Professional Documents
Culture Documents
EQUALITY INDEX
BY: WOMEN OF DIVERSITY
PRODUCTIONS, INC.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY............................................................................................................... 6
RESOURCES .................................................................................................................................33
MISSION:
To give visibility to women and to
create a woman-appreciated future.
survey to assess the status of Our approach was to obtain We believe that by identifying
women in our society and to voluntary answers to a survey the level of commitment to
learn why women’s advancement and to access what could be pay equality and the number of
had stalled. Since the pay gleaned from the corporate women in leadership positions,
gap was the most visible and image presented to the public. we might discover ways to
impactful public outcry, we Our hypothesis was that full accelerate the advancement of
decided to create a survey to commitment to gender equality gender equality. These results
investigate gender equality in the could be measured utilizing will generate increased dialogue
work place. This was a logical both sets of data. This method within and outside these
project since the lack of pay provided us with an avenue to corporations. There has not
equity is an economic issue that discover what information was been enough exploration into
impacts families, economies, shared and how transparent the interrelationships between
businesses and government the information is concerning full corporate commitment and
revenues. It even impacts our gender equality policies and policy implementation.
country’s Gross Domestic practices. We discovered
Product. We chose to survey the that the corporations who
gaming industry since it is highly made their Corporate Social
dependent upon how the public Responsibility (CSR) report
evaluates hospitality practices available online, often had
and policies and because made greater advancements
so many of the company’s than those who did not. Is full
headquarters were local. gender equality possible without
sharing and full transparency?
5 | Gaming Gender Equality Index
THE YEAR
2059
Women comprise half the workforce in the United States
WOMEN’S WAGES WILL and are the primary earners in 23% of families (2016 Census
NOT EQUALIZE TO THAT
OF MEN UNTIL 2059 Bureau Reports), yet they continue to only make 80 cents to
every dollar a man makes. In all occupations, men’s median
earnings are higher than women’s earnings, regardless
of the gender composition of the industry. According to
the American Association of University Women in their
report, The Simple Truth about the Gender Pay Gap, Spring
2017 Edition, women’s wages will not equalize to that of
men until 2059, based on the current rate of change. The
National Women’s Law Center reports “A 20-year old
woman just starting full time, year round work today stands
to lose $418,800 over a 40-year career compared to her
male counterpart. And when her male counterpart retires
at age 60 after 40 years of work, she would have to work 10
more years, until age 70, which is past Social Security’s full
retirement age, in order to close this lifetime wage gap.”
8 | Gaming Gender Equality Index
Since 1883, the American discriminatory and economical The comprehensive report
Association of University problems as a result of Barriers and Bias (aauw.org
Women (AAUW) has inequality in the workplace 2016) addresses the status of
published research reports for women, especially for women in leadership (a 5:1
relative to gender inequity women of color. ratio). It outlines the barriers
in education and in the to equality and what facts
workplace. The more than In 2014, and updated in 2017, are important to share with
100 reports, which range from AAUW published The Simple businesses, men, women,
current issues, barriers to Truth about the Gender Pay government entities
equality, women’s status, and Gap. It provided data to and the public.
more, are available on their dispel the naysayers who
website (aauw.org). did not believe the pay gap
The reports are worth existed. It does. There is no
reading to gain a broader refuting the research.
understanding of the
9 | Gaming Gender Equality Index
Note: Key elements taken from AAUW’s Barriers and Bias, 2016
The pay gap negatively would increase $12 trillion and disseminate a report
impacts women’s sense of by 2025, simply by increasing to encourage voluntary
well-being plus their and women’s workplace equality. corporate commitment to
their family’s quality of life. compensation equalization
This earning power inequality The pay gap closure needs to by doing their own internal
impacts everyone as it accelerate. How can we help pay equity analysis and
reduces our country’s ability reduce what appears to be then make the appropriate
to generate a healthy and a stalled progression to pay internal changes to
sustainable economy. The equality? We can survey a compensation structures,
Bloomberg Financial Services small group of corporations, behaviors and perceptions.
