You are on page 1of 28

See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/290950006

E-health: Current status and future trends

Chapter · January 2014


DOI: 10.4018/978-1-4666-7266-6.ch016

CITATIONS READS
21 4,018

7 authors, including:

Virginie Felizardo Paula Sousa


Universidade da Beira Interior Universidade da Beira Interior
35 PUBLICATIONS   213 CITATIONS    8 PUBLICATIONS   87 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE SEE PROFILE

Nuno Garcia Ivan Miguel Pires


Universidade da Beira Interior Universidade da Beira Interior
241 PUBLICATIONS   1,620 CITATIONS    123 PUBLICATIONS   825 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

Roadmap to the Design of a Personal Digital Life Coach View project

IC1303 AAPELE (Algorithms, Architectures and Platforms for Enhanced Living Environments) View project

All content following this page was uploaded by Nuno Garcia on 17 February 2016.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.


Handbook of Research
on Democratic Strategies
and Citizen-Centered
E-Government Services

Ćemal Dolićanin
State University of Novi Pazar, Serbia

Ejub Kajan
State University of Novi Pazar, Serbia

Dragan Randjelović
Academy for Criminalistic and Police Studies, Serbia

Boban Stojanović
University of Niš, Serbia

A volume in the Advances in Electronic


Government, Digital Divide, and Regional
Development (AEGDDRD) Book Series
Managing Director: Lindsay Johnston
Managing Editor: Austin DeMarco
Director of Intellectual Property & Contracts: Jan Travers
Acquisitions Editor: Kayla Wolfe
Production Editor: Christina Henning
Development Editor: Allison McGinniss
Typesetter: Amanda Smith
Cover Design: Jason Mull

Published in the United States of America by


Information Science Reference (an imprint of IGI Global)
701 E. Chocolate Avenue
Hershey PA, USA 17033
Tel: 717-533-8845
Fax: 717-533-8661
E-mail: cust@igi-global.com
Web site: http://www.igi-global.com

Copyright © 2015 by IGI Global. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored or distributed in
any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, without written permission from the publisher.
Product or company names used in this set are for identification purposes only. Inclusion of the names of the products or
companies does not indicate a claim of ownership by IGI Global of the trademark or registered trademark.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
CIP Data
ISBN: 978-1-4666-7266-6
eISBN:978-1-4666-7267-3
Print & Perpetual:978-1-4666-7269-7

This book is published in the IGI Global book series Advances in Electronic Government, Digital Divide, and Regional
Development (AEGDDRD) (ISSN: 2326-9103; eISSN: 2326-9111)

British Cataloguing in Publication Data


A Cataloguing in Publication record for this book is available from the British Library.

All work contributed to this book is new, previously-unpublished material. The views expressed in this book are those of the
authors, but not necessarily of the publisher.

For electronic access to this publication, please contact: eresources@igi-global.com.


302

Chapter 16
E-Health:
Current Status and Future Trends

Virginie Felizardo Celina Alexandre


University of Beira Interior, Covilhã, Portugal University of Beira Interior, Covilhã, Portugal

Paula Sousa Rafael Couto


University of Beira Interior, Covilhã, Portugal University of Beira Interior, Covilhã, Portugal

Daniel Sabugueiro Nuno Garcia


University of Beira Interior, Covilhã, Portugal University of Beira Interior, Covilhã, Portugal
& Universidade Lusófona de Humanidades e
Tecnologias, Lisbon, Portugal
Ivan Pires
University of Beira Interior, Covilhã, Portugal

ABSTRACT
Due to higher life expectancy, the number of older people continues to increase, and with it the number
of cases of chronic diseases. Estimates indicate that the percentage of people with at least one chronic
disease living in modern societies can reach as much as 40%, making chronic diseases one of the ma-
jor challenges for modern healthcare systems. In order to reduce healthcare costs, solutions based on
information and communication technologies have emerged. The expansion of e-Health solutions is as-
sociated with the increased demand for flexible, comprehensive, and cost-effective chronic care models,
and continues expanding, putting together a very comprehensive set of knowledge. This chapter presents
an inclusive and widespread current state of the art of e-health solutions for chronic diseases, proposing
a number of predictable future trends and scenarios.

1. INTRODUCTION technologies, being one emerging area that has


potential to improve healthcare service delivery,
The growing cost of healthcare and the aging diagnostic monitoring, disease-tracking and
of population have created many challenges for related medical procedures. The use of wireless
governments, healthcare providers and healthcare technologies to remotely monitor patients in an
industry that they try to overcome using E-Health unobtrusive manner attracts great interest since it

DOI: 10.4018/978-1-4666-7266-6.ch016

Copyright © 2015, IGI Global. Copying or distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.

E-Health

can be done in a reliable and cost effective man- better, or redefined products, but in fact, solutions
ner, offering personalized sustainable services to that may profoundly improve the quality of treat-
patients (Ragesh & Baskaran, 2012). ment and broaden access to medical care.
Thus, eHealth solutions are particularly iden- These technologies aim to increase efficiency
tified by several characteristics, such as context in health care treatments, improve quality of life,
aware, personalized, anticipatory, adaptive, ubiq- increase commitment to evidence-based medi-
uity, transparency, performance, security, privacy cine, empowerment of patients and consumers,
(Acampora et al., 2013). and the development of new and more intimate
From the point of view of functionality, these relationships between patients and health care
systems can be useful in different areas, includ- professionals. From a more abstract point-of-
ing diagnosis, prognosis, screening, behavior view, e-Health can be used to spread, share and
discovery, therapy, decision support, hospital man- relate health information through both patients
agement, prediction of effectiveness of surgical and health professionals.
procedures, continuous monitoring, medication, Nowadays there is an increasing consciousness
discovery of relationships among clinical and about the importance and challenges e-Health and
diagnosis data (Acampora et al., 2013; Abdel-Aal, e-Health systems represent, being these challenges
2004, 2005). are as distinct as:
In addition to these characteristics and tasks,
also low cost and user-friendly interface help to • An aging population, which demands for a
improve comfort and life quality to users. longer-term care, consecutively demanding
The remainder of this chapter is as follows: more elaborated and more available health-
section 2 addresses the relevance and challenges care solutions, on which the Information
of the e-Health; section 3 covers some available Technologies (IT) may provide a solution
technologies and solution in e-Health divided in like, for example, autonomous monitoring
wearable multi-sensors platforms and support platforms that may synchronize patient vi-
to care givers and care organizations; section 4 tal data with a physician in real-time, and
describes the issues of security and privacy of sound an alarm at the nearest healthcare
health data; and finishing, section 5 covers open facility if anything goes wrong with the
research issues and future perspectives in e-Health. patient;
• The rising expectations of patients from
their healthcare professionals due to their
2. RELEVANCE AND CHALLENGES access to the Internet that allows them to
be better informed about their health issues
Health is something of common concern for by consulting and participating in health
everyone, as society live minded and wanting to counselling forums;
live well as long as possible. With that in mind • Pressure from the governments to reduce
the delivery of high quality e-Health products is healthcare budgets by adopting IT solu-
currently the main priority of each company that tions that automate manual procedures
develops such products. Advances in e-Health leading to cost reductions;
solutions have shown that it is possible to get the • A population that demands for better
most out of the existing technology by investing equipment conditions when hospitalized,
on it and creating newer and better technologies like for example, newborn trackers, vital
for this field. Newer and better technologies don’t alarm systems, non-intrusive monitoring
just refer to new products that do things a little bit solutions, etc.

