Fundamental Errors of the

New Natural Law Theory

6WHYHQ$/RQJ

Abstract.  This  essay  argues  that  the  new  natural  law  theory  (NNLT)  propounds  
¿YHHUURUVWKDWSODFHLWRQDFROOLVLRQFRXUVHZLWKWKHWUDGLWLRQDO7KRPLVWLF
XQGHUVWDQGLQJFHQWUDOWRWKHPRUDOPDJLVWHULXPRIWKH5RPDQ&DWKROLF&KXUFK
7KHVHURRWHUURUVDUHDUJXHGWREHWKHGHQLDORIWKHSULPDF\RIVSHFXODWLYH
RYHUSUDFWLFDOWUXWKWKHQHJDWLRQRIXQL¿HGQRUPDWLYHQDWXUDOWHOHRORJ\
H[SUHVVHGLQWKH11/7GRFWULQHRIWKHSXWDWLYH³LQFRPPHQVXUDELOLW\´RIEDVLF
JRRGVSULRUWRFKRLFHIDLOXUHWRDI¿UPWKHWUDQVFHQGHQFHRIWKHFRPPRQ
JRRGQHJDWLRQRIWKHHVVHQWLDOO\WKHRQRPLFFKDUDFWHURIWKHQDWXUDOODZ
DQGWKHLQWHQWLRQDOLVWFRQVWUXFWLRQRIKXPDQDFWLRQ7KHWHDFKLQJRI6W
7KRPDV $TXLQDV LV KHOG WR EH D VXSHULRU OLJKW IRU XQGHUVWDQGLQJ &DWKROLF
PRUDOOLIHNational  Catholic  Bioethics  Quarterly6SULQJ±

*HUPDLQ*ULVH]-RKQ)LQQLV-RKQ%R\OHDQG5REHUW*HRUJHDUHZHOONQRZQIRU
WKHLUGHYHORSPHQWDQGDSSOLFDWLRQRIDQDFFRXQWRIWKHQDWXUDOODZWKDWKDVFRPHWREH
NQRZQ²LQSDUWRZLQJWRDGYHUVHFULWLFLVP²DVWKH³QHZQDWXUDOODZWKHRU\´11/7
7KHJHQHVLVRIWKLVDFFRXQWPD\EHREVHUYHGLQDQHIIRUWWRUHVFXHWKH&KXUFK
IURPZKDWWKHVHDXWKRUVYLHZHGDVDGH¿FLHQWDQDO\VLVRIQDWXUDOODZRQHWKDWVXS-­
SRVHGO\REVWUXFWHGDSURSHUGHIHQVHRIHumanae  vitae.16HHNLQJQHZZD\VWRGHIHQG
WKH&KXUFK¶VWHDFKLQJ11/7DXWKRUVLQIDFWGHYHORSHGDFRPSUHKHQVLYHWUHDWPHQW
RIQDWXUDOODZ,WLVRQO\MXVWWRQRWHWKDWWKHLUHIIRUWVKDYHEHHQIURPWKHRXWVHWSODFHG

6WHYHQ$/RQJ3K'LVDSURIHVVRURIWKHRORJ\DW$YH0DULD8QLYHUVLW\LQ$YH0DULD
)ORULGD
1  
6HH *HUPDLQ *ULVH] Contraception   and   the   Natural   Law 0LOZDXNHH %UXFH
3XEOLVKLQJDQG*HUPDLQ*ULVH]-RVHSK%R\OH-RKQ)LQQLVDQG:LOOLDP(0D\
³µ(YHU\0DULWDO$FW2XJKWWR%H2SHQWR1HZ/LIH¶7RZDUGD&OHDUHU8QGHUVWDQGLQJ´
The  Thomist±

©  2013  The  National  Catholic  Bioethics  Center   105

 THE  NATIONAL  CATHOLIC  BIOETHICS  QUARTERLY      SPRING  2013

DWWKHVHUYLFHRIWKHPDJLVWHULXPDQGWKDWWKH\KDYHEURXJKWLQWRUHQHZHGIRFXVWKH
FHQWUDOLW\RIQDWXUDOODZGRFWULQHIRUDQ\SURSHUXQGHUVWDQGLQJRIWKH&KXUFK¶VPRUDO
PDJLVWHULXPRULQVLJKWLQWR&DWKROLFPRUDOWKHRORJ\DQGSKLORVRSK\
+RZHYHU DQG OLNHZLVH IURP WKH EHJLQQLQJ WKH HIIRUW RI WKHVH DXWKRUV KDV
VXIIHUHGVWURQJH[WHUQDOFULWLFLVPERWKRQV\VWHPDWLFJURXQGVDQGIRUIRXQGDWLRQDO
LQDGHTXDF\ZLWKUHVSHFWWRWKHFRUUHFWXQGHUVWDQGLQJRIWKHWHDFKLQJRI6W7KRPDV
$TXLQDV²DWHDFKLQJZKLFKLVLQGHHGFHQWUDOWRWKH&KXUFK¶VPRUDOSDWULPRQ\2$
ZHOONQRZQDQGSHUVLVWHQWFRQWURYHUV\KDVWKXVNHSWSDFHZLWKWKHGHYHORSPHQWRI
WKLVVFKRRORIWKRXJKW
:KLOHWKHUHFDQEHQRTXHVWLRQRIWUHDWLQJHYHU\LQWHUYHQWLRQRUUHDVRQLQJ
RI11/7DGYRFDWHVZLWKLQWKHFRPSDVVRIDVLQJOHHVVD\WKH11/7LVQRWPHUHO\
D ORRVHNQLW FRQVHQVXV EXW RIIHUV D SULQFLSOHG DQG V\VWHPDWLF DQDO\VLV RI PRUDO
SKLORVRSK\*LYHQWKHLPSRUWDQWDQGZLGHVSUHDGLPSOLFDWLRQVDQGDSSOLFDWLRQVRI
WKLVWKHRU\LWLVLPSRUWDQWWRWDNHVWRFNRILWVVWUDWHJLFGHSDUWXUHVIURPWKHWHDFKLQJ
RI$TXLQDVDVWKLVKDVFHQWUDOO\IRUPHGWKH&DWKROLFWUDGLWLRQ$VPDOOHUURULQWKH
EHJLQQLQJLVJUHDWLQWKHHQGDQGDVWKH11/7KDVGHYHORSHGDQGEHHQDSSOLHG
GHVWUXFWLYHLPSOLFDWLRQVKDYHHQVXHG
7KH11/7LQYROYHVDVVHUWLRQVZKLFKWKHSULRUFRPPHQWDWRULDOWUDGLWLRQKDV
QHYHUFRXQWHQDQFHGZLWKUHVSHFWWRWKHWHDFKLQJRI$TXLQDV37KLVGHURJDWLRQRI
$TXLQDV¶VWHDFKLQJKDVJUDYHFRQVHTXHQFHVGHVSLWH²DQGSHUKDSVWRVRPHGHJUHH
SUHFLVHO\ EHFDXVH RI²WKH IDFW WKDW WKH 11/7 DXWKRUV VHHN WR VHUYH WKH &KXUFK
,WLPSOLHVDUHODWLYHGLVUHJDUGIRUWKHDFWXDOWHDFKLQJRI$TXLQDVFRPELQHGZLWKD
VHHPLQJFRQ¿GHQFHWKDWWKHWUDGLWLRQRI7KRPLVWLFPRUDOUHÀHFWLRQLVDWEHVWPHUHO\
DOHVVGHYHORSHGDQGLQIHULRUDQFHVWRURILWVHOI    DQGDWZRUVWVLPSO\LUUHOHYDQW

2  
)RU H[DPSOH VHH 5XVVHOO +LWWLQJHU A   Critique   of   the   New   Natural   Law   Theory  
,QGLDQD 8QLYHUVLW\ RI 1RWUH 'DPH  5DOSK 0F,QHUQ\ Ethica   Thomistica:   The  
Moral  Philosophy  of  Thomas  Aquinas  :DVKLQJWRQ'&&DWKROLF8QLYHUVLW\RI$PHULFD
3UHVV+HQU\9HDWFKSwimming  against  the  Current  in  Contemporary  Philosophy:  
Occasional  Essays  and  Papers&DWKROLF8QLYHUVLW\RI$PHULFD3UHVVHVSHFLDOO\
WKHODVWWZRFKDSWHUV³&DQ-RKQ)LQQLV%ULQJ2IID5HYLYDORI1DWXUDO/DZ´DQG³1DWXUDO
/DZDQGWKHµ,V¶±µ2XJKW¶4XHVWLRQ4XHULHVWR)LQQLVDQG*ULVH]´DQG6WHYHQ$/RQJ³6W
7KRPDV$TXLQDVWKURXJKWKH$QDO\WLF/RRNLQJ*ODVV´The  Thomist±
3  
2QHGRHVQRW¿QGWKH11/7DFFRXQWRI³LQFRPPHQVXUDELOLW\RIHQGV´HLWKHULQWKH
WHDFKLQJRI$TXLQDVRULQDQ\RIWKHSURPLQHQW'RPLQLFDQFRPPHQWDWRUVVXFKDV&DSUHROXV
&DMHWDQ9LWRULD%DxH]DQG-RKQRI6W7KRPDV-RKQ3RLQVRWQRUWKHLUWUHDWPHQWRIREMHFW
LQWHQWLRQDQGDFWLRQQRUWKHLUJHQHUDOYLHZRIQDWXUDOODZ

)RUWKLVSKHQRPHQRQDWLWV]HQLWKVHH-RKQ)LQQLV¶VAquinas:  Moral,  Political,  and  
Legal   Theory 2[IRUG 2[IRUG 8QLYHUVLW\ 3UHVV  ,W SURPLQHQWO\ FULWLFL]HV DFWXDO
SRVLWLRQVRI6W7KRPDV$TXLQDVDVLQFRQVLVWHQWZLWKZKDWWKHDXWKRUVXSSRVHV$TXLQDV¶V
SULQFLSOHVWREH7KXVKRZHYHUZHPXVWEHZLOOLQJWRWKLQNWKDW$TXLQDVLVDQRWYHU\
SHQHWUDWLQJ WKLQNHU VLQFH DIWHU DOO ³WKHUH DUH VRPH VHULRXV ÀDZV LQ $TXLQDV¶ WKRXJKWV
DERXWKXPDQVRFLHW\$VRXQGFULWLTXHRIWKHPFDQUHVWRQSUHPLVVHVKHKLPVHOIXQGHUVWRRG
DQGDUWLFXODWHGEHWWHU,WKLQNWKDQKLVSKLORVRSKLFDOPDVWHUV3ODWRDQG$ULVWRWOHDQGPXFK
EHWWHUWKDQ0DFKLDYHOOL+REEHVDQGWKHRWKHUPDNHUVRUKHLUVRIWKH(QOLJKWHQPHQW´%\

 LONG      FUNDAMENTAL  ERRORS  OF  THE  NNLT

7KHSUHVHQWHVVD\LGHQWL¿HVDQGEULHÀ\DGGUHVVHV¿YHSULQFLSDOHUURUVWKDWVHW
WKH11/7LQRSSRVLWLRQWRWKHWHDFKLQJRI$TXLQDVDQGUHQGHULW²LQWKLVDXWKRU¶V
YLHZ²XQDEOH¿QDOO\WRSURPRWHWKH&DWKROLFSDWULPRQ\7KHHVVD\LVZULWWHQZLWK
DQDWWLWXGHVLPLODUWRWKDWZLWKZKLFK-DFTXHV0DULWDLQZURWHThe  Peasant  of  the  
GaronneLQDQHIIRUWWRLGHQWLI\GLVORFDWLRQVLQWURGXFHGXQGHUWKHHUURQHRXVEHOLHI
WKDWWKH11/7LVFRQVRQDQWZLWKWKHWHDFKLQJRI$TXLQDVDQGWKHWUDGLWLRQDO&DWKROLF
XQGHUVWDQGLQJRIWKHQDWXUDOODZ,QSURSRVLQJWKHPDWWHULQWKLVIDVKLRQZKDWLV
SURYLGHGLVVXPPDU\LQQDWXUHDQGVRH[SRVHVLWVDXWKRUWRWKHFKDUJHRILQDGHTXDWH
FRQVLGHUDWLRQ<HW,KDYHHOVHZKHUHDUJXHGWKHVHV\VWHPDWLFLVVXHVDWOHQJWK5  
Strategic  Errors
)LYHURRWHUURUVJHQHWLFDOO\LGHQWLI\WKH11/7DQGSXWLWRQDFROOLVLRQFRXUVH
ZLWKWKHWUDGLWLRQDOPRUDOPDJLVWHULXPRIWKH&KXUFK7KHVHSURFHHGIURPWKHPRUH
SURIRXQGDQGUHPRWHWRWKHPRUHSUDFWLFDODQGSUR[LPDWH7KHLPSRUWDQFHRIWKH
PRUHUHPRWHSULQFLSOHVLVRIWHQRYHUORRNHGJLYHQWKHFRQWHPSRUDU\SUHMXGLFHDJDLQVW
WKHLPSRUWDQFHRIVSHFXODWLYHWUXWKIRUSUDFWLFDOOLIH7KHVHHUURUVIURPZKLFKPDQ\
RWKHUVÀRZDUHDVIROORZV
  ‡ 7KHGHQLDORIWKHSULPDF\RIVSHFXODWLYHRYHUSUDFWLFDOWUXWK
  ‡ 7KHQHJDWLRQRIXQL¿HGQRUPDWLYHQDWXUDOWHOHRORJ\WKHHUURURI
³LQFRPPHQVXUDELOLW\´
  ‡ 7KHIDLOXUHWRDI¿UPWKHWUDQVFHQGHQFHRIWKHFRPPRQJRRG
  ‡ 7KHQHJDWLRQRIWKHHVVHQWLDOO\WKHRQRPLFFKDUDFWHURIWKHQDWXUDOODZ
  ‡ 7KHLQWHQWLRQDOLVWFRQVWUXFWLRQRIKXPDQDFWLRQ
The  Primacy  of  the  Speculative
7KHGHQLDORIWKHSULPDF\RIVSHFXODWLYHRYHUSUDFWLFDOWUXWKLVSHUKDSVWKH
PRVWIRUPDOHUURUGH¿QLQJWKH11/7$V-RKQ)LQQLVDUWLFXODWHVWKLVFHQWUDOWKHVLV
RIWKH11/7³SULPDU\JRRGV´DUHQRWGHULYHG³IURPDQ\SURSRVLWLRQVRIVSHFX-­
ODWLYHUHDVRQ´$TXLQDVIDPRXVO\WHDFKHVWKDWWKHGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQVSHFXODWLYH
and  practical  intellect  LVDFFLGHQWDO6SHFXODWLYHNQRZOHGJHLVVLPSO\IRUWKHVDNH
RIWKHWUXWKSUDFWLFDONQRZOHGJHLVNQRZOHGJHDOOWKHVDPHEXWLVFDOOHG³SUDFWLFDO´

FRQWUDVWRQHPLJKWLQVWHDGMXGJHWKDWWKHVH³ÀDZV´DUHLQVWHDGSURSHULPSOLFDWLRQVDQGWKDW
WKHSULQFLSOHVIURPZKLFKWKH\SURFHHGVLPSO\GLYHUJHIURPWKH11/7
5  
6HHHVSHFLDOO\³$TXLQDVWKURXJKWKH$QDO\WLF/RRNLQJ*ODVV´EXWDOVR³$%ULHI
'LVTXLVLWLRQUHJDUGLQJWKH1DWXUHRIWKH2EMHFWRIWKH0RUDO$FWDFFRUGLQJWR6W7KRPDV
$TXLQDV´The  Thomist  The  Teleological  Grammar  of  the  Moral  Act   1DSOHV)/
6DSLHQWLD3UHVVRI$YH0DULD8QLYHUVLW\³7KH1DWXUDO/DZWKH0RUDO2EMHFWDQG
Humanae  Vitae´LQRessourcement  Thomism,  Sacred  Doctrine,  the  Sacraments,  and  the  
Moral  Life:  Essays  in  Honor  of  Romanus  Cessario,  O.P.:DVKLQJWRQ'&&DWKROLF8QLYHUVLW\
RI$PHULFD3UHVV±DQG6WHYHQ$/RQJ³(QJDJLQJ7KRPLVW,QWHUORFXWRUV´
Nova  et  Vetera(QJOLVKHGLWLRQ±

)LQQLVNatural  Law  and  Natural  Right2[IRUG&ODUHQGRQ3UHVV,

 THE  NATIONAL  CATHOLIC  BIOETHICS  QUARTERLY      SPRING  2013

EHFDXVHRIWKHDFFLGHQWYLVjYLV  WUXWKDVVXFKRIWKHWUXWKEHLQJIXUWKHURUGHUHGWR

WKHJRRGRIDQDFWLRQ  
7KXV RQH FRXOG HYHQ NQRZ D SUDFWLFDO VFLHQFH ZKLFK LV RQH WKDW LQFOXGHV
GRLQJRUPDNLQJLQLWVREMHFWHJHWKLFVLQDVSHFXODWLYHZD\QRWEHFDXVHRQHKDG
DSUHVVLQJSUDFWLFDOHWKLFDOGLOHPPDRUSUREOHPRUIRUWKHJRRGRIDQ\SDUWLFXODU
SURSRVHGDFWLRQEXWIRUWKHVDNHRIFRQWHPSODWLQJWKHWUXHQDWXUHRIWKHJRRGIRU
PDQ/LNHZLVHZKHQRQHNQRZVDWUXWKIRUWKHVDNHRIWKHJRRGRIDQRSHUDWLRQ²DV
DSDUWLFLSDQWLQDVSDFHPLVVLRQPLJKWZLVKWRNQRZFHUWDLQWUXWKVRISK\VLFVIRUWKH
VDNHRIWKHLUDSSOLFDWLRQLQHQJLQHHULQJWRHQDEOHKLPWRVXUYLYH²ZKDWFRXOGEH
SXUHO\VSHFXODWLYHEHFRPHVSUDFWLFDOE\LWVH[WHQVLRQWRDJHQF\
7UXWKLVWKHDGHTXDWLRQRUFRQIRUPLW\RIPLQGDQGWKLQJDQGSUDFWLFDOWUXWKLV
WUXWKWKDWLVRUGHUHGWRWKHJRRGRIDQRSHUDWLRQ$V$TXLQDVWHDFKHVLQWKHSumma  
theologiae³WKHSUDFWLFDOLQWHOOHFWNQRZVWUXWKMXVWDVWKHVSHFXODWLYHLQWHOOHFWEXW
LWGLUHFWVWKHNQRZQWUXWKWRRSHUDWLRQ´7KXVWKLVGLIIHUHQFHRIVSHFXODWLYHDQG
SUDFWLFDOLQWHOOHFWVLVDV$TXLQDVH[SUHVVO\VD\V³DFFLGHQWDO´²IRUall  truth  as  such  
LQYROYHVFRQIRUPLW\RINQRZHUDQGNQRZQDQGWKHSUDFWLFDOLQWHOOHFWNQRZVWUXWK
³MXVWDVWKHVSHFXODWLYHLQWHOOHFW´EXWDQGWKLVLVDFFLGHQWDOWRWUXWKDVVXFKLWIXUWKHU
RUGHUVWKLVWUXWKWRWKHJRRGRIDQRSHUDWLRQ
7KLV PD\ VHHP DQ DEVWUXVH DQG SUDFWLFDOO\ PHDQLQJOHVV SURSRVLWLRQ %XW
SUDFWLFDONQRZOHGJHFOHDUO\SUHVXSSRVHVDGHVLUHWRDFWWKHGHWHUPLQDWLRQWRdo  
VRPHWKLQJ VSULQJV HLWKHU IURP GHVLUH RU IHDU DQG IHDU SUHVXSSRVHV SULRU GHVLUH
IRUVRPHJRRGSHUFHLYHGDVWKUHDWHQHG7KHGHVLUHWRDFWLVFOHDUO\LWVHOISULRUWR
IRUPLQJDQLQWHQWLRQZLWKUHVSHFWWRZKDWLVWREHGRQHDQGWRGHOLEHUDWLRQDQG
FKRLFHRIWKHPHDQV<HWWKLVGHVLUHWRDFWSUHVXSSRVHVNQRZOHGJH6LQFHSUDFWLFDO
NQRZOHGJHLVdownstream  ofDQGconsequent  uponDNQRZOHGJHprecedingGHVLUH
WKLVSULRUNQRZOHGJHFDQQRWEHSUDFWLFDODQGLVQHFHVVDULO\VSHFXODWLYH+HQFHDOO
SUDFWLFDONQRZOHGJHSUHVXSSRVHVDQGGHSHQGVRQDSULRUspeculum  RUVSHFXODWLYH
WUXWKZLWKRXWZKLFKQRSUDFWLFDORSHUDWLRQZLOORUHYHUFRXOGHQVXH6SHFXODWLYH
NQRZOHGJHLVDOZD\VSULRUWRWKHHQWLUHSUDFWLFDORUGHUZKLFKQHFHVVDULO\UHSRVHV
RQWKHIRXQGDWLRQRIVXFKNQRZOHGJH
7KRVHZKRDI¿UPZLWK$TXLQDVWKHSULRULW\RIWKHVSHFXODWLYHWRWKHSUDFWLFDO
DUHQRWFODLPLQJDV11/7DXWKRUVVXFKDV5REHUW*HRUJHKDYHDUJXHG  that  one  
PD\GHULYHSUDFWLFDOFRQFOXVLRQVFRQWDLQLQJUHDVRQVIRUDFWLRQIURPSUHPLVHVWKDW
GR QRW LQFOXGH UHDVRQV IRU DFWLRQ 7R WKH FRQWUDU\ $TXLQDV WHDFKHV WKDW WKHUH LV


7KRPDV$TXLQDVSumma  theologiae  ( ST ,TDUWVHGFRQWUDUHVSDQGDG

,ELGDG

6HH5REHUW3*HRUJH³1DWXUDO/DZDQG+XPDQ1DWXUH´LQNatural  Law  Theory:  
Contemporary   Essays HG 5REHUW 3 *HRUJH 2[IRUG &ODUHQGRQ 3UHVV  ±
HVSHFLDOO\IRUH[DPSOH³:HFDQQRWGHGXFHRULQIHUUHDVRQVIRUDFWLRQIURPSUHPLVVHV
WKDWGRQRWLQFOXGHUHDVRQVIRUDFWLRQ:HFDQQRWGHGXFHRULQIHUEDVLFUHDVRQVIRUDFWLRQIURP
DQ\WKLQJ´7KLVLVDQXQH[FHSWLRQDEOHSURSRVLWLRQWKHSUREOHPUHVLGHVZLWKLWVDSSOLFDWLRQ
WRWKHSULRULW\RIWKHVSHFXODWLYHWRWKHSUDFWLFDODVWKRXJKUHDOLW\DVVXFKZHUHGHSULYHGRI
natural  ends  the  knowledge  of  which  is  presupposed  WRSUDFWLFDOFRJQLWLRQEHFDXVHSULRU
WRSUDFWLFDOYROLWLRQDQGLQWHQWLRQ


