Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Introduction
TORSTEN(OLIVER(SALGE(|+Aachen
School(of(Business(and(Economics
TIME Research+Area+|(Innovation,+Strategy+and+Organization+Group+(ISO)
TIME Research+Area+|+Innovation,+Strategy+and+Organization+Group+(ISO)
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
Outlining+the+objectives+of+this+video
! To+observe+strategy+in+action+
(ILLUSTRATION)
! To+reflect+upon+how+to+scope+the+firm+and+change+the+rules+of+the+game
(REFLECTION)
! To+obtain+a+sneak+preview+of+all+subsequent+videos+on+the+session+theme+
(PREVIEW)
©+Torsten+Oliver+Salge 2
TIME Research+Area+|+Innovation,+Strategy+and+Organization+Group+(ISO)
INTRODUCTION(| Illustration
Developing+and+capturing+a+new+market+segment
UNOCCUPIED,(GROWING(
high MOST+ESTABLISHED+CAR+ MARKET(SEGMENT
MODELS+WITH+
CONVENTIONAL+
ENGINES
PERFORMANCE
TO(PRICE(
RATIO
MOST+CURRENT+CAR+
MODELS+WITH+
low ALTERNATIVE
COMBUSTION+ENGINES
©+Torsten+Oliver+Salge 3
TIME Research+Area+|+Innovation,+Strategy+and+Organization+Group+(ISO)
INTRODUCTION(| Illustration
Developing+resources+and+capabilities+most+critical+in+target+segment
Engineering(Talent Mass(Assembly(Capability
Charging(&(Service(Network Energy(Innovation(Capability
©+Torsten+Oliver+Salge 4
TIME Research+Area+|+Innovation,+Strategy+and+Organization+Group+(ISO)
INTRODUCTION(| Reflection
Positioning+the+firm+to+outcompete+or+reinventing+the+industry
How(should(Tesla(scope(its(activities(to(optimize(its(position?
Does(Tesla(have(the(potential(to(change(the(rules(of(the(game(in(the(
car(industry(and(create(largely(uncontested(market(space?
YOUR(VIEW
©+Torsten+Oliver+Salge 5
TIME Research+Area+|+Innovation,+Strategy+and+Organization+Group+(ISO)
INTRODUCTION(| Reflection
Entering+the+home+battery+business
Why+is+Tesla+entering+the+home+battery+business?+A+smart+move?
©+Torsten+Oliver+Salge Source:+Tesla+(2016) 6
TIME Research+Area+|+Innovation,+Strategy+and+Organization+Group+(ISO)
INTRODUCTION(| Preview
Identifying+key+questions+to+be+addressed
How(can(strategy(portfolios(guide(corporate(strategy(and(help(
1 decision\makers(scope(the(activities(of(their(organization?
How(can(generic(strategies(help(organizations(achieve(competitive(
2 advantage(in(their(industry?(
How(can(organizations(make(competition(irrelevant(and(create(
3 uncontested(market(space?
©+Torsten+Oliver+Salge 7
TIME Research+Area+|+Innovation,+Strategy+and+Organization+Group+(ISO)
INTRODUCTION(|+Preview
Exploring+positioning+strategies
Competitive Competitive
Market+ Resource+
View View
(Session(2) (Session(3)
Strategy
Process Strategy(Content
(Session(1)
Competitive Cooperative
Positioning
(Session(4) (Session(5)
Strategy(Context
(Session(6)
©+Torsten+Oliver+Salge 8
TIME Research+Area+|+Innovation,+Strategy+and+Organization+Group+(ISO)
INTRODUCTION(|+Preview
Previewing+key+insights+from+our+subsequent+videos
Red(Ocean(Strategy Blue(Ocean(Strategy
! Corporate(Strategy.( 2 ! Blue(Ocean(Strategy.(
5
Explore+the+tools+that+ Understand+how+to+create+
help+to+decide+on+the+ uncontested+market+
scope+of+the+business+ space+and+make+
! Generic(Strategy(I.( 3
competition+irrelevant
Become+familiar+with++
cost+leadership+
strategies
! Generic(Strategy(II.( 4
Become+familiar+with+
differentiation+strategies++++++++++++
6
Understand(how(to(best(position(and(scope(the(firm
©+Torsten+Oliver+Salge 9
TIME Research+Area+|+Innovation,+Strategy+and+Organization+Group+(ISO)
INTRODUCTION |+Readings
Sources+and+further+readings
De+Wit,+B.++&+Meyer,+R.+(2014).+Strategy:(An(International(Perspective.+Cengage Learning.
