Professional Documents
Culture Documents
AN AGRO-PASTORAL CALENDAR?
Patrice Lecoq
Situated in the heart of the Vilcabamba cordillera in Peru, some 150 km northwest of Cuzco, the ancient Inca state
capital, Choqek’iraw or Choquequirao (“the golden cradle” in Quechua), is one of the most beautiful achievements of
Inca architecture, and one of the very few pre-Hispanic sites displaying large wall mosaics, the only one known from
Inca times. This article will attempt to demonstrate that the figures represented on the walls convey cosmological signifi-
cance and are laid out following textile principles. After describing the site and its geo-cultural setting, the mosaics’ main
characteristics will be examined in detail, in an attempt to grasp their meaning. Finally, the author suggests that some of
the scenes depicted could have been inspired by pre-Columbian myths and could be linked to astronomical concepts.
Ubicado en el corazón de la cordillera de Vilcabamba, a unos 150 kilómetros de Cuzco, la antigua capital del estado
inca, Choqek’iraw o Choquequirao (la cuna del oro en quechua), es uno de los logros más hermosos de la arquitectura
Inca y el único sitio de época inca, con un gran mosaico mural. En este trabajo se intentará demostrar que las figuras
representadas en las paredes podrían transmitir significado cosmológico y se distribuyen siguiendo principios textiles.
Asimismo, después de hacer una breve descripción del sitio, ubicándolo en sus contextos geográfico y cultural, se
analizarán las principales decoraciones que allí se encuentran para tratar de entenderlas. Los temas representados
podrían referirse a antiguos mitos andinos y concepciones de orden astronómicos.
Patrice Lecoq, Université de Paris 1, UMR 8096 CNRS, Archéologie des Amériques, Paris, France, patricelecoq@free.fr
Ñawpa Pacha, Journal of Andean Archaeology, Volume 33, Number 1, pp. 43–69. Copyright # 2013 Institute of Andean Studies. All rights reserved.
43
Ñawpa Pacha: Journal of Andean Archaeology Volume 33, Number 1
Pumasillo and Choqetakarpu to the north, collected by Cobo (1964 [1653]) and Polo de
Wiraquchan to the northwest, Ampay to the south, Ondegardo (1906 [1567]); for additional discussion,
and Salkantay to the northeast, which the inhabitants see Bauer 2000; Zuidema 1974–1976, 1978). As
of the neighboring villages consider to be sacred with other ceremonial centers in the Cuzco region
places where the souls of their ancestors, the Apu, recently studied by Bauer (2000: 178), it is possible
reside (Reinhard 1983, 1985, 2002; Scanu 1987). that the site of Choqek’iraw in the valley of the
In order to avoid confusion, it is important to note Apurimac was conceived as a more or less idealized
that Choqek’iraw is not the only site to bear this name projection of this other wak’a associated with sun
in the Cuzco region. As Zuidema (1974–1976: worship and the Inca, although this cannot be
212–214) and Bauer (2000) have remarked, proven given current archaeological data.
Choquequirao or Chuquiquirao is also the name of
a sacred mountain (wak’a) situated northeast of
Cuzco in the Antisuyu, whose topography resembles General Description of Choqek’iraw
the site discussed in this article (Lecoq and Saintenoy
2013). In the Inca period, a spring called Given the limited published data available for the site
Chuquiquirao puquio emerged from the entrails of of Choqek’iraw and its context (Alencastre 2006;
the earth, and llamas and textiles were sacrificed to Echevarría López 2005, 2008; Echevarría López
pay homage to it. This wak’a, located on the and Valencia García 2009; Lecoq 2008, 2010;
fourth ceque of the Antisuyu, was one element in Lecoq and Duffait 2004; Lee 1997, 2010;
the cosmological system that then characterized the Lumbreras et al. 2001; Ravines 2006; Samanez
socio-political and ritual organization of Cuzco, as 2006; Samanez and Zapata 1995, 1999), a short
has been established, especially from the data description seems necessary. Choqek’iraw is a vast
44
Lecoq: Can the Inca site of Choqek’iraw be considered an agro-pastoral calendar?
architectural complex spread over nearly 100 ha. Its As in the upper district, the lower district contains
numerous edifices are located in several quarters, several buildings and kallanka surrounding a vast
both central and outlying, which today are divided square. At the side of this plaza, a group of three
into 13 sectors and several sub-sectors; some are still large two-story buildings and small constructions
covered by vegetation and have not been mapped. may have formed an elite residence. A monument
The most abundant and best-preserved buildings are stands to the south; its façade is pierced with trapezoi-
located in the urban nucleus covering nearly 11 ha. dal double-jamb doorways, and its door opens onto
Like the former Inca capital, Cuzco, Choqek’iraw is the southern sector and leads to a truncated hill,
organized into two districts—hanan (upper) and called an ushnu (Lecoq and Saintenoy 2013). A
hurin (lower) (Figure 2). large fountain occupies the western part of the
The upper district includes diverse edifices and square. Like all the other water sources, it is fed by
fountains grouped around a square, as well as public a long canal that originates several kilometers uphill
halls called kallanka (Gasparini and Margolies in the Quebrada Chunchumayu, the source of the
1977) and three two-story buildings—the streams flowing down from the glaciers of the
qollqa—that were used as warehouses (Zapata nevado that crown the mountain of Choqek’iraw.
2005). Sixteen short terraces irrigated by a network This principal canal crosses the site from north to
of canals were also built there. south and forms its main division (Samanez and
Zapata 1999). The most distant part of
Choqek’iraw’s southern slope includes several con-
structions: an enclosure, a fountain, and a group of
two large buildings facing each other called the
“House of the Priests.” Most of the buildings of
this site are oriented to either the cardinal directions
or towards surrounding mountains such as the
Cerro Wiraquchan to the northwest, which may
have played an important part in the ritual aspect of
this site (Lecoq 2007, 2008; see Figure 3). On the
eastern slope of the site, residential areas and various
workshops—including weaving and gold-working,
according to Echevarría López (2005) and Gallegos
(2005)—form groups of structures with rectangular
and circular plans (Lecoq 2008).
