Professional Documents
Culture Documents
PMnetwork Junio 2019
PMnetwork Junio 2019
PM NETWORK
MOONSTRUCK
AGAIN
PAGE 6
SPARKING
COLLABORATION
PAGE 24
THE VALUE
OF FAILURE
JUNE 2019, VOLUME 33, NUMBER 6
PAGE 56
48
56
30 AsStage Fright
threats to today’s events in- 48 The
Ready, Set, Stretch
next step up on the career 64 Outliers
Innovative
crease, project teams must rethink ladder might be just outside When an
risk to protect the masses. your comfort zone. organization’s
By Sarah Fister Gale By Ashley Bishel strategy shifts
or expands, the
40 Comprehensive 56
portfolio must
Full Service Silver Linings follow suit.
feedback and agile Capturing lessons learned can
By Novid Parsi
testing helped a U.S. city modernize help teams turn project failure
its system for helping residents. into long-term success.
By Hayley Grgurich By Matt Alderton
10 14
projects help improve patient safety.
VOICES
18 Inside Track: Healthy Outlook
Michael O’Connor, PhD, PMP, PgMP, director, strategy
and project management, Medtronic
28 Personal Power
By Javier Augusto González, PMP
ETC.
28 71 Good Reads From PMI
Risk management in projects,
programs and portfolios
72 Closing Thoughts
Karen Cedeño, PMP
DOWNLOAD THE PM NETWORK APP and read the magazine on your iPad, iPhone or iPod Touch or Android device.
Close Encounters
The world is moonstruck again. After several years of These aren’t the space race wars of the past
dormancy, projects to explore the moon are heating either. International collaboration is at the heart
up in a major way: China, India, Russia, Israel, Ger- of new exploration projects, with teams from
US$100
many and the United States all have projects to go various global outposts working together to
to the moon in some capacity this year. overcome technical hurdles. The United States’
million
It’s not just the quantity that’s noteworthy, NASA, for instance, is collaborating on data
though—these projects are trying to gener- exchanges with China’s project and helped pro-
The budget for ate major breakthroughs. In January, the China vide communication and technology support for
Panoramic
Precision
The project was as ambitious as the artwork is gar-
gantuan. Five years ago, the Atlanta History Center
launched a privately funded US$35 million initia-
tive to restore and relocate The Battle of Atlanta, a
133-year-old hand-painted panoramic artwork of
the U.S. Civil War that spans 371 feet (113 meters).
The room-filling cyclorama—one of only 19 such
works that exist—also showcases three-dimensional
figures in graduating scale along the base.
But before the team could move the 10,000- before the team settled on a 23,000-square-foot
pound (4,536-kilogram) piece roughly 10 miles (16 (2,137-square-meter) cylindrical space. The art- “I thought
kilometers) to its new home in Atlanta, Georgia, work itself underwent extensive renovations as when they
USA, it first had to assemble a team with the right well. That included replacing nearly 3,000 square unscrolled
know-how. That team would eventually span Swiss feet (279 square meters) of missing sections, which it, it would
and German art experts with experience in cyclo- had been cut out over the years to accommodate be blank.
ramas, architecture firms MSTSD and R.L. Brown
& Associates, and a small army of engineers, truck-
smaller displays. The project also restored more
than 100 of the 3D diorama figures at the base of
Paint chips
ers and riggers. In all, the team spent an estimated the painting.
on the
18,000 hours working on the project. For transport, the cyclorama had to be rolled up, floor.”
Relocation also included building a new facil- lowered into the open roof of the new facility, then —Sheffield Hale,
ity to house the painting, along with creating an unfurled. “I thought when they unscrolled it, it Atlanta History Center,
to The New Yorker
educational program for visitors to more accurately would be blank. Paint chips on the floor,” Atlanta
understand the events of the battle. The painting, History Center President and CEO Sheffield Hale
for instance, includes only one black person, despite told The New Yorker about his recurring fear.
hundreds having been involved in the battle. Instead, all was intact, and the project was com-
Sixty-six designs were proposed and rejected pleted—and open to tourists—in February.
sson to complete a six-month pilot project that helped the team execute the project and hit the
wrapped up at the end of 2018 to test the feasibility short timeline, Mr. Ma says. “Six months is a short “It’s critical
and benefits of 5G applications at the port of Qing- amount of time to get all of the involved parties
dao. The trial proved that the harbor could save up to agree to a common target and invest valuable
for all
to 70 percent on labor costs via automation. China resources in a project.”
parties to
Unicom, Ericsson and other partners are now actively For most initiatives, Mr. Ma’s teams usually agree on
exploring commercial 5G solutions for harbors, start- work with only one other company. But this project the planned
ing with a full-fledged project at the port of Qingdao. involved collaboration among four parties: Ericsson, approach
The 5G infrastructure is “the key to unlock other China Unicom, Shanghai Zhenhua Heavy Industries and then
technologies such as artificial intelligence, robot- and the Qingdao Port itself. To keep the project
to stick to
ics and the internet of things, therefore providing running smoothly, the team leaned on cloud-based
tremendous potential in China that could not be communication to update working documents in
the plan—
underestimated,” Steve Lo, managing partner of real time and maintain access from both desktop and while being
technology, media and telecommunications at mobile applications for all stakeholders. The team flexible.”
Ernst & Young China, told China Daily. also used WeChat for daily reports for the four par- —Eric Ma, Ericsson,
ties and held regular milestone-review meetings with Beijing, China
New Frontiers management. “If working processes and the collabo-
The 5G smart harbor pilot project was divided into ration model aren’t easy, some of the involved parties
three phases. First, the team developed the scope and won’t follow the protocol, which creates issues and
technology; then it tested the technology in a con- generates delays,” Mr. Ma says.
trolled lab setting. The final phase was on-site deploy- Additionally, when working with so many stake-
ment at the harbor, says Eric Ma, program manager holders, he says a clear organizational structure and a
for the Qingdao 5G smart harbor project, PMI Global robust project plan are necessary. “It’s critical for all
Executive Council member Ericsson, Beijing, China. parties to agree on the planned approach and then to
He worked on the project for the port of Qingdao. stick to the plan—while being flexible,” says Mr. Ma.
Ultimately, the team was trying to see if the 5G “With four parties involved, this can be difficult,
network was reliable enough to handle harbor tasks. so it’s important for one of the parties to take
For instance, the trial included an automated crane leadership.” —CJ Waity
City Escapes
Why can’t an old rail line be an urban oasis? Across
the United States, city governments have found
that it’s cheaper—and more engaging for resi-
dents—to rebuild infrastructure into public green
space than to simply tear it down.