 LONG      FUNDAMENTAL  ERRORS  OF  THE  NNLT

VSHFXODWLYHNQRZOHGJHRIUHDVRQVIRUDFWLRQDVDQHFHVVDU\FRQGLWLRQRIDSSHWLWLRQ
DQGWKHHQVXLQJIRUPDWLRQRILQWHQWLRQGHOLEHUDWLRQDQGVRIRUWKWKDWWKH³QDWXUH
RIWKLQJV´²WKHWHOHRORJLFDORUGHURIWKHXQLYHUVHDVNQRZDEOHE\UHDVRQSULRUWR
YROLWLRQ LQWHQWLRQ DQG FKRLFH²LQFOXGHV QRUPDWLYH UHDVRQV IRU DFWLRQ $TXLQDV
WHDFKHVXVWKDWWKHNQRZOHGJHRIDQHQGLVSULRUWRWKHGHVLUHIRULWDQGWKXVSULRUWR
LWVLQWHQWLRQVRWKDWDOZD\VWKHVSHFXODWLYHLV¿UVWDQGWKHSUDFWLFDOVHFRQG7KXV
LIRQHZHUHIRUH[DPSOHWREHPLVJXLGHGZLWKUHVSHFWWRWKHQDWXUHRIWKHJRRGIRU
PDQ²LQHUURUUHJDUGLQJWKHHQG²SUDFWLFDOZLVGRPZRXOGEHGUDVWLFDOO\LPSHGHG
$I¿UPLQJWKHSULPDF\RIWKHVSHFXODWLYHDQGWKHDFFLGHQWDOLW\RIWKHGLVWLQF-­
WLRQEHWZHHQSUDFWLFDODQGVSHFXODWLYHNQRZOHGJHLQQRZD\GHQLHVWKDWWKHUHDUH
per  se  nota  WUXWKVSHUWDLQLQJWRSUDFWLFDOUHDVRQprecisely  because  the  operations  of  
practical  reason  are  themselves  constituted  as  such  dependent  on  prior  speculative  
knowledge.107KHSUDFWLFDOLQWHOOHFWNQRZVWUXWKMXVWDVGRHVWKHVSHFXODWLYHLQWHOOHFW
DQGRUGHUVWKHNQRZQWUXWKWRWKHJRRGRIDQRSHUDWLRQ²KDYLQJIRULWVREMHFWJRRG
XQGHUWKHDVSHFWRIWUXWKDVRUGHUHGWRRSHUDWLRQ²DQGVRSUDFWLFDOUHDVRQLVJHVWDWHG
LQ WKH ZRPE RI VSHFXODWLYH NQRZOHGJH 3UDFWLFDO NQRZOHGJH VLPSO\ VSHDNLQJ
GHYROYHVIURPSULRUVSHFXODWLYHFRJQLWLRQZKLFKOLHVDWWKHRULJLQRIYROLWLRQLQFOL-­
QDWLRQDQGVXEVHTXHQWLQWHQWLRQ,WLVDFFLGHQWDOWRVSHFXODWLYHNQRZOHGJHWKDWLW
VKRXOGLJQLWHGHVLUHEXWLWLVQRWDFFLGHQWDOWRWKHWHOHRORJLFDORUGHULQJRIKXPDQ
nature  that  this  should  be  the  case.
.QRZOHGJHDVVXFKLVVSHFXODWLYHLQYROYLQJDGHTXDWLRQRINQRZHUDQGNQRZQ
DQG SUDFWLFDO FRJQLWLRQ LV GLVWLQJXLVKHG E\ VRPHWKLQJ DFFLGHQWDO WR NQRZOHGJH
QDPHO\WKHRUGHUWRRSHUDWLRQ7KDWLWLVGLVWLQJXLVKHGE\VRPHWKLQJDFFLGHQWDOGRHV
QRWPHDQWKDWWKLVDFFLGHQWDOLW\GRHVQRWEULQJZLWKLWLWVRZQGLVWLQFWLYHFKDUDFWHULVWLF
IHDWXUHV3UDFWLFDONQRZOHGJHKDVGLVWLQFWLYHFRQFHUQVDQGFRQVLGHUDWLRQVQRWIRXQG
LQSXUHO\VSHFXODWLYHNQRZOHGJHEHFDXVHWKHPRGHRIWKHNQRZLQJÀRZVIURPWKH
HQGRIWKHNQRZLQJDQGWKHHQGRISUDFWLFDONQRZLQJLVWKHWUXWKRIWKHJRRGRIDQ
RSHUDWLRQ1RQHWKHOHVVWKHYHU\UHDVRQIRUWKHVHGLVWLQFWLYHIHDWXUHVLVWKHRUGLQDWLRQ
RINQRZOHGJHWRRSHUDWLRQDQGWKDWNQRZOHGJHEHRUGDLQHGWRRSHUDWLRQLVDFFLGHQWDO
WRNQRZOHGJHas  such5DWKHUWKDQGHSULYLQJSUDFWLFDONQRZOHGJHRILWVGLVWLQFWLYH
IHDWXUHVWKHUHFRJQLWLRQWKDWSUDFWLFDONQRZOHGJHSUHVXSSRVHVDQGGHYROYHVIURP
SULRUVSHFXODWLYHFRJQLWLRQDGGUHVVHVWKHIRXQGDWLRQRIWKHSUDFWLFDODVVXFK  

10  
2QHVHHVWKHFRQWUDU\YLHZLQWKHZRUGVRI-RKQ)LQQLVAquinas  ±³6RPH
FRPPHQWDWRUV RQ $TXLQDV KDYH LPDJLQHG WKDW WKH\ DUH VXFK SURSRVLWLRQV RQ ZKLFK D
µSUDFWLFDO¶LHGLUHFWLYHFKDUDFWHULVFRQIHUUHGE\WKHLQWHUYHQWLRQRIVRPHDFWRIZLOO6XFK
DYLHZQRWRQO\FRQWUDGLFWV$TXLQDV¶FRQFHSWLRQRIWKH¿UVWSUDFWLFDOSULQFLSOHVDVµIRXQGHG
RQ¶DQDEVROXWHO\¿UVWSUDFWLFDOSULQFLSOHZKRVHIRUP²WKHIRUPZKLFKPDNHVHYHU\SUDFWLFDO
principle  and  proposition  practical²LVQHLWKHULQGLFDWLYHQRULPSHUDWLYHEXWJHUXQGLYHDQG
GLUHFWLYH,WDOVRKRSHOHVVO\FRQWUDGLFWVKLVEDVLFDQGSHUYDVLYHXQGHUVWDQGLQJRIZLOO²WKDW
LWLVUHVSRQVHWRUHDVRQV3UDFWLFDOLQWHOOLJHQFHLVQRWVODYHWRWKHZLOODQ\PRUHWKDQLWLVWKH
VODYHRIWKHSDVVLRQV´2IFRXUVHWKHSUDFWLFDOLQWHOOLJHQFHLVQRW³VODYHWRWKHZLOO´²QHLWKHU
WKH¿[HGIRXQGDWLRQVDQGOLPLWVRISUDFWLFDOUHDVRQLQJQRUSUXGHQWLDOFLUFXPVWDQFHVDUH
VLPSO\PDWWHUVRIZLOO%XWWKHSUDFWLFDOLQWHOOLJHQFHqua  practical  necessarily  presupposes  
ZLOOLQJDQGWKDWZLOOLQJQHFHVVDULO\LVLQIRUPHGE\DQGGHULYDWLYHIURPSULRUVSHFXODWLYH
NQRZOHGJH


 THE  NATIONAL  CATHOLIC  BIOETHICS  QUARTERLY      SPRING  2013

While  the  speculative  may  be  considered  in  precision  from  the  practical,  the  
converse  is  never  true,  because  the  practical  implicitly  and  actually  presupposes  the  
speculative.  Hence,  the  effort  to  separate  from  the  speculative,  for    methodological  
purposes,  and  then  reconnect  later,  is  badly  misconceived  from  the  outset.3ULRU
WRYROLWLRQDQGLQWHQWLRQWKHUHLVQRSUDFWLFDOUHDVRQLQJDQGSULRUWRGHVLUHWKHUHLV
QRYROLWLRQRULQWHQWLRQ,WIROORZVWKDWWKHNQRZOHGJHpriorWRGHVLUHDQGa  fortiori  
SULRUWRYROLWLRQDQGLQWHQWLRQLVQRWSUDFWLFDOEXWUDWKHUVSHFXODWLYHNQRZOHGJH
$V$TXLQDVZULWHV³1RZWKH¿UVWIRUPDOSULQFLSOHLVXQLYHUVDOµEHLQJ¶DQGµWUXWK¶
ZKLFKLVWKHREMHFWRIWKHLQWHOOHFW$QGWKHUHIRUHE\WKLVNLQGRIPRWLRQWKHLQWHOOHFW
PRYHVWKHZLOODVSUHVHQWLQJLWVREMHFWWRLW´11
This  speculum  LVDWWKHKHDUWRIHYHU\SUDFWLFDOFRJQLWLRQOLNHWKHJUDLQRIVDQG
DURXQGZKLFKDSHDUOZLOOIRUP2QHGRHVQRWGHQ\WKHGLVWLQFWLYHQHVVRIWKHSHDUO
WRQRWHWKDWQRWDOOJUDLQVRIVDQGDUHWKHVWDUWRIWKHIRUPDWLRQRIDSHDUOVRWKDWLW
LVDFFLGHQWDOWRWKHVDQGWKDWLWEHWKHEHJLQQLQJRIDSHDUO/LNHZLVHLWLVDFFLGHQWDO
WR NQRZOHGJH DV VXFK²ZKLFK LV GH¿QHG E\ VSHFXODWLYH DGHTXDWLRQ²WKDW LW EH
IXUWKHURUGHUHGWRWKHJRRGRIDQRSHUDWLRQ7KHVSHFXODWLYHDVVXFKDQGSUHFLVHO\
YLHZHGLVQRWSUDFWLFDOEXWWKHSUDFWLFDOLVFRQVWLWXWHGLQQHFHVVDU\GHSHQGHQFHRQ
WKHVSHFXODWLYH
7KHHUURURIGHQ\LQJWKHSULPDF\RIWKHVSHFXODWLYHLVFORVHO\UHODWHGWRWKH
11/7GHQLDORIXQL¿HGQRUPDWLYHQDWXUDOWHOHRORJ\³2XJKW´ZHDUHWROGFDQQRW
EHLQIHUUHGIURP³LV´12SUDFWLFDOLPSOLFDWLRQVFDQQRWEHLQIHUUHGIURPVSHFXODWLYH
NQRZOHGJH13%XWLQDVPXFKDVQDWXUHis  RUGHUHGWRHQGDVLWVJRRG²DWUXWKIURP
ZKLFKZHPD\DEVWUDFWEXWZKLFKLVUHDODOOWKHVDPH²WKLVRUGHULQJFDQQRWKHOSEXW
VXSSO\UHDVRQVIRUDFWLRQDQG³RXJKWV´$QGZKLOHLWLVDFFLGHQWDOWRVRPHVSHFXODWLYH
NQRZOHGJHDVVXFKWKDWLWHQJHQGHUVLQFOLQDWLRQLWLVQRWDFFLGHQWDOWRKXPDQQDWXUH
WKDWLWLVRUGHUHGLQVXFKDZD\WKDWNQRZOHGJHHQJHQGHUVDSSHWLWH1DWXUHDQGJRRG
DUHQRWDQWLSRGHVGHVSLWHWKHFRQMRLQWQHJDWLRQVRIDQDO\WLFORJLFLVPDQGFRQWLQHQWDO
DSULRULVP0DQ¶VUHDVRQLVD³PHDVXUHGPHDVXUH´,WLVQRWLWVHOIWKHPHDVXUHRI
WKHWKLQJVWKDWDUHIURPQDWXUHDOWKRXJKLWLVWKHPHDVXUHRIRXUDFWLRQ ²LQRWKHU
ZRUGVLQRUGHUIRURXUUHDVRQWREHWKHSURSHUPHDVXUHRIRXUDFWVRXUUHDVRQPXVW
¿UVWEHPHDVXUHGDQGQRUPHGE\UHDOLW\E\WKDWZKLFKLV
2QHUHFROOHFWVZKDWRXUODWHSRQWLII%OHVVHG-RKQ3DXO,,ZURWHLQQRI
Fides  et  ratioUHJDUGLQJ³WKHQHHGIRUDSKLORVRSK\RIJHQXLQHO\PHWDSK\VLFDOUDQJH
FDSDEOHWKDWLVRIWUDQVFHQGLQJHPSLULFDOGDWDLQRUGHUWRDWWDLQVRPHWKLQJDEVROXWH
XOWLPDWH DQG IRXQGDWLRQDO LQ LWV VHDUFK IRU WUXWK 7KLV UHTXLUHPHQW LV LPSOLFLW LQ

11  
ST  ,,,TD³3ULPXPDXWHPSULQFLSLXPIRUPDOHHVWHQVHWYHUXPXQLYHUVDOH
TXRGHVWRELHFWXPLQWHOOHFWXV(WLGHRLVWRPRGRPRWLRQLVLQWHOOHFWXVPRYHWYROXQWDWHP
VLFXWSUDHVHQWDQVHLRELHFWXPVXXP´
12  
6HHIRUH[DPSOH-RKQ)LQQLVNatural  Law  and  Natural  Rights³$ULVWRWOHDQG
$TXLQDVZRXOGUHDGLO\JUDQWWKDWought  FDQQRWEHGHGXFHGIURPis´
13  
-RKQ)LQQLV*HUPDLQ*ULVH]DQG-RVHSK%R\OH³3UDFWLFDO3ULQFLSOHV0RUDO7UXWK
DQG8OWLPDWH(QGV´American  Journal  of  Jurisprudence±±

ST  ,,,TDDG

110
 LONG      FUNDAMENTAL  ERRORS  OF  THE  NNLT

VDSLHQWLDODQGDQDO\WLFDONQRZOHGJHDOLNHDQGLQSDUWLFXODULWLVDUHTXLUHPHQWIRU
NQRZLQJWKHPRUDOJRRGZKLFKKDVLWVXOWLPDWHIRXQGDWLRQLQWKH6XSUHPH*RRG
*RGKLPVHOI.´$SKLORVRSK\RIJHQXLQHO\PHWDSK\VLFDOUDQJHLVLQGHHGD³UHTXLUH-­
PHQW´IRUDGHTXDWHXQGHUVWDQGLQJRIWKHPRUDOJRRG
2ZLQJWRLWVQHJDWLRQRIWKHSULPDF\RIWKHVSHFXODWLYH15WKH11/7VHYHUHO\
derogates  the  essentially  theocentric  and  theonomic  character  of  the  doctrine  of  
natural  lawVRPHWKLQJRIZKLFK,ZLOOVSHDNEHORZ,QLWVVXSHURUGLQDWLRQRIWKH
SUDFWLFDOWRWKHVSHFXODWLYHLWEHDUVPRUHOLNHQHVVERWKWRWKHWHDFKLQJRI,PPDQXHO
.DQWDQGRI-RKQ'XQV6FRWXVWKDQLWGRHVWRWKHPRUDOWHDFKLQJRI$TXLQDV7KLV
YLHZLVDVLWZHUHWKH³RULJLQDOVLQ´RIWKH11/7DJDLQVWWKHOLJKWRIWKHLQWHOOHFWDQG
WKHVXSUHPDF\RIWKHVSHFXODWLYHDWWKHKHDUWRI$TXLQDV¶VGRFWULQHRIQDWXUDOODZ
Negation  of  Unified  Normative  Natural  Teleology:    
The  Error  of  “Incommensurability”
7KHQHJDWLRQRIWKHSULPDF\RIWKHVSHFXODWLYHZLWKUHVSHFWWRWKHSUDFWLFDO
LVWKHIRUPDOHOHPHQWWKDWLVPRVWGHWHUPLQDWLYHRIWKHODWHUIDLOXUHVRIWKH11/7
%XWWKHPRVWLPSRUWDQWmaterial  MXGJPHQWWKDWÀRZVIURPWKLVORVVRIWKHSULPDF\
RIWKHVSHFXODWLYHLVWKHMXGJPHQWWKDWXQL¿HGQRUPDWLYHQDWXUDOWHOHRORJ\LVQRW
IRXQGDWLRQDOIRUQDWXUDOODZ7KLVLVVRIXQGDPHQWDODQHUURUWKDWDERRNZRXOGEH
UHTXLUHGWRGRMXVWLFHWRLWVPDQLIROGLPSOLFDWLRQV)URPRUGLQDU\HWKLFDODQDO\VLV
WRWKHIXUWKHVWUHDFKHVRIELRHWKLFVWKH11/7UHIXVDOWRDGPLWWKDWXQL¿HGQDWXUDO
WHOHRORJ\LVQRUPDWLYHIRUPRUDOMXGJPHQW²WKDWWKHRUGHURISUHFHSWVIROORZVWKH
RUGHURILQFOLQDWLRQVZKLFKIROORZVWKHRUGHURIHQGV ²GRRPVLWVWHDFKLQJWRWKH
FRQ¿QHVRIGHRQWRORJ\DQGDQHZFDVXLVWU\
,WLVLQGHHGODUJHO\EHFDXVHRIWKLVIDLOXUHWRDFNQRZOHGJHWKHQRUPDWLYHIXQF-­
WLRQRIQDWXUDOWHOHRORJ\WKDWWKH11/7GHQLHVWKDWWKH¿UVWSUHFHSWRIWKHQDWXUDO
ODZ²WRGRDQGSXUVXHJRRGDQGDYRLGHYLO²LVDJHQXLQHPRUDOSUHFHSW0RUH
LPSRUWDQWO\WKHGHQLDOWKDWWKHKLHUDUFK\RIHQGVGH¿QLQJWKHQDWXUHRIWKHJRRGLV
QRUPDWLYHIRURXUPRUDOOLIHIDLOVWRVHHWKDWHQGVDUHUHDVRQVIRUDFWLRQDQGWKDW
WKHRUGHULQJRIQDWXUHWRZDUGHQGVLVDWUXWKRIQDWXUH$VQRWHGDERYHLWLVQRWWKDW
UHDVRQVIRUDFWLRQDUHORJLFDOO\GHGXFHGIURPSURSRVLWLRQVWKDWFRQWDLQQRUHDVRQV
IRUDFWLRQ5DWKHULWLVWKHFDVHWKDWQDWXUHVDUHWHOHRORJLFDOO\RUGHUHG²WKDWQDWXUHV

15  
6HH)LQQLVAquinas±

ST  ,,,TD

6HH)LQQLVAquinas±

6HH )LQQLV Natural   Law   and   Natural   Rights ± WKH VHFWLRQ WLWOHG ³$OO
(TXDOO\)XQGDPHQWDO´DQGHVSHFLDOO\WKHOLQHVRQ³(DFKLVIXQGDPHQWDO1RQHLVPRUH
IXQGDPHQWDOWKDQDQ\RIWKHRWKHUVIRUHDFKFDQUHDVRQDEO\EHIRFXVHGXSRQDQGHDFKZKHQ
IRFXVHGXSRQFODLPVDSULRULW\RIYDOXH+HQFHWKHUHLVQRREMHFWLYHSULRULW\DPRQJVWWKHP´
1RWHDOVR±HVSHFLDOO\UHJDUGLQJEDVLFJRRGV³7KH\DUHLQFRPPHQVXUDEOH´
7KH11/7GHQLHVDQ\KLHUDUFK\RI³EDVLF´JRRGVSULRUWRFKRLFH2IFRXUVHIRU$TXLQDV
WKLVLVLPSRVVLEOHIRUDQ\WKLQJWKDWLVQRWGHVLUHGDVWKHfinis  ultimus  is  necessarily  desired  
as  ordered  to  it  (ST,,,TD