Gender-Equality Index authors interpret the conclusions The idea is not new.
state that the global GDP from major multi-year surveys
11 | Gaming Gender Equality Index
Recently, this idea of In order to do this, we teamed have been used, including
with Dr. Jessica Word, faculty one recent employee survey
surveying companies for from the University of Nevada, Las by the Nevada Commission
Vegas and her graduate students. for Women, the greatest
their pay equity practices The first step of the process information has resulted from
was to conduct a review of the large studies in 2002 and later,
and results, has been
literature, comprising what women with multiple year conclusions.
adopted by others. It and the public considered issues
of gender inequality, the policies The four most important
was about the same time and practices corporations put contemporary equality surveys
into effect and their workplace are the Bloomberg Financial
that Women of Diversity advertising, plus decades of Services Gender-Equality Index
Productions decided to research, which depicted changes (designed to investigate gender
in the pay gaps among other status within only that business
create a Gaming Gender factors, that influenced the status category), the InHerSight online
of gender equality. interactive project to rate your
Equality Index, that The business employer, as well as a
Three survey approaches usually comparison between male and
Bloomberg Financial
have been utilized to assess gender female employee responses to a
Services Gender-Equality equality in the work place: separate survey, the Corporate
Equality Index sponsored by the
Index, InHerSight survey 1) gather opinions and facts Human Rights Campaign, in the
provided by employees about quest for equality for the LGBT
of employees, and the their current or previous community, and the Women in the
work experiences, Workplace studies by LeanIn.Org
McKinsey Company &
LeanIn Company surveys
2) obtain facts submitted by and McKinsey & Company.
representatives from
were published. corporations about their
policies, practices and
workplace environment, and
Women of Diversity Productions
took on the challenge to 3) search the print and
survey the largest industry media messages produced by
in their home state, gaming. corporations available through
Many of the largest casino and sources, such as their
gaming corporations have their websites (employer content-
headquarters in Nevada. It researched approach).
was a prime location to begin
its inaugural Gaming Gender Although single time surveys
Equality Index. and small population findings
Non-Discrimination Policies
Equal Benefits
Organizational Competency
Surveys
FACTORS SIGNIFICANTLY
HIGHER SATISFACTION
RATINGS THAN WOMEN.
3. To what degree is gender data being tracked by corporations and is NOT AVAILABLE”.
there transparency in the collection and analysis of their gender data?
Q14. What is the average annual pay Q28. Board of Directors. Q40. Enter the percent of
for positions requiring a two year % Men, % Women employees that have been promoted
college degree or higher? in the last 12 months: Men, Women
Men, Women Q29. Does the corporation offer
UNPAID parental leave beyond Q41. Are there other gender
Q15. Has the corporation performed the requirements of FMLA’s (Family equity or equality programs your
a pay equity analysis? Pay equity is a Medical Leave Act) 12 weeks of corporation would like to share?
means of eliminating discrimination in unpaid, job-protected leave per year?:
the wage setting system.
19 | Gaming Gender Equality Index
Note: Largest Gaming Employers in Nevada,Vegas, Inc. March 19, 2017. Numbers 7,8,10,11,13,14 are non-gaming corporations. #12 was a gaming
corporation not invited to participate.
2015 TOP CASINO AND GAMING COMPANIES BY REVENUE (IN BILLIONS OF USD)
The surveyed list also includes 7 of the top 12 casino and gaming companies world-wide by revenue in billions of United States
dollars (from online Directory of Major Casino and Gaming Companies in the World, 2015 data). Minimum revenue was $1.85 billion
and maximum was $11.69 billion.
Note: Numbered corporations 3,4,6,8 and 10 are not United States Corporations
3. Internal Supporting 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39 30
Policies
4. Community Gender 41 5
Equality Commitment
The Cosmopolitan
of Las Vegas
Las Vegas, NV 1 S 14.5 24 18 0 56.5
The total points, ranged from a is in Australia. The headquarters in category has a mean equal to 80%
low of 25 to a high of 62. The mean Las Vegas is one of its sites. of a possible score of 30 points,
was 43.89 points. As expected, no whereas, the Community Gender
company achieved 100 points. Only The highest scores were obtained Commitment category has a
seven corporations scored 50 by four corporations ranging from mean of 13%, of a possible five
points or above and ten 56.5 to 62, one standard deviation points. The Gender Composition
corporations scored above the above the mean. In the first and Compensation category has
mean. Four of the five corporations Bloomberg study, 26 corporations a mean of 21% of a possible 35
who submitted their GGEI having achieved a score of 60 points. The mean of the Internal
survey, scored among the top five; points or higher were invited to Support Policies category is 39% of
whereas the fifth submitter, was be members of the Bloomberg a possible 30 points.