303

E-Health

That consciousness and even enthusiasm 3. TELEMONITORING AND


about the potential that IT offers to healthcare has SELF-MANAGEMENT OF
resulted in massive investments into IT compa- CHRONICDISEASES
nies and into the IT departments at Universities
worldwide. The information technologies may be According to World Health Organization, aging
used, as said before, to record, process and share population is becoming a significant problem at
information on patients (e.g. electronic health the same time that sedentary lifestyle is causing
records). These technologies may also be used millions of people to suffer from obesity or chronic
as “electronic autonomous guiders” for proce- diseases (Alwan et al., 2011). Thus it is expected
dural treatments (e.g. mobile apps) and even in that this circumstance will contribute to a contin-
solutions that may facilitate care, diagnosing and ued decline in the quality of services provided by
even perform surgeries from distance. Designing an already overloaded healthcare system (Chen
effective e-Health systems and services requires et al., 2011). Several applications and solutions
the enforcement of expertise from diverse fields will benefit from the advanced integration of
and will surely benefit from interdisciplinary sensors and emerging wireless technologies, such
collaboration. In scope of that multidisciplinary as support to care givers and care organizations
team, there are already many working groups that architectures or wearable multi-sensors platforms.
may include health professionals, IT teams, and
professionals from other related areas that work a. Support to Care Givers
together. Not only those teams work inside compa- and Care Organizations
nies, but with Universities as well, since university
environments are usually more favorable to the Information systems, such as electronic health
design and development of new entrepreneurial records (EHRs), mobile phones and handheld
concepts that eventually may result in future solu- computers (all of these components of m-health
tions for e-Health. solutions), can be very valuable in providing
The return of this massive investment resulted health care in several settings (Blaya, Fraser &
in new solutions that are presented every single Holt, 2010).They can give support to people
day, from wearable technologies, like smart suffering from chronic conditions, such as Par-
clothing that monitors Electromyography (EMG), kinson’s disease or Alzheimer, allowing them to
Electrocardiography (ECG) and Electroencepha- live independently in their own homes for as long
lography (EEG), or smart shoe soles that monitor as possible, and also support the care givers and
the performance of athletes, to home solutions care providers.
that are connected via Internet to a service health The projects presented in this section are a
provider, and aim, for example, to monitor and/or part of The Ambient Assisted Living (AAL) Joint
diagnose patients with chronic illnesses. There is Programme that aims to enhance the quality of
paraphernalia of new solutions being presented life of older people and strengthen the industrial
every day, and thus it can be said that IT has already base in Europe through the use of Information
gained an extremely important role in the Health and Communication Technologies (ICT). Most of
research and business, and we all will certainly these projects are focused on people with chronic
benefit from this current investment. conditions and their caregivers. Additionally,

304

E-Health

Acampora et al. (2013) provides an overview on • A social networking technology platform


several aspects related to ambient intelligence in specifically designed to meet the needs of,
health care, and gives examples of other finished and be usable by, the elderly person, and
and on-going projects. providing the communications channel
through which people and applications will
AGNES: User-Sensitive Home- communicate;
Based Systems for Successful • Diverse applications specifically aimed at
Ageing in a Networked Society the needs of the older person, to help deal
with, or even prevent, the mild cognitive
The AGNES project addresses chronic conditions, impairment that tends to be a chronic and
such as mild cognitive impairment and dementia. worsening feature of this user population;
The main aim is to prevent, delay and help man- • Features that also support the needs of car-
age these conditions, emphasizing the role of the ers, both formal and informal, for informa-
home as the care environment in which chronic tion about the older person, their activities
conditions are largely self-managed. and current state.
The project applies ICT in innovative ways to
support a personalized and person-centric care The system consists of an ICT platform to cre-
process, aimed at the needs of the individual ate and maintain an easy-to-use web-based social
elderly person, as well as formal and informal network for individual persons. This platform
care givers. The objectives are to enhance mental is used to pass information between the social
and physical wellbeing by encouraging the older network and the elderly person. The technology
person to respond to physical, social and cognitive in the in-home system supports the evaluation of
stimulation from outside, thus maintaining and the subjective and objective states of the elderly.
even improving selective attention, memory span The AGNES platform provides an information
and prospective memory. The AGNES approach and communication channel between the elderly
is to incorporate new healthcare technologies to and the network, i.e. timely information about the
keep the elderly mentally and socially stimulated activities and subjective states of the elderly person
and in contact with others by combining state (e.g. presence, state of wellness) is passed to the
detection and social network technologies, con- network and information on the network (news,
tributing significantly to supporting the elderly updates on activities of close persons, reminders
and their care givers (Waterworth, Ballesteros & of things “to do”, etc.) is available for the elderly.
Peter, 2009). Other functionalities include monitoring physi-
For this purpose, the AGNES project integrates cal activities, which assists the elderly and the
several different technologies and devices, includ- carers to plan and perform exercises, and to keep
ing (Waterworth, Ballesteros & Peter, 2009): an appropriate diet (Waterworth, Ballesteros &
Peter, 2009).
• Ambient devices for the display of infor- The system has two aspects regarding caregiv-
mation and events and for easy interaction ers. Formal carers are assisted to manage their work
with the home-based system and connect- load and improve communication and services as a
ed others; result of better comprehension of the elderly needs.
• Web-cams and mobile phones for the Informal carers have greater access to information
unobtrusive detection of user states and about the person, and those at a distance will be
activities; enabled to keep in touch and share activities with

305

E-Health

their elderly family member or friend, and to know lows the exchange of information with ex-
their current condition (Waterworth, Ballesteros ternal Hospital Information Systems (HIS)
& Peter, 2009). and provides a web based graphical user
interface for clinicians and platform ad-
ALADDIN: A Technology Platform ministrators to interact with the system;
for the Assisted Living of Dementia • External Services: Provided by external
Elderly Individuals and Their Carers web portals. There are two types of servic-
es involved: cognitive games and a social
The ALADDIN project addresses mild to moderate network. The integration of these services
dementia chronic conditions, and aims to provide in the platform is achieved by integrating
an integrated online clinical, educational and social a web browser component in the Carer’s
support network for sufferers and their carers in Client Application, which opens a web
the everyday management of the disease at home page with the selected external service di-
(Haritou et al., 2012). rectly in the client application.
ALADDIN is a platform that provides planning,
management and monitoring of the health status. The system helps to ensure that the individual
This technology prevents emergency situations remains as long as possible in its familiar environ-
due to worsening symptoms, cognitive function, ment. The ALADDIN-platform is designed to stand
behavioral aspects, in the reduction of stress and out by its user-friendliness and simplicity, and it
burden in the home care situation, and maintain- is expected that carer and patient should perceive
ing the patient’s and carer’s quality of life (Cuno the technology as a relief (Cuno et al., 2011).
et al., 2011).
The architecture of ALADDIN-platform con- eCAALYX: Enhanced Complete
sists of three main parts (Cuno et al., 2011): Ambient Assisted Living Experience

• Carer’s Client Application: An applica- eCAALYX builds on the strengths of the infra-
tion used by carers and patients to access structure and functionality already developed in
the services of the platform. With this ap- the original CAALYX project (Boulos et al., 2007).
plication, carers can answer the question- eCAALYX offers a complete solution for im-
naires about the patient’s mental health proving the quality of life of elderly patients, to
condition, as well as their own. The infor- monitor their state of health, assess their health
mation about the physiological measure- risk, promptly detecting and controlling any
ments of the patient can be submitted by decompensation episodes, and providing them
the caregiver using the application. The education focused on a healthy lifestyle, so that
submitted data is analyzed by clinicians on their independent life at home can be extended and
a regular basis. Additionally, the applica- their hospitalization or admission in nursing homes
tion enables a caregiver to send a warning avoided for longer periods (Boulos et al., 2009).
message to request the clinician to contact The eCAALYX system is composed of three
the caregiver in the near future; main subsystems (Boulos et al., 2009):
• Server Application: The core of the plat-
form. It implements the basic functional- • The Home Subsystem: Includes Customer
ities of the platform, provides secure com- Premises Equipment (CPE), Set-top-box
munication with client applications, stores (STB)/interactive TV (to deliver health
information about patients and carers, al- education and other functions), Tricorder

306

E-Health

and home sensors (those sensors that are The system consists of a home monitoring and
stationary and not continuously worn on an alarm system for monitoring pathophysiological
the body), all of them located at home; parameters, a control and communication system
• The Mobile Subsystem: Includes a smart to allow interaction between the home system, and
garment, with all sensors integrated into a the Hospital Information System (HIS) (Sánchez-
wireless BAN – Wearable Body Sensors Tato et al., 2010).
(WBS), and a mobile phone; The H@H system has the typical client/server
• The Caretaker Site: Includes the Caretaker architecture. The communication between the two
Server and the Auto-configuration Server. main parts is through the Internet. The patient is
monitored by a set of Bluetooth sensing devices for
The eCAALYXproject also presents the eCAA- measuring the main vital parameters and a home
LYX Mobile Application which aims at building a gateway that centralizes all needed computation
remote monitoring system targeting older people and communication resources. The home gateway
with multiple chronic diseases. The eCAALYX receives data from sensors and processes them
Mobile Platform is a connection between the wear- to detect critical alterations. Then all data are
able health sensors used by the older person and forwarded to the remote server, using one of the
the health professionals’ Internet site, and reports transmission channels, to be further analyzed and
the latter alerts and measurements obtained from made available in the existing HIS. In an alarm
sensors and the geographic location of the user. situation, caregivers or relatives are contacted via
Additionally, the mobile platform is also able Short Message Service (SMS) and all pending data
to reason with the raw sensor data to identify are sent to the server. In this way the clinician is
higher level information, including easy-to-detect enabled to monitor patients’ situation at distance,
anomalies such as tachycardia and signs of respi- taking actions in case of necessity (Saponara et
ratory infections, based on established medical al., 2012).
knowledge. A user interface is also provided, The home gateway also provides an intuitive
which allows the user to evaluate the most recent graphical user interface with reminder messages,
medical details obtained from sensors, perform images and animations in order to guide the
new measurements, and communicate with the patient in performing the scheduled activities.
caretakers (Boulos et al., 2011). Furthermore, it allows the manual submission of
perceived symptoms. The role of the remote server
H@H: Health at Home application is to receive data coming from gate-
ways. Vital sign observations, raised alarms and
The Health at Home (H@H) project aims at solv- other data are used to update the patients’ record
ing societal problems related to the provision of in the HIS. It also permits the management of all
healthcare services for Chronic Heart Failure information related to the patient: browse histori-
(CHF) diagnosed elderly patients. cal data, plot data trends and revise his Operating
The model allows planning, controlling, and Protocol (Saponara et al., 2012).
monitoring the activities carried out by patient,
caregivers, social and sanitary professionals, HELP: Home-Based Empowered Living
enabling the medical staff to distantly monitor for Parkinson’s Disease Patients
situations and take action in case of necessity.
This will decrease the acting time in cases of Current Parkinson’s disease treatments improve
destabilization of CHF patients and will reduce symptoms but lead patients to develop a toler-
avoidable hospital re-admissions, resulting in an ance to the drug. But as the disease progresses
improved quality of life for the patient and in costs it becomes more difficult to determine the exact
reduction (Sánchez-Tato et al., 2010). drug dosage.
307