Grant,+R.+M.+(2015).+Contemporary(Strategy(Analysis.+John+Wiley+and+Sons.+8th Edition.
Kim,+W.+C.,+&+Mauborgne,+R.+(2005).+Blue+ocean+strategy:+from+theory+to+practice. California(Management(
Review, 47(3),+105c121.
Kim,+W.+C.,+&+Mauborgne,+R.+(2015).+Blue(Ocean(Strategy:(How(to(create(uncontested(market(space(and(
make(the(competition(irrelevant.+Expanded+Edition.+Harvard+Business+Review+Press
Porter,+M.+E.+(1998).+Cluster+and+the+new+economics+of+competition. Harvard(Business(Review, 76(6),+pp.+77–
90.
©+Torsten+Oliver+Salge 10
TIME Research+Area+|+Innovation,+Strategy+and+Organization+Group+(ISO)
CONTACT(US(
Contact+details+and+disclaimer
©+Torsten+Oliver+Salge 11
POSITIONING(THE(FIRM
Red$Ocean$Strategy$I:$Corporate$Strategy
TORSTEN(OLIVER(SALGE(|$Aachen
School(of(Business(and(Economics
TIME Research$Area$|(Innovation,$Strategy$and$Organization$Group$(ISO)
TIME Research$Area$|$Innovation,$Strategy$and$Organization$Group$(ISO)
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
Outlining$the$objectives$of$this$video
! To$learn$about$strategy$portfolios$that$help$to$scope$the$firm
(PORTFOLIOS)
! To$discuss$salient$tensions$in$corporate$strategy
(TENSIONS)
! To$learn$how$to$assess$the$value$creation$potential$of$business$opportunities
(RECONCILIATION)
©$Torsten$Oliver$Salge 2
TIME Research$Area$|$Innovation,$Strategy$and$Organization$Group$(ISO)
CORPORATE(STRATEGY(| Portfolios
Integrating$insights$from$the$marketK and$the$resourceKbased$view
McKinsey(Matrix Matrix(Dimensions
! External(View((MBV):(
Industry$Attractiveness
Investment$
Selective$ ! Based$on$rigorous$industry$analysis
Competitive(Advantage
High
Selectivity and$
Growth
Growth ! How$high$is$the$rentKearning$
potential$of$that$industry?
Medium
Harvest$/$$$$$ Selective$
Selectivity
Divest Growth
! Internal(View((RBV):(
Competitive$Advantage
Harvest$/$$$$ Harvest$/$$$$
! Based$on$rigorous$resource$and$
Low
Selectivity
Divest Divest
capability$analysis
Low$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$Medium$$$$$$$$$$$$High ! How$well$is$the$firm$positioned$to$
Industry(Attractiveness exploit$the$rentKearning$potential$of$
the$industry?
©$Torsten$Oliver$Salge 3
TIME Research$Area$|$Innovation,$Strategy$and$Organization$Group$(ISO)
CORPORATE(STRATEGY(| Portfolios
Deriving$strategic$implications
maintenance$level elsewhere
Low$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$Medium$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$High
Industry(Attractiveness
©$Torsten$Oliver$Salge 4
TIME Research$Area$|$Innovation,$Strategy$and$Organization$Group$(ISO)
CORPORATE(STRATEGY(| Portfolios
Highlighting$the$plethora$of$strategy$portfolios
What(other(strategy(portfolios(do(you(know?(
YOUR(VIEW
©$Torsten$Oliver$Salge 5
TIME Research$Area$|$Innovation,$Strategy$and$Organization$Group$(ISO)
CORPORATE(STRATEGY(| Portfolios
Reviewing$the$classic$BCG$matrix
BCG(Matrix Matrix(Dimensions
! Market(Growth(Rate
15%
Question(Marks Stars ! YearKonKyear$growth$of$market$
segment$in$value
10%
! CutKoff$points:$e.g.$industry$growth$
Extend$/ Sustain$/
Market(Growth
©$Torsten$Oliver$Salge 6
TIME Research$Area$|$Innovation,$Strategy$and$Organization$Group$(ISO)
CORPORATE(STRATEGY(| Portfolios
Deriving$strategic$implications
Stars
Hold/ Around$zero$or$
High High
Increase slightly$negative
Cash(Cows
High Low
Hold Highly$positive
Question(Marks
Increase* None$or$negative Very$high Highly$negative
Dogs
Harvest/
Low$or$negative Disinvest Positive
Divest
*$There$is$a$selective$application$of$the$strategy$depending$on$the$decision$made$with$regard$to$the$business:$$$
either$to$enter$aggressively$or$withdraw.
