Professional Documents
Culture Documents
a
Sorbonne Universités, UPMC Université Paris 6, APHP, Service de Médecine Foetale, b Sorbonne Universités,
UPMC Université Paris 6, APHP, Unité de Foetopathologie, c APHP, Service de Néonatologie, and d APHP, Service de
Key Words performed in three cases: one case within the context of se-
Congenital toxoplasmosis infection · Ultrasound · vere maternal schizophrenia with isolated hyperechogenic
Prognosis · Cerebral lesions foci, one case where hyperechogenic foci were associated
with extensive lesions of the white matter, and one case for
severe fetal hydrops. Conclusion: The neurological progno-
Abstract sis of cerebral hyperechogenic lesions without ventriculo-
Objective: To evaluate the neurodevelopmental and ocular megaly in fetal toxoplasmosis infection may be favorable.
outcome of a continuous retrospective series of fetal toxo- The risk of ocular damage however remains high and unpre-
plasmosis infections for which prenatal ultrasound (US) fol- dictable in the prenatal period. © 2016 S. Karger AG, Basel
low-up revealed abnormal cerebral findings without associ-
ated ventriculomegaly. Materials and Methods: We retro-
spectively reviewed all cases of proven fetal Toxoplasma
gondii infection with fetal cerebral anomalies at US examina- Introduction
tion without significant ventriculomegaly (≥10 mm) evalu-
ated in our center over a 5-year period. US and magnetic Maternal primary infection by Toxoplasma gondii
resonance imaging findings were collected. The neurodevel- during pregnancy may result in fetal infection with the
opmental and ocular outcomes of the cases were studied. potential risk of mild or severe lesions. The justification
Results: Nine fetuses were included. Hyperechogenic foci of of both maternal biological systematic screening [1] and
the cerebral parenchyma were isolated in five cases. Among prenatal treatment still remain controversial [2, 3]. Thus,
those, four children had normal neurological development. few countries have implemented toxoplasmosis infection
Amblyopia was detected in on case. Hyperechogenic foci screening in the prenatal care for normal pregnancies.
were associated with other anomalies of cerebral parenchy- The prenatal diagnosis of toxoplasmosis is based either
ma in three cases among which two children had normal on maternal primary infection or on the detection of fetal
neurological development. Termination of pregnancy was anomalies on routine fetal ultrasound (US) examination.
144.82.108.120 - 6/7/2016 4:14:11 AM
E-Mail karger@karger.com
26 avenue A. Netter, FR–75012 Paris (France)
www.karger.com/fdt
E-Mail jean-marie.jouannic @ aphp.fr
UCL
The aim of prenatal diagnosis is to identify the most se- tions were thereafter scheduled on a yearly basis. Visual acuity was
vere cases associated with fetal cerebral damage. Ventric- assessed using Parinaud charts for children up to 3 years of age. All
neonates received a specific 12-month pyrimethamine-sulfadia-
ular dilation is a frequent ultrasonographic sign that is zine treatment [5].
easy to demonstrate. This progressive hydrocephaly is
due to necrotizing lesions in the periaqueductal area and
carries a poor prognosis. Other cerebral locations of the
encephalopathy may exist without ventricular dilation Results
[4]. However, there are few data on the prognosis of these
cerebral parenchymal lesions. Nine cases of fetal infection for toxoplasmosis with
We aimed to evaluate the neurodevelopmental and oc- anomalies of the cerebral parenchyma and no associated
ular outcome of a continuous retrospective series of in- ventriculomegaly were identified (table 1). Fetal infection
fected fetuses for which prenatal US follow-up revealed occurred during the second trimester in six cases. In three
abnormal cerebral findings without associated ventricu- other cases the available maternal serum did not allow to
lomegaly. formally exclude fetal first-trimester infection based on
avidity tests on IgG.
Materials and Methods Fetal Imaging Findings
We retrospectively reviewed all cases of proven fetal T. gondii Fetal cerebral anomalies were identified by US exami-
infection with fetal cerebral anomalies at US examination without nation at a median gestational age of 31+5 weeks (range
significant ventriculomegaly (≥10 mm) evaluated in our center 24.0–34.5 weeks). In one case fetal toxoplasmosis infec-
over a 5-year period (January 2010 to January 2015). The gesta- tion was diagnosed as part of the prenatal investigation
tional age at maternal seroconversion was estimated by maternal for a fetal hydrops observed during third-trimester rou-
serum analysis, including avidity test for IgG when required. The
prenatal data collected included (1) time of maternal infection tine scan. An US examination performed at 32+5 weeks
classified as first-, second- or third-trimester infection, and (2) re- revealed multiple (>10) echogenic nodular foci through-
sults of PCR analysis for T. gondii in the amniotic fluid. In cases of out the cerebral parenchyma. Hepatosplenomegaly asso-
proven fetal infection, patients received a specific treatment using ciated with myocardial hypertrophy was also noted. Fetal
pyrimethamine + sulfadiazine. hydrops worsened and termination of pregnancy (TOP)
According to our protocol of prenatal follow-up in case of
proven fetal toxoplasmosis infection, monthly US examinations was performed at 34 weeks (case 9).