E-Health

The HELP project aims to improve Parkin- viding real-time support to patients to monitor,
son’s disease symptoms, by the development of self-manage and improve their physical condition
a subcutaneous pump, which injects a gradual according to their specific situation (IS-ACTIVE
and constant flow of apomorphine (i.e. liquid Project, 2010).
drug for treating Parkinson’s) throughout the day, The sensor-based system proposed by IS-
improving the control of symptoms. However, this ACTIVE provides the patients an effective sensing
control method is not sufficient because the pump system for daily use, which analyzes in real-time
administers a constant dose, and the appropriate their physical activity and condition, and an easy-
dose is variable and is a consequence of the pa- to-use interface and a natural feedback, in order to
tient’s symptoms that fluctuate throughout the day. sensitize them to the importance of preventing and
This project has designed a “Parkinson’s” managing their chronic conditions; and provides
sensor which sends relevant information to the the caregivers an effective remote monitoring tool,
platform and automatically establishes the optimal through which they investigate the success of the
level of drug administration, depending on the state physical therapy and adapt it with minimal effort.
of each patient. At the same time, a constant level Figure 1 presents the main architectural
of drug is administered by another sub-system components of IS-ACTIVE. The main important
developed through the HELP project, consisting building blocks are:
of an intraoral device embedded in the patient’s
mouth in the form of a tooth. This aims to achieve • Wireless Sensors Networks (WSNs): The
continuous dopaminergic stimulation, improving core technology of IS-ACTIVE, creating a
symptomatic benefits and minimizing concerns pervasive environment around the user:
about complications resulting from intermittent ◦◦ Body Sensor Network (BSN): I.e.
dosage of medication (AAL, 2012). on-body sensors, such as inertial sen-
The solution proposed by HELP is also high- sors and physiological sensors;
lighted by Telefónica (http://www.tid.es/en/): ◦◦ Infrastructure Sensors: Such as en-
Telefónica has announced the results of a recently vironmental sensors (used for signal-
finished pilot that used mobile technology to re- ing possible adverse environmental
motely monitor and treat patients with Parkinson’s conditions with respect to the user
disease, as the operator and its partners decide specific condition).
on future research and how to commercialize the • Technology-Aided Objects (TAOs):
technology (Handford et al., 2013). Technology-enhanced daily objects that
contribute to monitoring and assessing the
IS-ACTIVE: Inertial Sensing Systems physical training performance of patients
for Advanced Chronic Condition at home and outdoors. Together, the on-
Monitoring and Risk Prevention body sensors and TAOs form the Extended
Body Sensor Network (BSN+).
IS-ACTIVE aimed the creation of person-centric • Feedback Devices: Covering all user in-
healthcare solutions, based on recent advances teraction aspects, providing the informa-
in wireless inertial sensing systems, for patients tion sensed and processed by the WSN to
with chronic conditions. This project highlights the user.
the role of the home as care environment, by pro-

308

E-Health

Figure 1. Block diagram of IS-ACTIVE system architecture


(IS-ACTIVE, 2010).

• Home-Based Infrastructure: The wire- PAMAP: Physical Activity


less communication infrastructure (hard- Monitoring for Aging People
ware and software) interconnecting the
above components (WSNs, technology- The PAMAP project allows monitoring the physi-
aided objects and feedback devices) in a cal activity both in a clinical setting and in the
seamless way. subject’s home environment. The goal is to provide
• Multiple Users/Patients: Providing mul- physicians with the means to encourage people
tiple patients with the possibility of exer- to a healthy activity level, and also to diagnose
cising and using together the IS-ACTIVE problems at an early stage (Hendeby et al., 2010).
system. It is designed to support physical rehabilitation and
• Communication with the Caregiver: physical activitymonitoring services. The system
That allows him/her to assess the progress can be used in a clinical environment, as well as,
of the patient, as well as to give proper ad- in daily life, thus providing health professionals
vice adapted to the current status and evo- with important information to diagnose problems
lution of the disease. at an early stage (Hendeby et al., 2010).

309

E-Health

The system has two separate conceptual parts: well as detecting risks or critical situations. For
the information management and the underlying this purpose the project uses and scales-up existing
information acquisition system (the sensor network research prototypes and new systems for collecting
and associated information extraction technology) human- and context-related data (including sen-
(Hendeby et al., 2010). sors attached to a person’s body, or sensors and
From the information management point of actuators installed in houses or cars) (REMOTE
view, the PAMAP system consists of the infrastruc- Project, 2012).
ture and the applications used to monitor physical The applications and services developed in the
activity, present information, and provide an easy project are three-part oriented:
way for the main system users (the monitored
subject, family and friends and the clinicians) • To the Elderly: To enhance their self-care,
to interact. From the data acquisition point of social interaction, and skills maintenance
view, the PAMAP system consists of the sensor ability, offering the comfort, security and
network and a control unit that links the sensors safety required: to maintain links with their
and several different I/O devices. An interactive family and friends, to go out for shopping
TV (i-TV) interface is used to enable patients to or vacation etc.;
gain access to their health record and the details • To Health Professionals: To be provided
of the rehabilitation plan to be followed. with tools for continuous monitoring of a
The PAMAP system is a technical support sys- patient’s situation (e.g. real time data and
tem that can be used both preventive and to make records of the patient’s condition, activity,
rehabilitation more efficient. Moreover, the system and life environment changes) and history
allows for a more independent elderly life style, patient data;
since it can be managed by the elderly themselves • To Health and Care Insurance Providers:
in their homes. This way, PAMAP encourages the Facilitating the development and integra-
elderly to keep an as active, independent, and tion of new services and new delivery plat-
normal life as possible (Hendeby et al., 2010). forms; this will meet their requirements
concerning cost reduction, interoperability,
REMOTE: Remote Health and Social and standardization of services.
Care for Independent Living of Isolated
Elderly with Chronic Conditions ROSETTA: Guidance and Awareness
Services for Independent Living
REMOTE is a project concerned with the needs of
elderly and individuals with chronic conditions, The ROSETTA project has developed an innova-
especially those living in isolation (geographical tive, integrated system aiming at preventing and
or social), and whose independent life is at risk managing the problems that can occur as a result
with chronic conditions or lifestyle factors. of chronic progressive diseases, such as dementia,
The REMOTE project provides support for an Parkinson’s disease and Alzheimer. The target
independent life at home with the aid of Ambi- group of ROSETTA includes elderly people, liv-
ent Intelligence (AmI) and tele-healthcare. The ing in their own houses or in small-scale living
elderly’s personal environment is enhanced with communities, and their formal and/or informal
various kinds of monitoring and automation abili- caregivers.
ties for tracing activity and health condition, as

