Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2 EATON www.eaton.com
Benefits of contactors vs. breakers for Application Paper AP020006EN
medium-voltage motor control applications Effective September 2020
Higher mechanical and electrical endurance Enhanced safety: faster clearing times
Motor starters using contactors have extended mechanical and and lower let-through currents
electrical life when compared to breakers used in the same Breaker-based motor controller short-circuit protection is usually
application. The impact here is substantial. For motor starting provided by the instantaneous overcurrent setting of the motor
applications, contactors can require little, if any, maintenance for protection relay. Although this type of protection operates with no
decades. In contrast, breaker-based solutions for motor starting intentional time delay, it is important to note that inherit delays exist
could require repeated maintenance beginning within a year of due to relay and breaker operations or total clearing time.
operation.
To obtain the relay operating time, the protection engineer must
As seen in Table 1, vacuum breakers have a mechanical endurance account for the relay’s output contact and instantaneous protection
of 10,000 operations with a manufacturer recommended operating time. Relays typically have an 8 msec contact operation
maintenance period of 500 operations. Vacuum contactors are time with a 30 msec maximum pickup time. This means the relay’s
commonly rated for 25,000 electrical operations before maintenance total operating time is about 38 msec or about 2¼ cycles. Once the
is recommended and a total electrical life up to 300,000 operations. relay picks up and closes its output contact to trip the breaker, it
will take an additional 50 to 83 msec (3 to 5 cycles) in order to fully
Table 1. Vacuum breaker and contactor rated operations
open its contacts and clear the fault. Adding both the relay’s and the
and maintenance
breaker’s operating times, the total clearing time is 88–121 msec
Recommended (5–7 cycles).
Rated electrical maintenance
Device operations operations
Class E2 motor controllers use a main contactor to make and break
Vacuum breaker 10,000 500 load and overload currents, in addition to MV current-limiting fuses
400 A vacuum contactor 300,000 25,000 for interrupting fault currents that exceed the breaking capacity of
800 A vacuum contactor 200,000 25,000 the main contactor.
Most 400 A MV contactors have interrupting ratings between
6000 A and 8500 A; and 800 A MV contactors have interrupting
ratings of 7200 A to 12,500 A. In order to obtain higher interrupting
Breakers are constructed to stop high levels of current in the event ratings, current-limiting fuses are supplied as backup protection to
of a fault. They are excellent interrupters, and as such, they are interrupt and limit short-circuit currents higher than the contactor’s
better suited for power distribution applications instead of motor rating. The motor starter design must ensure the contactor does not
starting applications where the number of operations significantly open above its interrupting rating, and instead allow the fuse to
increases. For example, an application where only four motor starting clear this fault.
operations are required per day would lead to maintenance periods of
four months if a breaker-based controller is applied. Using the same Table 2 tabulates the minimum and total clearing times as well as
scenario, we find that the contactor will not require any recommended the let-through current of common fuses used in 400 A and 800 A
maintenance for more than ten years. Breakers can be used in this MV motor starters. As seen in this table, the higher the levels of
context, but it’s important to understand manufacturers’ maintenance prospective short-circuit current at the fuse location, the faster the
recommendations in order to implement maintenance schedules that fuse takes to clear and limit the let-through fault current feeding
accommodate for this usage. the fault. This current-limiting feature clears a fault within ½ cycle or
at least 10 times faster than a breaker’s instantaneous protection,
greatly reducing the amount of arc-flash energy produced during a
fault, making it safer for its users.
EATON www.eaton.com 3
Application Paper AP020006EN Benefits of contactors vs. breakers for
Effective September 2020 medium-voltage motor control applications
Conclusion
With the ability to pair a fully rated 800 A starter with an 800 A
induction motor, there’s an opportunity for an optimum solution to
starting and stopping MV motors. Applying a fully rated 800 A starter
instead of a 1200 A circuit breaker not only right-sizes the equipment
for the application but also translates to other benefits: reduced
footprint, lower chopping currents, higher endurance, and faster
clearing times. The contactor-based solution provides significant
advantages along each of these parameters:
All that said, the traditional approach can work, and equipment
can last until it becomes too expensive and too difficult to find
replacement parts. When that happens, there’s an opportunity
to assess the best approach available today.
References
[1] Eaton Corp., R-Rated Medium-Voltage fuses for
Motor Circuit Protection, 2018.
Eaton
1000 Eaton Boulevard
Cleveland, OH 44122
United States
Eaton.com
© 2020 Eaton
All Rights Reserved Eaton is a registered trademark.
Printed in USA
Publication No. AP020006EN / Z24197 All other trademarks are property
September 2020 of their respective owners.