111
 THE  NATIONAL  CATHOLIC  BIOETHICS  QUARTERLY      SPRING  2013

DQGDFWLRQVDUHIRUWKHVDNHRIDQHQG6LQFHQDWXUDOWHOHRORJLFDORUGHUH[LVWVUHDO
LPSOLFDWLRQVIRUDFWLRQÀRZIURPNQRZOHGJHRIWKLVRUGHU  
7KH TXLQWHVVHQWLDO DFW RI PRGHUQ FRQMXU\ RFFXUV LQ WKH VXSSRVLWLRQ WKDW
EHFDXVHRQHPD\DEVWUDFWIURPWHOHRORJLFDORUGHULWWKHUHIRUHGRHVQRWH[LVW%XWRXU
FDSDFLW\WRDEVWUDFWIURPQDWXUDORUGHUGRHVQRWLPSO\LWVQRQH[LVWHQFH7KHWUXWK
WKDWK\SRWKHWLFRGHGXFWLYHSK\VLFVODUJHO\DEVWUDFWVIURPWKHRUGHULQJRIQDWXUHV
toward  ends  cannot  supplant  the  truth  that  action  as  such  can  only  be  understood  
DQGGHQRPLQDWHGLQUHODWLRQWRDQHQG:KLOHLWLVRIWHQWKRXJKWWKDWWHOHRORJ\GRHV
QRWSHUWDLQWRWKHFRVPRVDWODUJHEXWRQO\DWEHVWWRGHOLEHUDWHKXPDQDFWLRQVLQ
IDFWQRDJHQF\LVLQWHOOLJLEOHDVVXFKZLWKRXWUHIHUHQFHWRWKDWWRZDUGZKLFKLWWHQGV
:K\ZRXOGRQHFDOOVRPHWKLQJ³DJHQF\´WKDWGRHVQRWKLQJ²LVQRWD³GRLQJ´²DQG
that  neither  tends  toward  anything  nor  brings  anything  about?)  
&RQWUDU\WRWKH+XPHDQVXSSRVLWLRQWKDWDQ³RXJKW´FDQQRWEHGHULYHGIURPDQ
³LV´WKHJRRGexists7KHLGHDWKDWQDWXUHODFNVWHOHRORJ\RUWKDWVSHFXODWLYHNQRZO-­
HGJHRIQDWXUHPXVWRPLWWHOHRORJ\²RUWKDWLWLPSOLHVQRWKLQJUHJDUGLQJKXPDQ
PRUDOLW\²LVHUURQHRXV,WLVRIFRXUVHWUXHWKDWPXFKRIWKHFRVPRVLVEHQHDWKWKH
OHYHORIDJHQF\DQGVXEWHQGVLWDQGLVWDNHQXSE\LWDVDQDQWPRYHVDSHEEOH%XW
DJHQF\DVVXFKLQYROYHVPRWLRQWRZDUGDQHQG²LWGRHVQRWVHHPWKDWDQDFWWKDW
tends  toward  or  does  nothing  is  intelligible  as  an  act.  
,WKDVEHFRPHSRSXODULQVRPHTXDUWHUV²LQFOXGLQJWKH11/7²WRVSHDNRI
QDWXUDOWHOHRORJ\DVWKRXJKLWSHUWDLQHGRQO\WRWKHSK\VLFDOVSHFLHVRIDFWLRQV20  But  
³QDWXUH´GRHVQRWRQO\SHUWDLQWR³ORZHUQDWXUH´DQGLWLVWKHQDWXUHRIDJHQF\LQDOO
LWVDQDORJLFDOH[WHQVLRQWKDWLPSOLHVDQGUHTXLUHVWREHVSHFL¿HGDQGGHQRPLQDWHG
E\VRPHWKLQJWKDWVWDQGVLQWKHSODFHRIWKHHQG7KHEHJLQQLQJRIZLVGRPLVWKH
UHDOL]DWLRQWKDWUHDVRQLVQRWQRUPHGE\LWVHOI$V$TXLQDVVRZHOOSXWVLW³+XPDQ
UHDVRQLVQRWRILWVHOIWKHUXOHRIWKLQJVEXWWKHSULQFLSOHVLPSUHVVHGRQLWE\QDWXUH
DUHJHQHUDOUXOHVDQGPHDVXUHVRIDOOWKLQJVUHODWLQJWRKXPDQFRQGXFWZKHUHRIWKH
QDWXUDOUHDVRQLVWKHUXOHDQGPHDVXUHDOWKRXJKLWLVQRWWKHPHDVXUHRIWKLQJVWKDW
DUHIURPQDWXUH´212UWRSXWLWVLPSO\LQRUGHUIRUUHDVRQWREHDQDGHTXDWHUXOHRU
PHDVXUHRIFRQGXFWLWPXVW¿UVWUHFHLYH²KDYH³LPSUHVVHGRQLWE\QDWXUH´²WKH
UXOHWRZKLFKLWPXVWFRQIRUPVRDVWREHDEOHWRVHUYHDVDQDGHTXDWHUXOHDQG
PHDVXUHIRUFRQGXFW


3RWHQFLHVDUHRUGHUHGWRZDUGDQGGHWHUPLQHGE\DFWVDQGQRWYLFHYHUVDWKHUHLVQR
FRQWUDGLFWLRQLQDI¿UPLQJWKDWWKHSRWHQF\LVGHWHUPLQHGE\WKHDFWZKLOHWKHDFW²EHFDXVH
SRWHQF\LVDFFLGHQWDOWRDFWDVVXFK²LVQRWGH¿QHGE\WKHSRWHQF\
20  
6HH-RKQ)LQQLV*HUPDLQ*ULVH]-RVHSK%R\OH³µ'LUHFW¶DQGµ,QGLUHFW¶$5HSO\
WR&ULWLFVRI2XU$FWLRQ7KHRU\´The  Thomist  -DQXDU\±HVSHFLDOO\±
ZKHUH$TXLQDV¶VGLVWLQFWLRQEHWZHHQWKHSK\VLFDODQGPRUDOVSHFLHVLVLQWHUSUHWHGLQVXFK
DZD\DVWRUHQGHUWKHQDWXUDOWHOHRORJ\RIWKHDFWRIFUDQLRWRP\WREHLUUHOHYDQWWRWKH
MXGJPHQWRILWVPRUDOVSHFLHVDQDUJXPHQWWKDWUXQVWKURXJKWKHUHPDLQGHURIWKHHVVD\
21  
ST,,,TDDG³$GVHFXQGXPGLFHQGXPTXRGUDWLRKXPDQDVHFXQGXPVH
QRQHVWUHJXODUHUXPVHGSULQFLSLDHLQDWXUDOLWHULQGLWDVXQWTXDHGDPUHJXODHJHQHUDOHVHW
PHQVXUDHRPQLXPHRUXPTXDHVXQWSHUKRPLQHPDJHQGDTXRUXPUDWLRQDWXUDOLVHVWUHJXOD
HWPHQVXUDOLFHWQRQVLWPHQVXUDHRUXPTXDHVXQWDQDWXUD´

112
 LONG      FUNDAMENTAL  ERRORS  OF  THE  NNLT

5HDVRQLVLWQRWLWVRZQQRUPEXWLWLVQRUPHGE\WKHRUGHURIWKLQJVDVLPSUHVVHG
E\ DQG SDUWLFLSDWLQJ LQ WKH 'LYLQH 0LQG $TXLQDV¶V DFFRXQW DI¿UPV WKH VHFRQG-­
DU\FDXVDOLW\RIWKHKXPDQPLQGZLWKLQGLYLQHLOOXPLQDWLRQZKLFKLVQRWDGLUHFW
LOOXPLQDWLRQEXWUDWKHUDSDUWLFLSDWHGLOOXPLQDWLRQZKHUHE\WKHLQWHOOHFWLYHSRZHU
HQDEOHVPDQWRDSSUHKHQGFRQFHLYHXQGHUVWDQGDQGMXGJHWKHRUGHULPSUHVVHGE\
WKHGLYLQHZLVGRPRQQDWXUHDQGWRUHFHLYHWKLVRUGHULQDpreceptivePDQQHUDV
DUWLFXODWLQJUHDVRQVIRUFRQGXFW7KHUDWLRQDOEDVLVIRURXUHWKLFDOOLYHVWUDQVFHQGV
practical  reason  while  also  interiorly  ordering  it.
7KH11/7GRHVDGPLWWKDWWKHUHDUH³EDVLF´QDWXUDOJRRGVRUHQGV%XWDFFRUG-­
LQJWRWKH11/7WKHVHJRRGVH[KLELWQRPRUDOO\VLJQL¿FDQWRUGHUSULRUWRFKRLFH
7KLVMXGJPHQWLPSOLFLWO\GHQLHVWKHXQLW\RIKXPDQQDWXUHDQGJRRGLWGHQLHVWKH
XQL¿FDWLRQRIQDWXUDOHQGVDFFRUGLQJWRWKHLUGLYHUVHWHOHORJLFDOUHODWLRQVWRWKHJRRG
OLIHDVDQRUGHUHGZKROH7KHQDPHIRUWKLVYLHZ²WKDWSXWDWLYHO\³EDVLF´JRRGV
IRUH[DPSOHOLIHSUDFWLFDOUHDVRQDELOLW\UHOLJLRQSOD\NQRZOHGJHVRFLDELOLW\DQG
practical  reasonableness  22DUHQRWRUGHUHGDPRQJVWRQHDQRWKHUKLHUDUFKLFDOO\LQD
PRUDOO\VLJQL¿FDQWPDQQHUEXWUDWKHUDUHVWULFWO\LQFRPSDUDEOH²LV³LQFRPPHQVX-­
UDELOLW\´7KH11/7KROGVWKDWWKHVHEDVLFJRRGVRUHQGVDUH³QRWFRPHDVXUHG´E\
RQHDQRWKHUDUHQRW³SDUWV´RIWKDWZKROHRIWKHJRRGOLIHWKDWFDQEHFRPSDUHGLQ
WKHLUUHODWLRQWRWKHZKROHVXFKWKDWVRPHZRXOGEHQDWXUDOO\QREOHUWKDQRWKHUV23  
2IFRXUVHIRUWKH11/7DXWKRUVWKHEDVLFJRRGVDVVXFKDUHVDLGWREHQREOHUWKDQ
PHUHO\LQVWUXPHQWDOJRRGVZKLFKDUHGHSLFWHGDVVLPSOHXWLOLWLHV
%DVLFJRRGVLQWKHPVHOYHVDUHVDLGLQWKH11/7QRWWREHVXEMHFWWRDQ\PRU-­
DOO\VLJQL¿FDQWRUGHUSULRUWRFKRLFH,WLVFKRLFHWKDWLVKHOGWRLPSRVHDPRUDOO\
VLJQL¿FDQWRUGHURQWKHVHJRRGVZKLOHLQWKHPVHOYHVWKHVHJRRGVDUHKHOGQRWWR
EHQDWXUDOO\RUGHUHGRQHWRDQRWKHU2QHVHHVKHUHWKDWFRQWUDU\WRWKHWUDGLWLRQRI
&DWKROLFPRUDOUHÀHFWLRQZKLFKKDVEHHQGHFLVLYHO\IRUPHGLQUHODWLRQWRWKHWHDFK-­
LQJVRI$ULVWRWOHDQG$TXLQDVWKH11/7HPEUDFHVWKHTXLQWHVVHQWLDOO\PRGHUQYLHZ
WKDWPRUDORUGHULVZKROO\FRQVHTXHQWRQFKRLFHUDWKHUWKDQQDWXUDOO\SULRUWRDQG
QRUPLQJVXFKFKRLFH
7KXVIRUWKH11/7XQL¿HGQRUPDWLYHWHOHRORJ\DVLPSUHVVHGE\*RGRQQDWXUH
SULRUWRDQ\FKRLFHGRHVQRWUXOHRUPHDVXUHPRUDOMXGJPHQWDWOHDVWQRWEH\RQGWKH
QDWXUDOO\JLYHQGLVWLQFWLRQEHWZHHQEDVLFDQGPHUHO\LQVWUXPHQWDOJRRGV5DWKHU
ZKDWUXOHVRUPHDVXUHVPRUDOMXGJPHQWLVVLPSO\WKHEDVLFJRRGVWKHPVHOYHVDQG
WKHUHFRJQLWLRQWKDWRQHVKRXOGQHYHUDFWFRQWUDU\WRWKHP%XWQRPRUDOO\VLJQL¿-­
FDQWSRVLWLYHRUGHULQJRIWKHVHJRRGVSULRUWRFKRLFHLVLQVLVWHGRQDVHVVHQWLDOWRWKH
JRRG7KLVIRXQGDWLRQDOVHSDUDWLRQIURPQDWXUDOWHOHRORJ\VWURQJO\GLVWLQJXLVKHVWKH
11/7IURPWKHWHDFKLQJRI$TXLQDV
)RU$TXLQDVDVIRU$ULVWRWOHKXPDQQDWXUHDVDZKROHLVWHOHRORJLFDOO\RUGHUHG
7HOHRORJ\LVQRWVRPHWKLQJWKDWSHUWDLQVRQO\WR³ORZHU´RU³SK\VLFDO´QDWXUHEXW

22  
7KHUHLVVRPHGLIIHUHQFHUHJDUGLQJWKHH[DFWFRQVWLWXWLRQRIWKHOLVWEXWWKHVHVHYHQ
KDYHEHHQQDPHGDVFRQVWLWXHQWVE\-RKQ)LQQLVLQNatural  Law  and  Natural  Rights±
23  
,ELG±

,ELG±

113
 THE  NATIONAL  CATHOLIC  BIOETHICS  QUARTERLY      SPRING  2013

SHUWDLQVWRKXPDQQDWXUHDVDXQL¿HGZKROH$FWLRQDVVXFKFDQQRWEHGHQRPLQDWHG
DSDUWIURPHQG)XUWKHUDQGPRVWSURPLQHQWO\IRU$TXLQDVDQG$ULVWRWOHWKHJRRGIRU
PDQLVDQRUGHUHGZKROH25,ISXWDWLYHO\EDVLF³JRRGV´DUHQRWRUGHUHGWRWKHHQGRI
WKHJRRGOLIHZK\VKRXOGRQHGHQRPLQDWHWKHPDV³JRRG´"$QGLIWKH\DUHRUGHUHG
WRWKHHQGRIWKHJRRGOLIHWKHQWKH\DUH³FRRUGHUHG´DQG³FRPHDVXUHG´LQUHODWLRQ
WRLWWKH\DUH³FRPPHQVXUDEOH´WKDWLVFRPSDUDEOHLQWKHLURUGHULQJDFFRUGLQJDV
WKH\DUHPRUHRUOHVVFRPSUHKHQVLYHRIWKHJRRGIRUPDQ
&RPPHQVXUDWLRQLVQRWQHFHVVDULO\FUDVVO\TXDQWLWDWLYHJRRGVDUHWHOHRORJL-­
FDOO\FRPPHQVXUDWHG7KXVOLIHLVDJRRGDQGDQHQGEXWLWLVQRWWKHVXSUHPHJRRG
DQGHQGLWLVJRRGQRWRQO\inLWVHOIEXWSUHFLVHO\DVfurther  ordered  toward  other  
and  nobler  HQGVVXFKDVMXVWLFHWUXWKIULHQGVKLSDQGZLVGRP,QDVHQVHPHUHO\
E\DFNQRZOHGJLQJWKDWWKHSXWDWLYHO\³EDVLF´JRRGVDUH³EDVLF´WKH11/7DGPLWV
WKLVPXFKFRPPHQVXUDWLRQHDFKVKDUHVLQDFRPPRQratio%XWIRUWKHPWKLVratio  
GRHVQRWDGPLWRIRUGHU7KXVDOOEDVLFJRRGVDUHEDVLFEXWQRQHLVORIWLHUWKDQDQ\
RWKHUDQGWKHUHLVQRorder  WKDWLVUHTXLVLWHWRWKHJRRGEH\RQGWKHQHJDWLYHRUGHU
RIQRWDFWLQJGLUHFWO\DJDLQVWDEDVLFJRRG
<HWWRWKHFRQWUDU\ZHUHDQ\JRRGQRWRUGHUHGWRZDUGWKHJRRGOLIHDVVXFK
DQGDVDZKROHWKHQQRRQHFRXOGHYHUKDYHDUHDVRQIRUSXUVXLQJVXFKD³JRRG´
6XFKSXWDWLYHO\³QRQRUGHUHG´DQG³EDVLF´JRRGVZRXOGEHOLNHURDGVWKDWHQGLQWKH
PLGGOHRIQRZKHUHOHDGLQJWRQRWKLQJ6XFKDYLHZLVVLPSO\LQFRPSDWLEOHZLWK
WKHWHDFKLQJRI$TXLQDVDFFRUGLQJWRZKRPLWLVLPSRVVLEOHIRURQHDJHQWWRKDYH
WZRDEVROXWHO\ODVWHQGVDQGIRUZKRPZKDWHYHULVQRWWKHODVWHQGRUfinis  ultimus  
is  desired  as  ordered  to  the  finis  ultimus.7KXVWKHHQWLUHRUGHURISURSRUWLRQDWH
QDWXUDOHQGVLVQRZGHVLUDEOHLQUHODWLRQWRWKHVXSHUQDWXUDOJRRGRIEHDWL¿FYLVLRQ
ZKLFKLVWKH¿QDOHQGRIPDQDQGLVMXGJHGLQUHODWLRQWRWKLVHQGDVOLNHZLVHQDWX-­
UDOHQGVPD\EHMXGJHGDPRQJWKHPVHOYHV6RPHHQGVDUHQREOHUWKDQRWKHUVIRU
H[DPSOHZLVGRPLVQREOHUWKDQOLIHEHFDXVHLWLVWUXHUWRVD\WKDWZHOLYHVRDVWR
DFKLHYHZLVGRPWKDQLWLVWRVD\WKDWZHKDYHZLVGRPVLPSO\WROLYHDQGWKHZKROH
RUGHURISURSRUWLRQDWHQDWXUDOHQGVLVIXUWKHURUGHUHGLQJUDFHWRZDUGWKH¿QDOHQG
RIVXSHUQDWXUDOEHDWL¿FYLVLRQ  
7KHPRUDOOLIHLVQRWVLPSO\DQRQRUGHUHGOLVWRIJRRGVWKDWRQHVKRXOGQRWDFW
DJDLQVWEHFDXVHWKHSULRUDQGFODVVLFDOTXHVWLRQPXVWDOZD\VEHGHFLVLYHQDPHO\ZKDW
LVWKHULJKWRUGHULQJRIJRRGVDVGH¿QLQJWKHQDWXUHRIWKHJRRGIRUPDQ"*UDQWHG
WKDWOLIHLVDJUHDWJRRGLWLVLQIHULRUWRWKHJRRGRIWUXWKDQGOLNHZLVHWRWKHJRRGV
RIMXVWLFHDQGIULHQGVKLSEHFDXVHLWLVSDUWRIWKHYHU\FRUHRIWKHJRRGQHVVRIOLIH
that  it  is  by  nature  further  ordered  WRWKHVHORIWLHUJRRGVDQGRUGHUHGWRWKHPVRDV
WREHSHUIHFWHGE\WKHP7RVXJJHVWWKDWOLIHLVPHUHO\RQHDPRQJRWKHUJRRGVWKDW
KDYHQRPRUDOO\VLJQL¿FDQWRUGHUSULRUWRFKRLFHLVWRORVHWKHPRUDODVVXFKWRORVH
WKHTXHVWLRQRIWKHRUGHUWKDWGH¿QHVWKHQDWXUHRIWKHJRRG,WLVYLUWXDOO\DGHVFHQW
LQWRVRFLRORJ\SHRSOHVHHNWKHVHJRRGVZKLOHORVLQJWKHUDWLRQDOHOHPHQWLQPRUDO
WKRXJKWZKDWLVWKHQRUPDWLYHRUGHURIWKHVHJRRGVWKDWVKRXOGLQIRUPRXUDFWLRQV

25  
ST,,,TDUW

,ELGTD


 LONG      FUNDAMENTAL  ERRORS  OF  THE  NNLT

The  proposition  that  a  lower  good  is  ordered  to  a  higher  good  is  understood  
E\VRPH11/7DXWKRUVWRLPSO\WKDWNQRZOHGJHRIWKHKLHUDUFK\RIHQGVRUJRRGV
VKRXOGE\LWVHOIEHVXI¿FLHQWWRSURYLGHDQDQVZHUWRSUDFWLFDOTXHVWLRQV6LQFHLWLV
QRWSRVVLEOHWRUHDFKLPPHGLDWHO\SUDFWLFDOFRQFOXVLRQVVLPSO\IURPWKHKLHUDUFK\
RIHQGVWKHVHDXWKRUVFRQVLGHUVXFKKLHUDUFK\WREHRWLRVHIRUPRUDOUHÀHFWLRQ  But  
WKHKLHUDUFK\RIHQGVLVRQO\WKHPDMRUSUHPLVHIRUDGGUHVVLQJVXFKTXHVWLRQVVLQFH
SUXGHQWLDONQRZOHGJHRIFLUFXPVWDQFHVJLIWVOLPLWDWLRQVDQGVRIRUWKLVDOZD\V
UHTXLUHG7KDWRQHFDQQRWGHGXFHIURPWKHVXSHULRULW\RIZLVGRPWROLIHZKHWKHUWR
FRQWHPSODWHRUREWDLQPHGLFLQHGRHVQRWDOWHUWKHSURSRVLWLRQWKDWZLVGRPLVDJRRG
QREOHUWKDQOLIHDQGWKDWDQ\UHDVRQDEOHPRUDOXQGHUVWDQGLQJVKRXOGDFNQRZOHGJH
WKLVQRUPDWLYHRUGHU²DQRUGHUZKLFKWDNHQWRJHWKHUZLWKSUXGHQWLDOVSHFL¿FDWLRQ
HQWDLOVSUDFWLFDOLPSOLFDWLRQV
7KHFRPSDVVGLUHFWLRQVZLOOQRWDQVZHUWKHTXHVWLRQRIZKHWKHURQHQHHGV
WRGHWRXURUQRWEXWWKHFRPSDVVGLUHFWLRQVGRREMHFWLYHO\PHDVXUHZKHWKHURQHLV
DSSURDFKLQJRUPRYLQJDZD\IURPWKHREMHFWLYH/LNHZLVHZLWKRXWWKHKLHUDUFK\
RIHQGVLWLVLPSRVVLEOHWRGHWHUPLQHZKHWKHURQHLVSURJUHVVLQJWRZDUGWKHJRRG
OLIHRUUHJUHVVLQJIURPLW
$OVRRQWKH11/7DFFRXQWZKDWFRQVWLWXWHV³DFWLQJDJDLQVWDJRRG´",VLW
RQO\DQDFWRIFRPPLVVLRQ",VDQ\OHDVWSRVLWLYHHQJDJHPHQWZLWKUHVSHFWWRDOOWKH
goods  required  ",IVRKRZFDQVXFKDSRVLWLYHminima  natura  EHGHWHUPLQHG",IRQH
PXVW³WRVRPHGHJUHH´DFWWRZDUGDOOWKHEDVLFJRRGVZKDWGHWHUPLQHVWKHUHTXLVLWH
³GHJUHH´",IWKHUHLVDZD\RIDVVLJQLQJWKLVZK\LVWKLVQRWLWVHOIDQLQVWDQFHRIWKH
SXWDWLYHO\LPSRVVLEOHFRPPHQVXUDWLRQ",IQRZD\H[LVWVWRGHWHUPLQHWKHUHTXLVLWH
GHJUHHRISRVLWLYHFRPPLWPHQWWKDWPXVWEHVKRZQHDFKRIWKHEDVLFJRRGVLQDFWLRQ
LVWKHPDWWHUWKHQZKROO\VXEMHFWLYH",QWKDWFDVHZK\FRXOGQRWVRPHRQHRQWKH
JURXQGRIWKH11/7VLPSO\SXUVXHWKHJRRGRISOD\EXWQHYHUWKHJRRGRIIULHQG-­
ship  or  religion?  
7KH 11/7 FODLPV WKDW WKHUH LV QR PRUDOO\ VLJQL¿FDQW RUGHU DPRQJ JRRGV
SULRUWRFKRLFH%XWLWVHHPVVLPSO\FRQWUDU\WRWKHWUXWKWRGHQ\WKDWHYHU\OLIH²LQ
DFFRUGZLWKLWVRZQXQLTXHJLIWVDQGFLUFXPVWDQFHV²PXVWQRQHWKHOHVVUHFRJQL]H
WKHSULPDF\RIWUXWKDQGZLVGRP*RRGVDUHQRWPRUDOO\LQFRPPHQVXUDEOHSULRUWR
FKRLFHEXWLIWKH\ZHUHDOOFRPPHQVXUDWLRQZRXOGEHDUELWUDU\2QVXFKDK\SRWKHVLV
LWZRXOGWKHQEHUHDVRQDEOHWRMXGJHZLVGRPDQGIULHQGVKLSWREHsolely  for  the  sake  
of  staying  alive  UDWKHUWKDQDVJRRGVVXSHURUGLQDWHWROLIH7KLVLVPDQLIHVWO\IDOVH
*RRGDFWLRQLVJRYHUQHGE\UHDVRQDQGULJKWDSSHWLWHERWKRIZKLFKDUHQRU-­
PDWLYHO\ VSHFL¿HG E\ WHOHRORJLFDO RUGHU 5DWKHU WKDQ XQGHUVWDQG WKH GLJQLW\ DQG
LPSRUWDQFH RI WKH RUGHU SURYLGHQWLDOO\ LPSUHVVHG RQ QDWXUH IURP WKH EHJLQQLQJ
WKH11/7WUHDWVUHDVRQDVLPSOLFLWO\constitutiveRIWKHJRRGUDWKHUWKDQDVPHUHO\
regulatory  RIWKHJRRGLQDFWLRQIRUWKHJRRGin  itself  LVSULRUWRRXUXVHRIUHDVRQ
DQGLQGHHGWKHUHDVRQIRURXUDFWLRQ

