Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Rio de Janeiro
August 2020
Abstract of the Thesis proposal presented to Programa de Engenharia Mecânica,
Coppe – UFRJ, as a partial requirement for the doctorate candidature, as a partial
requirement for the scholarship grant.
AUGUST/2020
Tensegrity comes from the concept that the structure relies in the interaction
between tension and compression, opposing forces to maintain the structure integrity.
Tensegrity structures are self-standing, lightweight with stiffening behavior under
external loads. Biological systems present several characteristics of tensegrity structures
such as the legs of animals that usually endure various extreme situations, as impact and
vibrations. Essentially, tensegrity structures are composed by bars (struts) and strings
(cables), where the bars work under compression whereas the strings work under tension.
Animal legs have the same characteristics where the bars represent the bones while the
strings represent the tendons.
i
SUMMARY
1. INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................... 1
5. REFERENCES ...................................................................................................... 17
ii
1. INTRODUCTION
1
the first tensegrity has appeared, there is still not a cabal definition of it, but it is usually
defined as “islands of compression in an ocean of tension” (Fuller, 1962).
One way to visualize what is a tensegrity structure is to observe if exists an
arrangement of strings that connects and stabilizes a set of rigid bodies (Figure 1b). If the
configuration of rigid bodies cannot be stabilized by any set of strings, then it does not
constitute a tensegrity configuration (Figure 1a). A tensegrity system (Figure 1c) is
composed by any set of strings connected to a tensegrity configuration (Figure 1b)
(Skelton & Oliveira, 2009).
2
(a) (b)
(a) (b)
(c)
3
(a) (b)
(c)
In the macroscale, tensegrity structures can represent the structure of the cosmos,
where the nodes represent the planets and their interactions are represented by invisible
bars and strings members. Due to the broadness of tensegrity structures, since their
beginning as art works, their applications have been consistently increasing in a large
variety of fields.
Smart materials can be synergistic combined with tensegrity creating adaptive
self-expandable structures. In addition, one can even attempt to use an origami or a
kirigami structure in consonance with the tensegrity. The bars and strings can represent
the bones and the muscles, and origami (or kirigami) structure can define the clothing that
represents the skin. Based on this idea, the whole animal can serve as a design inspiration.
Figure 5 shows examples of tensegrity and kirigami structures that could be combined as
just mentioned.
4
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
Wu et al. (2015) and Pan et al. (2018) have got inspired by birds’ legs to develop
a 2D structure (planar structure) and explored its softening and stiffening properties for
vibration isolation, but they have not utilized the tensegrity concepts.
The proposal deals with the analysis of a Minimal Regular Tensegrity Prism (T-
Prism) to represent an animal leg. A T-Prism can be generated from a twisted regular
5
dihedron of any number of sides p . The twist is necessary to make the structure stable
and, without it, the structure would fall off limp. The twist angle is responsible to alter
the geometry and the forces distribution along the structure. In the case of a trigonal
dihedron ( p = 3 ), the twist angle is , and the resultant tensegrity structure is
6 2
called a simplex tensegrity for being the simplest 3D tensegrity structure possible. Figure
6 shows an analogy for the construction of the tensegrity prism structure from a trigonal
dihedron. Figure 6a shows the starting dihedron, then its top face is twisted (Figure 6b)
and, after that, the bars are diagonally put on the side faces of the twisted dihedron (Figure
6c). Next, the horizontal (bottom and top) strings are tied to the bars (Figure 6d) and
finally the vertical strings (Figure 6e). Now, eliminating the solid dihedron, only the
tensegrity prism structure remains (Figure 6f).
6
The tensegrity prism is modeled considering the possibility of using strings made
of smart materials (SM), e.g., Shape Memory Alloys (SMA), to confer adaptability for
the system. Analysis regarding different height, radius, bars and strings stiffness are
performed. The analysis target the investigation of the structure stiffness in the vertical
direction for compression resistance.