©$Torsten$Oliver$Salge 7
TIME Research$Area$|$Innovation,$Strategy$and$Organization$Group$(ISO)
CORPORATE(STRATEGY(| Reflection
Highlighting$the$plethora$of$strategy$portfolios
©$Torsten$Oliver$Salge 8
TIME Research$Area$|$Innovation,$Strategy$and$Organization$Group$(ISO)
CORPORATE(STRATEGY(| Tensions
Exploring$tensions$in$corporate$strategy
Michael(Porter(suggested(that(“the(essence(of(strategy(is(choosing(
what(not(to(do.(Strategy(is(creating(fit(among(a(company’s(activities.”(
Why(could(that(be(important?
YOUR(VIEW
©$Torsten$Oliver$Salge 9
TIME Research$Area$|$Innovation,$Strategy$and$Organization$Group$(ISO)
CORPORATE(STRATEGY(| Tensions
Exploring$tensions$in$corporate$strategy
Attribute Responsiveness((((((((((vs((((((((((Synergy(
Emphasis(on Responsiveness Synergy
©$Torsten$Oliver$Salge Source:$De$Wit$&$Meyer$(2014) 10
TIME Research$Area$|$Innovation,$Strategy$and$Organization$Group$(ISO)
CORPORATE(STRATEGY(| Reconciliation
Assessing$Tesla’s$entry$into$the$home$battery$business
Was(this(a(smart(strategic(move?
©$Torsten$Oliver$Salge Source:$Tesla$(2016) 11
TIME Research$Area$|$Innovation,$Strategy$and$Organization$Group$(ISO)
CORPORATE(STRATEGY(| Reconciliation
Assessing$strategic$diversification$opportunities$
If$diversification$is$to$create$shareholder$value,$it$must$meet$three$tests
(Porter’s$three$essential$tests):
1.(The(Attractiveness(Test(
Diversification$must$be$directed$towards$attractive$industries
(or$industries$that$have$the$potential$to$become$attractive)
2.(The(Cost(of(Entry(Test(
The$cost$of$entry$must$not$capitalize$all$future$profits
3.(The(Better_Off(Test
Either$the$new$unit$must$gain$competitive$advantage$
from$its$link$with$the$company,$or$viceKversa
©$Torsten$Oliver$Salge Source:$Grant$(2015),$Tesla$(2016) 12
TIME Research$Area$|$Innovation,$Strategy$and$Organization$Group$(ISO)
CORPORATE(STRATEGY(| Reconciliation
Building$the$electric$mobility$ecosystem
Introducing$the$‘missing$piece’$...