were performed using a Voluson Expert VE8 (General Electric In the eight other cases, cerebral anomalies were de-
Medical Systems, Zipf, Austria) or an Applio unit (Toshiba, Tokyo, tected within the context of a specific US follow-up for a
Japan). All US scans were performed transabdominally and the proven infection of the fetus (PCR positive on amniotic
transvaginal route was not necessary in order to obtain satisfac- fluid). In these cases, one or multiple echogenic nodular
tory central nervous system evaluation. Magnetic resonance imag-
ing (MRI) examination was performed in cases of abnormal fetal foci (fig. 1) were observed at third-trimester US examina-
cerebral US findings on a 1.5-Tesla unit (Achieva Philips Medical tion (29–34 weeks) in seven cases and at 24 weeks in one
Systems, Best, The Netherlands) 30–40 min following fetal seda- case (case 3).
tion achieved by maternal oral administration of flunitrazepam In three out of eight cases, these echogenic nodular foci
(1 mg). Fetal brain examination was performed using a phased- were associated with other cerebral findings. In two cases
array abdominal coil, T1-weighted spin echo, spectral presatura-
tion inversion recovery, fat-saturated sequences (693/14/2; flip (cases 1 and 2), 5–10 echogenic nodular foci were found
angle 90°; matrix 256 × 125; field of view 320 mm; section thickness at US examination performed at 33 and 34 weeks, respec-
4 mm; acquisition time 2 min 56 s) and T2-weighted single-shot tively. In both cases, abnormal echogenicity and thicken-
turbo spin echo sequences (15,000/120/1 flip angle, 90°; turbo spin ing of the germinal matrix were observed below the fron-
echo factor 102; matrix 256 × 170; field of view 300 mm; section tal horns at US examination (fig. 2). In case 1, an echo-
thickness 2 mm; acquisition time 45 s). In some cases, T2*- and
diffusion-weighted imaging sequences were added. All prenatal genic lesion of the left thalamus was also observed (fig. 3).
imaging was reviewed by an expert radiologist (C.G.). No additional cerebral anomalies were found at MRI. In
Postnatal evaluation included complete clinical and neurologi- the third case (case 7), multiple echogenic nodular foci
cal evaluation of the neonates using the revised Brunet-Lezine were observed throughout the cerebral brain at 31 weeks.
scale within the first 2 weeks and every 3 months during the first Multiple echogenic areas of the white matter were present
year. A systematic transfontanellar US examination was per-
formed during the first month of life. Ocular examinations, includ- in the subcortical, periaqueductal and periventricular re-
ing ocular fundus examinations, were performed every 3 months gions. MRI examination confirmed multiple lesions of
during the first year and at 15, 18 and 24 months. Ocular examina- the fetal brain and TOP was performed at 33 weeks.
144.82.108.120 - 6/7/2016 4:14:11 AM
6 14 – 20 26 + 5 27 + 2 31 + 5 1 parenchymal focus; rhizomelic shortening of 39 + 0 Transfontanellar US: 5 foci (1 right frontal, 2 right
2 additional parenchymal long bones at 32 WG 2,905 g parietal, 2 left parietal)
foci at 36 WG; no with subsequently 35 cm Neurodevelopmental delay: none
ventriculomegaly maintained growth Fundus oculi exam: normal
Visual sequela: no visual impairment
Postnatal regimen: pyrimethamine + sulfadoxine
(12 months)
Follow-up: 24 months
9 <30 31 + 1 – 32 + 5 multiple parenchymal severe fetal hydrops at TOP Pathological findings: toxoplasmic fetopathy with
nodular foci; no 32 WG: fetal anemia and 34 + 0 multivisceral involvement: interstitial
ventriculomegaly toxoplasmic fetopathy 2,280 g mononuclear infiltrates in the lung, kidneys,
32 cm myocardium, bowel and liver; cerebral findings:
diffuse lesions of vasculitis associated with
multiple limited lesions of necrosis disseminated
in the periventricular white matter, foci
surrounded by inflammatory lesions and
calcifications
BW = Birth weight; GA = gestational age; HC = head circumference; n.a. = not available; WG = weeks gestation.
* Amniotic fluid sampling declined by the patient.