Large complexes of terraces, probably for agricul-
ture, rise in tiers on both sides of Choqek’iraw. The
most spectacular terraces—which are visible from
afar—are on the eastern slope, grouped in four sets
over three levels that give the site its identity
(Figure 2, sector 7). Each terrace is bordered above
and below by a meticulously constructed retaining
wall. Three stairways allow passage from one terrace
to another, and flagstones inserted in the wall also
serve as steps. Below these terraces, another complex
Figure 2. Map of the central part of Choqek’iraw (redrawn from of narrower terraces spreads out below (Figure 2,
the original plan prepared by COPESCO in 2003 and Echevarría sector 8), in the center of which stands a single-
López 2008). roomed building on two levels called “the House of
45
Ñawpa Pacha: Journal of Andean Archaeology Volume 33, Number 1
46
Lecoq: Can the Inca site of Choqek’iraw be considered an agro-pastoral calendar?
The Mosaics of Choqek’iraw recall those of the terraces of Yucay in the valley of
Anta east of Choqek’iraw (Molinié 1996).
Choqek’iraw was more than a center for Inca agricul- However, the stone mosaics found at Choqek’iraw
tural and textile production as Echevarría López apparently continue a long tradition of mural art
(2005) and Gallegos (2005) imply, but also had a going back to the Initial period (1800–1500/900
ritual role, as suggested by the mosaics discovered B.C.) that continued and evolved into the Late
in various sectors. For example, in 2002, the archae- Horizon (A.D. 1440–1539) and thereafter. As the
ologist Paz Flores encountered some mosaics depict- late Duccio Bonavia argued, “this artistic expression
ing llamas on the upper western slope close to the is closely associated with religious practices and man-
central square; this discovery was made public in ifested itself above all in the decoration of the temples
September 2004 (Paz Flores 2007). Subsequently, and palaces where it was linked to the beliefs of the
several other mosaics decorated with geometric, various cultures that developed throughout the pre-
anthropomorphic, and zoomorphic motifs have Hispanic epoch” (1990: 155 [translation by author]).
been excavated, in particular by the archaeologist In many cases, the painted mural motifs were inspired
Valencia García while cleaning the high slopes of by—and, in some cases, more or less reproduced—tex-
sector 8 (sub-sector D); these mosaics were later tile motifs (Bonavia 1974: 145). This seems to have
restored. The terraces decorated in this way are been the case at Choqek’iraw where the motifs and
located below the central square of the lower half, their arrangements were inspired by textile patterns as
beneath the edifice defined as a temple (hurin) and I have argued elsewhere (Lecoq 2010).
the fountains constructed nearby (Figure 4). A
small, more or less dried-up, spring emerges at this Organization and Arrangement of the
location. These terraces rise in tiers from 2,766 to Motifs
3,010 m in altitude and cover nearly 185,700 m2.
Each terrace measures nearly 80-m long by 1.50-m The Choqek’iraw mosaics comprise 28 motifs in stone
wide, but only the currently exposed part is decorated. corresponding to five types: lines, broken lines, checker-
In fact, the entire western slope of Choqek’iraw was boards, stylized llamas, and an anthropomorphic figure
covered by terraces whose organization and symbolism (Echevarría López 2008; Echevarría López and
47
Ñawpa Pacha: Journal of Andean Archaeology Volume 33, Number 1
Figure 5. Overview of the mosaics localized on the western slope of sector 8 (sub-area D) of Choqek’iraw, showing the textile-inspired
motifs. The arrangement of the stones forming the figures evokes the weft of a textile chain.
Valencia García 2009; see Figure 5). The llamas and the solstices or equinoxes, with lunar phases, or with
figure are displayed on 19 terraces forming the arc of a the appearance of certain constellations (such as the
circle. Collectively, the terraces form a large mural, Pleiades)—a topic for future research. Because the
which can be seen as a whole only from afar, overhan- motifs face the setting sun, Zapata (2005) gave them
ging the Río Apurimac which flows westward in a the evocative but rather arbitrary name “the Llamas of
deep canyon below before reaching the Amazonian the Sun,” although there is no evidence to suggest this
piedmont. The terraces are oriented towards the west was the Inca name for these motifs.
and northwest as well as towards the three peaks of the
already-mentioned Cerro Wiraquchan. At precise The Upper Terraces
moments throughout the year, Cerro Wiraquchan may
have played a decisive role at Choqek’iraw—perhaps in To make the study of these mosaics easier, the
connection with the movements of the sun at the Copesco archaeologists divided the slope into six
48
Lecoq: Can the Inca site of Choqek’iraw be considered an agro-pastoral calendar?
sub-sectors designated A to F (see Figures 2 and 4). that form the outer facing of the terrace, the height of
Two sub-sectors—D and F—have decorations, which fluctuates between 1.80 and 2 m.
which were catalogued and numbered 1–28 by A second terrace, some 10 m below, shows a set of
Echevarría López (2008), a designation I have partly 12 checkerboards extending underneath the debris
followed. These sub-sectors are located on the upper (Figure 5). A few meters from there, these motifs
and middle part, respectively, of the western slope are replaced by a more complex design made up of
and form two distinct, but complementary, units. a series of undulating lines coming out of a sort of
The first sub-sector—F—corresponds to the upper big rectangle evoking what could be an altar or an
terraces, and its decorative motifs are essentially ushnu (not illustrated).
linear and geometric. On the first terrace, a zigzag
line (motif 26 according to Echevarría López 2005: Terraces Decorated with Camelids
209 and Echevarria López and Valencia García
2009) is formed of 12 units, with a point on top Sub-sector D corresponds to the lower terraces, and is a
(Figure 5). Each motif is made from stones of section of the site of particular interest. Located at about
whitish schistose limestone arranged vertically or hori- 2,900 m above sea level, these terraces display a set of 24
zontally. These stones stand out from the others, llamas varying in size and posture (Figures 6 and 7)
which are slightly smaller and positioned horizontally, accompanied by a small anthropomorphic figure
Figure 6. Overview of the main part of the mosaics localized on the western slope of sector 8 (sub-area D) of Choqek’iraw.
