You are on page 1of 52

Jose James Honors Bill Withers ★ Frozen Fish Design ★ Scott Gershin Q&A ★ Classic Track: Blondie’s “Denis”

October 2018 \\ mixonline.com \\ $6.99

>REVIEWED
HAFLER P3100 AMPLIFIER
LEAPWING AUDIO DYNONE V2

MUSIC PRODUCTION • LIVE SOUND • SOUND FOR PICTURE

SOUND, SOUND, SOUND


DAVE AMLEN, TONY DROOTIN AND QUALITY RECORDING—A PLAY IN THREE ACTS

AES 2018 PREVIEW


> NEW PRODUCTS, NEW TECHNOLOGIES
> GUIDE TO EDUCATION AT AES
10.18 Contents
Volume 42, Number 10
Photo by Cherry Chill Will

14
FEATURES MUSIC TECH
14 José James:
A Bill Withers Tribute, AES 2018 PREVIEW
a METAlliance Session
BY BARBARA SCHULTZ

16 Classic Track: 34 Review:


“Denis,” Blondie Hafler P3100
BY BARBARA Power Amplifier
SCHULTZ BY MICHAEL COOPER 40 New Products:
22 On the Cover AES 2018 Edition
18 News & Notes: 36 Review:
Sound on Sound Leapwing 44 The Mix Guide to
Capitol Honors
Studios: NYC Legacy Ron McMaster Audio Education at AES
Outside the City BY MATT HURWITZ DynOne
Version 2
BY MIKE LEVINE
BY BARRY
RUDOLPH

50 Back Page
Blog
BY MIKE LEVINE
AND
STEVE LA CERRA
DEPARTMENTS
26 Frozen Fish Design: 10 From the Editor
Two Consoles, 12 Current
One Surface 19 Tribute:
Aretha Franklin’s 49 Marketplace/Classifieds
BY JENNIFER WALDEN
Timeless, Amazing Grace
BY DAVID MCGEE On the Cover: Owner Dave Amlen and studio manager Tony Drootin at the Euphonix System 5
28 Scott Gershin: in Studio B of Sound on Sound Studios’ spacious new Mont clair, N.J., home.
The Art and Science 21 News & Notes: Photo: Adam Frumkin/AFK Visuals.
Studer Celebrates
of Interactive Audio 70th Anniversary
Mix, Volume 42, Number 10 (ISSN 0164-9957) is published monthly by Future US, Inc., 28 East 28th Street, 12th floor,
New York, NY 10016. Periodical Postage Paid at New York, NY, and at additional mailing offices. POSTMASTER: Send
address changes to Mix, PO Box 8518, Lowell, MA 01853. One-year (12 issues) subscription is $35. Canada is $40. All
BY TOM KENNY BY SARAH JONES other international is $50. Printed in the USA. Canadian Post Publications Mail agreement No. 40612608. Canada return
address: BleuChip International, P.O. Box 25542, London, ON N6C 6B2.

6 M I X | O C T O B E R 2 0 1 8 | mi x o n l i n e.co m
Vol.
Vol. 42
42 No.
No. 10
9 October 2018
September 2018
mixonline.com
mixonline.com
FOLLOW US
twitter.com/Mix_Magazine
facebook/MixMagazine

CONTENT
VP/Content Creation Anthony Savona
Content Director Tom Kenny, thomas.kenny@futurenet.com
Content Manager Katie Makal, katie.makal@futurenet.com
Technology Editor, Studio Mike Levine, techeditormike@gmail.com
Technology Editor, Live Steve La Cerra, stevelacerra@verizon.net
Senior Editor Barbara Schultz, barbara.schultz@futurenet.com
Sound Reinforcement Editor Steve La Cerra
Contributors: Strother Bullins, Eddie Ciletti, Michael Cooper,
Gary Eskow, Matt Hurwitz, Steve Jennings (photography),
Sarah Jones, Barry Rudolph
Production Manager Beatrice Weir
Managing Design Director Nicole Cobban
Design Director Walter Makarucha, Jr.

ADVERTISING SALES
VP/Market Expert, AV/Consumer
Electronics, Education & Pro Audio
Adam Goldstein, adam.goldstein@futurenet.com, 212-378-0465

SUBSCRIBER CUSTOMER SERVICE


To subscribe, change your address, or check on your current
account status, go to mixonline.com and click on About Us,
email futureplc@computerfulfillment.com, call 888-266-5828,
or write P.O. Box 8518, Lowell, MA 01853.

ARCHIVES
This magazine is available for research and retrieval of
select
select archived
archived articles
articles from
from leading
leading electronic
electronic database
database and
and search
search
services,
services, including
including ProQuest.
ProQuest. For
For microform
microform availability,
availability, contact
contact
National
National Archive
Archive Publishing
Publishing Company,
Company, 800-521-0600,
800-521-0600, oror search
search
the
the Serials
Serials in
in Microform
Microform listings
listings at
at napubco.com.
napubco.com. Back
Back issues
issues are
are
available. For more information, contact www.proquest.com
available. For more information, contact www.proquest.com

REPRINTS/PERMISSIONS
REPRINTS/PERMISSIONS
This
This magazine
magazine maymay not
not be
be reproduced
reproduced or
or quoted
quoted
in
in whole
whole oror in
in part
part by
by printed
printed or
or electronic
electronic means
means without
without
written
written permission
permission from
from Future
Future US,
US, Inc.
Inc. To
To obtain
obtain permissions,
permissions,
contact
contact Wright’s
Wright’s Media,
Media, 877-652-5295.
877-652-5295.

MANAGEMENT
MANAGEMENT
Managing
Managing Director/Senior
Director/Senior Vice
Vice President
President Christine
Christine Shaw
Shaw
Chief
Chief Revenue Officer
Revenue Officer Diane
Diane Giannini
Giannini
Chief Content Officer Joe Territo
Chief Content Officer Joe Territo
Chief
Chief Marketing
Marketing Officer
Officer Wendy
Wendy Lissau
Lissau
Head
Head of Production
of Production US
US && UK
UK Mark
Mark Constance
Constance

FUTURE
FUTURE US, US, INC.
INC.
28
28 East
East 28th
28th Street,
Street, 12th
12th Floor,
Floor, New
New York,
York, NY
NY 10016
10016

Keyboard Presents:
the best of the ’80s All contents
All contents ©Future
magazine may
©Future US,
may be
be used,
US, Inc.
Inc. or
used, stored,
or published
published under
stored, transmitted
transmitted or
under licence.
licence. All
or reproduced
reproduced in
All rights
rights reserved.
in any
any way
reserved. No
way without
without the
No part
part of
the prior
of this
this
prior written
written
The ArTisTs, insTrumenTs, magazine
permission of
permission of the
the publisher.
publisher. Future
Future Publishing
Publishing Limited
Limited (company
(company number
number 2008885)
2008885) is is

And Techniques of An erA


registered in
registered in England
England andand Wales.
Wales. Registered
Registered office:
office: Quay
Quay House,
House, The
The Ambury,
Ambury, Bath Bath BA1
BA1 1UA.
1UA.
All information
All information contained
contained in in this
this publication
publication isis for
for information
information only
only and
and is,
is, as
as far
far as
as we
we are
are

edited by Ernie Rideout, Stephen Fortner,


aware, correct
aware, correct at
at the
the time
time ofof going
going to
to press.
press. Future
Future cannot
cannot accept
accept any
any responsibility
responsibility forfor errors
errors or
or
inaccuracies in
inaccuracies in such
such information.
information. YouYou are
are advised
advised toto contact
contact manufacturers
manufacturers and and retailers
retailers
and Michael Gallant directly with
directly with regard
regard to
websites mentioned
mentioned in
to the
the price
in this
price of
of products/services
products/services referred
this publication
publication are
are not
not under
referred to
under our
to in
in this
our control.
this publication.
control. We
We are
publication. Apps
Apps andand
websites are not
not responsible
responsible forfor
BackBEat BookS their contents
their contents or
not affiliated
or any
affiliated in
any other
in any
any way
other changes
way with
changes or
with the
or updates
updates to
the companies
to them.
them. This
companies mentioned
This magazine
mentioned herein.
magazine is
herein.
is fully
fully independent
independent and and
not
No single decade revitalized the keyboard as a focal point If you
If you submit
submit material
material toto us,
us, you
you warrant
warrant that
that you
you own
own the
the material
material and/or
and/or have
have the
the necessary
necessary

as much as the 1980s. Now, the editors of keyboard rights/permissions to


rights/permissions
licence to
to publish
to supply
publish your
supply thethe material
your submission
material and
submission in
and you
in whole
whole or
you automatically
or in
automatically grant
in part
part in
in any/all
grant Future
any/all issues
Future and
issues and/or
and its
its licensees
and/or editions
licensees aa
editions ofof
licence
magazine have culled that era’s most significant articles publications,
channels and
in any format
and associated
published
associated products.
products. Any
worldwide
Any material
material you
and on
you submit
associated
submit is
is sent
websites,
publications, in any format published worldwide and on associated websites, social media
sent at
at your
your own
social
own risk
media
risk and,
and,
and combined them with a wealth of insight to create channels
although every
although every care
care is
is taken,
taken, neither
neither Future
Future nor
nor its
its employees,
employees, agents,
agents, subcontractors
subcontractors oror

this landmark book. Features 20 interviews with noted licensees shall


licensees shall be
unless otherwise
unless
be liable
liable for
otherwise stated,
for loss
stated, and
loss or
or damage.
and reserve
damage. We
reserve the
We assume
the right
right to
assume all
to edit,
all unsolicited
edit, amend,
unsolicited material
amend, adapt
adapt all
material is
is for
for publication
all submissions.
submissions.
publication

players and producers like Jimmy Jam & Terry Lewis,


Duran Duran’s Nick Rhodes, Depeche Mode’s Vince
Clarke, Peter Gabriel, and The Human League, as well as
such visionary pioneers as Herbie Hancock, Chick Corea,
and Frank Zappa.
00331932......................................... $19.95

ORDER TODAY! Future


Futureplc
plcisisa public company
a public company ChiefChief executive
executive Zillah
Zillah Byng-Thorne
Byng-Thorne
See your favorite retailer or call Music Dispatch at quoted
quotedon
onthethe London
LondonStock
Stock Non-executive
Non-executive chairmanPeter
chairman PeterAllen
Allen
Exchange
Exchange(symbol:
(symbol: FUTR)
FUTR) ChiefChief financial
financial officer
officer Penny
Penny Ladkin-Brand
Ladkin-Brand