©$Torsten$Oliver$Salge Source:$Tesla$(2016) 13
TIME Research$Area$|$Innovation,$Strategy$and$Organization$Group$(ISO)
CONTACT(US(
Contact$details$and$disclaimer
Phone:(+49$241$80$99197
Mail:(info.iso@time.rwthKaachen.de
Web:(www.time.rwthKaachen.de/iso
©$Torsten$Oliver$Salge 14
POSITIONING(THE(FIRM
Red$Ocean$Strategy$II:$Generic$Strategy$I$
TORSTEN(OLIVER(SALGE(|$Aachen
School(of(Business(and(Economics
TIME Research$Area$|(Innovation,$Strategy$and$Organization$Group$(ISO)
TIME Research$Area$|$Innovation,$Strategy$and$Organization$Group$(ISO)
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
Outlining$the$objectives$of$this$video
! To$unpack$the$nature$of$Porter’s$generic$strategies$
(INTRODUCTION)
! To$discover$and$illustrate$the$nature$of$cost$leadership$strategies$
(COST(LEADERSHIP)
! To$discuss$der$boundary$conditions$of$cost$leadership$strategies
(REFLECTION)
©$Torsten$Oliver$Salge 2
TIME Research$Area$|$Innovation,$Strategy$and$Organization$Group$(ISO)
GENERIC(STRATEGY(|$Introduction
Introducing$Porter’s$three$generic$strategies
Competitive(Advantage
Uniqueness$perceived$by$the$ Low$cost$
customer position
Industry
Strategic(Target
wide
Differentiation Cost(leadership
Particular$
segment$
Focus
GENERIC(STRATEGY(|$Introduction$
Aligning$the$entire$organization$with$selected$generic$strategy
! ScaleRefficient$production$ ! Standardization$and$volume
! Design$for$manufacture ! Reduced$complexity
! Control$of$overheads$and$R&D ! Tight$cost$control
Cost(Leadership ! Process$innovation ! Process$engineering$capabilities
! Outsourcing$(e.g.,$overseas) ! Specialization$of$jobs$/$functions
! Technological$innovation ! Energy$innovation$capabilities
! New$product$development ! IT$capabilities$(e.g.,$connectivity)
! Charging$ecosystem ! Automation$capabilities
Differentiation ! Quality$ ! High$quality$mass$production
! Design ! Design$capabilities
! Branding$ ! Marketing$capabilities
! Advertising
©$Torsten$Oliver$Salge Source:$Grant$(2015) 4
TIME Research$Area$|$Innovation,$Strategy$and$Organization$Group$(ISO)
GENERIC(STRATEGY(|$Cost$Leadership$
Understanding$the$drivers$of$cost$advantage
Increased$dexterity
Economies(of(learning Improved$organizational$routines
Indivisibilities
Economies(of(scale Specialization$and$division$of$labor
Process$innovation
Production(techniques Reengineering$business$processes
Standardizing$designs$&$components
Production(design Design$for$manufacture
Location$advantages
Ownership$of$lowRcost$inputs$
Input(costs NonRunion$labor
Bargaining$power
Ratio$of$fixed$to$variable$costs
Capacity(utilization Speed$of$capacity$adjustment
Organizational$slack_$motivation$&
Residual(efficiency culture_$managerial$efficiency
©$Torsten$Oliver$Salge Source:$Grant$(2015) 5
TIME Research$Area$|$Innovation,$Strategy$and$Organization$Group$(ISO)
GENERIC(STRATEGY(|$Cost$Leadership$
Minimizing$costs$along$the$value$chain
Imagine,(you(are(consultant(to(Skoda.(
What(would(you(recommend(to(enhance(its(position(as(a(cost(leader?
YOUR(VIEW
©$Torsten$Oliver$Salge 6
TIME Research$Area$|$Innovation,$Strategy$and$Organization$Group$(ISO)
GENERIC(STRATEGY(|$Cost$Leadership$
Minimizing$costs$along$the$value$chain
Value(
R&D( Component Testing Goods Sales(&(
Chain Purchasing Assembly Distribution
Design MFR quality inventory Marketing
Linkages 4 3
2
1
Conclusion 1)(Consolidating$purchase$orders$to$increase$discount$increases$inventories
2)(High$quality$parts$and$materials$reduce$costs$of$defects$at$later$stages
3)(Reducing$manufacturing$defects$cuts$warranty$costs
4)(Designing$different$models$around$common$components$and$
platforms$reduces$manufacturing$costs$
©$Torsten$Oliver$Salge Source:$Grant$(2015) 7
TIME Research$Area$|$Innovation,$Strategy$and$Organization$Group$(ISO)
GENERIC(STRATEGY(|$Cost$Leadership$
Examining$cost$advantages$in$the$airline$industry
Costs(per(Available(Seat`Mile
vs
Southwest(Airlines United(Airlines
(cents) (cents)
Wages$and$benefits 2.4 3.5
