Professional Documents
Culture Documents
)
Sarah A. Dunlop,‡ and K. Swaminathan Iyer†,*
†
School of Biomedical, Biomolecular and Chemical Sciences, The University of Western Australia, 35 Stirling Highway, Crawley WA 6009, Australia, ‡Experimental
and Regenerative Neurosciences, School of Animal Biology, The University of Western Australia, Australia, §School of Physics, The University of Western Australia,
Australia, ^Centre for Microscopy, Characterisation and Analysis, The University of Western Australia, Australia, School of Anatomy and Human Biology,
)
The University of Western Australia, Australia, #School of Materials Science and Engineering, Clemson University, Clemson, South Carolina 29634, United States,
4
Department of Bioengineering, University of California, San Diego, 9500 Gilman Drive, La Jolla, California 92093, United States, and 3Department of
Ophthalmology, University of California, San Diego, Jacobs Retina Center, 9415 Campus Point Drive, La Jolla, California 92037, United States
T
he use of nanoparticles for site-
specific delivery of therapeutic pay- ABSTRACT
loads is a goal that has attracted
considerable attention in biomedical
research.1,2 The potential ability to load a
single nanoparticle preparation with a vari-
ety of drugs and facilitate delivery to
specific intracellular or extracellular sites
would be a significant advance, because
the nanoparticle delivery strategy is gener-
alizable and can be used to release low Polymer nanoparticles are widely used as a highly generalizable tool to entrap a range of different
molecular mass compounds, proteins, and
drugs for controlled or site-specific release. However, despite numerous studies examining the kinetics
recombinant DNAs at focal areas of disease,
maximizing clinical benefits while limiting of controlled release, the biological behavior of such nanoparticles remains poorly understood,
side effects.2,3 Recent reports also suggest particularly with respect to endocytosis and intracellular trafficking. We synthesized polyethylenimine-
that nanoparticles can influence cellular decorated polymer nanospheres (ca. 100250 nm) of the type commonly used for drug release and
signaling by interacting with membrane used correlated electron microscopy, fluorescence spectroscopy and microscopy, and relaxometry to
microdomains that house different signal- track endocytosis in neural cells. These capabilities provide insight into how polyethylenimine mediates
ing components such as receptors, signal
the entry of nanoparticles into neural cells and show that polymer nanosphere uptake involves three
activators, and transducers.2,46 Because
distinct steps, namely, plasma membrane attachment, fluid-phase as well as clathrin- and caveolin-
the response to this activation includes
changes to cellular transport and target- independent endocytosis, and progressive accumulation in membrane-bound intracellular vesicles.
ing, a precise understanding of the entire These findings provide detailed insight into how the intracellular delivery of nanoparticles is mediated
intracellular nanoparticle itinerary, beyond by polyethylenimine, which is presently the most commonly used nonviral gene transfer agent. This
the point of initial entry, is important to fundamental knowledge may also assist in the preparation of next-generation nonviral vectors.
fully realize the potential of these nano-
materials as drug carriers and transfection KEYWORDS: nanosphere . endocytosis . neuron . polyethylenimine .
multimodal imaging
agents.
Intracellular and extracellular barriers
preventing successful drug delivery have
been overcome in numerous studies using in very high transfection efficacy of its * Address correspondence to
swaminatha.iyer@uwa.edu.au.
nanosized complexes of cationic lipids polyplexes.10,11 After endocytosis, the nat-
(lipoplexes) or synthetic polycations (poly- ural acidification within the endosome pro- Received for review June 16, 2011
plexes).79 Of the latter, polyethylenimine tonates PEI, inducing chloride ion influx, and accepted October 17, 2011.