1-800-637-2852 www.futureplc.com
www.futureplc.com Tel +44 (0)1225 442
Tel +44 (0)1225 442 244 244

www.musicdispatch.com

1018679-ThirdPgSQUAREISHAd.indd 1 10/17/11 2:24 PM

MIX502.masthead.indd
MIX_09_18_v5.indd 6 8 9/19/18 10:55
8/24/18 1:52 PM
AM
Current
From the Editor
What Makes a Brand?
I’ve said many times that the smartest thing that Mix co-founders David And then, over the past decade or two, the AES has had to face
Schwartz, Penny Riker Jacob and Bill Laski ever did was name it Mix. numerous challenges. The world changes. Recently, AES has responded
Back in 1977, when it debuted as a directory of Northern California in a great number of positive directions, from partnerships with NAMM
studios inside the much more popular BAM magazine, DB and Recording and NAB, to adding Live and Project Expos, to hosting regional events on
Engineer/Producer were flying high in pro audio. Mix was a simple 24-page VR/AR. The brand maintains. But you have to keep it fresh. AES has been
supplement of studio names, equipment and services in a regional music working at it, and it shows.
journal. Here in our pages, we have a tribute to Studer’s 70th anniversary. Last
The founders, I was told, named it Mix because out of all the possibilities year Criteria Studios (now Hit Factory Criteria) celebrated 60 years. This
being tossed around at the time, it fit most neatly as a logo on a T-shirt year Shure hit 93 years! That’s amazing. That’s a brand.
or baseball cap. Mix. It says exactly what it is: it’s about mixing. And of Then I walk down the aisles each year at AES, and each and every booth
course all the varied services and developments and tools and people and is a brand filled with a cast of characters, all of whom contribute to the
ideas that feed the mix. It just sounds like a brand. And it is. At its height, impression made on show-goers. The audio industry is loaded with solid
it was a 248-page monthly, occasionally jumping into the 300s, with lots names like API, SSL, Universal Audio, Avid, JBL, Meyer Sound, Neumann/
of ads and editorial across every audio market we thought fit the mission Telefunken, Lectrosonics, Yamaha, Genelec, ATC, Eventide, Manley, Grace
of providing access to the world of professional audio. Design, Focusrite, Bose ... I could go on and on. The point is, pro audio is
Now in Mix’s 41st year, my 30th as an editor, we are regularly at 52 pages relatively unique within the world of entertainment technology in that a
a month, occasionally jumping into the 60s. The world changes, and media high, high percentage of the industry is made up of identifiable and strong
and music both got hit hard in the rapid changeover to a web-mobile-social brands. Boutique manufacturer or multinational corporation, it doesn’t
world. People sometimes ask me if I miss the “good old days,” and of course matter. The majority have an established identity.
I do! But these are good days, too! The mission remains the same, and we Look around at the show, look at the names. There are newcomers
still reach out to audio professionals. The delivery, however, might be a that are building their brand and trusted friends who continue to evolve.
biweekly newsletter, a Facebook or Twitter post, or a Sound for Film Event There are precision, handmade electronics and subscriptions to software
at Sony Pictures Studios. The world may change, but brands are brands. updates. The world changes every day. And we can thank the passionate
In that way, I feel a sort of kinship with the AES as I look forward to people of pro audio—who really are the brands—for that.
heading out to New York City for the annual fall convention. When I
first joined Mix, one of the first organizations/clients/companies I was
introduced to was the Audio Engineering Society. It was a big show! Javits
was packed! The tape manufacturers hosted sometimes debauched boat
parties around the island! The TEC Awards on Saturday night remain one Tom Kenny
of the highlights of my career. Editor, Mix

10 M I X | O C T O B E R 2 0 1 8 | mi x o n l i n e.co m
Current // news & notes
Blue: 100% Cyan, 25% M

Panelists Announced for Sound Editing, Mixing Series


at Mix Presents Sound for Film & Television Event
Mix magazine and parent company Future U.S. have announced the sound within the animation field. Sponsored by MPSE.
editors, designers and mixers to appear on the popular expert panel series Moderator: Carolyn Giardina, The Hollywood Reporter
at Mix Presents Sound for Film & Television, to be held on host partner Panelists: Paul Ottoson, Geoffrey Rubay, Erik Aadahl, Tim Chau and
Sony Pictures Studios’ lot in Culver City, Calif., October 13, 2018. Eileen Horta
The Mix Panel Series, which is presented in cooperation with event
partners Motion Picture Sound Editors (MPSE) and Cinema Audio Society DIALOG MIXING: The Audio Pipeline
(CAS), and sponsor Westlake Pro have become the centerpiece of the event, More than ever, production sound mixers, editors and re-recording mixers
which began five years ago with an in-depth look at immersive audio. This must adapt their workflows to consider advances in technology. A panel
year’s panels include: of established production and post-production professionals explain how
they work today, and discuss the way it was and their predictions for the
SOUND EDITING FOR ANIMATION: Pre-Production Through the Final Mix future. Sponsored by CAS.
This panel will discuss how sound takes the leading role in the creation Moderator: Karol Urban, CAS
of an animated project, from the pre-records used to create the visual Panelists: Gary Bourgeois, Mathew Waters, Phil Palmer, Margit Pfeifer
animation of characters to the final soundtrack created completely from Previously it was announced that sound designer, technologist, musician
scratch to bring the visual story to life on screen. What are their workflows and all-around audio manipulator Scott Gershin will deliver the keynote
and creative thought processes? How do these processes and challenges address, which will focus on the art of storytelling on the big and small screen
vary from a typical live action project? We will hear from both feature and amid developments in VR, gaming, film sound and television expansion.
television sound supervisors and designers who have years of experience Registration for the fifth annual event is open at www.mixsoundforfilm.com.

Thomas Dolby to Deliver AES Keynote


The Audio Engineering Society (AES) has announced that Thomas Dolby “A big difference between
will deliver the keynote address during the opening ceremonies of the AES ‘real’ and ‘electronic’ sounds
New York 2018 convention, to be held October 17-20, 2018, at the Javits is that electronic sounds have
Center in New York City. zero awareness of each other,”
While most widely known for his work as a musician, producer, film says Dolby. “Sound bytes
score composer and filmmaker, Dolby has been an educator throughout blindly follow orders and fire
his career. In 2014, he was named Homewood Professor of the Arts at off [usually] as instructed by a
Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore, Md. During his 35-year career, human. Yet musicians playing ‘real’ instruments listen, resonate and respond
he has consulted and assisted on countless technological developments, to the music, the room, and to each other, in a matter of microseconds.
including LaserDiscs, computer games, interactive TV, virtual reality “In the hands of master arranger or programmer, this is not a problem,”
installations and location-based entertainment. he continues. “Many of the nuances of real music can be simulated quite
With the title “The Conscious Sound Byte,” Dolby’s AES keynote effectively as processor speed, bandwidth and resolution improve. But as
address will focus on next-generation sound technologies—in particular, entertainment becomes more interactive, with games and augmented reality
adaptive/nonlinear music and audio for games, VR/AR, “hearables” and and ‘wearable’ technologies, it is increasingly vital that electronic sounds and
other new media platforms. music learn an awareness of the context in which they are playing.”

Sugar Studios Goes Dolby Atmos


Sugar Studios has expanded from its fourth floor were first planning this expansion,” says Sugar Studios
headquarters in the historic Wiltern Theater Tower in principal Jijo Reed. “They were an integral partner
Los Angeles to add the ninth floor and entire 12th floor throughout the entire process. We couldn’t be happier
penthouse space, which now includes a 25-seat Dolby with the results.”
Atmos Mix Stage and 4K Color-DI Suite. The 800-square-foot Dolby Atmos Mix Stage is
Audio Intervisual Design helped develop the based around a Slate Digital Raven Z3C console
design/construction, acoustics, equipment selection, surface, Avid Pro Tools HDX workstations, a JBL 7
programming and overall management support. Series-based 7.1.4 monitoring system, and a 16x9-foot Sugar Studios’ 25-seat Dolby Atmos
“Jim Pace and AID started working with us when we screen with 2.39:1 motor mattes. Mix Stage and 4K Color-DI Theater
Photo by David Goggin

12 M I X | O C T O B E R 2 0 1 8 | mi x o n l i n e.co m
Music

Photo by Cherry Chill Will


“LEAN ON ME”
Students Have a Ringside Seat as José James Pays Tribute to Bill Withers
By Barbara Schultz

B
ack in 1985, a young engineer named Jim Crow South.” students, who would rotate through the rooms
Ed Cherney got the call to work on Bill Fast-forward to spring 2018: Now a great throughout two days to observe a variety of
Withers’ Watching Me Watching You. mentor for budding music engineers, Cherney recording or mixing sessions.
For Cherney, that was hundreds of records ago, was planning an educational event to be It takes connections and skill to make such
but the memories of hang time with the great conducted by METAlliance, the group he co- a complex venture happen. “I called my good
singer/songwriter, who turns 80 this year, have founded with top engineer/producers Frank friend Don Was and asked if he had a project that
stayed with him. Filipetti, George Massenburg, Al Schmitt, Elliot he wanted to track as an opportunity to educate
“I remember he was funny and smart and Scheiner and Chuck Ainlay. The engineers these kids, letting them see and experience what
he was kind to me,” Cherney says. “We ended would divide into singles and pairs, each taking a a real professional recording session is like,” says
up hanging out and laughing, and he’d tell me room in Capitol Studios and working with small Cherney, whose collaborations with Was go back
stories about what it was like growing up in the groups of attendees, including audio engineering to Bonnie Raitt’s multi-Grammy Award-winning

