Professional Documents
Culture Documents
COLE’S SONG
LYRICS
A THESIS
MUHAMMAD IQBAL
N1D2 16 043
1
2
ABSTRACT
LIST OF CONTENTS
TITLE SHEET.................................................................................................i
APPROVAL SHEET......................................................................................ii
ABSTRACT....................................................................................................iii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT.............................................................................iv
LIST OF CONTENTS....................................................................................v
CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION....................................................................1
1.1. Background Of The Research .................................................................1
1.2. Research Question...................................................................................4
1.3. Objective Of Research ............................................................................4
1.4. Scope of the Research..............................................................................5
1.5. Significance of the Research...................................................................5
1.6. Definition of Terms.................................................................................6
REFERENCES..............................................................................................83
APPENDIX....................................................................................................87
5
CHAPTER I
INTRODUCTION
objective of the study, significance of the study, scope of the study and definition
of terms.
1.1 Background
other. In this world, there are various kinds of languages used by humans. In the
life, human use languages to communicate with other people in the environment.
It also can be affecting the human language development. Basically, human has its
own language and characteristic of it. Therefore, the broader a person's social life,
the greater the possibility that the person is adopting the language from the other
variation, the function of language, and language use in interaction and the
(2006:12) said that sociolinguistics is the study of language variation and that the
purpose of such a study is to find out what variation tells us about language and
6
The language also has another role in society. By knowing their language,
then we will easily know the culture of that person. That can happen because
language and culture go hand in hand. We can also know the place of origin of
other people only through the language. Then from this knowledge, we can easily
wrong. This misconception usually results from a person's past experiences with
others and it also called a stereotype. Actually this stereotype can also be a system
that is at the core of our personal traditions, and also a way for us to maintain our
position in society (Lippman, 1998). Stereotype also is a fixed idea or image that
many people have a particular type of person, thing, or event, but sometimes it is
not true in reality. People who are stereotyped will be worried about what they are
doing. They will think that whatever they do will get criticism from others. The
In addition to the social life of the community, stereotypes are also often
realized in some works. The works can be in the form of movies, novels, songs,
and so on. Here the writer will explain the stereotype in a song. In a song,
stereotypes emerge from the song's lyrics. The lyrics are the expressions of the
heart or ideas owned by the author. The lyrics are usually derived from the
Song lyrics are the media or means used by the author in expressing ideas
or thoughts to the listeners. Besides entertainment, song lyrics can also be a place
song makes words and wordplay to create attraction and distinctiveness to the
lyrics. This wordplay can be in the form of vocal games, linguistic styles and
deviations of word meanings and is reinforced by the use of melodies and musical
notations that are tailored to the lyrics of the song so that listeners get carried
In this study, the writer took Jermaine Lamarr Cole's song lyrics as an
object. Jermaine Lamarr Cole or better known by the name J. Cole is an American
Rapper, Singer, Songwriter, and record producer. These songs from J. Cole are
the work of his own creation and handwriting. That can show us that the songs of
J. Cole are the result of thoughts or past experiences of himself. J. Cole's song
lyrics describe a lot about the social life he experienced. Such as his love for a
woman, how difficult it is to get a decent life, and he often writes about how
people perceive black people. Then, he packaged very beautifully in song lyrics.
The stereotype in the J. Cole’s song lyrics are usually about views directed
at the Black People. Because that's basically that J. Cole is an African American.
The song lyrics of J. Cole are expressions of his resistance in seeing racism in
black life in America. The history sheet proves that the American black
community often gets tortured and social discrimination. They are identified
8
differently from other general public. They are only mobilized to work without
J. Cole also takes so many social issues in his lyrics. Although the lyrics of
J. Cole’s songs telling about racism and government institutions. But his song's
lyrics are widely accepted because he presents them in a very complex way. Song
lyrics of J. Cole can not only be judged by wordplay but also from the meaning in
the lyrics of the song. In one of his songs, he wrote about how politics in America
much deviated, and a system of justice and police that seemed to view an African
American as a criminal.
man, does not often cause problems, and is also a loyal person to his wife. These
are so different from the rapper impression that has been raised in the public. The
rapper who initially seemed like a gangster but many people changes the
his interview with theme J. Cole: I Am Not Be as Successful If I Had a Dark Skin
in BET about his nominee for Best Hip-Hop Video at 2013. BET is the best
source for looking for about the news that included the black celebrity. In BET the
interviewer asked him about stereotype that he got in real life. It because he talked
about racism and stereotype through his song lyrics. He said “I am a rapper, I
wish I could tell them something better that happen all the time and I hate it. I hate
that we’re stereotyped and I hate that I’m fitting into the same stereotype” (BET,
9
2013). Racial stereotypes are usually directed by white people against black
people. Stereotypes are sometimes unfair to the recipients and are very loaded
with negative emotions, which is very dangerous for the interaction between them
because it is done without any argumentation. J. Cole not only told about the hard
times experienced by black people, but he also had discussed how the lives of
important because we can see a form of life of black people in song lyrics, which
we can then make reference that we cannot immediately judge a people just by
looking at it. The reason the author took J. Cole's song lyrics as research material
is as discussed in the previous paragraphs that J. Cole very often took up issues
about social life which were his personal experiences during his life as a black
man in the United States. That’s why the writer choose this topic because there are
still many stereotypes of black people in J. Cole’s song lyrics that haven’t been
revealed because it hasn’t been revealed yet so the writer wants to study further.
question as follows “What are the stereotypes of black people in J. Cole’s song
lyrics?”
The objective of this study is to find out what are the stereotypes of black
This study would only focus on identifying the stereotype of black people
in J. Cole’s song lyrics. In this analysis the writer only uses J. Cole’s song lyrics
which are using the stereotype of the black people in it based on Lippman’s
theory.
In this analysis the writer only use six J. Cole song lyrics, they are:
Immortal, Be Free (Live on Letterman), Neighbors, G.O.M.D, Too Deep for the
1. Theoretical Significance
2. Practical Significance
1. This study can be used as a reference for anyone who wants to learn
2. This study can also be used as a reference to another writer who wants
1. Stereotype can exist about casual or temporary groups no less than about
2. Song lyrics is a thing that can make the interrelationship between the
LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 Sociolinguistics
in social life. Social issues can also be learned through sociolinguistics. Because
in sociolinguistics we are taught or we can see how languages can interact with
society. Sociolinguistics study has more to say about social issues, and some
sociolinguistic study has more to say about linguistic matters (Meyerwoff, 2006).
language is. By studying sociolinguistics we can also learn about society. In the
social community, there are several people who have different languages.