310

E-Health

The ROSETTA system functionalities are as To implement the market launch for the
follows: AAPS part of the ROSETTA system, early in
2013, the Institute for Technology Development,
• The system monitors the activities of the the Netherlands (TNO) has created a spin-off
resident by means of multiple and different company called “Dutch Domotics” (http://www.
sensors; dutchdomotics.com).
• It generates an alarm in case of deviant ac-
tivity/inactivity or wandering, which is for- SOFTCARE: Unobtrusive Plug
warded to the caregiver (the AAPS part); and Play Kit for Chronic Condition
• The system generates a warning in case of Monitoring Based on Customized
long-term variations in the patterns of daily Behavior Recognition from Wireless
living, which is forwarded to the caregiver Localization and Remote Sensoring
(EDS Lifestyle monitoring part);
• It supports the resident directly in carrying Many older people who live at home may have
out his or her daily activities (EDN Elderly or be at risk of developing a chronic condition.
Day Navigator part). By monitoring their daily activity levels it is pos-
sible to warn carers about falls or other abnormal
The ROSETTA system is composed of three behaviors which might signal the beginning of a
main parts: Unattended Autonomous Surveil- problem with the person’s health.
lance (UAS-AAPS), Early Detection System The SOFTCARE project addresses the need to
(EDS), Early Day Navigator (EDN) (ROSETTA improve upon existing home care technology for
Project, 2012). the elderly by developing an easy-to-deploy and
The UAS-AAPS is for surveillance for emer- non-intrusive indoor wireless home monitoring
gencies, including those as a result of falling and system for the independent elderly that proactively
straying, for persons with advanced dementia or monitors anomalies in behavior that may point to
persons with a combination of memory problems/ the onset of a chronic condition or indicate risk to
mild dementia and Parkinson’s disease. The pos- physical wellbeing (CRIC, 2012), and at the same
sible emergencies are detected by sensors and a time allow carers and users to get real-time alarms
camera and reported to a mobile care team. in dangerous or potentially dangerous situations.
The EDS is the lifestyle monitoring system. The system is composed by a small bracelet,
Sensors in the home monitor the daily life pattern with a 3D accelerometer and a mobile communi-
of persons living alone. These daily life patterns cation device, worn by the user, and static nodes
are available to care providers as well as informal placed in each room of the user’s home.
carers via a computer programme. As a result of the SOFTCARE project, the most
The EDN part offers memory support for relevant outcomes are:
people with memory problems, through the
development of a touch screen and an adapted • A prototype system composed by a brace-
Smartphone. let, static nodes, gateways and a server side
At the end of the project, the UAS-AAPS sur- software application, that provides activity
veillance was almost market ready and therefore recognition and fall detection features;
it was selected to be launch as first to the market • A set of algorithms for fall detection and
in The Netherlands in 2013. The EDS Lifestyle activity recognition based on the informa-
monitoring is expected to be launched in The tion gathered by the bracelet.
Netherlands and Germany in 2014.

311

E-Health

The project consortium is currently negotiating 2.1. Wearable Sensors and Monitoring
with potential commercial partners to integrate Patches;
SOFTCARE bracelet and algorithms (for fall 2.2. Smartwatches and Wristband Sensors;
detection and activity recognition) in an existing and
commercial product (AAL, 2012). 2.3. Wearable systems embedded in textile.

b. Wearable Multi-Sensors Platforms i. “Holter-Type” Systems

A biosignal change is given in function of time Many multi-sensors platforms systems look like
or space (McAdams et al., 2010). Some of the standard Holter monitoring systems. These moni-
standard sensors include body movement (via toring systems involve a recording and transmitting
accelerometer), location (via GPS), temperature, device which attached to the person’s accessories
electro-dermal activity (EDA), ECG, heart rate, such as a belt, necklace or is located in some forms
EMG, EEG, and photoplethysmography (PPG). of waistcoat. The acquisition system is connected
These sensors are included in a variety of devices to standard sensors placed in standard locations. A
and solutions (Swan, 2012). variety of models with different features manufac-
The multi-sensor platforms allow a wearable tured by different companies are available below
approach of medical devices (McAdams et al., (McAdams et al., 2010).
2010). These products include “Holter-type” sys-
tems, smartwatches, wristband sensors, wearable physioPlux (PLUX wireless biosignals S.A.)
sensor patches, brain computer interfaces, wear- According to the company Plux, the physioPlux
able systems embedded in textile, smartphone (Figure 2, left) is a device that collects and digi-
applications and their enhancements and home tizes signals from sensors, transmitting them via
automation sensors (McAdams et al., 2010, Swan Bluetooth® (Connectivity - 10m range, with
2012). standard adapter; >100m with high range adapter)
The wearable platforms with application in to a computer, where are viewed in real time. The
Healthcare and Assisted Living in this section analog-to-digital converter (ADC) channels have
can be divided in two groups: 12 bits, and its sampling frequency is 1 kHz. The
physioPlux has 4 channels for sensors connection,
1. “Holter-type” systems and also has a digital port, a terminal for connecting
2. Wearable Technology:

Figure 2. “Holter-type” systems: left, physioPlux; and right, BITalino

312

E-Health

the AC adapter and charge the internal battery This physiological information can be sent
(allows a lifespan of approximately 12 hours), using Wi-Fi, 3G, GPRS, Bluetooth, 802.15.4 and
and a channel to connect the reference electrode. ZigBee, depending on the application, and data
Plux has several sensors that can be linked to can be sent to the Cloud for storage or visualized
physiobioPlux such as respiration sensor, respPlux, in real time in a laptop or Smartphone.
single button resistive sensor, forcePlux, air pres-
sure, airPlux, angle measurement tool, anglePlux, BITalino (PLUX Wireless Biosignals S.A.
ambient luminosity, lightPlux, triaxial accelerom- and Instituto de Telecomunicações)
eter, xyzPlux, ECG sensor (ECG triodes), ecgPlux, According to the company Plux, BITalino (Figure
electro-dermal activity sensor, edaPlux, peripheral 2, right) is a low-cost toolkit that claims to allow
temperature sensor, tempPlux, electromyography any developer to create projects and applications
sensor, emgPlux, and encephalography sensor, with physiological sensors.
eegPlux (www.plux.info). BITalino integrates hardware blocks with
The physioPlux system is related with physical multiple sensors that can operate as a single sys-
activity because it has great potential for free- tem or snapped off into their individual blocks
living applications. for applications with ECG, EMG, EDA, an ac-
celerometer, and ambient light; and easy to use
g.MOBIlab+ (g.tec Medical Engineering) software (http://www.bitalino.com).
g.MOBIlab+ is a tool for recording multimodal
biosignal data on a standard Pocket PC, PC or ii. Wearable Technology
notebook.
According to the company, this allows inves- The development of wearable technology for
tigation of brain-, heart-, and muscle-activity, eye monitoring vital signals allows the patient to be
movement, respiration, galvanic skin response, continuously monitoring their health conditions,
pulse and other body signals. g.MOBIlab+ is assuming either being at home or walking outside,
available in two versions: the 8 channel EEG and moving from time to time and place to place,
the multi-purpose version (http://www.gtec.at). in a comfortable, unobtrusive and independent
way. Consequently, a series of benefits and new
e-Health Sensor Platform for Arduino and applications would be taken advantage of by the
Raspberry Pi (Cooking Hacks) users including both the patients and the healthcare
According Cooking Hacks, the e-Health Sensor providers (Zhou et al., 2013).
Platform for Arduino and Raspberry Pi allows These systems have some categories: Wearable
users to perform biomedical applications, using Sensors and Patches, Smartwatches and Wrist-
nine different sensors, for body monitoring: pulse, band Sensors and Wearable systems embedded
oxygen in blood (SPO2), airflow (breathing), in textile.
body temperature, ECG, glucometer, galvanic
skin response (GSR - sweating), blood pressure a. Wearable Sensors and Patches
(sphygmomanometer) and patient position (ac-
celerometer) (Cooking Hacks, 2013). Advances in sensor technologies, materials and
software are driving to the development of a new