14 M I X | O C T O B E R 2 0 1 8 | mi x o n l i n e.co m
microphones I got by Sanken, the CU-51s,”
Cherney says. “I put one over the low hammers
and one over the high hammers and pushed the
faders up, and the piano just sang. That’s such a
beautiful piano.”
Cherney waxes a bit philosophical when asked
how he captured Pino Paladino’s awesome bass
sound: “We had just a little Ampeg B-15 cabinet
with him, and we plugged him in direct; there
was a touch of 1176, and that’s really it. The
sound comes out of his fingers. He’s got such a
beautiful, even touch.
“When I was first starting out, like these kids,
I couldn’t get a bass sound or a drum sound
to save my life,” Cherney adds. “I’d stay up all
Photo by David Goggin

night, plot and scheme what microphones I was


going to use and what signal processing, and
I couldn’t make stuff sound good at all. Then
Engineer Ed Cherney and producer Don Was in Capitol Studio B one day I was with Don doing a Bonnie Raitt
record and Jeff Porcaro came in, and I think I had
1989 masterpiece, Nick of Time. approach. I think we hit a really good balance.” one microphone up because I was just getting
As it turned out, Was, the producer and now Sessions for Lean on Me took place in Capitol sounds, prepping—a 57 about 10 feet away from
president of Blue Note Records, was about to Studio B, where Cherney captured the band live him—and it was the greatest drum track I’d ever
go into the studio with jazz/hip-hop artist José to Pro Tools HDX via the studio’s vintage Neve gotten. It had everything to do with the player,
James to make Lean on Me, a full album of Bill 8068 board, with about a dozen METAlliance as opposed to the gear.”
Withers covers. students in attendance. It’s an exceptional opportunity for the
“The concept for this album totally originated “José and his band were so good. You rarely students, especially, to sit down in front of the
with José,” Was explains. “Like a lot of vocalists, get an opportunity to see something like that control room glass, put on headphones, and
José loves to sing Bill’s songs. The melodies are with Don producing and with a halfway decent listen in while a powerful vocalist like James
beautiful and the lyrics roll off the tongue like engineer,” Cherney jokes. “I think with those sings live with the band. Cherney treated those
butter; they’re deeply soulful. José had been kids being there, it actually put everyone on vocals like keepers, because that’s how James
performing one or two of them live, and the their toes. They might have played a little better sang them.
audience would go crazy every night. However, because it was more of a performance with an “They have that Frank Sinatra U49
I think he found that younger audiences audience. microphone, and we used that with a touch
were becoming increasingly unaware of Bill’s “I got there early to set up,” Cherney of Fairchild compression and not much else,”
incredible musical legacy. So the idea comes continues. “The band showed up around noon, Cherney says. “When the tracking went down,
from a combination of wanting to do something but kids were there at 9, so I had them help set it was one of those things where the music was
to shine a light on the greatness of Bill Withers up the room and explained what I was doing: just filling the speakers and everybody was really
and the love of performing his songs.” why I put people in certain places, the kind knocked out.”
On unforgettable songs such as the title track, of microphones I was using. We also talked After two days in Capitol, additional recording
as well as “Ain’t No Sunshine,” “Use Me,” “Kissing generally about how to become a great music- was done by Pete Min, Todd Carder and Rouble
My Love,” “Just the Two of Us” and others, maker and a great recording engineer. How to Kapoor in L.A. and New York before Brian
the arrangements worked up by James and make a session go and make everyone feel good Bender mixed the album at The Motherbrain
the band—drummer Nate Smith, keyboardist about what they’re doing.” West (L.A.).
Kris Bowers, guitarist Brad Allen Williams, Among the recording techniques Cherney “Don and I started out together doing Bonnie
percussionist Lenny Castro and bass player Pino shared was a favorite drum-miking tip: “I like to Raitt’s Nick of Time record and we spent a good
Palladino—bring Withers’ songs into new focus. place a Sanken CO-100K about 6 feet in front of 15 years together every day, traveling the world,
“The challenge lay in remaining true to the drums and about 6 feet high,” he says. “It’s doing everybody from Bonnie to Bob Dylan to
Bill’s original instincts for the songs while still an ultrawide-band omni and I usually limit the Neil Diamond to Iggy Pop to the B-52s to the
recording something other than karaoke covers bejeezus out of it and just try to break it. Then Rolling Stones—it was the time of my life,” says
of the originals,” Was says. “I suggested that I’ll use just a little bit of that to give the drums Cherney, looking back. “So to work with him
José treat the compositions as if he wrote them more life.” now, with such wonderful, sensitive musicians—
and find his own way into interpreting the lyric Another critical element was the Steinway B it was a beautiful couple of days, and I hope
separate from Bill. Same with the musicians: “Nat King Cole piano” at Capitol—an essential that translates to the way people experience the
Respect Bill, but be creative and honest in your sound on the title track. “I used these new record.” n

mixonline.com | O C T O B E R 2 0 1 8 | M I X 15
Classic Tracks
“DENIS”
Blondie
By Barbara Schultz

“F
rom the minute they started playing, I was thinking, ‘I know this song,’” recalls engineer/ Freeman points out that the suspended,
producer Rob Freeman. He was behind the board at Plaza Sound Studios for Richard room-within-a-room studio design no doubt
Gottehrer’s production of the first two albums by then-up-and-coming band Blondie. contributed to the high cost of building the
facility, which, as noted, shared walls and
The track he’s referring to is “Denis,” or Toscanini and his orchestra, and was later used halls with Radio City. “The entire sixth floor
“Denise,” a Neil Levenson-penned song that had as a broadcast studio,” the engineer explains. “It was suspended on cork and steel springs,” he
been a Top 10 hit for doo-wop group Randy & cost over half a million dollars—a ton of money says. “The Rockettes rehearsed up there, and
The Rainbows in 1963 before Blondie covered it. back then—to build that huge, orchestral room their hundreds of feet dancing would make
Before the melody was even apparent, Freeman with its wonderful, nicely controlled acoustics. a thunderous sound. For that reason, they
recognized a key element of the arrangement Plaza was quite unique! acoustically isolated the sixth floor from the
that the two versions share: that strumming, “Plaza Sound had a certain vibe,” Freeman rest of the building.”
drum-rolling intro that owes much to Buddy continues. “Even just getting up to the studio By the time Blondie began recording their first
Holly’s “Peggy Sue.” was an interesting experience. The studio was album at Plaza Sound, the studio was reasonably
Blondie included “Denis” on their album located on the sixth floor, above Radio City well-equipped for music projects, and that was
Plastic Letters, in the great punk tradition of Music Hall. You entered the building from either at least partly due to Freeman’s efforts. When
honoring the beauty and romance of early rock of the side streets, 50th or 51st Street. Then you he joined the Plaza Sound staff in 1974 as head
’n’ roll, even while offering up songs such as went up a special elevator, through unmarked engineer, the studio worked on industrial and
“Youth Nabbed as Sniper,” “Kidnapper” and “I’m doorways, and climbed a flight of stairs before commercial projects mainly via an 8-track Scully
on E.” winding through a labyrinth of hallways, all machine and a Spectrasonics console.
Plastic Letters was the second LP that the painted battleship gray. It was a weird, cloak- “Being a musician, I thought, ‘What can I
band made in Plaza Sound, New York City, and-daggerish route. It was part of Plaza’s charm, do to bring in the technology and the ability to
with Gottehrer and Freeman. Their eponymous and it felt special. Bands seemed to love how make records?’” Freeman recalls. “The studio
debut came in 1976, and Freeman remembers tucked away it was.” had plenty to offer: There was a 9-foot concert
those early sessions as a time of discovery for

Photo courtesy Rob Freeman


the musicians.
“Recording in a professional studio like Plaza
Sound was something new for them, and it
created a sense of joy and wonder,” Freeman
says. “It was like, ‘Holy cow, that’s us coming
out of the speakers! Listen to that!’ They were
excited about what they were doing, and they
incorporated all kinds of things they’d heard into
their music. It could have been Japanese anime
background music or a cornflake commercial
that influenced a song, or a keyboard or guitar
part. Their sources of influences were wide
open.”
Freeman points out that the studio itself,
with its illustrious history and grand space, was
another source of inspiration. “Plaza was built
in the ’30s by NBC as a rehearsal studio for
Rob Freeman at the API console in Plaza Sound

16 M I X | O C T O B E R 2 0 1 8 | mi x o n l i n e.co m
grand Steinway, a built-in Wurlitzer pipe organ
with three separate pipe chambers, orchestral

Photo by George A. Le Moine, courtesy Don Hunerberg


instruments such as tympanis, tubular chimes
and glockenspiel, as well as a wide array of
vintage microphones—many with their original
tube power supplies. The mic closet was a joy to
behold. The studio had all these great features
but just wasn’t doing the right kinds of projects.
So I kept chipping away, saying, ‘Let’s get some
proper equipment in here and make records!’”
During Freeman’s first two years, studio
owner Gregg Raffa did make many key changes,
including upgrading to a 16-track 3M Isoloop A view from the Plaza Sound control room into the live room.
tape machine and installing a 32-input API
console, the first in New York City. move it around. Debbie liked to sing in that well and sounded great. Her voice cut right
“Our console acted as a demo board, so to booth with no lights on. I had her sing into a through the rhythm tracks. She had that little
speak, for API, who wanted to showcase their [Neumann] tube U47. Singing with the band growl that would come in every now and then.”
new line of consoles in a functioning studio,” while they recorded basic tracks, Debbie might Harry also played with the lyrics of the
Freeman says. “Folks from API would come have assumed she was just providing scratch song. The band had changed their version from
around every so often, bringing people through vocals, but many of those performances became “Denise” to “Denis,” French for Dennis, so that
and saying, ‘Check out our beautiful board in finished vocals, with a only few tweaks later on.” Harry could sing “You’re my king” and “I’m so
this spectacular room.’” The rest of the musicians played together lucky ’cause I found a boy like you” in French,
The members of Blondie—singer Debbie in the half-studio, with amplifiers individually in one of the verses toward the end of the song.
Harry, guitarist Chris Stein, keyboardist Jimmy baffled. Infante’s bass was split between an amp “When we came to the point where we had the
Destri, drummer Clem Burke and new bass and a DI. Destri’s keyboards were also taken solid track and a great vocal, that’s when Richard
player Frank Infante (replacing Gary Valentine)— direct; everything else was miked up. would put on his final touches,” Freeman says.
were seasoned and rehearsed when they came in “The drum kit was set up fairly close to “It was often Richard’s layer of percussion that
to record their sophomore album, after playing the control room glass for added liveliness,” made a track sound truly finished. He brought
numerous gigs behind the first record and Freeman explains. “I believe we recorded drums in a huge bag of tambourines, shakers, and some
then spending several days in a rehearsal space on five tracks: bass drum blanketed with an AKG African instruments. That song also had some
finalizing the Plastic Letters arrangements with D12 placed inside, snare drum with a Sennheiser foot stomps added.
Gottehrer. Freeman remembers the sessions as 421 on top, hi-hat with a Neumann KM56 pencil “Those percussion sessions were the capper,
being fun but more businesslike than the first mic, and overheads left and right were two and always great for me, too, because I loved
album. The studio setup, however, was very Neumann U87s to capture the tom-toms and getting out of the control room to play in the
similar to what had been used on their debut. cymbals.” studio after setting things up,” he reminisces.
“If a band came in and we wanted the whole Infante’s bass mic was an Electro-Voice RE20, “I’d have my assistant hit the record button,
room to be open acoustically, we could do that,” and Burke’s guitars were captured by a Shure and I would become one of the musicians,
Freeman says. “But for more separation and SM57 and a Neumann U87. “The dynamic mic shaking a tambourine or shaker, clapping hands
control, I would often divide the room in half, would be placed right up close to the cone of the or stomping feet along with the band. That
and that’s what I did with Blondie. Plaza had a speaker, and the condenser mic, with a -10 dB percussion really made the record sound like a
number of large rolling baffles that were 8 or pad in, would be about 2 to 3 feet back,” Freeman hit. It gave it a timeless sound.”
9 feet tall and about 8 inches thick. Some had says. “As we were doing overdubs later, I would “Denis” was the first single that Blondie
windows. I’d roll them in to divide the 100-foot- move the U87 8 to 10 feet away from the amp released from Plastic Letters in 1978, and it was
long room literally in half, putting two baffles because we weren’t worried about drum leakage a massive hit in Europe: a Number 2 song from
tightly together, leaving a little space to walk at that point.” a Top 10 album in the UK, Number One in
through, then two more and two more, all the Freeman also employed the studio’s collection Belgium and The Netherlands, and a Top 20
way across the 65-foot width of the room.” of “now-vintage” outboard gear during tracking: song in several other countries.
Bisecting the space gave Freeman more Teletronix LA-2A tube compressor/limiters, “Denis” didn’t chart in the U.S.; Americans
control over the room acoustics, as did Harry’s Pultec tube EQs and more. “We had a wealth don’t always share Europeans’ love for old-
preference to sing live in a booth, in the room of Pultecs—three or four different types—and school rock ’n’ roll. But Plastic Letters was a Top
while the band tracked. several of those classic LA-2A compressors, and 100 album, and the video for “Denis,” with the
“There was a huge rolling vocal booth,” I just used them like crazy,” he recalls. exceptionally beautiful Harry dancing in what
Freeman recalls. “It had glass panels for isolation “‘Denis’ sounded like a hit from the minute looks like a sweater over a swim suit, captured
and a sound-locking door in the back; it was they started playing it,” Freeman says. “Debbie’s viewers’ attention and primed them for Blondie’s
really heavy and took at least two people to voice was bubbly, and she sang the song really biggest successes to come. n