49
Ñawpa Pacha: Journal of Andean Archaeology Volume 33, Number 1
Figure 7. The main figures, on the same scale, represented on the terraces of the western slope (sector 8) of Choqek’iraw (drawings made
from slides and digital images, including several telephotos). The number of figures resumes the nomenclature used by COPESCO, as
presented in Echevarría López (2008).
shown with arms stretching outwards and towards the from the front of its chest to its tail, but certain
sky (Figures 6 and 7, no. 25). The llamas are shown figures are smaller. The motif appears vertically in the
in profile going towards the left, i.e. to the north for center of the terrace wall, 15 cm off the ground and
an observer in front of the panel. Small blocks of off- about 30 cm from the top, arranged on the top part
white schistose limestone are arranged to form the of the sub-sector (Figures 5, 6, and 7). The smaller
head, the body, and the limbs of each animal, and in llamas are 1.0-m tall and 0.75-m long (Paz Flores
some cases incised lines define the eye and the mouth 2007). In addition to their differences in size, the
(Figure 7, nos 9, 17, and 18). The stones in the llama motifs can be divided into two groups: (1) rela-
façades of these terraces are also arranged vertically, in tively stylized motifs (the most numerous) in which
contrast to other terraces where the stones are laid hori- the various parts of the body consist of a single
zontally (Figures 7 and 8). course of stone (Figure 7, nos 1, 2, 6–11, 16, 17, 19,
The llama motifs fall into two size categories, prob- 23, and 24); and (2) motifs in which the body is
ably representing adults and juveniles, as discussed made of two or more courses of stone, placed one
further below. Each adult llama is 1.70-m tall from beside the other (Figure 7, nos 3–5, 12–15, 18, and
its forelimbs to the top of its ears, and 1.30-m long 20–22).
50
Lecoq: Can the Inca site of Choqek’iraw be considered an agro-pastoral calendar?
51
Ñawpa Pacha: Journal of Andean Archaeology Volume 33, Number 1
the pictorial space. To make things clearer, I have sep- from the boulder, there are three other animals
arated these terraces into three major zones—upper, limited by the stairs (terraces 13–15), below which
middle, and lower (Figure 6)—and defined each there are three llamas between the staircase and a
decorative element as a motif. I have then grouped rock on the right (terraces 16–18). A small
the motifs into units for interpretation (designated figure, which may be the herder leading the caravan
A–J in Figure 6), and each motif is cross-referenced of llamas, is depicted at the end of the lowest
with the number assigned by the Copesco terrace numbered 19 (Figure 7, no. 4). Facing
archaeologists during terrace restoration (Echevarría northwest, he forms a new unit of interpretation by
López 2008; Echevarría Lopéz and Valencia García himself.
2009). (On the second-highest terrace, llama 24 was Thus, and in spite of their apparent cohesion, the
given this number because it was discovered after mosaics of Choqek’iraw seem to form distinct pictor-
most of the other motifs had been found and ial groups: adult llamas, probably males, on the top
recorded.) four terraces; female llamas, accompanied by their
Beginning with the upper terraces, the artists young on the two terraces just below; and two cara-
shifted each of the motifs towards the right along an vans in motion, probably composed of male llamas,
oblique north–south axis, which gives a sense of mostly young, ascending the slope of the mountain
movement to the whole panel and the impression of from the Río Apurimac. These caravans consist of
being oriented from northeast to southwest owing four groups of three llamas each: the first at the top
to the perspective. The four upper terraces in the on the right (unit F), the second below on the left
top zone include eight llamas that could be adult (unit G), the third in the center continuing the one
males because of their size and bulk and the before it (unit H), and the fourth right at the
burdens they carry; they are more or less similar, bottom on the right (unit I).
arranged next to one another on four levels, each of The placement of the motifs on the mountain’s
which is treated as an interpretation unit. One of slope is unlikely to be by chance, and it may indicate
these llamas—llama 1—is on a projecting panel a specific code with which to “read” the motifs.
that makes it stand out; it is oriented towards the Apart from the terraces at the very top (nos 1 and
west. Another llama—llama 24—is placed just 2), which only have a single motif, a decreasing
above. Then, on the next two terraces (nos 4 and order is observable in the number of motifs on
5), there are two adult llamas, probably females as each panel from top to bottom: from three on ter-
they are accompanied by their young (Echevarría races 3 and 4, the number decreases to two for ter-
López 2008: 39; Paz Flores 2007). I consider that races 5 and 6, and to one for all the terraces in the
these four, more or less similar, motifs form a unit middle and bottom parts (7–19). Curiously, the
of interpretation. number of terraces of which the motifs form a
As discussed above, the motifs on the 12 terraces unit, based on my analysis—follows an inverse
(numbered 7–18) in the middle and bottom zones organization. Thus, while each of the four upper-
show two caravans of adult llamas, probably males. most units corresponds to a single terrace, the fol-
Although each llama is found on a single terrace lowing unit is depicted on two terraces (E), the
face, they appear to form groups of three, set apart next three units are composed on three terraces,
by features that interrupt the caravan’s progress. while the last (unit J) is found on a single terrace
Three animals, for example, are seen in the caravan (no. 19). Thus, the number of motifs per terrace
in the top on the right (on terraces 7–9) and three could be summarized as follows: 1, 1, 3, 3, 2, 2,
other llamas are placed on the left side (on terraces and then 1, 1, 1; 1, 1, 1; 1, 1, 1; 1, 1, 1, 1
10–12). These are separated by a rocky outcrop (Figure 6, on the left).2
(white in color here again) and placed exactly in Urton (2003) has shown that the numbers two,
the center of the mural. Continuing downwards three, four, and six generally have strong symbolic
52
Lecoq: Can the Inca site of Choqek’iraw be considered an agro-pastoral calendar?
53
Ñawpa Pacha: Journal of Andean Archaeology Volume 33, Number 1
visitors probably understood the symbolism of the ceremonial and sacred attitude in the form of illa or
iconographic motifs they saw—especially the conopa (Flores Ochoa 1974–1976). So, it is possible
mosaics of the western slope—since they had seen that the purpose of the mosaic llamas was to extol fer-
them represented in other media such as textiles, cer- tility by manifesting the camelids’ reproductive
amics, wood, gold, or rock art. Furthermore, llamas power. The two llamas with their young on terraces
had an essential role for most Incas. As they had no 5 and 6 may symbolically represent the reproduction
knowledge of writing, the artists gave the designs of the livestock. Even today, young animals are used
and colors symbolic values that any member of the to embody the future generation.