313

E-Health

generation of wearable sensors and medical moni- EKG Glove™ (IneedMD, Inc.)
toring device. A notable example is a patch-based The EKG Glove™ (Figure 3, top left) is, according
wearable sensor that adheres comfortably to the to IneedMD Inc., a medical device that replaces
user’s skin and continuously gathers physiological the cumbersome cables, electrodes and plugs
and lifestyle information (Praskah, 2012). typically used to perform an ECG. The EKG
Glove™ is disposable, portable and can easily
Metria™ (Avery Dennison® Medical connect to most industry standard ECG record-
Solutions) ing devices typically used in private practice,
The platform is based on advanced adhesives, hospitals, emergency services and home health
materials and manufacturing processes in com- care (IneedMD Inc., 2012).
bination with a personal monitoring device for According the company, for obtaining the
continuous physiologic monitoring developed by tracing, a care giver needs to connect this medical
Proteus Biomedical, Inc. According to the com- device to an ECG machine or wireless transmission
pany, the patch will incorporate multiple sensors device, insert his right hand into glove and prop-
including ECG and an accelerometer that will erly positioned the glove over the patient’s chest.
allow measurement, during day-to-day activity,
such as exercising or taking a shower, of heart Angel Sensor (Seraphim Sense Ltd.)
rate, activity, sleep and other physiologic metrics Angel sensor’s (Figure 3, top right) is a wristband
(Avery Dennison Corporation, 2013). platform that monitors pulse, temperature, activity
and blood oxygen level. Angel is able to send this
Actiheart Monitor (CamNtech Ltd and vital information to applications on smartphone,
CamNtechInc) laptop and possibly even treadmill. According
According to the company, Actiheart is a chest- to Seraphim Sense Ltd., Angel is the first device
worn monitoring device that records heart rate, designed for developers, with open communica-
Inter-Beat-Interval (IBI), and physical activity. It tion protocols, API/SDK and sensor data streams
is designed for capturing the heart rate variability (http://www.angelsensor.com).
(HRV) data and for calculating and measuring
Activity Energy Expenditure (CamNtech Ltd and A-PULSE CASPro® (HealthSTATS
CamNtechInc, 2012). International)
PULSE CASPro®, developed by HealthSTATS
b. Smartwatches and International, is a simple and yet revolutionary
Wristband Sensors device for the measurement of Central Aortic
Systolic Pressure (CASP) in clinical environment
Currently, there are a growing number of other or home setting. According the developers, it is
health and fitness wristband devices: Wrist-worn empowered by Evidence-Based Blood Pressure
devices, Arm-worn devices, Chest harnesses and (EVBP) technology; a FDA listed and patented
Head bands and caps. The market for wearable technology using modified applanation tonometry
health and fitness wristbands and smartwatches is on the radial artery at the wrist (HealthSTATS,
about to boom, especially now that ‘open’ platform 2010). The system consists of four main elements:
is about to be released. 1) PULSE CASPro® monitor; 2) Wrist sensor

314

E-Health

Figure 3. Smartwatches and wristband sensors: top left, EKG Glove™; top right, Angel Sensor; bottom
left, LifeShirt; and bottom right, Easy Ambulatory EEG System

module; 3) PULSE CASP® software; and 4) motion sensitive control. The integrated wireless
Integrated oscillometric blood pressure module interface allows the eZ430-Chronos to act as a
for calibration. central hub for nearby wireless sensors such as
pedometers and heart rate monitors. The eZ430-
ez430Chronos (Texas Instruments) Chronos offers temperature and battery voltage
The eZ430-Chronos software development tool measurement and is complete with a USB-based
developed by Texas Instruments(Texas Instru- CC1111 wireless interface to a PC.
ments, 2014) is a highly integrated, wearable, The sports watch firmware (default) provides a
wireless development system that is based on the broad set of features. Besides basic watch functions
MCU CC430F6137. It may be used as a reference such as time, date, alarm and stopwatch, advanced
platform for watch systems, a personal display sports watch features such as an altimeter, heart
for personal area networks, or as a wireless sen- rate monitor, calorie, vertical speed and distance
sor node for remote data collection. Based on information are available. The internal acceler-
the MCU CC430F6137 sub-1-GHz RF SoC, the ometer provides acceleration data on the watch
eZ430-Chronos is a complete development system LCD and allows controlling a PC by transferring
featuring a 96-segment LCD display, an integrated the sensor’s measurements.
pressure sensor, and a three-axis accelerometer for

315

E-Health

BodyMedia FIT (BodyMedia, Inc.) c. Wearable Systems


According to the company,BodyMedia FIT is an Embedded in Textile
on-body monitoring system that consists of the
armband monitor, online Activity Manager, an In the past decade, a variety of noninvasive sensors
optional Display and free downloadable applica- have been developed for measuring and moni-
tions for mobile device users. The system measure toring various physiological parameters such as
the intensity of workouts, calories burned during ECG, EEG, EDA, respiration, etc. Some of those
daily activities and also monitors the quality of sensors are in form of wearable devices such as
your sleep (BodyMedia Inc., 2013). wrist bands, as those mentioned in the previous
section, while others are embedded into textile,
LifeShirt (Vivonoetics) known as E-textile or smart fabrics. These section
presents recently developed solutions that use
The LifeShirt (Figure 3, bottom left) is a washable textile-embedded sensors inside clothes, such as
shirt system with embedded sensors: respiratory fiber, yarn and fabric structure (Chen et al., 2011).
sensors, a three-lead, single channel ECG, and Great strides have been made in the category
a three-axis accelerometer (Vivonoetics, 2013). of capture vital signals with wearable systems,
especially in a system integrated into textiles.
CoughSense (Ubiquitous Computing Lab – There are a number of research and commercial
University of Washington) projects in this area.
The Ubiquitous Computing Lab (University of
Washington) developed algorithms for using audio VitalJacket (Biodevices)
recorded from a mobile phone microphone to count VitalJacket (Figure 4, top right) is a medical
the number of cough episodes an individual has device combining wearable technology and main-
and the number of coughs within each episode stream biomedical engineering solutions, reliable
(Larson et al., 2011). cardio monitor. According to the company, the
This system could be used to track and monitor- VitalJacket can be worn by the patient allowing
ing cough frequency for a single person or, when at least 72 hours of continuous exams enables
networked, trends across an entire population physicians to do a correct assessment of cardiac
using nothing more than an individual’s existing problems in an everyday life environment (http://
mobile phone. www.vitaljacket.com).

Easy Ambulatory EEG System (Cadwell Smart-Clothing (University of Beira Interior


Laboratories Inc.) - Portugal)
The Easy Ambulatory system (Figure 3, bottom In the University of Beira Interior - Portugal, a
right) allows full EEG and polysomnography project called Smart-Clothing ended in 2009.
(PSG) data acquisition outside traditional labo- The main areas addressed by the Smart-Clothing
ratory. The Easy Ambulatory system not only Project are Obstetrics and Sports activity (Figure
continuously collects data for extended periods of 4, top left). The objective of this project was to
time, but it allows performing longer term stud- obtain a universal obstetric tracing, allowing for
ies over multiple days in a cost effective manner the identification of sudden changes in the fetus
and can also be connected to a computer during health, by continuously monitoring the fetus move-
acquisition to examine real time data (http://www. ments and the Fetal Heart Rate (FHR) frequency
cadwell.com). (Borges et al., 2010).

316

E-Health

Figure 4. Wearable systems embedded in textile: top left, VitalJacket; top right, Smart-Clothing; bottom
left, Armband integrating textile electrodes; and bottom right, Moticon

Armband integrating textile electrodes EMG signals obtained with an armband inte-
(University of Beira Interior - Portugal) grating textile electrodes, worn by a volunteer and
The Department of Textile Science and Tech- processed by a wireless portable unit exhibited
nology (University of Beira Interior, Portugal) comparable quality to those obtained with bipolar
developed an armband made of plain weave Ag/AgCI electrodes (Trindade et al., 2010).
fabric, integrating embroidery textile electrodes
of stainless steel (SS) and elastics to conform to Moticon (Moticon GmbH)
human forearms (Figure 4, bottom left) (Trindade Moticon is the world’s first fully integrated and
et al., 2010). wireless sensor insole (Figure 4, bottom right),
The fabric integrates stitched conductive according to the company. The insole can be used
threads of SS/cotton and snaps fasteners intercon- in any shoe to measure the distribution and motion
necting the textile electrodes to a bioPlux signal parameters for patients and athletes. The wireless
processing electronic module.The electronic mod- sensor insole is currently used for daily patient
ule connects through shielded cables to a portable monitoring, rehabilitation, and for status training
unit, which can be held in a pocket, and transmit in sports. The sensor insole, which is fitted with
wirelessly to a PC located anywhere in the room firmware that communicates with PC software
where the person is, for real time monitoring and via a USB radio stick, is easy to use and doesn’t
recording of the processed signals. require special training (http://www.moticon.de).

