig. 24-1 sketch p [C−(B + G ) / 2] /2


(e)] h2p average thickness of hub shoulder, in. (mm)
Cp diameter of effective clamp-hub reaction circle, p T − (g2 tan ␾) /2
in. (mm) hp axial distance from the hub face to the hub
p (A + Ci) /2 shoulder ring centroid, in. (mm)
Cip inside diameter of clamp, in. (mm)
Cgp effective clamp gap determined at diameter C, p T 2g1 + h22g2
in. (mm) 2(Tg1 + h2g2)
Ctp effective clamp thickness (Ct shall be equal to
or greater than r), in. (mm) Hp total hydrostatic end force, lb (kN)
Cwp clamp width, in. (mm) p 0.785 G 2P
ebp radial distance from center of the bolts to the HDp hydrostatic end force on bore area, lb (kN)
centroid of the clamp cross section, in. (mm) p 0.785 B2P
p Bc − (Ci /2) − lc − X HGp difference between total effective axial clamp-
fp hub stress correction factor from Fig. 2-7.6. ing preload and the sum of total hydrostatic end
(This is the ratio of the stress in the small end force and total joint contact surface compres-
of the hub to the stress in the large end.) (For sion, lb (kN)
values below limit of the figure, use f p 1.0.) p [1.571 W /tan (␾ + ␮)] − (H + H p )
gop thickness of hub neck at small end, in. (mm) Hmp total axial gasket seating requirements for
g1p thickness of hub neck at intersection with hub makeup, lb (kN) (3.14bGy or the axial seating
shoulder, in. (mm) load for self-energizing gaskets, if significant)
g2p height of hub shoulder, in. (mm) (g2 shall not Hpp total joint contact surface compression load, lb
be larger than T.) (kN)
gp radial distance from the hub inside diameter B p 2b × 3.14GmP
to the hub shoulder ring centroid, in. (mm) (For self-energized gaskets, use Hpp0 or actual
retaining load if significant.)
p Tg12 + h2g2 (2g1 + g2) HTp difference between total hydrostatic end force
2(Tg1 + h2g2) and hydrostatic end force on bore area, lb (kN)
p H−HD
Gp diameter at location of gasket load reaction. Icp moment of inertia of clamp relative to neutral
Except as noted in Fig. 24-1, G is defined as axis of entire section, in.4 (mm4)
follows (see Table 2-5.2):

冢 冣
(a) when bo ≤1⁄4 in. (6 mm), G p mean diame- p A1 A2 Al2
+ Ct2 + 3 c − AcX2
ter of gasket or joint contact face, in. (mm); 3 4 3
(b) when bo > 1⁄4 in. (6 mm), G p outside
diameter of gasket contact face less 2b, in. (mm) Ihp moment of inertia of hub shoulder relative to
hp hub taper length, in. (mm) its neutral axis, in.4 (mm4)
hDp radial distance from effective clamp-hub reac-
tion circle to the circle on which HD acts, in. p g1T 3 g2h23
(mm) + − (g2h2 + g1 T)h2
3 3
p [C−(B + g1 )] /2
hGp radial distance from effective clamp-hub reac-
Lap distance from W to the point where the clamp
tion circle to the circle on which HG acts, in.
lug joins the clamp body, in. (mm) [see Fig.
(mm) (for full face contact geometries, hGp 0)
24-1 sketch (e)]
hnp hub neck length, in. (mm) [minimum length of
Lhp clamp lug height, in. (mm) [see Fig. 24-1
hn is 0.5g1 or 1⁄4 in. (6 mm), whichever is larger]
sketch (e)]
Lwp clamp lug width, in. (mm) (see Fig. 24-2)
hop 冪 Bgo, in. (mm) lcp effective clamp lip length, in. (mm)
lmp effective clamp lip moment arm, in. (mm)
hTp radial distance from effective clamp-hub reac- p lc − (C − Ci) /2
tion circle to the circle on which HT acts, in. mp gasket factor from Table 2-5.1
(mm) MDp moment due to HD , in.-lb (kNWm)

463

COPYRIGHT American Society of Mechanical Engineers


Licensed by Information Handling Services
24-3 2001 SECTION VIII — DIVISION 1 24-4

p H D hD S3p maximum hub shear stress at shoulder, psi (kPa)


