Second-Order Linear Differential Equations

A second-order linear differential equation has the form

d 2y dy
1 Psxd 1 Qsxd 1 Rsxdy − Gsxd
dx 2 dx

where P, Q, R, and G are continuous functions. Recall that equations of this type arise in
the study of the motion of a spring. In Chapter 10 we also saw equations in this form in the
context of jellyfish locomotion (for example, see Exercise 10.1.34).
In this section we study the case where Gsxd − 0, for all x, in Equation 1. Such equa-
tions are called homogeneous linear equations. Thus the form of a second-order linear
homogeneous differential equation is

d 2y dy
2 Psxd 1 Qsxd 1 Rsxd y − 0
dx 2 dx

If Gsxd ± 0 for some x, Equation 1 is nonhomogeneous.

Two basic facts enable us to solve homogeneous linear equations. The first of these says
that if we know two solutions y1 and y2 of such an equation, then the linear combination
y − c1 y1 1 c2 y2 is also a solution.

3   Theorem If y1sxd and y2sxd are both solutions of the linear homogeneous
equation (2) and c1 and c2 are any constants, then the function

ysxd − c1 y1sxd 1 c2 y2sxd

is also a solution of Equation 2.

PROOF  Since y1 and y2 are solutions of Equation 2, we have

Psxd y01 1 Qsxdy19 1 Rsxdy1 − 0

and Psxd y20 1 Qsxd y29 1 Rsxdy2 − 0

Therefore, using the basic rules for differentiation, we have

   Psxdy0 1 Qsxdy9 1 Rsxdy

− Psxdsc1 y1 1 c2 y2d0 1 Qsxdsc1 y1 1 c2 y2d9 1 Rsxdsc1 y1 1 c2 y2d

− Psxdsc1 y10 1 c2 y20d 1 Qsxdsc1 y19 1 c2 y29d 1 Rsxdsc1 y1 1 c2 y2d

− c1fPsxdy10 1 Qsxdy19 1 Rsxdy1g 1 c2 fPsxdy20 1 Qsxdy29 1 Rsxdy2g

− c1s0d 1 c2s0d − 0

Thus y − c1 y1 1 c2 y2 is a solution of Equation 2. n

The other fact we need is given by the following theorem, which is proved in more
advanced courses. It says that the general solution is a linear combination of two linearly
independent solutions y1 and y2. This means that neither y1 nor y2 is a constant multiple of
the other. For instance, the functions f sxd − x 2 and tsxd − 5x 2 are linearly dependent, but
f sxd − e x and tsxd − xe x are linearly independent.

1
2  ■  SECOND-ORDER LINEAR DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS

4   Theorem  If y1 and y2 are linearly independent solutions of Equation 2 on an

interval, and Psxd is never 0, then the general solution is given by

ysxd − c1 y1sxd 1 c2 y2sxd

where c1 and c2 are arbitrary constants.

Theorem 4 is very useful because it says that if we know two particular linearly indepen-
dent solutions, then we know every solution.
In general, it’s not easy to discover particular solutions to a second-order linear equa-
tion. But it is always possible to do so if the coefficient functions P, Q, and R are constant
functions, that is, if the differential equation has the form

5 ay0 1 by9 1 cy − 0

where a, b, and c are constants and a ± 0.

It’s not hard to think of some likely candidates for particular solutions of Equation 5 if
we state the equation verbally. We are looking for a function y such that a constant times its
second derivative y0 plus another constant times y9 plus a third constant times y is equal to
0. We know that the exponential function y − e rx (where r is a constant) has the property
that its derivative is a constant multiple of itself: y9 − re rx. Furthermore, y0 − r 2e rx. If we
substitute these expressions into Equation 5, we see that y − e rx is a solution if
ar 2e rx 1 bre rx 1 ce rx − 0

or sar 2 1 br 1 cde rx − 0

But e rx is never 0. Thus y − e rx is a solution of Equation 5 if r is a root of the equation

