Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Accuracy of Computerized Cephalometric Software in Comparison With Manual Tracing in A Group Yemeni People in Sana'a City - Yemen
Accuracy of Computerized Cephalometric Software in Comparison With Manual Tracing in A Group Yemeni People in Sana'a City - Yemen
Sana’a University
Postgraduate Studies and Scientific Research
Faculty of Dentistry
Periodontology Department
Presented by
Saif-Aldeen Kareem Zughair
B. D. S. Faculty of dentistry
Dar Alssalam University – Yemen
Supervisor
Assistant. Prof. Dr. Rami Ishaq
Department of Orthodontic
Faculty of Dentistry
Sana’a University - Yemen
2021H
1443AD
الجمهورية اليمنية
جامعة صنعاء
نيابة الدراسات العليا والبحث العلمي
كلية طب االسنان قسم التقويم الثابت
خطة بحث مقدمة استيفاءا لمتطلبات الحصول على درجة الماجستير في تقويم األسنان
مقدمة من الطالب
المشرف الرئيسي
1443هـ
2021م
Accuracy of Computerized Cephalometric Software In
Comparison With Manual Tracing In a group Yemeni
People in Sana’a City - Yemen
1. Background:
1.1. Introduction:
Cephalometric is a compound latin word includes two distinct terms: cephalo (the
Thus, cephalometry is the art of the human head measurements which used to evaluate
craniofacial growth. Skull radiographs is involved widely to measure the human head
the cephalometric technique has been regarded as a most important tool for
Maxillofacial surgery, and orthodontics uses X-ray images to mark specific point on
skull to obtain the various angular and linear parameters (Delaire, 1997).
those points called cephalometric landmark which identified as set of feature in both
hard and soft tissue of the skull. Landmarks are employed to measure the cephalometric
There are nearly 20 to 30 landmarks on the human skull which used widely in
The computer development has had a tremendous influence on individuals and society
in all aspects of daily life such as the medical area, the economy, education and
It has become an invaluable work tool, and orthodontics is not the exception because
in the last 30 years there has been an expansion the ough the development of
The arrival of the digital systems for taking radiographs has been of great help to
into a digital image through professional scanners to obtain a good image of the
anatomical structures thus avoiding distortion for an excellent digital tracing (Morales,
2005).
This study aimed to compare the error in cephalometric measurements with manual and
computerized methods using the softwares EZortho software program and Orthovision
analyzed.
cephalometric points manually and digitally, evaluating and comparing the outcomes
achieved and comparing them to each other, to aid the clinician in selecting the best
cephalometric analysis and the manual tracing in Yemen , this study will investigate
this comparison through both manual tracing and computerized cephalometric analysis
this comparison among Yemeni population. Therefore, this will be selected as a theme
of the study.
The main aim of this study is to compare the measurements made using
population.
cephalometric points manually and digitally, evaluating and comparing the outcomes
achieved and comparing them to each other, to aid the clinician in selecting the best
1.6. Hypothesis:
compared With manual Tracing, among some of Yemeni population in Sana’a city –
2. Review of Literature :
Silling et al (Silling et al., 1979). stressed that LCR was only needed for Class II
division 1 patients. Later, Han et al (Han et al., 1991) stated that patient examination
together with dental casts provided sufficient information with which to render a
diagnosis.
According to them, only 55% of treatment plans were changed after LCR
evaluation. In the same vein, Bruks et al (Bruks et al., 1999) suggested that in 93% of
the cases treatment plans remained unchanged after LCR evaluation. They evaluated
cephalometric tracing both through the use of digitizers and directly on screen-
6
7
measurements, whereas second-generation systems use scanners or digital cameras to
The use of direct digital images offers several advantages, such as instant image
landmarks on acetate overlays and using these reference points to construct lines, planes
and angles to enable the measurement of linear and angular values, using a millimetre
scale and a protractor. This manual process can be time-consuming and the
1998)
offering enhanced accuracy, nevertheless, the skills of manual analysis are still
required.
has the disadvantage of being subject to random and systematic error. The main sources
landmarks.
Most error soccur in landmark identification and are influenced by clinician experience,
landmark definition, image density and sharpness (Cohen, 1984) (Sandler, 1988)
Digital Tracing
the first uses digitizer pads for tracing conventional cephalometric films and
third transmits digital radio-graphs directly to a computer database. The use of both
digital radiography and conversion of manual film to a digital format offers several
manipulate the size and contrast of the image and provides the ability to archive and
The landmarks lying on the poorly defined structures are difficult to automatically
second method uses storage phosphor plates to capture the image (indirect
digitization). The plates store the radiation energy generated by the radiographic
apparatus in a latent image which is then transferred by a red laser scanner to the
computer in digital format. The computer images from either method consist of a
collection of pixels, whose size and colour values produce different colours and
shades of grey. The final size of the image is determined by the number and
The manual method is not only time-consuming but also allows more measurement
method on paper in comparison to the analysis of digital image was controversial for a
long time. The complicated process to obtain a digital record of X-ray, loss of data
during digitization resulting in reduced quality of the image, or complicated and not
sufficiently tested software analysis disputable in the past (Thurzo et al., 2010).
