Professional Documents
Culture Documents
THE
APPLE
STORY
Deconstructing Steve Jobs through the triple
F model: function, functionality and form
BY ANAND KURIAN
REUTERS
S
teve Jobs is remembered as the iconic founder Triple F model, deconstructing a product into three
of a company, where ingenious bursts of cre- different aspects — function,functionality and form.
ativity catalysed extraordinary feats of en- For the purposes of this piece, I am going to apply
gineering. He is considered to have trans- this model to Apple, under Steve Jobs. It would be
formed half a dozen industries — personal com- illuminative and instructive to measure Steve’s con-
puters, animated movies, music, phones, tablet tribution in each area.That would teach us just how
computing, and digital publishing. He was a con- Apple became the most valuable company in the world
duit for both — the creative arts as well as cut- (by the Forbes ranking of 2011).
ting-edge technology; Apple’s singular achieve- For the purpose of clarity, particularly with
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
ments were made possible because he possessed reference to computers, I have defined ‘function’
Anand Kurian is a marketing
a unique meld of many abilities. as being what a product, such as a computer, can
communications theorist and As he himself put it,“Tech companies don’t un- do, the tasks it can perform and how well it can
practitioner; he has been
featured among thirty
derstand creativity.They don’t appreciate intuitive perform them.
marketers from around the thinking, I’m one of the few people who under- ‘Functionality’, I define, as how the user gets it
globe. Extracts from this
article have been part of
stands how producing technology requires intu- to perform those functions — or to put it differently,
lectures at the Indian ition and creativity, and how producing something how quick, simple and easy it is for the user to get
Institutes of Management
and the National Institute
artistic takes real discipline.” the computer to perform those functions.
of Design. In order to review products, I have created the ‘Form’ is, of course, the aesthetic design of the
158 I N D I A N M A N A G E M E N T — M AY 2 0 1 2
TECHNOLOGY & INNOVATION
▼
STEVE WOZNIAK DESERVES ACCLAIM
REUTERS
$10 each. The Xerox Corporation’s Palo Alto Re- into an office, there are papers on the desk.The one
search Center (PARC) had pioneered the concept of on the top is the most important.The reason we model
bitmapping at that time; the bitmapped screen made our computers on the desktop is that we can lever-
a graphical interface possible. age the experience people already have.”
The Apple ‘theft’ of the Xerox PARC bitmapping He motivated his team to make the Macintosh
concept is oftentimes described as one of the biggest boot up 28 seconds faster.When they started to ex-
raids in the chronicles of industry. Jobs occasion- plain that it couldn’t be done, Jobs cut them off. “If
ally accepted this, and not without some degree of it could save a person’s life, would you find a way
pride.As he once said,“Picasso had a saying — ‘good to shave off the boot time?”he asked.“If five million
artists copy, great artists steal’ — and we have al- use the Mac, and it takes 10 seconds extra to boot
ways been shameless about stealing great ideas.” up, that adds up to some three hundred million or
Steve Jobs could never claim credit for the so hours in a year,which is the equivalent of at least
bitmapped screen (nor did he). one hundred lifetimes…”
But, Jobs, and the team of engi-
neers he led, greatly improved iTunes and the iPod
on the graphical interface they Jobs’ limited contributions in the domain of the es-
saw at Xerox PARC, in terms of sential functions of a product
functionality,and they were able and his very significant contri-
to execute them in ways that Xe- The creation of the butions in the area of function-
rox, perhaps, never could ac- iPod converted Apple ality seem to be replicated in al-
complish. For example, the Xe- most every product category.
rox mouse had three buttons,
from a computer Other companies were already
was far too complicated, didn’t manufacturer into, in making music-management ap-
move around smoothly and, at the words of Forbes, plications,but they were unwieldy
$300 a piece, was outrageously and far too intricate to use. One
expensive. Jobs got a local firm
‘the world’s most of Jobs’ unique abilities was to
to make a simple, single-button valuable company’ identify product categories where
model that moved effortlessly the existing players were less
and cost just $15. than first-rate.When he examined
The improvements were more than just in the the music apps available — including real jukebox
details. The mouse at Xerox PARC could not be and windows media player — he concluded that
used to drag a window around the screen. Apple’s they were so complicated that only a prodigy could
engineers devised an interface so you could not only wade through and figure out most of their features.