6 ar 2 1 br 1 c − 0

Equation 6 is called the auxiliary equation (or characteristic equation) of the differential
equation ay0 1 by9 1 cy − 0. Notice that it is an algebraic equation that is obtained from
the differential equation by replacing y0 by r 2, y9 by r, and y by 1.
Sometimes the roots r1 and r 2 of the auxiliary equation can be found by factoring. In
other cases they are found by using the quadratic formula:

2b 1 sb 2 2 4ac 2b 2 sb 2 2 4ac
7 r1 −       r 2 −
2a 2a

We distinguish three cases according to the sign of the discriminant b 2 2 4ac.

CASE I  b2 2 4ac . 0
In this case the roots r1 and r 2 of the auxiliary equation are real and distinct, so y1 − e r x1

and y2 − e r x are two linearly independent solutions of Equation 5. (Note that e r x is not a
2 2

constant multiple of e r x.) Therefore, by Theorem 4, we have the following fact.

1

8   If the roots r1 and r 2 of the auxiliary equation ar 2 1 br 1 c − 0 are real and
unequal, then the general solution of ay0 1 by9 1 cy − 0 is

y − c1 e r x 1 c2 e r
1 2 x
 SECOND-ORDER LINEAR DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS  ■  3

In Figure 1 the graphs of the basic EXAMPLE 1  Solve the equation y0 1 y9 2 6y − 0.
solutions f sxd − e 2x and tsxd − e23x of
SOLUTION  The auxiliary equation is
the differential equation in Example 1
are shown in blue and red, respec­tively.
Some of the other solutions, linear
r 2 1 r 2 6 − sr 2 2dsr 1 3d − 0
combinations of f and t, are shown
in black. whose roots are r − 2, 23. Therefore, by (8), the general solution of the given differen-
tial equation is
8
5f+g
y − c1 e 2x 1 c2 e23x
f+5g
f+g We could verify that this is indeed a solution by differentiating and substituting into the dif-
f g ferential equation. n
_1 1
g-f
f-g d 2y dy
EXAMPLE 2 Solve 3 2 1 2 y − 0.
_5 dx dx

FIGURE 1 SOLUTION  To solve the auxiliary equation 3r 2 1 r 2 1 − 0, we use the quadratic

formula:
21 6 s13
r−
6

Since the roots are real and distinct, the general solution is

y − c1 e s211s13 d xy6 1 c2 e s212s13 d xy6 n

CASE II  b 2 2 4ac − 0

In this case r1 − r2; that is, the roots of the auxiliary equation are real and equal. Let’s
denote by r the common value of r1 and r 2. Then, from Equations 7, we have

b
9 r−2     so  2ar 1 b − 0
2a

We know that y1 − e rx is one solution of Equation 5. We now verify that y2 − xe rx is also

a solution:

ay20 1 by29 1 cy2 − as2re rx 1 r 2xe rx d 1 bse rx 1 rxe rx d 1 cxe rx

− s2ar 1 bde rx 1 sar 2 1 br 1 cdxe rx

− 0se rx d 1 0sxe rx d − 0

In the first term, 2ar 1 b − 0 by Equations 9; in the second term, ar 2 1 br 1 c − 0

Figure 2 shows the basic solutions because r is a root of the auxiliary equation. Since y1 − e rx and y2 − xe rx are linearly inde-
f sxd − e23xy2 and tsxd − xe23xy2 in pendent solutions, Theorem 4 provides us with the general solution.
Exam­ple 3 and some other members of
the family of solutions. Notice that all
of them approach 0 as x l `. 10   If the auxiliary equation ar 2 1 br 1 c − 0 has only one real root r, then the
general solution of ay0 1 by9 1 cy − 0 is
f-g 8
f y − c1 e rx 1 c2 xe rx
5f+g
f+5g

