Professional Documents
Culture Documents
EMPLOYEE BENEFITS
IAS 19
- Outlines the accounting for all types of employee benefits except share-based compensation.
-All forms of consideration given to an employee by an entity for services rendered by the employee is
called employee benefits.
*Post-employment benefits
*Termination benefits
- Are employee benefits other than termination benefits and short-term benefits which are payable
after the completion of employment.
- Usually established as part of remuneration package for its employees and may also be established by
law.
- These include:
- Contributory – both the employer and the employee shoulders the cost of the employment benefits by
making the contributions to the plan, although not of equal amounts.
- Non-contributory – it is only the employer making the contributions to the plan for the employee
benefits. Only the employer bears the burden of the cost of the benefits.
-Funded plan vs Non-funded plan -the difference is the transferring of assets from the entity to a
separate fund into a trustee, bank or insurance company.
- Funded plan – the employer just makes the payment and contributions to the fund in agency. It is the
responsibility and obligation of the funding agency to accumulate funds and pay the employee benefit
to the retired employee when due.
- Unfunded plan/Non-funded plan – there is no separate plan for that purpose. The company maintains
the fund and has obligation to pay for the employee at the time of the retirement when due.
-In this type of retirement benefit, the employee bears the investment risk. The obligation of the
employer is to just make the contributions to a fund- where as the trustee, must accumulate and
increase the fund so that upon the retirement of the employee, retirement benefits received will be
higher amount.
- Simply stated, the contribution is fixed, but the benefit is not fixed. Therefore the amount of the
retirement benefits depends on the success of the management of the fund under the trustee.
- The amount of employee benefit is agreed or fixed, definite or specific that is usually computed in
consideration of salary and number of years in service.
- Moreover, in here, the employer must make additional contributions to meet up with the required
fixed amount of retirement benefit.
- The obligation of the company is determined by the amount of contribution at each period and in
which the amount is an undiscounted basis. This is simple to apply. The amount contributed is
recognized as an expense in the period it is payable.
- Just like normal accounting consideration or treatment, any amount of unpaid contribution is regarded
as accrued expense at the end of the accounting period and any excess shall be recognized as prepaid
expense if it will reduce future payments or will lead to a cash refund.
- Required Disclosures:
b. The contribution to defined contribution plan for key management personnel as required by PAS 24
on related party disclosures.
ILLUSTRATION 1 (ADAPTED)
- An employee of a large manufacturing company in Davao City earned 480,000 during the current year.
- The employee is covered by the firm’s defined contribution plan which requires the entity to
contribute the equivalent of 5% of the employee’s salary of 24,000 for the current year to a trustee.
Case 1: If the entity paid the 24,000 on December 31, 2019, the entry will be:
Cash 24,000
- Having made the contribution, the entity has n further obligation. Thus no further entries to be
prepared util the next accounting period.
- An employee of a large manufacturing company in Davao City earned 480,000 during the current year.
- The employee is covered by the firm’s defined contribution plan which requires the entity to
contribute the equivalent of 5% of the employee’s salary of 24,000 for the current year to a trustee.
Case 2: If the entity paid the 24,000 concerning 2019, on January 31, 2020 (late payment); the entry will
be:
Cash 24,000
- An employee of a large manufacturing company in Davao City earned 480,000 during the current year.
- The employee is covered by the firm’s defined contribution plan which requires the entity to
contribute the equivalent of 5% of the employee’s salary of 24,000 for the current year to a trustee.
Case 3: If the company paid 35,000 pesos total in which 11,000 is in respect for services to be rendered
in 2020 (11,000 advance payment), the entry will be:
-December 31 2019
Cash 35,000
- Under IAS 19, the entity uses an actuarial technique, the projected unit credit method to estimate the
ultimate cost of benefits.
- This type of plan requires the expertise of an individual expert in dealing with actuarial assumptions
(Actuary) in order to measure the obligation and the expense.
