You are on page 1of 7

4.

CONCLUSIONS
and radiation patterns brings fractal Koch and becomes enticing among
It is possible to achieve two antenna operating bands from a researchers. The design of the log periodic fractal Koch antenna has
simple, single-layer FSS with single-sided printing. In this been elaborated in this article. The computer simulation technology
approach, both operating bands of the antenna are determined software has been used to analyze the performances of the designed
by the same FSS resonance mode. The concept is demonstrated antenna. This has been compared between simulation and measurement.
by designing, constructing, and testing a prototype antenna that The results show that this antenna has been reduced by up to 27% in
operates well in two bands 11.4 GHz and 13.4 GHz. It is based size from the normal log periodic planar dipole antenna. The
performance of the antenna has been compared in terms of return
on a slot array FSS resonating at 12.12 GHz. The measured
losses, bandwidths, and radiation patterns. V
C 2011 Wiley Periodicals,
directivities in the two bands are 16.8 dBi and 15.3 dBi, and the Inc. Microwave Opt Technol Lett 53:1869–1875, 2011; View this article
measured gains are 15.2 dBi and 13.1 dBi, respectively. This online at wileyonlinelibrary.com. DOI 10.1002/mop.26111
dual-band antenna concept relies on the change of the gradient
of the FSS refection phase versus frequency curve around the Key words: fractal antenna; log periodic antenna; wideband antenna;
FSS resonance frequency, from a small negative value to a large planar antenna
positive value. Any simple or complex FSS with this character,
which is readily obtained, can be used to design a dual-band
EBG resonator antenna this way. 1. INTRODUCTION
Antenna design has become one of the most promising fields in
wireless communication. Historically, when radiofrequency was
REFERENCES discussed simple antenna designs were used as a device to trans-
1. P. Feresidis and J.C. Vardaxoglou, High gain planar antenna using mit electrical energy or radio waves through the air in all direc-
optimized partially reflective surfaces, IEE Proc Microw Antennas tions. This innovative way of communication to replace wired
Propag 148 (2001), 345–350. technology to wireless technology was first introduced by Galileo
2. L. Leger, R. Granger, M. Thevenot, T. Monediere, and B. Jecko, Marconi when he successfully initiated the first wireless telegraph
Multifrequency dielectric EBG antenna, Microw Opt Tech Lett 40 transmission in 1895 [1]. Wireless technology has since expanded
(2004), 420–423. rapidly, not only for commercial but also for military purposes.
3. D.H. Lee, Y.J. Lee, J. Yeo, R. Mittra, and W.S. Park, Design of
In modern telecommunication systems, the requirement for
novel thin frequency selective surface superstrates for dual-band di-
antennas with wide bandwidth and smaller dimensions than con-
rectivity enhancement, IET Microw Antennas Propag 1 (2007),
248–254. ventional has become popular. Therefore, in recent years, sev-
4. E. Rodes, M. Diblanc, E. Arnaud, T. Monédière, and B. Jecko, eral fractal geometries have been introduced for antenna applica-
Dual-band EBG resonator antenna using a single-layer FSS, IEEE tions with varying degrees of success for improving antenna
Antennas Wireless Propag Lett 6 (2007), 368–371. characteristics [2, 3]. Some of these geometries have been par-
5. A. Pirhadi, M. Hakkak, F. Keshmiri, and R.K. Baee, Design of ticularly useful in reducing the size of the antenna, whereas
compact dual band high directive electromagnetic bandgap (EBG) other designs aim at incorporating multiband characteristics. A
resonator antenna using artificial magnetic conductor, IEEE Trans few works have been made in designing the fractal properties
Antenna Propag 55 (2007), 1682–1690. for the antennas [4, 5].
6. Y. Ge, K.P. Esselle, and Y. Hao, Design of low-profile high-gain
Several antenna configurations based on fractal geometries
EBG resonator antennas using a genetic algorithm, IEEE Antennas
have been reported in recent years [6, 7]. These are low profile
Wireless Propag Lett 6 (2007), 480–483.
7. Y. Ge, K.P. Esselle, and T.S. Bird, Designing a partially reflective antennas with moderate gain and can be made operative at mul-
surface with increasing reflection phase for wideband EBG resona- tiple frequency bands and are multifunctional. Fractal shape
tor antennas, IEEE Antennas and Propagation Society (AP-S) inter- antennas have already been proven to have unique characteris-
national symposium, North Charleston, SC, June 1–5, 2009. tics that, therefore, link to the geometrical properties of the frac-
8. Y. Ge, K.P. Esselle, and T.S. Bird, A method to design dual-band, tal. Fractals were first defined by Benoit Mandelbrot in 1975 as
high-directivity EBG resonator antennas using single-resonant, sin- a way of classifying structures whose dimensions were not
gle-layer partially reflective surfaces, Prog Electromagn Res C 13 whole numbers [8].
(2010), 245–257. There are several types that have been proved by other
researchers and some of these fractal types can be used to
V
C 2011 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
reduce the antenna size [9]. Some papers discuss size reduction
of space filling antenna using Hilbert curve technique compared
SECOND ITERATION FRACTAL KOCH with other methods, such as meander line and zig zag antenna
PLANAR LOG PERIODIC ANTENNA [10]. These configurations can reduce the antenna size further,
DESIGN especially at lower frequency bands. Moreover, Minkowski frac-
tal patch antenna also has been proven to reduce the antenna
M. K. A. Rahim, M. N. A. Karim, F. Zubir, O. Ayop, size by 47% as maintaining the same resonant frequency [11].
and N. A. Samsuri This reduction in size indirectly reduces the mutual coupling
Department of Radio Communication Engineering, Faculty of between each element for array configuration antenna [12, 13].
Electrical Engineering, Universiti Teknologi Malaysia, 81310 UTM
Skudai, Johor, Malaysia; Corresponding author: Koch curves are a good example of self-similar, space-filling
mkamal@fke.utm.my fractals, which have been used to develop wideband/multiband
and/or miniaturized antennas. The features of the Koch geome-
Received 19 October 2010 try can overcome some of the limitations of small antennas [14–
16]. Koch curves are also used in radio frequency identification
ABSTRACT: In this article, the design of log periodic fractal Koch (RFID) applications, ultra high frequency (UHF) bands, and
antenna using the second iteration has been developed for ultra high broadcasting applications [17–19]. The fractal antenna is also
frequency band applications. The ability to reduce the size as used in mobile handsets [20]. Fractal Koch geometry has been
maintaining the performances of the antenna such as input return loss chosen in this article due to its capabilities to reduce the size of