_2 2
f+g g-f EXAMPLE 3  Solve the equation 4y0 1 12y9 1 9y − 0.
g
SOLUTION  The auxiliary equation 4r 2 1 12r 1 9 − 0 can be factored as
_5
FIGURE 2 s2r 1 3d2 − 0
4  ■  SECOND-ORDER LINEAR DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS

so the only root is r − 2 32. By (10) the general solution is

y − c1 e23xy2 1 c2 xe23xy2 n

CASE III  b 2 2 4ac , 0

In this case the roots r1 and r 2 of the auxiliary equation are complex numbers. (See Appen­
dix G for information about complex numbers.) We can write

r1 −  1 i      r 2 −  2 i

where  and  are real numbers. [In fact,  − 2bys2ad,  − s4ac 2 b 2 ys2ad.] Then,
using Euler’s formula
e i − cos  1 i sin 

from Appendix G, we write the solution of the differential equation as

y − C1 e r x 1 C2 e r x − C1 e s1idx 1 C2 e s2idx
1 2

− C1 e xscos x 1 i sin xd 1 C2 e xscos x 2 i sin xd

− e x fsC1 1 C2 d cos x 1 isC1 2 C2 d sin xg

− e xsc1 cos x 1 c2 sin xd

where c1 − C1 1 C2, c2 − isC1 2 C2d. This gives all solutions (real or complex) of the
dif­ferential equation. The solutions are real when the constants c1 and c2 are real. We sum-
marize the discussion as follows.

11   If the roots of the auxiliary equation ar 2 1 br 1 c − 0 are the complex numbers
r1 −  1 i, r 2 −  2 i, then the general solution of ay0 1 by9 1 cy − 0 is

y − e  xsc1 cos x 1 c2 sin xd

Figure 3 shows the graphs of the solu- EXAMPLE 4  Solve the equation y0 2 6y9 1 13y − 0.
tions in Example 4, f sxd − e 3x cos 2x
and tsxd − e 3x sin 2x, together with SOLUTION  The auxiliary equation is r 2 2 6r 1 13 − 0. By the quadratic formula, the
some linear combina­tions. All solutions roots are
approach 0 as x l 2`. 6 6 s36 2 52 6 6 s216
r− − − 3 6 2i
3 2 2
f+g
g By (11), the general solution of the differential equation is
f-g f
_3 2 y − e 3xsc1 cos 2x 1 c2 sin 2xd n

Initial-Value and Boundary-Value Problems

An initial-value problem for the second-order Equation 1 or 2 consists of finding a solu-
_3
tion y of the differential equation that also satisfies initial conditions of the form
FIGURE 3
ysx 0 d − y0      y9sx 0 d − y1
where y0 and y1 are given constants. If P, Q, R, and G are continuous on an interval and
Psxd ± 0 there, then a theorem found in more advanced books guarantees the existence
and uniqueness of a solution to this initial-value problem. Examples 5 and 6 illustrate the
technique for solving such a problem.
 SECOND-ORDER LINEAR DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS  ■  5

EXAMPLE 5  Solve the initial-value problem

y0 1 y9 2 6y − 0      ys0d − 1      y9s0d − 0

Figure 4 shows the graph of the solu-
tion of the initial-value problem in
Example 5. Compare with Figure 1.
SOLUTION  From Example 1 we know that the general solution of the differential equa-
tion is
ysxd − c1 e 2x 1 c2 e23x
Differentiating this solution, we get
y9sxd − 2c1 e 2x 2 3c2 e23x
To satisfy the initial conditions we require that

20 12 ys0d − c1 1 c2 − 1

13 y9s0d − 2c1 2 3c2 − 0

From (13), we have c2 − 23 c1 and so (12) gives

c1 1 23 c1 − 1      c1 − 35      c2 − 25
_2 2
0
Thus the required solution of the initial-value problem is
FIGURE 4
y − 35 e 2x 1 25 e23x n