In using language in social life, people usually use language that can
represent them. Because by speaking or in the language they use, we can know the
place or where that person came from. From these things, radicalism usually
12
13
happens in social life. Those things they consider as self-protection because they
feel threatened by the presence of someone new in their environment. They feel
they already know how the social life of the person is only from the language. In
sociolinguistics, social issues are things that can be understood and studied
because they refer to how the language relates to social life. One radical storage of
social issues in sociolinguistics is that writers are given a very strong foundation
that language speakers use language to present themselves in front of others and to
provide information from one person to another, but at the same time, a speaker
uses language that shows who they are, how they perceive their relationship with
the listener, and in which part they want to be involved in a conversation. As the
language, we can easily find out about someone we haven't even known before.
But it can also have an impact on the speaker because with this thing the listener
can set a statement about how nature, character, and a social life that is owned by
the speaker. These statements are usually negative because the assessment given
the sociolinguistics knowledge of a person, then that person will easily blend into
the environment they will face. Everyone can modify or change the way they
14
speak depending on who and what situation they are facing. When they do this,
they use their sociolinguistics science. Every time they talk, they change their way
of speaking depending on who the other person is talking to and the situation
(Meyerwoff, 2006).
draw the conclusion that sociolinguistics can separate barriers between people in
language and social life. That happens because language users get a lot of
This Social Network approach is not based on the same use of language but is an
approach that is based on social ties, such as family, school friends, and neighbors
(Ball, 2005). From that data, we can make an explanation that sociolinguistics can
be a link between people of different places of residence and origin, who can
understand each other in a social group. In sociolinguistics, there are two factors
in a Social Network that become the main strength in it (Ball, 2005:8), namely:
2. Density (If the relationship around you is a binding relationship between one
another, these ties realizes that this relationship is denser than ties that don't
know one another.This proves that in social relationships there are also
15
differences depending on the ties or closeness of each person. The ties can
also affect the language he uses, the closer the bond between people the
Meyerwoff (2006:52), the different views of these speakers underlie the tensions
class or age groups, and generalizations that tend to be much smaller, and
sometimes quite special, in which the community is built through the member
shared practices.
The conflict also exists because of social and linguistic problems that are
deemed to prevent or are disliked by certain forms that occur in the variations of
the given language, which are actually part of the variation of sociolinguistics
above, there is a desire for generalization from several social parties because it is
considered to hinder or not release it. It explains that the language variables in
their use or distribution are limited. This can be done by linking or placing
In other cases as well, we can assume that even in a group of speakers are
aware of different places, but we are not aware of the time difference. In a group
16
of speakers, there are variations in age with each speaker. That happens because
the basics of the speaker's language system have been placed in their youth, when
we listen to someone who is 75 years old then we can find out about the norms or
patterns of society that existed when they were children (Meyerwoff, 2006:134).
This can lead to the assumption that diversity in sociolinguistics is not just a
difference in place and style of language, but can also be a difference in time
compared to differences in gender, social class, and ethnicity. This results in that
age are considered a global sociolinguistic that is not yet fully developed. Because
the nature of age tends to be dynamic, changing over time, and difficult to
difficult to learn about complex relationships that occur because of the changing
From some of the explanations above, the writer can conclude that
which is also explains how language life in a group of people. We can also know
often occur in a community group. Even this eventually led to conflict within the
social group itself. However, if we can study carefully what sociolinguistics is,
2.2 Stereotype
group against other groups (Lippman, 1998). The way they see or value a culture
can be through their past experiences that have cultural similarities with the
person or group they face today. If we look at this assumption, we can define
stereotype as the impression someone leaves on someone else. That can be a good
thing, but on the other hand it can also have a negative impact on the person left
behind by the impression. Through this way, the person will only judge someone
only from the outside. Then the person who is subject to the stereotype will
Stereotype has a very strong effect because people who carry out these
perspectives can spread their responses on a mass scale. It can also be a spread of
stereotypes against people or a group. Stereotypes are powerful because with the
disposition of someone or the recipient of the event it can make a large scale
(Schweinitz, 2011). This can prove that the stereotype of someone can spread.
This thing is very bad for those who are subject to these stereotypes. It could be,
because these things will call social inequalities within a community group.
18
People only think or only remember the negative side of someone. Although it
seems that this assessment will only affect one's perspective, it is very bad for the
to the social influence (Kashima, Fiedler, & Freytag, 2008). The concept that we
get about a group or someone sometimes we just accept it without any prior
Without any experience, or the events experienced do not hold a person to carry
out his perspective or views. However, this is very negative towards those subject
In another view, we can give the idea that this stereotype is inaccurate and
stereotype are cultural, racial, gender and social class issues. Culture is often the
main factor in one's judgment. Where does the person come from, how is the
culture contained in the area of origin, and what physical features are there in the
person's area. These things are part of one's thoughts on the culture that is owned
by someone else. The reason why culture used as a form of assessment is because
humans grow and develop with the culture around them. Therefore, people will
associate between the cultures of the person with the original nature they have.
19
The phenomena that occur in society regarding cultural issues make this
environment consists of various cultures and personalities that are owned by each
in the mind of people who stereotype that people who are different from us will
(Schweinitz, 2011). From this explanation, it can be said that an action or an event
that occurred could not have been due to the actions of a group or social class
becomes a depiction in the community, which assumes that someone in the group
will be a depiction of people who are in a group or social class. What cause
The views that arise in society are sometimes not followed by clear facts.
Sometimes it also appears just an opinion of the person. Kashima, Fiedler, &
Freytag (2008:1) stated that in society there are questions about whether
judgments and decisions that occur are informed by facts or only based on
20
that occurs to people who are subject to stereotypes is not based on the facts that
exist in the individual itself, but only based on the stereotypes that have been
community lies in the assumption that the community considers all individuals in
group there is a person or a group that performs a limited function and in each of
their activities they will be limited (Lippman, 1998). Of course, it will have a
negative impact not only on individuals but also on social groups that are subject
to a stereotype. Actions carried out by someone against another person, can lead
to assumptions that are not significant to the social group of the person. Because
the assumption is not accompanied by data and facts that show that the people in
that person's social group are of the same character or characteristics. A social
class should not be considered good or bad only by the actions of one or a few of
its members.