mixonline.com | O C T O B E R 2 0 1 8 | M I X 17
Music // news & notes
CAPITOL STUDIOS HONORS RON McMASTER
Mastering Engineer Retires After 35 Years

Y
ou don’t hear much about retirement parties

Photos by Matt Hurwitz


these days, and it’s rare for someone to spend
a full career with a single company, but after 35
years at Capitol Mastering, veteran mastering engineer
Ron McMaster has hung up his lacquers. As a testament
to his talent and the respect he has garnered, the
appropriately named and much-loved disc cutter was
given a warm sendoff at the studio earlier in the summer,
attended by colleagues including engineers Al Schmitt,
Geoff Emerick and Niko Bolas, as well as fellow mastering
engineers Gavin Lurssen, Kevin Reeves and Peter Doell,
and former studio boss Michael Frondelli.
Lurssen, who noted that McMaster had cut his final
set of lacquers that very day—a vinyl reissue of Jackson
Browne’s Running on Empty—told of how he had come
to rely on the engineer after founding his own mastering
studio and needing discs cut for vinyl customers.
“Fifteen years ago we decided we needed to work out
a system,” Lurssen recalled. “There are two parts to the
process. First, we give Ron the highest possible resolution
Retired mastering engineer Ron McMaster, left,
of a file. The other part is the professional-grade digital- with one of his protégés, Ian Selchik
to-analog conversion process. Ron just has ‘secret sauce’
of unique analog equipment, which he knows how to use to give records a him, and he would patiently explain
kind of depth of field, where the sound is not overcooked in level.” everything he was doing.”
McMaster, who began cutting vinyl in 1979, said, “I’ve been working in a Adds Reeves, “I would watch
room where I’ve got some great Neve EQs and SoundTech EQs and a great him—he has a personal relationship
limiter/compressor that was built and designed here. And that’s really all I with every client. You could see how
need.” they trust him.”
Schmitt pointed out one other important piece of equipment: “It’s in his Filling his shoes at the studio will Legendary engineers Geoff Emerick,
ears—it’s in the way he hears. Nobody cuts vinyl better.” be Kevin Bartley, who will cut in left, and Al Schmitt honored their
friend and colleague Ron McMaster.
Reeves, a protégé of both McMaster and his late colleague, Wally McMaster’s former room, and Ian
Traugott, told Mix that upon his arrival at Capitol in 1986, “I already knew Selchik, who began as a tech 10 years ago, eventually learning to cut five years
who Ron was from reading the backs of records I loved. I was blessed to ago, after resuscitating Traugott’s Neumann VMS 66 cutting lathe, under
come up through the ‘Capitol farm club’ and be trained in this fine art by McMaster’s tutelage. “When the vinyl resurgence came, Ron was slammed,
Ron and Wally.” so I started taking on some of his work,” Selchik said.
Among the most important early lessons Reeves learned from his “People are just in awe of vinyl—it still amazes them,” McMaster told
mentors was to take himself out of the picture and let the music do the the audience, most humbly. “Whether it’s people who want a high-quality
talking. “When I came in, I was headstrong and thought I knew all about record and are willing to spend a lot of money and time on getting it just
this stuff, and would immediately start turning knobs. Ron and Wally would right, or other folks who just want to have a record made, just want to have
say, ‘No, take your hands off the controls and listen for a second. This isn’t their music on vinyl. But they’ll come in and take a ton of pictures with their
about you; this is about the music. Let’s talk about how to make the music cameras, watching me transfer their recording and go through my board and
great—or even if you need to touch it at all.’ That was a hard lesson for me cut them a lacquer, and then play it back. It still fascinates them, even though
to learn as a young engineer.” it’s a pretty simple process.”
All who spoke noted a common element: McMaster’s humble, gentlemanly And, about that name, Lurssen notes, “‘McMaster,’ of course, is perfect.
manner. “I’ve never seen him rattled,” said Schmitt. “I don’t think he ever gets Thankfully, his first name is Ron—not Skip.” n
mad. He’s such an easy guy to be around. I would recommend clients to —Matt Hurwitz

18 M I X | O C T O B E R 2 0 1 8 | mi x o n l i n e.co m
Music // a tribute
ARETHA’S TIMELESS, AMAZING GRACE
Remembering the Queen of Soul’s Finest Hour on Record
By David McGee

O
n the sunny morning of August 16,
word came early of Aretha Franklin’s
passing. Awakening to this news
broadcast on New York City’s classical station,
WQXR, followed by the sound of Aretha rolling
out her stunning rendition of Puccini’s “Nessun
dorma” live at the 40th Grammy Awards in New
York City on February 25, 1998—she filled in at
the last minute for an ailing Luciana Pavarotti,
who had already made the song his indelible
trademark, and did nothing less than save the
show, according to producer Ken Ehrlich—I
immediately sent a text to my son on the West
Coast, stating simply, “Aretha RIP.” A couple of
hours later, when he woke up, he sent a replay
text: “One of a kind. No comparison.”
Well, the lad was right, in a sense. But in
my return reply I pointed out a couple of valid
comparisons, with the proviso that you have
to go deep to find them, which in and of itself
speaks to the sweep of history Aretha brought to
every note she sang. In my estimation, only two
artists brook comparison to Aretha and, indeed,
together define Aretha.
The first would be Bessie Smith, the “Empress
of the Blues,” who sold millions of records over

Photo by Atlantic Records


the course of the 1920s and ’30s, was the highest
paid entertainer of her day, and became the
archetype for all big-voiced, swaggering, soulful
blues women to come.
Seventeen years Smith’s junior, Mahalia
Jackson, “The Queen of Gospel,” became a moral
force—and million-selling artist—after signing
with the Apollo label in 1947 and breaking out
with a fiercely committed reading of William the source of Aretha’s formidable artistry. To this mixture Aretha
Herbert Brewster’s “Move On Up a Little Higher” added much of her own. As www.criticofmusic.com points
to the tune of 8 million copies sold. out, “Franklin crafted incredible phrases by utilizing rhythmic
Bessie and Mahalia—the secular and sacred variations and motifs, dynamics, articulation, vocal colors and
sides of Aretha, both possessed of strong, drives to create original and brilliant phrases.”
authoritative contralto voices, Bessie being the With all due respect to the towering Atlantic sides of legend
friskier of the two, to put it lightly, and Mahalia (largely produced by Jerry Wexler, with the singer backed by the
commanding a vocal pulpit as if channeling legendary Swampers of Muscle Shoals and Atlantic Studios’ A-team
God’s voice—are the twin poles on which hang session players), Aretha’s finest hour, the moment captured that

mixonline.com | O C T O B E R 2 0 1 8 | M I X 19
Prints and Photographs Division, Library of Congress. Reproduction Number LC-USZ62-119977