The High Line, the once-abandoned, elevated
rail-line-turned-promenade in New York, New
York, is the inspiration behind a new spate of proj-
ects that are refashioning underutilized infrastruc- The project is broken into nine phases, which has
ture. Eighteen similar initiatives have now been proven helpful to allocate the required funding and
built or are planned across the U.S., as well as one allow the team to adapt based on lessons learned, Ms.
in Toronto, Ontario, Canada. Hegedus says. For instance, traffic studies performed
The High Line Network, an advisory group for for the first phase indicated that rapid flashing bea-
these projects, is helping to facilitate knowledge shar- cons would not sufficiently increase the level of safety
ing. Lessons learned proved helpful for Irene Hegedus, for pedestrians and bicyclists—an insight that will be
chief of transportation enhancements and the county’s applied to the remaining phases. Another item the team
program manager on the US$123 million Underline discovered is that one site has light levels of contamina-
“We have used reclamation project in Miami, Florida. (She is also tion due to a previous railroad line, which the team is
all that we based in Miami.) Ms. Hegedus drew on lessons from assuming will remain constant for the full 10 miles, she
1
Warsaw, Poland became the first in the nation to
NEW YORK, NEW YORK, USA
Some of the world’s biggest tech companies—includ- implement biometric signature recognition. Impri-
ing Apple, Facebook and LinkedIn—have bulked up their vata, a provider of biometric systems, completed 23
presence in the city. And though Amazon’s proposal to biometric healthcare projects globally last year and
establish a headquarters in the Queens borough fell has more underway.
through, Google announced its own plans in December
“If you consider the very real risk to patient
to double its New York-based workforce and build a US$1
safety when duplicate records are created, this has
2
billion campus in Manhattan.
the potential to save lives,” says Jack Cole, admin-
BEIJING, CHINA
istrative director of IT, CoxHealth, Springfield,
The city government has backed a fundraising campaign
that would inject CNY10 billion into the city’s tech sec- Missouri, USA. In February, CoxHealth, which
tor. The money will be used to underwrite Beijing-based partnered with Imprivata, introduced palm vein
ventures that are developing everything from new uses scanners across five of its six hospitals and most
for artificial intelligence to electric vehicles—and aim to of its clinics. This was part of a project initiated in
give those ventures an edge over their Western counter-
2017 and scheduled to be completed later this year.
3
parts.
But for these projects to be successful, organiza-
(TIE) TOKYO, JAPAN
tions need to get internal stakeholders on board to
Tokyo has become a hotbed for the development of
robotics and 3D manufacturing, which earned it the top ensure patients will use the new technology.
spot on 2thinknow’s Innovation Cities Index in 2018.
Industry leaders hope to use the Tokyo 2020 Olympic Safe and Secure
Games to supercharge their tech innovation efforts— While privacy concerns have hindered past efforts
similar to the 1964 Olympics, when the city unveiled the
to establish similar patient identifiers, the growing
3
world’s first bullet train.
ubiquity of biometric identification in everyday
(TIE) LONDON, ENGLAND
transactions, such as unlocking smartphones, is
London is being refashioned into a global capital of the
fintech industry. Of the 29 fintech unicorns (startups giving this latest batch of projects a greater chance.
valued over US$1 billion), seven are based in London— “It’s encouraging that people are becoming more
topped only by San Francisco, California, USA, which is comfortable with biometrics. Any issues they have
home to nine. But with Brexit looming, the fintech indus- are addressed with the project teams, which have
try could be standing on potentially shaky ground. systemized the process of implementation and put
18%
ington, Massachusetts, USA.
The major challenges remaining for project
teams are coordinating the many stakeholders average portion of a healthcare
involved in the complex and far-reaching projects, provider’s patient records that
and ensuring their buy-in. “Many hospitals out- are duplicates
source system management to a third company,
The average expense of repeated
so coordinating three teams becomes more of a medical care because of a
challenge. We also need to deal with many depart- duplicated record:
ments within the hospitals, and getting each to
agree on workflow changes can take time,” Mr. US$1,950
Ferguson says, noting that project delays can ensue per patient per inpatient stay
when hospitals do not prioritize the projects and
assign them sufficient staff. >US$800
per emergency department visit
Health Drive Source: Black Book Research, 2018
WWW.PMEDUCATE.COM
27
eventually reintroduce about 20 species into a
fenced-off sanctuary that spans 170,000 hectares
(420,000 acres). Rewilding Europe, meanwhile, is
overseeing dozens of projects spread across the
of 29 continent, aiming to rewild 2.5 million acres (1
mammal million hectares) of land by 2020.
species “A lot of species have become extinct from
disappear. specific areas, and we’re trying to bring them
back,” says Sofia Heinonen, director, Conservation
Land Trust, Iberá National Park, Argentina. Ms.
Heinonen oversees a rewilding project to restore munity and regulatory officials. Teams also have to
the ecosystem of 1.3 million hectares (3.2 million build on and communicate each successful mile-
acres) of Argentina’s Iberá Wetlands. stone so they can convey the project’s benefits to
help ensure future funding.
Human, Nature That often results in years of community out-
One of the biggest challenges for rewilding projects reach before the first animal arrives on-site. The
isn’t animals—it’s people. The project teams must Yorke Peninsula project, for instance, launched in
conduct long-term engagements with the com- 2009 as a collaboration among Naturally Yorke,
WWF and Greening Australia. The project team Rewilding projects can take years, if not decades, to
spent the first decade on planning and community hit their intended targets. Even with a thoroughly
engagement before erecting a mostly predator- defined scope, the Yorke project could take 20 to 25
proof, 20-kilometer (12.4-mile) fence stretching years and cost US$10 million to US$20 million, Mr.
across the peninsula earlier this year. Plans are to Grover says. Given the uncertain timeline and costs,
“It first reintroduce the first species into the area in 2020. it can be tricky to establish an overall budget—much
“Our biggest project risk was not getting the less secure all of it—at the start.
took many local community on board,” says Darren Grover, Rather than trying to get all the project funds
years of head of living ecosystems, WWF-Australia, Bris- upfront, Mr. Grover’s team broke down the proj-
discussion bane, Australia. “We had to get the communities ect into smaller phases and sought funding for
and raising involved and show them the project’s opportuni- each. That way, the team leverages the success of
awareness ties and benefits.” each milestone to help fund the subsequent one.
of the To accomplish that, the team held town halls For instance, the Yorke team obtained funds for
and one-on-one meetings to directly address the AU$1 million fence from the Australian gov-
project and the concerns of farmers and other residents. For ernment and other organizations before seeking
its benefits instance, farmers feared the reintroduced animals AU$500,000 to reintroduce an endangered kanga-
to make could attack livestock or dig burrows that could roo species.
sure we wreak havoc on their property. The team assured “This enables us to build momentum so we can
got the them the animals did not pose those threats. get money for one activity, get that underway and
community “Slowly but surely the farmers became advocates then get money for the next activity,” Mr. Grover
onboard.” for the project,” Mr. Grover says. says. “We approach potential donors, let them
Launched in 2000, with an expected end date know what we’ve done and ask them if they want
—Sofia Heinonen,
of 2025, the Iberá project did not introduce its to be part of the next phase.”
Conservation Land
Trust, Iberá National first species until 2007. “It first took many years Similarly, the Iberá team builds upon each suc-
Park, Argentina of discussion and raising awareness of the project cess to generate more interest and buy-in for the
and its benefits to make sure we got the commu- project. The team’s first successfully introduced
nity onboard,” Ms. Heinonen says. That involved species was an anteater. “Afterward, people saw we
communicating the benefit of ecotourism that the could do this, and that allowed us to translocate
project should usher in. other animals from other regions,” Ms. Heinonen
The Iberá team also helped secure the public’s says. —Novid Parsi
©2019 Project Management Institute. All rights reserved. “PMI”, the PMI logo, “PMO Symposium” and “Sem
PMO Symposium®
5–7 OCTOBER 2019 Organizational leaders come
PMI Global Conference 2019 in Philadelphia
®
together at PMO Symposium to
Pennsylvania Convention Center
exchange best practices and new
insights into the strategies and
3–6 NOVEMBER 2019 practices that drive success.
