Professional Documents
Culture Documents
From the *James J. and Joan A. Gardner Center for Parkinson Disease and Movement Disorders, Department of Neurology and Rehabil-
itation Medicine, University of Cincinnati, Cincinnati, Ohio; †Department of Neurology, Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston,
South Carolina; ‡Department of Chemistry, Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio; and §Department of Biomedical Sciences, Division of
Biostatistics and Epidemiology, Texas Tech University Health Sciences Center El Paso, El Paso, Texas.
Received March 2, 2018; revision received April 7, 2018; accepted April 23, 2018.
Financial disclosure: Dr. Dwivedi is supported by the NIH (1R01HL125016-01) as a Co-Investigator and (R21 AI118228) as a Collaborator.
He has also been serving as a statistician in 4 CPRIT grants (PP110156, PP140211, PP150031, and PP130083), Coldwell (Co-Investigator), MSA
Coalition (Collaborator), and as a principal investigator in a TTUHSC ELP mini seed grant. Dr. Dwivedi is a director of Biostatistics and
Epidemiology Consulting Laboratory at the TTUHSC ELP. Dr. Espay has received grant support from the NIH, Great Lakes Neurotechnologies,
and the Michael J. Fox Foundation; personal compensation as a consultant/scientific advisory board member for Abbvie, TEVA, Impax, Acadia,
Acorda, Cynapsus/Sunovion, Lundbeck, and US WorldMeds; publishing royalties from Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, Cambridge Univer-
sity Press, and Springer; and honoraria from Abbvie, UCB, US WorldMeds, Lundbeck, Acadia, the American Academy of Neurology, and the
Movement Disorders Society.
Conflict of interest: Drs. Suri, Rodriguez-Porcel, Donohue, and Lovera, and Ms. Jesse declare that they have no conflict of interest to disclose.Author
contributions: Case Series Project: Conception: R.S., F.R.P., L.L., and A.J.E.; Organization: R.S. and A.J.E.; Execution: R.S., F.R.P, E.J., and K.D.
Statistical Analysis: A.D. Manuscript: Writing of the First Draft: R.S. and F.R.P.; Review and Critique: E.J., K.D., L.L., A.D., and A.J.E.
Address correspondence to Alberto Espay, MD, MSc., Department of Neurology and Rehabilitation Medicine, University of Cincinnati Academic
Health Center, 260 Stetson St., Suite 2300 (PO Box 670525), Cincinnati, OH 45267-0525. E-mail: espayaj@ucmail.uc.edu.
1052-3057/$ - see front matter
© 2018 National Stroke Association. Published by Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jstrokecerebrovasdis.2018.04.028
2388 Journal of Stroke and Cerebrovascular Diseases, Vol. 27, No. 9 (September), 2018: pp 2388–2397
POST-STROKE MOVEMENT DISORDERS 2389
vulnerability and resilience may explain the differences observed in movement
phenomenology and outcomes after stroke. Key Words: Movement disorders—
stroke—ischemic stroke—hemorrhage—dystonia.
© 2018 National Stroke Association. Published by Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Methods Results
We conducted a systematic review of the literature to General Features of PSMD
identify cases of PSMDs reported between 1986 and 2016. Of a total of 323 qualifying cases, 39 were excluded
We performed a PubMed search with the following terms: due to insufficient data. In total, 284 cases fulfilled our
(stroke or infarct or hemorrhage or ischemia) AND (move- research criteria and were used for analyses. Reported
ment disorders or hyperkinetic or dystonia or myoclonus PSMDs were more common in men (58%), with a mean
or chorea or Parkinson’s or parkinsonism or tremor or age at presentation of 62 years (range 18-93). Ischemic
restless legs syndrome or periodic limb movements or strokes preceded more than three quarters of PSMDs. Pos-
stereotypy or akathisia or alien hand syndrome or tics). terolateral thalamus (23%) was the region most frequently
Search results, titles, and abstracts were reviewed to include affected, followed by the putamen (19%) and caudate (14%).
case reports and case series pertinent to our research ob- Dystonia was the most common PSMD (23%), followed
jectives. Among the identified articles, we included in the by chorea (16%) and myoclonus (15%) (Table 1).