Nowadays, due to the technology advancement and necessity of data mobility, the
manual method is becoming a handicap. Nowadays, digitizing X-rays has become the
becomes increasingly easier for professionals to adapt to the many routine tasks of
Various computer programs have been developed in recent years for cephalometric
analysis. Previous studies have evaluated systems such as the Dentofacial Planner, the
Dolphin Imaging, and the Quick Ceph®. The common conclusion of these studies
was that although differences between computer prediction and manual tracing are not
Some landmark locations and measurements (SNA, Wits, E-plane, soft tissue point B,
gonion, points articulare) were more reproducible with manual tracing while other
points (e.g. the apex of the upper incisor root) were easier to locate with digital tracing
(Gerbo et al., 1997); Csaszar et al. , 1994 ; Loh et al. , 2001 ; (Turner & Weerakone, 2001); (Ferreira &
Telles, 2002) (Loh & Yow, 2002); (Ongkosuwito et al., 2002); (Cousley et al., 2003); (Chen et al.,
2004) , b ; (Gossett et al., 2005); (Power et al., 2005); (Bruntz et al., 2006)).
He compared 50 lateral cranial radiographs of 12-year-old children, half male and half
female. Fourteen landmarks were defined in that study: S, N, anterior nasal spine,
subspinal, incisal and zenith of the maxillary incisor, incisal and zenith of the
articulare. The conclusion was that traditional methods were inferior in comparison to
digital procedures, but not alarmingly so, and in some cases traditional methods
research and in clinical applications, Nimkarn and Miles (Nimkarn & Miles, 1995)
from the same x-ray machine were used and chosen at random. Each radiograph was
traced in acetate paper, and the images of the radiographs and tracings were captured
in a video camera, projected onto a monitor, where the landmarks were digitized. The
cephalometric measurements were obtained using Quick Ceph 5.1 software (Quick
The program performed the calculations for all 40 measurements, from 22 marked
landmarks. In order to assess methodology errors and identify the source of errors, the
digitalization errors. The results showed that the measurements performed in the
differences.
One study involving two orthodontists, who each twice traced 21 cephalometric
landmarks in 100 radiographs obtained through the traditional method and 100
al., 2000).
The authors also highlighted that the linear and angular measurements were more
precise in the digitally obtained radiographs, emphasizing that the quality of digital
Ceph-X was evaluated by using X-ray images of 30 subjects (male and female)
obtained from University of Malaya hospital , Statistical analysis for the comparison
between the manual and automatic cephalometric approaches showed that Ceph-X
approximately less than 0.5 mm, and 1°. Results showed that Ceph-X increased the
Manual method
All the lateral cephalograms were traced using a sheet of acetate tracing paper. The
tracings were done on a view box with the tracing paper securely positioned over the
radiograph with a masking tape. Once the landmarks were traced, the lines and planes
were obtained.
Digital method
transferring the selected images archives of the cephalogram folder to the orthovision
were identified on the displayed image and digitalized on‑screen by the technician who
evaluate the accuracy and performance of the programs , and the lines and planes were
Well manual tracing for the same cephalometric x-ray will be done by the
researcher.
The data will be collected by a specific program then analysis by SPSS software
The study sample are calculated by using open epi® software, where the prevalence
≤ 0.05, confidence interval 95% , the minimal calculating sample size are 90 x-ray for
the participants.
General information (personal information, age and gender) will be obtained from
an X-ray center.
ray, as follows:
The skeletal cephalometric measurements :- SNA, SNB, ANB, Ant. cranial base ,
And the soft tissue cephalometric measurements :- Esthetic line to upper lip (mm) ,
All data will be collects then analyze by SPSS software, version 19 manufactured by
IBM, Chicago Illinois USA, corporation is use to perform the statistical analysis. A
3.6. Management :
The Proposal Schedule will start from september, 2021 up to collect final number of
participants.
4. Ethical Considerations :
Approval for the study will be applied for the Ethical Committee of Sana’a University
All costs including equipment’s , data collection and data processing will be a self
funding .
4 Analysis 2 1000$
programs
rental
Total 4200$
6. Timelines (2020/2021):
2021 2022
Step/Months Dec.
Oct. Nov. Jen. Feb. Mar. Apr. May. Jun. Jul. Aug. Sep.
Protocol
Computerized
analysis
Manual
Analysis
Writing
Presentation of
final research
7. References :