Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Challenge Accepted!
Perspectives on Survivorship in Pediatric
Oncology
KEYWORDS
Survivors Late effects Long-term follow-up Patient advocacy
(Childhood cancer) survivor Patient-centered care
KEY POINTS
Cured does not always mean “being well.” Up to 75% of survivors deal with late effects.
Keeping the balance between coping and living life to the fullest can be a life-long
challenge.
There is a worldwide lack of structure for psychosocial and medical follow-up care. They
need to be developed.
Survivors need comprehensive and age-appropriate information about the risks they can
expect due to their cancer and treatments, what to do about their late effects, and where
to turn to.
More research must be carried out to reduce late-effects and optimize long-term care.
INTRODUCTION: BETWEEN THE KINGDOM OF THE SICK AND THE KINGDOM OF THE
WELL—CURED FROM CANCER BUT NOT WELL ENOUGH
In a very impressive New York Times blog article, Suleika Jaouad, an American jour-
nalist and leukemia survivor commented on Susan Sontag’s view that “Everyone who
is born holds dual citizenship, in the kingdom of the well and in the kingdom of the
sick.” She went on commenting that Susan Sontag did not mention that there was
also a third kingdom, “no-man’s land,” that exists between the 2 kingdoms, inhabited
by people such as Suleika, who are neither sick nor well.1
a
Österreichische Kinder-Krebs-Hilfe (ÖKKH), Childhood Cancer International Europe, Borsch-
kegasse 1/7, Wien 1090, Austria; b Vereniging Ouders, Kinderen en Kanker, Childhood Cancer
International Europe, Schouwstede 2b, Nieuwegein 3431 JB, The Netherlands; c Kinderkrebs
Schweiz, Childhood Cancer International Europe, Dornacherstrasse 154, Basel 4053,
Switzerland
* Corresponding author.
E-mail address: c.schneider@ccieurope.eu
Before I got sick, I knew exactly if I wanted kids or not, just like I knew that I wanted
to become a lawyer, or like I knew that I would run a marathon before I would turn 30
years. I tried to hold on to these ideas and dreams for as long as I could, after having
been diagnosed and treated, hoping that I would soon be able to step back into my old
life. But then 1 day I may realize that I am too fatigued to keep up with university or that
surgery or some serious side effects from chemotherapy will actually prevent me from
running a marathon in my life. Similarly, 1 day I may discover that I will have no choice
in having a child of my own.. whether I ever wanted one or not.
It can be hard to keep up with my peers who seem to have unlimited energy,
whereas I feel drained. At times, I don’t really understand why I am not like them,
even though I do my best and give everything I have. Accepting that my “new normal”
can be a lifelong challenge.
Keeping a Balance
Many of us carry our inside and outside scars with us. Sometimes, there is not a day
without having it on our minds. On good days, it’s easy to deal with it. On bad days,
this is what being cured means: being neither sick nor well.
When saying that aloud, we don’t want anyone to get us wrong: the health care pro-
fessionals, our families, friends and also myself, we all did everything possible to fight
my cancer and have me survive. And yes, I am grateful. I, and many others like myself,
live a good life, and we are glad we survived and we enjoy every moment we can. But
sometimes it needs to be possible to express that the happy parts of survival are also
intertwined with the difficult parts of survival.
It needs to be possible to express that, unfortunately, the harsh reality is that
everyone needs to be aware that after treatments and follow-up care, not all survivors
will live in the “kingdom of the well.”
1014 Schneider et al
Unmet Needs
Treatment might have cured our bodies of cancer, but it also left many of us with major
challenges: fertility concerns, cardiac problems, neuropsychological issues, orthopedic
problems, anxiety, body image issues, endocrine disorders, or even with the risk of devel-
oping a new cancer. Worst of all, many of us still do not know what real challenges lay
ahead, many of us still do not have adequate care to tackle these issues with us.
And this is why—in the “no man’s land between the kingdom of the well and the
kingdom of the sick”—we need to be educated and informed about what we might
have to deal with. We need to know what we might expect, in order to know what
to be aware of, in order to understand why we need to go to our follow-up appoint-
ments. We need to be transitioned from pediatric experts to adult experts, providers
who know how to deal with our late effects. We need to know where to turn to with our
health and psychosocial issues, we need to know where our needs are met with the
adequate expertise, know-how, and understanding. Only this way can we take re-
sponsibility for our own health and the life we have fought for so hard to keep.
Certainly, the experiences described here do not apply to 100% of childhood cancer
survivors (CCS). Not all encounter problems, not all encounter the same problems or
experience the same challenges. Still, the majority of survivors are or will be con-
fronted with some kind of physical and psychosocial issues, and the above section de-
picts experiences that many CCS face in their daily lives. Some survivors certainly
show enormous resilience and live their lives no matter what. But as patient advocates
it is our responsibility to support those who still need to find ways to cope and regain
control over their lives.