- IAS 19 (2011). 80 provides that financial assumptions must be made at the end of the reporting period.
- Contrary to defined contribution plan, the obligation in a defined benefit plan is on a discounted basis.
- IAS 19 (2011). 83 provides that the discount rate used is determined by reference to market yields on
high quality corporate bonds at the end of the reporting period.
- Thus, accounting procedures involve is more complex than that of a defined contribution plan.
- Further, unlike the first plan, the amount of contribution to the plan in a defined benefit plan may not
be the same amount as the expense to recognized for the period.
- PAS 19 of PAR 120 provides that the defined benefit cost shall be composed of the following:
a. Service cost – (Profit or Loss) which includes current service cost, past service cost, and gain or loss on
settlement.
b. Net Interest - (Profit of Loss) which is composed of interest expense on defined benefit liability,
interest income on plan assets, interest expense on effect of asset ceiling.
*change in effect of asset ceiling less interest on the effect of asset ceiling.
- Current service cost is the present value of the annual benefit obligation in a defined benefit plan for
the services rendered by the employee in the current year.
- The method used to compute the present value of the defined benefit obligation along with the
current service cost is the projected unit credit method.
- To illustrate the process by using this method, assume the following information as adapted:
-Lumpsum payment to employees upon retirement 5% of final salary for every year of service
- To get the final salary, the future value of 1 at 8% for 4 years which is 1.3605 is multiplied to 400,000.
=400,000 (1.3605)
=544,200
- To compute for the benefit each year, multiply 5% with the final salary computed.
=544,200 (0.05)
=27,210
- The amount of 136,050 is the total present value of the obligation at the time that the employee is
expected to be paid.
- The annual benefit of 27,210 shall be discounted at 10% from the final year which is 2023 to get the
annual present value of the future benefits. The following PV factors can be computed or can be
obtained in a table of present value factors.
1 .909
2 .826
3 .751
4 .683
- Note that the factor used for 2019 is .683 because 2019 is 4 years away from 2023, .751 for 2020
because 3 years away from 2023 and so on.
- The amount discounted per year represents the current service cost. To determine the amount of
interest cost, the preparation of the table projected benefit obligation is necessary as illustrated below:
- For the final year, 12/31/2023, the interest cost is just worked back 136,050 less 27,210 and less
98,918 to get the 9,922. The 136,050 was computed above as the total present value build-up of the
benefit obligation.
- Accordingly, as we discussed a while ago that the employee benefit or the defined benefit cost is
composed of the service cost plus interest cost plus remeasurements, in the problem above the
company shall report employee benefit expense per year as follows:
expense
- Note that when you add the employee benefit expense per year, it will result to 136,050.
Proof:
18,584
22,293
26,563
31,478
37,132
136,050
- Net interest as component of employee benefit expense mentioned awhile ago is composed of three
elements: Interest expense on the defined benefit liability, interest income and interest expense on
effect of asset ceiling.
- Interest expense computation has already been discussed earlier as the result of multiplying the
discount rate to the present value of the benefit obligation at the beginning of the period.
- Interest expense on effect of asset ceiling is computed by multiplying the effect of the asset ceiling at
the beginning of the reporting period multiplied at the same discount rate used for the defined benefit
obligation.
ILLUSTRATION 2 (ADAPTED)
- At the beginning of the current year, the record showed the following:
- To compute the net interest, get first the interest expense which is 12% multiplies to 4,000,000
resulting to 480,000. Interest income is computed as discount rate same as used for the defined benefit
obligation of 12% multiplies to the fair value of plan assets at 3,200,000 resulting to 384,000
- In the memorandum record of the trustee, the 480,000 interest expense is included in the defined
benefit obligation while the 384,000 interest income as part of the computation of the fair value of plan
assets at year-end in the memorandum record.
- The term used to describe the change in a defined benefit obligation for employee service in the prior
periods is past service cost.