drag windows and files around,you could even drop They scored extremely poorly on functionality.
them into folders. Apple allowed the windows on After he had set up iTunes, Jobs realised that
a screen to overlap so that the “top” one clipped Apple had the opportunity to design a portable
into the ones “below” it. In terms of its pure func- music player device to sync with the iTunes soft-
tion, the product was clearly Xerox’s; in terms of ware, allowing it to be far simpler. He would sac-
its functionality, however, Apple had taken it to a rifice function for functionality — easy functions
totally new and different level. would be executed on the device, more difficult
Jobs loved the notion of a ‘desktop’.“People know ones on the computer. This led to the creation of
how to deal with a desktop ‘intuitively’. If you walk the iPod; and it was truly this device that con-
162 I N D I A N M A N A G E M E N T — M AY 2 0 1 2
TECHNOLOGY & INNOVATION
PHOTOS: REUTERS
164 I N D I A N M A N A G E M E N T — M AY 2 0 1 2
TECHNOLOGY & INNOVATION
make. Did we care about getting our wash done in Steve was slowly adopting the Bauhaus aesthetic;
an hour versus an hour-and-a-half? Or, did we care he liked the notion of simple and clean modernism,
about our clothes feeling soft and lasting longer? produced for the masses. And he believed that
Did we care about using a quarter of the water…?” there should be no distinction between fine art and
applied industrial design.
Form As a matter of fact, the Power Mac G4 Cube, re-
We now enter the area and domain where Steve Jobs leased in the beginning of the 21st century, was so
left his most important and most indelible legacy. alluring that it was exhibited in New York’s Museum
Mike Markkula, the first chairman and one of of Modern Art.An eight-inch perfect cube,it was the
the first major investors in Apple, had put down pure expression of the Apple aesthetic philosophy.
the company’s philosophy, emphasising three prin-
ciples. Heading the list was empathy. “We will Minimal, yet playful
truly understand their needs better than any As Jobs’ design sensibilities were evolving,his early
other company.” tryst with Buddhism spilled over onto his sense of
Next came focus: “In order to do a good job of design (his black turtleneck was a creation of the
those things that we decide to do, we must elimi- Japanese designer Issey Miyake — he had more than
nate all of the unimportant opportunities.” a hundred of them). ‘Simplicity is the ultimate so-
The last was impute.“People phistication’,‘real artists simplify’,were quickly be-
DO judge a book by its cover,” he coming his design mottos. In Jony Ive, Jobs met his
wrote. “We may have the best soul mate in the quest for true rather than surface
product, the highest quality, the simplicity. Ive believed that,“To be truly simple, you
most useful software etc.; if we have to go really deep. Deep
present them in a slipshod man- enough to understand the essence
ner, they will be perceived as Jobs’ limited of a product…”
slipshod; if we present them in contributions in the But Steve and Ive were care-
a creative, professional manner, ful that their sleek designs would
we will impute the desired qual- domain of the not become slick, over-powering
ities.” And it was this last that essential functions of or unapproachable; they kept it,
Steve seemed to take most to a product seem to be on the other hand, warm, pas-
heart and was to prove to be his sionate and playful. Steve’s own
unique strength. replicated in almost leaning towards Zen tilted him to-
every product category wards minimalism but it was
The brand name and never clinical.
the logo Jobs would constantly stress
The name Apple Computer had been suggested by that his products should look friendly. One of the
Steve Jobs.There were long periods,in his twenties, fascinating changes that one can observe as a di-
when he would eat nothing but fruit. The name rect consequence is that, as the design evolved, the
sounded fun, spirited and not intimidating. Apple Macintosh began to resemble a human face. Taller
took the edge off the word ‘computer’.Plus,it would and narrower than most computers, it suggested a
get us ahead of Atari in the phone book!” ‘head’. The base reminded one of a ‘chin’, and Jobs
His instincts would prove to be right. During a reduced the plastic at the top to make the ‘forehead’
period when computers were still seen to be intim- more appealing.The designers were later to confess,
idating, meant to be used by people who were “in- “Even though Steve didn’t draw any of the lines, his
telligent” and “skilled at that kind of thing”, Apple ideas and inspiration made the design what it is.
disarmed the average person. It was as American as We didn’t know what it meant for a computer to be
you could get. The logo linked Apple to the tree of ‘friendly’ until Steve told us.”
knowledge, which most Americans would know That was the basic philosophy that both Jobs
about, and had a whiff of the rebel about it. and Ive believed in. In an interview with Fortune,
he said,“In most people’s vocabularies,design means
The mass production of art veneer. But to me, nothing could be further from the
He once took his Apple team to see an exhibition meaning of design. Design is the fundamental soul
of Tiffany glass at the museum; he wished them of a man-made creation that ends up expressing it-
to learn that great art could be mass-produced. self in successive outer layers.”