6HH5REHUW*HRUJH³5HFHQW&ULWLFLVPRI1DWXUDO/DZ7KHRU\´University  of  Chicago  



Law  Review$XWXPQ±

115
 THE  NATIONAL  CATHOLIC  BIOETHICS  QUARTERLY      SPRING  2013

$TXLQDVVD\VWKDWHYHU\FUHDWXUHSDVVLYHO\SDUWLFLSDWHVLQWKHHWHUQDOODZWKH
W\SHRULGHDRIWKHJRYHUQPHQWRIWKLQJVLQ*RGZKHUHE\LWUHFHLYHVLWVEHLQJQDWXUH
SRZHUVRUGHULQJRIWKHVHSRZHUVWRWKHHQGDQGHYHQWKHDFWLYDWLRQRIWKHVHSRZHUV
WRZDUGWKHHQGEXWWKDWPDQDOVRSDUWLFLSDWHVLQWKLVRUGHUUDWLRQDOO\DQGDFWLYHO\
7KHKXPDQFUHDWXUHDVUDWLRQDOLVFDSDEOHRIUHFHLYLQJWKHZKROHRUGHULQJRIQDWXUH
preceptivelyWKDWLVWRVD\as  articulating  reasons  to  act  and  reasons  not  to  act.  
This  preceptive  UDWLRQDOUHFHSWLRQRIWKHGLYLQHO\LPSUHVVHGRUGHULVZKDW$TXLQDV
calls  the  rational,  active  participation  in  the  eternal  law.  
$TXLQDVWHDFKHVWKDWQDWXUDOODZLVnothing  other  than  a  rational    participation  
in  the  eternal  law.  But  this  rational  participation  in  the  eternal  law  necessarily  pre-­
supposes  and  implies  the  prior  passive  participation  in  the  eternal  lawZKHUHE\
WKHFUHDWXUHSDVVLYHO\UHFHLYHVLWVEHLQJQDWXUHDQGQDWXUDORUGHULQJ)RU$TXLQDV
QDWXUDOODZLVQRWDGRFWULQHRIGLUHFWGLYLQHLOOXPLQDWLRQLVP²HYHQWKRXJKLWis  true  
WKDWWKHQDWXUDOODZLVWKHGLYLQHOLJKWDVKXPDQUHDVRQQDWXUDOO\SDUWLFLSDWHVLQLW
1RULVQDWXUDOODZDQDSULRULVWUXFWXUHRIKXPDQNQRZLQJ5DWKHUQDWXUDOODZLV
the  rational  preceptive  SDUWLFLSDWLRQRIWKHGLYLQHO\LPSUHVVHGRUGHULQJRIKXPDQ
QDWXUHZKLFKRUGHULQJDFFRUGLQJO\DQGDVUDWLRQDOO\UHFHLYHGLVPRUDOO\QRUPDWLYH
&RQWUDU\WRWKLVXQGHUVWDQGLQJIRUWKH11/7SDVVLYHSDUWLFLSDWLRQDSSHDUV
WREHWDNHQPHUHO\IRUDQHXWUDOSK\VLFDOSUHFRQGLWLRQRIQDWXUDOODZUDWKHUWKDQDV
SRVVHVVLQJDQ\PRUDOO\QRUPDWLYHIXQFWLRQ7KXVWKHRUGHUWRWKHHQGLVYLHZHGDV
DPHUH³SK\VLFDO´GDWXPJLYLQJQRPRUHWKDQDSK\VLFDOVSHFLHVRIDQDFWZKHUHDV
WKHPRUDOVSHFLHVLVXQGHUVWRRGDVFRQVHTXHQWRQDUHDVRQQRWnormed  by  teleologi-­
cal  order  but  replacing  or  substituting  for  teleological  order.    Teleological  order  is  
GRRPHGLQWKLVXQGHUVWDQGLQJWREHWDNHQIRUDPHUHO\ORZHUSK\VLFDOUHDOLW\VXEMHFW
WRDUHLQWHUSUHWDWLRQRIUHDVRQHPDQFLSDWHGIURPQDWXUDOWHOHRORJ\
,Q WKLV VSHFL¿F UHVSHFW WKH 11/7 LV SURIRXQGO\ VLPLODU WR WKH WHDFKLQJ RI
.DQW²DOWKRXJKLWFRQWDLQVPRUHQDWXUDOGHQVLW\LQDVPXFKDVWKHOLVWRIEDVLFJRRGV
SURYLGHVDWOHDVWVRPHQDWXUDOFRQWHQW1RQHWKHOHVVGHVSLWHWKLVJUHDWHUQDWXUDOGHQ-­
VLW\WKH³EDVLF´JRRGVDUHKHOGWREHVXEMHFWWRQRPRUDOO\VLJQL¿FDQWRUGHUSULRUWR
FKRLFH7KLVFOHDUO\LPSOLHVWKDWQHLWKHUWKHGLYLQHZLVGRPDVVRXUFHRIDOOPRUDOO\
VLJQL¿FDQWRUGHUQRUDQ\FRPPRQJRRGZKDWVRHYHULHQHLWKHU*RGDVH[WULQVLF
FRPPRQJRRGRIWKHXQLYHUVHQRUHYHQWKHFRPPRQJRRGRIMXVWLFHRUWUXWKLVPRU-­
DOO\VLJQL¿FDQWSULRUWRFKRLFH%XWsed  contraLWLVSUHFLVHO\WKHRUGHULQJRIKXPDQ
QDWXUHVRFLHW\DQGWKHXQLYHUVH²HYHQWKHRUGHUof  WKHXQLYHUVHWR*RG²WKDWLVRI
PRUDOVLJQL¿FDQFHLQQRUPLQJPRUDOFKRLFH
7KLVLVRIJUHDWLPSRUWDQFHIRUPDQ\UHDVRQV)LUVWDQGPRVWSURPLQHQWO\LW
LVLPSRUWDQWEHFDXVHLWGRRPVWKH11/7WRSURYLGHDQDO\VHVRIPRUDOJRRGVWKDW
DUHVRLQIHFWHGZLWKWKHPRGHUQDQGSRVWPRGHUQUHMHFWLRQRIQDWXUDOWHOHRORJ\DVWR
EHLQFDSDEOHRISURYLGLQJDQLQWHJUDOO\&DWKROLFDFFRXQWRIPRUDOOLIH6HFRQGLWLV
LPSRUWDQWEHFDXVHLWFRQWULEXWHVWRWKHORVVRIQDWXUHLQWKHDFFRXQWRIQDWXUDOODZ
LQDOOLWVGHSDUWPHQWVLQFOXGLQJWKHDQDO\VLVRIKXPDQPRUDODFWLRQ
7KHORVVRIPRUDOO\VLJQL¿FDQWWHOHRORJLFDORUGHUSULRUWRDQGJRYHUQLQJFKRLFH
LPSRVHVJUHDWEXUGHQVRQWKH11/7HVSHFLDOO\LQFRSLQJZLWKTXHVWLRQVRIVRFLDO
DQGSROLWLFDORUGHULQWKHPVHOYHVDQGLQUHODWLRQWRGLYLQHUHYHODWLRQ7KHRUGHURI
ORZHUJRRGVWRKLJKHUJRRGVLVDQHFHVVDU\IHDWXUHRIPRUDODQGSROLWLFDOOLIHDQGWKH


 LONG      FUNDAMENTAL  ERRORS  OF  THE  NNLT

UHDVRQZK\WKHSROLWLFDOFRPPRQJRRGFDQQRWDGPLWRIWKHVXSSUHVVLRQRIUHOLJLRXV
WUXWK7KH11/7DFFRXQWRILQFRPPHQVXUDELOLW\ZRXOGRILWVHOIGRRPWKHWKHRU\WR
DQH[WUHPHO\VWULFWGHRQWRORJ\)RUWKLVUHDVRQWKH11/7KDVGHYHORSHGDQDFFRXQW
RIWKHREMHFWRIPRUDODFWLRQDQGLQWHQWLRQZKLFKHQDEOHVWKHWKHRU\WRHVFDSHIURP
WKHOLPLWDWLRQVRILWVGRFWULQHRILQFRPPHQVXUDELOLW\ZKLOHOLEHUDOO\PDNLQJXVHRIWKH
DUJXPHQWWKDWQDWXUDOWHOHRORJ\LVPHUHO\DQGUHGXFWLYHO\SK\VLFDOUDWKHUWKDQPRUDO
7KH QHJDWLRQ RI XQL¿HG QRUPDWLYH QDWXUDO WHOHRORJ\ DV PRUDOO\ VLJQL¿FDQW
SULRUWRFKRLFHLPSOLHVDWOHDVWWZRIXUWKHUHQRUPLWLHVDVDOUHDG\VXJJHVWHGDERYH
the  loss  of  the  transcendence  of  the  common  good    and  the  loss  of  the  theocentric  
and  theonomic  character  of  natural  law.
Negation  of  the  Transcendence  of  the  Common  Good  
,WLVZLWKRXWGRXEWWKHVWURQJWHQGHQF\LIQRWWKHFRPSOHWHO\VHWWOHGWHDFKLQJ
RIWKH11/7WRWUHDWWKHFRPPRQJRRGDVSXUHO\DQLQVWUXPHQWDOJRRG,WLVGLI-­
¿FXOWWRVHHKRZLWFRXOGEHRWKHUZLVHJLYHQWKHGRFWULQHRILQFRPPHQVXUDELOLW\
XQOHVVLWZHUHKHOGWKDWWKHFRPPRQJRRGKDGQRPRUDOVLJQL¿FDQFHSULRUWRFKRLFH
despite  LWVREMHFWLYHO\JUHDWHUQRELOLW\ZKLFKPDNHVQRVHQVHZKDWVRHYHUVLQFHWKDW
ZKLFKLVREMHFWLYHO\PRUHQREOHLVMXVWVRIDUPRUHDQHQGDQGVRPRUHJRYHUQLQJ
PRUHUHJXODWLYHZLWKUHVSHFWWRWKHJRRGOLIH
&HUWDLQO\HYHQDSDUWIURPWKHH[SUHVVWHDFKLQJRILQFRPPHQVXUDELOLW\WKH
GHQLDORIWKHWUDQVFHQGHQFHRIWKHFRPPRQJRRGLVDWHDFKLQJWKDWPD\EHLQIHUUHG
IURPJHQHUDO11/7DQDO\VLVRIPRUDOTXHVWLRQVHJIURPWKHDQDO\VLVRIWKHGHDWK
SHQDOW\RUMXVWZDU%XWPDQLIHVWO\IURPWKHGRFWULQHRIWKH³LQFRPPHQVXUDELOLW\´
RIJRRGVLWLVLPSRVVLEOHWKDWSULRUWRFKRLFHDJRRGEHPRUDOO\FRQVWLWXWHGDVVXSHU-­
RUGLQDWHPXFKOHVVDVWUDQVFHQGHQW7KLVRIFRXUVHKDVWKHGUDVWLFHIIHFWRILPSO\LQJ
WKDW*RGDVWKHH[WULQVLFFRPPRQJRRGRIWKHXQLYHUVHDQGDVWKHFRPPRQJRRG
RIDOORUGDLQHGLQJUDFHWRWKHEHDWL¿FYLVLRQLVQRWRIVXSHURUGLQDWHPRUDOLPSRUW
SULRUWRFKRLFHQRUWUDQVFHQGHQWRIPHUHO\SULYDWHJRRG
:KLOHWKHZULWLQJVRI11/7DXWKRUVVHHPWRDI¿UPWKDWWKHFRPPRQJRRG
LVPHUHO\LQVWUXPHQWDOVXFKDYLHZDOVRVHHPVWREHQHFHVVLWDWHGE\SLYRWDOPRUDO
WHDFKLQJVRIWKH11/77KXVIRUH[DPSOHWKHGHDWKSHQDOW\LVRSSRVHGRQSULQFLSOHG


,DPLQGHEWHGWRWKHZRUNRI&KDUOHVGH.RQLQFNZKRVHThe  Primacy  of  the  Common  
Good  against  the  Personalists  and  In  Defense  of  St.  ThomasFRQVWLWXWHWKHPRVWPDVWHUIXO
WUHDWPHQWRIWKHFRPPRQJRRGLQWKHFRPPHQWDWRULDOWUDGLWLRQ6HHThe  Writings  of  Charles  
de  KoninckYROHG5DOSK0F,QHUQ\8QLYHUVLW\RI1RWUH'DPH3UHVV

)RUH[DPSOHVHH)LQQLVAquinas,  ³7KHWKRXJKWWKDWZHFDQQRWOLYHUHDVRQDEO\
DQG ZHOO DSDUW IURP D civitas   LV FRQVLVWHQW ZLWK WKH SURSRVLWLRQ WKDW WKH FRPPRQ JRRG
VSHFL¿FWRWKHcivitas  DVVXFK²WKHSXEOLFJRRG²LVQRWEDVLFEXWUDWKHULQVWUXPHQWDOWR
VHFXULQJKXPDQJRRGVZKLFKDUHEDVLFLQFOXGLQJRWKHUIRUPVRIFRPPXQLW\RUDVVRFLDWLRQ
HVSHFLDOO\GRPHVWLFDQGUHOLJLRXVDVVRFLDWLRQVDQGQRQHRIZKLFKLVLQLWVHOIVSHFL¿FDOO\
SROLWLFDOLHFRQFHUQHGZLWKWKHVWDWH,IWKDWSURSRVLWLRQQHHGVTXDOL¿FDWLRQWKHTXDOL¿FDWLRQ
FRQFHUQVWKHUHVWRUDWLRQRIMXVWLFHE\WKHLUUHSDUDEOHPRGHVRISXQLVKPHQWUHVHUYHGWRWKH
VWDWHJRYHUQPHQW´7RWKHEHVWRIP\NQRZOHGJH11/7DXWKRUVKDYHQRWDFNQRZOHGJHGWKH
WUDQVFHQGHQFHRIWKHFRPPRQJRRGDQDORJLFDOO\VSHDNLQJLQFOXGLQJWKHFRPPRQJRRGRI
FLYLOVRFLHW\


 THE  NATIONAL  CATHOLIC  BIOETHICS  QUARTERLY      SPRING  2013

JURXQGVWKDWVHHPWRLPSO\WKDWLWLVDmalum  in  seDQHYLOLQLWVHOI  30  despite  the  

WUXWKWKDWWKHUDWLRQDOMXVWL¿FDWLRQIRUWKHGHDWKSHQDOW\KDVEHHQHPEUDFHGE\DOO
WKHIDWKHUVDQGGRFWRUVRIWKH&KXUFKRWKHUWKDQ7HUWXOOLDQZKRGLHGRXWVLGHWKH
&KXUFK(YHQWKHUHVHUYDWLRQVRI/DFWDQWLXVSHUWDLQQRWVRPXFKWRWKHSHQDOW\LQ
LWVHOIEXWWRKLVGLVWUXVWRIVHFXODUFRXUWVDQGKLVREMHFWLRQWR&KULVWLDQVVHHNLQJWR
DGGUHVVHYLOVE\UHFRXUVHWRWKHP$XJXVWLQH¶VWHDFKLQJLVFOHDU31  Nor  does  Evan-­
gelium  vitae  RUDQ\RWKHUIRQWRIDXWKRULWDWLYHPDJLVWHULDOWHDFKLQJFRQIRUPWRWKH
NNLT  insistence  that  the  death  penalty  is  a  malum  in  se.  
$V $TXLQDV SXWV LW WKH MXGJH SUHIHUV WKH JRRG RI MXVWLFH WR WKH OLIH RI WKH
LQGLYLGXDOEHDULQJWKHLQGLYLGXDOQRPDOLFH321RUGRHV$TXLQDV¶VUHIHUHQFHWRWKH
FULPLQDOGHVFHQGLQJWRWKHOHYHORIWKHEHDVWVLQDFWLRQLPSO\GHQLDORIVXEVWDQWLYH
KXPDQGLJQLW\DVLWSHUWDLQVWRDFTXLUHGGLJQLW\337KHJURXQGRIWKHSHUPLVVLELOLW\
RIVWDWHLPSRVHGSHQDOW\DVVXFKLVWKHWUDQVFHQGHQFHRIWKHFRPPRQJRRG²QRW
PHUHO\DVDTXDQWLWDWLYHO\JUHDWHUJRRGEXWDJRRGPRUHFRPPXQLFDEOHWRPDQ\
PRUHLQWHOOLJLEO\LUUDGLDQWDQGPRUHXQLYHUVDO7KHUHIHUHQFHWRWKHGHIHFWRIWKH
FULPLQDOZLWKUHVSHFWWRDFTXLUHGGLJQLW\JRHVWRWKHapplicabilityRISHQDOW\,QDV-­
PXFKDVLQGLYLGXDOVSUHVHUYHWKHLUDFTXLUHGGLJQLW\WKDWLVWKH\GRQRJUDYHZURQJ
LWLVXQUHDVRQDEOHWRVOD\WKHPRULPSRVHDQ\RWKHUSHQDOW\RQWKHPIRUWKDWPDWWHU
EXWJLYHQWKHSHUIRUPDQFHRIJUDYHHYLOWKHLPSRVLQJRIDSHQDOW\RIGHDWKRUIRU
WKDWPDWWHURWKHUJUDYHSHQDOWLHVPD\EHMXVWL¿HGRZLQJWRWKHQHHGWRSXQLVKJUDYH
wrongdoing.  
,WLVSUHFLVHO\WKHVXEVWDQWLYHGLJQLW\RIWKHYHU\SHUVRQZKRJUDYHO\KDUPV
KLVDFTXLUHGGLJQLW\E\YLFLRXVFRQGXFWWKDWUHQGHUVKLPVXEMHFWWRMXGJPHQWDQG
SXQLVKPHQWDQRQUDWLRQDODJHQWFDQPHULWSXQLVKPHQWRQO\HTXLYRFDOO\2IFRXUVH
VXFKDSHQDOW\LVDPDWWHURISUXGHQFHDQGLWPD\EHLPSUXGHQWWRKDYHUHFRXUVHWR
VXFKSXQLVKPHQW%XWWKHUHLVQRIRXQGDWLRQHLWKHULQWKHWHDFKLQJRIWKH&KXUFK
IDWKHUVDQGGRFWRUVRULQ6DFUHG6FULSWXUHIRUWKHFODLPWKDWWKHGHDWKSHQDOW\LV
LQWULQVLFDOO\LPPRUDO
)RUWKHIDWKHUVDQGGRFWRUVRIWKH&KXUFK²LQFOXGLQJFRQVSLFXRXVO\$XJXV-­
WLQHDQG$TXLQDV²WKHFRPPRQJRRGRIMXVWLFHLQVRFLHW\WUDQVFHQGVWKHJRRGRI

30  
)LQQLVUHIHUVWRWKHLQWHQWLRQDOH[HFXWLRQRIJXLOW\IHORQVLQMXVWSXQLVKPHQWDVDQ
³LQKHUHQWO\LPPRUDOPHDQV´Aquinas  
31  
)RU6W$XJXVWLQHVHHThe  City  of  God
32  
ST,,,,TDDG
33  
,ELG  TDDG

:KDWSHQDOWLHVDUHUHDVRQDEOHDWDJLYHQWLPHLQDVRFLHW\LVDIXQFWLRQRISUXGHQFH
7KHSULQFLSOHGMXVWL¿FDWLRQRIWKHGHDWKSHQDOW\LQ&DWKROLFWUDGLWLRQGRHVQRWLPSO\WKDW
HYHU\VRFLHW\PXVWRUVKRXOGLPSRVHLWQRUWKDWFLUFXPVWDQFHVFDQQRWEHVXFKDVWRUHQGHULW
FRXQWHUSURGXFWLYHRUKDUPIXO%XWWKH5RPDQ&DWKROLFPRUDOWUDGLWLRQRIFHQWXULHVWKHFOHDU
FRQVHQVXVRIWKH)DWKHUVDQG'RFWRUVRIWKH&KXUFKXQLIRUPFDWHFKHVLVRYHUFHQWXULHVDQG
XQHTXLYRFDOSURQRXQFHPHQWVVXFKDV3RSH3LXV;,,¶VWHDFKLQJRIWKHHVVHQWLDOYDOLGLW\RI
the  penalty  (see  Acta  Apostolicae  Sedis  >@±UHFRXQWLQJWKLVWHDFKLQJRI3RSH3LXV
;,,DOOLQGLFDWHLWVSULQFLSOHGOHJLWLPDF\2QHREVHUYHVWKHKLJKWKHRORJLFDOQRWHUHSUHVHQWHG
E\WKHUHTXLUHPHQWRIDQDFNQRZOHGJPHQWRIWKHYDOLGLW\RIWKHGHDWKSHQDOW\LQRUGHUIRU
WKH:DOGHQVLDQVWRUHHVWDEOLVKHFFOHVLDOFRPPXQLRQDenzingerQ