- Past service cost is the change in the present value of defined benefit obligation for the employee
service in the previous years that resulted from amendment of plan and curtailment.
- PAS 19R in paragraph 103 states that the recognition of past service cost as an expense is necessary at
the earlier between
- Moreover, IAS 19 (2011), 110 provides that any gain or loss on settlement of a defined benefit plan are
to be recognized on the event of occurrence of settlement.
ILLUSTRATION 3 (ADAPTED)
- An entity with a defined benefit plan provides for a 5% benefit based on final salary or each year of
service. The benefits become vested after five years of service.
- On January 1, 2019, the entity improves the benefit to 6% of final salary for each year of service
including prior years.
- At the amendment date, the present value of the additional benefits increased as follows:
- The total past service cost of 225,000 (150,000 + 75,000) shall be recognized as expense immediately
and also the amount is included as addition to the defined benefit obligation.
PLAN ASSETS
- Plan assets are composed of the assets held by a long-term benefit fund and qualifying insurance
policies.
- The measurement of plan assets is at fair value. It does not include unpaid contributions due from the
reporting entity to the fund. Moreover, it is reduced by the amount of liabilities of the fund not relating
to employee benefits.
- Qualifying Insurance Policy – an insurance policy issued by an insurer that is not a related party of the
reporting entity. The proceeds of the policy can be used only to pay employee benefits and are not
available to the reporting entity’s own creditors even in bankruptcy.
- Except.
a. when the proceeds represents surplus assets not needed for the policy to pay employee
benefits.
b. when the proceeds are returned to the reporting entity to reimburse it for employee benefits
already paid.
- When an insurance policy is not a qualifying insurance policy, that insurance policy is not a plan asset.
a. Interest, dividend and other income derived from the plan assets.
- The said return on plan assets is accounted for through other comprehensive income as
“remeasurements” which is not to be recycled through profit or loss. Instead, it can be reclassified to
retained earnings. [IAS 19(2011) 120-130]
Less: interest income on FV of plan assets at the beginning of the period (xx)
ILLUSTRATION 4 (ADAPTED)
Remeasurement computation:
- The actual return of 675,000 is separately reported as the interest income included in the computation
of employee benefit expense as deduction from interest expense to get the net interest.
- Whereas the 450,000 remeasurement gain is reported through other comprehensive income.
- The same problem above, the fair value of plan assets can be computed as follows:
*Total 5,175,000
*Total 5,175,000
- PAS 19R of paragraph 20 provides the remeasurement such as actuarial gains and losses be reported
through other comprehensive income and not reclassified through profit or loss subsequently.
- Actuarial gains and losses represents changes in the present value of the defined benefit obligation
arising from changes are inevitable.
- As a guide, actuarial loss occurs when actual benefit obligation is higher than the estimated amount
because the obligation actually increased from that which is estimated.
- Illustration:
2. Identification and explanation of the amounts in the financial statements of the defined benefit plan.
3. Description of how the plan may affect the amount, timing an uncertainty of the future cash flows of
the entity.
- As earlier, the benefit plan is a sub entity separate and distinct from the primary entity which is the
employer. Hence, the sub entity maintains information that is not reflected in the general ledger of the
employer entity and that information will not appear in the financial statements of the employer entity
because such information is kept only by means of memorandum records. This memorandum records
contain the fair value of plan assets (FVPA) and the projected benefit obligation (PBO). These two items
are off statement of financial position account, which is an asset if debit balance and a liability if credit
balance. Since these two items are kept only in the memorandum records of the sub entity, what
appears in the employer entity’s financial statements is the account “prepaid/accrued benefit cost”. If
FVPA is more than the PBO, there is a prepaid benefit cost, which is classified as a non-current asset. In
the scenario, the plan is overfunded. On the other way around, if the FVPA is less than the PBO , the
fund is underfunding giving rise to an accrued benefit cost which is a non-current liability.