(2015:2), by placing the stereotype in the context of social conversation can make
that is shared by others. If it is packaged with a good scheme and with a good
purpose, the actual discussion about stereotypes in society can be very useful. Not
21
only improve the relationship between social classes, but also in terms of our
gives their views wrong or their description of something is not clear (Lippman,
1998). Then, the results of these thoughts become a stereotype of the person who
terms of social groups. From these responses we can also say that a stereotype
arises only from a person's short thoughts. They do not see the facts of what is
might be able to trigger the brain to be able to think and interpret things quickly.
However, in terms of the authenticity of the information can still be doubted. This
is because there are no facts and data obtained before interpretation in the brain
that occurs.
From the explanation above, the writer can give an understanding that
Stereotypes exist because of the past experience of the person who gives and the
person who bears the stereotype itself. Stereotype itself is a person's judgment
without the appearance of facts and data about a situation or event experienced by
with our speed of giving a perception of someone it will also quickly our brain
will process and that is a good thing for the human brain. However, the data and
facts possessed by the giver of the stereotype can still be doubted. But, that cannot
22
be a reason for not learning stereotypes in society. Because, with how much we
understand about stereotypes, we will get more knowledge about the diversity of
cultures and languages in society. Stereotypes also have a variety of types, but this
time the author will only explain how stereotypes are toward black people.
of black people. Of course the user of this stereotype comes from people who are
different from the black race itself. Sometimes white people support the existence
of negative stereotypes of black people who not only judge black people against
white people, but also influence the way white people respond to counter
stereotypes against people blacks (Peffley, Hurwitz, & Sniderman, 1997). This
proves that the assessment of white people against these black people is deeply
assessment with what is in the minds of the white people earlier, they will always
respond to it.
people than older people. From the explanation put forward by the expert, we can
say that the most disadvantaged in this regard were the black people themselves.
Because basically the presumption about culture and also their lifestyle is always
assessed by those who do not check in advance about what facts are in the
stereotype problem. Another thing we get from this explanation is that the
culture and social issues. Because when we are talking about a stereotype we must
also learn and have knowledge about the culture especially black people before
stereotype that black people are people who have souls of crime. In other
explanation said that white people are very serious in assuming that black people
are more likely to have a high spirit of crime (Peffley, Hurwitz, & Sniderman,
1997). In addition to the problem of crime, white people also often give
stereotypes to the field of welfare owned by black people. The welfare of black
people is sometimes lower than that of white skin. That is what then makes
for them to become suspects in the event of murder and rape (Weafer, 2016). This
shows that there is no justice and equality before the law of black people. In their
actions for justice, community members use stereotypes as benchmarks for crime.
Stereotype has a big impact on black people. Based on this we can assume that the
Based on what has been written above, the writer assumes that the Black
Next is that the perpetrators of this stereotype are usually people who do not have
more knowledge about the culture of people who are subject to this stereotype.
24
addition, language also has very close ties with culture and has very strong roots.
According to the Nabi (2017: 91), language is used as a preserver and a means to
convey culture and the bonds contained therein. Language is said to be the
preserver of culture because in essence culture that is spread in a social group will
Because language and culture are very closely related to society. Then
language must also be taught to other members of the community so that they can
understand the culture taught to them. One way to ensure that culture can be
official language (Freimuth, 2006). That language then becomes something very
important in spreading culture. It not only affects culture but also the language.
By the spread of culture can also maintain the language used in a community
group.
The languages that exist in this world will always carry external meaning
from what is conveyed by a speaker. The language used by someone can show the
25
culture of that person (Nabi, 2017). Someone whose language is taught and grows
in a community group will tend to show the culture contained in the community
where they came from. It can also mean that someone who is taught the language
and culture of his community will be more likely to represent their culture
towards others. However, that is not necessarily true. Because of the assessment
of their second language acquisition (Amer, 2016). Learning a new language does
not mean leaving their main language entirely. But it can be said that by learning a
second language, someone is also ready to learn the culture that is in it. By
learning languages, we also need to know the culture contained in groups that use
From these things we can say that language and culture have a connection
between one another. Nabi (2017:92) stated that a language is spread through
culture and culture is spread also through language. The relationship between
these two things cannot be separated, by learning the language of a place we are
also required to learn the culture. The writer assumes that if in a community
group, its members no longer want to learn or use their language and culture then
the existence of these social groups will fade. By learning the culture and
relationships with fellow members. But it can also maintain the integrity and
relationships and make them inseparable from one another. In other words, we
cannot use one and ignore the other. It was very clearly explained in the previous
relationship. These results in them are not able to stand alone in social life.
Culture needs language to spread itself, so does the language that requires a
Language can show a person's cultural identity, but that is also not
necessarily trusted because someone's words may refer to other things (Nabi,
language. The intention may be different from what is taught by the community
shows us how close the relationship between culture and society itself.
in seeing other people who belong to the same social group that leaves a social
27
impression on that person. The role of language and culture in a community group
can be misused by its members. This can happen if the individual intentions of the
members are then misperceived by some people who are subject to the intention
called stereotypes. This is sometimes different from the original cultural identity
of a community group.
group and is owned by each of its members, whose interpretation of culture is left
to each of its members (Nabi, 2017). Sometimes, the culture taught or contained
that have been taught, and have been shown by them cannot be separated from
that occurs can sometimes be a good thing, but sometimes it can also be
something bad. This is not a mistake made by language and culture itself.
difficulty is also inseparable from the past experience of someone who already has
with. That may have a negative impact on the social group or to the other group
Another thing that can prove that the relationship between culture and
language is very close is when the naming of an object will be called something
perception of fellow speakers who have different cultures. An object or thing that
something in another culture. But let us imagine if this can be understood then the
perceived error between the speaker and the interlocutor will be so controlled.