 LONG      FUNDAMENTAL  ERRORS  OF  THE  NNLT

WKHOLIHRIWKHLQGLYLGXDO&OHDUO\IRU$TXLQDVWKHOLIHRIWKHLQGLYLGXDOLVRUGHUHGWR
WKHFRPPRQJRRGZKLFKLVXQGHUVWRRGQRWPHUHO\DVDTXDQWLWDWLYHO\JUHDWHUJRRG
EXWDVDPRUHIRUPDODQGVXSHURUGLQDWHJRRG357KHFRPPRQJRRGLVDJRRGWKDW
LVRQHLQQXPEHUDQGWKDWLVE\LWVQDWXUHPRUHFRPPXQLFDEOHWRPDQ\PRUHLQWHO-­
OLJLEO\LUUDGLDQWDQGFDXVDOO\GLIIXVLYH,WLVJRRGfor  WKHLQGLYLGXDOZLWKRXWEHLQJ
PHUHO\DQLQGLYLGXDOJRRG8QOLNHSULYDWHJRRGVZKLFKLIRQHKDVDQRWKHUGRHV
QRWWKHFRPPRQJRRGLVPRUHGLIIXVLYH-XVWLFHLVJRRGIRUWKHLQGLYLGXDOEXWLWLV
QRWPHUHO\DQ\LQGLYLGXDO¶VJRRG7UXWKPD\EHSRVVHVVHGE\PDQ\ZLWKRXWGLPLQX-­
WLRQOLNHZLVHLIRQHGRHVMXVWLFHWRRQHSHUVRQRQHLVQRWUHTXLUHGWRGRLQMXVWLFH
WRDQRWKHUZKHUHDVLQWKHGLVWULEXWLRQRI¿[HGPDWHULDOJRRGVWRJLYHPRUHWRRQH
LVWRJLYHOHVVWRDQRWKHU
:KLOHIRUHFRQRPLFSXUSRVHVLWLVFRPSOHWHO\OLFLWWRWKLQNLQWHUPVRIFRP-­
PRQXWLOLWLHV²PXFKHFRQRPLFDQDO\VLVWKDWLVKHOSIXOIRUWKHFRPPRQRUGHULQJRI
VRFLDODIIDLUVSURFHHGVLQWKLVZD\²QRQHWKHOHVVQRRQHUHDVRQDEO\VDFUL¿FHVKLVOLIH
IRUDFRPPRQXWLOLW\%\FRQWUDVWWKHFRPPRQJRRGXQGHUVWRRGDVDJRRGRUHQG
PRUHFRPPXQLFDEOHWRPDQ\E\LWVQDWXUHDQGDVWUDQVFHQGLQJSULYDWHRULQGLYLGXDO
JRRGLVDQREOHHQGRIRXUODERUVWULYLQJDQGVDFUL¿FH7KHSKLORVRSKLFDQDO\VLVRI
WKHFRPPRQJRRGFRQVLGHUVQRWPHUHO\HFRQRPLFFRPPRQXWLOLWLHVEXWJRRGVWKDW
E\WKHLUYHU\FKDUDFWHUDUHPRUHUDWLRQDOO\GLIIXVLYHVXFKDVWREHSHUIHFWLYHof  and  
for  WKHLQGLYLGXDOZLWKRXWWKHUHE\EHFRPLQJLQGLYLGXDORUSULYDWHJRRGV7KHVHDUH
JRRGVVXFKDVWUXWKDQGMXVWLFHRU*RGDVH[WULQVLFFRPPRQJRRGRIWKHXQLYHUVH
RUWKHFRPPRQJRRGRIWKH&KXUFKRUWKHFRPPRQJRRGRIWKH+HDYHQO\&LW\LQ
supernatural  beatitude.  
%\DQDORJ\RIDWWULEXWLRQZHFRPHWRVSHDNRIWKHVRFLDODUUDQJHPHQWVZLWKLQ
DQ\VRFLHW\IRUWKHVDNHRIVXFKFRPPRQJRRGVDV³WKHFRPPRQJRRGRIVRFLHW\´²
PXFKDVZHFDOOWKHFRXUWVWKHSROLFHWKHSULVRQVDQGVRIRUWK³WKHMXVWLFHV\VWHP´
DOOWKHZKLOHUHDOL]LQJWKDWWKHUHDUHGHIDFWRLPSHUIHFWLRQVDQGIDLOLQJVLQFRPSDWLEOH
ZLWKMXVWLFHLQWKLVV\VWHP%XWLQWKHDEVHQFHRIDUHDOLVWLFVHQVHRIWKHFRPPRQ
JRRGDVQRWPHUHO\DTXDQWLWDWLYHFRPPRQDOLW\EXWDVDQHQGE\QDWXUHPRUHFRP-­
PXQLFDEOHWRPDQ\PRUHXQLYHUVDODQGPRUHLUUDGLDQWLQJRRGWKHPRUDOVXSHURU-­
GLQDF\RIWKHFRPPRQJRRGLVORVW(SLVRGHVVXFKDV²ZKHUHZKHQHYHU\RQH
else  descendedIURPDQGfled  WKHEXUQLQJEXLOGLQJVFRXUDJHRXV¿UH¿JKWHUVascended  
WRVHUYHWKHFRPPRQJRRG²FDQQRWEHSURSHUO\XQGHUVWRRGZLWKRXWIDWKRPLQJWKH
WUDQVFHQGHQFHRIWKHFRPPRQJRRG
7KHIDLOXUHWRDI¿UPWKHWUDQVFHQGHQFHRIWKHFRPPRQJRRGDOVRGHOHWHULRXVO\
DIIHFWVWKH11/7XQGHUVWDQGLQJRIWKHUHODWLRQEHWZHHQGLYLQHUHYHODWLRQDQGWKH
political  order.  Because  political  society  is  further,  if  remotely,  ordered  WRWKHXOWLPDWH
JRRGRISHUVRQV²LILWLVQRWVRRUGHUHGLWLVQRWgood²DQ\DWWHPSWRIWKHSROLWLFDO

ST,,,,TDDG³DGWHUWLXPGLFHQGXPTXRGERQXPFRPPXQHSRWLXVHVW
35  

ERQRSULYDWRVLVLWHMXVGHPJHQHULV´²³7KHFRPPRQJRRGWDNHSUHFHGHQFHRIWKHSULYDWH
JRRGLILWEHRIWKHVDPHJHQXV´6HHDOVRTDDGZKLFKPDNHVFOHDUWKDWWKHGLIIHUHQFH
EHWZHHQLQGLYLGXDODQGFRPPRQJRRGLVVRPHWKLQJIRUPDO³7KHFRPPRQJRRGRIWKHUHDOP
DQGWKHSDUWLFXODUJRRGRIWKHLQGLYLGXDOGLIIHUQRWRQO\LQUHVSHFWRIWKHmany  and  the  few
EXWDOVRXQGHUDIRUPDODVSHFW´

 THE  NATIONAL  CATHOLIC  BIOETHICS  QUARTERLY      SPRING  2013

VWDWHWRVXSSUHVVWKHOLEHUW\RISHUVRQVWRGLVFRYHUGLYLQHWUXWKRUWRVXSSUHVVWKH
OLYLQJRIVXFKWUXWKFORVHVWKHSROLWLFDORUGHURIIIURPORIWLHUFRPPRQJRRGVWRZKLFK
LWLVUHDOO\RUGHUHG-XVWLQVRIDUDVWKHSROLWLFDOVWDWHVHHNVWRGLVVHYHUVRFLHW\IURP
KLJKHUJRRGVWRZKLFKLWLVJHQXLQHO\RUGHUHGWKHVWDWHUHQGHUVLWVHOIQRORQJHUWR
FRQVWLWXWHDQDXWKHQWLFFRPPRQJRRGmala  lex  nulla  lex7KXVWKHSROLWLFDOVWDWHLV
OLPLWHGQRWRQO\IURPEHORZE\WKHYLEUDQF\RISULYDWHJRRGVEXWIURPDERYHE\WKH
WUDQVFHQGHQFHRIORIWLHUFRPPRQJRRGVERWKQDWXUDODQGVXSHUQDWXUDO
+DPSHUHGE\WKHDEQHJDWLRQRIWKHKLJKHUVSHFXODWLYHWUXWKVIRUSUDFWLFDOOLIH
DQGRIDQ\DZDUHQHVVRIWKHQRUPDWLYLW\RIWHOHRORJ\ZKHWKHULQQDWXUHRUJUDFHWKH
11/7DXWKRUVVHHPWRGHQ\WKHWUDQVFHQGHQFHRIWKHFRPPRQJRRGDQGDWOHDVWWR
WHQGWRZDUGDQLQVWUXPHQWDOLVWDFFRXQW7KLVVWURQJO\GLVUXSWVWKHPRUDOXQGHUVWDQG-­
LQJRIVRFLDOSROLWLFDODQGOHJDORUGHUZKLOHLWDOVRFRQWULEXWHVDORQJVLGHWKHRWKHU
DIRUHPHQWRQHGHUURUVWRWKHORVVRIWKHWKHRFHQWULFLW\DQGWKHRQRPLFFKDUDFWHURI
WKHGRFWULQHRIQDWXUDOODZ
Negation  of  the  Essentially  Theonomic  Character  of  Natural  Law
,IVSHFXODWLYHWUXWKLVQRWXQGHUVWRRGWREHSULRUWRDQGSUHVXSSRVHGE\WKH
SUDFWLFDODVVXFKLIQDWXUDOWHOHRORJLFDORUGHULVQRWQRUPDWLYHIRURXUPRUDOMXGJPHQW
LIWKHUHLVQRWWKHQDQorder  RIFRPPRQJRRGVUHDFKLQJHYHQWR*RGDVWKHH[WULQVLF
FRPPRQJRRGRIWKHXQLYHUVHWKHQLWZLOOEHGLI¿FXOWWRUHWDLQZKDWIRU$TXLQDVLV
DEVROXWHO\HVVHQWLDOWRWKHQDWXUDOODZQDPHO\LWVWKHRFHQWULFDQGWKHRQRPLFFKDUDFWHU
%HFDXVH*RGLVWKH¿UVWHI¿FLHQWFDXVHDQGLVDOVRWKHODVW¿QDOFDXVHWKDWLV
WKH¿QDOHQGRIWKHXQLYHUVHLWIROORZVWKDWWRGHQ\WKDWWHOHRORJLFDORUGHULVPRUDOO\
VLJQL¿FDQWSULRUWRFKRLFHLVWRGHQ\WKDWWKHGLYLQHZLVGRPLVPRUDOO\QRUPDWLYH
IRUPDQSULRUWRFKRLFH7KLVLQLWVHOILVLQFRPSDWLEOHZLWKWKH&DWKROLFWUDGLWLRQRI
PRUDOWKHRORJ\,QDQ\FDVHWKHWKHRQRPLFFKDUDFWHURIQDWXUDOODZLVUHÀHFWHG
IRU$TXLQDVLQWKHYHU\GH¿QLWLRQKHSURIIHUVIRUWKHQDWXUDOODZDV³QRWKLQJRWKHU
WKDQWKHUDWLRQDOSDUWLFLSDWLRQRIHWHUQDOODZ´$WKLQJ¶VGH¿QLWLRQLVQRWRQHZRXOG
WKLQNDFFLGHQWDOWRLW$QGFRQWUDU\WRWKHYLHZVRIWKRVHIRUZKRPQDWXUDOODZLV
DSXUHSUD[LRORJ\JHQHUDWLQJULJKWDQDO\VLVRISDUWLFXODUPRUDOTXHVWLRQVIRU$TXL-­
nas  it  is  the  preconditionIRUULJKWH[HUFLVHRISUDFWLFDOUHDVRQ,WLVWKHQRUPDWLYH
WKHRORJLFDODQGPHWDSK\VLFDORUGHUWKDWXQGHUJLUGVPDNHVSRVVLEOHDQGÀRZVLQWR
RXUPRUDOORJLF2QWKLVROGHU7KRPLVWLFYLHZRXUSUDFWLFDOUHDVRQLQJLVHSLVWHPL-­
FDOO\DQGRQWRORJLFDOO\GHULYHGIURPWKHQDWXUDOODZ,WLVGHULYDWLYHRIWKHODUJHU
FRVPLFVWRU\UDWKHUWKDQVXSSODQWLQJLW:KLOHWKURXJKRXUSUDFWLFDOPRUDOUHDVRQ
ZHDFWLYHO\SDUWLFLSDWHLQWKHGLYLQHJRYHUQPHQWRIRXURZQDFWLRQVWKHSUHFRQGL-­
WLRQIRUWKLVDFWLYHSDUWLFLSDWLRQLVWKHPLQG¶VSULRUadequatioRUFRQIRUPLW\WRWKH
ULJKWHQG)RULWLVNQRZOHGJHRIWKHHQGZKLFKLVWKHURRWRIULJKWDSSHWLWHDQGDOO
SUDFWLFDOPRUDOMXGJPHQWPXVWEHFRQIRUPHGWRULJKWDSSHWLWH$V$TXLQDVZULWHV
LQTXHVWLRQRIWKHPrima  secundaeRIWKHSumma  theologiae³1RZLQUHJDUGWR
WKHPHDQVWKHUHFWLWXGHRIWKHUHDVRQGHSHQGVRQLWVFRQIRUPLW\ZLWKWKHGHVLUHRI
DGXHHQGnevertheless  the  very  desire  of  the  due  end  presupposes  on  the  part  of  
reason  a  right  apprehension  of  the  end´

ST,,,TDDG³,QKLVDXWHPTXDHVXQWDG¿QHPUHFWLWXGRUDWLRQLVFRQVLVWLW


LQFRQIRUPLWDWHDGDSSHWLWXP¿QLVGHELWL6HGWDPHQHWLSVHDSSHWLWXV¿QLVGHELWLSUDHVXSSRQLW
120
 LONG      FUNDAMENTAL  ERRORS  OF  THE  NNLT

,W LV WKH GLYLQH ZLVGRP WKDW LPSUHVVHV WKH QRUPDWLYH WHOHRORJLFDO RUGHU RQ
FUHDWLRQDQGLWLVWKHIXQFWLRQRIRXUUHDVRQWRDSSUHKHQGWKLVRUGHUVRWKDWLWPD\
QRUPRXUDFWLRQDSSURSULDWHO\%HFDXVHODZSURFHHGVIURPWKHPLQGRIWKHOHJLVODWRU
WRWKHPLQGRIWKHUHFLSLHQWWKLVGLYLQHO\LPSUHVVHGRUGHULQJLVQRWSURSHUO\³ODZ´
VDYHLQVRIDUDVLWLVUDWLRQDOO\UHFHLYHGDVDUWLFXODWLQJUHDVRQVIRUDFWLRQ%XWLWLVWKH
YHU\VDPHSDVVLYHO\SDUWLFLSDWHGRUGHUWKDWZKHQUHFHLYHGUDWLRQDOO\LVWKHQDWXUDO
ODZ-XVWDVWKHRUGHULQJRIWKHLQNLQDERRNGRHVQRWIXQFWLRQDVLWLVGHVLJQHGWRGR
VDYHLQVRIDUDVLWLVUHDGVRWKHRUGHULQWKHFRVPRVDQGLQSDUWLFXODULQKXPDQQDWXUH
LVRUGHUHGWREHUHFHLYHGE\PDQQRWRQO\de  facto  DQGRQWRORJLFDOO\EXWrationally  
DQGDVSURYLGLQJWKHQRUPDWLYHJURXQGRIFRQGXFW
+DYLQJEURNHQWKHUHODWLRQEHWZHHQVSHFXODWLYHDQGSUDFWLFDOEHWZHHQWHOHR-­
ORJLFDORUGHUDQGUDWLRQDOSUHFHSWWKH11/7LVPRUHRUOHVVIRUFHGWRWKHFRQFOXVLRQ
KHOGVRSODLQVSRNHQO\E\-RKQ)LQQLV³WKDWQDWXUDOODZFDQEHXQGHUVWRRGDVVHQWHG
WRDSSOLHGDQGUHÀHFWLYHO\DQDO\VHGZLWKRXWDGYHUWLQJWRWKHTXHVWLRQRIWKHH[LV-­
WHQFHRI*RG´  
7KLVLVZURQJIRUVHYHUDOUHDVRQV)LUVWEHFDXVHWKHUHDUHQDWXUDOPRUDOREOL-­
JDWLRQV WR *RG ZKLFK ELQG XQGHU QDWXUDO ODZ DQG ZKLFK DFFRUGLQJO\ FDQQRW EH
³XQGHUVWRRGDVVHQWHGWRDSSOLHGRUUHÀHFWLYHO\DQDO\]HGZLWKRXWDGYHUWLQJWRWKH
TXHVWLRQRIWKHH[LVWHQFHRI*RG´7KH¿GHLVWWHQGHQF\RIWKH11/7FRQVHTXHQWRQ
WKHORVVRIWKHWKHRFHQWULFLW\RIQDWXUDOODZGRFWULQHLVKHUHRQSURPLQHQWGLVSOD\
)RU$TXLQDVWKHGXW\RIUHOLJLRQLVFRPSULVHGXQGHUWKHYLUWXHRIMXVWLFH  since  
RQHRZHV*RGSXEOLFDQGSULYDWHZRUVKLSWKDQNVDQGKRQRUDVWKHLQ¿QLWHO\JRRG
VRXUFHRIHYHU\¿QLWHJRRG%XWWKLVPHDQVSUHFLVHO\WKDWQDWXUDOODZGRFWULQHPXVW
DGYHUWWRWKHH[LVWHQFHRI*RGDVDVLPSOHPDWWHURIMXVWLFHVLQFHLIWKHUHLVDQLQ¿-­
QLWHO\JRRG)LUVW&DXVHWKHQLWZRXOGEHXQMXVWQRWWRRIIHUWKDQNVWRWKH&DXVHRI
DOOJRRGWKLQJVDQGLIWKHUHLVQRWVXFKDFDXVHLWZRXOGEHGHOXVLYHWRRIIHUVXFK
WKDQNVDQGXQMXVWWRH[SHFWRWKHUVWRGRVR
6HFRQGWKHYHU\form  RIQDWXUDOODZLV“nothing  other  than  a  rational  par-­
ticipation  of  the  eternal  law´7KLVFOHDUO\LPSOLHVWKDWwere  there  no  eternal  law,  
there  would  be  no  natural  law7KHUHDVRQLVFOHDUQDPHO\WKDWWKHQRUPDWLYLW\RI
QDWXUDOWHOHRORJLFDORUGHULVDIXQFWLRQRILWVLPSUHVVE\GLYLQHZLVGRPVXFKWKDW
WKLVRUGHUFRPSULVHVJHQXLQHlawSURFHHGLQJIURPWKHPLQGRIWKHOHJLVODWRUWRWKH
PLQGRIWKHUHFLSLHQW$V<YHV6LPRQVXJJHVWHGWKHODVWZRUGLQQDWXUDOODZLVQRW
PHUHIDFWLFLW\EXWWKHPLQGRIWKHODZJLYHU,QGHHGWKHSURSHUVHQVHRIODZUHTXLUHV
DQGLPSOLHVSURPXOJDWLRQE\WKHODZJLYHU
2IFRXUVHWKLVdoes  not  mean  WKDWRQHPXVWEHDZDUHRIWKHUHDOLW\RI*RGWR
KDYHany  minimal  degree  of  knowledge  of  the  natural  law  whatsoever.  The  proposi-­

UHFWDPDSSUHKHQVLRQHPGH¿QHTXDHHVWSHUUDWLRQHP´HPSKDVLVDGGHG

-RKQ)LQQLVNatural  Law  and  Natural  Right  2[IRUG

ST,,,,TD

,ELG,,,TDUWUHVSDQGDG

<YHV6LPRQThe  Tradition  of  Natural  Law:  A  Philosopher’s  ReflectionsHG9XNDQ
.XLF1HZ<RUN)RUGKDP8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV±7KLVLVRQHRIWKHJUHDWHVWDQG
PRVWOXFLGVKRUWZRUNVRQWKHQDWXUDOODZHYHUZULWWHQ
121
 THE  NATIONAL  CATHOLIC  BIOETHICS  QUARTERLY      SPRING  2013