The work is structured in three chapters. After this introduction, where the main
features of the tensegrity structures are presented as well as some examples of applied
tensegrity. The second chapter is devoted to the literature review, and presents a survey
of the works that have been made in the field of tensegrity structures.
The third chapter is dedicated to the conclusion of the research proposal.
7
2. LITERATURE REVIEW
8
Skelton and Oliveira (2009) stated that the goal of the tensegrity structure design,
although not mandatory, is to assure that the members are unidirectionally loaded, so that
no member has to serve both compressive and tensile functions. Hence, the strings only
carry tension, but when compression force is applied they go slack. When slacking of the
strings happen, it is worthy to consider replacing it for a bar and vice-versa, if a bar goes
under traction, it is worthwhile consider replacement by a string. However, in the place
of a string one could consider an element that can undergo compression as well as tension
without slacking, e.g., a spring. Although, in most scenarios, the string is considered.
Bansod et al. (2014) present an overview of tensegrity structures and highlight its
main features as being self-standing modulated structures having a higher load-bearing
capacity with similar weight or as being lightweight with similar resistance if compared
to conventional structures. Self-standing structures are those whom do not need to be
anchored or have to lean in any surface, since they are stable by its tensile and
compressive members through the means of prestresses structures. In addition, modulated
structures are those whom are made of elementary modules that can be used to assemble
structures that are more complex. Furthermore, Tensegrities are sensitive to vibrations
under dynamic loading, thus slight changes in load causes the structure to redistribute the
stress in the whole structure instantaneously, making the structure to respond as whole.
The load-deformation response of the structure is nonlinear and its stiffness increases
rapidly with the load. The main advantages of the tensegrity structures lie in the fact that
since the load is distributed in the whole structure, there are no critical points; they can
naturally adapt itself to deformations and vibrations, hence, are very interesting for
developing smart structures, sensors and actuators; larger, tending to the infinity,
structures can be built from elementary blocks. Therefore, they are highly resilient and at
the same time very economical. In contrast, the major disadvantage of the tensegrity
structures is the fabrication complexity and assembly, also there is a lack of adequate
design tools available and as the structure grows in quantity of members it becomes hard
to avoid interference between bars, in other words, to avoid that they touch each other.
The authors classify tensegrity structures into three main categories: tensegrity prism,
diamond tensegrity and zig-zag tensegrity. Another way of classifying is into four main
categories based on its basic tendon patterns of construction: spherical system, star
system, irregular system and cylindrical system. The overview focuses on the spherical
systems due its large-scale application in generating a broad variety of tensegrity
9
structures. Spherical systems can be further subdivided into three categories: rhombic,
circuit and zig-zag configurations, as depicted in Figure 7.
Termonia (1994) and Simmons, Michal and Jelinski (1996) analyzed the spider
silk using magnetic resonance and X-Ray data, respectively. The silk is described as being
composed of a complex-folded protein primarily made of two amino acids, glycine and
alanine, one highly oriented and other poorly oriented, which can be modeled as a
microscale tensegrity model. The Nephila Clavipes, a spider usually known as the golden
orb weaver, produces nature’s strongest fiber. Hence the spider silk has very interesting
properties, since it is stronger than steel and its tensile strength is similar of Kevlar,
although having an extremely high elasticity. This uncommon feature of high strength
and stretch presents toughness values never obtained in synthetic (man-made) high-
performance fibers.
The erythrocyte (red blood cell) membrane is a lipid bilayer (membrane) that has
33 thousand units, forming a junction complex (protofilament), that resemble tensegrity
models attached to its under-side. The lipid bilayer has remarkable static and dynamic
comportment. The protofilament is rigid compared to the rest of the components, so it can
be modeled as rigid bar, while the spectrin are elastic and can be modeled as elastic
tendons. Vera et al. (2005) have developed a mesoscale tensegrity structure to model one
cell of 33 thousand cells of the junction complex. Through numerical simulations using
different initial conditions to study unhealthy behavior of the cells, the model presented
good agreement with experimental data. This model can represent the underlying
mechanisms in a variety of physiological and pathological occurrences in erythrocytes.