That is the function for us to be able to learn the culture and language contained in
this world. The less misunderstanding that occurs between speakers, the more
Based on these things, the writer can assume that the relationship between
language and culture cannot be separated from one another. Not impossible, but
because they are already related to one another. The existence of culture is
inseparable from the existence of language, so also the language will not be tone if
there is no culture. It also belongs to the context of the spread of both. Therefore,
our perception of a culture will not be separated from someone who has used his
language to those who carry out that perception. It will be very easy for us to
understand someone who belongs to a group if we can learn and understand the
29
culture that is owned by that person. If that happens, a significant conflict that
2.4 Discrimination
Many perpetrators of discrimination are left alone without the intention of the
people who realize it to stop it. People close their eyes and ears when that happens
and also the person who discriminates against it or could also be because there is
only a few people are aware of it. Based on this opinion the writer can illustrate
because the perpetrators of this discrimination are very careful about hiding their
discrimination. In fact, many other things of people who are subject to it will
experience a slight disturbance, not just from a few experiences or memories that
and certainly has a negative effect on people who experience it, especially the
effect on their physical and mental health. This happens because the
in those who get the discrimination and they will remember it as a bad experience
in their lives.
makes the assessment of discrimination often lies in the assessment of the subject.
This, of course, can lead to conflict with the people involved in it. The evaluation
that seems to only assess the subject will have an impact on the nature or behavior
the mistakes that exist or have been committed by that person. This will be the
indeed he just does not like that person. However, what we must understand is
that our failure to know an event is discrimination or not, sooner or later it will
affect the mental and physical health of the recipient of the discrimination itself.
people who discriminates usually takes action to the minority people or races
occupying their territory. This will certainly have a negative impact not only on
the recipient but can also cause harm to other people or groups who have
committed such discrimination. The bad impact that can occur to both parties here
is that there will be chaos and hostility between people or community groups.
Another detrimental thing that can happen is a sense of alienation for those who
accept discrimination. This feeling can lead to other people cannot spend what he
which it is said that discrimination is judged only on its subjectivity. Based on this
opinion the writer can assume that a person's behavior is judged from the way that
the victim. The distaste could have been the impact of the stereotype that is
Based on the things that say that discrimination occurs due to the actions
discrimination feel hesitant to entrust this to the existing government in that area
well as spreading about the existence of discrimination. They did this because
they lacked trust in regional leadership. This lack of trust cannot be separated
from the majority and minority groups themselves. The government in an area
tends to put their leadership into the majority group, rather than the minority
group.
nationality, race, origin, and country of origin (Sargeant, 2004). It becomes a case
if the majority of people or groups that are in an area of the arrival of someone or
a group from outside their area which then they feel will disrupt the existence of
their group which had already been there. If there are similarities between them it
might not happen, but groups that have or have just come to an area if they have
different perspectives on something with groups that already exist in the area then
they will be considered to threaten the presence of the majority group. Then
discrimination will be more likely to occur, and feelings of alienation within the
perspective that will cause this discrimination. Supporting factors for racial
discrimination are also very much included. Differences in skin color, nationality,
race, origin, and country of origin also play an important role in the occurrence of
33
things are inseparable from the name stereotype. The sense of being threatened by
a person or a group of others occurs because of the stereotype that appears in their
who do an unfair behavior towards minorities. What can be said to support this
problem. According to Block (2010:98), the tax paid to pay the government was
not only from the majority but also by the minority. This means it can also be said
treatment.
Based on the opinions above, the writer can assume that discrimination is
an unfair behavior committed by the majority towards the minority. This happens
because of the differences between the two peoples. The difference can be in the
majority group by the minority group itself. This can happen, because of prejudice
or stereotype that was first embedded in the majority of the people. This
discrimination will certainly not have a good effect on both parties. The potential
for hostility and alienation will continue to increase along with this discrimination
Song lyrics are a series of words that are pitched, written by the author to
convey what they feel. Song lyrics are usually written based on the experiences of
the author. Song lyrics can also be obtained from inspirations that occur from
phenomena that occur in the community. Song lyrics depend on the embodiment
proves that in a song lyric there is a situation experienced by the writer which he
then poured into this writing. The context of the situation in the lyrics of the song
experienced will add to the reality that is in the lyrics of the song.
Each song has its own message placed by the author in each song's lyrics
(Firdaus, 2013). The meaning implicit in the song is often not mentioned directly
by the writer. The implied meaning of the song is used by the writer so that the
writing can be understood through the perspective of each person. This happens
because the effectiveness of the song to the listeners depends on the lyrics of the
song. In addition, one teaching medium that can be used to learn anything about
something that has happened in the community. The lessons about language and
Lyrics are the main set for making a song (Qurrotul 'ain, 2013). Without
the lyrics of the song will feel meaningless, sometimes only the music we hear,
but no other meaning. Maybe some of it just like that and some others don't. The
abstract side presented by a song's lyrics adds to the appeal of a song's work. The
35
nature that can be interpreted by various perspectives will have an impact on the
song's spread of the song itself. Because of giving each perspective to a song, the
meanings if we have knowledge about what the lyrics mean in that song. The
higher our knowledge, the broader the way we view or interpret the lyrics of the
song (Ekstein, 2010). This could mean that differences in the knowledge of each
person can distinguish the way people look at the song. However, how come that
does not change the beauty in the song. One can interpret song lyrics that are
different from others, it will strengthen the fact that the song can be understood
Based on the opinions above, writers can assume that song lyrics are a
major component in making a song work. That happens because the ad lyrics in a
song will describe something more clearly. Although this clarity side goes along
with the abstract side, it doesn't make a song lose its beauty side. Precisely the
abstract side is not actually dropped a work but will add beauty to the song
because based on the lyrics that can be assessed from the perspective of each
listener.
There are several previous study on stereotype that will be discussed below:
36
is Khan Movie (2018)”. This research aim to describe Islamophobia that happen
in America. How can Muslim got a lot of discrimination. The result of her
of Hindu-India to Muslim
against Stereotype Threats Reflected in Toni Morrison’s The Bluest Eye Novel
(2018)”. In his study, he analyzed about: (1) Exploring the social African
background of The Bluest Eye, (2) Identifying the author’s protest against
negative stereotypes, and (3) Describing the author’s concerns about stereotype
threats. The results of his analyzing showed that The Bluest Eye novel is relevant
to the problem of racism in 20th century of America. The author of this novel
existence of women by calling for the right of freedom and legal protection; 2)
Increase the role of black families; 3) Claiming that black has its own beauty; 4)
Opposing the racial doctrine of educational literacy. The author of this novel
encompassed that stereotype threats sourced on two reasons, she aspired to obtain
This study uses a different object from previous studies but with the same
theory. The objective of the study used by writer is song lyrics by J. Cole. The
purpose of this study is to find out how are the stereotypes of black people in J.