Mahalia Jackson at the May 17, 1957, Prayer Pilgrimage of Freedom in Washington, D.C. Bessie Smith in a portrait from 1925

still brings me to my knees, is her 1972 gospel from the mainstream both in fact and in with the choir on “What a Friend We Have in
album, Amazing Grace, first issued as a double- influence, it seems nigh on a miracle. In 2018 Jesus”; or, with a scintillating assist from the Rev.
vinyl collection, recorded live at the New Temple Amazing Grace remains the best-selling release Cleveland and the animated choir, bending and
Missionary Baptist Church in Los Angeles. Not of Franklin’s career and in the history of live shaping “Precious Memories” into an extended,
since Elvis’ two 1960s gospel albums and Peace gospel albums. Verily, she did get over. sweat-inducing blues workout. This goes on and
in the Valley EP from 1957 had a truly towering So even today, 46 years later, I am surely not on through four sides of the original release, the
mainstream artist delivered such a profound alone in turning to it for spiritual sustenance. spirits of Bessie and Mahalia materializing in,
faith manifesto, both artists doing so at the To hear Aretha absolutely wrecking the house meshing with and being redefined in Aretha’s
height of their commercial powers. and wringing every last ounce of faith and earthy attack.
When Jerry Wexler signed Aretha following redemption for the entirety of a near-11-minute The double-vinyl release was in fact edited
her stint recording mostly pop and jazz standards fire-and-brimstone scalding of “Amazing from two nights’ worth of services finally made
for Columbia under the aegis of John Hammond, Grace” is to hear testifying of an exalted order, available unabridged on a splendidly remastered
he famously declared his intention to put her approached only by Mahalia. double-CD set in 1999, Amazing Grace: The
back in the church. Lo these many years later, And with the backing of the choir directed Complete Recordings, guaranteed to leave a
it still strikes me as a courageous move on by the Rev. James Cleveland, a gospel giant listener limp but spiritually reinvigorated.
Atlantic’s part to release Amazing Grace instead worthy of sharing this pulpit, a circle becomes Speaking to the assembled multitude, the
of another surefire smash soul album with complete. Once the child Aretha’s mentor, now Rev. C.L. Franklin, Aretha’s father, describes
multiple hit singles; however the decision was he’s spurring the choir to sing to the angels as the how moved he had been by what he was hearing,
made, it paid off to the tune of multi-million mature Aretha ups the emotional ante at every “because my daughter Aretha is just a stone
album sales and a Grammy Award in 1973 for turn, whether it be in de- and reconstructing singer!” Upon the raucous applause and shouted
Best Soul Gospel Performance. Inez Andrews’ “Mary Don’t You Weep”; finding a hallelujahs dying down, and without referencing
Back then, a gospel album’s success on this seam in Carole King’s “You’ve Got a Friend” and “Natural Woman,” “Respect,” “Chain of Fools,”
scale seemed impossible; in today’s more secular reimagining it as a hymn of faith; igniting the “A Brand New Me” or any of the monuments
society, when gospel has practically disappeared worshipers with an incendiary call-and-response his daughter had erected in popular culture to
that point, the Rev. Franklin reminds those on
Aretha ups the emotional ante at every turn, hand, “If you want to know the truth, [Aretha]
has never left the church!”
whether it be in de- and reconstructing Inez Andrews’ So herein she resides, right where she
“Mary Don’t You Weep”; finding a seam in Carole King’s belongs, never better, completely in command
“You’ve Got a Friend” and reimagining it as a hymn of faith; of her art, her soul soaring free and unfettered
Heavenward. Herein lies the truth. Amen and
igniting the worshipers with an incendiary call-and-response. Godspeed, great lady. n

20 M I X | O C T O B E R 2 0 1 8 | mi x o n l i n e.co m
Photo courtesy Studer
Music // news & notes
STUDER AT 70
From Tape Machines to Digital Consoles,
a Lifetime of Audio Innovation
By Sarah Jones
Willi Studer presided over his

S
tuder’s story is a testament to time and technology. From its recording, editing, track bouncing and namesake company for more
beginnings as a tape recorder manufacturer, the company built mixing with two J37s manually synched than four decades.
a reputation in consoles, and in the 1990s pivoted to digital in Abbey Road Studio Two. Soon the J37
technology. But back in 1931, Willi Studer was a Swiss teenager with an would be found in nearly all of England’s major studios.
aptitude for engineering, an entrepreneurial spirit and some big ideas. Studer recorders soon made it to the States. Recording and mastering
After graduating high school, Studer enrolled in an apprenticeship engineer Bob Olhsson, who spent much of the 1960s at Motown Records’
program, then abandoned it soon after to market his own radio receiver. Hitsville U.S.A., recalls that the facility owned four of the first C37
He went on to design audio test equipment, including high-tension machines in the country, and they played a major role in the recording
oscilloscopes, launching the Studer business in the basement of an old methods pioneered at the studio.
post office building near Zurich, with a staff of three. The company’s focus “The Studer C37s sounded incredible,” Olhsson says. “And their
shifted to tape recorders in 1948 when Studer was contracted to convert extended, very flat low-frequency response allowed us to accomplish
500 American-made products to European specifications. He quickly extremely precise half-speed lacquer mastering at unprecedented cutting
realized that he could produce a better machine, and two years later he levels for the amount of low-frequency information present.”
launched the Dynavox T-26. Studer continued to develop tape recorders for the next quarter-century.
In 1951, the Studer company split into two brands. Studer recorders, In 1970, the company released the A80 professional studio tape recorder,
initially marketed under the Dynavox name, found instant acceptance in which was based on a new modular design concept. It was followed by the
professional circles, while the Revox line offered the same core circuitry A800, the first microprocessor-controlled recorder, in 1978, then the A820
but added consumer-friendly features such as IR remote control. (One of in 1985. Studer’s first digital machines, the D820 and D820X, were released
Revox’s most successful products, the A77 recorder, was introduced in 1967 in 1989; the D827 DASH recorder followed in 1993.
and went on to sell more than 400,000 units.) By the late 1980s and early 1990s, Studer was sharpening its focus on
In 1952 Studer launched its first professional studio tape recorder, the digital technology, forming Studer Editech after buying Integrated Media
A27, which was the first Studer machine to feature a three-motor drive Systems, maker of the Dyaxis hard disk recording system. Other early
design. The A37 followed, then the B37, and later the half-inch, 2-track C37 Studer digital products included the SFC16 sampling frequency converter,
and its 1-inch, 4-track version, the J37, both of which went on to become DAD-16 disc cutting digital preview delay, the A725 CD player and the
recording studio standards. TLS4000 synchronizer.
Studer’s studio legacy was cemented when, in 1965, Abbey Road Studios In 1990 Willi Studer, set to retire, sold the company to the Swiss Motor
purchased four J37 machines. At that time the Beatles were entering a Columbus Group, and in 1994, Studer was acquired by Harman. (The
deeply experimental period in the studio, layering and editing sounds to Revox group was sold to private investors.)
create groundbreaking new textures. The J37 is probably best known for its By 1993, Studer had launched its first large-scale digital mixing console,
role in the Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band sessions, when producer the D940. In 1995 the Swiss National Broadcasting Company’s first all-
George Martin, engineer Geoff Emerick and the band spent four months digital broadcast system, based on the Studer D941 console and Studer
MADI router, went on air.
Photo courtesy Bob Olhsson

Studer continued to develop both analog and digital desks for broadcast
and live production, including the 928 analog console, the OnAir Series of
digital broadcast consoles that pioneered the Touch ’n’ Action user interface,
and the Vista Series, which features Vistonics “knobs in glass” technology. n

Left: Motown’s Hitsville U.S.A. had some of the first Studer C37 mono and stereo
1/4-inch machines in the United States. In the Mastering Room, an eight-track
mixing room, mono and stereo Studer C37s
flanked the console.
Inset: The Studer Vista 1 Black Edition, built for
broadcast, live sound and installation, combines
control surface with DSP, configurable I/O and
redundant power supplies.

Photo courtesy Studer

mixonline.com | O C T O B E R 2 0 1 8 | M I X 21
on the cover

Sound on
Sound Studios
The Legacy Lives on With a Bold Move to New Jersey
By Mike Levine

B
y 2016, Dave Amlen had finally had jackhammers leaking into his control room from OVER THE RIVER
it. He’d been a studio owner in New 7 a.m. to 11 p.m., six days a week, from the slow Amlen quickly discovered that the commercial
York since 1987, starting with Sound on demolition of a building that was just feet from real estate market had become so inflated that
Sound Recording, which later became Legacy the outer wall of his studio in Times Square. there was just no way to find an affordable
in partnership with Right Track Recording and “We went from roughly a $2-million-a-year location in New York City with enough space
ended up as MSR after that partnership was business down to about three-quarters of a to put his studio. But rather than giving up, he
dissolved. Amlen had certainly prospered during million dollars,” Amlen says of the effect of the began to ponder the idea of building a studio in
the boom years of the recording business in the construction noise. “It was a huge kick in the the New Jersey suburbs.
1990s and early 2000s; he also had witnessed the ass.” “I started to look at space and I realized that
decline from up close after 9/11, dropping further Feeling “battered and shell-shocked” when he a lot of my clients came from north and north-
after the 2008 financial meltdown. finally had to shutter MSR, Amlen sold off some central Jersey,” he says. “There were still clients
Still, Amlen managed to keep his business of his gear, put the rest in storage, and tried to on the Upper West Side of Manhattan, but when
viable until about 2013, when the devastating figure out what to do next. “I wasn’t ready to I talked to them informally, they told me, ‘Sure,
troika of the fall of the record business, the call it quits,” he says, “so I held onto some stuff I’ll come out to Jersey.’ I realized that the asking
maturity of the home studio and the skyrocketing that I might need for a smaller, smarter studio prices in Jersey were kind of like what they had
New York real estate market became too much. in the future, which I figured was going to be in been in New York many years ago.”
What finally did him in was the sound of Manhattan.” Amlen found a location in Montclair, N.J., a

22 M I X | O C T O B E R 2 0 1 8 | mi x o n l i n e.co m
tree-lined suburb with a population of about David Amlen, left, and Tony Drootin at the Euphonix S5 console in the Studio B control room. Photo by Neil Grabowski
40,000, just 15 miles west of Times Square and
easily accessible by car, train and bus. “We have “From Maplewood all the way up through Bridge. With real estate as expensive as it is in
lots of parking on premises,” Amlen explains. Englewood, and all the towns in between, New York, there are likely to be more to follow.
“We are two blocks from the Bay Street train Montclair being the most notable, you have this
station, which, unlike the other Montclair hotbed of creativity,” says Amlen. “So the idea of BUILD QUALITY
stations, is open on weekends. You can also take building a studio in Montclair didn’t scare me. Construction began at Sound on Sound’s
a bus from Port Authority that will literally drop All of the producers and engineers I talked to Montclair location in the spring of 2017, and by
you off at the corner here, on Grove Street. So said, ‘We’re really positive about the idea if you December the facility was complete. It contains
you can drive, you can train, you can bus it, you build a great facility outside of New York. You’re two main rooms: Studio A, which features a
can Uber and Lyft it.” going to have business.” 1,250-square-foot live room with four iso booths,
As suburbs go, Montclair has an unusually large The new Sound on Sound is not the only major a Yamaha Concert Grand, a Neve VR console in
population of creatives, including musicians, New York facility to move across the river to New the control room and much more. Studio B is a
songwriters, composers and engineers. It’s full Jersey. Mastering giant Sterling Sound recently 600-square-foot live room with two iso booths,
of New York City transplants, so it has a pretty left its Manhattan headquarters and relocated a Yamaha C7 Concert Grand and a Euphonix S5
sophisticated vibe and even its own highly much of its operation to Edgewater, which is on console. Both control rooms have Augspurger
regarded film festival. the Hudson River near the George Washington three-way main monitors, along with Genelec