DOI 10.1002/mop MICROWAVE AND OPTICAL TECHNOLOGY LETTERS / Vol. 53, No. 8, August 2011 1869
Figure 1 0th and 2nd iteration Koch antennas

the elements by applying different numbers of iteration such as (l), width (w), and distance (d) of the antenna can be related to
0th and 2nd iteration to investigate the performances of the the scaling factor, s as shown in the Eq. (1) [21].
antennas, especially at the UHF band applications. These design
methodology of these antennas using a log periodic technique is ln wn dn
s¼ ¼ ¼ (1)
discussed and the detailed results of the proposed antenna are lnþ1 wnþ1 dnþ1
presented.
From this technique, the resonant frequencies of the antenna can
2. DESIGN CONSIDERATIONS be combined to obtain wider.
Table 1 shows the number of elements for designed anten-
The designs of 2nd iteration fractal Koch antenna are based on
nas 0th and 2nd iteration, which cover the DTV frequency
the log periodic concept, which has been described in many
range. As can be seen from Table 1, the longest element for
antenna books [21]. Computer simulation technology (CST)
the 0th iteration antenna is 138 mm and for the 2nd iteration
software has been used as a tool to analyze the performances of
with 45 degree of flare angle the length is reduced to 100
the antenna [22]. Thus, several factors must be considered in the
mm. This shows that by applying the fractal Koch technique,
design process such as operating frequency, bandwidth, gain,
the size of the antenna can be reduced. The parameters that
and polarization. These factors play an important role in the
influence size reduction for this type of antenna are angle of
design of the antenna. The antenna is designed to cover the fre-
flares and the number of iterations. The increment on both the
quency range from 0.48 to 0.84 GHz that can be operated as a
number of iterations and flare angles reduces the size of the
TV antenna. The 0th and 2nd iteration fractal Koch antenna for
antenna. However, there is a ‘‘cut off value’’ or limit for both
DTV application using a log periodic technique has been
of these parameters and it has some significant effect on the
designed, analyzed, and the performances are discussed in this
performance of the antenna, such as frequency shift and mu-
section. Figure 1 shows the schematic of the designed antennas
tual coupling effects among the elements.
for both 0th and 2nd iteration antennas.
Additionally, the length of the 0th iteration antenna is 280
The log periodic antenna was originally designed at the Uni-
mm, whereas for the 2nd iteration antenna the length is about
versity of Illinois in the USA in 1955. Antenna exists in a num-
204 mm. This shows that size reduction of the 2nd iteration
ber of forms. The most common is the log periodic dipole array.
antenna is about 27% with a 45-degree flare angle. The per-
This consists of a number of dipole elements. One of the most
centage of the size reduction for both iterations is shown in
important parameters in this design is the scaling factor, which
Table 2.
is closely related to the log periodic. Dimensions such as length