In addition, this study may serve to the purpose of establishing the base to understand and
predict nanomechanics at molecular level and lay down the base for the designing
artificial network structures in biomedical applications and material science. Cañadas et
al. (2002), Sultan et al. (2004), and other similar studies using tensegrity to model living
cells can also be found in the literature.
Eckberg and Pearson (2005) performed computer simulations to study the
physiology of cat’s hind legs. A tensegrity-like 3D structure was utilized as a model,
where controllers were employed to actuate two different signals: one force related to the
force ankle extensors; and one related to the angle at the hip joint. The two signals have
11
a fundamental importance in understanding the terminating stance of the hind legs: one
related to unloading the leg and the other to hip extension. Through a series of
simulations, the conclusion reached was that coordination of hind legs are highly
dependent on load-sensitive signals from each leg, also the linkages between legs, in
addition to the signals, play a very important role in establishing the alternating walk.
Scarr (2011) experimentally examines an elbow from a tensegrity perspective,
where the elbow is depicted as a uniaxial hinge rotation with pivot of proximal forearm
rotation. The motions of the elbow are guided by the joint surfaces, while the ligaments
serve the purpose of maintain structural integrity and the muscles drive the motion. The
model has a relevance to shed a light in common pathologies, such as “tennis elbow” and
“repetitive strain injure”, which remain as an open debate.
Sun et al. (2019) utilizes the tensegrity concept to model a robotic foot for the
purpose of adaptive locomotion on complex terrain, without control, with improved
deformability, impact resistance and adaptability to environmental solicitations. An
analytical model is developed to derive the behavior of the mechanism proposed and to
calibrate the stiffnesses. To simulate the foot locomotion, numerical simulations are
carried out using ADAMS. In addition, for last, an experimental prototype is constructed
to verify the features of the proposed terrain-adaptive locomotion mechanism. The
theoretical, numerical and experimental responses are compared to verify the
effectiveness of the propose mechanism. The results show that the developed foot can
mimic the human foot remarkably well, even in complex terrain, while being relatively
simple and lightweight. Thus, it is concluded that tensegrity structures offer new avenues
of research and several advantages over traditional rigid
systems.Equation Chapter (Next) Section 1
3. MATHEMATICAL MODELING
F −W = 0 (1)
For the simplex tensegrity structure (Figure 8), equations (2) and (3) together with
equation (1) represent the equilibrium of the whole structure.
13
3r 0 3r 2 3r 0 3r 2 r r 3 4
2 + 2 − − − − − − 3 3 − r 3 5 + r 3 3 + r 3 5 +
2 2 2 − 2
2
3 1 3 r 8 1 3 3
− 1 r 6 − r 7 − − r 7 + r 3 4 − 1 r 6 +
2 2 2 2 2 2 + 2
2
3 r 1 3 3 1
− −1 − r 0 − 1 + r 2 −1 − r 0 r 8 r 1 +
3
r 2
2 2 2 +
2 2
2 2 2 2
1 r 3 2 3 3r 3 3r 4 3 r
F = r 3 − − r 3 0 − r 3 1 − 3r 1 + − − r 3 + + + − 4
−
0 2 2 2 2 2 2
2
r 3 3 1 3 3 1 3 r 6
2 − r 7 − 1 − r 8 − − r 7 − 1 − r 8 + +
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
(2)
r 6 r 0 3 −1 3 r 0 3 1 3
+ + 1 + r 1 − r 2 1 + r 1 − − r 2
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
−h0 6 − h0 0 −h0 7 − h0 1 −h0 8 − h0 2 h0 7 + h0 0 h0 8 + h0 1 h0 6 + h02
14
W0 x W1x W2 x W3 x W4 x W5 x
W = W0 y W1 y W2 y W3 y W4 y W5 y (3)
W0 z W1z W2 z W3 z W4 z W5 z
Equation Chapter (Next) Section 1 The objective of this research is the nonlinear
mechanics investigation of tensegrity structures, especially smart bioinspired structures
actuated by smart materials. Human foot is one example of such structures that can be
used as prothesis. Nonlinear dynamics is of special interest.