MFp offset moment, in.-lb (kNWm) S4p maximum radial hub shear stress in neck, psi
p HD(g1− go) /2 (kPa)
MGp moment due to HG, in.-lb (kNWm) S5p clamp longitudinal stress at clamp body inner
p HGhG diameter, psi (kPa)
MHp reaction moment at hub neck, in.-lb (kNWm) S6p clamp tangential stress at clamp body outer di-
ameter, psi (kPa)


p 1.818 S7p maximum shear stress in clamp lips, psi (kPa)
Mo / 1 +
冪 Bg1 S8p clamp lug bending stress, psi (kPa)
S9p effective bearing stress between clamp and hub,
冤 冥冧
3.305 Ih
× T−h+ 2 psi (kPa)
g1 (B /2 + g)
Tp thickness of hub shoulder per Fig. 24-1, in.
(mm)
Mop total rotational moment on hub, in.-lb (kNWm)
Wp total design bolt load required for operating or
(see 24-5)
assembly conditions, as applicable, lb (kN)
MPp pressure moment, in.-lb (kNWm)
Wep total effective axial clamping preload on one
clamp lip and hub shoulder (gasket seating or
p 3.14 × PBT (T /2 − h) assembly), lb (kN)
p 1.571 W /tan(␾ + ␮ )
MRp radial clamp equilibriating moment, in.-lb Wm1p minimum required total bolt load for the op-
(kNWm) erating conditions, lb (kN) [see 24-4(b)(1)]
Wm2p minimum required total bolt load for gasket
p 1.571 W {h − T + [(C − N) tan ␾] /2} seating, lb (kN) [see 24-4(b)(2)]
Wm3p minimum required total bolt load for assembly,
MTp moment due to HT, in.-lb (kNWm) lb (kN) [see 24-4(b)(3)]
p H T hT Xp clamp dimension to neutral axis per Fig. 24-1
Np outside diameter of hub neck, in. (mm) sketch (f), in. (mm)
Pp internal design pressure (see UG-21), psi (kPa)
Qp reaction shear force at hub neck, lb (kN)
冤冢 2 冣 冥
p Cw Ct (C − Cg) 2
− Ct2 − w lc /Ac
3 2
p 1.818 MH / 冪 Bg1

rp clamp or hub cross section corner radius, in. yp gasket seating stress, psi (kPa) (from Table 2-
(mm) 5.1)
p 1⁄4 in. (6 mm) min., Ct max. Zp clamp-hub taper angle, deg. (for gasket seating
Sap allowable bolt stress at room temperature, psi and preload, Zp␾+␮; for operating, Zp␾−␮)
(kPa) [see 24-4(b)(4)]
Sbp allowable bolt stress at design temperature, ␣p hub transition angle, deg.
psi (kPa) p 45 deg. max.
SOHp allowable design stress for hub material at (op- ␮p friction angle, deg.
erating condition) design temperature, psi (kPa) ␾p clamp shoulder angle, deg.
SAHp allowable design stress for hub material at (as- p 40 deg. max.
sembly condition) room temperature, psi (kPa)
SOCp allowable design stress for clamp material at
(operating condition) design temperature, psi
24-4 BOLT LOADS
(kPa)
SACp allowable design stress for clamp material at (a) General. During assembly of the clamp connec-
(assembly condition) room temperature, psi tion, the design bolt load W is resolved into an effective
(kPa) clamp preload We, which is a function of the clamp-
S1p hub longitudinal stress on outside at hub neck, hub taper angle ␾ and the friction angle ␮. An appro-
psi (kPa) priate friction angle shall be established by the Manufac-
S2p maximum Laḿe hoop stress at bore of hub, turer, based on test results for both assembly and
psi (kPa) operating conditions.

464

COPYRIGHT American Society of Mechanical Engineers


Licensed by Information Handling Services
24-4 APPENDIX 24 — MANDATORY 24-6

(b) Calculations. In the design of bolting for a clamp Operating conditions:


connection, complete calculations shall be made for
three separate and independent sets of conditions which W p Wm1 (4)
are defined as follows.
(1) The required bolt load for the operating condi- Assembly conditions:
tions Wm1 shall be sufficient to resist the hydrostatic
end force H exerted by the design pressure acting on
W p (AmL + AbL )Sa (5)**
the area bounded by the diameter of gasket reaction
plus a gasket compressive load Hp which experience
has shown to be sufficient to assure a tight joint. The
minimum operating bolt load Wm1 shall be determined
in accordance with Formula (1): 24-5 HUB MOMENTS
The moments used in determining hub stresses are
Wm1 p 0.637 (H + Hp ) tan (␾ − ␮) (1) the products of loads and moment arms illustrated in
Fig. 24-1 and defined in 24-3.
In addition, reaction moments due to hub eccentrici-
(2) Before a tight joint can be obtained, it is
ties and bearing pressure are considered.
necessary to seat the gasket or joint-contact surface For the operating condition, the design moment Mo
properly by applying a minimum initial load (under is the sum of six individual moments: MD, MG, MT,
atmospheric temperature conditions without the presence MF, MP, and MR. The bolt load W used is that from
of internal pressure), which is a function of the gasket Formula (4).
material and the effective gasket area to be seated. For assembly, the design moment Mo is based on
The minimum initial bolt load required for gasket the design bolt load of Formula (5):
seating Wm2 shall be determined in accordance with
Formula (2):
0.785 W(C − G)
Mo p (6)**
tan (␾ + ␮)
Wm2 p 0.637 Hm tan (␾ + ␮) (2)