In the other five cases (cases 3, 4, 5, 6 and 8), echogen- Our results demonstrate the importance of closely
ic nodular foci were isolated. In one case, TOP was per- monitoring the fetal cerebral anatomy in cases of proven
formed at 30 weeks within the context of severe maternal and treated fetal infection with T. gondii. Moreover, they
schizophrenia (case 8). emphasize the need to carefully examine the brain paren-
chyma, including in cases where no ventriculomegaly is
Pregnancy and Neonatal Outcomes noted. The majority of our cases were related to a second-
Postmortem examinations were performed in all three trimester maternal infection and the cerebral anomalies
cases where patients opted for TOP. In case 9, several in- were detected several weeks later, until 34 weeks. This
144.82.108.120 - 6/7/2016 4:14:11 AM
long period of time between the onset of fetal infection tis during childhood [12]. To the best of our knowledge,
and the appearance of the first anomalies of the fetal brain the association between these calcifications and the neu-
has already been reported [4]. This observation makes it rodevelopment of the children has not yet been specifi-
essential to continue monitoring these cases until the end cally assessed. In the prenatal period, cerebral hyper-
of pregnancy. echogenic foci have been described in case of congenital
The majority of studies on congenital toxoplasmosis toxoplasmosis, but most often associated with ventricu-
have focused on the justification of a screening policy in lomegaly, making it difficult to evaluate their specific im-
pregnant women [6] and the potential benefit of prenatal pact on future neurological development [7, 8]. Some au-
treatment [2, 3]. These two questions still remain very thors described them as ‘calcification’ by analogy with
controversial. Surprisingly, only few reports on cerebral the images of calcifications that may be observed later on
US findings in case of fetal infection have been reported in life on skull radiographs of patients with neurological
[3, 7–11]. Whatever the recommendation on systematic impairment [11]. These echogenic cerebral lesions were
maternal serum screening across different countries, we found postnatally in all our cases. The results from the
consider that the cerebral signs associated with congeni- postmortem examinations of our terminated cases may
tal toxoplasmosis should be more largely diffused. Except suggest that these echogenic lesions correspond to lim-
for cases of significant ventricular dilation, very few stud- ited areas of cerebral necrosis, as previously suggested by
ies have focused on fetal cerebral signs in congenital toxo- Hohlfeld et al. [10]. However, conversely to their state-
plasmosis [3, 7–11]. Yet, a better knowledge of these signs ment, our results may suggest that the neurodevelop-
would be of interest as fetal prognosis largely depends on mental outcome may be favorable when these lesions are
the severity of the cerebral damage. isolated in the prenatal period. Only one case of prenatal
Cerebral calcifications in children with congenital diagnosis of isolated cerebral echogenic nodular foci
toxoplasmosis are observed in 5–9% of cases [12, 13]. with no ventriculomegaly has been reported by Malinger
The presence of these cerebral calcifications is consid- et al. [11], who suggested that in these circumstances,
ered a risk factor for the development of retinochoroidi- neurological outcome may favorable. However, our re-
144.82.108.120 - 6/7/2016 4:14:11 AM
References
1 Wallon M, Garweg JG, Abrahamowicz M, 5 McLeod R, Boyer K, Karrison T, Kasza K, 7 di Carlo P, Romano A, Casuccio A, Cillino S,
Cornu C, Vinault S, Quantin C, Bonithon- Swisher C, Roizen N, Jalbrzikowski J, Rem- Schimmenti MG, Mancuso G, la Chiusa S,
Kopp C, Picot S, Peyron F, Binquet C: Oph- ington J, Heydemann P, Noble AG, Mets Novara V, Ingrassia D, Li Vecchi V, Trizzino
thalmic outcomes of congenital toxoplas- M, Holfels E, Withers S, Latkany P, Meier M, Titone L: Investigation and management
mosis followed until adolescence. Pediatrics P; Toxoplasmosis Study Group: Outcome of Toxoplasma gondii infection in pregnancy
2014;133:e601–e608. of treatment for congenital toxoplasmo- and infancy: a prospective study. Acta Phar-
2 SYROCOT (Systematic Review on Congeni- sis, 1981–2004: the National Collaborative macol Sin 2011;32:1063–1070.
tal Toxoplasmosis) study group, Thiebaut R, Chicago-Based, Congenital Toxoplasmosis 8 Friedman S, Ford-Jones LE, Toi A, Ryan G,
Leproust S, Chene G, Gilbert R: Effectiveness Study. Clin Infect Dis 2006;42:1383–1394. Blaser S, Chitayat D: Congenital toxoplasmo-
of prenatal treatment for congenital toxoplas- 6 Wallon M, Peyron F, Cornu C, Vinault S, sis: prenatal diagnosis, treatment and postna-
mosis: a meta-analysis of individual patients’ Abrahamowicz M, Kopp CB, Binquet C: Con- tal outcome. Prenat Diagn 1999;19:330–333.
data. Lancet 2007;369:115–122. genital Toxoplasma infection: monthly pre- 9 Guerina NG, Hsu HW, Meissner HC, Ma-
3 Gras L, Gilbert RE, Ades AE, Dunn DT: Effect natal screening decreases transmission rate guire JH, Lynfield R, Stechenberg B, Abroms
of prenatal treatment on the risk of intracra- and improves clinical outcome at age 3 years. I, Pasternack MS, Hoff R, Eaton RB, et al:
nial and ocular lesions in children with con- Clin Infect Dis 2013;56:1223–1231. Neonatal serologic screening and early treat-
genital toxoplasmosis. Int J Epidemiol 2001; ment for congenital Toxoplasma gondii infec-
30:1309–1313. tion. The New England Regional Toxoplasma
4 Jacquemard F: Ultrasonographic signs of con- Working Group. N Engl J Med 1994; 330:
genital toxoplasmosis (in French). Arch Pedi- 1858–1863.
atr 2003;10(suppl 1):35–38.
144.82.108.120 - 6/7/2016 4:14:11 AM