PMO Symposium® 2019 in Denver Featuring distinctive networking
Gaylord Rockies Hotel Denver events and advanced workshops,
this premier, interactive event is
11–14 NOVEMBER 2019 tailored to leaders and executives
SeminarsWorld in Houston with experience directing a portfolio
of projects, programs and initiatives.
2–5 DECEMBER 2019
SeminarsWorld in Las Vegas
PMI members receive significant discounts on registration.
Not a member?
Join today at PMI.org/membership.
” and “SeminarsWorld” are registered marks of Project Management Institute, Inc. (9-18) BRA-203-2018
INSIDE TRACK
Healthy
Outlook
G
MICHAEL rowth drives change and How do you marry strategy and project
LOCATION: Minneapolis, the corporate science, technology and innova- three enterprise imperatives.
Minnesota, USA tion group, Michael O’Connor is responsible
for helping standardize the organization’s proj- How do you help ensure alignment?
ect management processes. One primary way We meet and collaborate with the executive mem-
of achieving such crucial alignment is to coach bers and our various councils, such as the research
and mentor junior project managers across the and development council, the public-private part-
enterprise. nerships council and the project management of-
fice council. With both the leadership team and the and by following them you’ll get your projects done
councils, we look at the strategy for the next year faster, cheaper and with higher quality.
and the next five years, then we prioritize the projects
we need to focus on going forward. While the com- How have you gained buy-in for this across the
pany typically focuses on a five-year plan, our group organization?
looks further out, to the 10-year space and beyond. It would have been easy to just do it all here in Minne-
We come up with innovative product ideas down the apolis, where we have more than 10,000 employees, but
line while supporting innovative products now. it was key that we had global representation with some- Small Talk
one in China and someone in Europe so we could un-
What one skill
How have you helped standardize derstand their needs. We have a small volunteer team should every project
project management at Medtronic since it working on this: one person in China, one in Europe manager have?
acquired Covidien? and roughly three to five people in the United States. People skills. You
Soon after the acquisition, I was at the airport with a We went to internal company conferences globally, and can teach project
colleague, and we were talking about how to improve we had a booth where we laid out what we were doing management, but people
skills typically require
project management in the company. I was getting on and asked employees to write their thoughts about it on
on-the-job experience
my soapbox, and this person said, “Put your money Post-it notes and put them on a poster. So we had the and usually some failures
where your mouth is.” So we created a project charter voice of our customer along the way. along the way.
in the airport. Then we came back to the company,
put it on paper and put it into motion. We met with What’s the toughest challenge you face in What inspires you?
my boss and another executive. It took one meet- your role? Education. I’m
ing, and they were both in. We started planning the Time. On any given day, I’m in meetings most of the fascinated with how
people learn, and I learn
project, which we called the Project Management day, then I need to catch up on email, then I go home
from the people I teach.
Rigor for Innovation, in 2016, creating the vision in and catch up on email again—while trying to figure
2017 and executing it in 2018 and 2019. We’ll be in out how to get things done. There are a couple of What’s your biggest
the execution stage for another two or three years. ways I manage my time. With each email, I act on it, pet peeve?
delegate it, delete it or file it, and I do that quickly so Getting too much
What does the project involve? I always clear out my inbox. With meetings, I look at detail when I ask a
We’re developing our project management train- my calendar the night before and decide if I need to go simple question.
ing, tools, frameworks and processes, and com- to each meeting or not, if I can send someone else or
What’s underrated?
municating them out across Medtronic globally to listen to a recording.
The art of taking time,
help the organization be more successful with its like handwriting a
projects. For instance, we’re looking at how to get thank-you note.
people Project Management Professional (PMP)® PMI is celebrating its
certified across the globe. In addition to train- 50th anniversary.
ing, we’re coaching and mentoring both formally What has been the biggest change in project
and informally. I mentor mostly junior project management over the past half-century, and
managers about, for example, how to improve their what’s the biggest challenge for the future?
people skills and how to network.
“We’ve been moving past traditional project
In a nutshell, we’re creating a project manage- management, and project managers now
ment toolbox and adding different information have to be more flexible and adaptable. But
inside it, so that people across the organization can the biggest challenge for the future will be
pick and choose what works best for them. We’re training and maybe even certifying project
not saying everyone has to use all these things. professionals in people skills and leadership.”
We’re saying these are some of the best practices,
Positive
FEED THE APPETITE
We often have a project team lunch while
doing the postmortem meeting in a special
Reinforcement
venue for each of the major milestones achieved.
This form of reward also helps create a more
engaging environment for getting the right and
We asked the project management community: How do you reward honest feedback for the postmortem. We also
team members for managing difficult tasks or completing projects? believe that the highest form of praise is a reward
that’s beneficial to the exposure and career devel-
opment of the team members. For example, send-
ing the team members to a special conference or
training abroad as part of the reward.”
—Marzikmal Omar, PMI-RMP, PMP, head of project
management office, Dagang Nexchange Berhad, Kuala
Lumpur, Malaysia
To give your team members the right covered in the annual performance management challenge you face
reward, first you need to know what drives process. But the reality is that, for most leaders, during agile testing
their respective careers. Each employee in every those conversations are spliced into packed agen- phases? And what
organization has different goals. For example, in das, feel a bit perfunctory and rarely dig deeply steps do you take
our organization, most team members expect into career ambitions. The ‘tell-me-how-I-can- to anticipate and
financial rewards, but there are people who prefer help-enrich-your-career’ coffee includes gentle overcome those
obstacles?
to get additional responsibilities and even more but deliberate probing into where team members
Email responses
complex tasks. This also can lead to their further want to go and why. I advise from the heart, using to pmnetwork@
skill development in order to complete these new my own career experience—good and bad—where imaginepub.com for
tasks. Giving the right rewards sustains their indi- appropriate. Usually, deeper career desires emerge, possible publication in
vidual performance, and it’s also good for the com- as does a heart-to-heart collaboration on expedit- a future issue.
pany’s overall performance.” ing their growth into the next role.”
—Stanimir Sotirov, director of operations, Visrez, Dublin, —Dev Ramcharan, PMP, program director, infrastructure
Ireland security engineering delivery, TD, Toronto, Ontario, Canada
Standing Out
From the Start
Showcase skills when you lack experience. Plus: Advancing beyond
project manager and how to pick the right performance review metrics.
By Lindsay Scott
I
just earned the Certified Associate in the job advertisement states, “You will be taking
Project Management (CAPM)® certi- accountability for the effective execution of project
fication, and I’m ready to start work. processes, procedures and tools for the project on
How do I promote my skills when I behalf of the project manager.” If I’m the hiring
lack experience? manager, I want to know if you can demonstrate
Not all project management roles require advanced knowledge of the project processes, procedures
experience and skills. Ideally, you are looking for the and tools using your CAPM® qualification. Show
roles where budget responsibilities and authority me evidence of previous experience and skills
levels aren’t huge. At this stage in your career, go for a working with processes, continuous improvement
supporting role, such as project coordinator or a proj- and redesigns. I would also like to see evidence of
ect manager role in which the project risk is fairly low. skills used to put processes in place and how you
Either role depends on your comfort level. achieve compliance from others.
Being a project coordinator will help you learn the Next, I want you to show evidence of account-
ropes while working alongside a project manager. ability traits: problem-solving, drive, integrity,
You typically will complete administrative tasks, such communication, motivation and so on. I also
as setting times and dates for meetings or maintain- would highlight knowledge of certain tools, includ-
ing paperwork. Taking on a project manager role will ing software skills and any kind of data collation.
work only if the value of the project is low and the What’s your experience in extracting information
project itself is likely to repeat. or providing reports and administering tools?