(3) To assure proper preloading of the clamp 24-6 CALCULATION OF HUB


STRESSES
connection against operating conditions, an assembly
bolt load Wm3 shall be determined in accordance with The stresses in the hub shall be determined for both
Formula (3): the operating and the assembly condition.
(a) The reaction moment MH and the reaction shear
Q are defined in 24-3 and shall be calculated at the
Wm3 p 0.637 (H + Hp ) tan (␾ + ␮) (3)
hub neck for rotational moment Mo.
(b) Hub stresses shall be calculated from the follow-
(4) In Formula (1), credit for friction is allowed ing formulas:
based on clamp connection geometry and experience, Hub longitudinal stress
but the bolt load shall not be less than that determined
using a ␾−␮ value of 5 deg. Friction is also considered
冤4g (B + g ) + g 冥
PB 2 1.91MH
S1 p f (7)**
in determining bolt loads by Formulas (2) and (3), but 1 1 1
2
(B +g1 )
the ␮ factor used shall not be less than 5 deg.
(c) Required Bolt Area. The total cross-sectional area Hub hoop stress
of bolting AmL required shall be the greater of the
values for operating conditions Am1, gasket seating
冢N 冣
N 2 + B2
conditions Am2, or assembly condition Am3. Bolt bending S2 p P 2
(8)
− B2
in the assembly shall be avoided by utilization of
spherically seated nuts and /or washers.
(d) Clamp Connection Design Bolt Load W. The
** For some of the terms of the above equation(s), it may be
bolt load used in the design of the clamp connection necessary to convert millimeters to meters to obtain a rational result
shall be the value obtained from Formulas (4) and (5). in SI units.

465

COPYRIGHT American Society of Mechanical Engineers


Licensed by Information Handling Services
24-6 2001 SECTION VIII — DIVISION 1 24-8

Hub axial shear stress TABLE 24-8


ALLOWABLE DESIGN STRESS FOR CLAMP
0.75 W CONNECTIONS
S3 p (9)**
T(B + 2g1 ) tan Z Stress Category Allowable Stress
S1 1.5SOH or 1.5SAM
Hub radial shear stress S2 SOH
S3 0.8SOH or 0.8SAH
0.477 Q S4 0.8SOH or 0.8SAH
S4 p (10)**
g1(B + g1 ) S5 1.5SOC or 1.5SAC

S6 1.5SOC or 1.5SAC
S7 0.8SOC or 0.8SAC
S8 SOC or SAC
S9 (1)
24-7 CALCULATION OF CLAMP
NOTE:
STRESSES (1) 1.6 times the lower of the allowable stresses for hub material
(SOH, SAH ) and clamp material (SOC , SAC).
The stresses in the clamp shall be determined for
both the operating and the assembly conditions. Clamp
stresses shall be calculated from the following formulas:
Clamp longitudinal stress
Clamp lug bending stress


W 1 3(Ct + 2lm )
S5 p
2C tan Z Ct
+
Ct2
冥 (11)
S8 p 3 W
La
(14)**
LwLh2
Clamp tangentialstress
In addition, a bearing stress calculation shall be made
W 1 |eb| (Ct − X) at the clamp-to-hub contact by Formula (15):
S6 p
2 Ac冤+
Ic 冥 (12)
W
S9 p (15)**
(A − Ci ) C tan Z
Clamp lip shear stress

1.5 W
S7 p (13) 24-8 ALLOWABLE DESIGN STRESSES
(Cw − Cg ) C tan Z
FOR CLAMP CONNECTIONS
** For some of the terms of the above equation(s), it may be
necessary to convert millimeters to meters to obtain a rational result Table 24-8 gives the allowable stresses that are to
in SI units. be used with formulas of 24-6 and 24-7.

466

COPYRIGHT American Society of Mechanical Engineers


Licensed by Information Handling Services

You might also like