review those that contained (1) well-documented pa-
tients with movement disorders developing after a stroke;
Basic Demographics and PSMD
(2) characterization of the stroke type (e.g., ischemic, hem-
orrhagic) and location; (3) report of the latency between In patients between 50 and 70 years (51.4%), the pos-
the stroke and onset of the movement disorder; and terolateral thalamus was the most common location (29%),
(4) patients who did not present alternative causes for while myoclonus and dystonia were the most common
the emergence of the movement disorder (e.g., metabol- PSMD (27% and 24%, respectively). In those younger than
ic abnormalities, medications). Additional articles were age 50, the putamen and caudate (28% and 19%, respec-
identified by screening secondary research articles (reviews, tively) were the most common locations, and dystonia
commentaries, and letters) yielded by the initial PubMed the most common PSMD (40%). In those older than 70
search. We excluded articles with incomplete character- years, the putamen was most frequently affected (25%)
ization of the movement disorder or the imaging data and chorea the most common PSMD (24%) (Supplementary
regarding localization. Subjects from criteria-meeting ar- Table S1). Women showed greater putaminal involvement
ticles were included in a database, which included than men (26% versus 14.0%) but similar frequency of
2390 R. SURI ET AL.
Table 1. General characteristics of poststroke movement disorders
All 284 164 (57.7) 61.8 (18-93) 218 (76.7) 66 (23.2) Posterolateral thalamus: 64 (22.5)
Dystonia 66 (23.2) 39 (40.9) 61.7 (37-76) 19 (28.7) 20 (30.3) Posterolateral thalamus: 22 (66.6)
Chorea 46 (16.1) 25 (54.3) 61.72 (42-85) 19 (41.3) 6 (13.0) Caudate: 5 (50)
Myoclonus 43 (15.1) 25 (58.1) 66.6 (47-83) 20 (46.5) 5 (11.6) Frontal lobe: 9 (75)
Parkinsonism 42 (14.7) 26 (61.9) 60.7 (18-80) 25 (59.5) 1 (2.4) Putamen: 9 (64.2)
Tremor 39 (13.7) 24 (61.5) 53.3 (18-76) 16 (41) 8 (20.5) Midbrain: 6 (54.5)
Restless legs syndrome 20 (7.04) 7 (35.0) 65.2 (46-83) 7 (35) 0 (0) Pons: 2 (28.5); putamen: 1 (14.2)
Alien hand syndrome 9 (3.1) 4 (44.4) 62.9 (25-83) 4 (44.4) 0 (0) Parietal lobe: 2 (40)
Periodic limb 9 (3.1) 4 (44.4) 60.5 (53-75) 4 (44.4) 0 (0) Pons: 3 (50)
movements
Stereotypy 8 (2.8) 6 (75) 63.8 (40-93) 6 (75) 0 (0) Putamen: 3 (37.5)
Akathisia 1 (.35) 1 (100) 60 (N/A) 1 (100) 0 (0) Posterior thalamus: 1 (100)
Tics 1 (.35) 1 (100) 71 (N/A) 1 (100) 0 (0) Caudate: 1 (100)
stroke involvement in other localizations. While dystonia affecting the globus pallidus exhibited parkinsonism in
and myoclonus were of relatively similar frequency in men nearly 40%. Thalamic strokes yielded distinct pheno-
and women (~23% and ~15%, respectively), parkinsonism types depending on the region affected (Fig 1).
was among the top 3 disorders in men (16%) and chorea
among the top 3 in women (18%) (Supplementary Table S2). Latency to PSMD after Stroke
Most PSMDs (46%) manifested within the first 7 days
Type of Stroke and PSMD
after a stroke. Chorea was the earliest PSMD, appearing
Ischemia was the most common mechanism of stroke within 24 hours, whereas dystonia and tremor had a
in those older than 70, whereas hemorrhage was more poststroke latency measured in several months (Fig 2).
common between the ages of 50 and 70. The distribu- Ischemia remained the most common mechanism of stroke
tion of ischemic and hemorrhagic strokes was similar for movement disorders manifesting in less than a month.
between men and women. Ischemic strokes complicat- Hemorrhagic strokes were responsible for most cases of
ed with PSMD were more frequently located in the delayed onset of movement disorders (>6 months) (Fig 3).
putamen (22%), followed by frontal lobe (16%), mid- The latency period varied depending on stroke loca-
brain (16%), and caudate (15%), whereas hemorrhagic tion. For patients who manifested PSMDs within the first
strokes frequently affected the posterolateral thalamus week, the posterolateral thalamus was the most common
(42%), midbrain (15%), and pons (9%). Parkinsonism, location. The putamen was the most common location
chorea, and dystonia (17% each) were the most com- involved in patients presenting with symptoms within
monly observed movement disorders in patients with a day, and the caudate was most commonly involved in
ischemic strokes, whereas dystonia (46%), tremor (20%), patients presenting with symptoms within 6 months.