When you search for such opportunities, try Finally, to show that you can work on behalf of the
to pinpoint the actual skills needed to carry out project manager, I would expect to see relationship
the tasks outlined in the job description. These management, delegation, collaboration and organi-
are your transferable skills. For example, let’s say zational skills.
When it
For my next review, my manager asked me to I’ve been a senior project manager for a while, and
come up with performance measures beyond I want a new challenge. What are my options?
comes to
delivering on time, within cost and within There are two immediate options that many other project
scope. What else can I use? senior project managers pursue. The first is pro- metrics that
When it comes to project metrics that measure gram management, a step up in terms of responsi- measure your
your performance, choose the ones that mean bility, level of complexity and risk in delivery. From performance,
the most to your business. For example, show there, you can move on to portfolio management, choose the
how your resource prioritization benefited work where you have accountability for the organiza-
in progress or gross margin. You also should be tion’s entire portfolio of change. The second option
ones that
looking to provide the context, the story and the is to seek a role in the project management office
mean the
insights from those numbers that reflect how you (PMO). Working in the PMO is a move away from most to your
have influenced those outcomes. hands-on delivery to having a wider influence on business.
Don’t just choose metrics that are easy to col- maintaining good practices, processes, capabil-
lect, either. Make sure you include quantitative ity and governance. In fact, many organizations
measurables, such as customer satisfaction or combine the role of the enterprise PMO with that
Have a career
stakeholder engagement. Look for performance of portfolio management, making it a versatile and question for Lindsay
indicators that show how you managed or moti- challenging position. Scott? Email
vated a team. Did you contribute to project man- With both options, leadership approaches are pmnetwork@
agement maturity in the organization through key. The options for your career change are split: imaginepub.com.
leading, coaching or mentoring team members? Do you carry on in the delivery role, or do you take
Did you stop or cancel any projects? How have a position with a bigger influence around change in
you contributed to lessons learned? the organization? With some research and an hon-
Finally, there’s the improvement in your own est look at what is going to excite you in the next
performance that can be achieved through com- stage of your career, the answer should become
petencies, skills and behaviors. If your organiza- apparent very quickly. PM
tion has its own competency or skills assessment
GETTY IMAGES
system, use it. It can help you identify any perfor- Lindsay Scott is the director of program and
mance gaps and set you on a path to improvement project management recruitment at Arras People
in London, England.
in the different areas as required. If your organi-
C
ollaboration is not just a buzzword. It one to get to work. But better results arise if you
lies at the very center of projects and, give team members time upfront to discover each
therefore, project management. When other’s strengths, build personal ties and develop
the project environment is focused a common understanding of the project. A collab-
on collaboration, team members feel they belong orative leader builds a connected culture.
to something bigger than themselves and do their
Collaborative best work. Maintain the Right Mix
leaders ... are Top-flight project leaders create this environ- Collaborative leaders also know how to build
authentic, ment as a matter of course—but it doesn’t always teams and take advantage of everyone’s abili-
Transformation
Stories
Effective storytelling can boost buy-in
for digital overhauls.
By Priya Patra, PMP
D
igital transformations are all the rage
these days—and also a source of anx-
iety. CEOs and other business leaders
say their top concern for 2019 is risks
surrounding digital transformation, according to a
Protiviti survey conducted late last year. They have
good reason to worry: 43 percent of CIOs surveyed
by Harvey Nash/KPMG in 2017 cited resistance to
change as the top impediment to digital success. A
lack of employee engagement can grind a transfor-
mation effort to a halt.
One way to build engagement has always been
central to the human experience: storytelling.
ISTOCKPHOTO
The Next
Evolution
Young project managers will change the profession:
Here’s what organizations need to know.
By Alfonso Bucero, PMI-RMP, PMP, PfMP, PMI Fellow
ISTOCKPHOTO
M
illennials and Generation Z, those GET EFFICIENT
born since the early 1980s, are Technology may make it easier than ever to work
bringing fresh perspectives to remotely—and around the clock. But don’t assume
projects—leveraging technological that just because project managers can be reached
advancements and drawing heightened focus to at all hours of the evening, they want to be. In fact,
economic, ecological and social issues. Learning millennials and Gen Z are drawing work boundar-
to work alongside these younger generations isn’t ies more clearly than other generations, and these
optional, as they increasingly dominate the labor boundaries are at odds with the old “all-nighter”
force and extend their influence. mentality of project management deadlines. A 2018
Millennials have already arrived: According to World Services Group global survey of nearly 1,600
Pew Research, this group surpassed Gen X in 2016 young professionals found that work-life balance
and is now the largest generation in the U.S. labor was the biggest professional priority, more than
force. And, globally, Gen Z isn’t far behind. A 2018 leadership opportunities or even wealth.
Bloomberg analysis found that Gen Z will make Instead of assuming you’ll have 24/7 access to a
up 32 percent of the global population this year— young project manager, focus on maximizing the
meaning those who aren’t already in the workforce productivity they can achieve in eight hours. That
Organizations will soon be moving into it. probably means you don’t want them spending
that embrace The difference between these generations and two or three of those hours each day in meetings
older ones isn’t merely limited to age. Collectively,
that change, millennial and Gen Z workers tend to be open to
getting consensus around change requests and
scope adjustments. Instead, try to eliminate as
and focus on new opportunities and new technologies, while much unnecessary bureaucracy as possible. Make
these young demonstrating an aversion to hidden agendas, an effort to run effective meetings (and encourage
employees rigid corporate structures and information silos. and train project managers to do the same), leav-
and their As the ranks of these younger project managers ing people more time to focus on their tasks. Help
needs, have swell, those differences can fundamentally change employees not to work longer but to work smarter
the potential organizations’ project management culture. and be more effective.
Organizations that embrace that change, and focus
to thrive. on these young employees and their needs, have the EMBRACE TECH
potential to thrive. Others may find they’ve created a The young generations excel at collaboration, but they
high-churn culture that dampens productivity, qual- expect tools to keep pace. Static software that doesn’t
ity and service. allow collaboration is a dinosaur in their eyes, akin to
Here are three ways to lean into the generational being asked to fax or update an analog paper-and-pen
shifts—and reap the rewards: note system.
Organizations and their project managers need even a few hours of lag between a question asked
to embrace and support modernized tools that and an answer received can feel like eons.
can handle collaborative brainstorming, real-time To find a communication style that works for
updates, multiple readers and users, integrated younger project managers—and gels with older
video, voice and more. Integrating those tools into generations as well—teams must be willing to talk
the organization’s workflow isn’t always easy, nor early and openly about what is expected of team
are the payoffs immediate, but the effort that goes members and what the team’s communication
into effective change management can pay off in norms will be. This may vary significantly by indi-
spades. Also, organizations should routinely survey vidual initiative, but tailoring the style to the people
younger project managers for the new tools and on the team is the best way to ensure an organiza-
technologies that would allow them to collaborate tion is getting the most out of all of its workers—
more quickly or effectively. That signals both that young and old.
you value their suggestions and that the organiza- Young project professionals tend to be highly
tion wants to proactively take advantage of the motivated, with an enthusiastic attitude and a
latest tools and tech trends. deep commitment to the work at hand. Orga-
nizations that understand how to harness those
COMMUNICATE THOROUGHLY positive traits—while integrating these generations
Young workers are highly responsive communica- seamlessly into the existing workforce—can see
tors who appreciate the same in their managers immense benefits for projects and people. PM
and co-workers. Accustomed to having the world’s
information at their fingertips, they are uncomfort-
Alfonso Bucero, PMI-RMP, PMP, PfMP, PMI
able with silos and hidden agendas. And thanks Fellow, is managing partner at Bucero PM
to the prevalence of real-time chat tools and apps, Consulting, Madrid, Spain.
