Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Study site
can take place, provided the stigma (the female portion of the flower ('Simmonds', 'Tonnage',and 'Choquette')in FL indicatethat over
on which the pollen is deposited)hasnot yet senesced(Davenportet 857oof the maturefruit arederived from self-pollinatedflowers (Dav-
al.,1994). For most growing regions,however,it has beenassumed enport, unpublisheddata). Recentresearchexaminedthe rate of out-
that selfing should not be relied upon as the sole means of ovule crossingof'Hass' from coastalandinlandorchardsofCA (Kobayashi
'Hass' yield resultedfrom self pollination
fertilization(Peterson,1955).Accountsof single-cultivargrovespro- et al., 2000). Most of the
ducing high yields in the apparentabsenceof complementary culti- (about60 to 807o),althoughoutcrossingwas found to explain roughly
vars have been cited as evidencethat pollinizer interplantings to fa- l}Vo of the variance in yield. It is unclear, however, whether honey
cilitatepollination arenot necessary(Hodgson,1947;Gustafsonand bees were available to serve as pollinators in this study, since the
Bergh, 1966). More recentwork by Vrecenar-Gadus and Ellstrand presenceor absenceof honey beeswas not monitored(M. Clegg,L.
( 1985),however,showedthat single-cultivar groves canreceivesub- Francis,personalcommunication). Severalworkers have also exam-
stantial amounts of pollen from distant pollinizers in other groves. ined the relationshipbetweendistancefrom a pollinizer and outcross-
This meansthat high yields in single-cultivar orchards cannot neces- ing, aswell as yield. Although resultsfrom thesestudiesvary in their
sarily be interpretedas strictly the result of self-fertilization. magnitude and in their statistical significance, generalfindings indi-
catethat outcrossing(Degani et aL.,1991),aswell as yield (Ellstrand,
Recent observations of avocado floral behavior and pollination in 1992),conelatenegativelywith distancefrom a pollhizer.
southem FL, however, have prompted a reexamination of the ten-
dency of avocado to self-pollinate. Researchshowed that cross- The key to understandingthe importance of crossvs. self-pollination
pollination occurredin only about l7o of avocadoflowers, despitethe appearsto be the proportion of viable female organsthat persist into
presenceof honey bees and other pollinating insects in orchards. the male phase. Dry, Mediterraneanclimatesmay promote high cross
within flowers, without the aid of insects,occurredin vs. self-pollination ratios becauseof excessivedesiccationof stigmas
3l.lf-pollination
more than 957oof the pollinated flowers of most cultivars grown in in the male phase.Conversely,more humid conditions may promote
southemFL (Davenport,1989; Davenportet al.,1994). This is be- high ratesof selfpollination due to the increasednumber ofreceptive
cause,contrary to previous assumptions,a substantialpropotlion of stigmasin the male phase. Hence honey beesmay increasefruit yield
stigmasremain receptiveuntil the closeof the male stage(Davenport, in dry climates by increasingthe number of pollinated female phase
1986). Moreover, pollen typically disperseswithin thirty minutes af- flowers if sufficient hives are deployed to saturateboth the avocado
ter dehiscence(Davenport, 1998) and may, therefore, be efficiently orchardand the more attractiveneighboringflowering plants,whereas
transferredby wind or gravity within flowers to receptive,white stig- honey beesmay havelittle impact in conditions where self pollination
mas in the male phase, giving rise to self-pollination rates propor- predominates.
tional to the number of receptive stigmaspresent.