Cole’s song lyrics. In previous studies the writer conducted study on novel and
movie. Furthermore, in previous studies, writer has not received studies that
analyze how the stereotypes of black people in J. Cole’s song lyrics. Therefore, it
Based on the theoretical and previous study above, the writer has a
construction of the conceptual framework to describe how the theory will take
part on the topic of study. This framework would help reader to understand this
study easier.
The object of this study are J. Cole’s song lyrics. In this study, the writer
will analyze the stereotype in his song lyrics . The writer analyzed the song Lyrics
by J. Cole with using stereotype. The writer analyzes the song lyrics using the
to the research project’s goal that directly refers to the collection and analysis of
data. By applying this stereotype theory, the writer was able to answer the
research question how are the stereotypes of black people in J. Cole’s song lyrics.
Sociolinguistics
Stereotype
Black Stereotype
Language Culture
Discrimination
CHAPTER III
RESEARCH METHODOLGY
group against other groups (Lippman, 1998). Based on the explanation in the
previous chapters, this chapter consists of the method that the writer was use. This
chapter was divided into four parts: research design, source of data, procedure of
methods are procedures that produce descriptive data, including written and oral
In this study, the writer used the J. Cole’s song lyrics as primary data and
qualitative research study also explains descriptively how the stereotypes of black
people in J. Cole’s song lyrics. This study used descriptive qualitative methods
because the data is the form of words or qualitative research also explain how the
stereotypes of black people in J. Cole’s song lyrics. Writer also used the
foundation of theory is used as a guide to focus the study in accordance with the
The writer focused on analyzing the song lyrics of J. Cole that have the
stereotype in that. The writer took the lyrics as the data source from Genius.com.
Genius.com is the world biggest collection of the song lyrics and music
Mahbod Moghdam. In this website we can found any lyrics that we wanted to
1. Searching and downloading, the writer downloaded the song and the
lyrics of J. Cole.
2. Listening and Reading, the writer listened and read the song of J. Cole
3. Reducing, the writer reduced the object and picked up the songs that
4. Coding the data, the writer coded the data by bold the lyrics to make it
The writer uses Dey (1993) qualitative data analysis theory, they are:
1. Presenting the data, After coding the data that had been sorted out by the
2. Describing the data. After presenting the data, the writer described the
CHAPTER IV
The objective of this research that has been mentioned in the previous
chapters is to find out what are the stereotypes of black people in “Immortal”, “Be
Free (Live on Letterman)”, “Neighbors”, “G.O.M.D”, “Too Deep for the Intro”’,
and “Middle Child” J. Cole’s song lyrics. The writer found some of stereotypes
4.1 Findings
42
4.1.1 Immortal
Data 1
In the lyrics of this song reveal that black people who basically have
problems with the use of drugs in their environment. The lyrics of this song say
that people sometimes assume that black people are "lookin' clean" as if nothing
had happened. Then when seen in the line "Now I was almost seventeen with a
pocket full of hope" actually the black people did not want to get involved in the
problem, and they actually have great hopes too. Hope for a decent life even
though they basically look so in limitations, it can be seen in "Screamin ', dollars
This is often associated with cultures that are usually practiced by black
people. As reported that many black people are trapped in the life of the drug.
That is the meaning of the song's lyrics, as well as giving stereotypes to black
culture by people from other races or from within their own race.
43
Data 2
Here the writer assumes that equating crime with part-time work means
that a crime committed in this case by black people will be given a wage or
payment for it. Just as glance at this song told us that the part time job that they
will get pleasure only for a while, because with wages or money from proceeds of
crime will not be used for life in the long term. But, that doesn't necessarily mean
they do it for fun. It can also be their way of "black people" in fulfilling their
desire to survive.
In relation to the cultural life lived by black people. We are often shown
the difficulty of getting jobs for black people. Therefore, they are more likely to
use violence and crime in terms of getting needs and to meet their daily needs.
However, based on the lyrics above we can get an information that sometimes
there are also black people who make this "crime" as a job rather than as the last
Data 3
One-Seven-Forty-Five
From this song lyrics we can assume that "Form on the plot" here means
that the black people were formed by the "real niggas" plot itself which is said to
be slaves, who survive by working hard and fighting for their freedom. Then on
the other side "real niggas" at the present time which is then formed by a system
that already exists in the "form on the block" society is in contradiction with what
happens to the "real niggas" society that has been formed by the plot itself. At
present, the "real niggas" or black people themselves will still have the spirit of
45
survival but no longer work hard but they are trapped by street life, and they are
From the lyrics of the song above, we can also get an understanding or a
description that the culture of black people in ancient times in this song was
written with the word "real niggas" which fights to free themselves from the
who tend to be trapped in the negative direction such as drugs, crime, and
violence.
Data 4
From the lyrics of this song the writer can give a view that stereotypes
about black people can also occur by existing legal instruments. As written "If
they want a nigga, they don't have to send a SWAT team" this indicates that
violations of a case are black people. Based on the lyrics above we can see that the
done by black people. A legal instrument that should act against the perpetrators
of justice fairly regardless of race, but different things are shown if the
perpetrators are black people. They often regarded as a guilty person even though
they did not do it. It also happened on the ground that a black person was
immediately punished on the spot without the need for any evidence or statement
Data 5
In this song we can take another stereotype about the black people. In
order for Black people to be successful, they have to sell drugs, become well-
known rappers, or make it into professional basketball. These song lyrics also
stated that this mentality is holding them back from realizing their full potential.
associated with the assumption that they will become a rapper or a professional
NBA player. It is assumed as if these black people could not be anything other
than the three things that have been mentioned above. Of course, this does not
Data 6
From the lyrics of the song we can get a description of the environment
from the writer himself, or can say as a stereotype about the environment of black
people. In these lyrics, we can interpret that the environment of black people very
often occur murder. Whether it's because of gangsters or because they attack each
This of course relates to the lives of black people themselves who are very
hard and also very difficult for them to live. This has a bad impact on the people
who live in their environment. Not infrequently even they kill each other because
of the difficulty of life in the environment. These lyrics can also mean that often
heard the news that there are black people who die every day. That could be due
to a criminal attack or also because of an error from law enforcers who often try
Data 7
We are so elated, we celebrated like Obama waited until his last day
in the office to tell the nation, brothers are getting their reparations,
hey
48
The lyrics of this song stereotype that black people are very happy about
the election of Barrack Obama as President of the United States of America. They
believe that with the election of Obama as President, their lives will be given
more attention by government officials. This can also illustrate that Obama's
election as President will certainly have a very good impact on their lives.