Background: Studio A at Sound on Sound Studios in Montclair, N.J., features


a 1,250-square-foot live room with four iso booths. Photo by Ticha Vichitlakakran mixonline.com | O C T O B E R 2 0 1 8 | M I X 23
1031s, Yamaha NS-10s and a Genelec 1094 sub.
In his effort to make the new Sound on Sound
a leaner and meaner operation, Amlen opted
for a smaller outboard gear collection than he’d
had in his previous locations. He’s depending
more on plug-ins, fully stocking both studios,
with a special emphasis on the Universal Audio

Photo by Neil Grabowski


collection. Back when he was still in New York,
Amlen says, he became sold on UAD.
“I started listening to them, and I said, ‘Oh
my God. You don’t need racks of the stuff for
mixing,” he recalls. “And most people, when they The Studio A control room is centered around a Neve VR console.
were tracking, were being very purist: mic pre
into Pro Tools, and we’ll process it later.” and Paul Shaffer, which was a lot of fun to do. but isolated. There’s no place that I know of
With the Neve and Euphonix consoles both We’ve had a lot of local rappers. DMC lives in anywhere that can do that like we can.”
having excellent mic pre’s, Amlen brought over Wayne [a nearby town]. He’s a regular client of
just a small number of extra units, adding in ours. We’ve had Billy Drummond, Billy Hart— MOVING FORWARD
some essential outboard gear. He brought over you know, jazz legends. Jay Anderson. A lot of Despite all the great gear, well-designed rooms
eight of his Neve 1081s. local jazz projects. A lot of local rock projects. and highly experienced personnel, the idea
“I kept some other mic pre’s for flavor,” he says. We’re doing something with School of Rock of locating such a facility in the suburbs was
“I kept a full dynamics rack. I literally said I wanted in Montclair, we’re doing something with Jazz definitely a gamble, and a high-stakes one at
12 channels of mic pre’s, EQ and compression. House Kids in Montclair.” that. Would there be enough business to make
Different flavors, but 12 full channels of that in Drootin describes Sound on Sound as being it viable?
different permutations. But the console front- diverse in both its capabilities and its client base. The answer is, it’s too soon to tell. Amlen has
end mic pre’s are amazing in both rooms. I’ve “We designed it to be quite formidable as a live- found the relocation surprising in some ways. “I
engineered a couple of sessions every week since tracking facility,” he says. “Out here we have the really thought we were going to have a lot more
we’ve opened. Whether it was a single voice, a full luxury of having a larger space, and it sounds of our New York base, and I didn’t expect that
ensemble, dozens of singers, multi-instruments, great and looks great. Our clientele is diverse. the local scene would provide us with much
whatever it’s been, I’ve mostly relied on the mic We have a podcast this weekend with nine business,” Amlen says, “but the upshot is that it’s
pre’s on the console. Occasionally we’ll use the participants. We’re doing larger scripted podcast sort of been the reverse.”
1081s. The stuff sounds wonderful.” series. We did a kids series. We’re starting to see “We look at it as the train is just getting
more local podcast companies and individuals rolling out of the station,” says Drootin. “We
STAFFING UP who are doing it.” would like to see more. We’ve made a facility
One of the smartest additions Amlen made was Due in no small part to the experience of here that makes clients and artists in the New
hiring veteran New York studio manager Tony Amlen and Drootin, Sound on Sound has the Jersey area realize that we’ve brought a New York
Drootin, who came aboard while the facility look and feel of a big-city facility, from the gold commercial operation here, and they no longer
was being finished. Drootin, who has years of and platinum records on the wall to the large- have to go to the city. What we’re hoping to do
experience managing major New York facilities format consoles and Augspurger monitors in is convince more people in New York that we are
like Sony Studios and Unique Recording, brought the control rooms. When getting ready to leave, incredibly easy to get to. And that’s our challenge.
his considerable expertise to the project. you almost expect you’ll be walking out into Getting the New York business to realize that we
“Tony has always been among the very select, Midtown Manhattan. can be extremely competitive rate-wise; we are
highly regarded studio managers who actually “I carried over a lot of the things that made very close, and have capabilities that rival some of
know what they’re doing,” Amlen says. “The Sound on Sound a special facility and what made the facilities that still exist in Manhattan.”
clients love him, the studio ownership always MSR a special facility up to the end,” says Amlen. But Drootin thinks they made a smart bet that
loved him. So he’s a rare breed.” “The rooms here are just a little smaller than will pay off in the long term. “We look at it like
Drootin has been a key figure not only in the they were at MSR. We’re literally talking about we got in when the timing was right,” he says.
day-to-day studio operations, but in helping to 5 feet on a dimension, give or take. And they’re “Because, quite honestly, it’s going to become
bring in business. also linked together with 48 mic or line-level unmanageable to do business monetarily in
“We’ve had some great projects here,” Drootin tielines. We have two great sounding rooms that Manhattan, at least for recording facilities. You
says. “We’ve had a few from the city that actually can link together, and we actually have a project can’t continue getting your rent doubled while
were quite high-profile, including [Broadway later this month where we’re going to do that. your rates are level.” n
actress] Renee Fleming with Leslie Odom Jr. It’s a big contemporary jazz ensemble recording
from Hamilton and classical producer David where they really want to utilize strings in one Mike Levine, Mix technical editor-studio, is a
Frost. We just had the Hell’s Kitchen Funk room, horns in another, rhythm section here, composer, producer and multi-instrumentalist
Orchestra with Bill Warfield, Blue Lou [Marini] vocalists there. Everybody at the same time, from the New York City area.

24 M I X | O C T O B E R 2 0 1 8 | mi x o n l i n e.co m
Two Consoles, One Surface
Frozen Fish Design Integrates Avid S6, Neve DFC, Euphonix System 5 Surfaces
By Jennifer Walden

The Frozen Fish Design hybrid AMS Neve DFC2/Avid S6 console at Goldcrest Films, London

S
tudios tend to hold onto their large- box was already entrenched practice, and the the studio’s existing console. It was a temporary
format digital mixing consoles for a while functionality of the S6 improved that workflow. fix for what became a permanent staple in his
because upgrading a big-ticket item every Many mixers jumped on board, including Oscar- workflow. But stacking the two looked unsightly,
two years or so can be expensive. But facilities winning re-recording mixer Niv Adiri, who was and it wasn’t very ergonomic; it also proved hard
still need to keep pace with technology, whether one of the S6’s early adopters. He liked the to get at the console underneath. Like stacking
to improve workflow for mix engineers or to option of having a different control surface for a Lego on top of a Mega Blok, the two mixing
support emergent sound formats—or to simply different aspects of a mix. surfaces just didn’t fit together.
have tools that are a cut above the competition. “If you’re mixing effects, you might want to “If you still want to use the main surface,”
How can a studio stay current while still holding use an Avid S6, and if you’re mixing music, you Adiri laments, “then you have to put the S6 off
onto their boards? might want to use the AMS Neve DFC,” he says. to the side, and that means you end up mixing
When the Avid S6 came out in 2013, it offered “That’s what a lot of mixers do these days.” while looking sideways.”
re-recording mixers more comprehensive control When a studio didn’t have an S6, Adiri would Frozen Fish Design out of London, co-founded
over Pro Tools sessions. Keeping mixes in-the- bring in his own and simply park it on top of by Glenn Haddock and Alan Frost and essentially

Photos courtesy Frozen Fish Design

26 M I X | O C T O B E R 2 0 1 8 | mi x o n l i n e.co m
The Frozen Fish Design hybrid
AMS Neve DFC Gemini and Avid S6 console
Frozen Fish Design co-founders Alan Frost, left, and Glenn Haddock at Abbey Road Studios Mix Stage, London

unknown in the audio world, recognized the different controls, on one console desk.” Haddock on a console made entirely of buckets
problem and engineered a solution, dubbed The company’s first hybrid console, installed to house both Avid S6 and AMS Neve DFC
the Hybrid Integration System. In very simple at Twickenham Studios, was a hit and was soon Gemini components. According to Haddock,
terms, HIS combines the Avid S6 with consoles followed by Goldcrest Films and Lipsync Post in the challenge was making sure the support
such as the AMS Neve DFC Gemini and the London, and RH Factor, Skywalker Sound and frame underneath could handle the flexibility
Euphonix System 5, both popular in high-end 20th Century Fox Studios in the U.S. Adiri has of unplugging any or all of the buckets and
audio post-production, by placing the smaller mixed on Frozen Fish Design’s hybrid consoles swapping out more or fewer buckets of S6 and
S6 components into DFC or System 5–sized at several studios, including Pinewood Studios, DFC Gemini, all while keeping the look of a
buckets. where he mixed the films Annihilation and complete console.
“The DFC needs our HIS components to make Adrift, and at Halo Post in London for the film “Having the desk in a bucket style means we
the Avid S6 modules fit,” Haddock explains. “But Paddington. can move it all around to suit our clients’ tastes,”
for the Euphonix System 5, we had to completely “Halo installed the hybrid console specifically Campbell says. “The mixers will get in touch
remake the buckets. I’d say that is the core of for Paddington because we asked for it,” Adiri and tell us what bits of desk they want where,
this product, and it’s where our design and says. “Glenn [Haddock] did an amazing job of and who is sitting where, and what they’ll want
manufacture skills have come into play.” integrating the S6 into the DFC 1 at Halo Post.” within arm’s reach, whether it’s more S6 or more
Frozen Fish Design is not an audio company Frozen Fish Design recently installed a hybrid DFC. Then we slot it around accordingly. That
in the traditional sense, though it fits perfectly console at Wave Studios in Amsterdam—in one makes it flexible and easily adaptable to personal
into the modern recording industry paradigm of evening. preference, which hopefully makes the mixers
digital/analog integration. As Haddock explains, “Their studio was Euphonix System 5 on happy before they’ve even turned up.”
“We come from a much more bespoke world Thursday night, and by Friday morning we The custom design for Abbey Road
of design for branding, product launches, car had integrated a new Avid S6 into the basic incorporates sliding picture monitor rails on
shows, and even props for film and TV builds. chassis of the Euphonix,” Haddock says. “The the back of the console desk. Haddock notes
We design things from scratch, so we’re used technicians there were saying, ‘Great, we don’t that there was limited space at the back of
to this challenge of ‘I need this to do that,’ or ‘I have to throw this away. We don’t have to try the console where all of the cabling and slide
need to repurpose this to do something it wasn’t to resell it and lose money on it.’ This is a better mechanisms are located, “so we had to do a bit
originally designed for.’ We saw a deficiency in way to reuse and repurpose consoles, bringing of reworking there to make things fit,” he says.
this area of pro audio that no one was addressing, them right up to date. Studios can upgrade to The picture monitor rails will be retrofitted onto
this issue of having to put one console on top of the new equipment gradually. It can be more of other consoles at Abbey Road, including the
another in order to work with both consoles.” a thought-out process. They can integrate the Neve 88Rs in Studio 1 and Studio 2, and onto the
The pieces combine into a congruent console newer equipment into the older equipment, and SSL J-Series in Studio 3.
that looks as good as it feels. “We’re getting people that gives the equipment a longer life.” “At Abbey Road, we didn’t stop at HIS,”
to understand and appreciate the ergonomics Frozen Fish Design’s bucket solution offers Haddock adds. “We covered a range of
of a console,” he says. “It’s not only about the more than integration. It gives studios the ability accessories and furniture, all designed and
hardware; it’s how easy and comfortable it is to to reconfigure their consoles to suit any re- engineered to improve the workflow of the mix
work on. The ergonomics aren’t a last thought recording mixer’s preferences. The layout can environment.” In fact, they’ve designed custom
anymore.” literally be made-to-order. That’s a huge draw console furniture for studios across the world,
Adiri adds, “Frozen Fish Design helped us for high-end film mixers. including Soundsquare in Prague, Goldcrest
to look forward, literally, to look at the screen Simon Campbell, head of technical services Post in NYC and VSI Berlin.
directly in front of us by giving us the flexibility for Abbey Road Studios’ Mix Stage—a Dolby With the hybrid console challenge solved,
to move our preferred surface in front of us. Atmos Premier, DTS:X and IMAX audio Frozen Fish Design is setting its sights on another
They gave us the option to use different surfaces, accredited film mixing studio—worked with industry issue: how to mix while standing up. n