3. SIMULATION AND MEASUREMENT RESULTS


TABLE 1 Dimension of Fractal Koch Antenna To investigate the validity of the simulations both 0th and 2nd
Dimension of Fractal Koch Antenna (0th and 2nd iteration)
iteration, fractal Koch has been fabricated using Fire Retardant-
4 laminated board. This fabrication process has been done using
Length Element (ln) photolithography and wet etching technique. This feeding of the
Distance
mm antennas has been excited at the smaller elements to ensure that
Width Between
Number of 0th 2nd Element Element
Element Iteration Iteration (wn) (mm) (dn) (mm)
1 61.0 44 2.2 10.0 TABLE 2 Comparison of Size Reduction of UHF Second
2 71.5 51 2.8 12.5 Iteration Fractal Koch Antenna
3 84.5 61 3.0 16.6
Antenna Type Dimension (l  W  t) mm Size Reduction (%)
4 99.5 72 3.6 19.5
5 117.5 85 4.3 24.4 0th Iteration 280  160  1.6 –
6 138.5 100 5.0 30.5 2nd Iteration 204  160  1.6 27%

1870 MICROWAVE AND OPTICAL TECHNOLOGY LETTERS / Vol. 53, No. 8, August 2011 DOI 10.1002/mop
Figure 2 Fabricated antennas: (a) 0th iteration and (b) 2nd iteration

Figure 3 Simulated and measured input return loss for 0th and 2nd iteration fractal Koch antenna: (a) simulated and (b) measured.

Figure 4 Comparison between simulated and measured return loss UHF fractal Koch antennas: (a) 0th iteration and (b) 2nd iteration

DOI 10.1002/mop MICROWAVE AND OPTICAL TECHNOLOGY LETTERS / Vol. 53, No. 8, August 2011 1871
Figure 5 Simulated 3D radiation pattern for 0th iteration fractal Koch antenna at 0.7 GHz and 0.8 GHz

the antenna is radiated in end fire radiation as simulated. Figures 0.85 GHz, fl ¼ 0.44 GHz). The simulated bandwidth is wider
2(a) and 2(b) show the fabricated 0th and 2nd iteration antennas. than the measured bandwidth.
The measurement process for the input return loss, radiation pat- Comparisons for each simulated and measured input return
terns, and gain has been performed using Agilent network ana- loss results for both antennas are shown in Figure 4. As can be
lyzer (8720ES), spectrum analyzer, Hittite signal generator, and seen, the simulated and measured, for 0th iteration fractal Koch
antenna measurement system. The measurement results are antenna exhibit similar patterns. This also occurs at the 2nd iter-
shown in the next section. ation antenna where the measured data are similar to the simu-
lated results as shown in Figure 4(b). These correlations show
that the simulated result is sufficient enough for the analysis. It
3.1. Input Return Loss can also be seen that the simulator bring much benefits to the
Figure 3 shows the simulated and measured results for both the antenna designer because it helps him to analyze before pro-
0th and 2nd iteration fractal Koch antennas. The simulated ceeding to the fabrication process.
return losses for the 0th and the 2nd iterations are shown in Fig-
ure 3(a).The return loss for 0th iteration antenna resonates from
480 up to 840 MHz with respect to 10 dB. Also the return 3.2. Analysis of Radiation Patterns for Fractal Koch Antennas
loss for the 2nd iteration antenna gives good agreement with the The simulated 3D radiation patterns for 0th iteration and 2nd
0th iteration antenna. The simulated bandwidth for both anten- iteration fractal Koch antenna were conducted using CST simu-
nas is 79%. The simulated return loss of the 0th iteration lation tools and presented in Figures 5 and 6. These figures
antenna is shifted up to 8 dB but can still produce a good per- show that the radiation patterns for both design antennas radi-
formance because at this level only 15% of the power will be ated toward the smaller elements are indicated by the black
reflected back. In some cases, the return loss can be referred at color. Figures 5(a) and 5(b) show the strength of the radiated
6 dB, which means that 25% of the power will be reflected field at 0.7 GHz and 0.8 GHz for 0th iteration antenna,
back to the system. respectively.
Figure 3(b) shows the measured return loss for 0th and 2nd To plot the simulated and measured radiation patterns on the
iteration antennas. From the graph, the 2nd iteration antenna is same graph, both sets of data have been normalized. The radia-
slightly shifted to the upper frequency. However, the resonant tion patterns for the fabricated antennas have been measured in
frequency is still under the operating region. The calculated an anechoic chamber at two difference frequencies, 0.7 GHz
bandwidth from the measured return loss is around 67% (fh ¼ and 0.8 GHz for both E-plane and H-plane (co-polar and cross-