- To illustrate an underfunded plan, assume that an entity made a contribution amounting to 900,000 to
the defined benefit plan for the current year and to simplify the illustration, the only component of the
benefit expense is the current service cost of 1,000,000. The journal entry would be as follows:
Cash 900,000
- Moreover, to illustrate an overfunded plan, assume that an entity made a contribution amounting to
1,200,000 to a defined benefit plan for the current year and to simplify the illustration , the only
component of the benefit expense is the current service cost of 1,000,000.
Cash 1,2000,000
- Note that the account “Prepaid/Accrued benefit cost” account is a balancing figure and may have a
debit or a credit balance at the end of reporting period and will be reported as prepaid benefit cost (if
debit balance) or accrued benefit cost (if credit balance) as earlier stated.
ILLUSTRATION 1
Assumes that at the beginning of the year, the memorandum records in relation to a defined benefit
plan showed the following information:
4. FVPA, end
5. PBO, end
4. FVPA, end
5. PBO, end
Cash 500,000
- With this entry the prepaid/accrued benefit cost as shown at the beginning which amounted to
1,000,000 is increased by the amount of accrued benefit cist during the year in the amount of 650,000
resulting to 1,650,000 accrued benefit cost at the end.
STATEMENT OF A PLAN
- This is a transaction which eliminated all further legal or constructive obligations in part or all of the
benefits provided under a defined benefit plan. Example of settlement is when an entity purchases
annuity contracts from insurance entities for less than the amount in the retirement fund and another is
when there is a one-off transfer of significant employer contributions under the plan to an insurance
entity through purchase of insurance policy. It is provided under PAS 19, paragraph 110 that when
settlement occurs, an entity shall recognize gain or loss on settlement price and the present value of the
defined benefit obligation on the date of settlement. Settlement gain arises when settlement price is
lower than present value of defined benefit obligation settled while settlement loss occurs when
settlement price is higher than the defined benefit obligation settled. This gain or loss on settlement
shall be fully recognized and included in service cost in the computation of employee benefit expense.
- Assume the following data adapted from the book of Conrado T. Valix, et al which is entitled Financial
Accounting, Volume 2:
Discount rate 5%
1. settlement gain
5. FVPA, end
6. PBO, end
7. Accrued benefits cost, end
Answers:
1. Settlement gain
5. FVPA, end
Total 2,450,000
Less: settlement price 225,000
- Or computed as :
Total 2,450,000
6. PBO, end
Total 3,287,500
- Or computed as :
Cash 300,000
ILLUSTRATION 3
A scenario where there is a prepaid benefit cost which does not exceed asset ceiling, assume the
following information revealed at year end for a defined benefit plan:
- Assume further that the asset ceiling or the present value of available future refunds and reduction in
future contributions amounted to 600,000
- In this case, the surplus does not exceed the asset ceiling. Hence, there is no accounting problem. The
500,000 difference between the FVPA and PBO shall be recognized as prepaid benefit cost which is
reported as non-current asset in the financial statements at year end.
ILLUSTRATION 4
Scenario where there is a prepaid benefit cost but exceed asset ceiling, assume the following date
revealed for a defined benefit plan at the beginning of the current year:
*FVPA 9,000,000
*PBO 8,000,000
- As provided in PAS 19, par 8, any change in the effect of the asset ceiling, excluding interest on the
effect of asset ceiling is considered as a remeasurement which will be recognized in other
comprehensive income. Further provided is that the interest on the effect of the asset ceiling is part of
the total change in the effect of the asset ceiling. The amount of which is determined by multiplying the
effect of the asset ceiling at the beginning of the period by the discount rate. The difference between
the total change in the effect of the asset ceiling and the interest on the effect of the asset ceiling is
considered as remeasurement. Any increase in the effect of asset ceiling gives rise to a remeasurement
loss minus interest expense on the effect of asset ceiling and any decrease in the effect of asset ceiling is
a remeasurement gain plus interest expense on the effect of asset ceiling.