and myoclonus (15%) were commonly experienced by
patients with hemorrhagic stroke. Compared with hem- Outcome of PSMD
orrhagic strokes, parkinsonism and restless legs syndrome
Outcome data were reported in 64% of cases re-
were significantly the more frequent type of PSMD after
viewed. Over 70% of these patients exhibited spontaneous
ischemic strokes (6% versus 17% and 0% versus 9%, re-
improvement or resolution. Of those with persistent symp-
spectively); compared with ischemic strokes, dystonia (46%)
toms, only half experienced benefit from symptomatic
and tremor (20%) were significantly more frequent after
treatment. The most common movement disorder to
hemorrhagic strokes, complicating almost two thirds of
improve or resolve spontaneously was myoclonus (84%),
such cases (P < .001) (Table 2 and Supplementary Table S3).
tremor was the most to persist (38%), and parkinson-
ism was the most common to improve with treatment
Stroke Location and Type of PSMD
(36%) (Fig 4). The frontal lobe was the most common lo-
PSMDs varied depending on the location of the stroke. cation involved in cases that spontaneously improved or
While caudate and putaminal strokes were complicated resolved, the putamen in cases that persisted despite treat-
by dystonia in one third of the cases, those selectively ment, and the midbrain in cases that responded to
POST-STROKE MOVEMENT DISORDERS 2391
Table 2. Type of stroke and movement disorders
treatment. There was no difference in outcome among was significantly higher in patients with hemorrhagic
the different age groups. There was no statistical difference strokes, whereas the frequency of parkinsonism and rest-
in the outcomes of PSMD manifesting from ischemic or less legs syndrome was significantly higher in patients
hemorrhagic strokes, although there was a trend for move- with ischemic strokes. Delayed onset of movement dis-
ment disorders resulting from ischemic strokes to improve orders was mostly observed in patients with hemorrhagic
on their own or resolve with treatment compared with strokes associated with dystonia and tremor, whereas earlier
movement disorders resulting from hemorrhagic strokes. onset of movement disorders was due to ischemic strokes
In summary, an interesting portrait emerged from the leading to chorea (over one third persisted), parkinson-
analysis of these 284 cases. The most common PSMD was ism (over half improved with treatment or resolved), and
dystonia (both in men and women), and most post- restless legs syndrome (over two third improved or
stroke dystonia occurred in patients younger than age resolved).
50 years and after hemorrhagic strokes. The second most
common PSMD was chorea, with slightly higher fre-
Discussion
quency among those older than 70 years with ischemic
strokes. Myoclonus was the third most common PSMD, With the inherent biases of published case reports and
was mostly observed in the 50-70 age bracket, and was case series, the collective data suggest a relatively small
equally distributed among patients with hemorrhagic and but significant burden of poststroke movement-related com-
ischemic strokes. The frequency of dystonia and tremor plications. As with other studies, the type of stroke and
2392 R. SURI ET AL.
location provided only a rough estimate of the associ- differences in gender, latency, and outcome according to
ated movement disorder. 1,2 Posterolateral thalamus, the type of stroke, localization, type of movement dis-
putamen, and caudate emerged as the most commonly order, and age, assisted by the high number of cases
reported regions affected by stroke and dystonia as the retrieved compared with the 3 studies mentioned above.
most common movement disorder. Ischemia remained the The relatively poor association between stroke local-
most common mechanism of stroke across all PSMDs. The ization and movement phenomenology (most associations
type of stroke was important in predicting the phenom- were under 30%) may be explained by the inability to
enology, with parkinsonism and restless legs syndrome discern the different motor networks involved in the patho-
being more prevalent after ischemic strokes while dys- physiology of movement disorders. These networks
tonia and tremor after hemorrhagic strokes (more than represent the interaction between multiple regions of the
two thirds of hemorrhagic cases exhibited dystonia). Finally, brain and can be analyzed at different levels, from neurons
age was also a variable affecting location and move- and synapses to anatomical regions and fiber tracts.77 There-
ment phenomenology, with putamen and caudate fore, the focal damage caused by a stroke may affect 1
appearing more frequently affected in those under 50. or multiple neural networks within a single structure. Thus,
Three studies have examined the clinical characteris- patients with stroke involving a given region (e.g., the
tics of PSMDs and have reported chorea, including thalamus) may suffer damage in 1 or more varying neu-
hemiballism (the most severe form), as the most common ronal networks, resulting in a spectrum of motor deficits.