2. Honey bee behavioral genetics
Previous Australian research indicated that pollen tubes stop grow- Behaviorsof honeybeesvary amongindividuals, amonggeneticlines,
ing sometime within 24 hrs after pollen is deposited on the stigmas of and among races. Variation at all these levels has an important ge-
flowers that are in their male-phase (Sedgley, 1977a; 1977b). This nefic component(FrumhoffandBaker,1988;RobinsonandPage,1988).
finding supported the argument that fertilization cannot occur during Various behaviors that have been genetically selected have direct
the male phase. T. Davenport recently examined pollen-tube growth consequences for foraging performance. These include aspectsof
in male-phase pollinated flowers that still bore receptive stigmas (which
are still white, as opposed to brown and desiccated). He observed Table 1. Proportion
{o/oof total) of flowers in which the
pistils at 24 and48 hrs after pollen deposition in the male phaseand
pollen tube penetrated the ovule within 48 hr after hand
that, regardlessof the pollen source,eachcultivar displayed a pollination (HCP) from adjacent complementary
J.trd cross
substantialproportion of flowers in which ovules were penetratedby pollination (HSP) from same cultivar,
cultivar, hand close
a pollen tube within 48 hrs of pollination (Table l). These data sup- pollination (NSP) within the male phase
and natural self
port the contention that a substantialportion (-25Vo to -85Eo) of the
avocado flowers.
male-phasepollinated flowers are successfullyfertilized and that fer-
tilization generally occursbeIweenZ4 and 48 hrs after pollination. In Cultivar Race FloralType HCP HSP NSP
addition, outcross pollen from the complementary cultivars tested
appearedto have no benefit over (selfl pollen from the samecultivar, booln / GA/V B a1 A1
//"1 | 69.14 73.44
in terms of pollen-tube growth.
Brooks Late cAru 82.88 5 0 . 1 2 5 7 . 2 8
Selfing is clearly the primary mode of avocadopollination in FL, and Choquette CIW 59.94 70.0'1 75.84
results in successfulfertilization, but is it universally effective in the
production of a crop? Researchersin IS found that
'Hass' fruit de- Monroe c/w B 25.00 23.58 30.16
'Ettinger' (Goldring et al.,1981; Degani 64.68
rived from flowers pollinated by Simmonds 63.77 58.19
'Ardith' (Degani et al.,l99l) were preferentially re-
et al., 1989)and
Tonnage G,4/V R 39.77 57.27 56.46
tained on the plant all the way to fruit maturity, relative to fruit derived
from self-pollinatedflowers. Somepollinizers, however,havenot shown Tower 2 B 64.91 73.68 76.76
this effect when tested. Degani and Gazit (1984) observedthat the
proportion of self-pollinated progeny ranged from 8 to 93Voin caged and WestIndianracehvbrid;W is
Race:G/W is Cuatemalan
pairs of several cultivars. Likewise, studies of three cultivars West Indianrace.
leaming andmemory (Benataret al., 1995;BrandesandMenzel, 1990; visitation to avocadoby NWC beesas comparedto IT beesat the Orr
Brandeset al., 1998),flightrange (Gary andWitherell, 1977),andthe Farm in Somis. Differences betweenthe races,however,were negli-
tendencyto collect nectaror pollen (Hellmich et al', 1985; Calderone gible at ACW (Fig. 1). In IS, honey was extractedfrom eachhive
and Page,1988;Gordon etal.,1995:Page,1999), as well as actual separatelyat the end ofthe seasonand PSL concentrationwas deter-
preferencesfor certain crops over others(Nye and Mackenson, 1968, mined for eachhoney sample. The honey yield from NWC beeswas
1970). Through artificial selection,lines with significantly betterper- significantly greaterthan that of IT bees. Additionally, at one of the
formance in desiredtraits can be createdwithin a few generations. sites,the honey collectedfrom the NWC hives had significantly more
PSL and tendedto be darker. Color is anotherindicator of visitation to
One of the most successfulbreeding programs in the U.S. is that of avocado,as avocadohoneyhas a molasses-likecolor. The resultsof
the New World Carniolanhoneybee(NWC) (Cobey,L999),atacethat the honey data support the hypothesis that NWC honey bees are
is now used extensively. It was observedat ACW Farm in southern more attracted to avocado than IT honey bees. They also suggest
CA that NWC beeswere very active on avocado,even though com- that the strength with which honey bees are attractedto avocado is
peting vegetation was in bloom in the surrounding area. Such levels influenced by competing forage, becausedifferences between the
of activity were not observedon nearby farms where Italian (IT) honey races were more pronouncedat some sites than others.
beeswere commonly employed(R. Hofshi, personalcommunication).