- To apply what has been stated in the standard let us determine the items below using the data
provided above.
1. FVPA, end
2. PBO, end
Answers:
1. FVPA, end
- Observe that the prepaid benefit cost at the end is 1,600,000 which is equal to the amount of asset
ceiling because as the standard provides that the surplus should not exceed the asset ceiling. The journal
entry to record the above information would be:
Cash 1,400,000
DISCLOSURE
- The following information shall be disclosed in the report of a retirement plan, defined contribution
and defined benefit plan:
3. Description of the plan and the effect of any changes in the plan during the period.
- IAS 19 criteria for recognizing short term benefits provides that a liability is recognized when the
employee has rendered the services to be paid in the future as employee benefit.
2. Short term compensated or paid absences such as paid annual leave and sick leave.
- The recognition of short-term benefits is simple because there is no complex computations since it is
recognized on an undiscounted basis because these are payable not later than 12 months after the end
of the accounting period.
- Thus, any unpaid benefit is recognized as accrued expense while the amount paid in advance is
reported as prepaid expense.
- One of the example mentioned above was sick leave and annual leave.
- Accumulating can also be vesting or non-vesting. In a vesting type, it means that an employee receives
cash payment for unused entitlement on leaving t entity. Whereas non-vesting means that even if the
leave entitlement is not used, there is no cash payment to the employee.
- Accumulating type is that unused leave entitlement is carried forward while non-accumulating means
that when the leave entitlement is not used, it cannot be carried forward for the next accounting period.
- The entry to be recognized the leave entitlement used is to debit the expense and credit cash such as :
Cash xx
- When the leave is accumulating, the entry to recognize the leave entitlement that is not used is as
follows:
- If the leave entitlement is non-accumulating, there is no entry on the unused vacation leave.
- In profit sharing or bonus plan, the computation of which has been discussed very early in this course.
- Its recognition requirements provided for in IAS 19 that states when there is legal constructive
obligation to make such payments and there is reliable estimate of the amount to be recognized.
- Thus, to review, the entry to recognize and paying of the bonus are as follows:
1. Bonus expense xx
Bonus payable xx
2. Bonus payable xx
Cash xx
- In the case of other long-term benefits, its recognition and measurement work similarly for that of a
defined benefit obligation.
- IAS 19 (2011). 153-154 states the difference as to the treatment of components of the defined cost
because all items are included as part of the computation of the employee benefit expense recognized
through profit or loss.
- Thus all components, current service cost, past service cost, gain or loss on settlement, net interest
expense and remeasurements are all reported through profit or loss and nothing to be recognized
through other comprehensive income.
TERMINATION BENEFITS
- PAS 19 provides that if the termination benefits is to be wholly settled within 12 months after the end
of the reporting period, the accounting for short-term employee benefits shall be used.
- On the other hand, if it is to be settled beyond 12 months, the application guidance on the other long-
term benefits shall be used.
- The recognition of termination benefits shall be at the earlier of period between when the entity can
no longer withdraw the offer of those benefits o when the entity recognized costs for restructuring as
provided for under IAS 37 guidance.
ILLUSTRATION 1
TERMINATION BENEFITS
- An entity decided to close its plant site in 10 months and will terminate the employees thereto.
2. Each employee that stays until closure received cash payment of 45,000.
20 (15,000) = 300,000
100(45,000) = 4,500,000
- The 4,800,000 is partly termination benefits and partly short-term benefits. The amount 15,000 is to be
paid regardless of staying in the company until closure or leaving before closure.
- Hence, this amount is regarded as termination benefits totaling 1,800,000 computed as 120 employees
multiplied by 15,000.
- Whereas the 30,000 multiplied to 100 employees which is equal to 3,000,000 is regarded as short-term
benefits and can be recorded as accrued monthly over 10 months for 300,000.