WLRQLVQRWHSLVWHPLF5DWKHUWKHSURSRVLWLRQUHIHUVWRWKHbeing  and  nature  of  the  

law  ²WKDWLVDOWKRXJKRQHPD\NQRZDVSHFWVRIQDWXUDOODZEHIRUHUHDOL]LQJWKDW
QDWXUDOODZLPSOLHVDQGSUHVXSSRVHVWKHUHDOLW\RIWKHHWHUQDOODZWKLVODZas  such  
LVQRW¿QDOO\LQWHOOLJLEOH  HLWKHUIRUPDOO\DVODZRULQLWVEHLQJRUHYHQLQLWVIXOO
FRQWHQWDSDUWIURPWKHUHDOLW\RI*RG,WLVQRWLQWHOOLJLEOHqua  ODZDSDUWIURP*RG
EHFDXVHDODZSURFHHGVIURPDPLQGWRDPLQGDQGLVQRWPHUHO\DGHVFULSWLYHEXW
DSUHVFULSWLYHSURSRVLWLRQ7KHXQL¿HGQRUPDWLYHWHOHRORJ\LPSUHVVHGE\*RGRQ
FUHDWLRQLVQRUPDWLYHSUHFLVHO\qua  SDUWLFLSDWLRQRIWKHXQFUHDWHGGLYLQHZLVGRP,W
LVQRWLQWHOOLJLEOHLQLWVEHLQJDSDUWIURP*RGEHFDXVHQRWKLQJFDQEHZKROO\DSDUW
IURPGLYLQHFDXVDOLW\DQGDUDWLRQDOSDUWLFLSDWLRQof  nothing  LVQRWQDWXUDOODZ,W
LVQRWLQWHOOLJLEOHHYHQLQLWVFRQWHQWDSDUWIURP*RGEHFDXVHWKHQDWXUDOODZitself  
includes  duties  toward  God.  
7KXVWRVXJJHVWWKDWWKHPDMHVW\DQGVROHPQLW\RIWKHGLYLQHRUGHULVLUUHOHYDQW
WRQDWXUDOODZGRFWULQHFOHDUO\LVWRSURPXOJDWHDVSHFLHVRIQDWXUDOODZGRFWULQH
QRWRQO\RWKHUWKDQWKDWRI$TXLQDVEXWDOLHQWR&DWKROLFWUDGLWLRQ,WLVRIFRXUVH
inconvenient  that  this  should  be  true  in  a  society  in  which  secularist  protocols  are  
MXULGLFDOO\HQIRUFHGVXFKWKDWDQ\SLHFHRIOHJLVODWLRQWKDWVHHPVWRKDYHD³UHOLJLRXV´
LQWHQWPD\EHVXEMHFWHGWRDUELWUDU\OLPLWDWLRQVRURXWULJKWQXOOL¿FDWLRQ%XWWKHWUXWK
LVWKDWERWKQDWXUDODQGKXPDQODZSDUWLFLSDWHLQHWHUQDOODZERWKLQWKHLUEHLQJDQG
in  their  nature  qua  ODZDQGQRWPHUHO\E\VRPHH[WULQVLFDQDORJ\RIDWWULEXWLRQWR
*RGRIDWKHRFUDWLFVRUW)RUWKHWKHLVWODZDVODZGHULYHVIURPWKHGLYLQHRUGHULQJ
RIFUHDWLRQDQGDEVHQWWKLVGLYLQHRUGHULQJQRODZZKDWVRHYHUFRXOGH[LVWRUEH
LQWHOOLJLEOHDVODZ+HQFHHYHU\MXVWODZRIWKHVWDWHIDOOVZLWKLQWKHSURYHQDQFHRI
*RGZKHWKHUVHFXODULVWMXULVSUXGHQFHDVH[HUFLVHGE\WKRVHZKRGHQ\PHWDSK\VLFDO
UHDVRQLQJDFNQRZOHGJHVWKLVRUQRW
,WLVLURQLFDOO\WKLVLQFRQYHQLHQFHRIFODVVLFDOQDWXUDOODZWKDWDFFRXQWVIRU
WKHUHPDUNDEOHSROLWLFDOHQJDJHPHQWRIWKH11/7DWWKHKDQGVRILWVSURSRQHQWVLQ
1RUWK$PHULFD,WLVDQLQFRQYHQLHQFHWKDWKDVLQYLWHGVLPLODUDWWHQWLRQVLQWKHSDVW
)RUH[DPSOHRQHWKLQNVRIWKHZRUNVRIWKHJUHDWMXULVW*LRUJLR'HO9HFFKLR  who  
DWWHPSWHGWRGHIHQGQDWXUDOODZRQODUJHO\.DQWLDQIRXQGDWLRQVQRWOHDVWEHFDXVH²LQ
DVNHSWLFDOFOLPDWH²WKHIHDUREWDLQHGWKDWLIRQHPXVWDQVZHUDOOVNHSWLFDOREMHFWLRQV
SULRUWRGHYHORSLQJDQDFFRXQWRISUDFWLFDOUHDVRQVXFKDQDFFRXQWZRXOGQHYHUEH
GHYHORSHG<HWVXFKDQHIIRUWLVVWLOOERUQSUHFLVHO\EHFDXVHWKH7KRPLVWLFGRFWULQHRI
SUDFWLFDOUHDVRQLVDQLPDWHGIURPZLWKLQE\IRXQGDWLRQDOO\PHWDSK\VLFDOMXGJPHQWV
,IRQHQHHGHGWRKROGRQWRHLWKHUWKHGRFWULQHRISUDFWLFDOUHDVRQRUWKHPHWDSK\VLFV
RIWKHWUDGLWLRQWKHODWWHUZRXOGEHWKHFRUUHFWFKRLFHEHFDXVHJLYHQWKHODWWHUDQG
FRQWUDU\WRWKHYLHZRIWKH11/7WKHIRUPHULVDFWXDOO\LPSOLFLWLQUHODWLRQWRWKH
WHOHRORJLFDOG\QDPLVPRIPDQ¶VDFWXDOQDWXUH
,Q DQ\ FDVH EHFDXVH RI WKH SUHYDOHQFH RI DJQRVWLF DQG VNHSWLFDO PRGHV RI
WKRXJKWLQDFDGHPHWKDWDUHUHPRWHIURPWKHPHWDSK\VLFDOUHDOLVPRI$TXLQDVDQG
EHFDXVHWKHOHJDOFXOWXUHRIWKH8QLWHG6WDWHVRI$PHULFDLVSDUWLFXODUO\DIIHFWHGby  

6HHDJDLQ6LPRQTradition  of  Natural  Law±



6HHIRULQVWDQFH*LRUJLR'HO9HFFKLRPhilosophy  of  LawWUDQV7KRPDV2ZHQ



0DUWLQ:DVKLQJWRQ'&&DWKROLF8QLYHUVLW\RI$PHULFD3UHVV
122
 LONG      FUNDAMENTAL  ERRORS  OF  THE  NNLT

WKHGLVWLQFWLYHKRVWLOLW\RIWKH6XSUHPH&RXUWWRZDUGUHOLJLRXVVSHHFKDQGH[HUFLVH
LWEHFRPHVSRVLWLYHO\DWWUDFWLYHWREHDEOHWRIRUZDUGDQDFFRXQWRIQDWXUDOODZWKDW
SXWDWLYHO\KDVQRVSHFXODWLYHRUPHWDSK\VLFDOIRXQGDWLRQVDQGUHTXLUHVQRUHIHUHQFH
WR*RG7KXVGHVSLWHWKHHIIHFWVRIWKHGRFWULQHRILQFRPPHQVXUDELOLW\LQLPSO\LQJ
WKDWWKHUHLVQRPRUDOO\VLJQL¿FDQWRUGHURIEDVLFJRRGVSULRUWRFKRLFHWKHGRFWULQH
RIWKH11/7KDVFHUWDLQOLPLWHGSROLWLFDODQGOHJDODGYDQWDJHVLQWKHSDWKRORJLFDO
VLWXDWLRQRIVHFXODULVWFXOWXUH<HWVXFKDGYDQWDJHVDUHVKRUWFRPLQJVLQDVPXFKDV
WKH\SUHVXSSRVHDQGSURFHHGIURPIRUPDOHUURUDERXWQDWXUHDQGODZ
1DWXUDOODZGRFWULQHLVWKHRFHQWULFQRWDVDQDGKRFHQWDLOPHQWRIDWKHRFUDWLF
YLHZRISROLWLFDORUGHUEXWDVDIXQFWLRQRIWKHPHWDSK\VLFDODQDO\VLVRIWKHEHLQJ
QDWXUH DQG LQWHOOLJLELOLW\ RI ODZ DV VXFK $Q\ MXVW ODZ SURPXOJDWHG ZLWKLQ DQ\
VRFLHW\RZHVLWVEHLQJDQGLWVOHJDOFKDUDFWHUWRLWVSDUWLFLSDWLRQLQWKHHWHUQDOODZ
7KXVLWLVQRWE\VRPHsuperadded  religiosityWKDWMXVWJRYHUQPHQWSDUWLFLSDWHVLQWKH
HWHUQDOODZ²UDWKHULWLVE\WKHYHU\EHLQJDQGQDWXUHRIMXVWODZWKDWLWSDUWLFLSDWHV
LQHWHUQDOODZ7KHHVVHQWLDOSRLQWLVWKDWDOOMXVWODZDQGJRYHUQPHQWSDUWLFLSDWHVLQ
WKHHWHUQDOODZDQGWKDWWKHVWDWHUHFHLYHVLWVSRZHUWRMXGJHWRSXQLVKDQGLQGHHG
WRH[HFXWHIURP*RG7KHQDWXUHRIKXPDQVRFLHW\DQGSROLWLFDOJRYHUQPHQWDQGWKH
DXWKRULW\WRSXQLVKRUHYHQVOD\GRQRWRULJLQDWHLQDQ\PHUHVRFLDOFRQWUDFWEXWLQ
that  natural  law  which  is  nothing  other  than  a  rational  participation  in  eternal  law.
7KXVWKH11/7UHPRWLRQRUGLVWDQFHIURPWKHWKHRORJLFDOPHWDSK\VLFDODQG
VSHFXODWLYHFKDUDFWHURIQDWXUDOODZZKLOHRIIHULQJFHUWDLQSUDFWLFDOEHQH¿WVJLYHQ
WKHVHFXODULVWLPSRVLWLRQVRIFRQWHPSRUDU\ODZDQGSROLWLFVLQ1RUWK$PHULFDGRHV
VRDWWKHFRVWRIWKHORVVRIDFRUUHFWXQGHUVWDQGLQJRIODZDVVXFKDQGWKHratio  RI
LWVMXVWGLUHFWLYHDXWKRULW\$&KULVWLDQXQGHUVWDQGLQJRIODZDQGVRFLHW\WKDWKRQRUV
QDWXUDOWUXWKLVRSHQWRVXSHUQDWXUDOUHYHODWLRQDQGKLQJHVRQWKHWKHRQRPLFFKDU-­
DFWHURIQDWXUDOODZLVUHSODFHGE\DQDFFRXQWWKDWUHQGHUVWKHUROHRI*RGLQQDWXUDO
ODZWREHH[WULQVLFWRQDWXUDOODZGRFWULQHSURSHU7KLVLVVLPSO\QHLWKHUWKH&DWKROLF
WUDGLWLRQQRUWKHWHDFKLQJRI$TXLQDV(YHQDSDUWIURPLWVVSHFXODWLYHGH¿FLHQF\
PHUHO\DVDSUXGHQWLDOTXHVWLRQWKLVHUURUFRQVWLWXWHVWRRJUHDWDQH[DFWLRQWREH
FRPSHQVDWHGIRUE\WKHGHJUHHRIOHJDODQGVRFLDOWUDFWLRQWKDWLWRIIHUVWKH&KXUFK
LQWKHSDUWLFXODU²DQGSDWKRORJLFDO²FLUFXPVWDQFHRIOHJDOO\VWUXFWXUDODQWLWKHLVP
The  Intentionalist  Construction  of  Human  Action
$OOWKHSULRUVWUDWHJLFGHIHFWVRIWKH11/7DUHSUDFWLFDOO\ZRUVHQHGE\WKH
11/7DFFRXQWRIPRUDOREMHFWHQGDQGLQWHQWLRQEHFDXVHLWLVWKHVHDFFRXQWVWKDW
PRVWDIIHFWWKHDSSOLFDWLRQRIWKHZKROHGRFWULQHWRVLQJXODUKXPDQDFWLRQ)DFHG
ZLWKDGHRQWRORJLFDOGRFWULQHRILQFRPPHQVXUDELOLW\WKDWFDQQRWIDWKRPWKHWUDQ-­
VFHQGHQFHRIWKHFRPPRQJRRGWKHQRUPDWLYHRUGHURIJRRGVSULRUWRFKRLFHDQG
WKHWKHRFHQWULFFKDUDFWHURIWKHPRUDOODZWKH11/7LVIRUFHGWRFRPSURPLVHWKH
DQDO\VLVRIKXPDQDFWLRQWRDFKLHYHDQ\UHFRJQLWLRQRIRUGHUDPRQJ  goods.  The  

7KH 6XSUHPH &RXUW DSSHDUV WR YLHZ UHOLJLRXV VSHHFK DV PRUH GHOHWHULRXVO\


FRQWDJLRXVDQGGHVWUXFWLYHWKDQV\SKLOLVDQGWDNHVPDQ\SDLQVOHVWVRPHRQHVKRXOGKHDU
XQWRZDUG³UHOLJLRXV´VSHHFKVRPHWKLQJGHPRQVWUDEO\IDUIURPWKHYLHZVRIWKHIRXQGHUV
DVOLNHZLVHIURPWKH¿UVWRQHKXQGUHGDQG¿IW\\HDUVRIKLJKFRXUWMXULVSUXGHQFH
123
 THE  NATIONAL  CATHOLIC  BIOETHICS  QUARTERLY      SPRING  2013

SUREOHPLVWKDWWKHRUGHUFRQVHTXHQWO\DFNQRZOHGJHGLVQRWWKDWZKLFKLVLPSUHVVHG
RQQDWXUHE\GLYLQHSURYLGHQFHSULRUWRFKRLFHEXWUDWKHUWKHRUGHUWKDWDQ\FRQWLQ-­
JHQWDJHQWPD\GHFLGHWRSODFHLQKLVDFWLRQVRQEHKDOIRIDJRRGLQWHQWLRQIRUWKH
REMHFWRIPRUDODFWLRQLVWDNHQE\WKH11/7WREHVLPSO\WKHDJHQW¶V³SURSRVDO´IRU
DFWLRQexcluding  the  integral  nature  and  per  se  HIIHFWVRIWKHDFWLRQFKRVHQ7KH
SULFHIRUVXEVWLWXWLQJDGHRQWRORJLFDOSUD[HRORJ\IRUWKHVSHFXODWLYHIRXQGDWLRQVRI
QDWXUDOODZLVWKHGLVWRUWLRQRIWKHQDWXUHRIKXPDQDFWLRQ
6KRXOGWKHDJHQW¶VSURSRVDOIRUDFWLRQH[FOXGHWKHGHOLEHUDWHO\FKRVHQFDXVDO-­
LW\RIWKDWDFWWKHQWKH11/7KROGVWKDWVXFKGHOLEHUDWHO\FKRVHQFDXVDOLW\LVQRW
LQFOXGHGZLWKLQWKHREMHFWRIWKHDFWLRQ:KLOHWKH11/7DVVHUWVWKDWZKDWHYHUWKH
DJHQWSURSRVHVHLWKHUDVPHDQVRUDVHQGLVLQFOXGHGZLWKLQ³LQWHQWLRQ´VRWKDWWKH
PHDQVLVLQFOXGHGLQWKHREMHFWRIWKHPRUDODFWnonetheless  ³ZKDWWKHDJHQWSUR-­
SRVHV´LVJLYHQWUXPSLQJULJKWVRYHUWKHREMHFWLYHFRQVWLWXWLRQRIWKHIUHHO\FKRVHQ
PHDQV³0HDQV´LVWDNHQWREHHTXLYDOHQWWR³WKHDJHQW¶VGHVFULSWLRQRIPHDQV´DQG
VRLVUHGXFHGWRZKDWVRHYHULWLVDERXWWKHSURSRVHGDFWLRQWKDWLVGHVLUDEOHWRWKH
DJHQWH[FOXGLQJDOOHOVH7KXVLIWKHDJHQWGRHVQRWGHVFULEHKLVFKRLFHRIPHDQVDV
LQFOXGLQJZKDWLVREMHFWLYHO\HVVHQWLDOWRWKHPHDQVIUHHO\FKRVHQDQGZLOOHGWKHQ
WKH11/7H[FOXGHVWKLVREMHFWLYHO\HVVHQWLDOWUXWKRIWKHPHDQVIURPWKHREMHFWRI
WKHPRUDODFWThis  is  what  constitutes  the  logicism  of  the  NNLT  regarding  the  object  
of  the  moral  act,  namely,  its  conversion  of  the  deliberately  chosen  moral  causality  
of  an  act  into  a  mere  ideational  proposal  of  the  agent.6XFKDSURSRVDOLVIUHHWR
HPSKDVL]HZKDWHYHUJRRGHIIHFWWKHDJHQWVHHNVZLWKRXWDFNQRZOHGJLQJWKHYHU\
QDWXUHRIWKHDFWLRQWKDWLVGHOLEHUDWHO\DQGYROXQWDULO\HPEUDFHGDVPHDQV
7KXVIRUWKH11/7LWEHFRPHVHQRXJKWKDWRQHVHHNVDJRRGHQGVRLQFUDQL-­
RWRP\FUXVKLQJDFKLOG¶VVNXOOLVFRQVWUXHGDVPHUHO\UHGHVLJQLQJWKHFLUFXPIHUHQFH
RIWKHVNXOOUDWKHUWKDQGHOLEHUDWHO\FKRRVLQJWRLQÀLFWOHWKDOLQMXU\RQWKHFKLOG
:K\"%HFDXVHE\FUDQLRWRP\WKHDJHQWproposesWRDLGWKHPRWKHUDQGGRHVQRW
propose  WRKDUPWKHFKLOGZKLOHDOOWKHVDPHWKHGHOLEHUDWHO\FKRVHQDFWLRQWHUPL-­


6HH )LQQLV *ULVH] DQG %R\OH ³µ'LUHFW¶ DQG µ,QGLUHFW¶´ LQ WKH PDLQ WH[W DIWHU
QRWH³7KHEDE\¶VGHDWKLVDVLGHHIIHFWRIFKDQJLQJWKHGLPHQVLRQVRILWVVNXOO´DQGLQ
QRWHWKHIROORZLQJUHVSRQVHWR%URFN¶VFULWLFLVPV³%XW%URFNIDLOVWRVKRZWKHREMHFWRI
WKHVXUJHRQ¶VFKRVHQDFWLVEHWWHUGHVFULEHGDVµSURGXFLQJWKHFUXVKHGVNXOORIDQLQQRFHQW
SHUVRQ¶WKDQDVµFUDQLXPQDUURZLQJIRUWKHSXUSRVHVRIUHPRYDOIURPWKHELUWKFDQDO¶´<HW
WKH&KXUFKKDVQHYHUDFFHSWHGVXFKDYLHZ5HSO\LQJWRWKH$UFKELVKRSRI/\RQ¶VLQTXLU\
DERXWZKHWKHU&DWKROLFVFKRROVFRXOGWHDFKWKDWFUDQLRWRP\ZDVOLFLWDVDPHDQVRIVDYLQJWKH
PRWKHUZKHQWKHDOWHUQDWLYHZRXOGEHWKHGHDWKRIERWKPRWKHUDQGFKLOGWKH&RQJUHJDWLRQ
LQVWUXFWHG ³,W FDQQRW EH WDXJKW VDIHO\´ tuto   doceri   non   posse 6HH +HQU\ 'HQ]LQJHU¶V
Enchiridion  symbolorum,  WUDQV5R\-'HIHUUDULIURPWKHWKLUWLHWKHGLWLRQDVThe  Sources  
of  Catholic  Doctrine)LW]ZLOOLDP1+/RUHWR3XEOLFDWLRQVQ±D6HH
also  Acta  sanctae  sedis  7KH'HQ]LQJHUSDVVDJHVQRWHDOVRWKHLQVLVWHQFHRIWKH
&RQJUHJDWLRQSODFLQJWKHFRQVFLHQFHRIDVXUJHRQDWUHVWDERXWSHUIRUPLQJFUDQLRWRPLHV
LQFDVHVZKHUHRWKHUZLVHKHWKRXJKWWKHPRWKHUZRXOGGLHE\JLYLQJDQHJDWLYHDQVZHU
WRWKHTXHVWLRQ³:KHWKHUKHFDQVDIHO\UHSHDWWKHDERYHPHQWLRQHGRSHUDWLRQVXQGHUWKH
UHFXUULQJFLUFXPVWDQFHV"´7KHPRUDOPDJLVWHULXPRIWKH&KXUFKKDVQHYHUHPEUDFHGWKH
ORJLFRILQWHQWLRQDOLVP

 LONG      FUNDAMENTAL  ERRORS  OF  THE  NNLT

QDWHVLQWKHERG\RIWKHIHWXV²QRWWKHPRWKHU²DQGLQDOHWKDOZD\:LWKUHVSHFW
WRWKHPRUDOREMHFWDQGLQWHQWLRQWKH11/7LVODUJHO\VHFRQGHGE\5HY0DUWLQ
5KRQKHLPHUZKRXUJHVVLPLODUFRQFOXVLRQVDOWKRXJKKHDSSHDUVWRKROGWKDWLWLV  
impossibleWRZLOOWKHGHDWKRIWKHFKLOGLQFUDQLRWRP\DVDPHDQVLQDVPXFKDVWKH
FKLOGZLOOQRWVXUYLYHLQDQ\FDVH²VRPHWKLQJWKDWVHHPVFRQWUDU\WRIDFW
2QH SURPLQHQW DQG UHYHDOLQJ LOOXVWUDWLRQ RI WKH LPSOLFDWLRQV RI WKH 11/7
DFFRXQWRIWKHPRUDOREMHFWDQGLQWHQWLRQPD\EHIRXQGLQWKHFDVHRIWKHIRUPHUO\
&DWKROLF6W-RVHSK¶V+RVSLWDOZKLFKORVWLWV&DWKROLFVWDWXVIRUSHUIRUPLQJDGLUHFW
abortion.    The  ethicist  (Therese  Lysaught)  RI¿FLDOO\UHWDLQHGE\WKHKRVSLWDODIWHU
WKHIDFWWRGHIHQGZLWKIXOODFFHVVWRWKHKRVSLWDO¶VPHGLFDOFKDUWVWKHFOLQLFDODERU-­
WLRQSHUIRUPHGWKHUHGLGVRRQWKHH[SUHVVJURXQGVRIWKH11/7GRFWULQHWKDWRQO\
DQDJHQW¶VGHVFULSWLRQRIKLVLQWHQWLRQGH¿QHVWKHPRUDOREMHFWRIKLVDFWLRQ    This  
GHIHQVHFHGHVWKDWDGLODWLRQDQGFXUHWWDJHZDVSHUIRUPHGWRUHOLHYHWKHVWUHVVRQ


6HH0DUWLQ5KRQKHLPHUVital  Conflicts  in  Medical  Ethics:  A  Virtue  Approach  to  
Craniotomy  and  Tubal  PregnanciesHG:LOOLDP(0XUSK\-U:DVKLQJWRQ'&&DWKROLF
8QLYHUVLW\RI$PHULFD3UHVV³,QIDFWLQWKHFDVHZKHUHPRWKHUand  child  would  
GLHLIWKHOLIHVDYLQJLQWHUYHQWLRQZHUHQRWXQGHUWDNHQWKHUHLVQRWHYHQWKHpossibilityRI
DZHLJKLQJRIJRRGVLQWKHVHQVHRIZHLJKLQJEHWZHHQWZROLYHVDQGGHFLGLQJZKLFKRQH
VKRXOGQRWOLYHVRWKDWWKHRWKHUEHVDYHG´$QGDJDLQ³2QO\LIWKHIHWXVZRXOGRWKHUZLVH
VXUYLYHFRXOGLWVGHDWKE\VDLGWREHFKRVHQDVDPHDQV²DQGWKXVFDXVHGµGLUHFWO\¶LQD
PRUDOO\UHOHYDQWZD\%XWLQRXUFDVHWKHGHDWKRIWKHIHWXVLVQRWZLOOHGWRVDYHWKHPRWKHUDV
IDUDVWKHOLIHRIWKHIHWXVLVFRQFHUQHGLWLVEH\RQGDQ\NLQGRIZLOOLQJ´%XWWRWKHFRQWUDU\
MXVWDVRQHPD\ZURQJO\NLOODPRUWDOO\ZRXQGHGVROGLHURQWKH¿HOGRIEDWWOHVRRQHPD\
ZURQJIXOO\NLOODIHWXVWKDWQRQHWKHOHVVLVG\LQJDQGGLUHFWQHVVDQGLQGLUHFWQHVVRIZLOOLQJ
FDQQRWEHVHSDUDWHGIURPWKHPRUDOO\VLJQL¿FDQWFDXVDOLW\RIRQH¶VDFWLRQRUUHGXFHGWRD
PHUHORJLFDOSURSRVDOVKRUQRIQDWXUH:KLOHKROGLQJWKDW³it  is  morally  impermissible  to  
weigh  t wo  lives  against  each  other  and  to  make  a  preferential  choice”  HPSKDVLVDGGHG
5KRQKHLPHUWKXVEHOLHYHVWKDWFKRRVLQJWRFUXVKWKHVNXOORIWKHIHWXVFDQEHLQGLUHFWZKHQ
WKHIHWXVLVG\LQJEHFDXVHRQHVHHNVWKHUHE\QRWSULQFLSDOO\LWVGHDWKEXWJRRGWRDQRWKHU