PSMD, followed by dystonia.1,2,76 Our literature reap- In addition, the disruption of the network architecture
praisal showed that chorea, parkinsonism, dystonia, and may trigger different adaptive responses to ensure the
myoclonus were most commonly disorders among maintenance of motor function, which stand to alter the
patients with ischemic strokes. Dystonia was dispropor- movement disorder phenomenology.78,79 In particular, mal-
tionately more prevalent (accounting for two thirds of adaptive mechanisms like diaschisis, dedifferentiation, and
the cohort) in hemorrhaging cases. Ischemia was the most abnormal axonal regeneration may lead to an aberrant
common stroke mechanism, with thalamus and basal network function potentially manifesting as PSMD.77
ganglia the most common stroke localizations. Prior studies We found that patients with PSMD after hemorrhagic
underscore the inconsistencies between stroke localiza- strokes were younger compared with those presenting
tion and phenomenology. Mehanna and Jankovic’s study after ischemic stroke. In addition, younger age and hem-
sought to correlate movement phenomenology with other orrhagic type of stroke were independently associated with
stroke features. Similar to our study, they uncovered a a later onset of PSMD, beyond at least 1 month. We spec-
higher incidence of dystonia in younger patients and chorea ulate that the differences between these groups may be
in older patients. Our review is the first to assess due to the higher degree of resilience and neuroplasticity
POST-STROKE MOVEMENT DISORDERS 2393
in younger subjects and their decline with age.80,81 While are more likely to have more severe outcomes, includ-
diminished neuroplasticity results in limb paresis in some ing death or paresis (precluding later documentation of
cases, the ability of the neural networks to reorganize them- abnormal movements). Similar reasoning may apply to
selves may lead to aberrant network regeneration, ischemic strokes, where younger patients may be left with
manifesting as abnormal movements.82,83 In addition, the a lower prevalence of residual deficits compared with older
ability of the neural networks to reorganize themselves patients.
depends on the severity of the initial insult.84 We suggest There are several limitations to this literature reap-
that PSMDs are more likely to emerge after hemorrhag- praisal. First, it was based on reported cases that included
ic strokes in younger patients due to their higher degree a marked selection bias: while most PSMDs remain a small
of resilience (and at a longer latency due to stroke se- fraction of all strokes, it is likely that only a fraction of
verity), whereas older patients with hemorrhagic strokes this fraction has ever been reported, with more common
2394 R. SURI ET AL.
Figure 3. Latency according to type of stroke. * indicates significant difference (P < .05).
cases of poststroke chorea or dystonia becoming unlikely phenotype (e.g., potential for Lewy bodies and nigra de-
to be reported in the modern era. As a result, our find- generation in individuals with presumed poststroke
ings are not suitable to estimate prevalence assumptions parkinsonism). Despite these limitations, this is the first
after stroke types and localization in the general popu- comprehensive systematic review study to evaluate the
lation (e.g., it is uncertain whether the higher percentages distribution of PSMDs and their outcomes based on all
of movement disorders occurring in the first week after of the published cases (which may not be accrued from
strokes in patients older than 70 compared with those a single medical center) for which sufficient clinico-
younger than 50 are due to the shorter survival of the imaging data are available.
former group). Relatedly, a number of cases may have
been unique rather than representative of phenomena seen
Conclusion
during routine clinical practice. Moreover, most of these
case reports were not accompanied by video material and PSMDs remain an uncommon but important source of
the determination of the movement phenomenology may disability in neurology, with differences in phenomenol-
have been made by clinicians without specialized train- ogy and outcome that may result from selective network
ing in movement disorders, potentially leading to a vulnerability and resilience. A prospective epidemio-
percentage of mischaracterized phenotypes. Also, the ag- logic study would be desirable to determine which
gregated level of data from different studies did not allow elements of this evidence-mapping portrait may be ac-
the use of multivariable analysis. Due to mixed study curate and which may be embellished or misleading,
designs with small number of cases, the analysis could further refining the variables that may affect the frequen-
not account for weighting structure of each study. Finally, cy, type, and outcome of these secondary PSMDs.
we did not include abnormalities not considered “classic”
movement disorders, such as spasticity and apraxia, even
Appendix: Supplementary Material
though these may complicate strokes far more common-
ly and we lacked neuropathologic data to exclude Supplementary data to this article can be found online
comorbidities that may at least partially account for a given at doi:10.1016/j.jstrokecerebrovasdis.2018.04.028.
POST-STROKE MOVEMENT DISORDERS 2395
Figure 4. Outcome of poststroke movement disorders and locations involved for each.