Inca culture could understand (Bray 2008). There is no reason to be surprised that the llama
should have become a sacred animal connecting
mankind to divinities. Even today, during certain
The Camelid Motifs agrarian rites or at carnival time, the people of the
Andes sacrifice llamas or offer their fetuses to the divi-
The choice of llamas as the principal motif and their nities to invoke their benevolence—I will discuss this
position on the western slope overhanging the conflu- further below—it was also frequently the custom,
ence of the Apurimac and the Yamana do not seem when an important personage died, to sacrifice a
accidental, but rather result from concerns of a llama so that it could carry the deceased to the under-
ritual nature. For example, camelids are associated world (Goepfert 2011).
with fertility due to their sacred origins. According Llamas are recurrent elements in Inca-style cer-
to Flores Ochoa (1974–1976), llamas and alpacas amics where they are used to decorate plates or
came out of the depths of the earth, passing dishes. They are generally painted in black on a
through springs, lagoons, pools, rivers, and the sea red carmine, finely polished, slipped surface
itself, Mama Cocha. These streams and bodies of and arranged in files bordered above and below by
water are pacarina or places of origin (Duviols a broken white line (Baca Cosio 1989; see
1974–1976: 283, 292). The father creator, also Figures 10a and 10b). Very similar to the
Mañasqa Uywa, loaned the camelids to man, to Choqek’iraw motifs, scenes of lines of llamas climb-
help him survive in the puna, which is why they ing a slope are found on many other objects, includ-
must be honored in ceremonies held at certain ing several coca bags or Inca traditional chuspas,
times of the year. It is precisely from a more or less woven and embroidered in wool and cotton, which
dried-up spring, as mentioned above, that the were discovered on the south coast of Peru
llamas comprising the Choqek’iraw caravan seem to (d’Harcourt 2002 [1934]: Plate 31b; Lavallée and
emerge (Paz Flores 2007). On the other hand, the Lumbreras 1985; Lumbreras 1977; Stone-Miller
animals at the top of the first two terraces 1992: Plate 66; see Figure 11). Today, these pieces
(Figure 6) seem to incarnate the half-wild camelids are displayed in several museums, including Peru’s
destined to fertilize the females and live in the high National Museum of Archaeology, Anthropology,
pastures next to the tutelary rustic divinities (Flores and History, the Inca Museum in Cusco (Lecoq
Ochoa 1998). They seem to be more or less associated 2010: 37–38), and the British Museum ( piece no.
with meteorological phenomena, especially thunder, Am1954, 05.584).
which was once incarnated by Wiracocha; however, As I have discussed previously (Lecoq 2010), the
in Choqek’iraw, Wiracocha seems to be evoked by manner in which the motifs are arranged in relation
the massif of the same name towards which the to one another on the terraces of Choqek’iraw
llama mosaics and the openings of the “house of suggests that the mosaics were conceived according
the priests” are oriented. This is the fertilizing force, to the methods used to make fabric, specifically a
anqa or kamac, that the llamas and alpacas have, tapestry (Sophie Desrosiers, personal communication,
which explains why they are frequently shown in a April 2008). D’Harcourt (2002 [1959]: 17–21; 2008
54
Lecoq: Can the Inca site of Choqek’iraw be considered an agro-pastoral calendar?
55
Ñawpa Pacha: Journal of Andean Archaeology Volume 33, Number 1
Figure 12. Detail of a small llama woven in tapestry technique. The thick weft threads used to reproduce the patterns completely hide
the warp threads. This woollen figure evokes those of Choqek’iraw made of white stones.
now conserved in the Casa de la Moneda, in which Bolivia, members of the Coroma’s community still
the Cerro Rico, the great silver mine of Potosi, is worship some of those old sacred textiles, called
depicted as a virgin dressed in a sumptuous robe q’epi, and, among them, unku (Bubba 1997). This
that replaced the pre-Columbian unku she could hypothesis could explain Choqek’iraw’s magnifi-
have worn (Gisbert et al., 1987: 318, Figure 1). cence, as well as various monuments that were
Even today, during the celebrations in honor of the erected with the aim of proclaiming the symbolic
Virgin Mary, it is customary in Peru to clothe the force of state power throughout the Inca empire
statues of the Virgin and dress the crosses on May 2 (Bray 2008). We now know that the roles of
during the Fiesta de Las Cruces. Phipps writes that Andean textiles are complex and that they have mul-
“some of the sacred clothes worn by Christian tiple meanings (Cereceda 1978; Desrosiers 1992,
images were made with the remains of the old Inca 1997, 2010; Frame 1994; 2007; Franquemont
tunic” (2005: 90 [translation by author]). In et al. 1992; Murra 1975; Zorn 1987). For example,
certain ceremonial clothes were associated with real
geographical maps (Platt et al. 2006: 73–74) or
even calendars (Zuidema 2008a, 2008b, 2009). For
example, today on the island of Taquile in Lake
Titicaca, men still make belts in which each of the
motifs shown corresponds to months in the agricul-
tural calendar (INC 2006).
56
Lecoq: Can the Inca site of Choqek’iraw be considered an agro-pastoral calendar?
Figure 14. A possible representation of the inter-ecological barter system of the Choqek’iraw area.
1975; Flores Ochoa et al. 1995; West 1979). These Mythic Narratives and Decorative Motifs
highlands are where breeding llama males are found
and where the females give birth; I think the upper One of the basic Andean myths also illustrates very
terraces of the Choqek’iraw mural panel directly well the primordial role of the llama for the ancient
allude to them, since loaded males and females with stockbreeders of the high Andean plateau, which
their young appear on it. But, in this case, the three could partly explain why this animal is shown at
llamas placed just above could be interpreted as the Choqek’iraw. This myth is recounted in the anon-
representation of the transhumance between the ymous Quechua manuscript from the end of the six-
regions close to the highlands and the middle teenth century Rites and Traditions of Huarochiri,
valleys during March to May, and then from collected by the Spanish priest Francisco de Avila
September to October. As for the nine llamas and shortly after the conquest in the principality of
little shepherd comprising the caravan on the lower Huarochiri, as transcribed by Taylor (1974–1976:
terraces, they could evoke the great barter caravans tra- 241; 1980: 253), and translated and commented on
veling between the high plateau and the eastern low- by Salomon and Urioste (1991: 132–133). It
lands of the Amazonian piedmont in the dry period reveals the conceptual linkages between camelids,
from May to the end of August when the paths are the Milky Way, and the waters. According to this
dry and the journey is practicable (Brougère 1984, manuscript:
1988; Browman 1988; Lecoq 1987; Merlino and
Rabey 1983; West 1979).3 They say the Yacana, which is the animator
In the Andes, Aliaga (1989) and Ziólkowski (1989) (Cámac) of the llamas, moves through the
emphasize that the observations of the sun made in middle of the sky. The Yacana moves
the regional administrative centers allowed the Incas to inside the Milky Way. It’s big, really big.
establish a system for programing activities, mainly agri- It becomes blacker as it approaches
cultural, according to the different regions. Choqek’iraw through the sky, with two eyes and a very
mosaics could be an illustration of this practice. large neck. This, we know, is what native
57
Ñawpa Pacha: Journal of Andean Archaeology Volume 33, Number 1
people call the Yacana. They say if a man to worship them, saying, “These are the
were in luck and fortunate, the Yacana animators, the makers.” The rest still wor-
would fall right on top of him while it shipped these stars as they were rising,
drank water from some spring. As its spending the appropriate nights in sleepless
woolly bulk pressed down upon him, vigil, but said, “We’ll hold the other huacas
someone else would pluck out some of its in higher honor. This is all we know.”
wool.