6HHWKHVWDWHPHQWRIWKH86&&%&RPPLWWHHRQ'RFWULQH³7KH'LVWLQFWLRQEHWZHHQ
'LUHFW $ERUWLRQ DQG /HJLWLPDWH 0HGLFDO 3URFHGXUHV´ -XQH   ZKLFK UHSRUWV WKH
FRQGHPQDWLRQRIWKLVDFWE\WKHORFDORUGLQDU\%LVKRS7KRPDV2OPVWHG,WDGGUHVVHVWKH
GLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQGLUHFWDERUWLRQDQGOHJLWLPDWHPHGLFDOSURFHGXUHVE\UHIHUHQFHWRWKH
GLUHFWFDXVDOLW\RIOHJLWLPDWHVXUJHU\DVWDUJHWLQJRQO\WKHUHPRYDORIPDOIXQFWLRQLQJRUJDQV
RIWKHPRWKHUDQGQRWWHUPLQDWLQJLQWKHERG\RIWKHIHWXVLQVXFKPDQQHUDVWRKDUPRU
GHVWUR\LW³7KHUHLVQRWKLQJLQWULQVLFDOO\ZURQJZLWKVXUJHU\WRUHPRYHDPDOIXQFWLRQLQJ
RUJDQ´7KLVLVWKHFODVVLFDODQDO\VLVLQWHUPVRIPRUDOO\VLJQL¿FDQWFDXVDOLW\DVRSSRVHGWR
WKHUHGXFWLRQRIWKHREMHFWRIWKHPRUDODFWWRWKHDJHQW¶VPHUHGHVFULSWLRQRIKLVSURSRVDO
IRUDFWLRQ

7KHUHVH/\VDXJKW³0RUDO$QDO\VLVRIDQ,QWHUYHQWLRQ3HUIRUPHGDW6W-RVHSK¶V
+RVSLWDO DQG 0HGLFDO &HQWHU´ DYDLODEOH DW  KWWSZZZFRPPRQZHDOPDJD]LQHRUJEORJ
ZSFRQWHQWXSORDGV6W-RVHSKV+RVSLWDO$QDO\VLVSGI³7KH(WKLFV&RPPLWWHH
DW6W-RVHSK¶V+RVSLWDODQG0HGLFDO&HQWHUZDVDVNHGIRUDGHWHUPLQDWLRQRIZKHWKHURU
QRWWKHLQWHUYHQWLRQWRDGGUHVVWKHSODFHQWDOLVVXHYLDD' &ZRXOGEHPRUDOO\DSSURSULDWH
DFFRUGLQJWR&DWKROLFWHDFKLQJ3HUWKHLUUHDGLQJRIWKHEthical  and  Religious  Directives  for  
Catholic  Health  Care  Services  WKHGLWLRQDQGWKHLUXQGHUVWDQGLQJRIWKH&DWKROLFPRUDO
WUDGLWLRQWKH(WKLFV&RPPLWWHHGHWHUPLQHGWKDWWKHLQWHUYHQWLRQZRXOGQRWEHFRQVLGHUHG
125
 THE  NATIONAL  CATHOLIC  BIOETHICS  QUARTERLY      SPRING  2013

WKHPRWKHUVXIIHULQJZLWKSXOPRQDU\K\SHUWHQVLRQEXWDUJXHVWKDWWKHDFWZDVQRWD
GLUHFWDERUWLRQEHFDXVHLWVRXJKWSULQFLSDOO\WRUHPRYHWKHSODFHQWDZKLFKLWZRXOG
KDYHVRXJKWWRGRHYHQKDGWKHFKLOGEHHQGHDG  The  analysis  and  conclusion  are  
H[SOLFLWO\EDVHGRQWKHZRUNRI*ULVH]DQGDOVR5KRQKHLPHUDQGHYHQ5KRQKHLPHU¶V
HGLWRU:LOOLDP0XUSK\DOORIZKRPDUHFLWHG
,WPXVWEHVWUHVVHGWKDWWKHGHVWUXFWLRQRIWKHSODFHQWDHQWDLOVODFHUDWLQJWHDULQJ
RUFUXVKLQJWKHIHWXV(YHQZHUHWKLVQRWWUXHLWLVDOVRWKHFDVHWKDWWKHSODFHQWDLV
QRWXQLODWHUDOO\WKHRUJDQRIWKHPRWKHUDVLWLVWKHRUJDQIRUWKHR[\JHQDWLRQDQGWKH
QXWULWLRQRIWKHIHWXVVRWKDWGHVWUR\LQJLWLVHTXLYDOHQWWRGHVWUR\LQJWKHOXQJVRIDQ
DGXOWRUVWDUYLQJVRPHRQHWRGHDWKZHUHWKHRWKHUFDXVHVRIGHDWKQRWPDQLIHVWO\
TXLFNHU7KDWLVWRVD\WKDWLWLVE\QRPHDQVFOHDUWKDWDFWVGLUHFWHGVROHO\DWWKH
SODFHQWD²SUHVXPLQJWKDWVXFKDQDFWLVVRPXFKDVSRVVLEOHVLQFHWKHDFWLRQE\LWV
QDWXUHZRXOGDSSHDUWRNLOOWKHIHWXVE\FUXVKLQJODFHUDWLQJRUGLVPHPEHULQJLW²
FDQEH³LQGLUHFW´ZLWKUHVSHFWWRWKHIHWXVLQDVPXFKDVWKHIHWXV¶VQRUPDOELRORJLFDO
RUJDQIRUEUHDWKLQJDQGQXWULWLRQLVWKHSODFHQWD,WPXVWEHVWUHVVHGWKDWWKHSRLQWDW
LVVXHLVWKHQDWXUHRIWKH11/7DQGLWVLPSOLFDWLRQV7KDWWKHVHLPSOLFDWLRQVH[WHQG
WRWKHGHIHQVHRIDFWLRQVWKDWWHUPLQDWHLQWKHERG\RIDQLQQRFHQWLQVXFKDZD\DV
WRNLOOWKDWLQQRFHQWLVUHYHODWRU\ZLWKUHVSHFWWRWKH11/77KDWWKHSULQFLSOHVRI
WKH11/7LPSO\WKHSHUPLVVLELOLW\RIVXFKDQDFWLVGDPQLQJDQGWKLVZRXOGEHWUXH
HYHQLIIRUVRPHUHDVRQ/\VDXJKW¶VDFFRXQWRIWKHIDFWV²made  at  the  bequest  of  the  
hospital  itself²ZHUHVRPHKRZmirabile  dictu  to  be  erroneous.
:KDWLVSURPLQHQWO\DWVWDNHLQWKH3KRHQL[FDVHLVQRWDVWDQGDUGDSSOLFDWLRQ
RIWKHWUDGLWLRQDOGLVWLQFWLRQEHWZHHQWDNLQJDQDFWLRQWKDWGLUHFWO\DLGVWKHPRWKHU
ZKLOHPHUHO\LQGLUHFWO\KDUPLQJWKHIHWXVDQGWDNLQJDQDFWLRQGLUHFWO\WDUJHWLQJ
WKHIHWXV5DWKHUZKDWLVDWVWDNHLVWKH³UHGH¿QLWLRQ´RIZKDW³GLUHFW´means.  The  
11/7DQDO\VLVLPSOLHVWKDWZKDW/\VDXJKWGHVFULEHVDVRFFXUULQJLQWKH3KRHQL[
case  was  not  a  direct  abortion.50  
$FFRUGLQJWRWKH11/7DQDFWLRQWKDWWHUPLQDWHVLQWKHERG\RIWKHIHWXVLQVXFK
DZD\DVWRKDUPRUGHVWUR\WKHIHWXVVKRXOGEHFRQVLGHUHG³LQGLUHFW´KDUPLQVRIDU
DVWKHDJHQWLQWHQGVVRPHIXUWKHUJRRGREMHFWLYHDQGWKHKDUPLVQRWLQFOXGHGLQWKH
DJHQW¶VGHVFULSWLRQRIKLVSURSRVDOIRUDFWLRQ7KHDFWXDOPRUDOFDXVDOLW\HPEUDFHG
E\FKRLFHLVV\VWHPDWLFDOO\UHSODFHGE\WKH11/7ZLWKWKHPHUHGHVFULSWLRQRID
SURSRVDOIRUDFWLRQDVWKRXJKZHFKRVHRQO\WKHDVSHFWXQGHUZKLFKZHDFWEXWQRW
WKHDFWLWVHOI6XFKDQDFFRXQWUHQGHUVWKHODQJXDJHRI³GLUHFW´DQG³LQGLUHFW´WR
UHIHUH[FOXVLYHO\WRDSUHIHUUHGGHVFULSWLRQRIDFWLRQUDWKHUWKDQWRDFWLRQ7KXVWKH
11/7DFFRXQWWKDWLQLWLDOO\ZDVLQWHQGHGWRGHIHQGWKH&KXUFK¶VWHDFKLQJERWKRQ
FRQWUDFHSWLRQDQGDERUWLRQKDVFRPHIXOOFLUFOHRU³WUDQVPLJUDWHG´WRDGRFWULQDO

D GLUHFW DERUWLRQ 7KH\ WKHUHIRUH DSSURYHG WKH LQWHUYHQWLRQ ZKLFK ZDV FDUULHG RXW RQ
1RYHPEHU´

,ELG

,ELG±
50  
7KH11/7LPSOLHVWKDWWKHFDVHLQTXHVWLRQEHDUVPRUHVLPLODULW\WRVWDQGDUGFDVHV
RIGRXEOHHIIHFWWKDQWRDERUWLRQGHVSLWHWKHIDFWWKDWWKHDFWLRQWDNHQZDVVXFKDVWRWHUPLQDWH
LQWKHERG\RIWKHIHWXVLQVXFKDPDQQHUDVWRGHVWUR\WKHIHWXV

 LONG      FUNDAMENTAL  ERRORS  OF  THE  NNLT

GHIHQVHRIDFWLRQVWKDWWHUPLQDWHLPPHGLDWHO\LQWKHIHWXVDQGDUHVXFKDVWRKDUP
RUGHVWUR\WKHIHWXVZKDWWKHWUDGLWLRQKDVDOZD\VFRQVLGHUHGWREHGLUHFWDERUWLRQV
Veritatis  splendor  QLVDWWLPHVPLVFRQVWUXHGDVMXVWLI\LQJWKHLQWHQWLRQDOLVP
RIWKH11/7
7KHREMHFWRIWKHDFWRIZLOOLQJLVLQIDFWDIUHHO\FKRVHQNLQGRIEHKDYLRXU
7RWKHH[WHQWWKDWLWLVLQFRQIRUPLW\ZLWKWKHRUGHURIUHDVRQLWLVWKHFDXVHRI
WKHJRRGQHVVRIWKHZLOOLWSHUIHFWVXVPRUDOO\DQGGLVSRVHVXVWRUHFRJQL]H
RXUXOWLPDWHHQGLQWKHSHUIHFWJRRGSULPRUGLDOORYH%\WKHREMHFWRIDJLYHQ
PRUDODFWWKHQRQHFDQQRWPHDQDSURFHVVRUDQHYHQWRIWKHPHUHO\SK\VLFDO
RUGHUWREHDVVHVVHGRQWKHEDVLVRILWVDELOLW\WREULQJDERXWDJLYHQVWDWHRI
DIIDLUVLQWKHRXWVLGHZRUOG51
%XWWKLVLVPHUHO\WRVD\WKDWWKHREMHFWRIDJLYHQPRUDODFWGRHVQRWGHVLJQDWHmerely  
DSK\VLFDOUHDOLW\EHFDXVHDFWLRQLVIURPWKHSHUVSHFWLYHRIWKHDFWLQJSHUVRQDQGVR
the  ratio  RILQWHQWLRQLVDOZD\VHVVHQWLDO7KHUHLVQRGRXEWRIWKLV%XWWRVD\WKDW
DFWLRQPD\QRWEHreduced  PHUHO\WRVRPHSK\VLFDOVWDWHRIDIIDLUVDSDUWIURPUHDVRQ
LVIDUIURPVD\LQJWKDWWKHQDWXUDORUGHUWKDWLVFRQVFLRXVO\HPEUDFHGLQUDWLRQDO
FKRLFHLVQRWLQFOXGHGZLWKLQWKHREMHFWRIWKHPRUDODFW
,WLVVLPSO\DQGZKROO\LQFRUUHFWWRUHDGVeritatis  splendor  QDVOLFHQVLQJ
the  exclusion  RIWKHGHOLEHUDWHO\DQGYROXQWDULO\FKRVHQPRUDOFDXVDOLW\RIDQDFW
IURPWKHREMHFWRIWKDWDFWRQWKHJURXQGWKDWWKLVUDWLRQDOO\HPEUDFHGFDXVDOLW\LV
QRWZKDWLVFKLHÀ\VRXJKWRULQGLFDWHGE\WKHDJHQW¶V³SURSRVDO´IRUDFWLRQ³3URSRV-­
DOV´IRUDFWLRQDUHVXEMHFWWRFULWLFLVPLQSDUWRQWKHJURXQGRIUDWLRQDOL]LQJWKHXVH
RIHYLOPHDQV²DFWLRQVWKDWDUHLQWULQVLFDOO\GLVRUGHUHGDQGXQMXVW²WRDWWDLQJRRG
intended  ends.  Those  who  cite  Veritatis  splendor  n.  LQWKLVZD\IRUJHWRUGRQRW
ULJKWO\XQGHUVWDQGWKHUHPDLQGHURIWKHSDUDJUDSK
5DWKHUWKDWREMHFWLVWKHSUR[LPDWHHQGRIDGHOLEHUDWHGHFLVLRQZKLFKGHWHU-­
PLQHVWKHDFWRIZLOOLQJRQWKHSDUWRIWKHDFWLQJSHUVRQ&RQVHTXHQWO\DVWKH  
Catechism  of  the  Catholic  Church  WHDFKHV³WKHUHDUHFHUWDLQVSHFL¿FNLQGVRI
EHKDYLRXUWKDWDUHDOZD\VZURQJWRFKRRVHEHFDXVHFKRRVLQJWKHPLQYROYHV
DGLVRUGHURIWKHZLOOWKDWLVDPRUDOHYLO´$QG6DLQW7KRPDVREVHUYHVWKDW
³LWRIWHQKDSSHQVWKDWPDQDFWVZLWKDJRRGLQWHQWLRQEXWZLWKRXWVSLULWXDO
JDLQEHFDXVHKHODFNVDJRRGZLOO/HWXVVD\WKDWVRPHRQHUREVLQRUGHUWR
IHHGWKHSRRULQWKLVFDVHHYHQWKRXJKWKHLQWHQWLRQLVJRRGWKHXSULJKWQHVV
RIWKHZLOOLVODFNLQJ&RQVHTXHQWO\QRHYLOGRQHZLWKDJRRGLQWHQWLRQFDQ
EHH[FXVHGµ7KHUHDUHWKRVHZKRVD\$QGZK\QRWGRHYLOWKDWJRRGPD\
FRPH"7KHLUFRQGHPQDWLRQLVMXVW¶5RP´ 52
,QVKRUWLWLVQRWPHUHO\DVDSK\VLFDOGDWXPEXWDVWKHGHOLEHUDWHFKRLFHRI
WKHDJHQWWKDWWKHGLVRUGHURIDQDFWLRQLVPRUDOO\HYLOSUHFLVHO\EHFDXVHLWLVDOZD\V
ZURQJWRFKRRVHFHUWDLQW\SHVRIDFWLRQLUUHVSHFWLYHRQH¶VIXUWKHULQWHQWLRQ7KXV
$TXLQDVREVHUYHVWKDW³LWRIWHQKDSSHQVWKDWPDQDFWVZLWKDJRRGLQWHQWLRQEXW
ZLWKRXWVSLULWXDOJDLQEHFDXVHKHODFNVDJRRGZLOO/HWXVVD\WKDWVRPHRQHUREVLQ
RUGHUWRIHHGWKHSRRULQWKLVFDVHHYHQWKRXJKWKHLQWHQWLRQLVJRRGWKHupright-­

51  
-RKQ3DXO,,Veritatis  splendor$XJXVWQ
52  
,ELG

 THE  NATIONAL  CATHOLIC  BIOETHICS  QUARTERLY      SPRING  2013

QHVVRIWKHZLOOLVODFNLQJ&RQVHTXHQWO\QRHYLOGRQHZLWKDJRRGLQWHQWLRQFDQEH
H[FXVHG´
7KHZKROHDUJXPHQWRIWKRVHZKRFLWHVeritatis  splendor  QDVDQDUJXPHQW
MXVWLI\LQJLQWHQWLRQDOLVPUHVLGHVLQWKHHUURQHRXVYLHZWKDWEHFDXVHWKHREMHFWRIWKH
PRUDODFWLVQRWPHUHO\DQGUHGXFWLYHO\SK\VLFDOWKHUHIRUHWKHLQWHJUDOQDWXUHDQGper  
se  HIIHFWVRIWKHDFWLRQFKRVHQDUHQRWLQFOXGHGZLWKLQWKHREMHFWRIWKHPRUDODFWDQG
VRPD\EHGLVUHJDUGHGDVFUDVVO\SK\VLFDODQGVXEUDWLRQDO%XWWRVD\WKDWWKHREMHFW
RIPRUDODFWLRQLVQRWPHUHO\DSK\VLFDOGDWXPLVQRWWRVD\WKDWRXUGHOLEHUDWHPRUDO
FKRLFHVDQGDFWLRQVGRQRWH[WHQGWRWKHHPEUDFHRISDUWLFXODUPRUDOFDXVDOLWLHV,I
,GHVLJQWRFKRRVHDQGHQDFWDVDPHDQVVRPHDFWLRQWKDWWHUPLQDWHVGLUHFWO\LQDQ
LQQRFHQWVRDVWRKDUPWKDWSHUVRQ,FDQQRWIUHHP\VHOIRIPRUDOFXOSDELOLW\IRUWKLV
GLUHFWKDUP,KDYHFKRVHQPHUHO\EHFDXVH,DPVHHNLQJVRPHRWKHUJRRGDQGH[FOXGH
WKHHYLOFDXVDOLW\IURPWKHGHVFULSWLRQRIP\DFWLRQ
6XSSRVHWKDWVRPHRQHZHUHLQDTXHXHIRUDOLIHVDYLQJWKHUDS\SUHFHGHGE\
VHYHUDORWKHUVEXWZLWKDSURJQRVLVVROLPLWHGWKDWLWVHHPHGKHZRXOGQRWOLYHORQJ
HQRXJKWRUHFHLYHWKHUDS\:HUHWKLVSURVSHFWLYHSDWLHQWWRNLOORQHRIWKRVHLQOLQH
DKHDGRIKLPWRUHPRYHWKHLPSHGLPHQWWRUHFHLYLQJWUHDWPHQWZRXOGWKLVDFWLRQ
PHUHO\ EH RQH RI ³UHPRYLQJ REVWDFOHV WR OLIHVDYLQJ WKHUDS\"´ 6XUHO\ WKLV PLJKW
DGHTXDWHO\GHSLFWWKHDJHQW¶VSURSRVDOIRUDFWLRQLQWHUPVRIWKHratio  RIWKHDSSH-­
WLELOLW\RIWKHDFWWRWKHDJHQWDQGWKHLQWHQWLRQRIWKHHQG3HUKDSVWKHDJHQWDFWVLQ
WKLVZD\ZLWKJUDYHUHOXFWDQFHDQGGLVWDVWHVROHO\EHFDXVHWKLVLVWKHRQO\PDQQHU
RIREWDLQLQJOLIHVDYLQJWKHUDS\%XWPRUDOO\ZRXOGQRWVXFKDQDFWLRQFRQVWLWXWH
ZURQJIXOKRPLFLGH"
7KHGHVFULSWLRQRIDQDJHQW¶VLQWHQWLRQLQKLVSURSRVDOIRUDFWLRQLVLQVXI¿FLHQW
WRFRQVWLWXWHWKHREMHFWRIWKHDFWXQOHVVLWLQFOXGHVWKHLQWHJUDOQDWXUHDQGper  se  
HIIHFWVRIWKHFKRVHQDFWLRQ7KHLQWHJUDOQDWXUHDQGper  seHIIHFWVRIWKHFKRVHQ
DFWLRQDUHLQFOXGHGLQWKHREMHFWEHFDXVHLQFKRRVLQJVXFKDQDFWLRQDVPHDQVWKH
will  goes  out  to  that  action  and  its  per  se  HIIHFWV$OWKRXJKZHFDQDJUHHWKDWWKLV
RFFXUVXQGHUWKHDVSHFWRUIRUPDOratioRIWKHLQWHQWLRQRIDQHQGWKHUHVXOWLVWKH
VDPH7KXVWKHRQHZKRPXUGHUVWKRVHLQIURQWRIKLPLQWKHTXHXHIRUOLIHVDYLQJ
WKHUDS\VRWKDWKHKDVDFKDQFHWRUHFHLYHLWLQWLPHWRVDYHKLVOLIHLVRQHZKR
FKRRVHVWRGRPXUGHUIRUWKHVDNHRIUHPRYLQJLPSHGLPHQWVWROLIHVDYLQJWKHUDS\
7KLVLVWRVD\WKDWWKHREMHFWLVQRWPHUHO\D³SRVLW´RU³SURSRVDO´RU³LQWHQWLRQ´EXW
is  what  is  done  under  the  ratio  RIWKHHQGVRXJKW$FFRUGLQJO\WKHHQGVRXJKWDQG
the  ratio  RIWKHDSSHWLELOLW\RIWKHDFWWRWKHDJHQWGRQRWVXI¿FHWRPDNHWKHQDWXUH
RIDFWLRQPRUDOO\LUUHOHYDQWQRULVWKHQDWXUHRIIUHHO\FKRVHQDFWLRQDPHUHO\DQG
FUDVVO\SK\VLFDOGDWXPWKDWLVRIQRPRUDOVLJQL¿FDQFH<HWIRUWKH11/7RQO\ZKDW
LVLQFOXGHGLQWKHSURSRVDORQHIRUPXODWHVDQGQRWWKHLQWHJUDOQDWXUHDQGper  se  
HIIHFWVRIFKRVHQDFWLRQLVKHOGWREHHVVHQWLDOWRWKHREMHFWRIWKHDFW
7KHYHU\ODQJXDJHRIVeritatis  splendor  QLVFRQWUDU\WRWKH11/7UHDGLQJ
LQDVPXFKDVLWHPSKDVL]HVWKDWno  matter  how  laudable  one’s  intention  may  be,  it  
cannot  justify  the  choice  to  perform  certain  types  of  action&OHDUO\ZKHWKHURQHLV
SHUIRUPLQJDQDFWRIVXFKDW\SHLVQRWPHUHO\DIXQFWLRQRIZKHWKHURQHFDQIRUZDUG
DSURSRVDOIRUDFWLRQZKRVHGHVFULSWLRQDYRLGVPHQWLRQLQJWKHW\SHRIDFWLRQWKDWLV
FKRVHQ7KHVH³W\SHV´DUHQRWWKHPVHOYHVPHUHIXQFWLRQVRIWKHDJHQW¶Vdescription
WKH\DUHIXQFWLRQVRIWKHQDWXUHRIWKHDFWLRQLWVHOIDVDQREMHFWRIFKRLFH  which  is  