166 I N D I A N M A N A G E M E N T — M AY 2 0 1 2
TECHNOLOGY & INNOVATION
ABOUT THE STORES On one occasion,Jobs and Ive ever be carried around but when Ive suggested it,
once wandered into the sunflower Steve immediately warmed to the idea — both of
■ The architectural firm had been hired
to design the stores garden that Job’s wife had planted. them understood that it would make the computer
■ The floors of most major Apple stores, Ive asked,“What if the screen was less intimidating to its target audience.
would be made of sandstone that separated from the base like a
came from the ll Casone quarry near sunflower?” He grew excited and Reverse engineering
the Tuscan town of Firenzuola
■ By opening their own stores,
started sketching what he had in In most corporations, form follows function. The
Steve jobs could have complete mind. Ive thought all design engineers created the innards of the machine and
control of how it was designed and should have a story behind it; he then it was put into an aesthetic shell by the de-
made to how it was sold
hoped that the sunflower shape signers.The Apple philosophy was almost iconoclastic,
would suggest that it was alive in this regard.Jobs had already finalised the design
and that it could reach up towards the sky. of the original Macintosh, when it was handed over
Almost as a playful afterthought, the iMac had to the engineers — they had to fit the insides of the
a handle that rested on top of it. Its use was doubt- computer into it.
ful,it was unlikely that the desktop computer would At NeXT,his very own company,he could indulge
168 I N D I A N M A N A G E M E N T -- M A Y 2 0 1 2
TECHNOLOGY & INNOVATION
REUTERS
170 I N D I A N M A N A G E M E N T -- M A Y 2 0 1 2
TECHNOLOGY & INNOVATION
172 I N D I A N M A N A G E M E N T -- M A Y 2 0 1 2
TECHNOLOGY & INNOVATION
powerful messages about the quality of the prod- and Ive insisted on a solid piece of brushed aluminum
ucts inside.This is fairly common for products such for the edge of the iPhone 4 though the engineers were
as jewellery but less common for more utilitarian nervous that it would affect the antenna.
products — Jobs’ unique ability lay in taking a prac- To function as an antenna, the rim had to have a
tical piece of machinery into a plane where none of tiny gap. But if the gap was covered, for instance, with
his competitors existed. a finger, there could be signal loss.The engineers rec-
“When you open the box of an iPhone or iPad, we ommended a clear coating over the metal as a solu-
want that tactile experience to set the tone for how you tion but Ive vetoed this. When the engineers com-
perceive the product,” he said. “Mike taught me that.” plained to Jobs, he brushed aside their objections,
“Steve and I spend a lot of time on the packaging,” saying, as always, that they could solve it.
said Ive. “I love the process of unpacking something. The engineers did get it to work — almost all the
You design a ritual of unpacking to make the product time.When the iPhone 4 was released, it looked splen-
feel special. Packaging can be theatre, it can create a did, but the signal problem did surface, though it oc-
story.”All Apple customers were to learn to be part of curred,perhaps,only once every long while.Consumer
and to love that ritual. reports did tests of its own and refused to recommend
the iPhone 4, citing the antenna problem; it became
Reset and start over known as “Antenna gate”.