EXAMPLE 6  Solve the initial-value problem

y0 1 y − 0      ys0d − 2      y9s0d − 3

The solution to Example 6 is graphed in
Figure 5. It appears to be a shifted sine
curve and, indeed, you can verify that
another way of writing the solu­tion is
y − s13 sinsx 1 d  where tan  − 23
5
SOLUTION  The auxiliary equation is r 2 1 1 − 0, or r 2 − 21, whose roots are 6i. Thus
 − 0,  − 1, and since e 0x − 1, the general solution is
ysxd − c1 cos x 1 c2 sin x
Since y9sxd − 2c1 sin x 1 c2 cos x
the initial conditions become
ys0d − c1 − 2      y9s0d − c2 − 3
Therefore the solution of the initial-value problem is
ysxd − 2 cos x 1 3 sin x n

A boundary-value problem for Equation 1 or 2 consists of finding a solution y of the

_2π 2π
differential equation that also satisfies boundary conditions of the form

ysx 0 d − y0      ysx1 d − y1
_5

FIGURE 5
In contrast with the situation for initial-value problems, a boundary-value problem does not
always have a solution. The method is illustrated in Example 7.

EXAMPLE 7  Solve the boundary-value problem

y0 1 2y9 1 y − 0      ys0d − 1      ys1d − 3

SOLUTION  The auxiliary equation is

r 2 1 2r 1 1 − 0    or    sr 1 1d2 − 0
6  ■  SECOND-ORDER LINEAR DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS

whose only root is r − 21. Therefore the general solution is

ysxd − c1 e2x 1 c2 xe2x

The boundary conditions are satisfied if

ys0d − c1 − 1
Figure 6 shows the graph of the solu-
tion of the boundary-value problem in ys1d − c1 e21 1 c2 e21 − 3
Example 7.
The first condition gives c1 − 1, so the second condition becomes
5
e21 1 c2 e21 − 3

Solving this equation for c2 by first multiplying through by e, we get

_1 5
1 1 c2 − 3e    so    c2 − 3e 2 1

_5
Thus the solution of the boundary-value problem is

FIGURE 6 y − e2x 1 s3e 2 1dxe2x n

Summary:  Solutions of ay0 1 by9 1 c − 0

Roots of ar 2 1 br 1 c − 0 General solution

r1, r2 real and distinct y − c1 e r x 1 c2 e r
1 2 x

r1 − r2 − r y − c1 e rx 1 c2 xe rx
r1, r2 complex:  6 i y − e  xsc1 cos x 1 c2 sin xd
 SECOND-ORDER LINEAR DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS  ■  7