 LONG      FUNDAMENTAL  ERRORS  OF  THE  NNLT

LUUHGXFLEOHWRSK\VLFDOFDXVDOLW\EXWGRHVQRWH[FOXGHLWRUH[LVWZLWKRXWLW,IWKH
DJHQWKLPVHOI³FRQVWLWXWHV´WKHPRUDOREMHFWZKROHFORWKWKHQWKHUHLVSUHFLVHO\QR
QRUPZKDWVRHYHUIRUKXPDQDFWLRQDQGWKHSDVVDJHVRIVeritatis  splendor  QWKDW
LQGLFDWHVXFKDQRUPUHVWUDLQLQJFKRLFHZRXOGEHYDLQDQGRWLRVHWDQWDPRXQWWRWKH
GLUHFWLRQWKDWRQHPD\QRWDFWXQGHUDFHUWDLQdescription³,DPQRWVXIIRFDWLQJD
FKLOG,DPSUHYHQWLQJG\QDVWLFFLYLOZDU´%XWWKHZKROH&DWKROLFPRUDOWUDGLWLRQ
WHDFKHVWKDWRQHPD\QRWFKRRVHDFWLRQVRIDFHUWDLQQDWXUHLUUHVSHFWLYHRQH¶VIXUWKHU
LQWHQWLRQRUSUHIHUUHGGHVFULSWLRQRIDFWLRQ
,WVKRXOGEHFOHDUWKDWIRURQHSODXVLEO\WRLQWHUSUHWDSDSDOHQF\FOLFDODVYLWLDW-­
LQJWKHSULRUXQGHUVWDQGLQJRIWKH&KXUFK¶VPRUDOWUDGLWLRQUHTXLUHVIDUPRUHWKDQ
DGXELRXVDQGLQWHQVLYHO\FRQWURYHUWLEOHDQDO\VLVRIRQHOLQHRIDQHQF\FOLFDO%XW
WKHOLQHRIWKHHQF\FOLFDOLVQRWHYHQREVFXUHLQYLHZLQJDFWLRQIURPWKHYLHZSRLQW
RIWKHDJHQWRQHPXVWQRWFRQVLGHUZKDWLVGRQHDORQHEXWWKHratio  under  which  it  
is  done.  This  does  not  at  all  reduce  WKHREMHFWPHUHO\WRWKHratio  under  which  the  
DJHQWSHUIRUPVKLVDFWLRQEHFDXVHWKHREMHFWRIWKHDJHQW¶VDFWLRQLVQRWPHUHO\WKH
ratioRIWKHDFW¶VDSSHWLWLELOLW\WRWKHDJHQWEXWDOVRWKHPRUDOO\VLJQL¿FDQWFDXVDOLW\
RIWKHDFWLRQWRZKLFKKLVZLOOGHOLEHUDWHO\H[WHQGVLQFKRLFHDQGDFWLRQ
2IFRXUVHRWKHUH[DPSOHVDUHFRPPRQO\EURXJKWIRUZDUGLQIDYRURIWKH11/7
DQDO\VLV,WLVQRWXQXVXDOWRKHDUWKHDUJXPHQWWKDWDQDOJHVLFVXVHGLQFDULQJIRU
WHUPLQDOSDWLHQWVIXQFWLRQGLUHFWO\ERWKZKHQLQWHQGHGIRUWKHVDNHRINLOOLQJWKH
SDWLHQWLQDQDFWRIHXWKDQDVLDDQGZKHQLQWHQGHGPHUHO\IRUWKHVDNHRISDLQUHOLHI
ZKHQWKH\PD\DFFLGHQWDOO\VSHHGWKHGHDWKRIWKHUHFLSLHQW:KDWWKHQLVWKHGLI-­
IHUHQFH",QWKHSHUPLVVLEOHXVHRIDQDOJHVLFVGHDWKLVGHQRPLQDWHGDVDFFLGHQWDO
QRWPHUHO\EHFDXVHLWLVQRWLQWHQGHGDVDQHQGEXWDOVREHFDXVHWKHFKRVHQGRVDJH
LVVHOHFWHGSUHFLVHO\DVQRWNQRZDEO\VXI¿FLHQWWRNLOOWKHUHIRUHWKHGHDWKLVULJKWO\
MXGJHGWREHDFFLGHQWDO
7KHFULWLFDOSRLQWLVHVWDEOLVKHGE\DVNLQJWKHIROORZLQJ*UDQWHGWKDWIRUVXI-­
¿FLHQWUHDVRQLWLVOLFLWWR³DWWULWH´WKHJRRGRIOLIH²WKDWLVWRZHDNHQWKHSDWLHQWLQD
ZD\WKDWULVNVVKRUWHQLQJOLIH²LVLWOLFLWWRDGPLQLVWHUDGRVDJHRIDQDOJHVLFVFOHDUO\
VXI¿FLHQWLPPHGLDWHO\WRNLOOWKHUHFLSLHQW":KLOHRQHPD\MXVWLI\WKHDGPLQLVWUDWLRQ
RIDQDPRXQWRIPRUSKLQHVXI¿FLHQWWRGLPLQLVKSDLQZHDNHQLQJWKHSDWLHQWDQG
LQYROYLQJDKLJKHUULVNRIGHDWKDVDUHVXOWWKLVLVTXLWHGLIIHUHQWIURPDGPLQLVWHULQJ
DGRVDJHWKDWE\LWVYHU\QDWXUHZLOONLOOWKHSDWLHQW7RGRWKHODWWHULVGHOLEHUDWHO\
WRFKRRVHWRFDXVHWKHGHDWKRIWKHSDWLHQWHYHQLIRQH¶VLQWHQWLRQLVQRWWRNLOOEXW
WRGRVRPHWKLQJHOVHHJUHPRYHVXIIHULQJRUDOWHUQDWLYHO\WHVWWKHSDLQUHOLHYHU
IRUWKHVDNHRIIXWXUHSDWLHQWVERWKFOHDUO\JRRGHQGVEXWQRWVXI¿FLHQWWRMXVWLI\
WKHLQWULQVLFHYLORIZURQJIXOKRPLFLGH,IWKLVGLVWLQFWLRQLVMXVWL¿DEOHLWZRXOG
VHHPWKDWWKHXVHRIWKHH[DPSOHRISDLQUHOLHIIRUWHUPLQDOSDWLHQWVE\WKHGHIHQG-­
HUVRILQWHQWLRQDOLVPLVVRSKLVWLFDOLQWKHH[WUHPHGHSHQGLQJRQWKHFRQIRXQGLQJRI
VRPHWKLQJZKROO\DFFLGHQWDOWRDQDFWZLWKVRPHWKLQJHVVHQWLDOWRLW7RZHDNHQWKH
SDWLHQWLQVHHNLQJWKHJRRGRISDLQUHOLHIDQGVRWRUXQDKLJKHUULVNRIDFFLGHQWDO
GHDWKLVQRWRILWVHOIWRFKRRVHWRLQWURGXFHDQHZFDXVHRIGHDWKDQGVRIRUVXI-­
¿FLHQWUHDVRQLVMXVWL¿DEOH
1RWLFHKRZLQWKHFDVHRIWKHWUHDWPHQWRIDWHUPLQDOSDWLHQWLWLVQRWWKHDFW
DVPHUHO\SK\VLFDODVLQWHQWLRQDOLVWVDOOHJHQRWLQWKHODQJXDJHRIVeritatis  splen-­
dor  Q³DSURFHVVRUDQHYHQWRIWKHPHUHO\SK\VLFDORUGHUWREHDVVHVVHGRQWKH


 THE  NATIONAL  CATHOLIC  BIOETHICS  QUARTERLY      SPRING  2013

basis  RILWVDELOLW\WREULQJDERXWDJLYHQVWDWHRIDIIDLUVLQWKHRXWVLGHZRUOG´EXW

UDWKHUWKHDFWSUHFLVHO\DVSUHVHQWLQJLWVHOIDVDQREMHFWRIFKRLFHZKLFKLVGHFLVLYH
,IRQHDGPLQLVWHUVDQDQDOJHVLF53LQDGRVDJHWKDWLVWRWKHEHVWRIRQH¶VNQRZOHGJH
QRWVXI¿FLHQWRILWVHOIWRNLOOEXWZKLFKRQHNQRZVZLOOZHDNHQWKHSDWLHQWDQGWKXV
ULVNVDWWHQXDWLQJRUVKRUWHQLQJWKHJRRGRIOLIHDQGLQFUHDVLQJWKHULVNRIGHDWKDQG
LIWKHQGHDWKDFFLGHQWDOO\HQVXHVWKLVLVQRWDZURQJIXOKRPLFLGH+RZHYHULIRQH
SULQFLSDOO\VHHNVRQO\SDLQUHOLHIEXWNQRZLQJO\DGPLQLVWHUVDGRVDJHFOHDUO\VXI-­
¿FLHQWLPPHGLDWHO\WRNLOOWKLVLVREMHFWLYHO\DQDFWRIDWWHPSWHGZURQJIXOKRPLFLGH
HYHQLIRQO\SDLQUHOLHILVVRXJKW)XUWKHULWUHPDLQVDQHYLOFKRLFHHYHQVKRXOGWKH
SDWLHQWQRWGLHDVDUHVXOWEHFDXVHLQFKRRVLQJDGRVDJHRILWVHOIMXGJHGWREHOHWKDO
SULRUWRDFWLRQRQH¶VZLOOHPEUDFHVDQDFWLRQWKDWLVZURQJIXOHYHQVKRXOGDGLYLQH
PLUDFOHIRUHVWDOOLWVHYLO
&KRRVLQJWRNLOODQLQQRFHQWDVSDUWRISDLQUHOLHILVREMHFWLYHO\GLIIHUHQWIURP
DWWHQXDWLQJWKHJRRGRIOLIHRIDQLQQRFHQWDQGWDNLQJDFDOFXODWHGO\KLJKHUULVNRI
GHDWKWRDYHUWWKHKRUURURIXQUHPLWWLQJSDLQ:HIUHTXHQWO\VXEMHFWWKHJRRGRIOLIH
WRKLJKHUULVNVRIKDUPRUGHDWKIRUWKHVDNHRIJRRGHQGV6XFKFKRLFHWRULVNOLIHLV
ZKROO\RWKHUWKDQDFWLQJGLUHFWO\WRFDXVHGHDWK$UHDOLVWUDWKHUWKDQORJLFLVWDFFRXQW
RIWKHREMHFWRIPRUDODFWLRQLQFOXGHVQRWRQO\WKHDJHQW¶VLGHDWLRQDOSURSRVDOIRU
DFWLRQEXWWKHGHOLEHUDWHO\FKRVHQDFWLRQLQLWVLQWHJUDOQDWXUHDQGper  se  HIIHFWV
7KXVIRUH[DPSOHLQWKHXVHRIVDOSLQJHFWRP\LQWXEDOSUHJQDQF\UHPRYLQJ
DGDPDJHGWXEHLVPHGLFDOO\LQGLFDWHGWRKHOSWKHPRWKHUWKHKDUPWKDWHQVXHV
WRWKHFKLOGLVQHLWKHUWKHSULQFLSDOUHDVRQIRUDFWLQJnor  does  the  action  directly  
ZKLFKUHIHUVWRPRUDOO\VLJQL¿FDQWcausalityWHUPLQDWHLQWKHERG\RIWKHFKLOG
LQDGHVWUXFWLYHPDQQHU,QVWHDGLWWHUPLQDWHVLQWKHWXEHDQGLQVXFKDZD\DVWR
FRUUHFWDPHGLFDOGHIHFW,QGHHGLWLVQRWPRYLQJDSDUWRIWKHWXEHDVVXFKZKLFK
UHQGHUVWKHKDUPWKDWHQVXHVWRWKHFKLOGSUHGLFWDEOHEXWUDWKHUWKHIDFWWKDWWKHFKLOG
VHHPLQJO\LVZKHUHLWFDQQRWEHVXVWDLQHGLQOLIHDQGFDQQRWEHPRYHGWRDQ\SODFH
ZKHUHLWFDQEHVXVWDLQHG+RZGLIIHUHQWDUHWKHVHFDVHVIURPFUDQLRWRP\ZKHUH
WKHFKLOG¶VKHDGLVGLUHFWO\DQGGHOLEHUDWHO\FUXVKHGKRZGLIIHUHQWIURPDERUWLRQLQ
ZKLFKWKHFKLOGLVHVVHQWLDOO\FUXVKHGRUODFHUDWHGWRGHDWKRUGLVPHPEHUHGWRJHWKHU
ZLWKLWVSODFHQWDORUJDQRIR[\JHQDWLRQDQGQXWULWLRQ
7KXVLWPXVWEHVDLGWKDWWKH11/7UHDVRQLQJRIIHUVOLWWOHWRQRLPSURYHPHQW
ZKDWVRHYHURYHUWKHSURSRUWLRQLVWRUFRQVHTXHQWLDOLVWDFFRXQWVDYHWKDWLWLVOHVVRYHUW
DQGVRSHUKDSVSLRXVO\REVFXUHVWKHHQRUPLW\RIWKHGHURJDWLRQRIWKHPRUDOODZWKDW
LWUHSUHVHQWV7KHLQWHQWLRQDOLVWDFFRXQWRIDFWLRQWKHRU\LVGHFHSWLYHLQDVPXFKDV
LWDOORZVXVHRIWKHODQJXDJHRI³LQWULQVLFHYLOV´ZKLOHQRQHWKHOHVVFRQVWUXLQJWKLV
ODQJXDJHLQVXFKDPDQQHUWKDWLQIDFWDQ\WKLQJ²VXEMHFWRQO\WRDQDJHQW¶VRZQ
VHOIGHVFULSWLRQRIDSURSRVDOIRUDFWLRQ²PD\EHGRQH  7KDWLVWRVD\LQWKH11/7
DFFRXQWRQO\WKHFRJQLWLYHSURSRVDORIWKHDJHQWDQGQRWWKHGHOLEHUDWHO\FKRVHQ
FDXVDOLW\RIWKHDFWLRQSURYLGHVPRUDOGH¿QLWLRQThis  is  the  result  of  adopting  a  
logicist  rather  than  realist  starting  point  in  one’s  object  theory.,QGHHGLWLVDVSHFX-­
ODWLYHHUURUZLWKSUDFWLFDOLPSOLFDWLRQVWKHYHU\WKLQJWKDWWKH11/7PDLQWDLQVWR
EHLPSRVVLEOHEXWZKLFKLVWKHZHOOVSULQJRILWVPDQ\HUURUV

53  
2IFRXUVHWKLVLVLQWKHFDVHRIDG\LQJSDWLHQWZKHUHVXFKDFKRLFHLVLQWHOOLJLEOH
130
 LONG      FUNDAMENTAL  ERRORS  OF  THE  NNLT

,WLVWUXHWKDWDV$TXLQDVWHDFKHVZKHUHWKHREMHFWLVper  se  ordained  to  the  

HQGWKHVSHFLHVGHULYHGIURPWKHHQGLVPRVWIRUPDODQGFRQWDLQLQJ7KXVLQMXVW
GHIHQVLYHDFWLRQRQHPD\KDUPDQXQMXVWDVVDLODQWXQGHUWKHratioRIZDUGLQJRII
XQMXVWDVVDXOWLQVRIDUDVVXFKKDUPLVWKHRQO\SURSRUWLRQDWHPHDQVRIGHIHQVH55  
%XWWKLVLVDIDUFU\IURPGLUHFWO\NLOOLQJDQLQQRFHQWPHUHO\EHFDXVHRQHDOVRVHHNV
VRPHIXUWKHUJRRGHQGWKHDVVDLODQWLVDWOHDVWSHUIRUPDWLYHO\FXOSDEOHRIGHVWUXFWLYH
DJHQF\ZKHUHDVWKHIHWXVLVQRWVRPXFKDVFDSDEOHRIDJHQF\2QHPD\QRWGLUHFWO\
NLOODQLQQRFHQWHYHQWRVDYHRQH¶VRZQOLIH)XUWKHUWKHIHWXVLVQRWDQDVVDLODQW
EXWUDWKHUD³FRYLFWLP´LQFDVHVRIWXEDOSUHJQDQF\
A  Small  Error
7KHHDUOLHUFRPPHQWRIWKLVHVVD\UHJDUGLQJ³DVPDOOHUURULQWKHEHJLQQLQJ´
WKXVKDVDQLURQLFGLPHQVLRQ)RULWVKRXOGQRZEHFOHDUWKDWIURPWKHEHJLQQLQJWKH
HUURUVRIWKH11/7DUHJUHDWEXWLWVLPSOLFDWLRQVDUHHYHQJUHDWHULQGHHGVHLVPLF
LQWKHLUJUDYLW\$GRFWULQHDYDLODEOHDVDQ³LQWUD&DWKROLFVRXUFH´IRUWKHGHIHQVHRI
DERUWLRQDVDOLFLWPHDQVRIDGGUHVVLQJDSUHJQDQWZRPDQ¶VSXOPRQDU\K\SHUWHQVLRQ
IRUWKHFUXVKLQJRIIHWDOVNXOOVIRUHXWKDQDVLDWKURXJKGHOLEHUDWHDQDOJHVLFRYHUGRVH
DQGIRURWKHUVXFKHQRUPLWLHVad  infinitum²DOOIRUVRORQJDVRQHPHUHO\SURSRVHV
WKHUHE\WRDFKLHYHVRPHIXUWKHUJRRG²LVQRWDGRFWULQHWKDWFDQEHH[SHFWHGWR
QXUWXUHWKHWHOHRORJLFDOPRUDOG\QDPLVPRIWKH&DWKROLFLQWHOOHFWXDOWUDGLWLRQ
7KHUHDUHFRQVHTXHQFHVRIMXGJPHQWDQGWKHUHMHFWLRQRIWKH11/7PDQL-­
IHVWVWKHQHHGIRUDSURIRXQGO\GLIIHUHQWDSSURDFK:KDWLVUHTXLUHGLQVWHDGLVDQ
DSSURSULDWHO\VSHFXODWLYHHQJDJHPHQWZLWKWKHWHDFKLQJRI$TXLQDV7KLVLVQRWD
QHZDQVZHUDOWKRXJKLWDGYHUWVWRDGRFWULQHVRVWDUWOLQJO\SURIRXQGDVWREHQHZ
WRHDFKHQVXLQJJHQHUDWLRQ,WLVWLPHIRUWKHWRRZLGHVSUHDGde  factoGHURJDWLRQRI
WKHWHDFKLQJRI$TXLQDVDIWHU9DWLFDQ&RXQFLO,,WRHQG7KHUHLVPXFKZRUNWRGR


ST ,,, T  DUW  7KH QRUPDWLYH RUGHU RI HQGV VXIIHUV QR GHIHFW EXW KXPDQ
LQWHQWLRQPD\DQGWKHRUGHURIZKDWLVFKRVHQLQUHODWLRQWRLQWHQWLRQLVLPSRUWDQWHYHQLQ
FDVHVRIGHIHFWLYHLQWHQWLRQIRUXQGHUVWDQGLQJWKHVSHFLHVRIDQDFWLRQDVSHFLHVZKRVHJRRG
RUHYLOLVLQGHHGMXGJHGLQUHODWLRQWRXQL¿HGQRUPDWLYHWHOHRORJ\
55  
$V9LWRULDDUJXHVLQFDVHVZKHUHWKHRQO\PHDQVRIGHIHQVHLVOHWKDORILWVQDWXUH
LWLVGHIHQVHWKDWLVLQWHQGHGDVHQGDQGWKHOHWKDOLW\RIWKHFKRVHQDFWLRQEHFDXVHSHUVH
RUGDLQHGWRGHIHQVHWDNHVRQWKHVSHFLHVRIWKHHQGVRWKDWWKHZKROHDFWPD\EHZLOOHGEXW
QRWLQWHQGHGDVDQHQG³7RWXPLOOXGOLFHWYHOOHVHGQRQLQWHQGHUH´)UDQFLVFRGH9LWRULD
Comentarios  a  la  Secunda  secundae  de  Santo  TomasWRPDe  justitia,  HG9LQFHQWH%HOWUiQ
GH+HUHGLDBiblioteca  de  Teólogos  EspañolesYRO6DODPDQFD

%\ZKLFK,PHDQVRPHRQHERWKPRUDOO\DQGSHUIRUPDWLYHO\LQQRFHQW²WKHODWWHU
EHLQJUXOHGRXWE\WKHFDVHIRUH[DPSOHRIWKHPDQZLWKDEUDLQWXPRUZKREHFRPHVVXEMHFW
WR DJJUHVVLYH RXWEXUVWV DQG ZKRVH DFWLRQ UHQGHUV KLP D OHWKDO WKUHDW 7KH DFWLRQ LV QRW
PRUDOO\LPSXWHGWRKLPEXWGDQJHURXVDQGZURQJIXODFWLRQLVLPSXWHGWRKLPQRWDVPRUDO
agent  but  qua  DJHQWVLPSO\VSHDNLQJ7KXVEvangelium  vitae  n.  55  DFNQRZOHGJHVWKDWVXFK
DQLQGLYLGXDOPLJKWEHLQVRPHFDVHMXVWO\VODLQ³8QIRUWXQDWHO\LWKDSSHQVWKDWWKHQHHGWR
UHQGHUWKHDJJUHVVRULQFDSDEOHRIFDXVLQJKDUPVRPHWLPHVLQYROYHVWDNLQJKLVOLIH,QWKLV
FDVHWKHIDWDORXWFRPHLVDWWULEXWDEOHWRWKHDJJUHVVRUZKRVHDFWLRQEURXJKWLWDERXWHYHQ
WKRXJKKHPD\QRWEHPRUDOO\UHVSRQVLEOHEHFDXVHRIDODFNRIWKHXVHRIUHDVRQ´
131