Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT
Background: Preeclampsia (PE) is a major sectional study design. Articles were collected
complication in pregnancy and a major cause of using PRISMA flow diagrams. Articles were
maternal and fetal morbidity and mortality. analyzed using the Review Manager 5.3.
Analysis of risk factors and prevention of pre- Results: A total of 9 articles were reviewed in
eclampsia are needed to reduce the adverse this study. The meta-analysis showed that
effects of preeclampsia. Important supplements vitamin D supplementation reduced the risk of
during pregnancy to prevent the increase in preeclampsia in pregnant women (RR= 0.45,
blood pressure of pregnant women are Vitamin 95% CI 0.32-0.63, p<0.001). The meta-analysis
D and calcium. This study aimed to analyze the of 8 articles also showed that calcium supple-
effect of vitamin D and calcium supplemen- mentation reduced the risk of preeclampsia in
tation on reducing the risk of preeclampsia. pregnant women with calcium (RR= 0.42; 95%
Subjects and Method: This study is a meta- CI= 0.31 - 0.57; p<0.001). This meta-analysis
analysis of a number of randomized controlled combines primary research from Iran, India,
trials. The articles used in this study were Bangladesh, South Africa, Cameroon, and
obtained from several databases including Saudi Arabia.
PubMed, Google Scholar, Springerlink, and Conclusion: Vitamin D and calcium supple-
Sciencedirect. The articles used in this study mentation reduces the risk of preeclampsia.
were those published from 2002-2020. The
article search was carried out by considering Keywords: vitamin D, Calcium, preeclampsia,
the eligibility criteria defined using the PICO randomized controlled trial
model. P: Pregnant women, I: vitamin D and
calcium, C: placebo, and O: preeclampsia. The Correspondence:
keywords to find articles are as follows: Fanny Kartika Fajriyani. Masters Program in
"Vitamin D" OR "Calcium" OR "Vitamin D and Public Health, Universitas Sebelas Maret, Jl. Ir.
Calcium" AND "preeclampsia" AND "Rando- Sutami 36A, Surakarta 57126, Central Java.
mized Controll Trials". The articles included in Email: fannykfa9@gmail.com.
this study are full text articles with Cross-
20 weeks of gestation. Most of the maternal obtained from several databases including
deaths caused by preeclampsia occur in PubMed, Google Scholar, Springerlink, and
developing countries and countries with Sciencedirect. Keywords to find articles are
low to middle income populations. The as follows: "Vitamin D" OR "Calcium" OR
biggest impact of preeclampsia occurs in "Vitamin D and Calcium" AND "Preeclamp-
developing countries where the incidence of sia" AND "Randomized Controll Trials"
preeclampsia is 20-80% of the maternal 2. InclusionCriteria
mortality rate (Dodd et al, 2014). The articles included in this study are full
Preeclampsia is still a theoretical paper articles with randomized controlled
disease. Various studies have not been able trials study design and in English. Appro-
to clearly penetrate the exact cause. The priate articles should mention the popula-
widely held theories are: (1) placental vas- tion of pregnant women, vitamin D and
cularization disorders; (2) placental ische- calcium interventions with the outcome of
mia, free radicals and endothelial dysfunc- preeclampsia. Articles must be published in
tion;(3) immunological intolerance between 2002-2020 with multivariate Relative Risk.
mother and fetus; (4) cardiovascular adap- 3. Exclusion Criteria
tation; (5) malnutrition; and (6) inflam- Articles excluded in this study were articles
mation (Cunningham et al., 2014). with pregnant women with gestational
Analysis of risk factors for preeclamp- hypertension and articles with results not
sia is needed to reduce the adverse effects randomized controlled trials.
of preeclampsia. The theory of nutrition is 4. Operational definition of variables
one of the theories adopted and during The article search was carried out by con-
pregnancy there will be changes in the sidering the eligibility criteria defined using
mother's metabolism. Important supple- the PICO model. The population in the
ments during pregnancy to prevent an study were pregnant women with interven-
increase in blood pressure for pregnant tion in the form of vitamin D and calcium,
women are calcium and vitamin D (Khaing the comparison was placebo and outcomes
et al., 2018). in the form of preeclampsia.
