Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Microelectronics Reliability
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/microrel
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: We analyse vertical breakdown signatures in normally-off and normally-on AlGaN/GaN HEMTs on Si and
Received 28 May 2013 SiC substrate for power applications. The probability distribution function of the breakdown voltage VBD
Received in revised form 18 July 2013 values shows mostly a bimodal distribution that is characteristic for substrate/epitaxy type and bias
Accepted 25 July 2013
polarity. Different types of distribution functions are tested. The vertical breakdown is found to be a time
Available online 23 August 2013
dependent phenomenon and hypotheses for its initiation are discussed. Using backside infrared micros-
copy, we found that the breakdown occurs in localized spots, related to current filaments. Failure local-
isation under pulsed mode shows better spatial localisation compared to the DC conditions.
Ó 2013 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction have been determined [8]. The vertical leakage current mechanism
across the GaN buffer was recently attributed to trap-mediated
AlGaN/GaN HEMTs are promising candidates for power switch- transport [9,10] and the failure location was analysed from device
ing applications [1], but there are challenges to improve their reli- top side [10]. In this paper, we report the statistical measures of VB
ability [2,3]. For low cost mass production, it is desirable to grow data and localise the VB spots in normally-off and normally-on
the III-N epitaxial layers on large area silicon substrates with rea- AlGaN/GaN HEMTs on n-type SiC and Si substrates. The cumulative
sonable quality [4]. For safe system operation under power-off distribution function (CDF) of VBD values is determined as a
condition, normally-off transistor operation is usually requested function of device area, substrate and heteroepitaxy. An analogy
to reduce the requirements for gate driving circuitry. Normally- with statistics of time dependent dielectric breakdown (TDDB) in
off AlGaN/GaN HEMTs with p-doped GaN gate, fabricated on SiC thin gate oxides [11] and off-state degradation of the AlGaN barrier
substrates, have demonstrated a breakdown voltage of 600 V [5]. [12,13] is discussed. The position of VB paths is accurately obtained
It has been shown that the device breakdown voltage VBD of such by backside infrared (IR) microscopy under DC and pulsed condi-
power devices first linearly increases with the gate to drain dis- tions. The mechanisms leading to the initiation of VB are discussed.
tance LGD (i.e. lateral breakdown) and then becomes independent
of LGD and saturates [6,7]. In a floating substrate configuration, this 2. Experiments
saturation is caused by a vertical leakage current and vertical
breakdown (VB) through the GaN buffer, between the Ohmic con- The structures of the investigated devices are given in Fig. 1
tact and the substrate [6,7]. For sufficiently conductive substrates, and Table 1. Device A is a normally-on HEMT with threshold volt-
the saturation value of VBD is thus a sum of breakdown voltages be- age Vth 2.5 V (IDmax = 0.39 A/mm). Its structure is a Schottky-
tween the drain-and-substrate and substrate-and-source [6]. Fur- gate (Ir/Ti/Au) with a 25-nm-thick Al0.25Ga0.75N barrier, and a
thermore, a large spreading in VBD values has been found, which 2-lm-thick Al0.08Ga0.92N buffer grown on conductive Si substrate.
indicates that the VB path can be due to current filaments related The Ohmic contact is Ti/Al/Ni/Au/Ti/Pt. Device B is a normally-off
to extended defects [6,8]. Based on area scaling of statistically dis- device with Vth 0.5 V (IDmax = 0.35 A/mm). Its structure is a
tributed VB data, guidelines for optimal power device contact area p-GaN gate with 14-nm-thick Al0.23Ga0.77N barrier fabricated on
a 3.1-lm-thick GaN buffer grown on a conductive n-type SiC
substrate [5]. The Ohmic contact is Ti/Al/Mo/Au. Devices C and
⇑ Corresponding author. Tel.: +43 158801362 31; fax: +43 158801362 99. D are test structures with a 13-nm-thick Al0.23Ga0.77N barrier,
E-mail address: clement.fleury@tuwien.ac.at (C. Fleury). with and without a 3-nm-thick GaN cap layer, respectively, and
0026-2714/$ - see front matter Ó 2013 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.microrel.2013.07.117
C. Fleury et al. / Microelectronics Reliability 53 (2013) 1444–1449 1445
Table 1
Summary of the studied devices and main results.
Device A B C D
Substrate Si SiC, epi1 SiC, epi2 SiC, epi3
Normal operation On Off Off Off
Drain bias + + + +
VBD stat. distr. large structures Normal Weibull (or more complex)
No. of modes 1 1 1 2 3 3 3 2
Failure signatures on small HEMTs Channel area Drain + contact pad Drain + contact pad
1446 C. Fleury et al. / Microelectronics Reliability 53 (2013) 1444–1449
Fig. 4. CDF of VBD values for positive bias in linear scale (a) and in Weibull coordinates (b) in Dev. C, for the three diameter values. The blue and orange ellipses indicate the
intrinsic and extrinsic VB regions, respectively. (For interpretation of the references to colour in this figure legend, the reader is referred to the web version of this article.)