Exercises

1–13  ■  Solve the differential equation. 22.  4 y 0 2 20 y9 1 25y − 0,  ys0d − 2,  y9s0d − 23
1. y0 2 y9 2 6y − 0 2.
y0 1 4 y9 1 4 y − 0 23.  y 0 2 y9 2 12y − 0,  ys1d − 0,  y9s1d − 1
3. y0 1 16y − 0 4.
y0 2 8y9 1 12y − 0 24.  4 y 0 1 4y9 1 3y − 0,  ys0d − 0,  y9s0d − 1
5. 9y0 2 12y9 1 4 y − 0 6.
25y0 1 9y − 0
25–32  ■  Solve the boundary-value problem, if possible.
7. y9 − 2y0 8.
y0 2 4 y9 1 y − 0
25.  y0 1 4y − 0,  ys0d − 5,  ysy4d − 3
9. y0 2 4 y9 1 13y − 0 10.
y0 1 3y9 − 0
26.  y0 − 4y,  ys0d − 1,  ys1d − 0
d 2y dy
11. 2 12 2y−0 27.  y 0 1 4y9 1 4y − 0,  ys0d − 2,  ys1d − 0
dt 2 dt
d 2y dy 28.  y 0 2 8y9 1 17y − 0,  ys0d − 3,  ysd − 2
12. 8 2 1 12 1 5y − 0
dt dt 29.  y 0 − y9,  ys0d − 1,  ys1d − 2
d 2P dP 30.  4y 0 2 4y9 1 y − 0,  ys0d − 4,  ys2d − 0
13. 100 2 1 200 1 101P − 0
dt dt
31.  y 0 1 4y9 1 20 y − 0,  ys0d − 1,  ys d − 2
32.  y 0 1 4y9 1 20 y − 0,  ys0d − 1,  ysd − e 22
; 14–16  ■  Graph the two basic solutions along with several other
solutions of the differential equation. What features do the solutions
have in common? 33.  Let L be a nonzero real number.
(a) Show that the boundary-value problem y 0 1 y − 0,
d 2y dy ys0d − 0, ysLd − 0 has only the trivial solution y − 0 for
14. 14 1 20y − 0
dx 2 dx the cases  − 0 and  , 0.
d 2y dy (b) For the case  . 0, find the values of  for which this prob­
15. 5 22 2 3y − 0 lem has a nontrivial solution and give the corre-sponding
dx 2 dx
solution.
d 2y dy
16. 9 16 1y−0 34.  If a, b, and c are all positive constants and ysxd is a solution
dx 2 dx
of the differential equation ay 0 1 by9 1 cy − 0, show that
lim x l ` ysxd − 0.
17–24  ■  Solve the initial-value problem.
35.  C
 onsider the boundary-value problem y 0 2 2y9 1 2y − 0,
17.  y0 2 6y9 1 8y − 0,  ys0d − 2,  y9s0d − 2 ysad − c, ysbd − d.
(a) If this problem has a unique solution, how are a and b
18.  y0 1 4y − 0,  ysd − 5,  y9sd − 24
related?
19.  9y 0 1 12y9 1 4y − 0,  ys0d − 1,  y9s0d − 0 (b) If this problem has no solution, how are a, b, c, and d
related?
20.  2y0 1 y9 2 y − 0,  ys0d − 3,  y9s0d − 3
(c) If this problem has infinitely many solutions, how are
21.  y 0 2 6y9 1 10y − 0,  ys0d − 2,  y9s0d − 3 a, b, c, and d related?
8  ■  SECOND-ORDER LINEAR DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS

Answers

1.  y − c1 e 3x 1 c 2 e22x    3.  y − c1 cos 4x 1 c 2 sin 4x 21.  y − e 3x s2 cos x 2 3 sin xd

5.  y − c1 e 2xy3 1 c 2 xe 2xy3     7.  y − c1 1 c 2 e xy2 23.  y − 17 e 4x24 2 17 e 323x    25.  y − 5 cos 2x 1 3 sin 2x
9.  y − e 2x sc1 cos 3x 1 c 2 sin 3xd e22 ex
27.  y − 2e 22x 2 2xe 22x    29.  y − 1
11.  y − c1 e (s321) ty2 1 c 2 e2 (s311) ty2 e21 e21
31.  No solution
f
13.  P − e2t c1 cos s10
1
td 1 c 2 sin s10
1
td g 33.  (b)   − n 2 2yL2, n a positive integer; y − C sinsnxyLd
35.  (a)  b 2 a ± n, n any integer   
15.  10 All solutions approach either c cos a
0 or 6` as x l 6`. (b)  b 2 a − n and ± e a2b unless cos b − 0, then
g d cos b
c sin a
f ± e a2b     
_3 3 d sin b
c cos a
(c)  b 2 a − n and − e a2b unless cos b − 0, then
d cos b
c sin a
_10 − e a2b
d sin b
17.  y − 3e 2x 2 e 4x    19.  y − e 22xy3 1 23 xe 22xy3
 SECOND-ORDER LINEAR DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS  ■  9

Solutions

1. The auxiliary equation is  −  − 6 = 0 ⇒ ( − 3)( + 2) = 0 ⇒  = 3,  = −2. Then by (8) the general solution

is  = 1 3 + 2 −2 .