Another thing that might happen is that they have proven to everyone that black
people can also lead a big country like the United States.
The lyrics of this song prove that black-skinned people can be calculated more
in a country, especially in the United States. That happened when Barrack Obama
was chosen as president of the United States. This proves that the assumptions
that say that black people only revolve in social terms also crime is a mistake.
Because the election of Obama as president will emerge the notion that a black
Data 8
These lyrics can provide stereotypes about black people who can dream
even with a harsh environment and with a lot of discrimination that occurs against
them. That relates to the previous data which says that a Barrack Obama who is a
black person can occupy the highest position in the government seat of the United
States. That means nothing can block the dreams of black people. They also
49
assume that they can be whatever they want no matter what discrimination or
In this lyrics "a man" refers to black people where they are blocked by dreams
only because of the color of their skin. The discrimination that occurs or they feel
is one of the causes of obstruction of their dreams. Based on previous data. These
black people got treatment or opinion that said they could only be a bunch of
criminals, criminals, rappers, and even limited to NBA players. It was as if a black
person could not dream more than that. While of course there are many black
Data 9
This lyrics tells us that in the environment of black people there are also
people who have luxurious lives. But they don't care about the "brothers" or other
black people, who even have difficulty surviving when the changing seasons have
come because they don't have a heater or air conditioner that can help maintain
The lyrics show how difficult the life of black people themselves. In their
lives, many black people also became successful, but with their success, they no
longer cared about their relatives or with other black people. This happens
because they have been consumed by the glamor of the world so that they forget
where they come from and also forget their relatives. It is as if the values of
brotherhood and humanity have dimmed from that person. Meanwhile, on the
other hand, black people who are not fortunate enough with their economic life
are trying to survive on a minimum. Even just to survive In the changing season
Data 10
The lyrics of this song stereotype us about how difficult it is for black
people to get jobs and keep the jobs they have got. Here maybe we can assume
that a large company sometimes does not look at the lives of its employees but see
with what benefits they can achieve. Therefore, large companies can easily fire
their employees. However, back to the fact that these black people find it difficult
to get a job and difficult to maintain, even when they have babies to raise. Of
course it was very hard for them, not only had an impact on their parents but also
on their babies. If the baby's needs cannot be met, then they can experience
As explained in previous data, that black people tend to be difficult to get a job.
Not only that, in maintaining their jobs too, but it has also been very difficult.
51
Even with the dependents they have, they cannot be avoided from the dismissal
that occurs in the workplace. This could be due to a lack of ability from the person
factors because of the discrimination that will occur, such as dislike, even
Data 11
Apart from the work problems that we saw in the previous data, in this
data we can find stereotypes about the education problems that are owned by
black people. This lyric explains to us that how many black people left school and
did not continue their studies. This could also be one of the causes of their
difficulties in getting a job and keeping their jobs discussed in the previous data
inability to compete and the lack of knowledge and skills they have, because they
From the lyrics, we can get information that few of the black people completed
their education. This could have been caused by a stereotype that developed in
their area which said that black people would only be a criminal, basketball
player, or rapper. This of course resulted in these black people being unmotivated
to continue their education to a higher level. This could also be one of the factors
52
that caused many black people who have difficulty finding work because they are
4.1.3 Neighbors
Data 12
environments that have racial differences with them. This lyrics illustrates that
black people are often stereotyped by their neighbors as drug dealers. All the
activities of black people were not free from bad views by the environment. The
A culture that shows that black people are very closely related to narcotics life
is very often encountered. Therefore, many people who have a house or live next
door to black people only speculate that they (Black People) have drug
conversation.
Data 13
In the lyrics of this song we can stereotype about how hard life is lived by
Black people, especially for children in their teens. From these lyrics we can get a
little description of the average life expectancy of black people is very low. This is
evidenced by the lyrics "My sixteen should've came with a coffee", which can be
described how it is possible for children in their teens to walk with coffins that
follow. That indicates that black teenagers are already struggling with life and
The lives of black people are hard and full of discrimination, not
infrequently to the point of causing death. This happens even if it doesn't look at
age or gender. Even sometimes they may not necessarily commit a crime. They
are subject to discrimination only because their race is a black race. As we often
see, in America, there are often things that lead to discrimination, whether it is
Not only that but also the death of young children cannot be separated from the
name of illegal drugs. Sometimes the overdose of narcotics itself causes many
Data 14
From the lyrics of this song we can get a stereotype which illustrates that
some things that cannot be separated from black people, namely Death, taxes, and
racist. Here is illustrated how these things are closely related to all black people
without exception. Even though these black people are someone who has been
successful and someone who has not been successful these things will not be
separated from them. The portrayals given by them are also what caused this to
against black people which is very influential on these matters. For this reason,
there is a verse that says "Every nigga feel like a candidate", which means that all
black people are inseparable from the names of Death, Taxes, and Racist.
The things that became very difficult for black people and became a problem in
their lives especially in the United States were death, taxes, and racism. These
things can no longer be avoided for black people, both because of mistakes from
themselves and from people of other races. In these lyrics, "Death" indicates that
death is very closely related or is a daily life that black people must face because
of the environment or even from their own mistakes that cause death to occur.
55
Then "Taxes" becomes the next thing that cannot be separated from the lives of
black people because they consider that taxation is very heavy. This is hard or
difficult for black people who tend to have a small income so that everyday
expenses are difficult, but due to taxes, they have to set aside more money for tax
problems. The last one is "Racist" which is the main problem that black people
have. Racists that eventually lead to stereotypes and social discrimination against
black people are very common, especially in the United States. It happened
because of the dislike of black people than white people or other races, or it could
also be because people of other races and white people felt they were more
Data 15
At this lyrics, we can find stereotypes about how worried black people are
that the discrimination they get. Only because of their lifestyle or with the words
they say in their environment is considered a crime. They are also sometimes
reported to the police for their activities even without clear evidence and reasons.