Fig. 5. IVs (a) and CDF of VBD values for positive bias in Weibull coordinates (b) in
Dev. B. Fig. 7. DC IV on silicon substrate (device A) in current-controlled mode (a) and
resulting damage from bottom (b) and top (c).
Acknowledgments
GaN-related extended defect where a large energy is deposited.
Even if the total current is limited in this mode, the current density This work was performed within EU Project HiPoSwitch (Grant
in the current filament can be large since, at the breakdown, the agreement no. 287602) and supported by EU.
device enters the region with a negative differential resistance
with a tendency to current filament formation [22,23]. The
filament can be pinned at the position of an extended defect. The References
second effect is that, as the voltage snaps back, a large charge from
[1] Ikeda N, Niiyama Y, Kambayashi H, Sato Y, Nomura T, Kato S, et al. GaN power
connecting coax cables is discharged to the device, which can also transistors on Si substrates for switching applications. In: Proc IEEE; 2010. p.
help creating a relatively large area defect in the metallisation, 1151.
similarly as in Ref. [10]. A TLP stress produces damage with a smal- [2] Meneghesso G, Verzellesi G, Danesin F, Rampazzo F, Zanon F, Tazzoli A, et al.
Reliability of GaN high-electron-mobility transistors: state of the art and
ler area, allowing localising the current path with micrometre perspectives. IEEE TDMR 2008;8:332.
accuracy. Since a TLP stress produces less severe damage [3] Würfl J, Bahat-Treidel E, Brunner F, Cho E, Hilt O, Ivo P, et al. Reliability issues
(Fig. 8b) than a DC stress (Fig. 7b and c), the damage it makes of GaN based high voltage power devices. Microelectron Reliab 2011;51:1710.
[4] Fontserè A, Pérez-Tomás A, Banu V, Godignon P, Millán J, De Vleeschouwer H,
can sometimes only be observed from the bottom. The curves 1
et al. A HfO2 based 800 V/300 °C Au-free AlGaN/GaN-on-Si HEMT technology.
and 2 in Fig. 8a show the transient voltage of a non-damaging In: Proc ISPSD; 2012. p. 37.
and a damaging pulse, respectively. The creation of the damage [5] Hilt O, Brunner F, Cho E, Knauer A, Bahat-Treidel E, Würfl J. Normally-off high-
is correlated with a transient voltage decrease during the TLP voltage p-GaN Gate GaN HFET with carbon-doped buffer. In: Proc ISPSD; 2011.
p. 347.
pulse, indicating the creation of a permanent low resistance path [6] Würfl J, Bahat-Treidel E, Brunner F, Cho M, Hilt O, Knauer A, et al. Device
(Fig. 8b). A VBD in pulsed operation is often higher than a VBD breakdown and dynamic effects in GaN power switching devices:
observed under DC conditions, which is consistent with the results dependencies on material properties and device design. ECS Trans
2012;50:211.
of Fig. 6b. Both the above-mentioned trap-related and self-heating [7] Visalli D, Van Hove M, Derluyn J, Cheng K, Degroote S, Leys M, et al. High
effects can be considered. The breakdown spot created by a TLP breakdown voltage in AlGaN/GaN/AlGaN double heterostructures grown on 4
stress can be enlarged furthermore by a prolonged operation in inch Si substrates. Phys Stat Solidi C 2009;6:S988.
[8] Zhytnytska R, Cho E, Bahat-Treidel E, Hilt O, Würfl J, Tränkle G. Voltage power
the DC mode (i.e. post-stress mode, Fig. 8c), being consistent with transistor design influence of metallic contact area on device breakdown.
the DC observations where the input energy and therefore the WOCSDICE 2011.
cumulated thermal damage is higher. [9] Zhou C, Jiang Q, Huang S, Chen K. Vertical leakage/breakdown mechanisms in
AlGaN/GaN-on-Si devices. IEEE EDL 2012;33:1132.
Finally, a possible role of the self-heating effect in initiating [10] Pérez-Tomás A, Fontserè A, Llobet J, Placidi M, Rennesson S, Baron N, et al.
permanent damage under the DC conditions was evaluated using Analysis of the AlGaN/GaN vertical bulk current on Si, sapphire, and free-
a finite element thermal simulation in cylindrical coordinates. An standing GaN substrates. J Appl Phys 2013;113:174501–174501-7.
