Professional Documents
Culture Documents
xi
9781905816200 Cornwall in the Age of Rebellion (793j) - 8th pass.indd xi 16/06/2021 13:02:13
Cornwall in the Age of Rebellion
That the story so enthralled Nicholas Boson’s eldest son, John, is evidenced,
perhaps, in the fact that he christened his own daughter Katherin[e],
perpetuating the association into the next generation.
One cannot tell how widespread ‘a confused memory of rebellion nearly
two hundred years before’ may have been, nor whether it existed far (or
even at all) beyond the Cornish-language heartland of the far west. But
what is surely remarkable, is the possibility of a continuous popular memory
over two centuries of the events of 1497, passed in this instance from
father to son and on to his daughter. It lends credence to the argument that
there were threads of continuity between the rebellions of 1497 and 1549
and the events of the Civil War in Cornwall, in which elements of a
dynamic Cornish identity—or identities—coalesced and metamorphosed
to produce an enduring resistance to external intrusion and a stout defence
of the territory of Cornwall during the upheavals of Tudor and Stuart state
formation in the ‘Atlantic Archipelago’, the British and Irish Isles.
Although some recent scholarship has cast doubt on the strength (or even
existence) of such continuity, preferring to see the Cornish ‘commotions’
as discrete events, each with its own causes and motivations,2 it seems
clear that Cornwall ‘in the age of rebellion’ was characterized by a habitual
resistance to outside interference—political, cultural, religious, military—
which ultimately created the modern territorial identity so readily observ-
able by the end of the seventeenth century.
This argument is outlined in Chapter 1, newly written, where the ‘St
Tudy fragment’ of the late seventeenth century, with its catch-cry ‘And
shall Trelawny die?’, is presented as evidence of this continuity, popular
sentiment having not only ‘survived’ but been moulded and perpetuated
by the series of upheavals during the preceding two hundred years.
Subsequent chapters, some extensively rewritten, first appeared in the
series Cornish Studies, published by University of Exeter Press between
1993 and 2013, a period during which the place of Cornwall in the ‘new
British historiography’—the debates about the making of the Tudor and
Stuart state in the early modern period, not least the complex interactions
between England, Ireland, Scotland and Wales—was discussed with a
vigorous intensity. They culminate in this collection in the Annex ‘The
Recent Historiography of Early Modern Cornwall’, first published in
Cornish Studies in 2002, by the principal architect of the Cornish debate,
Mark Stoyle. As relevant today as when it was first written, Stoyle’s
xii
9781905816200 Cornwall in the Age of Rebellion (793j) - 8th pass.indd xii 16/06/2021 13:02:14
Introduction
xiii
9781905816200 Cornwall in the Age of Rebellion (793j) - 8th pass.indd xiii 16/06/2021 13:02:14
Cornwall in the Age of Rebellion
the far west of Cornwall, to the parishes west and south of Helston on the
Lizard and Penwith peninsulas, an error that again illustrated his limited
grasp of the cultural geography of early modern Cornwall. As Deacon
remarks, this limited grasp was a pity, for a better-informed discussion of
cultural diversity within Cornwall might have prompted that more
nuanced examination that he had called for, and which Mark Stoyle
had echoed.
In fact, evidence for this cultural diversity had already existed in a
number of forms, as the subsequent chapters in this book illustrate. Taken
together, they broadly support this volume’s theme: that against the back-
ground of Cornish cultural diversity, there was an enduring resistance to
intrusion from beyond the Tamar and a growing identification with the
territory of Cornwall itself. In Chapter 3, Matthew Spriggs asks ‘Where
was Cornish spoken and when?’. Drawing upon the research of Ken
George, Julyan Holmes, Oliver Padel and others, he arrives at an impres-
sive synthesis which, among other things, maps the retreat of Cornish
during the early modern period. In marked contrast to J.P.D. Cooper,
Spriggs indicates that by 1500 Cornish was still spoken in Cornwall up to
the Fowey-Camel line, and that even by 1600 was still on the lips of those
in many parts of mid-Cornwall as well as in the west. Given that external
intrusion was one of those factors influencing the retreat of Cornish, it is
interesting to note Spriggs’s comments on language decline and survival.
Anglo-centric historians have long considered the demise of Cornish to
have been ‘inevitable’, no matter how much this was to be regretted, but
Spriggs provides a new perspective when he observes that ‘minority’
languages under pressure from colonialism and assimilation can and do
survive. He cites the example of present-day Vanuatu, with its multiplicity
of separate languages, and notes how that in Melanesia as a whole, language
has been used effectively as a vehicle of community cohesion and resist-
ance. The wonder, then, as he says, may not be that Cornish died out but
rather that it did not survive as a community language.
In Chapter 4, the focus is on the aftermath of the 1497 rebellions.
A.L. Rowse imagined that post-1497 the Cornish may have retreated into
introspective isolation, stunned by defeat and impoverished by punish-
ment, licking their wounds as they turned in on themselves. Chapter 4,
however, offers an alternative interpretation, one that detects a lingering
resentment bubbling beneath the surface in Cornwall. Henry VII, it is
xiv
9781905816200 Cornwall in the Age of Rebellion (793j) - 8th pass.indd xiv 16/06/2021 13:02:15
Introduction
xv
9781905816200 Cornwall in the Age of Rebellion (793j) - 8th pass.indd xv 16/06/2021 13:02:15
Cornwall in the Age of Rebellion
xvi
9781905816200 Cornwall in the Age of Rebellion (793j) - 8th pass.indd xvi 16/06/2021 13:02:15
Introduction
xvii
9781905816200 Cornwall in the Age of Rebellion (793j) - 8th pass.indd xvii 16/06/2021 13:02:15
Cornwall in the Age of Rebellion
xviii
9781905816200 Cornwall in the Age of Rebellion (793j) - 8th pass.indd xviii 16/06/2021 13:02:15
Introduction
xix
9781905816200 Cornwall in the Age of Rebellion (793j) - 8th pass.indd xix 16/06/2021 13:02:15
Cornwall in the Age of Rebellion
xx
9781905816200 Cornwall in the Age of Rebellion (793j) - 8th pass.indd xx 16/06/2021 13:02:15
Introduction
preserve and revive the Cornish language, restoring its esteem as some-
thing of intrinsic value and worthy of study, now that, presumably, its
unflattering reputation as a subversive speech had begun to fade. But, as
we have seen, Nicholas Boson tied the Cornish language unequivocally to
the story of the ‘Duchesse of Cornwall’, and in so doing entwined it in
what appears to have been a half-remembered allusion to the rebellions of
1497, almost two centuries before. Reading against the grain, as it were, we
can see that Cornish retained echoes of its erstwhile status as the language
of resistance in the ‘age of rebellion’: ‘Rag gun Arlothas da / Ny en gweel
gun moyha’.
Notes
1 See Chapter 12.
2 Stuart Dunmore, ‘Language Decline and the “Theory of Cornish
Distinctiveness”: The Historiography of Language and Identity in Early
Modern Cornwall’, in A. Furchgott (ed.), Proceedings of the Harvard Celtic
Colloquium 31 (Cambridge, MA, 2011), pp. 91–105; see also Bernard Deacon,
Chapter 2.
3 John Chynoweth, Tudor Cornwall (Stroud, 2002), p. 23.
4 Dunmore, ‘Language Decline’, p. 93.
xxi
9781905816200 Cornwall in the Age of Rebellion (793j) - 8th pass.indd xxi 16/06/2021 13:02:15