Personal Power
Managing without direct authority? Strong project
professionals know how to maximize their influence.
By Javier Augusto González, PMP
I
t’s the first day in your new project man-
agement job. You’re full of hope and antici-
pation, but you’re also woefully short on
institutional knowledge and control over
the organization’s procedures. For your first proj-
ect, you’re handed a collaborative initiative that
heavily involves external entities. You’re not in a
position of direct authority over your project team,
and—worse yet—your influence is limited because
no one knows you yet. What now?
Don’t give up or assume you face an insur-
mountable challenge. Though it can be tough to
lead a new and sprawling team from a position of
limited official authority, success is certainly pos-
If you’re sible. Here are tips that can help you quickly adapt
giving and to a new scenario.
enthusiastic,
CONTROL THE FOCUS, NOT THE TASKS
your team If you aren’t the supervisor of your project team
will naturally members, micromanagement will be impos-
follow suit. sible. If you attempt it anyway, your team may
bristle—perhaps losing its motivation and even
responsiveness. Instead, forget about the way in
which a task is completed, and focus on how the
task will contribute to the project objectives. Don’t
only focus your own attention there; make sure to
underscore with individual team members how
their specific tasks will drive project success. And
do not be afraid to be repetitive with the most
important aspects, so their importance remains top
of mind. Also remember that leading by example is
more effective than micromanagement—if you’re
giving and enthusiastic, your team will naturally
follow suit.
tions. It can be tempting to want to hit the ground you’ll still have gathered quick impressions and
running at the start of a new project, but investing insights over the first few days of working together.
even a small amount of time in team-building and Think about the key people whom you trust the
cohesion will pay off handsomely once the project most. Are there others you wish were not on the
is underway. project? Then think about what you can do to cre-
Take time to talk with your new team and ate more “trusted” colleagues and reduce the num-
understand their individual and group preferences: ber of “out-of-the-project” people. Finally, define
Sometimes inexpensive and easy-to-implement who will fill the major roles on the project.
actions (such as scheduling meetings to allow
a team member to pick up their children from GIVE SPACE FOR AUTONOMY
school) create important gains. And recognizing AND CREATIVITY
that a certain meeting time is preferred or people Once you begin to trust your team, you have to
are more comfortable with one type of collabora- give them space to make their own decisions—it
tion tool over another, for instance, can save you is the only way to unleash their potential. Some
endless frustration in the long run. people assume giving team members autonomy
Understanding your team is the only way to means being completely hands-off, but there’s actu-
effectively communicate, motivate and involve them.
ally a lot involved in properly coaching from the
Especially because you are new to the organization
sidelines. If a team member is acting in a way that
and your team, you need to be empathetic and giving
you want others to emulate, let everyone know it.
in order to drive the project toward completion.
Recognize and celebrate your team members when
they make good decisions, make it clear you’re Share Your
ALIGN INDIVIDUAL AND
available for questions and assistance when they hit Thoughts
PROJECT OBJECTIVES
a wall, and support them when they make errors. No one
Once you understand your team members, you knows project
Once the team members know you’re available and
should consider how the project’s objectives can management
invested—for both the project’s highs and lows—
help further their personal objectives. Think about better than you, the
they’ll feel more empowered to perform their best project professionals
the team member who is seeking higher visibility
work. At the same time, you need to draw clear “Getting It Done.”
in the organization: Why not let them present the
lines for what behavior you won’t tolerate—and So every month,
most recent project achievements? Or consider the
follow up if it happens anyway. PM Network shares
colleague who wants to become a machine learning your expertise on
These tips can help you lead a project in environ-
expert, and assign them the most challenging rel- everything from
ments where you do not have direct power. In fact,
evant task in the project. There is always room in a sustainability to
project to find these quick gains, and your team will these actions will help you to speed up the process talent management,
be much more engaged with the project as a result. of creating personal power inside the organization, and all project
boosting this project and all the ones that follow it. PM topics in between.
If you’re interested
DEFINE THE ROLES in contributing,
ISTOCKPHOTO
After going through the previous steps, you will email pmnetwork@
Javier Augusto González, PMP, is a project man-
have a clear picture of the people on your team. ager at Televes, Santiago de Compostela, Spain. imaginepub.com.
Though the team may be largely unknown to you,
Fright
PHOTO BY SYDNEY GAWLIK/COURTESY LOLLAPALOOZA
Lollapalooza festival in
Chicago, Illinois,31USA
JUNE 2019 PM NETWORK
ISTOCKPHOTO
a more comprehensive plan by festival organizers delphia, Pennsylvania, USA. Also a senior producer
and city law enforcement leaders to identify possible of major events for live entertainment company
risks. At this year’s Women’s World Cup in France, Live Nation Middle East, Mr. Digby has witnessed
FIFA is introducing airport-level security screening the culture of event safety and security mature. He
to reduce threats in a country that’s dealt with violent now sees more clearly defined practices and pro-
political protests and deadly terror attacks over the cesses to establish mitigation strategies for known
past year. And at last year’s World Cup in Russia, and unknown threats. It also means treating events
security teams stepped up screening by implement- like a business rather than a party, he says.
ing face-recognition technology that allowed security “The culture of large events and the music busi-
officials to automatically check individuals caught on ness is evolving toward a more serious respect for
camera against a police database. The use of biomet- safety and security accountability.”
ric screening will be expanded for the 2022 World
Cup in Qatar. SECURITY STRATEGY
“Every audience at every event has an expectation Making risk management a core part of event
of safety while attending events,” says Jim Digby, security planning helps stakeholders adjust their
expectations so all threats are accurately assessed, members work together to organize the flow of
PHC IMAGES / ALAMY STOCK PHOTO
says Marina Tranchitella, PMP, general manager communication, identify and remove obstacles,
of stadium operations, Sport Club Internacional, and establish strategies to manage unexpected out-
São Paulo, Brazil. “Risk management is important comes, she says. “This results in transparency in
because through it you can develop a framework, management and allows a baseline for budget and
and prioritize which risks must be addressed and timeline planning.”
which will be accepted,” Ms. Tranchitella says. But project teams often need to collaborate with
As security manager for last year’s Youth Olym- outside vendors and experts to identify and deliver
pic Games in Buenos Aires, Argentina, she had security solutions. Working hand in hand with local
her teams use a responsibility matrix tool to clarify authorities and global governing agencies helps
which stakeholder owned each security mitigation ensure that security plans align with other civic or
action. The tool also assigned who was responsible privacy requirements.
for the budget. Breaking down risks into actions For FIFA events, security planning and site-
allows her team to transform the overall security inspection visits of all stadiums begin as soon as
requirements into smaller, manageable tasks, she the host location is chosen, which can be up to
says. Once the matrix actions are assigned, team 10 years before the event, says Helmut Spahn,
security director, competition and events, FIFA, ners, we keep the risk assessment under dynamic
PHOTO BY SHAHJEHAN/SHUTTERSTOCK
Zurich, Switzerland. review, which is supported by contingency plans
“These inspection visits help all stakeholders that enable us to act quickly and decisively if some-
understand how a stadium will work during the thing happens.”
event,” Mr. Spahn says. “They ensure safety and Local security and law enforcement experts also
security risks are highlighted in enough time for “We keep can help teams prioritize risks. For example, when
remedial action, as well as ensuring overall stan-
the risk Ms. Tranchitella served as security assistant man-
ager for the 2016 Olympic and Paralympics Games
dards are raised in line with FIFA requirements.”