This is the reason for the establishment of peer support groups and patient advo-
cates at the local, national, and international level. By exchanging our different expe-
riences, we realized that the problems we face as survivors are very similar around the
globe and that was reason enough for national survivor-representatives to get
together, team up, and start patient advocacy work on an international level. Within
Childhood Cancer International (CCI), a global umbrella organization representing
childhood cancer organizations around the world, we ensure that together our voices
are heard even louder.
Today, there are many survivor-representatives, parent-representatives, childhood
cancer organizations, and medical and psychosocial health care professionals around
the globe who are working together to develop structures for long-term care, with the
aim to improve the quality of survivorship.
In 1975, Dr Giulio D’Angio was one of the first medical specialists to acknowledge
that “cure is not enough.”2 His paper has had a huge impact on pediatric oncology.
His assertion that “cure was not enough” was the reason that medical professionals,
parents, and survivors came together in Erice (Italy) in 2007, to have a workshop on
long-term follow-up care. This workshop led to the so-called Erice Statement: 10
key points summarizing the essential components of cure and care for CCS.3 The
Erice Statement can be seen as the start of what we now know as the PanCare
Network,4 a multidisciplinary pan-European network of professionals, survivors, and
their families to improve the care and quality of life of CCS by means of research
and guideline development.
Ten years later, in November 2016, 65 pediatric cancer experts, including parents
and CCS, from 17 European countries and North America, met again in Erice to review
Surviving Survival 1015
the original statement. An updated version was subsequently published.5 The original
and revised statement most importantly point out that
“There is an additional need for continuing systematic follow-up after cure for sur-
veillance of potential long-term effects of the cancer or its treatment. To this end, every
Pediatric Care Unit should have a well-structured “long-term follow-up clinic” with
care plans based on risk stratification and evidence-based guidelines and a multidis-
ciplinary team.”3,5
It is clear that there is still significant work to be done with regard to providing
adequate care after the cure of childhood cancer.
Survivor representatives attending a meeting organized by the Childhood Cancer In-
ternational Survivors Network (CCISN) in Dublin (2016) wrote a declaration in which the
views of survivors on survivorship are being pointed out. This so-called Declaration of
Dublin (DoD) comprises issues that are encountered by CCS worldwide, including
inadequate transition, lack of psychosocial care, discrimination, lack of informa-
tion—reconfirming that there is still much to be done in to improve quality of
survivorship.6
Because of this declaration, advances at the advocacy level have been made. The
need for a survivor’s voice was necessary at the continental level, which led to the
establishment of a Europe-wide survivors network under the umbrella of CCI Europe.
At the 2017 CCI Europe conference in Rome, 9 survivor representatives from 7 Euro-
pean countries started a network that now has grown to more than 20 representatives
and fosters a close collaboration in the field of survivorship care and research in
Europe.
Fig. 1. #RaiseYourHands4Survivors: up to 75% of survivors will suffer from late effects. Mes-
sage 1: eighty percent of patients with childhood cancer survive and then? In Europe, each
year 15,000 children and adolescents are diagnosed with cancer. About 80% survive due to
multimodal treatment methods. This high cure rate comes with a price: It comes with the
price of possible chronic health conditions. According to current research, about 2/3 as
many as up to 75% of childhood and adolescent cancer survivors will suffer from at least
one adverse late effect of their prior cancer and its treatment. Approximately 1/3 of these
survivors will suffer from severe late effects with major impacts on their daily lives.13,14
1016 Schneider et al
#RaiseYourHands4Survivors
Another important milestone for survivors was marked by CCI Europe’s awareness
campaign #RaiseYourHands4Survivors, which was developed in cooperation with
the Austrian Childhood Cancer Organization ÖKKH.10
Since the formulation of the DoD, patient advocates from CCI Europe and its survi-
vors network have put the survivorship topics in the spotlight. In early 2019, this
resulted in the development of a Europe-wide social media campaign, which so far
has reached 60,000 people, including survivors, parents, and childhood cancer orga-
nizations all around the world.
Fully aware of the inequalities in access to and differences in quality of care—which
often depends on the economic situation of the respective country—survival rates
vary drastically around the globe. Luckily, there are initiatives that envision tackling
this problem.11
In some countries, however, survival rates are greater than 80%,12 leading to the
growing necessity for infrastructure to improve quality of survivorship.
Drawing on European numbers and realities, the #RaiseYourHands4Survivors
campaign addresses survivors, health care providers, and politicians and points at
4 main messages: the reality of late effects; the need for relevant and credible informa-
tion; the need for adequate follow-up care; and the need for research.