Quite often,even as he neared the end of a project,Jobs
would call a halt and then ask for The stores
changes that would turn the clock “The store will become the most powerful physical ex-
right back.This happened with his pression of the brand,”it had been predicted.That fore-
first Pixar film, Toy Story, with the cast never did come true — but that the Apple stores
Apple stores and with the iPhone became one of a kind retail outlets
as well. One morning, when the is certainly a fact.
iPhone project was almost nearing Jobs’ unique ability Jobs had been advised to build
completion, Jobs went over to see a mock-up of a store near the Ap-
was in taking a
Ive. “I didn’t sleep last night,” he ple campus, furnish it completely,
said, “because I realised that I just practical piece of and then to spend time there, tin-
don’t love it.” Ive was upset and machinery into kering with it till he was completely
then,to his own consternation,found happy with it. He did do just that
a plane where
Jobs was correct. — he rented a vacant warehouse
The design was re-done; it meant none of his in Cupertino and then,every Tues-
that they had to re-work the circuit competitors existed day for six months,they held meet-
boards, antenna, and processor ings there,talking about their ideas
placement inside,but Jobs was fine for retailing and building the store
with that. “Other companies may have shipped,” said around their concepts. “I loved to wander over there
an old Apple hand, “but we pressed the reset button on my own, just checking it out,” Jobs would remem-
and started over.” ber later.
Jobs’ unique signature style is very much in evi-
Backfire: design versus engineering dence in Apple’s Manhattan Fifth Avenue store: it was
Conflict between designers,who want to make a prod- almost the visual embodiment of his design philos-
uct look aesthetic, and engineers, who need to make ophy — a cube, a signature staircase, glass, making
sure it fulfills its function, is fairly common in many a “maximum statement through minimalism”.It is open
companies. At Apple, Steve always weighed in with 24/7, it justified Jobs’ policy of creating unique sig-
the design team, ignoring the objections of the man- nature high-traffic stores by drawing 50,000 visitors
ufacturing engineers, who raised practical consider- a week during its first year. “This store grosses more
ations when confronted with Ive’s artistic creations. per square foot than any store in the world,”Jobs said
There were, sometimes, minor hiccups. The iPod in 2010. “It also grosses more in total-absolute dol-
Nano, for example, was liable to getting scratched be- lars, not just per square foot-than any store in New
cause Ive thought a clear coating would mar the ele- York. That includes Saks and Bloomingdale’s.”
gance of his design. But that was not a disaster. As the number of stores grew and they thrived,
On occasions, there were more serious conse- Jobs stayed immersed in every minute detail. In one
quences,however.Antenna gate was one of them.Jobs meeting just before a store opening, Steve agonised
174 I N D I A N M A N A G E M E N T -- M A Y 2 0 1 2
TECHNOLOGY & INNOVATION
for half an hour about the precise shade of gray that he has had a great influence on several indus-
of the restroom sign.An architectural firm had been tries during his lifetime.
hired to design the stores, but Jobs made every By applying my Triple F model to Steve Jobs,
major decision. The floors of most major Apple I have demonstrated that there is a clear pattern
stores, for instance, would be made of sandstone that emerges when we study his work and his
that came from the ll Casone quarry near the Tus- achievements. Steve Jobs had an extremely tu-
can town of Firenzuola. Jobs had seen this in Flo- multuous career — it might, therefore, come as a
rence, twenty years earlier. surprise that the pattern that emergesis a fairly
He was also able to create great hoopla and ex- consistent one.Throughout his life, his major con-
citement over the store openings,the same way that tributions came, not in the functions of the gad-
he did with the product launches. Men, women and gets he produced; his permanent and greatest con-
children would travel to store openings, spending tributions were consistently in the functionality
the night outside so they could be among the first and in the form of the products he produced. And
in. The stores became part of the entire experience in the technology space, he was undoubtedly, the
of Apple products and by opening their own stores, first to recognise the importance of these areas.
Steve could have complete control, from how it was He was playing to his strengths, of course, in do-
designed and made to how it was sold. ing this — there were few others in the intersec-
tion of the arts and the sciences where he stood.
Summing up Steve He was almost alone where he was and he knew
It is said that you will never need an Apple, but you best how to leverage that position.
will always want one. “Steve understands desire,” The passage of time will,perhaps,show us more
said Alan Kay, who had conceived the tablet com- clearly where Steve Jobs stands in the history of in-
puter nearly 40 years before the iPad was launched. dustry — particularly and more specifically, in-
Fortune magazine has rated Steve Jobs as the dustry in the technology space, but in the two ar-
greatest entrepreneur of our time. There will be eas of functionality and form, it is unlikely that his
those who would argue with that rating — but it is bequest will be challenged. That, in the end, could
unlikely that anyone will quarrel with the thought be his enduring legacy. IM
176 I N D I A N M A N A G E M E N T -- M A Y 2 0 1 2