For this intent, the following tasks can be proposed and summarized
through Table 1.
Tasks:
1. Subject matters;
2. Literature review;
3. Numerical implementation;
4. Nonlinear analysis;
5. Text writing.
2024
Taks 2021 2022 2023
1 X X
2 X X X
3 X X X
4 X X X
5 X X
16
5. REFERENCES
BERCK, P., SYDSÆTER, K., BERCK, P., et al. "Kronecker products and the vec
operator", Economists’ Mathematical Manual, p. 113–115, 1993. DOI: 10.1007/978-
3-662-11597-8_22
CAÑADAS, P., LAURENT, V. M., ODDOU, C., et al. "A cellular tensegrity model to
analyse the structural viscoelasticity of the cytoskeleton", Journal of Theoretical
Biology, v. 218, n. 2, p. 155–173, 2002. DOI: 10.1006/jtbi.2002.3064.
EKEBERG, Ö., PEARSON, K. "Computer simulation of stepping in the hind legs of the
cat: An examination of mechanisms regulating the stance-to-swing transition", Journal
of Neurophysiology, v. 94, n. 6, p. 4256–4268, 2005. DOI: 10.1152/jn.00065.2005.
17
HANDBOOK, B. R. Biomimicry Resource Handbook. [S.l: s.n.], 2011.
HUTSON, M., WARD, A. Musculoskeletal medicine. 2nd. ed. [S.l.], Oxford, 2003.
LEON, S. E., PAULINO, G. H., PEREIRA, A., et al. "A unified library of nonlinear
solution schemes", Applied Mechanics Reviews, v. 64, n. 4, 2011. DOI:
10.1115/1.4006992. .
MOTRO, R. Tensegrity, Structural Systems for the Future. [S.l.], Kogan Page
Limited, 2003.
PAN, H., JING, X., SUN, W., et al. "Analysis and Design of a Bioinspired Vibration
Sensor System in Noisy Environment", IEEE/ASME Transactions on Mechatronics,
v. 23, n. 2, p. 845–855, 2018. DOI: 10.1109/TMECH.2018.2803284.
18
American Association for the Advancement of Science Stable URL :
http://www.jstor.org/stable/2890379", Advancement Of Science, v. 271, n. 5245, p. 84–
87, 2010.
SUN, J., SONG, G., CHU, J., et al. "An Adaptive Bioinspired Foot Mechanism Based on
Tensegrity Structures", Soft Robotics, v. 6, n. 6, p. 778–789, 2019. DOI:
10.1089/soro.2018.0168.
VERA, C., SKELTON, R., BOSSENS, F., et al. "3-D nanomechanics of an erythrocyte
junctional complex in equibiaxial and anisotropic deformations", Annals of Biomedical
Engineering, v. 33, n. 10, p. 1387–1404, 2005. DOI: 10.1007/s10439-005-4698-y.
WU, Z., JING, X., BIAN, J., et al. "Vibration isolation by exploring bio-inspired
structural nonlinearity", Bioinspiration and Biomimetics, v. 10, n. 5, p. 56015, 2015.
DOI: 10.1088/1748-3190/10/5/056015.
YUAN, X. F., MA, S., JIANG, S. H. "Form-finding of tensegrity structures based on the
Levenberg–Marquardt method", Computers and Structures, v. 192, p. 171–180, 2017.
DOI: 10.1016/j.compstruc.2017.07.005.
19
20