below the mean, at 40.5 points. Financial Services Gender-Equality
The highest score was from a Index. In our Gaming Gender
corporation that had its Workplace Equality Index, we had only one
Gender Equality Report on its corporation that met that standard.
website. This report is required
by Australian law to be submitted When comparing the scores Comparing these mean
to the Workplace Gender Equality among categories, we note that positions, one may state
Agency, since its main headquarters the Non-discrimination Policies the following:
When governmental laws
IGT 10 0 10 0% 13
4 1 3 25%
4 5 44% 2 0 2 0%
3 8 27% 5 1 4 20%
0 11 0% 6 2 4 33.3%
1 4 20% 1 1 0 100%
1 8 11% 10 0 10 0%
1 5 16.7% 3 2 1 67%
1 7 12.5% 4 1 3 25%
0% 20%
0 7 0% 2 0 2 0%
2 11 15.4% 4 0 4 0%
1 10 9.1%
3 9 25% 9 2 7 22.2%
1 4 20% VP title
not used
0 7 0% 3 0 3 0%
2 6 25% 11 1 10 9.1%
2 6 25% 7 3 4 43%
10% 20%
2 11 15.4% 3 1 2 33.3%
0 6 0% 3 1 2 33.3%
1 9 10% 25%
Category 1: Gender The majority of points in this section There are two corporations with
Composition and could be obtained if there were no women in leadership roles.These
Compensation a greater number of women in organizations were at the bottom of
Two questions in this category the top leadership positions. The total points for the GGEI.
were relative to compensation greatest number of women were
data. No corporation responded serving as vice presidents. The We identified five women
to these two questions. We were numbers we had are underestimated who were women of color
warned that questions regarding because four of the corporations (three Asians and two African
compensation would not be did not provide the total numbers, Americans). There may be others
answered, but we needed to know only percentages. As far as board that we could not identify.
if this were true. It was. positions, usually no more than one
or two women per corporation Category 2: Non-
Less than half the corporations served in these capacities. The larger discrimination Policies
tracked leadership by gender. the corporation, the more leaders Nineteen corporations rated 78%
they have, but the number of women on non-discrimination policies. Since
There is evidence that there did not proportionally change. these policies are primarily man-
has been an awareness and Smaller board sizes favored a greater datory or traditional policies, this
work to close the pay gap in percentage of women in leadership was an inadequate commitment
previous decades. Boyd Gaming roles. From this sampling, there were to the serious problem of gender
Corporation stated in 1975, no women who held the position equality discrimination. However
that it had established equal pay of CEO/Chair/President. However, these policies do fulfill the
for men and women. Several there were instances of women in gender (sex) non-discrimination
corporations have indicated that the highest position within a casino. characteristic. Only half the
it is difficult to provide equal pay This was evident in three of the corporations had gender-specific
since merit, bonuses, awards and Station Casinos out of nine that prohibition policies, such as
experience impact compensation. had women casino managers and harassment clauses. Most companies
Station Casinos, LLC has included one other corporation that had a merely used its inclusive phrase as a
an analysis of skills required and woman manager. No other place statement of non-discrimination:
responsibility included in the on the websites could we find
position for determining pay equity. managers for properties. “We are an equal opportunity
Based upon the job classifications, company and do not discriminate on
it appears entry level positions See Women in Leadership the basis of race, color, religion, sex,
have a set salary, but once a Positions in 21 Gaming national origin, ancestry, age, medical
person advances beyond, the Corporations/Casinos on condition, disability or handicap,
true compensation data becomes previous page. perceived disability or handicap,
difficult to ascertain. Thus, we have military service, veteran status, marital
gained little knowledge of the status The average of women in leadership, status or sexual orientation.”
of equal pay. in the 16 corporations where we
had male and female data, was 16.4% Some of these policies, as the one
How can one evaluate if gender for executive leadership. listed above, are not up to date
equality exists or not when Representation of women on the and do not include Nevada’s
data is not collected with respect board of directors was 13.6%. gender identity and expression
to gender? mandated protections.
Company Retirement Nursing In-House Ed/ Mentoring Tuition and Paid Flex Time Remote Child
Training Other $$$ Maternity Working Care
Boyd Gaming
Yes No Yes No No No Yes No No
Corporation
Caesars
Yes No Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes
Entertainment Corp.