That apparition would occur at night. In The meaning of this myth and its relation to the
the morning, at daybreak, the man would Andean cosmology, water, sources, animal and
look at the wool he’d plucked out. human fertility, and the wealth and symbolism of
Examining it he’d see the wool to be wool have been the subject of numerous analyses
blue, white, black, and brown, of every and commentaries (Pucher de Kroll 1950; Zuidema
hue, thickly matted together. If he has no 1992; Zuidema and Urton 1976). Each of the
llamas, he’d worship at the place where he animals that the myth describes was formed by dark
has seen the apparition and plucked the patches in the Milky Way consisting of clouds of
wool, and trade for some llamas right interstellar dust and this negative zodiac was used to
away. After worshiping, he’d trade for a determine the agricultural phases, such as times for
female and a male llama. Just from the sowing and harvesting, or to guide shepherds and
two he’d bought, two or three thousand caravan drivers in their journeys across the mountain
llamas would soon come. In old times the (Bauer and Dearborn 1998; de Bock and Zuidema
Yacana revealed itself this way to a whole 1990; Loza-Balsa 1995; Urton 2006; Zuidema
lot of people all over this province. In the 1978, 1992, 2009; Zuidema and Urton 1976). So,
middle of the night, when nobody is we may wonder, to what extent did the
aware of it, the Yacana drinks all the Choqek’iraw llama mosaics refer to this celestial divi-
water out of the ocean. If the Yacana nity connected to the snow-covered mountains, ferti-
failed to drink it, the waters quickly lity, sources, and rivers? Choqek’iraw is well suited to
drown the whole world. observing these heavenly bodies, especially from the
A small dark spot goes before the truncated hill (the ushnu) dominating the southern
Yacana, and as we know, people call it sectors and the Apurimac valley (Lecoq and
Tinamou. This Yacana, they say, has a Saintenoy 2013). When night falls, the stars in the
calf. It looks just as if the calf were suck- constellation of the Southern Cross are the first to
ling. Also, we know there are three stars appear in the cold months of May to August just
in a straight line. They call these the before the beginning of the farming year. A few
Condor, the Vulture, and the Falcon. moments later and 10–12 degrees further north, the
Next are the ones we call the Pleiades; if stars of the Southern Cross are followed by two par-
they come out (crossed out [very]) at their ticularly brilliant stars identified in the European
biggest, people say, “This year we’ll have zodiac as Alpha and Beta Centauri and in the
plenty.” But if they come out at their smal- Andes as the eyes of the celestial Llama, the Llamas
lest, people say, “We’re in for a very hard Ñawi (Pucher de Kroll 1950: 198–201; Urton
time.” 2006: 202; Zuidema 2011; Zuidema and Urton
Certain other stars always appear very 1976). If at night one stands facing the mosaics, the
large? People give them the names Poco caravan depicted on the terraces appears to climb
Huarac, Willca Huarac, and Cancho the western slope of Choqek’iraw following a route
Huarac. In the old times, people, or at going from right to left and from southwest to north-
least some few of them, reportedly used east on an axis comparable to the Milky Way’s at the
58
Lecoq: Can the Inca site of Choqek’iraw be considered an agro-pastoral calendar?
moment of the June northern solstice (Urton 2006). precipitations, thereby preventing the deluge and
At this time, from 10 p.m. to midnight, the Milky allowing the subsequent renewal of the land and flow-
Way is more or less directly above the site. The celes- ering of the plants (see Figure 15).4 The Llama con-
tial Llama’s eyes seem to dominate the truncated hill stellation therefore played a determining role in the
and, in August, its head extends above the Cerro Andean agricultural calendar, which is perhaps why
Ampay and its body over the mountain of llamas were so important in the calendar rituals of
Corihuayrachina, thereby symbolically uniting two Cuzco.
of the most important massifs of the region
(Figures 1 and 9). At the beginning of the rainy
season in October, on the other hand, the Yacana dis- The Camelids in the Andean Agro-pastoral
appears from the night sky only to reappear six Calendar
months later, marking the rhythm of the seasons.
Zuidema and Urton (1976; see also Zuidema 2011: Based on his analysis of the texts of colonial chroni-
669, 795–796) have shown that the pastoralists of clers, Zuidema (1989: 424–429; 1992: 63–65,
the high Andean plateau thought the Yacana took 2011: 668–669, 795; see Figure 16) identifies an
advantage of this period to retire to the other side interesting relationship between llamas and the calen-
of the Earth where it absorbed the water from the dar, which could perhaps be applied to Choqek’iraw
Figure 15. Outline of the Andean agro-pastoral calendar, in the Choqek’iraw area.
59
Ñawpa Pacha: Journal of Andean Archaeology Volume 33, Number 1
Figure 16. The Inca calendrical organization according to Zuidema (1992: 64 and 66). (a) The Inca calendar with four periods of three
months each and one other month; (a1) The black llama weeping for rain before the four-month period (Guaman Poma de Ayala 1936
[1615]: 256–257); (a2) The sacrifice of 100 black llamas after the four-month period (Guaman Poma de Ayala 1936 [1615]: 242–243);
(a3) The white llama ritual, half a year after the black llama ritual (Guaman Poma de Ayala 1936 [1615]: 320–321); (b) The Inca
calendar, with three periods of four months each and one other month.
and so is worth studying in more detail. Zuidema sacrificed and dedicated to the Thunder.
writes: Although no reason for this choice is given
and although more than two colors were
Most systematic information is concerned involved, binary color distinctions were
with llama sacrifice, as organized by calendar associated with the Thunder. During the
rituals of Cuzco, the capital of the Inca state. intermediate seasons, including the dates of
Llamas were selected according to breed, the solstices, when little or no agricultural
color, sex, age, hierarchy of purpose, and dis- activities were carried out, guanacos (wild
tributions like fertility/sterility and wild/ llamas), or llamas like guanacos with brown
domesticated … The most basic system of hair, were sacrificed. They were dedicated
sacrifice in Cuzco involved the killing of to the god Viracocha whom the Spaniards
100 llamas at the beginning of each month, called the “Creator” … The distinctions
selecting llamas of a different color for each were thus: domesticity of the Sun and the
of the four seasons … During the season of Thunder as opposed to the non-domesticity
planting, roughly around September, and of Viracocha, and, within this distinction,
November, the llamas with long white hair a strengthening of the Sun with a con-
were chosen in order to reinforce the sun’s comitant weakening of the Thunder
heat and its capacity to send rain. During during planting in contrast to a weakening
the season of harvest, that is, from about of the Sun and the strengthening of the
the March equinox to the beginning of Thunder during harvest (Zuidema 1992:
June, the llamas of different colors were 63–65).