Teams share comprehensive requirements
assessment in Brazil, her team worked closely with the Brazil-
with local organizers and collaborate with them under ian Intelligence Agency and Brazil’s mega-events
to ensure all plans meet all guidelines, including dynamic secretary to generate 46 venue vulnerability reports
FIFA stadium security regulations and wider public review, based on 150 security-performance metrics. Those
safety measures, he says. FIFA teams emphasize which is reports helped the team develop eight contingency
the importance of getting public safety and security supported by plans for terrorism attacks.
stakeholders, such as law enforcement, intelligence “Project management steps were directly linked
agencies and medical care providers, on the same
contingency with this process to ensure that all of the plans
page with private sector stakeholders such as sta-
plans that were delivered on time and had adequate resource
dium management and security service providers. enable availability and allocation,” she says. The plan
“As part of our planning, we prepare a compre- us to act included steps to track risks, monitor performance
hensive risk assessment. This helps identify, assess quickly and and identify when an issue should be escalated to a
and prioritize all risks to the tournament, as well as decisively.” senior decision maker. “It’s extremely important to
mitigating measures, such as a more robust search analyze the veracity of the information, the means
—Helmut Spahn, FIFA,
regime or specialist police support, to reduce the Zurich, Switzerland of verification and who needs to be aware of the
likelihood of these occurring or the impact should fact,” she says.
they do so,” Mr. Spahn says. “Along with our part- Making risk management a critical part of event
Smart
and
Secure
The rise in security threats is causing many
major event planners to deploy leading-
edge tech as part of their risk management
strategy to protect audiences.
AUTOMATED
MONITORING
At the 2018 Winter Olympics
in Pyeongchang, South Korea,
unmanned aerial vehicles
(UAVs), or drones, equipped
with high-definition and
planning does more than just increase security. It thermal imaging cameras
PHOTO COURTESY BURNING MAN PROJECT
also satisfies regulators and insurers, and builds were used to monitor activity
confidence among critical event sponsors—a major on the ground. The drones
component toward achieving long-term benefits, also helped watch the skies
for any unapproved UAVs
Ms. Tranchitella says. “When stakeholders see that
in the area’s no-fly zone. If
risks are being dealt with in a formal framework, it unauthorized vehicles were spotted, inter-
can positively impact sponsorship funding and the ceptor drones could be deployed to capture
contracting of specific insurers and liability.” them with nets.
RAPID RESPONSE
SOUND CHECK
The Boston Marathon in the
For annual events, teams must adapt their risk U.S. state of Massachusetts has
processes constantly—before, during and after the taken several steps to speed up
event. This means organizing prompt and proper safety and security response
testing of new equipment, such as badges, wrist- after bombs killed three people
bands and sensors that are needed to gain entry. In and injured hundreds during the
2013 event. Event planners now
other cases, it means assessing event attractions for
partner with Esri, a geographic
ISTOCKPHOTO
Gabe Kearney, event safety officer, Burning Man works with them to identify safety risks during
can’t be fixed, Mr. Kearney’s team has the struc- first-aid stations so attendees wouldn’t overburden
tures removed from the site. the hospital with emergency care requests, says Jim
“In the end, we always need to ensure nobody is Graham, senior adviser, strategic projects, Burning
going to get hurt,” he says. Man Project, Las Vegas, Nevada. “It cut the number
of small-injury visits substantially,” he says.
CRITICAL REVIEW Such post-event, safety- and security-focused
Long-term event success means having a comprehen- feedback helps fine-tune a risk-management-cen-
sive retrospective after each event that helps teams tered culture that’s critical to the success of major
review and revise security protocols and update risk events. “When there are time and budget pressures,
mitigation tactics. After each Burning Man event it is not uncommon for risk management to be
ends, Mr. Kearney’s team conducts a retrospective neglected,” Ms. Tranchitella says. When this hap-
to identify any safety or security issues that can be pens, she encourages event planners to think strate-
addressed for the next year’s event. The team solic- gically about the risks they face and where they can
its feedback via email from the 75,000 attendees to achieve a balance. As with many aspects of project
inform future planning. For example, the team found management, security risks have to be in line with
that some attendees were visiting the main hospital the rest of the project plan, she says.
near the festival to receive minor first-aid treatment. “What project managers need to understand is
So the planning team reminded attendees to bring that it can be okay to accept risks, but it has to be
first-aid kits and steered them toward existing small done consciously and not in an irresponsible way.”
Guarding
Glastonbury
A
s the largest greenfield music and perform-
ing arts event in the world, Glastonbury
Festival is a virtual minefield of risks. The
annual five-day outdoor music festival on a farm near
Glastonbury, England attracts 150,000 attendees
each year and requires substantial year-round risk
management planning, says Tim Roberts, director,
Event Safety Shop Ltd., Bristol, England. Mr. Roberts’
company has served as the health and safety
adviser and coordinator for Glastonbury
Festival since 2002.
Although the unique rural setting pro-
vides flexibility for accommodating crowds
and stage arrangements, myriad risks asso-
ciated with the open area require Mr. Rob-
“Risk erts’ team to constantly assess the land for
management known and unknown variables that could
injure someone or shut down the festival. So instead of moving the event, Mr. Roberts’
has to address
E RVICE
BY HAYLEY
GRGURICH
PORTRAITS
BY MICHAEL
ZAJAKOWSKI
resources that were needed to the implementation to departments of 311 to review all existing workflows
the community outreach—everyone understood the used by those departments. “It was important to get understood
magnitude of what needed to happen to get this tran- the buy-in from departments early for their active the magnitude
sition going,” says LaWanda Crayton, PMP, project participation and to begin business process require- of what
manager, Department of Innovation and Technology ments,” says Cortez McKinney, PMP, project man- needed to
PMO, City of Chicago, Chicago, Illinois, USA. ager, Department of Innovation and Technology
happen to get
PMO, City of Chicago, Chicago, Illinois, USA.
PUBLIC REWORKS Each department had six to 12 planning meet-
this transition
Scaling new technology across an entire city ings with the team—and each session lasted at least going.”
wouldn’t be possible without crystal-clear require- two hours. “We did a lot of drawings on the board, —LaWanda Crayton, PMP,
City of Chicago, Chicago,
ments. By breaking the project into two primary diagramming everything, creating workflows from
Illinois, USA
phases—one year of planning and 15 months of scratch, really walking through the life cycle of all
development and implementation—project manag- 250 business processes,” Ms. Crayton says.
ers were able to establish clear expectations from To tailor the engagement with city departments,
the start. This helped the team quickly clamp down the team divided departments into “cohorts”
on the budget and timeline to ensure ROI for tax- based on size, relevance and impact of impending
payers in a city of mounting debts and deficits. changes to their departments, Mr. McKinney says.
“Anytime one
What career lesson
did you learn on this
project?
of our user Understand where you
need to delegate. I found
departments felt that project manager
within, and I realized I
of them.”
and especially from an
environmental perspec-
tive—all of it mattered.