(PEI), the most widely used nonviral vector, osmotic swelling, and destabilization of
Published online
is considered the gold standard. This is the vesicle, leading to release of polyplexes 10.1021/nn2022149
because PEI can act as a “proton sponge” into the cytoplasm.12,13 The major shortfall
and promote endosomal escape, resulting of PEI as a nonviral vector, however, is that C XXXX American Chemical Society
toxicity scales with transfection efficacy.11,14 There is as the dispersed phase. This organic solution of the dye-
very little mechanistic understanding of PEI-mediated modified polymer, also containing iron oxide nanoparti-
intracellular delivery,15 which is important not only cles (Figure 1b), was emulsified in water in the presence
because PEI is commonly used for nonviral gene of a surfactant. The polymer nanoparticles were char-
transfer but also because this knowledge may direct acterized using transmission electron microscopy
the design and synthesis of next-generation nonviral (Figure 1c, d), dynamic light scattering (Figure 1e),
vectors with low toxicity. Most current methods to fluorescence spectrophotometry (Figure S1), and mag-
study intracellular trafficking of nanoparticles are re- netometry (Figure S2). Analysis of nanospheres before
stricted to co-localization of nanomaterials with specific and after PEI attachment revealed a small increase in
endocytic markers or the exclusion of specific mechan- average size and a large positive shift in the zeta
isms by chemical inhibition or cell mutation.1621 potential distribution (Figure 1e). The average particle
diameter following PEI attachment was 160 nm
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION (distribution 90260 nm), and particles comprised
In this work, an approach was developed to directly approximately 3% PEI by weight (see Supporting In-
image endocytosis and intracellular trafficking using formation for elemental analysis). Nanospheres were
fluorescent and magnetic polymer nanospheres. Polymer magnetically separated from excess, unbound PEI.
nanospheres were prepared from poly(glycidyl metha- Toxicity of Nanospheres. The toxicity and transfection
crylate) (PGMA) modified with rhodamine B (RhB) dye, efficacy of PEI depend on both its molecular weight
which was used to encapsulate magnetite (Fe3O4) nano- and structure (i.e., linear or branched).15 Two possible
particles. The epoxide groups on PGMA enabled an- explanations for cellular perturbation and toxicity have
choring of PEI chains by means of a simple ring-open- been suggested. First, the presence of free PEI may play
ing reaction (Figure 1a), as previously demonstrated.22 a role in inducing cell dysfunction because both
These nanospheres enabled a multimodal approach to branched and linear configurations can bind to plasma
directly assess how PEI mediates the cellular trafficking membrane proteoglycans, compromise membrane in-
of nanoparticles, using correlated relaxometry, fluores- tegrity, and induce early necrotic-like changes within
cence spectroscopy and microscopy, and transmission 30 min.14 Second, PEI-induced cytotoxicity has been
electron microscopy. The polymer nanoparticles were related to the activation of a mitochondrially mediated
synthesized using a nonspontaneous emulsification apoptotic program involving channel formation in the
method, in which a binary solvent mixture containing outer mitochondrial membrane within 24 h.14,23 In the
both immiscible and soluble components was employed present study, covalent grafting of PEI chains to the
magnetic PGMA core allowed the removal of free PEI with PEI modification were taken up rapidly, within
using magnetic separation, facilitating a clear determi- minutes, while those without PEI modification were
nation of whether PEI-modified nanospheres were not associated with cells even after 3 days (Figure S4).
toxic or not. Nanospheres that were internalized presented a punc-
The toxicity of the modified nanospheres was ex- tate distribution and were excluded from the nucleus
amined in rat pheochromocytoma neural progenitor (Figure 2ad). To examine the dynamics of endocyto-
(PC12) and retinal Müller glial cell lines (rMC-1), as well sis, we used live cell confocal imaging to monitor
as primary rat hippocampal and cortical neuron cul- fluorescence of nanospheres in PC12 cells for periods
tures after 24 and/or 72 h incubation (Figure S3). For of 24 and 72 h (Figure 2e, Videos S1 and S2). In time-
the immortalized cultures, there was no decrease in lapse experiments, using a single confocal slice
viable cell numbers (p > 0.05) for any of the tested through the cells, we observed a linear increase in
concentrations (up to 250 μg mL1). Similar results fluorescence per cell with time (Figure 2f). Similar
were observed in the primary neuron cultures, where a results were obtained with primary cortical and hippo-
toxic effect (p e 0.05) was observed only at very high campal neuronal cultures, with a greater intensity of
nanosphere concentrations (1000 μg mL1) that would fluorescence per cell in cortical cells (Figure S5). There
be inappropriate therapeutically. The assay was ver- was no apparent correlation between the intensity of
ified by assessing trypan blue dye exclusion in PC12 fluorescence indicating nanosphere uptake and the
cells. In line with previously proposed mechanisms of viability of the various cell cultures following treat-
PEI toxicity, we suggest two reasons for our observed ment. The result in PC12 cells was also confirmed using
lack of toxicity in the tested cell lines and primary a spectrofluorometric plate reader to measure inten-
cultures. First, our PEI chain length was shorter sity over large samples of cells. A constant rate of
(1.2 kDa) than used in previous studies (25 and uptake has been previously reported for zwitterionic
750 kDa),14,24 and second, PEI was bound to the nano- quantum dots in HeLa cells.25
spheres and, as a result, may have been unable to interact Endocytosis of Nanospheres Determined by Drug Inhibition
with mitochondrial membranes. This investigation cov- and Electron Microscopy. There are many distinct endocy-
ered the time course of known cytotoxic changes.14 tic pathways that coexist in mammalian cells that
Nanosphere Uptake Monitored by Fluorescence. Nano- regulate the entry of a wide range of different sized
sphere uptake was examined in more depth, to further moieties from ions to macromolecules, pathogens, and
analyze intracellular trafficking and investigate why drugs. It follows that polymeric nanoparticle drug
PEI-modified nanospheres were not toxic. When nano- delivery systems are also subject to the same
spheres were incubated with PC12 cells, nanospheres selectivity.2,6,26 Uptake of nanoparticles by endocytosis
resultant expression. The process is rapid, with release sequence in which smaller nanosphere clusters fused
via osmotic swelling occurring within 4 h and DNA to form larger aggregates, but were not contained in
expression peaking at 24 h.40 That we did not observe lysosomes within 72 h.