60
Lecoq: Can the Inca site of Choqek’iraw be considered an agro-pastoral calendar?
Additionally, Zuidema observes: “Old and black domain of the Inca Tupac Yupanqui. Thus, the
llamas played an important role in relation to the white color of the llamas shown on the mosaics of
four-month period organized symmetrically around Choqek’iraw may reflect the white llama that the
the December solstice, that is, during the same Incas chose in April, announcing the dry season
time that the young initiates of the Cuzco nobility when the Yacana reappeared in the sky above
were brought in contact with their ancestors” Choqek’iraw. The orientation of the mosaics
(Zuidema 1992: 65 citing Molina 1989 [1574]: towards the Cerro Wiraquchan also seems to have
98–110). Zuidema also highlights that: “In the played a decisive role along these lines. As Itier
month before the four-month period mentioned, a (2008) points out, Spanish colonial accounts docu-
black llama was tied to a pole in the plaza of ment that Wiraqucha was the name given to a divinity
Cuzco and made to ‘weep for rain’ (Polo de presiding over agriculture and irrigation, “of which
Ondegardo 1906 [1567]; Guaman Poma de Ayala the existence depended on the abundant supply of
1936 [1615]: 256–257). It was not killed.” While water to the springs and lakes feeding the canals”
the first black llama ritual, “weeping for rain,” had (Itier 2008: 121). Itier further writes:
a place in relation to the four-month period, it
In ancient times [Wiraqucha] travelled
also had a role in the organization of the four
about the world to create the fields to be cul-
seasons of three months each. Around October,
tivated, the walls that delimited them, and
when the black llama had to weep for rain, the
the irrigation systems, dividing these
black cloud constellation of the Llama, found in
resources between the various ayllu and
the Milky Way near the Southern Cross, disap-
teaching men the agricultural techniques.
peared from the night sky (Zuidema and Urton
In fact, one of the principal epithets the
1976). Half a year later, a similar ritual was held
Incas gave to Wiraqucha was pacha
in the plaza with a white llama. It did not weep,
Yachaqchiq, “he who lays out the land.”
but with its feet pushed aside a vessel of corn
This expression refers both to the primor-
beer, thus announcing the dry season (Cobo 1964
dial act of creating the agricultural infra-
[1653]: 214). It was the time of the culmination
structures and to the god’s constant
at midnight of the Llama constellation. A llama of
intervention in the yearly production
this specific breed represented the king himself; it
cycles (Itier 2008: 121 [translation by
was never killed and it was buried with pomp
author]).
when it died from natural causes. In another
article on the same subject, Zuidema clarifies his If the name “Choqek’iraw” is derived from the word
interpretation of the original text on the white choqe, meaning “gold” or “brilliance,” and by exten-
llama by writing: “In April, a white llama, tied to sion from choqella, meaning “lightning” (González
the same or similar pole (?), was given chicha Holguín 1989 [1608]: 117), it is surprising to
(corn beer) to drink as thanks for carrying the find in the same region and a few kilometers apart
harvest into town (Cobo 1964 [1653]: 244–245, two of the principal cosmic divinities in the Inca
256–267, 320–321) … During these two transi- pantheon—Wiraqucha and Choqella—under two
tional months, llamas and agricultural produce different forms, but both associated with moun-
were brought together” (Zuidema 2009: 93). tains. One is to the northwest, materialized as a
The description of the sacrifices of differently three-pointed summit, and the other is to the
colored llamas at Cuzco, as markers of the agricultural southeast, represented by the mountain of
year, is potentially rich in meaning for a site such as Choqek’iraw, with both being positioned along a
Choqek’iraw, which may have been the scene for southeast/northwest axis similar to that followed
rituals similar to those in the Inca capital, but on a by the Río Apurimac. But, as Itier again makes
regional level, particularly if it was the private clear:
61
Ñawpa Pacha: Journal of Andean Archaeology Volume 33, Number 1
Whereas Wiraqucha was the god of the represent this symbolic complementarity and it is
underworld and of the waters rising up possible the site of Choqek’iraw was dedicated to
from it through the springs and lakes, the one of these divinities. Thus, while the mosaics are
Lightning was the god of the sky, the atmos- oriented to the northwest towards the three peaks of
pheric phenomena, and the rain. … The the Cerro Wiracochan and the setting sun that
dyad presiding over the Andean pantheon marks the dry season, at the same time, the animals
thus defined a cosmic opposition between forming the caravan are heading for the northeast
lower and upper waters. It also embodied and the rising sun at the moment of the June solstice.
two principles that governed the alternating At night, they seem to be joining the constellation of
seasons: the wet heat of the period of the the Llama directly above the site in an ascending
rains, manifestation of Wari/Wiraqucha, and movement taking them from the canyon of the
the dry heat of the low-water months, of Apurimac to the Milky Way, and thereby uniting
which the master was the lightning … This the two extremes.5
fundamental dualism was based on the
social and economic principle of opposition
and complementarity that existed within The Choqek’iraw Mosaics as a
each local society between the ayllu exploit- Possible Ritual Calendar
ing the temperate valleys, the domain of
agriculture and irrigation, and the ayllu prac- The hypothesis that the artists who designed the
ticing stock raising and tuber cultivation in Choqek’iraw mosaics were inspired by the Milky
the puna. Wari/Wiraqucha, who presided Way is plausible, as we know that ancient Andean
over irrigated agriculture, was the tutelary peoples carefully observed the stars and planets and
god of the inhabitants of the valleys, while other celestial phenomena to determine the calendar
those of the high steppes considered them- for agricultural activities (Urton 2006 [1986];
selves to be “sons of lightning” … The light- Zuidema 1992, 2011; Zuidema and Urton 1976).