mixonline.com | O C T O B E R 2 0 1 8 | M I X 27
Scott Gershin and the
Meaning of Sound
Roots in Music, Career in Film, a Life of Interactive Storytelling
By Tom Kenny

Photos courtesy Scott Gershin


Scott Gershin in his newly revamped sound design/mix suite.

O
n October 13, at the fifth annual Mix Presents Sound for Film & Fable franchises. Gershin is equally at home in front of a roomful of game
Television event at Sony Pictures Studios, Scott Gershin will kick designers and implementers at Game Developers Conference as he is on an
the day off by delivering the Keynote Speech. His name might Oscar sound design panel at the Motion Picture Academy. He speaks the
not be on the nominee list for Best Sound Editing at the Oscars each year, language of sound, music and technology fluently.
but his sounds have appeared across hundreds of films, a few of them So when Mix went looking for someone well-respected with a foot in
nominees, since he entered the world of sound design in the early 1980s. tradition and both hands in the future, someone who could address an
He was a rock and roll musician out of Berklee College of Music with a audience of peers and offer compelling insights into the changing nature
deep understanding of the emerging MIDI standard, a great love of tone of workflow, the multi-release demands of modern media, the merging of
and an open, conceptual approach to storytelling. the big and small screens, and the coming of Virtual Reality/Augmented
Since then, few sound designers in the world can claim the variety and Reality, we called Scott Gershin.
types of A-list credits across as many mediums as Gershin. From films From his early days at the famed Soundelux, where his understanding
such as Pacific Rim, Hellboy 2, Night Crawler, Chronicles of Riddick, Team of the art and craft of sound design and sound supervision grew into
America, Shrek, Book of Life and American Beauty to major games such as full maturity, to his recent stint as head of the Interactive Group at
the Gears of War series, Epic Mickey, and Final Fantasy, the Resident Evil and Technicolor, and at all stops in between, Gershin’s curious mind and

28 M I X | O C T O B E R 2 0 1 8 | mi x o n l i n e.co m
obvious talents have kept him at the leading
edge of sound for picture. During our interviews
in mid-September he was finally able to talk
about his next venture, which has him thinking
worldwide and every bit as excited as he was
when he recorded and cut his first sound effects.
But first, about that Keynote Speech. We
asked Gershin for a few preliminary thoughts on
what he might like to say to a full house at the
Cary Grant Theater, what he’s discovering as he
bounces from Cubase to Pro Tools to the Wwise
console and Fmod game engine—and what it
means for storytellers, particularly sound story
tellers, in the coming years.

Mix: Let’s start with the brief-bio portion of the


interview, Scott, before moving into the future. Gershin recording group walla in a bull ring in Mexico for the movie Book of Life
Music provided your entrance into sound, I
understand? To me, designing sound for a project is like a cobblestone street in old England.” So with
I come from a music background, but it was tango between dialog, sound design/effects and backgrounds, which I love to create, we have
slightly different in that I realized early on music. In a music, sometimes it’s the sound of an audio’s version of an establishing shot.
that not only do I love notes and melody, but instrument, and sometimes it’s the melody that The next thing you have to do is glue reality
I love tone. I’ve always been fascinated by how stands out . The melody in sound design is how making sure dialog doesn’t just float against the
they got that sound of an orchestra. Early on, you decide to use, or not use, a sound within any music. Reality can come from many places, such
when people were listening to the Beatles, I was given scene. as from sound effects and Foley, to having a voice
listening to Yes, to Emerson Lake & Palmer. So, Here’s a good example: I supervised American and movement with the right amount of reverb
I was always attracted to music that was rich in Beauty, and when I interviewed for the job, the on it so that you buy they are in a room, not a set
tonal structure. director, Sam Mendes, looked at me, looked at my . It’s about the phonograph in the corner of the
Then when I first saw Star Wars, I thought, credits, looked at me again, a little perplexed and room. Is it scratchy? Is it new? All these kinds of
“Okay, I’ve now figured out what I want to do said, “I’m a little confused. You’re an interesting cues are part of the conversation, and they are
with my life. I either want to become a visual choice for me—everything you do is big, bold all tools that the sound supervisor, mixers and
effects artist, or I want to go into sound. The and loud. This movie is not that.” So I said, “Well, director can use to tell the story.
sound was so amazing. The two movies that set let me equate this to music. You can think of me I use sounds to create pace and timings.
me on my path were Star Wars, and Apocalypse as a heavy metal guitar player, a musician, and Once you understand the rhythmical arc of a
Now. When I heard the fan blades morph into the that’s what I’m known for. But I’m good at jazz, scene, you can work to start sculpting the sound
Helicopter while playing Ride of the Valkyries …. too. So when I looked at the script, it’s not about to extract emotion. Sound really is all about
I just went, “Oh yeah.” what I decide to put in, but what I decide not to emotion, about how you feel. At the end of the
put in. It’s got to be a quiet movie, about negative day, as a sound designer, supervisor or mixer, our
Those are two films that helped to redefine space. Its not about quantity, it’s about quality. job is to be an audio psychologist, to understand
how sound could work in film.. Like a fine wine, delicate… Every single sound in any given scene how these sounds will make
Absolutely. I have since learned that sound counts.” Ten minutes later while driving home an audience feel. Will you giggle, be sad, be
design is used in two ways. One: creating great from the interview, I got the gig. scared or feel triumphant?
creative sounds that open up new worlds of
possibilities, like the light saber in Star Wars, the Quiet can be a lot harder to mix than loud, I Is that fundamental approach the same
communication and language of R2D2, Darth understand. whether it’s a film or a game?
Vader’s ship-bys and all those amazing sounds Silence is the loudest sound I can use. In a Whether I’m doing a big screen, an interactive
that came out of that film. Then the other soundtrack and mix, it always comes down title, a game, VR or AR, or a theme park ride,
style, which is more Walter Murch, it’s not only to detail and making things easy to listen to. my job is to convey one of two things at any
the sounds you choose or design, but how you Just as a writer writes a script and a director of one time: the story and the experience. Some
decide to use them. The Valkyries coming in off photography captures a visual, the audio team things are much more story driven with regards
the helicopters. The fan blades becoming the has different tools to use at different times of to a beginning, a middle and an end, and some
helicopter. The accentuated footsteps of crossing a project. What do I mean? Well, in any film or projects are about the experience. “How would
a large room in Hudsucker Proxy. It wasn’t just script you have an establishing shot, a visual. it feel to fly a spaceship?” It’s all about fantasy,
about the individual sound, it was about how “Where are we? I see we’re in a room, but is about being someone else, about experiencing
each sound is used to help tell the story. that room in a modern city like NY or off a something else. I don’t care if you’re flying over