These observations raised the hypothesis that NWC bees have a 2. Effect of pollinizing cultivar on'Hass' yield
greater genetic predisposition to avocado visitation than IT honey M. L. Arpaia and B. Faber setup a pollinizer (B-flower type cultivar)
bees. trial in Oxnard, CA in 1998. The goal of the trial is to quantify potential
'Hass' yield in relation to nearest pollinizer type at{,
differences in
'Hass' cultivar is of the A-flow-) I
II. Pretiminary results from experiments in Israel and California the distancefrom the pollinizer. The
'Hass' with rows of differr
7. Honey bee race-speciilc visitation to uvocado type. The trial grove contains 6 blocks of I
'Hass'. follow- |
Colonies of NWC and IT honey beeswere placedin equal numbersin ent pollinizers interplantedwith every 6ft row of 'Bacon'.The 'Ettinger',
two avocado orchards each in IS and CA. Various techniqueswere ing B-flower types are included as pollinizers: I
'Z:utano','Fuerte','Marvel', 'Nobel', and'SirPrize'. 'Harvest'.an A-
employed to look for race-specificdifferencesin the bees' visitation |
to avocado. Avocado nectar is unusual in that it contains a 7-carbon flower type, is also included. The latter four cultivars are new selec- |
(7C) sugar,perseitol (PSL), and its 7C precursor,D-mannoheptulose. tions from the UC Riverside AvocadoBreedingProgram,whereasthe I
These are the major transport sugarsin the avocado tree (Liu et al., first 4 cultivars are long-used standards. Fruit yield data were col- |
'Hass' and pollinizers in 3 experimentalblocks
1995, 1999). PSL has been found in the nectar of all avocado cultivars lectedfrom a subsetof I
not
tested to date, and has not been found in the main flora competing during March 2001. The preliminary harvestresults. which have I
with avocado,suchascitrus or wild mustardflowers (Ish-Am, 1994)' yet been statistically analyzed,are presentedin Figure 2. The data I
the
Therefore,PSL offers a tool for measuringhoney bee nectarforaging corroborates the fruitlet count data that was presented both at I
bee race, foragers were FaIl2000 Avocado Research Symposium and at recent avocado grower
activity on avocadobloom. For eachhoney I
caught upon their return to the hive. Honey-stomachcontents were meetings. This data strongly suggeststhat there can be a distance I
'Hass' yield as related to the distance from the pollinizer.
then collected from each bee and analyzed for the presenceof PSL effect on I
using High PerformanceLiquid Chromatography. ln Callfomia, 21.67o The data also suggeststhat there may be pollinizer varietal effects on I
'Hass' yield. The datafrom this first year showsthat the highestfruit
(overall) of beesreturning to hives had PSL in their honey stomachs, I
'Zutano'
meaning that an averugeof 22Voof nectar-foraging trips from a given counts were obtained when 'Bacon'. was the pollinizer variety fol- |
'Ettinger' and then Of the 2 unreleased"B" flower I
hive were to avocado. There was a non-significant trend toward more lowed by rl
\ti
Fruit Count
t20
Figure2. The influenceof pollinizerson
100 'Hass'fruityieldin March2001. Datawere
collectedfrom'Hass'trees locatedat vary-
80 ing distancesfrom interplantedrows of
pollinizersin a grovecontaininghoneybees
60 at a densitvof 2.5 hives/acre.