ning was also the one who conferred their According to Reinhard (2002: 32), even today the
powers on the curer-shamans, whose thera- inhabitants of the region near Salkantay and around
peutic arsenal essentially came from the Abancay, not far from Choqek’iraw, consider the
wild flora above 3,800 meters. At this figure of the celestial Llama to be a protective divinity
upper level of the Andean pantheon, a sort connected to the camelids’ reproduction. It appears
of contract was established by exchanging therefore that, despite five centuries of European pres-
gods between maize cultivators and pastoral- ence, the ways in which contemporary Andeans think
ists: Wari/Wiraqucha’s protégés periodically about and relate to their environment exhibit some
worshipped the tutelary god of the sons of continuity with pre-Columbian cosmologies. There
the Lightning and reciprocally. So, the cult are further reasons to suggest that the Choqek’iraw
of Wari/Wiraqucha and the Lightning mosaics served as an agro-pastoral calendar for the
sealed the relationship of opposition and purposes of organizing the activity of the regional
complementarity existing between the communities all year round, as at other administrative
inhabitants of each of the two mountain eco- and religious sites in the territories conquered by the
logical stages (Itier 2008: 122 [translation by Incas (Ziólkowski 1989: 148). Furthermore, it is
author]). possible that the mosaic motifs stylistically and con-
ceptually on textiles encode calendric information.
Thus, it seems reasonable to suggest that the oppo- For example, on the island of Taquile, large woven
sition of the two massifs and the placement of the belts called “calendars” incorporate symbols depicting
llama on the high occidental slopes of Choqek’iraw the annual cycle, various aspects of agricultural life,
62
Lecoq: Can the Inca site of Choqek’iraw be considered an agro-pastoral calendar?
and the festive calendar of the community (Bellenger and the surrounding mountains and glaciers,
2007: 114; INC 2006: 44–58). These modern textile perhaps expressing the relationship between water
calendars recall the Nazca 2 “Paracas Textile” held by and fertility. This symbolic relationship also may be
the Brooklyn Museum (accession 38.121), which, it demonstrated by the orientations of most of the edi-
has been suggested, displays elements of a lunar calen- fices and the two great complexes of terraces on the
dar (d’Harcourt 2008 [1934]: Plates LXXX–XCVI). eastern and western slopes, which are oriented
Zuidema has suggested that the Wari tunics in the towards the main regional summits, and also by the
Robert Woods Bliss Collection of Pre-Columbian specific positions of fountains and networks of
Art at Dumbarton Oaks also had a calendric function: feeder canals. The site also reflects Andean dualism,
“particularly important for understanding the Wari in which everything seems to be skillfully arranged
concepts of political organization and the calendar” according to a game of mirrors and multiple opposi-
(Zuidema 2008b, 2009: 95–96). On the basis of ico- tions evoking the notion of yanantin (Platt 1978).
nographic analogies with the Inca culture, Zuidema The same type of opposition is found in the arrange-
proposes that: “The calendar, as it is represented on ment of the camelid motifs on the terraces of the
these ‘royal tunics,’ was probably organized around western slope of Choqek’iraw. Thus, the caravan
festivals similar to the Capac raymi that marked the seems to ascend from the depths of the valley of the
end of the December solstice” (Zuidema 2009: 96). Río Apurimac to the southwest, to the peak of
In a broadly similar manner, I suggest the hypothesis the Cerro Corihuayrachina to the northeast, while
that, at Choqek’iraw, the 12 llamas forming the two the mural panel is oriented towards the three
caravans and the other 12 camelids depicted on the summits of the Cerro Wiracochan to the northwest.
upper terraces played a role analogous to the geo- The number three also appears to have played an
metric and zoomorphic motifs on the Wari tunics. important role on this site, as it can be discerned
It is also possible that, like the woven “calendars” of both in the number of peaks crowning the two
Taquile, the individual llama motifs represented a massifs I have just mentioned and in the number of
specific month of the year and perhaps each terrace terraces on the western slope: the 12 terraces are
was associated with a specific community or social grouped in four units of three levels. Twelve is also
group responsible for taking care of this ceremonial the number of llamas comprising the two caravans
site, following a rotating system for providing services in the mosaics, which, again, are grouped in four
of ayni or minka type, a mutual aid system still used to units of three. It would be tempting to compare
maintain communal works such as irrigation canals, this figure with the number of months in a year,
terraces, and roads. The timing of these efforts may which would tend again to confer on Choqek’iraw
have been marked by the mosaics of Choqek’iraw, the role of a great calendar linked to the cycle of the
especially when lit up by the setting sun at the June seasons.
solstice. The presence directly above the site of the constel-
lation of the Llama or Yacana from April to October
may be connected to the calendar function I am pro-
Summary and Conclusion posing for Choqek’iraw, as represented by the appear-
ance and number of camelid motifs in the mosaics.
The archaeological evidence demonstrates that The appearance of the Milky Way in the regional
Choqek’iraw was a complex establishment, apparently sky and the white color used to depict the llamas
ritual in nature, probably built to extol the sovereign’s may be associated with the great agricultural festivals
power and perpetuate his memory with his panaca at Cuzco, particularly the Capac Raimi in
after his death. The site’s position appears to have December and the Inti Raimi in June. The vertical
been chosen and planned with care, taking full advan- arrangement of the stones used to assemble the
tage of the landscape features such as the Apurimac mosaics of the terraces on the western slope evokes
63
Ñawpa Pacha: Journal of Andean Archaeology Volume 33, Number 1
the weft threads of a textile—maybe an unku, which 4. This figure, drawn from data collected by Bouysse
was the tunic generally used by members of the Cassagne (1987), Ziólkowski (1989), Zuidema
Inca nobility. As these rich fabrics were also used to (1989 [1980] and 2011), and Zuidema and Urton
(1976), is a theoretical scheme to clarify the approxi-
clothe the sacred objects (Classen 1993; Phipps mate dates of the major astronomical phenomena,
2005), one could propose that the artists who deco- such as the solstice and equinoxes, or the appearance
rated the terraces sought to assimilate the mountain or disappearance of the constellation of the Pleiades
of Choqek’iraw with a great regional wak’a. As dis- or the Llama, as they could be observed from the
cussed above, the hypothesis is bolstered by the Choqek’iraw site. It is, in any case, a reconstruction
calendrical information contained in ancient texti- of an Inca calendar. Only a detailed astronomical
study, during a year of the appearance of the sun
les—such as elite Wari-Tiwanaku tunics—or and other celestial bodies viewed from the site, will
modern textiles woven by present-day Andean com- provide an understanding of the role it would have
munities. In conclusion, I have outlined a number played.
of subjects for future research, but there can be scar- 5. As Ziólkowski (1989: 137 and note 28) notes, this
cely any doubt today that the site of Choqek’iraw was socioeconomic opposition between pastoralists and
an important regional wak’a, probably connected to farmers, animals, and plants, evokes the division of
the year into two opposite and complementary
the cycle of the seasons within which the llama was periods, according to the solstices and the passage
a motivating force. of the sun at the zenith and anti-zenith.