Figure 6 Simulated 3D radiation pattern for 2nd iteration fractal Koch antenna at 0.7 GHz and 0.8 GHz

1872 MICROWAVE AND OPTICAL TECHNOLOGY LETTERS / Vol. 53, No. 8, August 2011 DOI 10.1002/mop
Figure 7 Simulated and measured radiation patterns for 0th iteration fractal Koch antenna: (a) E-plane at 0.7 GHz, (b) H-plane at 0.7 GHz, (c) E-plane
at 0.8 GHz, and (d) H-plane at 0.8 GHz. [Color figure can be viewed in the online issue, which is available at wileyonlinelibrary.com]

polar). The comparison for simulated and measured radiations 0.7 GHz are shown in Figures 8(a) and 8(b). It is shown that the
patterns for both antennas are shown in Figures 7 and 8. The E- simulated and measured radiation patterns give a very similar
co and H-co for both simulated and measured patterns have pattern, but the measured E-co is bigger than the simulated. At
been plotted and give a similar pattern at 0.7 GHz, as depicted a frequency of 0.8 GHz, a similar pattern to the simulated result
in Figures 7(a) and 7(b). However, there is a small difference at is obtained. As a conclusion, the performances of the antennas
the lower part for the measured E-co. This may be due to the are comparable with those computed by simulation and the gain
inaccuracy of the measurement process or some reflection during of the antenna is between 4 and 6 dB.
the measurement due to the cable in the chamber itself. How-
ever, this is a normal situation in any measurement setup, and
the radiation pattern of the antennas is comparable with the 4. CONCLUSIONS
simulated result. Figures 7(c) and 7(d) show the comparison for The 0th and the 2nd iteration of the Koch fractal antennas have
E-co and H-co polar at frequency 0.8 GHz. As can be seen, been designed, simulated, fabricated, and the performances have
both graphs also exhibit similar patterns with the simulated been analyzed. Simulated results such as input return loss and
result. radiation patterns have been elaborated in this article. The
The comparison between simulated and measured radiation antenna gives similar patterns for measured results as compared
patterns for 2nd iteration antenna at 0.7 GHz and 0.8 GHz are with the simulated for input return loss and radiation patterns.
depicted in Figure 8. The E-co and H-co polar at a frequency of As a conclusion, the comparison between 0th and 2nd iteration

DOI 10.1002/mop MICROWAVE AND OPTICAL TECHNOLOGY LETTERS / Vol. 53, No. 8, August 2011 1873
Figure 8 Simulated and measured radiation patterns for 2nd iteration fractal Koch antenna: (a) E-plane at 0.7 GHz, (b) H-plane at 0.7 GHz, (c) E-
plane at 0.8 GHz, and (d) H-plane at 0.8 GHz. [Color figure can be viewed in the online issue, which is available at wileyonlinelibrary.com]