From the lyrics above we can conclude that the lives of black people there (United
discrimination they get. As written in the lyrics of the song that they experience
like a paranoid or fear because they feel that the area they occupy is not the
territory of black people. This fear is inseparable from the injustice and
4.1.4 G.O.M.D
Data 16
In this lyrics we can associate with stereotypes that assume that black
people are people who are involved in the criminal world. That was what caused
the black people to be feared. However, in this lyrics "scared" can also be
something different. The higher the ability of black people, both intelligence and
other abilities will not change many perspectives or stereotypes about them. Their
expertise had greatly increased which caused people of other races to fear the
From the lyrics, it can be said that the discrimination they get so far is not only
because black people are seen as having a degree below those of the white race.
This was shown by how difficult it was to get a job for black people. While they
do not necessarily know about the ability of a black person himself. It could be
that more black people have more ability than white people themselves. Another
example is in terms of the music genre, rap. Rap which is music originating from
black people is often regarded as a work that does not educate, the lyrics tend to
be rough, and can cause a rebellion. However, in essence, rap music itself is a
work that is intended to criticize or tell stories and pour out what becomes his
mind with beautiful lyrics and meanings in it. However, it is often considered not
good, because rap music could be something that has a big impact like now.
Data 17
fake, they are anime". The lyrics can mean that black people today are not "the
real niggas" because they can only struggle with using or by conducting drug
trafficking, robbery, and also other criminal acts. This is different from black
people in ancient times, who are a group of slaves, but they can prove themselves
This relates to the culture of the former black people where they fought
very hard in achieving their freedom. Their long history makes them strong and
proud to be black. Because they have a stake in racial equalization and freedom to
live and are free from slavery. Why does this glance say that black people are now
black people now called "fake"? That's because black people now tend to be far
from the struggle because they only revolve around criminal circles and illegal
drugs. Therefore, these things are very far compared to the struggle of black
people before.
Data 18
In the lyrics of this song itself has discussed about the views or stereotypes
of black people. They are not unaware of the stereotype experienced, many of the
successful black people and become leaders but it does not make the black people
off their initial stereotypes. The example that can be seen is when Barrack Obama
became president of the United States, even though he became the leader and
59
became the first black person to become president of the United States and was
able to break the stereotype so far about black people. However, this does not
necessarily eliminate stereotypes that arise about black people. In the lyrics of this
In the lyrics of this song, we can see that the lives and culture of black
people sometimes have no place in the United States. It happened not only
discrimination from ordinary white people but also involved upper-class people
from the white race who racist against other races that were different from them.
These upper-class people assume that the white race is the race that has the most
power. Of course, if that happens black people are very difficult to get a place or
platform for them to develop so they can break the stereotypes that are developing
in the community.
Data 19
These boys got them hoslters and clips they pack like Lunchables
Like white boys in grade school, while we ate school made food
Knowing when mama hits the store she wasn't buying that shit
No I don't cry a bit man, that's just life that's how that shit works
60
In the lyrics of this song we can see about stereotypes about the economic
life of black people. From the lyrics we can take an example which says that they
can only see food from a lunch box owned by a white child. Even though they
want to live like that but they are aware of their economic situation, in the lyrics
"Knowing when mama hits the store she wasn't buying that shit" proves that they
know that they can't afford to buy the things they want. Then this made the black
This lyric refers to the economic problems of black society. From the lyrics
above we can see a side of the lives of black children that they are unable to enjoy
at school as white people feel. They could only look at it because they realized
that their parents could not afford to pay for food or buy them food like that of
white people.
Data 20
Damn, you win some, you lose some, that just how its happens
In the lyrics there is a stereotype about black people who are often
involved in chaos. They often fight to show that they are great. But they do not
know that by doing so they can lose something valuable that is their own lives.
This can also be the pride of a man. When they win a fight they will be rewarded
Of the many views about black people in the United States, one of them is the
way they achieve a pride just by doing a variety of ways. This is also what
triggers black people to pursue wealth or pride even in ways that are not all true.
For this reason, it is said in the lyrics above "you win some, you lose some" that
they can get something of course with a risk. This cannot be avoided because
Data 21
In this lyrics we can give a stereotype that among black people there are
some people who can make a decent living but some are not. The question that
arises in this lyric indicates the compassion of the writer who did not want to see
the other black people living in hardship while he was living in a well-off
situation.
The lyrics above relate to the lives of black people above who sometimes
forget or appear to be unconcerned with the lives of other black people. Many
black people are trapped in social problems they are experiencing and it is very
know, can be in the form of racism, poverty, drugs, crime, and others. The
62
problems mentioned earlier are sometimes forgotten by black people who have
gained their glory. They sometimes close their eyes to forget that they were in a
Data 22
In the lyrics of this song there is a stereotype about black people who
sometimes forget themselves when they have lots of money. In addition, they also
assume that money is a medicine for everything in their lives. This is evidenced
by the lyrics written "Hope" which indicates that the songwriter hoped that the
black people could realize that the money could not erase pain or be a pain
prevention itself.
The lyrics above are a reminder for black people who forget where they came
from. Black people who already have wealth and also glory will tend to use their
money for things that are not necessary and also tend to use it carelessly. Why is
said that the lyrics can be a reminder because no matter how much money they
have, it will not be enough to cover the wounds or pain from the past they have
experienced. A glamorous life and a feeling of flattery may be one way that they
63
can be respected in their environment, although of course, that is not a good thing
because they tend to forget their identity and where they come from.
Data 23
In the lyrics "Money in your palm don't make you real" it indicates that the
stereotype of black people who when they get wealth, they then live in a state of
luxury and tend to squander money. Then the lyrics of "Pistol in your hand don't
make you real" indicate the stereotype that black people who already have power
and can determine something according to their desires which sometimes actually
life. "Money" and "Pistol" aren't even just tools, they can control us. Because with
wealth and power we sometimes forget where we came from and can also make
us forget ourselves.
64
From the lyrics above you can get two keywords namely "pistol" and "money.