40
20
0
Zttano Ettinger Bacon Marvel SirPrize Fuerte Nobel Harvest
NearestPollinizer Variety
'Marvel'
selections, it appearsthat the may also serve as a Operating assumptions and costs
good pollen donor. This is of interest since the 'Marvel' tree is con-
siderablysmallerthanthe 3 top pollinizer varieties. Henceour prelimi- Preplant and P lanting: Land preparationcosts$816/acre.Land prepa-
nary work confirms previous observationsby others on the potential ration is performed on a custom basis and includes removing trees,
benefit of using pollinizers to boost the yield of 'Hass' avocadoin subsoiling, and leveling. To determine planting costs, I based this
Califomia. analysison 134 treesper acre(18' x I 8' spaceplanting). The cost of
planting is calculated at$I4.20ltree ($12.20 to purchasethe tree and
III. Futuredirections $2.00 for labor to plant trees).I am assumingthere is a loss of 2 trees/
We plan to continue the studies outlined above with ongoing fund- acre in the first season.These are replanted inyear 2.
ing from the California Avocado Commission (to A. E. Fetscher,N.
Waser,T. Davenport, and T. Chao). In the upcoming season,we will Irrigation: Based on the lemon production cost study, the average
collect additional datafrom the pollinizer site to determineif pattems cost of water purchasedfrom the Coastalregion of VenturaCo. is $ 190
detectedfrom the 2000 fruiting seasonare repeated. We also will per acre-foot. The amount of water applied is estimatedto be 4 to 9
monitor the incidence of receptive stigmas persisting into the male acre-inches/acreduring the first two yea.rsof establishmentand 16 to
phaseof flowers at this site, as well as the frequency of visitation by 20 acre-inches/acreduring years three to five. After the trees have
both NWC and IT honey beesto 'Hass' and the other cultivars, and reached full production, water application is assumedat an annual
we will study floral biology and phenological pattems of the various r ateof 24 acre-inches/acre.
cultivars. In addition,we will examinea similar setof variablesin other
orovesin Ventura County CA and elsewhere. Prune and Sucker: We calculatedpruning and suckering costsbased
\./ on data we have for lemon production. These operationscost about
$100/acreduring the first and secondyears of establishment,$2201
acreduring the third and fourth years,and about $500/acreduring the
fifth and production years. Because these operations are usually
performed on a conffact or custom basis, they are charged on a per
acrebasis.
Cherimoya production in the coastal regions of Califomia has been Fertilization: According to growers surveyed, the rate of nitrogen
i-.7eloling, and severalfarm advisorsat the University of California (N) appliedrangedfrom 17 lb/acrein the first yearto abott204lblacre
have been gathering information regarding production practicesand in production years. In addition, micronuffients (zinc sulfate and
the economicfeasibility of the crop. In this article,I provide estimates manganesesulfate) are each applied at the rate of 8 lb/acre eachyear
of the costsand capital needsfor producing cherimoya in the coastal during both establishmentand production periods. The cost of N is
regions of California, as well as a basis for evaluating profitability approximately $0.174b and micronutrients cost an averageof $0.37l
using gross and net margins to determine economic profit. Because lb. Fertilization is through the irrigation system.
values of land and water vary tremendouslywithin the region, I also
provide guidelines to adjust gross and net margins to accommodate Pollination: Hand pollination is requiredfor production of cherimoya
such variations. in Califomia. Hand pollination is estimatedto take about one hour/
acre for each application of pollen during years four and five of the
Determining Establishment and Production Costs establishmentperiod and two hours/acrefor each application of pol-
len during the production years. Annually, pollination is done every
Establishmentand production costs for cherimoya in the coastalre- other day for abouttwo months. This brings the total time for pollina-
gions of Califomia are determined basedon information gatheredfrom tion to 30 hours/acre each year during establishmentyears and 60
growers and shippers. In addition, growers and farm advisors sug- hours/acre each year during production. Costs of pollination are
gest that some of the cost information from a recent study conducted calculatedat labor rate.
for lemon production in Ventura County (Takeleet a1.,1997)will be
applicableto cherimoyaproduction. The following dataand assump- Labor: The averagecost of labor is estimatedto be $8.65/hour (the
tions have been used in determining the cost of cherimoya produc- samerate usedin lemon production costs)for both machine and non-
tion. machine workers. However, labor wage payrolls carry benefits in-