—LaWanda Crayton, PMP
What’s your next
project?
I’m juggling multiple ini-
tiatives simultaneously,
beyond our efforts to
continue enhancements
on the 311 system. This
includes a citywide per-
sonal computer replace-
ment initiative as well as
modernizing the finance
department’s call center.
ing residents fill out “postcards from the future” to engagement is unique to Chicago’s project. It really
describe what 311 services could look like in the year made a difference in all respects—design, function-
2035. Residents also participated in activities such ality, usage. With that, this truly becomes a product
as sorting notecards with city services and grouping that was built with Chicagoans and for Chicagoans,
them by intuitive categories. Such exercises helped and that can truly become a central access point for
residents ideate around future needs and improve residents and the city.”
the new system’s user experience.
The focus groups also uncovered a need to cen- THE RIGHT APPROACH
tralize information about city services. “Seventy Given the need for continuous development across
percent of calls to 311 are for information,” Mr. the three products, the team opted to use agile
McKinney says. In the old system, residents had to approaches. Only one-off additions to the products
go to each department’s website to find answers. uncovered by community outreach meetings were
The new system consolidated critical information handled with a hybrid of agile and waterfall (or pre-
and FAQs about each department and reduced dictive) approaches, since such additions wouldn’t
confusion when residents search the new system. require iterative testing.
“I’m most proud of the interaction with the pub- “At the end of every development sprint, we
lic,” Mr. McKinney says. “This level of community would do a sprint review,” Ms. Crayton says. “And
it would be every user department in the room. We Other specialists provide one-on-one digital skills
told them this is what we expected to do, and then training for residents at libraries throughout the city.
we’d demonstrate the product.” “For the first two to three days of go-live, we sent
The team used libraries and community colleges out staff to all city and ward offices and had a war
as sites where residents could test the new system room to support our staff out in the field and help
and share their thoughts. While the development troubleshoot issues,” Mr. McKinney says. Stake-
team performed back-end and accessibility testing, holder management didn’t end there: Site demon-
user departments conducted their own indepen- strations to increase public awareness will continue
dent tests after each sprint review, which helped through 2019, and the team is creating video tutori-
iron out all technical kinks to maximize user experi- als that residents will have free access to.
ence. For example: Could city crew workers in the The team incorporated robust reporting capabili-
field clearly view all images submitted by residents ties into the system’s back end to help quantify the
to illustrate their unique problems? long-term project benefits. Those tools will enable the
The iterative approach helped streamline project team to automatically evaluate usage across the three
progress dramatically. By adopting agile approaches, new platforms, measure request response times and
the team was able to develop the system more track app downloads. Preliminary data is promising: In
quickly than originally planned. As a result, it was the first three months, there were 17,000 mobile app
able to speed up delivery by a month. downloads and nearly 400,000 service requests logged
via the new system. The system will generate data so
GETTING RESULTS the city can analyze geographic trends, such as where
Prior to launch, the project team made sure all key certain services are requested most.
stakeholders were well situated for success. The team “I’ve been able to work on a number of great
developed training materials—both instructor-led projects and give back to the city, but not to this
and online training. The instructor-led training used magnitude,” Ms. Crayton says. “311 services touch so
gamification to build skills within the new system. many different people in so many different ways. It
All certified users in city departments were provided just warms my heart that we’re giving people all these
with access to an online learning management system. different avenues by which to get what they need.” PM
Set,
comfort zone.
BY ASHLEY BISHEL
ILLUSTRATION BY DAVE MURRAY
Stretch
PMN0619 d-Second Features.indd 48 5/13/19 1:45 PM
PMN0619 d-Second Features.indd 49 5/14/19 2:21 PM
static skill set can
guarantee a static
career. But for project
professionals eager
to be recognized,
get promoted or
take on more ambitious and
complex projects, an expansive
skill set is a hot commodity in
today’s job market.
More than 1 in 3 CEOs report that the availability of
key skills is a top threat to business growth in 2019,
according to PwC’s Global CEO Survey. The skills
dearth is a major concern, and only regulation and
policy uncertainty are keeping more top executives
up at night.
What an organization wants—and what will help
a project or program manager make the next career
leap—is hardly universal, says Sagarika Basak, PMP, IT
project manager consultant, Alshaya Enterprises, London,
England. Spotting an organizational deficit around a certain
skill may require talking to a manager or consulting the project
ISTOCKPHOTO
How executives plan to bridge the skills gap—and how receptive they might be to in-house training
programs and continuing education credits—depends, in part, on where the organization is located.
CEOs report the following are important:
Changing the
Establishing composition of
a strong the workforce
Significant Hiring from pipeline between
retraining or outside the direct from Hiring from permanent and
REGION upskilling industry education competitors contingent
World 46%
18% 17% 14% 5%
Africa 47%
16% 22% 10% 6%
roject failure
PHOTO BY AGCUESTA/SHUTTERSTOCK
comes in all
shapes and
sizes.
Mexico City’s US$13 billion
airport project was canceled in
October even though 37 percent
of the work already had been com-
pleted. And in February, an ambitious
high-speed rail project in the U.S. state of
California was dramatically scaled back after costs
more than doubled in the past 10 years. In the private
sector, Kinder Morgan canceled a project in Octo-
ber to convert a 964-mile (1,551-kilometer) natural
gas pipeline in the United States to carry fracking
byproducts—after four years of planning. The culprit:
The team failed to convince local stakeholders in
multiple states of the project benefits.
Fifteen percent of projects were deemed failures,
according to PMI survey data collected in 2018.
Yet when bad things happen, it’s up to project and “You always need a process for how to cap-
program managers to capture the value from an ture lessons learned,” says Andrew Okene, PMP,
otherwise negative outcome. Whether the misfire regional head of project management and con-
occurred during a signature phase in a high-stakes struction, Middle East and Africa, Exterran, Dubai,
megaproject or in the middle of a simple sprint, United Arab Emirates. “My aim is to mitigate fail-
project professionals need to deconstruct what ure, learn from it, and get better at doing the things
went wrong to ensure mistakes aren’t repeated. that we have already encountered and experienced.”
“Obviously, failure is always bad. When it hap- Michael Uhl, PMI-ACP, PMP, PgMP, senior
pens, it causes frustration and losses,” says Antonio technical program manager, Red Hat, Raleigh,
Elianti, PMP, senior project manager, Provincial North Carolina, USA, has an agile mindset when it
Health Services Authority, Burnaby, British Colum- comes to failure. Each failed project is a minimum
bia, Canada. “But if failure is properly managed, it viable product, and he carries it with him as if each
can turn into opportunity.” new project he works on is simply a new sprint in
one big, career-spanning initiative.
LEARNING CURVE “If a project fails, but you walk away with a lesson
When a project goes belly up, there’s always a les- learned that you apply to 500 future projects—and
son to be learned—for teams and often for orga- those projects succeed because of that—was that
nizations. Creating sustainable value from failure project really a failure?”
also means developing strong knowledge-sharing When he was a program manager at Lockheed
processes, such as easily accessible documentation Martin, his team of scientific programmers was
that helps teams and organizations ingrain lessons assigned as consultants to the U.S. Environmental
learned across the enterprise. Protection Agency (EPA), which required project
“We tried to cut corners, and in the end the sys- part of the methodology for our next project,” Mr.
tem that was completed did not meet user expecta- Omar says. “This helps deliver more accurate, con-
tions,” he says. sistent and reliable results.”