Fuel$and$oil 1.1 1.1
Aircraft$ownership 0.7 0.8
Aircraft$maintenance 0.6 0.3
Commissions$on$ticket$sales 0.5 1.0
Advertising 0.2 0.2
Food$and$beverages 0.0 0.5
Other 1.7 3.1
Total 7.2 10.5
©$Torsten$Oliver$Salge Source:$Grant$(2015) 8
TIME Research$Area$|$Innovation,$Strategy$and$Organization$Group$(ISO)
GENERIC(STRATEGY(|$Reflection
Discussing$the$boundary$conditions$of$cost$leadership$strategies
Boundary(Conditions(of(Cost(Leadership(Strategies
©$Torsten$Oliver$Salge Source:$Grant$(2015) 9
TIME Research$Area$|$Innovation,$Strategy$and$Organization$Group$(ISO)
CONTACT(US(
Contact$details$and$disclaimer
©$Torsten$Oliver$Salge 10
POSITIONING(THE(FIRM
Red$Ocean$Strategy$III:$Generic$Strategy$II$
TORSTEN(OLIVER(SALGE(|$Aachen
School(of(Business(and(Economics
TIME Research$Area$|(Innovation,$Strategy$and$Organization$Group$(ISO)
TIME Research$Area$|$Innovation,$Strategy$and$Organization$Group$(ISO)
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
Outlining$the$objectives$of$this$video
! To$review$Porter’s$three$generic$strategies$
(INTRODUCTION)
! To$discover$and$illustrate$the$nature$of$differentiation$strategies$
(DIFFERENTIATION)
! To$discuss$der$boundary$conditions$of$differentiation$strategies
(REFLECTION)
©$Torsten$Oliver$Salge 2
TIME Research$Area$|$Innovation,$Strategy$and$Organization$Group$(ISO)
GENERIC(STRATEGY(|$Introduction
Reviewing$Porter’s$three$generic$strategies
Competitive(Advantage
Uniqueness$perceived$by$the$ Low$cost$
customer position
Industry
Strategic(Target
wide
Differentiation Cost(leadership
Particular$
segment$
Focus
GENERIC(STRATEGY(|$Differentiation
Outlining$the$strategic$implications$of$differentiation$strategies
Customer
Value(Creation
“Providing$something$unique$
that$is$valuable$to$the$buyer$beyond$
simply$offering$a$low$price.”$(Porter,$1998)
Strategic
Implications
Customer Product
Segmentation Integrity
Value$can$be$provided$to$broad$ Consistency$of$offering$and$fit
or$narrow$customer$groups with$customer$values$and$preferences
©$Torsten$Oliver$Salge Source:$Grant$(2015) 4
TIME Research$Area$|$Innovation,$Strategy$and$Organization$Group$(ISO)
GENERIC(STRATEGY(|$Differentiation
Building$competitive$advantage$through$differentiation
Differentiation
“A$set$of$firm$choices$to$distinguish its$
offerings$from$those$of$its$competitors”
Tangible(Differentiation Intangible(Differentiation
pertains$to$observable(features$ pertains$to$unobservable(features$
! Technology$attributes ! Appeal$to$customer$values
! Performance$attributes ! Appeal$to$customer$image
! Quality$attributes ! Appeal$to$customer$status
! Design$attributes ! Appeal$to$customer$desire$for$exclusivity
! Service$attributes ! Appeal$to$customer$emotions
Example:$Tesla’s$battery$technology Example:$Tesla’s$environmental$mission
©$Torsten$Oliver$Salge Source:$Grant$(2015) 5
TIME Research$Area$|$Innovation,$Strategy$and$Organization$Group$(ISO)
GENERIC(STRATEGY(|$Differentiation
Identifying$differentiation$opportunities$along$the$value$chain
Imagine,(you(are(consultant(to(Tesla.(
Which(other(opportunities(for(differentiation(do(you(see?
How(would(you(proceed?
YOUR(VIEW
©$Torsten$Oliver$Salge 6
TIME Research$Area$|$Innovation,$Strategy$and$Organization$Group$(ISO)
GENERIC(STRATEGY(|$Differentiation
Identifying$differentiation$opportunities$along$the$value$chain
Firm(Infrastructure
Human(Resource(Management
Technology(Development
©$Torsten$Oliver$Salge Source:$Grant$(2015) 7
TIME Research$Area$|$Innovation,$Strategy$and$Organization$Group$(ISO)
GENERIC(STRATEGY(|$Reflection
Discussing$the$boundary$conditions$of$differentiation$strategies
Boundary(Conditions(of(Differentiation(Strategies
©$Torsten$Oliver$Salge Source:$Grant$(2015) 8
TIME Research$Area$|$Innovation,$Strategy$and$Organization$Group$(ISO)
CONTACT(US(
Contact$details$and$disclaimer
Phone:(+49$241$80$99197
Mail:(info.iso@time.rwth]aachen.de
Web:(www.time.rwth]aachen.de/iso
©$Torsten$Oliver$Salge 9