Eldorado Resorts,
Inc. Yes No Yes Yes Yes No No No Yes
Scientific Games
Yes No No No Yes No No No No
Corporation
Benefit Average 20 of 21 5 16 10 14 3 9 2 6
One obvious conclusion is that emphasize the corporation’s From the data it is evident that there
there is a barrier in advancing commitment to change. is a wide disparity in the gaming
women from vice president to industry because of the variance of
An in-depth evaluation of actual policies, practices, transparency and
higher levels of management and training, mentoring, sponsorship,
a general lack of commitment commitments to gender equality
leadership assistance and diversity among individual corporations. At
to tracking women through the injected into the corporate
leadership spectrum. The following least a third of the corporations have
environment is needed. shown policies and practices that
future actions could alleviate
these disparities. are designed to improve the status
Internal policies that attract and
of women and their compensation.
benefit female employees should be
Tracking is essential from which to There needs to be more willingness
front and center. They are incentives
improve the number of leadership to address these issues in a positive
to attract quality female applicants
positions and to gauge overall and proactive manner in the industry
and to retain them once hired.
advancement for women.The across the board. I t is becoming
Australian company scored higher This study did not focus on acceptable to join networks, to
than the 20 other corporations. the ethnic and race composition share information and to learn from
Australia mandates tracking. of the women. Many other studies other corporations and to upgrade
Results indicate that if the gender indicate that women of color fair the entire industry. One of the
gap is to be reduced dramatically, far worse in compensation and organizations that includes more
then more stringent methods few have positions of power and than 300 CEOs is ceoaction.com.
need to be mandated. It is evident influence in leadership. A special
that if something, such as a policy, emphasis needs to be made to At least half the corporations in this
is mandated by law, then the be as inclusive as possible in study are attempting to create an
corporations comply, to the letter of future studies, as well as in any environment of Diversity & Inclusion
that law. However, this does not alter corporation’s gender equality that will result in all employees
the internal policies and behaviors policies. Simply put, women of respecting each other, appreciating
that breed pay inequality. color deserve full equality and they what skills and qualities each has
need to be at the table and counted. to offer and harmoniously working
Self audits and analyses do not together, which will produce
appear to have been utilized by the The number of women in leadership maximum benefits to the employees,
majority of these gaming companies. roles needs to increase. If there were the corporation and community the
One corporation that did conduct more women in these roles, the corporation serves.
a pay equity analysis reported that corporation would benefit by their
compensation was then adjusted perspective, which would translate We commend such a commitment
with respect to skills required and into a more inclusive offering for their and we hope it will result in benefits
responsibility of the position. clients. It would also provide more role to women.
The lack of transparency in the models for younger women.
Everyone is talking about diversity
32 | Gaming Gender Equality Index
sponsors and
supporters,
Schipani, C., Dworkin, T., Kwolek- “Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of
Foll, A., & Maurer,V. (2009). Pathways 1964” (1964). Retrieved from the
for Women to Obtain Positions Web December 4, 2016. https://
of Organization Leadership: The www.eeoc.gov/laws/statutes/titlevii.
Significance of Mentoring and cfm Wai-Packard.pdf Definition of
Networking. Pathways for Women Mentoring. Retrieved December 12,
to Obtain Positions of Organization 2016, from http://ehrweb.aaas.org/
Leadership: The Significance of sciMentoring/Mentor_Definitions_
Mentoring and Networking, 16(1), Packard.pdf
3rd ser., 89-136. Retrieved from
http://scholarship.law.duke.edu/ Weiss, Ann E. (1999). The Glass
djglp/vol16/iss1/3 Ceiling: A Look at Women in the
Workforce. Brookfield, Conn:
Smithson, J. & Stokoe, E. H.
LernerPublishingGroup.
(2005). Discourses of work-life
balance: Negotiating ‘genderblind’
Women of Diversity Productions,
terms in organizations. Gender,
Inc. (October 22, 2016). Gender
Work, and Organization. 12(2),
Wave Workshop [Brochure].
147-168. Retrieved from http://
onlinelibrary.wiley.com.ezproxy.
Yim King Penny Wan, (2014)
library.unlv.edu/doi/10.1111/j.1468-
“Minding the gap in the gaming
0432.2005.00267.x/abstract
industry: Perceptions of gender
Taneja, S., Pryor, M. G., & Oyler, disparity at work among female
J. (2012). Empowerment and casino dealers”, International
gender equality: The retention Journal of Contemporary Hospitality
and promotion of women in Management,Vol 26 Iss: 1, pp.130 -
the workforce. The Journal of 153
Business Diversity, 12(3), 43- 53.