3. The auxiliary equation is 2 + 16 = 0 ⇒  = ±4. Then by (11) the general solution is

 = 0 (1 cos 4 + 2 sin 4) = 1 cos 4 + 2 sin 4.

5. The auxiliary equation is 92 − 12 + 4 = 0 ⇒ (3 − 2)2 = 0 ⇒  = 23 . Then by (10), the general solution is

 = 1 23 + 2 23 .

7. The auxiliary equation is 22 −  = (2 − 1) = 0 ⇒  = 0,  = 12 , so  = 1 0 + 2 2 = 1 + 2 2 .

√
4± −36
9. The auxiliary equation is  − 4 + 13 = 0
2
⇒ = = 2 ± 3, so  = 2 (1 cos 3 + 2 sin 3).
2
√ √
−2 ± 12 1 3
11. The auxiliary equation is 22 + 2 − 1 = 0 ⇒ = =− ± , so
4 2 2
√ √
 = 1 (−12+ 32)
+ 2 (−12−32)
.
√
−200 ± −400
13. The auxiliary equation is 100 + 200 + 101 = 0 ⇒  =
2
= −1 ± 1
10
, so
200
 1   1 
 = − 1 cos 10  + 2 sin 10  .

15. The auxiliary equation is 52 − 2 − 3 = (5 + 3)( − 1) = 0 ⇒  = − 35 ,

 = 1, so the general solution is  = 1 −35 + 2  . We graph the basic

solutions  () = −35 , () =  as well as  = −35 + 2 ,

 = −35 −  , and  = −2−35 −  . Each solution consists of a single

continuous curve that approaches either 0 or ±∞ as  → ±∞.

17. 2 − 6 + 8 = ( − 4)( − 2) = 0, so  = 4,  = 2 and the general solution is  = 1 4 + 2 2 . Then

 0 = 41 4 + 22 2 , so (0) = 2 ⇒ 1 + 2 = 2 and  0 (0) = 2 ⇒ 41 + 22 = 2, giving 1 = −1 and 2 = 3.

Thus the solution to the initial-value problem is  = 32 − 4 .

19. 92 + 12 + 4 = (3 + 2)2 = 0 ⇒  = − 23 and the general solution is  = 1 −23 + 2 −23 . Then (0) = 1 ⇒
 
1 = 1 and, since  0 = − 23 1 −23 + 2 1 − 23  −23 ,  0 (0) = 0 ⇒ − 23 1 + 2 = 0, so 2 = 23 and the solution to

the initial-value problem is  = −23 + 2 −23

10  ■  SECOND-ORDER LINEAR DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS

21. 2 − 6 + 10 = 0 ⇒  = 3 ±  and the general solution is  = 3 (1 cos  + 2 sin ). Then 2 = (0) = 1 and

3 =  0 (0) = 2 + 31 ⇒ 2 = −3 and the solution to the initial-value problem is  = 3 (2 cos  − 3 sin ).

23. 2 −  − 12 = ( − 4)( + 3) = 0 ⇒  = 4,  = −3 and the general solution is  = 1 4 + 2 −3 . Then

0 = (1) = 1 4 + 2 −3 and 1 =  0 (1) = 41 4 − 32 −3 so 1 = 17 −4 , 2 = − 17 3 and the solution to the initial-value

problem is  = 17 −4 4 − 17 3 −3 = 17 4−4 − 17 3−3 .

25. 2 + 4 = 0 ⇒  = ±2 and the general solution is  = 1 cos 2 + 2 sin 2. Then 5 = (0) = 1 and 3 = (4) = 2 ,
so the solution of the boundary-value problem is  = 5 cos 2 + 3 sin 2.

27. 2 + 4 + 4 = ( + 2)2 = 0 ⇒  = −2 and the general solution is  = 1 −2 + 2 −2 . Then 2 = (0) = 1 and

0 = (1) = 1 −2 + 2 −2 so 2 = −2, and the solution of the boundary-value problem is  = 2−2 − 2−2 .