Schematically, the first period, which begins in
Acknowledgments February, is related to pastoralism, and the
payment of tribute in the form of craft production
This article is dedicated to the memory of Percy Paz by women; the second, which begins with the agri-
cultural cycle in August, is linked to agriculture.
Flores, who introduced me to the secrets of
This antagonism also refers to other, more-complex
Choqek’iraw. The author wishes to thank Timothy ideas, like the opposition between the spatial move-
Seller for translating into English the original ment of the sun, inside and outside of the earth,
French version, Sophie Desrosiers for her communi- which is also the movement of the constellation of
cations about textiles techniques, and Eric Taladoire the Llama already discussed above.
and Hervé Lecoq for reviewing the text.
64
Lecoq: Can the Inca site of Choqek’iraw be considered an agro-pastoral calendar?
65
Ñawpa Pacha: Journal of Andean Archaeology Volume 33, Number 1
66
Lecoq: Can the Inca site of Choqek’iraw be considered an agro-pastoral calendar?
67
Ñawpa Pacha: Journal of Andean Archaeology Volume 33, Number 1
etnoarqueológico de ruinas en las altas cumbres quechua du début du XVIIe siècle. Éditions
andinas. Cuaderno de Historia 3: 27–62. l’Harmattan, coll. “Ethnolinguistique
1985 Chavin and Tiahuanaco: a new look at two Amérindienne,” Paris.
Andean ceremonial complexes. Nacional Urton, Gary
Geographic Research 1(3): 395–422. 2003 [1997] La vida social de los números: Una ontología
2002 [1991] Machu Picchu. El centro sagrado. Instituto de los números y la filosofía de la aritmética
Machu Picchu, Lima. quechua, Vol. 2. Centro Bartolomé de las Casas,
Rowe, John H. Cusco.
1973 Standardization in Inca tapestry tunics. The 2006 [1986] En el cruce de rumbos de la tierra y el cielo.
Junius B. Bird Pre-Columbian Textile Conference. Centro Bartolomé de las Casas, Cuzco.
The Textile Museum, Washington, D.C. Valencia García, Zenovio
1978 Technical features of Inca tapestry tunics. Textile 2004 Pinturas rupestres de Negruyoc, Primero simpo-
Museum Journal 17: 5–28. sio nacional de Arte Rupestre, Cuzco
Saintenoy, Thibault [manuscrito].
2011 Choqek’iraw et la vallée de l’Apurimac: paysages et 2005 Informe proyecto catastro y delimitación
sociétés préhispaniques tardives. Thèse de arqueológica: implementación plan maestro
l’Université Paris 1, sous la direction de Choquequirao. Copesco, Cuzco.
J. F. Bouchard et P. Lecoq, Paris. Valencia García, Zenovio, Jorge Chávez Rodríguez, César
Salomon, Franck, and George L. Urioste Morante Ángeles, and Abdias Calsin Ríos
1991 The Huarochirí manuscript: a testament of ancient 2005 Investigación histórica del complejo arqueológico
and colonial Andean religion. University of Texas de Choquequira, Sector VIII, Andenes de las
Press, Austin. llamas. Ministerio de Comercio Exterior y
Samanez, Roberto Turismo Mincetur, Proyecto Plan Copesco
2006 Arquitectura de Choquequirao. Boletín de Lima Nacional, Cuzco.
28(146): 96–126. West, Terry
Samanez, Roberto, and Julinho Zapata 1979 Sufriendo nos vamos: from a subsistence to a market
1995 El conjunto arqueológico inka de Choquequirao. economy in an Aymará community of Bolivia.
Andes 1: 97–114. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Michigan,
1999 El centro ceremonial inka de Choquequirao. New School for Social Research, Ann Arbor.
Arkinka 46: 80–94. Wiener, Charles
Sartiges, Eugène (de Lavandais) 1983 [1880] Perú y Bolivia: relato de viaje. Instituto
1851 Voyage dans les républiques de l’Amérique du Francés de Estudios Andinos, col. Travaux de
Sud, écrit sous le pseudonyme de E. de l’Institut Français d’Études Andines 56.
Lavandais. Revue des Deux Mondes 21(10): Universidad Mayor San Marcos, Lima.
1019–1059. Williams, Verónica
Scanu, Marcelo 2008 Espacios conquistados y símbolos materiales del
1987 Santuarios de altura de los Andes. Revista del imperio inca en el norte de Argentina. In
Museo Nacional 48: 213–249. Lenguajes visuales de los incas, edited by Paola
Squier, Georges Gonzáles Carvajal and Tamara Bray, No.
1974 [1877] Un viaje por tierras incaícas. Crónica de 1848, pp. 47–70. BAR International Series,
una expedición arqueológica (1863–1865). Editorial Oxford.
Los Amigos del Libro, La Paz-Cochabamba. Zapata, Julinho
Stone-Miller, Rebecca 2005 Paysages, ancêtres et eau sacrée à Choquequirao.
1992 To weave for the sun: Andean textiles in the In Choqequirao. Le mystère des lamas du Soleil et
Museum of Fine Arts, Boston. Museum of Fine le culte aux Apus, pp. 93–124. Fond Contre-
Arts, Boston. valeur Pérou-France, Lima.
Taylor, Gérald Ziólkowski, Mariusz
1974–1976 Camay, camac et camasca dans le manu- 1989 El calendario metropolitano inca. In Time and
scrit quechua de Huarochiri. Journal de la calendars in the Inca empire, edited by Mariusz
Société des Américanistes 63: 231–244. S. Ziólkowski and Robert M. Sadowski, No.
Taylor, Gérald (editor) 479, pp. 129–166. BAR International Series,
1980 Rites et traditions de Huarochirí: manuscrit Oxford.
68
Lecoq: Can the Inca site of Choqek’iraw be considered an agro-pastoral calendar?
69