Retrieved from http://ezproxy. Ziman, Rebecca L. (2013) “Women
library.unlv.edu/login?url=http:// in the Workforce: An In-Depth
search.proquest.com/ Analysis of Gender Roles and
docview/5153017?accountid=3611 Compensation Inequity in the
Modern Workplace” (2013). Honors
T.D. Allen, et al., Women and Theses and Capstones. Retrieved
career advancement, Organ Dyn from http://scholars.unh.edu/
(2016), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j. honors/157
orgdyn.2016.07.006
Accenture. (2017). Getting corporate ladder — in heels. Dishman, L. (2016).These Blind Spots
to Equal 2017 closing the Retrieved from: https://vegasinc. Prevent Gender Equality In The
gender pay gap. Retrieved from: lasvegassun.com/business/2015/ Workplace. Retrieved from: https://
https://www.accenture.com/ nov/30/climbing-the-corporate- www.fastcompany.com/3066653/
t20170403T052457Z__w__/us- ladder-in-heels/ these-blindspots-prevent-gender-
en/_acnmedia/PDF-45/Accenture- equality-in-the-workplace
IWD-2017-Research-Getting-To- Bloomberg. (2016). BFGEI
Equal.pdf#zoom=50 (Bloomberg Financial Services Ellingrud, K., Madgavkar,A., Manyika, J.,
Gender Equality Index) Woetzel, J., Riefberg,V., Krishnan, M. &
Anders, G. (2017). Equal Pay Is Bloomberg Launches Financial Seoni, S. (2016).The power of parity:
Women’s Top Workplace Issue, Services Gender Equality Index Advancing women’s equality in the
Survey Finds. Retrieved from May 3, 2016. Retrieved from: https:// United States. Retrieved from: http://
https://www.forbes.com/sites/ www.bloomberg.com/company/ www.mckinsey.com/global-themes/
georgeanders/2017/02/02/equal-pay- announcements/bloomberg- employment-and-growth/the-power-
is-womens-top-workplace-issue- launches-financial-services-gender- of-parity-advancing-womens-equality-
survey-finds/ equality-index/ in-the-united-states
AAUW. (2016). Barriers and Bias: Bloomberg. (2017). Bloomberg Green, J. (2017). Pay-Equity
The Status of Women in Leadership, Financial Services Gender Equality Fight Quickens Even Without
by C. Hill, K. Miller, K. Benson, & G. Index Reveals Global Progress. U.S.Cheerleader-in-Chief. Retrieved
Handley. Washington DC: Author. Retrieved from: https://www. from: https://www.bloomberg.com/
Retrieved from: http://www.aauw. bloomberg.com/.../bloomberg- news/articles/2017-04-04/equal-pay-
org/research/barriers-and-bias/ financial-services-gender-equality- fight-heats-up-across-u-s-with-or-
index-reveals-global-progress without-trump
AAUW. (2017). The Simple Truth:
About the Pay Equity Gender Gap, CEO Action for Diversity and InHerSight. (1916). New Study
by C. Hill, K. Miller, K. Benson, L. Inclusion, the largest CEO- Reveals How Men Perceive Support
Maatz, & K. Nielson. Washington, driven business commitment to for Women at Work. Retrieved
DC: Author. Retrieved from: http:// advance diversity and inclusion from: https://www.inHerSight.com/
www.aauw.org/aauw_check/ in the workplace. https://www. blog/how-men-perceive-support-
pdf_download/show_pdf. ceoaction.com for-women
php?file=Simple-Truth-Report-PDF-
Spring-2017 Devillard, S., de Zelicourt, A., InHerSight. (1916). 7 Companies
Kossoff, C. & Sancier-Sultan, S. Committed to Having Women at
Berman, R. (2017). How men and (2017) Reinventing the workplace the Top. Retrieved from: https://
women view their jobs. Retrieved to unlock the potential of www.inHerSight.com/blog/7-
from: https://www.tinypulse.com/ gender diversity. Retrieved companies-committed-female-
blog/survey-of-women-and-men- from: http://www.mckinsey.com/ representation-senior
work-satisfaction global-themes/gender-equality/
reinventing-the-workplace-for- Jones, S. (2017). White Men Account
Birkin, D. (2015). Three Stations greater-gender-diversity for 72% of Corporate Leadership at
Casinos employees climb the