osmotic swelling or signs of endosomal escape is in Relaxometry Can Be Used to Follow Nanosphere Endocytosis.
accordance with our finding of a lack of toxicity within The observation of compartmentalization of nano-
24 h. Taken together, our observations suggest a spheres in individual PC12 cells by TEM was confirmed
in a larger population of cells using relaxometry. This Figure 4a). There was a 2-fold decrease in the longi-
analysis was made possible by the superparamagnetic tudinal relaxivity r1 (r1free = 4.70 ( 0.05 mM1 s1,
iron oxide nanoparticles contained within the nano- r1cell = 2.70 ( 0.26 mM1 s1; Figure 4b). The decrease
spheres. Superparamagnetic nanoparticles are effec- in r2 on compartmentalization of nanospheres is at-
tive contrast agents for magnetic resonance (MR) tributed to the behavior of the aggregates as a micro-
imaging, as they possess a large magnetic moment metric nanosphere. The larger effective diameter shifts
and are free to align with an applied magnetic field. the compartmentalized nanoparticles into the echo-
The resultant microscopic field gradients dephase limited proton relaxation regime.47 In this echo-limited
nearby protons, shortening both the longitudinal re- environment, the perturbations in the magnetic field
laxation time T1 and the transverse relaxation time T2. experienced by the water protons become effectively
T1 is also reduced via other relaxation mechanisms. static. Hence, the refocusing pulses become efficient,
The corresponding relaxation rates, R1 and R2, are reducing r2 compared to the dispersed nanoparticles
influenced by the local concentration of nanoparticles, and introducing a significant dependency on the echo
the applied field strength, and the environment in spacing (Figure 4c). Furthermore, the dramatic depen-
which the nanoparticles interact with surrounding dence of r1 on magnetic field strength (Figure 4d) is
protons.4144 In particular, the relaxation induced by also consistent with clustering of the nanoparticles and
iron oxide nanoparticles is known to depend on their similar to theoretical predictions and observations.48
compartmentalization in macrophages, lymphocytes, We attribute the reduction in r1 to the less rapid inner-
oligodendrocytes, human neural stem cells, and me- sphere exchange of water molecules inside the cell as
senchymal stem cells.4146 well as a reduced molecular exchange with bulk water
We analyzed relaxation rates in PC12 cells after 72 h through a “membrane-shielding” effect.45
exposure, by which time PEI-modified nanospheres Using fluorescence intensity as a measure of iron
were bound within intracellular compartments. We content, we would expect that the state of clustering
compared relaxation rates of nanospheres that had within cells could be measured over time using relaxo-
been endocytosed by PC12 cells with those of free metry. This advantage of the multimodal nanospheres
nanospheres, both of which were held in agarose gels. will be helpful in following endolysosomal sorting not
The transverse relaxivity of free nanospheres at 1.4 T only in vitro but also on a larger scale in vivo using live
was r2free = 322 ( 26 mM1 s1 with a 19-fold fluorescence imaging in conjunction with MRI. A stan-
reduction in PC12 cells (r2cell = 16.7 ( 1.2 mM1 s1; dard curve of fluorescence versus iron content was