The role of calcium in the develop- Preeclampsia were pregnant women with
ment of the risk of preeclampsia during gestational age above 20 weeks where blood
pregnancy can be explained by low calcium pressure systole >140, diastole >90 and
levels or other factors during pregnancy urine protein +.
resulting in increased blood pressure. Preg- Calcium and vitamin D were given at
nant women with high calcium intake have gestational age with a calcium dose of
stable blood pressure levels which will 1,000-2,000 mg per day and vitamin D as
prevent hypertension, thereby reducing the much as 2000 IU per day.
risk of preeclampsia (Bhutta et al, 2012). 5. Data Analysis
This study aimed to examine the Data processing was carried out by the
effect of vitamin D and calcium supplemen- RevMan 5.3 by calculating the effect size
tation on reducing pre-eclampsia. and heterogeneity to determine which
research model was combined and formed
SUBJECTS AND METHOD the final meta-analysis result.
1. StudyDesign
This was a systematic review and meta-ana-
lysis. The articles used in this study were
www.theijmed.com 309
Fajriyani et al./ Vitamin D and Calcium Supplementation in Reducing Preeclampsia
Full text articles (n= 1,171) Deleted full text articles (n= 1,156)
Outcome not DM or obesity (n= 205)
Intervention was healthy food (n= 269)
Comparison was unhealthy food (n= 458)
Did not reporting aOR (n= 224)
Articles selected for meta
analysis (n= 15)
www.theijmed.com 310
Fajriyani et al./ Vitamin D and Calcium Supplementation in Reducing Preeclampsia
www.theijmed.com 311
Fajriyani et al./ Vitamin D and Calcium Supplementation in Reducing Preeclampsia
c. Summary Source
Table 1. Descriptions of primary studies included in the meta-analysis
P
Author Study
Title Country Sample Popula-
(Year) Design
tion
Sasan et The Effects of Vitamin D Supplement on Prevention Iran RCT 142 Pregnant Tot
al.(2017) of Recurrence of Preeklampsia in Pregnant Women women 50
with a History of Preeklampsia
Samimi et The effects of vitamin D plus calcium supplemen- Iran RCT 60 Pregnant V
al.(2017) tation onmetabolic profiles, biomarkers of inflam- women
mation, oxidative stress and pregnancy outcomes in
pregnant women at riskfor pre-eclampsia
Sablok et al. Supplementation of Vitamin D in pregnancy and its India RCT 165 Pregnant V
(2015) correlation with feto-maternal outcome. women
Roth et al. Randomized plasebo-controlled trial of high-dose Bangla- RCT 160 Pregnant V
(2013) prenatal third-trimester vitamin D3 desh women
supplementation in Bangladesh:
Karamali et Effects of high-dose Vitamin D supplementation on Iran RCT 60 Pregnant V
al. (2015) metabolic status and pregnancy outcomes women
inpregnant women at risk for pre-eclampsia
Naghshineh Effect of vitamin D supplementation in the reduce Iran RCT 60 Pregnant V
et al. (2016 risk of preeklampsia in nulliparous women women
Jamilian et The effects of vitamin D and probiotic co-supple- Iran RCT 58 Pregnant Vit
al. (2015) mentation on glucosehomeostasis, inflammation, women IU
oxidative stress and pregnancy outcomesin
gestational diabetes: A randomized, double-blind,
Q3 plasebo-controlled trial
Asemi et al. Vitamin D3 alters Toll-like receptor 4 signaling in China RCT 60 Pregnant Vit
Fajriyani et al./ Vitamin D and Calcium Supplementation in Reducing Preeclampsia
c. Forest Plot
The results of the forest plot (Figure data is declared homogeneous (fixed effect
3) show that calcium supplementation model).