317

E-Health

Micro-Electro Mechanical Systems Internet-mediated chronic disease self-monitoring


Micro-Electro Mechanical System (MEMS) and self-management platforms may exhibit great
are an innovative technology for sensors design potential to reach a broad population of chronic
based on miniaturized mechanical and electro- patients (Stellefson et al., 2013).
mechanical elements using microfabrication These web platforms are related to Web 2.0
techniques (https://www.memsnet.org). Recently concept, which consists in the information sharing
MEMS technology has been used for design of between people. This has the advantage of, being
sensors such as accelerometer, blood glucose, applied to healthcare, allowing the user to share
blood pressure, ECG, EEG, EMG, gyroscope, his experiences and give and get support about
pulse oximetry, etc. the health condition.
One of the main advantages in using this type Furthermore, online discussion forums provide
of sensors embedded into clothes fabrics is the an open-access space for chronic disease patients
alleviation of electrical contacts failure and skin to exchange information and learn about how to
irritation problems resulting from the long-term control disease exacerbations. Additionally, avail-
usage of silver chloride traditional disposable elec- able evidence shows that online self-help groups
trodes. Compared to the conventional electrodes, can enhance social capital in ways that do not
they are also much more flexible, since their shape undermine, and might in some cases strengthen,
can be adapted to human motion. hyper personal connections between patients and
providers (Stellefson et al., 2013).
iii. Self-Management Online Platforms Following, some of these platforms are present-
ed. They are often considered as social networks
Training and supporting patients in the self- and many can be used with mobile resources and
management of their health condition has shown applications.
improvements in the quality of life and reduction
in unplanned hospital admissions. • Patients Like Me: A health data-sharing
The use of Information and Communication platform that allows users to compare treat-
Technologies (ICT) in the form of e-health is ments, symptoms and experiences with
expected to lead to improvements in healthcare people with the same or similar conditions,
quality and efficiency, and has brought up an and take control of their health. It also al-
increasing emphasis on promoting self-care and lows sharing experiences, giving and get-
self-management by patients, and a more general ting support to improve the life of others
promotion of healthy behaviors (Murray, 2012). and their own; and track their health, cre-
As well as delivering greater choice and control ating health charts over time and contrib-
for patients, supported self-management increases ute to research that can advance medicine
patients’ health education, so that they are better research. (http://www.patientslikeme.com)
able to understand and engage with their health, • Patients Innovation: A recent Portuguese
and their activation. online platform developed with the pur-
Internet users living with chronic disease are pose of exchanging solutions and strategies
slightly more likely than other Internet users to for patients and caregivers to deal with the
access health information online and more likely to challenges imposed by their health condi-
share acquired health information with others, so tions, including new or modified devices or

318

E-Health

aids, strategies, behaviors, treatments, ad- The patient advocacy organizations can provide
aptations or low-cost alternatives to exist- safety for the online communities in which patients,
ing solutions. (https://patient-innovation. families, friends and caregivers connect with one
com/) another for support and information.
• Cure Together: A social platform that has
the purpose of bringing together people • HealthVault: An online platform, hosted
with certain medical conditions to better by Microsoft, which allows to gather, store,
understand their bodies and going toward use, and share health information.The plat-
the cure. In this platform the users discuss form allows the user to organize the family
symptoms and compare health data and health information (health records, medica-
which treatments work best for them. The tions, allergies, health history), prepare for
users can see several personal and medical doctor visits and unexpected emergencies,
data: rate symptoms they have, treatments create a complete picture of health status
they have tried and what they think causes (share medical image or upload medical
or triggers their condition. The users can data) and achieve fitness goals (weight
also track the daily health status, weight, control, exercise motivation). (https://
calories, physical activity and sleep. With www.healthvault.com)
this patient-contributed data, new research • Everyday Health: A platform to help
is made taking into account a range of ex- the self-management of all family health
periences. (http://curetogether.com) conditions and overall well-being through
• Daily Strength: A network platform where personalized advice, tools, and communi-
users share their knowledge, experiences ties. The platform has information on vari-
and support. In this platform, users can ous health topics and the user can check
track goals, discuss several themes, have a symptom, count calories, make a meal
expert advice and treatments reviews. The plan, find an expert or look up a drug.
platform has free support groups for is- (http://www.everydayhealth.com)
sues ranging from mental health to cancer • CarePages: An online community to share
to children’s health and parenting. (http:// the challenges, hopes and triumphs of peo-
www.dailystrength.org) ple facing or that have faced life-changing
• Inspire: An online platform for build a health events. CarePages allows the cre-
health and wellness community for pa- ation of personalized websites, through
tients and caregivers, patient advocacy or- which members can relate their stories,
ganizations and life science organizations. post photos and update friends and family.
The users of the group “Patients & caregiv- In turn, people who care send messages
ers” can share their health status and health of love and encouragement. (https://www.
concerns through discussions and blog- carepages.com)
ging. (http://corp.inspire.com) • Healthline: An online repository of medi-
cal information aiming to promote a healthy
The Life science organizations can access to lifestyle and facilitate disease prevention,
patients population for studies and research in- as well as to offer clinically significant,
cluding market research, clinical trial recruitment, medically reviewed information for those
issues analysis, opinion surveys and promotion of who are seeking answers to their health
brand awareness. questions. In addition to the Health Topics,

319

E-Health

it has several tools available as Symptom • eVidais a platform that allows a rapid de-
Checker, Body Maps, Doctor Search, etc. velopment and integration of wide range of
(http://www.healthline.com) applications for health and quality of life
• WebMD: Provides health information, systems.
supportive communities and in-depth ref- • TICE.Healthy: Based on Open Source
erence material about health subjects. The software and standards thus facilitating the
health information on WebMD can be use- interoperability and the integration of sys-
ful for patients, as well as for physicians tems. (https://evida.pt)
and other health providers. WebMD pro- • TICE.Healthyproject (2011-2014): A
vides information about the most com- project funded by the European Union
mon conditions, as well as a symptom and the Portuguese government, anchored
checker and a pill identifier, and allows in the TICE.PT program – Center for
creating profiles for the family members. Competitiveness and Technology, Center
Furthermore, it has content on several mat- for Information, Communication and
ters from healthy living to pregnancy and Electronics Technologies (http://tice.pt),
parenting. (http://www.webmd.com) (http://tice.healthy.ipn.pt).
• Patients Fusion: Built to patients and
doctors. Patients can find doctors, book
doctor appointments, access their health 4. SECURITY AND PRIVACY
records and latest updates from lab results OF HEALTH DATA
to prescriptions, read reviews and manage
the spending. Doctors can grow their prac- The use of information systems able to replace the
tice with Patients Fusion with free online traditional paper-based format raised some issues
scheduling. (http://www.patientfusion. regarding the security and privacy of the data
com) stored in them (Dong et al., 2012). Particularly
• HealthTap: An interactive health network for health care systems, privacy and security are
consisting in a web platform and mobile very complex issues, and the addition of a large
application that connect doctors with pa- number of sensors and devices results in additional
tients, provide education to those who seek challenges (Acampora et al., 2013).
it and disseminate trusted, vetted, peer- Mechanisms to improve security should be
reviewed health information. The aim of present in systems to prevent disclosure, data
HealthTap is to improve people’s health manipulation, removal or destruction without clear
and well-being by providing users with permission to do so, like specific security policies,
personalized health information and free passwords protection, secure communications,
online answers from thousands of doc- and so on. To have a certainty that the informa-
tors, improving people’s knowledge about tion is protected, a good practice is to periodically
health and keep them more informed on examine the network integrity and security.
health decisions; for doctors, it is a tool Privacy ensures that data isn’t seen by other
to better serve existing patients, find new people besides the ones that have authorization
ones and build reputation, by demonstrat- to access it, for instance, another health provider,
ing their expertise and contributing to the another patient, etc. To respect the privacy, the
improvement of online health information necessary permissions to access the e-health
quality. (https://www.healthtap.com) system should only be given with consent from
the patient.

320

E-Health

Some authors agree that these issues are two This invariably means more processing power
of the main concerns that need to be dealt with to on smaller devices, a fact that can be witnessed in
have an effective information governance archi- devices, such as the physioPlux and the BITalino,
tecture (Accenture, 2010), and they really stand not to mention the commodity devices, such as the
out in one of the most used e-health information wearable ECG monitoring and respiratory bands
system, cloud storage. from sports equipment manufacturers.
But the use of information systems also has Regarding miniaturization and smaller de-
some clear advantages, like the standardization vices, two major achievements are still unmet: the
of health data using Digital Imaging Communi- construction of easy to charge, durable and light
cations in Medicine (DICOM) and Health Level batteries, and the invention of self-chargeable,
Seven (HL7) (among others) that brings easy energy harvesting sensors and devices. There is
communication amidst different systems thanks strong ongoing research on both these challenges,
to its interoperability. and it is expectable that the 2010 decade does not
DICOM standard specifies protocols used end without these products becoming a commod-
to exchange medical images with encapsulated ity too. Combining low-power electronics with
information like timestamps, operators identifica- secure communication protocols, and using long
tion, patients, identification, etc. between several life, maybe self-rechargingbatteries, all the ele-
information systems and health-care providers. ments will be united to the development of truly
Thanks to that, images created using DICOM ubiquitous computing and therefore, pervasive
can be viewed in any system, without concerning eHealth devices.
where they were produced (Minnesota e-Health The miniaturization of electrical devices and
Initiative and the Minnesota Department of the widespread use of wireless networks have
Health, 2013). empowered the development of Body Area Net-
The HL7 organization is not-for-profit, and is works (BANs).A BAN consists of a set of mo-
accredited by the American National Standards bile and small size intercommunicating sensors,
Institutes (ANSI). HL7 defines how to translate which are either wearable or can be implanted
and exchange health data between several sys- into the human body for monitoring vital signs
tems. This can be achieved using the provided and/or environmental parameters and movements.
framework, which is capable of sharing, merging, The use of BANs in healthcare applications has
withdrawing and trading data according to previ- shown to be beneficial due to its communication
ously defined standards. efficiency and cost-effectiveness. Physiological
signals obtained by body sensors can be effec-
tively processed to obtain reliable and accurate
5. OPEN RESEARCH ISSUES physiological estimations and, at the same time,
AND FUTURE TRENDS the ultralow power consumption provision of such
sensors makes their batteries long-lasting (Acam-
Paying close attention to the evolution of the pora et al., 2013). Furthermore, BANs are scalable
health market, there are some clear trends in and integrable with other network infrastructures,
eHealth(AbuKhousa, Mohamed & Al-Jaroodi, such as Wireless Sensor Networks (WSNs), radio
2012). While relying on ICT, eHealth benefits frequency identification tags (RFID), Bluetooth
from the effects brought forth by the still valid Low Energy (BLE), etc.
Moore Law that roughly claims that each 18 Yet, the sensors’ limited resources in terms of
months, the number of transistors per integrated energy, bandwidth, memory, and computational
circuit doubles. capability are a research challenge to overcome