The campaign comprised more than 20 Facebook posts (Figs. 1–4) that were
posted during February 15th, the International Childhood Cancer Day (ICCD) and
the childhood cancer awareness month September. It also included 2 awareness
movies (Fig. 5) that have been shot in cooperation with the European Reference
Network for Pediatric Cancers (ERN PaedCan) and a petition in support of better
follow-up care services that will be brought up before the European Parliament.
cured, in some middle- and low-income countries the cure rate is only as high as
20%.11
This, however, does not change the fact that most of those who do survive will have
late effects and that they will need full disclosure about their risks and adequate follow-
up care. The day before the SIOP/CCI conference in Dublin in 2016, almost 40 survivor
representatives—patient advocates—from numerous countries, including Austria,
Germany, Hong Kong, India, Ireland, Japan, the Netherlands, and South Africa, voiced
their requests:
Survivors of childhood cancer may develop medical and psychosocial late effects
that severely impact their quality of life. Therefore, comprehensive long-term
follow-up care is essential. We ask that adequate long-term follow-up clinics
are established, where survivors can have access to personalized follow-up
care. We ask for more research on late effects so that survivor care services
can be improved.
Inadequate transition from childhood cancer care to adult medical care can result
in a lack of knowledge and understanding of the impact and consequences of
childhood cancer by the treating health professional(s). It is essential that these
health professionals have a thorough understanding of the needs of cancer survi-
vors. We request for full disclosure and sharing of our medical history and poten-
tial risks to our current and future health.
Although cancer is a major cause of death amongst children around the world, it is
important to convey to the general public that childhood cancer is often curable
and that the survivors’ population is increasing globally each year. We urge you
to work with us to educate the general public in order to dispel misconceptions
and myths about childhood cancer.
With the support and commitment of all stakeholders, childhood cancer survivors
can be actively engaged in society and live their lives to the fullest.’
—The declaration of Dublin. The CCISN. Dublin, October 18th, 20166
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Thank you to all survivor representatives from the CCISN involved in the making of the
Declaration of Dublin; to the Austrian Childhood Cancer Organization for developing
the campaign together with CCI Europe; to the ERN PaedCan for the possibility to
1020 Schneider et al
produce the awareness movies; and to SIOPE, PanCare, and the global network of
CCI for their continuous partnership. For more information visit us at: CCI Europe
www.ccieurope.eu; CCI www.childhoodcancerinternational.org; PanCare www.
pancare.eu; SIOPE www.siope.eu; ERN PaedCan http://paedcan.ern-net.eu/; www.
pancarefollowup.eu; www.survivorshippassport.org; To watch the awareness movies,
go to: https://ccieurope.eu/survivors/
DISCLOSURE
REFERENCES
1. Jaouad S. Lost in Transition after Cancer. In: Life, interrupted. 2015. Available at:
https://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/03/16/lost-in-transition-after-cancer/. Ac-
cessed November, 13, 2019.
2. D’Angio GJ. Pediatric cancer in perspective: Cure is not enough. Cancer 1975;
35(S3):866–70.
3. Haupt R, Spinetta JJ, Ban I, et al. Long term survivors of childhood cancer: Cure
and care. The Erice Statement. Eur J Cancer 2007;43:1778–80.
4. Jankovic M, Haupt R, Spinetta JJ, et al. Long-term survivors of childhood cancer:
cure and care-the Erice Statement (2006) revised after 10 years (2016). J Cancer
Surviv 2018;12(5):647–50.
5. Hjorth L, Haupt R, Skinner R, et al. Survivorship after childhood cancer: PanCare:
A European Network to promote optimal long-term care. Eur J Cancer 2015;51:
1203–11.
6. Childhood Cancer International Survivors Network. The Declaration of Dublin.
Available at: https://www.childhoodcancerinternational.org/understanding-
childhood-cancer/facts-on-survivorship/. Accessed November 13, 2019.
7. Haupt R, Essiaf S, Dellacasa C, et al. The ‘Survivorship Passport’ for childhood
cancer survivors. Eur J Cancer 2018;102:69e81.
8. PanCareFollowUp. What is PanCareFollowUp?. Available at: http://
pancarefollowup.eu/about/. Accessed November 13, 2019.
9. Loonen J, Blijlevens NM, Prins J, et al. Cancer survivorship care: person centered
care in a multidisciplinary shared care model. Int J Integr Care 2018;18(1):4.
10. CCI Europe. RaiseYourHands4Survivors. Petition. Available at: www.ccieurope.
eu/petition. Accessed: November 13, 2019.
11. World Health Organization WHO. Cancer in Children. Available at: https://www.
who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/cancer-in-children. Accessed: November
23, 2019.
12. Gatta G, Botta L, Rossi S, et al. Childhood cancer survival in Europe 1999–2007:
results of EUROCARE-5—a population-based study. Lancet Oncol 2014;15:
35–47.
13. Oeffinger KC, Mertens AC, Sklar CA, et al. Chronic health conditions in adult sur-
vivors of childhood cancer. N Engl J Med 2006;355:1572–82.
14. Hudson MM, Mertens AC, Yasui Y, et al. Health status of adult long-term survivors
of childhood cancer. JAMA 2003;290(12):1583–92.