29. 2 −  = ( − 1) = 0 ⇒  = 0,  = 1 and the general solution is  = 1 + 2  . Then 1 = (0) = 1 + 2

−2 1 −2 
and 2 = (1) = 1 + 2  so 1 = , 2 = . The solution of the boundary-value problem is  = + .
−1 −1 −1 −1

31. 2 + 4 + 20 = 0 ⇒  = −2 ± 4 and the general solution is  = −2 (1 cos 4 + 2 sin 4). But 1 = (0) = 1 and

2 = () = 1 −2 ⇒ 1 = 22 , so there is no solution.

33. (a) Case 1 ( = 0):  00 +  = 0 ⇒  00 = 0 which has an auxiliary equation 2 = 0 ⇒  = 0 ⇒  = 1 + 2 

where (0) = 0 and () = 0. Thus, 0 = (0) = 1 and 0 = () = 2  ⇒ 1 = 2 = 0. Thus  = 0.

√
Case 2 (  0):  00 +  = 0 has auxiliary equation 2 = − ⇒  = ± − [distinct and real since   0] ⇒
√ √
 = 1  −
+ 2 − −
where (0) = 0 and () = 0. Thus 0 = (0) = 1 + 2 (∗) and
√ √
0 = () = 1  −
+ 2 − −
(†).
√  √ √ 
Multiplying (∗) by  −
and subtracting (†) gives 2  − − − − = 0 ⇒ 2 = 0 and thus 1 = 0 from (∗).

Thus  = 0 for the cases  = 0 and   0.

√ √ √
(b)  00 +  = 0 has an auxiliary equation 2 +  = 0 ⇒  = ±  ⇒  = 1 cos   + 2 sin   where
√
(0) = 0 and () = 0. Thus, 0 = (0) = 1 and 0 = () = 2 sin  since 1 = 0. Since we cannot have a trivial
√ √
solution, 2 6= 0 and thus sin   = 0 ⇒   =  where  is an integer ⇒  = 2 2 2 and

 = 2 sin() where  is an integer.

35. (a) 2 − 2 + 2 = 0 ⇒  = 1 ±  and the general solution is  =  (1 cos  + 2 sin ). If () =  and () =  then

 (1 cos  + 2 sin ) =  ⇒ 1 cos  + 2 sin  = − and  (1 cos  + 2 sin ) =  ⇒

1 cos  + 2 sin  = − . This gives a linear system in 1 and 2 which has a unique solution if the lines are not parallel.
If the lines are not vertical or horizontal, we have parallel lines if cos  =  cos  and sin  =  sin  for some nonzero
 SECOND-ORDER LINEAR DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS  ■  11

cos  sin  sin  sin 

constant  or == ⇒ = ⇒ tan  = tan  ⇒  −  = ,  any integer. (Note that
cos  sin  cos  cos 
none of cos , cos , sin , sin  are zero.) If the lines are both horizontal then cos  = cos  = 0 ⇒  −  = , and
similarly vertical lines means sin  = sin  = 0 ⇒  −  = . Thus the system has a unique solution if  −  6= .

(b) The linear system has no solution if the lines are parallel but not identical. From part (a) the lines are parallel if

− cos 
 −  = . If the lines are not horizontal, they are identical if − = − ⇒ == ⇒
− cos 
 cos  sin 
= − . (If  = 0 then  = 0 also.) If they are horizontal then cos  = 0, but  = also (and sin  6= 0) so
 cos  sin 
 sin   cos 
we require = − . Thus the system has no solution if  −  =  and 6= − unless cos  = 0, in
 sin   cos 
 sin 
which case 6= − .
 sin 

(c) The linear system has infinitely many solution if the lines are identical (and necessarily parallel). From part (b) this occurs
 cos   sin 
when  −  =  and = − unless cos  = 0, in which case = − .
 cos   sin 