Koch fractal antenna shows that the antenna size reduces by 2. N. Cohen, Fractal antenna applications in wireless telecommunica-
27% in size with minimal degradation of the antenna’s perform- tions, In: Professional Program Proceedings of Electronics Indus-
ance and both designs show good agreements with simulated tries Forum of New England, IEEE, 1997, pp. 43–49.
and measured results. 3. D.H. Werner and S. Gangul, An overview of fractal antenna engi-
neering research, IEEE Antennas Propag Mag 45 (2003).
4. A. Kordzadeh and F.H. Kashani, A new reduced size microstrip
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS patch antenna with fractal shaped defects, Prog Electromagn Res B
11 (2009), 29–37.
The authors thank the Ministry of Science, Technology and Inno-
5. B. Mirzapour and H.R. Hassani, Size reduction and bandwidth
vation (MOSTI), the Research Management Centre (RMC), the Ra- enhancement of snowflake fractal antenna, IET Microwaves Anten-
dio Communication Engineering Department (RaCED), and the nas Propag (2008), 180–187.
Universiti Teknologi Malaysia (UTM) for the support of the 6. C. Puente-Baliarda, J. Romeu, R. Pous, J. Ramis, and A. Hijazo,
research works. Small but long Koch fractal monopole, Electron Lett 34 (1998),
9–10.
7. L.K. Kim, J.G. Yook, and H.K. Park, Fractal shape small size
REFERENCES microstrip patch antenna, Microwave Opt Technol Lett 34 (2002).
1. K.J. Vinoy, Fractal shape antenna elements for wide band and 8. J.P. Gianvittorio and Y. Rahmat-Samii, Fractal antenna: a novel
multi band wireless applications, PhD Thesis, The Pennsylvania antenna miniaturization technique, and applications, IEEE Antenna
State University, PA, August (2002). Propag Mag 44 (2002).