reduces the risk of preeclampsia. The meta- The funnel plot (Figure 4) shows a
analysis of RCT studies showed that publication bias which is characterized by
malaria infection increased the incidence of asymmetry of the right and left plots where
LBW by 0.42 times compared to placebo 1 and 1.5 and the right side plot have a
and was statistically significant (p <0.001). standard error between 0 and 0.5 The bias
The heterogeneity of the research data also occurs from an imbalance between the
shows that I2= 0% so that the spread of distances between studies both on the right
and left funnel plot.
d. Funnel Plot
www.theijmed.com 314
Fajriyani et al./ Vitamin D and Calcium Supplementation in Reducing Preeclampsia
www.theijmed.com 317
Fajriyani et al./ Vitamin D and Calcium Supplementation in Reducing Preeclampsia
study no serious side effects of calcium carbohydrates increased the risk of obesity
were reported. in adults (aOR= 1.42; 95% CI= 1.21 to 2.66;
The dose of calcium supplementation p<0.001). This meta-analysis combines 9
ranges from 500 mg/ day to 2 g/ day. One primary studies using a cross-sectional
study demonstrated a statistically signifi- design from Ghana, China, Romania,
cant effect in a study using a 2 g / day dose Kenya, Nepal, Ireland, Korea, and Ethiopia.
(RR 0.39 [95% CI 0.23-0.67]). This
suggests that the most effective dose for AUTHOR CONTRIBUTION
calcium supplements during pregnancy is 2 Linda is the main researcher who selected
g/ day and is given starting from the begin- the topic, explored and collected research
ning of pregnancy (Uzan et al, 2011). data. Yulia and Eti played a role in
Lack of calcium intake can cause an analyzing data and conducting research
increase in parathyroid hormone (PTH), document reviews.
which causes an increase in intracellular
calcium. The increase in intracellular CONFLICT OF INTEREST
calcium will cause the smooth muscle of the There is no conflict of interest in this study.
blood vessels to experience vasoconstriction
so that blood pressure increases. Increased FUNDING AND SPONSORSHIP
blood pressure during pregnancy is a risk of This study is self-funded.
developing preeclampsia (Harera, 2012).
When calcium intake is low, the body ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
uses a series of mechanisms to maintain We are very grateful to the database
serum calcium ion levels. Ionized serum providers PubMed, Google Scholar and
calcium concentration depends on adequ- Springer Link.
ate calcium intake. In preeclampsia, there is
a decrease in extracellular calcium concen- REFERENCE
tration with a low level of ionized serum Ali AM, Alobaid A, Malhis TN, Khattab AF
calcium. Extracellular calcium concentra- (2019). Effect of vitamin D3 supple-
tions are very important for synthesis in mentation in pregnancy on risk of
endothelium such as prostacyclin and NO, pre-eclampsia - Randomized control-
so that calcium deficiency is not only mine- led trial. Clin Nutr. 38(2):557-563.
ral deficiency but also associated with phy- https://doi.org/10.1016/j.clnu.2018.0
siological effects caused by oxidative stress 2.023.
(Kanagal et al., 2014). Aghamohammadi A, Zafari M (2015). Cal-
This meta-analysis concluded that an cium supplementation in pregnancy
unhealthy diet high in fat, high sugar, high and prevention of hypertensive dis-
carbohydrates increased the risk of deve- orders in elderly women. Science Asia,
loping diabetes (aOR= 1.65; 95% CI= 1.29 41(4): 259–262. http://dx.doi.org/10-
to 2.11; p<0.001). This meta-analysis com- .2306/scienceasia1513-1874.2015.41.-
bines 9 primary studies using cross-sectio- 259.
nal designs from the countries of Swazi- Asemi Z, Hashemi T, Karamali M, Samimi
land, China, Ethiopia, Kenya, the United M, Esmaillzadeh A (2013). Effects of
States, and Malaysia. vitamin D supplementation on glu-
This meta-analysis concluded that an cose metabolism, lipid concentrati-
unhealthy diet high in fat, high sugar, high ons, inflammation, and oxidative
www.theijmed.com 318
Fajriyani et al./ Vitamin D and Calcium Supplementation in Reducing Preeclampsia
www.theijmed.com 319
Fajriyani et al./ Vitamin D and Calcium Supplementation in Reducing Preeclampsia
www.theijmed.com 320