321

E-Health

so BANs can be widely used. Also, since the experiences at all levels, medication experiments
performance of BANs is closely related to peo- and treatment, contributing strongly to what has
ple’s health, it is important to have safe sensor been common to call the empowered user para-
networks in which the requirements of medical digm. Through these websites, the knowledge is
data privacy, confidentiality, authentication, and no longer only on the side of the healthcare
integrity should be satisfied. The lack of security professionals such as physicians, pharmacists,
in the operation and communication of resource- nurses and so on, but increasingly on the side of
constrained medical sensor nodes in BANs has the patient, who often arrives at a consultation
been an obstacle to move the technology forward with a self-diagnosis. Unfortunately, often this
(Zhang et al., 2012). is an ill-formed diagnostic, and here lies the true
Besides BAN, sensors are being embedded challenge to this type of information sharing
into environments, resulting in intelligent and pro- websites, to define what is trustworthy and what
active living environments capable of supporting is just misinformation and repeated misconcep-
and enhancing daily life. In particular, Wireless tion. The mechanisms to expunge the malignant
Mesh Sensor Networks (WMSNs) could be used information may again be a task for Big Data, if
for designing unobtrusive, interconnected, adapt- we have the necessary number of data items and
able, dynamic and intelligent environments where we apply some basic statistical concepts.
processors and sensors are embedded in everyday A final trend must not be discarded, and this is
objects (Acampora et al., 2013). related to the use of a wider variety of sensors. The
Until these monitoring and therapeutic devices last few years we have seen a number of sensors
are not autonomous, small and cheap, the promise being created, and many of them integrated into
of the Internet of Things, or as some companies mobile phones, cars, domestic appliances and so
like to name it not, the Internet of Everything, will on. The mass use of invasive body sensors has
not be fulfilled. And of course, e-health devices been halted by two reasons, the first related to the
are an important part of this future Internet, be- problems that energizing these sensors carry, and
cause the drive and need to permanent and reli- the second related to regulatory and legal issues.
able monitoring of our bodies as a mean to reach Combining all the previous aforementioned
a higher quality in life is very strong. trends, the future of e-health, we dare say, will
When this happens, and to some extent, it be permanent and pervasive Personalized Health
has been happening for a while, the data will Care Services and in particular, Personalized
start to pile in the servers, and we will need to Medicine. Using pervasive sensing and reliable
find a manner to address the enormous volume communication channels, with virtually inexhaust-
of bio-physiological, behavioral, positional, in- ible or self-chargeable light weight batteries, with
formational, genetic and epigenetic, and social a strong Internet infrastructure that provides not
interaction data, among others. Making sense only the communication and data transmission
of this volume of data is a task for the computer means, but also the hosting and processing of
science area termed Big Data. the Peta Bytes of data each of us will generate,
The number of Internet websites related to a storing them in the Cloud alongside with the Big
particular disease or condition, or to a particular Data applications that will crunch this data to
life-style or philosophy, will also grow. The aim of find the hidden patterns of our body health status.
these sites is to provide the Internet, the end user This will allow for making precise, time sensible
and the health care providers, a view of similar decisions regarding the correction of behaviors

322

E-Health

and lifestyles, the administration of drugs and Accenture. (2010). Information Governance
medicines, ultimately translated into a type of The Foundation for Effective e-Health. White
supervision over our health state that would be Paper. Retrieved from http://www.accenture.
equivalent to having a well-trained and informed com/SiteCollectionDocuments/PDF/Accen-
team of doctors permanently monitoring our bio- ture_100473_InfoGovPoV_Final.pdf
signals and living by our side.
Alwan, A., Armstrong, T., Bettcher, D., Branca,
F., Chisholm, D., Ezzati, M., et al. (2011). Global
status report on noncommunicable diseases.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
World Health Organization (WHO). Retrieved
from http://www.who.int/nmh/publications/
This work was supported by FCT projectPEst-OE/
ncd_report2010/en/
EEI/L A0008/2013 (Este trabalho foi suportado
pelo projecto FCT PEst-OE/EEI/LA0008/2013). Ambient Assisted Living (AAL). (2012). Success
The authors would also like to acknowledge Stories. Retrieved from http://www.aal-europe.
the contribution of the COST Action IC1303 eu/success-stories/
– AAPELE – Architectures, Algorithms and
Avery Dennison Corporation. (2013). Metria™.
Protocols
Retrieved January from http://www.averyden-
nison.com/en/home/technologies/creative-show-
case/metria-wearable-sensor.html
REFERENCES
Blaya, J. A., Fraser, H. S. F., & Holt, B. (2010).
Abdel-Aal, R. (2004). Abductive Network Com- E-Health Technologies Show Promise In Devel-
mittees for Improved Classification of Medical oping Countries. Health Affairs, 29(2), 244–251.
Data. Methods of Information in Medicine, 43(2), doi:10.1377/hlthaff.2009.0894 PMID:20348068
192–201. PMID:15136869
BodyMedia, Inc. (2013). BodyMedia FIT. Re-
Abdel-Aal, R. (2005). Improved Classification of trieved from http://www.bodymedia.com/the_in-
Medical Data Using Abductive Network Com- terface.html
mittees Trained on Different Feature Subsets.
Computer Methods and Programs in Biomedicine, Borges, L. M., Araújo, P., Lebres, A. S., Rente,
80(2), 141–153. doi:10.1016/j.cmpb.2005.08.001 A., Salvado, R., & Velez, F. J. et al. (2010). Wear-
PMID:16169631 able sensors for foetal movement monitoring in
low risk pregnancies. In S. C. Mukhopadhyay &
AbuKhousa, E., Mohamed, N., & Al-Jaroodi, A. Lay-Ekuakille (Eds.), Wearable and Autono-
J. (2012). e-Health Cloud: Opportunities and mous Biomedical Devices and Systems for Smart
Challenges. Future Internet, 4(3), 621–645. Environment: Issues and Characterization (pp.
doi:10.3390/fi4030621 115–136). Springer. doi:10.1007/978-3-642-
Acampora, G., Cook, D. J., Rashidi, P., & 15687-8_6
Vasilakos, A. V. (2013). A Survey on Ambi-
ent Intelligence in Health Care. Proceedings of
the IEEE, 101(12), 2470–2494. doi:10.1109/
JPROC.2013.2262913 PMID:24431472