[11] Degraeve R, Groeseneken G, Bellens R, Depas M, Maes HE. A consistent model
infinitesimally thin (i.e. a zero order, worst-case estimate) circular
for the thickness dependence of intrinsic breakdown in ultra-thin oxides.
heat source with a 1 lm radius located at the top of a 3 lm thick IEDM 1995:863.
GaN buffer was considered and the top metallisation and AlGaN [12] Marcon D, Kauerauf T, Medjdoub F, Das J, Van Hove M, Srivastava P, et al. A
layers were neglected. Adiabatic boundary conditions were set comprehensive reliability investigation of the voltage-, temperature- and
device geometry-dependence of the gate degradation on state-of-the-art GaN-
on lateral and top sides, and the bottom side of a 600 lm thick on-Si HEMTs. IEDM Tech Digest 2010:472.
SiC substrate was set as an ideal heat sink. A thermal boundary [13] Meneghini M, Stocco A, Bertin M, Marcon D, Chini A, Meneghesso G, et al.
resistance of 4 10 8 m2 K/W and temperature independent Time-dependent degradation of AlGaN/GaN high electron mobility transistors
under reverse bias. Appl Phys Lett 2012;100:033505.
thermal parameters of GaN and SiC were taken [24]. The results [14] Blaho M, Pogany D, Zullino L, Andreini A, Gornik E. Experimental and
indicate that for a typical power of 50 mW (i.e. 0.1 mA 500 V) simulation analysis of a BCD ESD protection element under the DC and TLP
the maximum temperature rise above room temperature can reach stress conditions. Microelectron Reliab 2002;42:1281.
[15] Amerasekera A, Duvvury C. ESD in silicon integrated
about 130 °C. This indicates that the thermal effects could acceler- circuits. Chichester: Wiley; 1995.
ate the VB in DC measurements, at least for the case where the [16] Vincent G, Chantre A, Bois D. Electric field effect on the thermal emission of
substrate leakage current reaches the value of 0.1 mA before the traps in semiconductor junctions. J Appl Phys 1979;50:5484–7.
[17] Degraeve R, Groeseneken G, Bellens R, Ogier J, Depas M, Roussel P, et al. New
breakdown. However, for better temperature estimation we will insights in the relation between electron trap generation and the statistical
need to know more exactly the lateral and vertical extent of the properties of oxide breakdown. IEEE TED 1998;45:904.
power dissipating region. [18] Meneghesso G, Meneghini M, Stocco A, Bisi D, de Santi C, Rossetto I, et al.
Degradation of AlGaN/GaN HEMT devices: role of reverse bias and hot electron
stress. Microelectron Eng 2013;109:257–61.
[19] Marko P, Meneghini M, Bychikhin S, Marcon D, Meneghesso G, Zanoni E, et al.
4. Conclusions Noise and electroluminescence analysis of stress-induced percolation paths in
AlGaN/GaN high electron mobility transistors. Microelectron Reliab
Our results suggest that the statistical analysis of VB data can 2012;52:2194–9.
[20] Makaram P, Jungwoo J, del Alamo JA, Palacios T, Thompson CV. Evolution of
give specific information on the VB mechanism and could be used structural defects associated with electrical degradation in AlGaN/GaN high
to characterise material quality and process technology. A time to electron mobility transistors. Appl Phys Lett 2010;96:233509.
C. Fleury et al. / Microelectronics Reliability 53 (2013) 1444–1449 1449
[21] Ťapajna M, Mishra UK, Kuball M. Importance of impurity diffusion for early [24] Manoi A, Pomeroy JW, Killat N, Kuball M. Benchmarking of thermal boundary
stage degradation in AlGaN/GaN high electron mobility transistors upon resistance in AlGaN/GaN HEMTs on SiC substrates: implications of the
electrical stress. Appl Phys Lett 2010;97:023503. nucleation layer microstructure. IEEE EDL 2010;31:1395.
[22] Pogany D, Johnsson D, Bychikhin S, Esmark K, Rodin P, Stecher M, et al. [25] Wu T-L, Marcon D, Zahid M, Van Hove M, Decoutere S, Groeseneken G.
Measuring holding voltage related to homogeneous current flow in wide ESD Comprehensive investigation of on-state stress on D-mode AlGaN/GaN MIS-
protection structures using multilevel TLP. IEEE Trans Electron Dev HEMTs. In: Proc int reliab phys symp; 2013.
2011;58(2):411–8. [26] Ostermaier C, Lagger P, Alomari M, Herfurth P, Maier D, Alexewicz A, et al.
[23] Kuzmík J, Pogany D, Gornik E, Javorka P, Kordoš P. Electrostatic discharge Reliability investigation of the degradation of the surface passivation of InAlN/
effects in AlGaN/GaN high-electron-mobility transistors. Appl Phys Lett GaN HEMTs using a dual gate structure. Microelectron Reliab 2012;52:1812–5.
2003;83(22):46554657.