The team discovered its mistakes during a series Failure can even help organizations identify
of retrospectives that have now become standard where to trim the portfolio. Concluding that
practice for the organization. Those meetings certain types of failed projects don’t align with
included reviewing a comprehensive issue log—a organizational strategy could generate long-term
document that details all problems and identifies benefits in spite of short-term project losses, Mr.
how the team can mitigate them in the future, he Okene says.
says. The issue log helps both internal and external Whether the primary cause of failure is poor align-
stakeholders conduct a root-cause analysis, during ment, scope creep, ineffective risk management or
which they collectively determine the reason for defiant stakeholders, project professionals who can
project failure. The next step in the review process is identify the patterns of failure can help facilitate sus-
a meeting during which stakeholders view the orga- tainable course correction, Mr. Omar says.
nization’s project management procedures through “Of course, damage is done when your project
the lens of the failed project. fails. But you have to understand the root cause
“We extend lessons learned into a specific session so you can fix it and do better in the next project.
where we try to map every process and then identify That’s the whole point of being a project manager:
the processes we missed so that they will become After every project you do, you get better.” PM
I N NOVATI V
64
OU TL I
PM NETWORK JUNE 2019 PMI.ORG
I VE
L I ERS
PMN0619 d-Second Features.indd 65
JUNE 2019 PM NETWORK 65
5/13/19 1:46 PM
T AT I C S T R AT E G I E S
DON’T LAST FOREVER.
Earlier this year, Uber expanded its strategy from
ride-sharing to autonomous bikes and scoot-
ers. Beauty subscription service Birchbox devel-
oped and rolled out a physical “beauty bar” within
existing brick-and-mortar stores across the United
States. And in 2018, global hotel brand Marriott—
in a bid to compete with the growing market for
bookable hospitality “experiences”—launched a
curated series of thousands of hands-on activities
and excursions that guests can buy to supplement
their traditional hotel stay.
When a company’s strategic goals do shift—either
GETTY IMAGES
due to market pressures or competitive survival—it
can push those tasked with managing the portfolio
into uncharted territory. Although innovative outli-
“At the ers, by definition, promise to take organizations into
outset of a new and bold strategic directions, these projects and
cutting-edge their teams can achieve success only if they follow
well-established project management processes.
project, the “Innovative” should never be a synonym for “undis-
project leader ciplined,” says Linda Szmyt, PMP, PfMP, project
has to assess management office director at ticketing software
its impacts company AudienceView, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
on other “Organizations often think of innovation as fast and
projects dirty: Let’s slap a prototype together very quickly,”
within the she says. “But innovative initiatives require the same
project management processes as the rest of the
portfolio.” portfolio.”
—Sridhar Peddisetty, PMP,
PgMP, PfMP, ProKarma,
Portland, Oregon, USA FACING CHANGE
One of the biggest challenges in managing an outlier,
says Ms. Szmyt, is convincing the team “that it shouldn’t
be treated any differently than any other project.”
UBER
Uber has become synonymous with ride-sharing. In 2018, as part
of the CEO’s strategy to become “the Amazon of transportation,”
Uber entered the two-wheel market: bicycle and scooter rentals.
This year, the transportation network company announced the
creation of a new division: microbility robotics. It will explore
projects that turn Uber’s bikes and scooters into autonomous
driving vehicles that can get themselves to the spots where users
need them—eliminating costly distribution operations.
Challenges: Uber’s initiatives to develop self-driving scoot-
ers and bicycles face the perennial technological challenge for
self-driving vehicles: navigating road and pedestrian obstacles.
But the company also has to design two-wheelers that don’t
tip over when human riders aren’t onboard. And it has to do
that without incurring the high costs typically associated with
self-driving tech.
addition to shouldering their usual workloads. To than pulling those team members into the project
address that challenge, project managers have to from the start and then expecting them to remain
identify the team members they will need, how engaged throughout the project, he took a phased
long they will need them and at what points in the approach, he says. “We didn’t have a fixed team
project they will tap them, Mr. Peddisetty says. from the beginning; it progressed as the project
“An organization’s key people are always its busi- went along.” Once the project was scaled up and
est people,” he says. “You have to involve them at a integrated into the organization, those subject mat-
minimal level. You can’t waste their time by pulling ter experts then served as its champions.
them into too many meetings. You have to be aware
that time is a constraint for everyone.” SCALING UP
On a US$2.5 million project to digitize and A phased approach helps determine how and when
automate previously manual human resources pro- to scale the project. Star Alliance has been execut-
cesses, which launched in mid-2018 and is slated for ing a new strategy to develop its digital services
completion later this year, Mr. Peddisetty decided in order to better help air passengers traveling
that some of the project’s key team members with different airlines do so seamlessly. “That has
comprised talent acquisition employees. Rather involved a transformation from a more traditional
development approach to a more iterative one,” the rest of the organization. They should resist that
Mr. Donohoe says. To make that transformation a impulse, Ms. Szmyt says. “Don’t call them special
reality, Star Alliance may launch a pilot project with or secret. That goes against a culture of fairness and
an eye on when and how it can be scaled. “From day transparency.” It also goes against the ultimate aim:
one with each project, we look at how it will benefit making the outlier project a successful part of the
the airline alliance passengers and the 28 member overall enterprise.
airlines,” he says. Too often, Ms. Szmyt says, a team tasked with
Now, for instance, if a flight arrives late and the developing an innovative tool or product is treated
passenger risks missing a connection, the alliance as special and distinct from the rest of the orga-
sends someone to meet the passenger at the gate nization and its project management standards.
and take them to the connecting flight. Star Alliance Only once the product is ready to be scaled and
is currently piloting an initiative that would digitize commercialized is it handed over to other depart-
that assistance, allowing passengers to see on their ments—which haven’t been involved in the project.
mobile devices how to quickly make it to the next “That can create a real it-was-not-invented-here
gate and to receive a voucher allowing them to skip mentality,” she says.
the queue. “Once the pilot phases are complete, Instead, organizations should integrate their
we’ll roll it out in a limited scale, then test and innovation teams and projects within the larger
retest until we can decide to do a global rollout,” culture. That unifying approach will help ensure
Mr. Donohoe says. that project outliers aren’t project aberrations—but
instead adhere to project management standards
OPEN SECRETS for success. “The idea part of innovative outliers is
Organizations might be tempted to treat innovative fun,” Ms. Szmyt says. “But they’re also hard work,
outlier projects—and their teams—as separate from like any other project.” PM
HYBRID…
approach —or mix of approaches — to deliver a successful
project. Often, no single approach will do.
PMI.org/OnePMGoal
#OnePMGoal
©2019 PROJECT MANAGEMENT INSTITUTE, INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. “PMI” THE PMI LOGO, “PMP” and “PMBOK” ARE REGISTERED MARKS OF PROJECT MANAGEMENT INSTITUTE, INC.
Agile Practice Guide was jointly funded by the Agile Alliance® and developed in collaboration with members of the Agile Alliance®. Agile Alliance® does not endorse any agile methodology or certification.
Project Management Institute, 2019, ISBN: 9781628255652, paperback, 175 pages, $59.95 Member, $74.95 List Price
HOW TO Online: marketplace.PMI.org | Email: info@bookorders.pmi.org | Telephone: 1-866-276-4PMI (U.S. and Canada) or +1-770-280-4129 (international)
ORDER Phone ordering hours until 8:00 p.m. U.S. Eastern Time (GMT -4). Or go wherever books are sold.