323

E-Health

Boulos, M. N. K., Lou, R. C., Anastasiou, A., Cuno, S., Glickman, Y., Baboshin, A., Haritou,
Nugent, C. D., Alexandersson, J., & Zimmermann, M., Serretti, A., Androulidakis, A., & Calati, R.
G. et  al. (2009). Connectivity for Healthcare (2011). Management, Monitoring and Supporting
and Well-Being Management: Examples from Dementia Patients at Home by ALADDIN. In
Six European Projects. International Journal Proceedings of eChallenges e-2011. IIMC Inter-
of Environmental Research and Public Health, national Information Management Corporation.
6(7), 1947–1971. doi:10.3390/ijerph6071947
Dong, N., Jonker, H., & Pang, J. (2012). Challenges
PMID:19742164
in eHealth: From Enabling to Enforcing Privacy.
Boulos, M.N.K, Rocha, A., Martins, A., Vicente, In Z. Liu & A. Wassyng (Eds.), Foundations of
M.E., Bolz, A., Feld, R., & …, Kinirons, M. Health Informatics Engineering and System (pp.
(2007). CAALYX: A new generation of location- 195–206). Springer. doi:10.1007/978-3-642-
based services in healthcare. International Journal 32355-3_12
of Health Geographics, 6(9). PMID:17352802
Handford, R. (2013). Telefonica reveals future
Boulos, M. N. K., Wheeler, S., Tavares, C., & plans following Parkinson’s trial. Retrieved
Jones, R. (2011). How smartphones are changing from http://www.mobileworldlive.com/telefon-
the face of mobile and participatory healthcare: An ica-announces-results-future-plans-following-
overview, with example from eCAALYX. Biomed- parkinsons-trial
ical Engineering Online, 10(24). PMID:21466669
Haritou, M., Glickman, Y., Androulidakis, A.,
CamNtech Ltd and CamNtech Inc. (2012). Acti- Xefteris, S., Anastasiou, A., & Baboshin, A. et al.
heart. Retrieved from http://www.camntech.com/ (2012). A Technology Platform for a Novel Home
products/actiheart/actiheart-overview Care Delivery Service to Patients with Dementia.
Journal of Medical Imaging and Health Informat-
Centre de Recerca I Inovació de Catalunya (CRIC).
ics, 2(1), 1–7. doi:10.1166/jmihi.2012.1060
(2012) Softcare: Unobtrusive plug and play kit for
chronic condition based on customized behaviour Health Stats. (2010). PULSE CASPro®. Re-
recognition. Retrieved from http://www.cric.cat/ trieved from http://www.healthstats.com/index3.
project-detail/16/ php?page=product_apulsepro
Chen, M., Gonzalez, S., Vasilakos, A., Cao, H., Hendeby, G., Bleser, G., Lamprinos, I., & Stricker,
& Leung, V. C. M. (2011). Body Area Networks: D. (2010). Healthy Aging using Physical Activity
A Survey. Journal Mobile Network Application, Monitoring. In Proceedings of AALIANCE Con-
16(2), 171–193. doi:10.1007/s11036-010-0260-8 ference. Malaga, Spain: AALIANCE.
Cooking Hacks. (2013). e-Health Sensor Platform Ineed MD, Inc. (2012). EKG Glove™. Retrieved
for Arduino and Rasperry Pi [Biometric/Medi- from http://www.ineedmd.com/public/features.
cal Applications]. Retrieved from http://www. html
cooking-hacks.com/documentation/tutorials/
IS-ACTIVE Project– Inertial Sensing System for
ehealth-v1-biometric-sensor-platform-arduino-
Advanced Chronic Condition Monitoring and
raspberry-pi-medical/
RiskPrevention. (2010). WP2 – Architecture,
Architecture Specification (Deliverable D2.2). Re-
trieved from http://www.is-active.eu/deliverables/

324

E-Health

Larson, E., Lee, T., Liu, S., Rosenfeld, M., & Patel, ROSETTA Project. (2012b). Guidance and Aware-
S. N. (2011). Accurate and Privacy Preserving ness Services for Independent Living (Flyer).
Cough Sensing using a Low-Cost Microphone. In Retrieved from http://www.aal-rosetta.eu/Site_ro-
Proceedings of the 13th International Conference setta/docs/ROSETTA_Flyer_e_IESE-100118.pdf
on Ubiquitous Computing (UbiComp 2011). Bei-
Sáez, I., Oliveras, M., Ciudad, M. J., Fort, I., Llo-
jing, China: ACM. doi:10.1145/2030112.2030163
part, J. R., & Haritou, M., & the Aladdin Research
McAdams, E., Krupaviciute, A., Gehin, C., Dit- Consortium. (2011). A Technology Platform for the
tmar, A., Delhomme, G., & Rubel, P. et al. (2011). Assisted Living of Dementia Elderly Individuals
Wearable Electronic Systems: Applications to and their Carers. Paper presented at the 7th Con-
Medical Diagnostics/Monitoring. In A. Bonfiglio gress of the European Union Geriatric Medicine
& D. De Rossi (Eds.), Wearable Monitoring Sys- Society (EUGMS). Malaga, Spain.
tems (pp. 179–203). Springer. doi:10.1007/978-
Sánchez-Tato, I., Senciales, J. C., Salinas, J.,
1-4419-7384-9_9
Fanucci, L., Pardini, G., Costalli, F., et al. (2010).
Minnesota e-Health Initiative and the Minne- Health @ Home: A telecare system for patients
sota Department of Health. (2013). Glossary with chronic heart failure. In Proceedings of
of Selected Terms and Acronyms. White Paper. Fifth International Conference on Broadband
Retrieved from http://www.health.state.mn.us/e- and Biomedical Communications (IB2Com).
health/glossary/ehealthglossary.pdf Malaga, Spain: IB2Com. doi:10.1109/IB-
2COM.2010.5723634
Murray, E. (2012). Web-Based Interventions for
Behavior Change andSelf-Management: Potential, Saponara, S., Donati, M., Bacchillone, T., Fanucci,
Pitfalls, and Progress. Medicine 2.0, 1(2e3). L., Sanchez-Tato, I., Carmona, C., & Barba, P.
(2012). Remote monitoring of vital signs in pa-
Prakash, D. (2012). New Patch-Based Wear-
tients with chronic heart failure: Sensor devices and
able Sensor Combines Advanced Skin Adhesive
data analysis perspective. In Proceedings of Sen-
and Sensor Technologies. Retrieved from http://
sors Applications Symposium (SAS) 2012. Brescia,
www.mdtmag.com/articles/2012/07/new-patch-
Italy: SAS. doi:10.1109/SAS.2012.6166310
based-wearable-sensor-combines-advanced-skin-
adhesives-and-sensor-technologies Stellefson, M., Chaney, B., Barry, A.E., Chavarria,
E., Tennant, B., Walsh-Childers, K., Sriram,P.S,
Ragesh, G. K., & Baskaran, K. (2012). A Survey
Zagora, J. (2013). Web 2.0 Chronic Disease Self-
on Futuristic Health Care System: WBANs. Pro-
Management for Older Adults: A Systematic
cedia Engineering, 30, 889–896. doi:10.1016/j.
Review. Journal of Medical Internet Research,
proeng.2012.01.942
15(2e35).
REMOTE Project. (2012). Remote health and
Swan, M. (2012). Sensor Mania! The Internet of
social care for independent living of isolated
Things, Wearable Computing, Objective Metrics,
elderly with chronic conditions. Retrieved from
and the Quantified Self 2.0. Journal of Sensor and
http://www.remote-project.eu/
Actuator Networks, 1(3), 217–253. doi:10.3390/
ROSETTA Project. (2012a). Retrieved from http:// jsan1030217
www.aal-rosetta.eu/

325

E-Health

Texas Instruments. (2014). eZ430-Chronos™ KEY TERMS AND DEFINITIONS


Development Tool. Retrieved from http://www.
ti.com/tool/ez430-chronos Ambient Assisted Living: New area that use
of information and communication technology to
Trindade, I. G., Lucas, J., Miguel, R., Alpuim, P., enable new products, services, and processes that
Carvalho, M., & Garcia, N. M. (2010). Lightweight help to provide safe, healthy, lives for the aged
Portable Sensors for Health Care. In Proceed- and for people in recovery.
ings of 12th IEEE International Conference on Chronic Diseases: Diseases that have one or
e-Health Networking Applications and Services more of the following characteristics: they are
(Healthcom). Lyon, France: IEEE. doi:10.1109/ permanent; they produce inability or residual
HEALTH.2010.5556575 disability, are caused by irreversible pathological
Vivonoetics. (2013). LifeShirt. Retrieved from changes, require special training of the patient
http://vivonoetics.com/products/sensors/lifeshirt/ for rehabilitation, or may require long periods of
supervision, observation or care.
Waterworth, J. A., Ballesteros, S., & Peter, C. E-Health: Healthcare practice supported by
(2009). User-sensitive Home-based Systems for information and communication technologies and
Successful Ageing. In Proceedings of 2nd Con- electronic processes.
ference on Human Systems Interactions. Catania, Multi-Sensors Platforms: Integrated technol-
Italy: Academic Press. ogy that enables ubiquitous presence of sensing,
Zhang, Z., Wang, H., Vasilakos, A. V., & Fang, computing and communication capabilities and
H. (2012). ECG-Cryptography and Authentication hence, enable a large number of application
in Body Area Networks. IEEE Transactions on domains.
Information Technology in Biomedicine, 16(6), Tele-Monitoring: Healthcare practice involv-
1070–1078. doi:10.1109/TITB.2012.2206115 ing remotely monitoring of patients who are not
PMID:22752143 at the same location as the health care provider.

Zhou, J., Cao, Z., Dong, X., Lin, X., & Vasilakos,
A. V. (2013). Securing m-Healthcare Scial Net-
works: Challenges, Countermeasures and Future
Directions. IEEE Wireless Communications,
20(4), 12–21. doi:10.1109/MWC.2013.6590046

326

View publication stats

You might also like