1874 MICROWAVE AND OPTICAL TECHNOLOGY LETTERS / Vol. 53, No. 8, August 2011 DOI 10.1002/mop
9. J. Gianvittorio, Fractal antenna: design, characterization, and appli- wireless channel. In general, deterministic propagation models
cation, Master Thesis, University of California, 2000. consider reflections from the surface of the building and diffrac-
10. K.J. Vinoy, K.A. Jose, V.K. Varadan, and V.V. Varadan, Hilbert tions from the edge as two major physical phenomenons to com-
curve fractal antenna: a small resonant antenna for VHF/UHF pute the field at the mobile station. High-frequency asymptotic
applications, Microwave Optical Technol Lett 29 (2001).
solution such as uniform theory of diffraction (UTD) [1] along
11. L.X. Zheng, X.X. Ming, L.S. Li, and Z. Xiang, Analysis of patch
antenna based on the Minkowski fractal, In: International Conference
with ray tracing is the most commonly used model to obtain
on Microwave and Milimeterwave Technology Proceeding, 2004. field prediction at the receiver (Rx).
12. C. Puente, J. Romeu, R. Bartoleme, and R. Pous, Fractal multiband In certain scenario, physical phenomenon like reflection and
antenna based on Sierpinski gasket, Electron Lett 32 (1996), 1–2. diffraction alone are not enough to accurately model the chan-
13. C. Puente-Baliarda, J. Romeu, R. Pous, and A. Cardama, On the nel. Earlier, extensive measurement in the area of microcellular
behavior of the Sierpinski multiband fractal antenna, IEEE Trans environment revealed that there is significant gap between field
Antenna Propag 46 (1998), 517–524. prediction and the measurement even though the model included
14. N. Cohen, Fractal antenna applications in wireless telecommunica- multiple reflections and diffractions [2, 3]. Additional measure-
tions, In: Professional Program Proceedings of Electronics Indus- ment on a high-resolution angle-of-arrival estimation showed
tries Forum of New England, 1997, pp. 43–49.
that there is a significant portion of energy that actually propa-
15. C. Puente-Baliarda, J. Romeu, R. Pous, J. Ramis, and A. Hijazo, Small
but long Koch Fractal monopole, Electron Lett 34 (1998), 9–10.
gates through the building [4]. The field propagating through the
16. P. Johnson, Fractal antenna design for RFID application, Mid-Swe- buildings can significantly contribute to the total field at the re-
den University, Department of Information Technology and Media, ceiver in the deep shadow regions where the rays propagating
Electronic Design Division, 2006. through reflections and diffractions are rather weak.
17. S.H. Zainud-Deen, H.A. Malhat, and K.H. Awadalla, Fractal A number of studies on propagation loss in the buildings are
antenna for passive UHF RFID, Prog Electromagn Res B 16 available in literature [5–7]. In [5], an empirical formulation is
(2009), 209–228. presented based on the measurement considering 10 medium
18. M.N.A. Karim, M.K.A. Rahim, and T. Masri, Fractal Koch dipole sized buildings. The results showed that penetration loss
antenna for UHF band application, Microwave Opt Technol Lett decreases with increase in the frequency. In [6], various meas-
51 (2009), 2612–2614.
urements were conducted under different scenario such as when
19. M.N.A. Karim, M.K.A. Rahim, H.A. Majid, M. Abu, O. Ayop, and
F. Zubir, Log periodic fractal Koch antenna for UHF band applica-
the receiver (Rx) is inside the building and the receiver is out-
tions, Prog Electromagn Res 100 (2010), 201–218. side the building and empirical formulations were presented for
20. N.A. Saidatul, A.A.H. Azremi, R.B. Ahmad, P.J. Soh, and F. those kinds of scenarios.
Malek, Multiband fractal planar inverted F antenna (F-PIFA) for In [7], a quasi 2D model is presented for propagation of ra-
mobile phone application, Prog Electromagn Res B 14 (2009), dio waves through buildings. Here, an empirical effective propa-
127–148. gation coefficient was proposed to take into account the scatter-
21. C.A. Balanis, Antenna theory: analysis and design, 2nd ed., Wiley, ing inside the building in the transmission model. The wall
New York, 1997. parameters such as permittivity and conductivity were assumed
22. CST GmbH–Computer Simulation Technology, Computer simula- to be 5 and 0, respectively. Good agreement between predictions
tion technology-workflow and solver overview, 1998–2007, CST
and measurements was obtained. Addition of scattering from
GmbH–Computer Simulation Technology, Wellesley Hills, MA.
trees gave better agreement between the measured and predicted
results. However, there remained considerable differences near
V
C 2011 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
street intersections. The mean and standard deviation error
between measurements and predictions were reported to be 2.1
AN ANALYTICAL CHARACTERIZATION OF dB and 5.9 dB, respectively.
TRANSMISSION THROUGH A BUILDING In this article, the urban scenario of Bern city [7] is reconsid-
FOR DETERMINISTIC PROPAGATION ered with a more analytical formulation compared with the ear-
MODELING lier empirical formulation using available data to predict path
loss in Rodtmatt St. Here, average values of wall width and
Sanjay Soni and Amitabha Bhattacharya wall permittivity as well as conductivity and building height are
Department of Electronics and Electrical Communication assumed to characterize the propagation through buildings as
Engineering, IIT Kharagpur, West Bengal, India; Corresponding
author: sanjoo_ksoni@yahoo.co.uk
well as rooftop diffraction. The mean and standard deviation
error between available measurements and present predictions
are 0.4 dB and 0.51 dB, respectively.
Received 26 October 2010

ABSTRACT: An accurate deterministic model for propagation through 2. PROPAGATION ENVIRONMENT


buildings is presented. The proposed model gives significant
improvement over earlier predicted results. The application of the
The scheme of the propagation environment considered in this
proposed model is considered for a single building scenario and urban work is shown in Figure 1. The figure shows the three-dimen-
microcellular scenario to demonstrate its accuracy. VC 2011 Wiley sional view of a building scenario where a receiver is located in
Periodicals, Inc. Microwave Opt Technol Lett 53:1875–1879, 2011; View the deep shadow of the building. Transmitter (Tx) is at the
this article online at wileyonlinelibrary.com. DOI 10.1002/mop.26152 height below the building height. Building material is assumed
to be lossy dielectric with finite conductivity and permittivity. In
Key words: radio propagation; transmission; microcellular scenario; this scenario, wave propagation from the transmitter to the re-
path loss; ray tracing ceiver is considered by different physical phenomenon such as
edge diffraction, transmission-through- building, rooftop diffrac-
1. INTRODUCTION tion, and scattering from a tree. Total field at the receiver ‘‘P’’
The accurate planning of the cellular network requires complete is given as coherent addition of diffracted, transmitted, rooftop-
knowledge of the propagation conditions and the losses in the diffracted, and tree-scattered ray components:

DOI 10.1002/mop MICROWAVE AND OPTICAL TECHNOLOGY LETTERS / Vol. 53, No. 8, August 2011 1875

You might also like