Why can these two words be said as keywords? Because the word is considered to
be very closely related to the lives of black people. We can represent this as a way
to achieve power or it can also be said as a form of power held by black people.
The word "gun" can represent that the lives of black people are closely related to
an act of violence. In fact, they can make the violence as a way to achieve pride
and recognition from people around them. Then the word "money" which can be
either the recognition of the people around him or the pride he gets is based on his
lifestyle or how much wealth he has so he can be at the peak of his glory.Data 24
prison. That can lead to the assumption that many black people who do and are
for his actions tends to be for a long time, as evidenced by the lyrics of "Spending
them birthdays inside a cell" which indirectly gives us information that the
From the lyrics above, we can associate it with the life of crime and
committed a crime and some have gone to jail because of the discrimination that
has caused them to be accused so that they end up in prison. Sometimes even
65
because of the discrimination, they get they are sentenced more severely or longer
Data 25
From the lyrics of the song above we can provide a stereotype that black
people grow and develop in a state of "trauma". Trauma in this case may be in the
form of environmental activities that are not conducive for children to grow. They
may also see and experience for themselves how black people are treated in the
environment. This trauma can also be caused by the violence experienced or what
them. Then the trauma is what will shape their personality in the future.
"Trauma" in the lyrics above indicates that they were born, grew, and formed their
thoughts with a traumatic state. The traumatic situation is formed from the
discrimination they get, as well as the racist actions they get from the people who
are in their environment and also what they are usually shown in the media and so
on. That is certainly a matter of life learning for children whose lives they feel are
4.2 Discussion
question about “What are the Stereotypes of Black People in J. Cole’s Song
66
Lyrics. The use or depiction of stereotypes contained in the data above is a form
of discrimination. As is the case with the above data, there are various kinds of
stereotypes that lead to discrimination of Black People. Based on the data above,
the author can indicate that the stereotype that occurs in black people can make
because of the discourse of superiority in the white race that has been circulated
through textbooks and mainstream media, many white people have learned to
believe that they have the biological right to be world leaders, to control and
oppress marginalized blacks, browns, and others. Based on these data, we can be
sure that the incidents and discrimination that happened to black people were the
impacts of white people who always assumed that they were a superior people
based on the white supremacy discussed earlier, it will be very related to what is
with the existence of the white supremacy earlier this course has resulted in how
interacting with police or the courts. These things indicate that there has been a
problem or even discrimination that happens to black people. They are often given
negative assumptions even about something they did not do. Related to the white
supremacy that has been discussed earlier has been alluded to or shown in the
song lyrics above. It was said that the assumptions about black people were not
something that could be lost because those who controlled them were "upper
class" people.
assumptions against black people. So, our attitude in stereotyping to other races
not good to a person or a group, there will be a name of discrimination. In the case
example in this case the problem is black people who are made as an object of
incidents that support this so that discrimination can no longer be avoided. Even
though there are some people who commit evil in black people that does not mean
that all people who belong to these people are the perpetrators. Here the
68
the person who assumes to give rise to what is called acts of discrimination.
As a result from the findings above the writer found 25 data which
contains stereotypes to Black People. The writer examines the song lyrics of J.
Cole using Stereotype theory from Walter Lippman. He said that the stereotype is
information that someone gets about someone or a group (Lippman, 1998). Based
on the theory put forward by Walter Lippman, the writer obtained 25 data
included in the stereotypes of black people in 6 Lyrics of the J. Cole song, which
CHAPTER V
5.1 Conclusion
According to this research, the writer draws some conclusion related to the
J. Cole’s song lyrics which have been analyzed with using Lippman’s theory
about stereotype. The objective of this study is to find out what are the stereotypes
of black people in J. Cole’s song lyrics. After analyzing the findings and
discussion with the problem statement about “What are the Stereotypes of Black
People in J. Cole's song lyrics”, the writer sumps up there are 25 data that
The 25 data was obtained from six song lyrics written by J. Cole, the six
“Neighbors”, “G.O.M.D”, “Too Deep for the Intro”’, and “Middle Child”. The
songs written by J. Cole itself come from personal experience. Many became the
70
background of these later writings, ranging from love, social life, and criticism of
government. But the authors only take that if there is a stereotype of Black people
in it. From the six song lyrics of J. Cole, the writer found data included in the
5.2 Suggestion
Based on this research that has been done with the title “Stereotype of
Black People in J. Cole’s Song Lyrics” the writer would give some suggestions as
the considerations for the readers especially the future writers who would like to
do the further research related to figurative stereotype. In this research, the writer
the writer only found 25 data which has or described about stereotype of Black
People in J. Cole’s song lyrics which are “Immortal”, “Be Free (Live on
Letterman)”, “Neighbors”, “G.O.M.D”, “Too Deep for the Intro”’, and “Middle
Child”. The writer was not able to find out the stereotype of White People in J.
Cole’s song lyrics, therefore the writer is highly expected that in the future the
other writers will be conducting more deep and perfect research concerning to
REFERENCES
Amer, Enas Subhi. 2016. The Effect of Culture in Language. Baghdad. Research
Gate
Block, Walter. 2010. Case for Discrimination. Alabama: Ludwig von Mises
Institute and published
Brink, Lizelle & Nel, Jan Alewyn. 2015. Exploring the Meaning and Origin of
Stereotypes amongst South African Employees. South Africa
Dey, Ian. 1993. Qualitative Data Analysis A User-Friendly Guide For Social
Scientists. London: Routledge.
Elmes, David. 2013. The Relationship between Language and Culture. Kanoya
Firdaus, Edwan Ali. 2013. Textual Meaning in Song Lyrics. Bandung: Indonesia
University of Education
Kashima, Yoshihisa et. all. 2008. Stereotype Dynamic. London and New York.
Lawrence Erlbaum Asociates.
Krasniqi, Kadri. 2019. The Relation between Language and Culture (Case Study
Albanian Language). North Macedonia
Lestari, Aprilia. 2016. A Study Of Slang Words In Song Lyrics Used By Bruno
Mars. Surabaya: State Islamic University Sunan Ampel Surabaya
Peffley, Mark et. all. 1997. Racial Stereotypes and Whites’ Political Views of
Black in The Context of Welfare and Crime. Research Gate
Schweinitz, Jörg. 2011. Film and Stereotype. New York: Columbia University
Press