mixonline.com | O C T O B E R 2 0 1 8 | M I X 29
the Grand Canyon like a bird or if you are making distance, I could hear distant gun report. As an
believe you’re a soldier in an interstellar battle opponent gets closer, I’ll hear more perspective
fighting aliens. Whatever it is, it’s taking a person differences such as the thud of the gun shot,
away from their daily life, for the time that you then as the opponent gets closer, a high-end
have them, and have them experience something. crack. Then as it gets really close, I’ll start to hear
mechanisms and bullet ejects. Or if I run away,
Does that mean you’re presenting them with that scene will play totally different. The user is
essentially one version of reality? controlling perspective.
Gershin records airplane sounds
Our whole history has been ingesting our In games there are parameters and conditions. for Chronicles of Riddick.
entertainment as a voyeur, from the other side I’m telling the game engine that when you get
of the window, whether it’s the proscenium of to this distance, I want to trigger these sets services, and I look forward to being part of the
a theater or the glass window of a TV. We are of sounds and not these sounds. Then at this team that grows the L.A. market.
always on the other side looking in. We watch distance I want to hear these, but not these.
what’s in front of us. Etc. I’m having to build the complexity as if I’m I presume that means films, games, VR/AR and
Now there are other types of technologies, moving a listener anywhere within that sonic all future experiences?
which is more like what we used to do as space—at a distance we trigger a set of samples, I feel that VR was kind of exciting there for a
children, where we would watch the movie add acoustical attributes based on the distance, second, and now it’s gotten a little bit timid
and then go act it out on the playground. With perhaps apply EQ and compression, and as it as we wait for the technology to catch up.
games and VR, you no longer have to go to the gets closer add different sets of samples. When VR first came out it was overhyped and
playground. You can put on your goggles or play Different acoustical applications change rushed to market. people were only seeing
a game, and now you are participating. This is in real-time parameters based on the player’s cardboard with low-quality images that looked
trickling into all forms of entertainment, and perspective to any given object. These are things like their childhood TV. It can’t compete with
right now I think we are at a fork in the road we would do automatically on a mixing console, their new 4k OLED, HDR television in their
like never before in terms of how we ingest our but we’re now getting the computer to do it homes. Eventually the technology will catch up.
entertainment. We’ve always been a passive based on where our taste is, based on players The most exciting thing on the VR side for
participant, and now we have the ability to be an perspective. me right now is the theme park industry. That
active participant. Remember, in games and VR, there is no static is where you have goggles and mobile PC on
mix! And that is the tricky part, because the backpacks. These systems have haptics, where
What does that mean for a more traditional parameters of a mix have to start somewhere. you have things you can touch and feel. So
sound editor or mixer? What do they need to It can be based on distance, it can be based on they’re using fans for winds and even technology
know before diving in? height. There are so many things you can define, for smell. I did a project called Tree where we
In a film you have a fixed point from where the and then you have to have the tools to help you. manipulated your senses. The Void has great
directors and filmmakers have decided they’re Like we have Pro Tools for linear, there are tools titles where you can experience these things. You
going to put the camera. In a game and in VR, like Wwise, Fmod, and custom programs for can grab a weapon, open a drawer, walk across
that is now about, “Where does the user want to interactive entertainment. a plank between buildings. And you believe it
put the camera? Inside the car? From the back because the plank is wobbly. There are some
of the car? On the front hood?” The player has Let’s jump to the present-future. Before they great experiences out there, where we’re getting
choices. had shuttered the rooms at Technicolor this close to being on a holodeck. That’s very exciting.
So again, each form of entertainment will summer, you had lines on a new gig, doing what AR, in the meantime, has a lot of everyday
dictate how the experience will be experienced. you do and maintaining the variety. Can you tools that people are going to like, such as, “I
It’s not about what I want. It’s about what talk about it now? was thinking about buying a couch.” You could
sonic perspectives and opportunities there are. I have just joined a new company which will photograph the room and overlay the couch in
So I now have to look at sound from all these be announced shortly. I’ll be working out of that corner. The value of that is huge. Think of
positions. the same room as when I was with Technicolor education for sound engineers. I want to learn
In film, I build elements based on the with the same crew, just a different name on the Avid S6, I reach out for a button and an
perspective of the camera and a picture editor’s the door. It’s a fascinating company in that overlay is there and you say, “Ah! That’s what
cuts, but in a game or VR, there are no cuts and it is very flat and spread around the world, that button does.” Medical is very exciting.
no set perspective. with approximately 6,000 employees. It’s about Doctors can start with visuals in an overlay of
Here’s a good example of the difference. the clients and the content, not about giant where or how they might have to operate. We
When I go out to record guns, I use many, many, structures in a centralized place. We want to can start understanding that there are so many
many microphones based on perspective. In be where our clients are. L.A. is a new territory great opportunities for this technology.
film, the sequence of events will always be the for them. They come from the gaming world
same, it’s a linear format. However, in games, supplying localization, testing, technology and And they all need audio.
when someone is running at me with a gun. graphic design. Now they are expanding into And they all need good audio. And good stories
I have to design for all possibilities. So in the other forms of entertainment with additional and experiences. n

30 M I X | O C T O B E R 2 0 1 8 | mi x o n l i n e.co m
TechHAFLER P3100 STUDIO POWER AMPLIFIER
150 Watts Per Channel Yields Open Sound, Pinpoint Detail, Tight Lows
reviews

By Michael Cooper

F
or almost 20 years now, I’ve used
the discontinued Hafler P3000
amplifier to power my Yamaha
NS10M Studio and DAS Monitor-8 passive
nearfields, nervously watching suitable
replacement amps exit the market as active
monitors became de rigueur. So I was
thrilled when Radial Engineering bought
the dormant Hafler brand in 2014 and soon The P3100’s attractive front panel includes level trims, LED meters and indicators, and a sturdy power switch.
thereafter announced the new Hafler P3100.
The P3100 needn’t be placed in an iso or P3100 will automatically shut down.
TRANSCENDENT closet: 34 oversized heatsinks (identical to All connections are made on the P3100’s
The 2-channel P3100 uses a refined those used in the legacy P3000) flank the rear panel. Each channel provides a balanced
version of Hafler’s patented Trans•Nova amp’s sides and provide passive convection XLR line input, with a ground lift switch
(TRANSconductance Nodal Voltage cooling that, along with vented top and that disconnects Pin 1 when engaged; two
Amplifier) circuitry. Employing high-speed bottom chassis, eliminate the need for an RCA jacks for unbalanced line-level I/O (the
lateral MOSFETs at the amp’s outputs, this internal fan. Four sturdy feet—2 inches output runs parallel to the input and can be
design reduces the audio path—employing in diameter and a half-inch tall—provide used to send the source signal to another
only three gain stages—and removes the need ventilating clearance for the bottom chassis destination); a switch that selects which
for elaborate protection schemes that would with tabletop installation; they can be input to use; and gold-plated binding posts
otherwise degrade the amp’s pristine sound. removed to snugly rackmount the 2RU amp. for wiring the amp’s speaker outputs to your
The circuit’s latest iteration uses a toroidal Like the P3000, the P3100 weighs 23 pounds. monitors, accommodating any cable size up
transformer, resulting in tighter bass-band On the P3100’s beautiful front panel, to 6AWG. I was disappointed to find that the
reproduction and less potential for induced a sturdy, rocker-style soft-start (time- XLR/TRS combo jack shown on prototypes
noise from external electrical sources delayed) power switch protects monitors was replaced by a less-adaptable XLR.
compared to when using a conventional from damaging pops and thumps when Engaging a mono switch feeds both
E-lam transformer. According to Hafler’s powering up. Two continuously variable speaker outputs from the left channel,
design engineer, the amp’s unusually high rotary knobs let you independently adjust for bridged operation. Another switch
biasing assures very clean low-level sound— (from +14 to +29 dB) respective gain for allows 115V or 230V operation worldwide
especially important for mixing and mastering left and right channels, which is critical and features a security cover to prevent
work. The amp runs pure Class-A up to about in asymmetrical rooms that reinforce one accidental adjustment. Yet another switch,
5 watts and Class-AB at higher levels. monitor over another. this one suitably recessed, disables the LED
Like the P3000, the P3100 can drive a Metering has been greatly improved over level indicators on the front panel. An
pair of monitors with 150 watts RMS per the P3000, which would be expected after IEC power receptacle accepts the included
channel into 8 ohms or 200 watts RMS into 20 years: Multicolored ballistic LEDs (11 per 14-gauge (beefy!), grounded, 6-foot AC
4 ohms; alternatively, you can bridge the channel) show levels, idle status (powered cable. The P3100 has a three-year warranty.
amp’s two output channels for 400 watts up, but no signal present) and clipping at
RMS of mono power to drive a subwoofer the P3100’s outputs. Two other LEDs (legacy AUDIO PERFORMANCE
or—using two P3100s—two large monitors holdovers) light up if an electrical fault or The P3100’s full-power bandwidth is cited
having at least 8 ohms impedance. excessive heat is detected, in which case the to be 0.15 Hz to 300 kHz (+0/-3 dB). THD is

34 M I X | O C T O B E R 2 0 1 8 | mi x o n l i n e.com

MIX502.tech_section.indd 34 9/19/18 2:10 PM


PRODUCT SUMMARY
COMPANY: Hafler
PRODUCT: P3100
WEBSITE: www.hafler.com
PRICE: $2,000
PROS: Very open, balanced and natural sound.
Yields impressively tight lows and transient
detail. Passive cooling (no noisy fan). Multi-
segment level meters and fault indicators.
Each channel provides a balanced XLR line input, two RCA jacks for unbalanced line-level I/O, a switch that
CONS: No TRS inputs.
selects which input to use, and gold-plated binding posts.

less than 0.01 percent from 1 watt to 85 percent Quiet when idling, the P3100 provided kick drum and bass guitar tracks that don’t need
of rated power, and signal-to-noise is said to be my nearfields with plenty of clean power—in them. Transient reproduction was superb—
102 dBA—significant improvements over the fact, way more than was needed to listen at extremely detailed, yet not harsh—no doubt
legacy P3000’s specs. Other specs match those reasonable levels. In my recording and critical due to the P3100’s exceptional slew rate. Using
for the P3000: The slew rate—in practical terms, listening sessions, the P3100 subjectively had an amp like the P3100 that responds so quickly to
an indicator of how fast the amp will respond the same essential sound—open, natural and drum hits and string plucks, you’re less likely to
to transients—is an impressive 100 volts per unrestrained—as its discontinued predecessor, reach for transient shapers and high-frequency
microsecond. The damping factor (the ability of the P3000. The amp’s spectral balance sounded EQ boost when they’re not needed. The P3100’s
the amp to control unwanted motion in a speaker honest, with clear midrange reproduction and stereo imaging and depth of field were also both
cone at its resonant frequency, most important smooth highs that allowed many hours of excellent, allowing accurate pan adjustments
in the bass range) is also very impressive: 400 up listening without fatigue. and creating an enjoyable, immersive experience.
to 1 kHz, 200 between 1 and 10 kHz, and 18 from Low frequencies sounded very focused, a The P3100 is an all-around excellent studio
10 to 100 kHz. To get the best sonic performance hallmark of the Hafler Trans•Nova sound; power amp. If, like me, you’re a fan of Hafler
from your P3100, it is recommended that you let listening with the P3100, you likely won’t be Trans•Nova amps’ highly detailed sound and
it warm up for an hour before critical use. making misguided adjustments to tighten up tight low end, you’ll love the new P3100. n

Noah Scot Snyder


“The m108 is so universally useful and sonically
impeccable that I can hardly imagine an engineer or
studio who would not benefit from owning one.”
noahscotsnyder.com learn more at gracedesign.com

MIX502.tech_section.indd 35 9/19/18 2:10 PM


Tech // reviews

LEAPWING AUDIO DYNONE VERSION 2


Mastering-Level, Multiband Parallel Processor with 5-Band Linking
By Barry Rudolph

C
o-founded by Belgian mastering engineer Robin Reumers,
coder Jeroen Dreessen and technical engineer Emiliano
Caballero, Leapwing Audio has released DynOne version
2, a 64-bit multiband parallel processor mastering plug-in. It is the
company’s second plug-in, joining CenterOne Spatial. They both come
as VST, VST3, and AU and AAX Native versions for both PCs and Macs.
DynOne offers a fresh look at the multiband compression/
expansion process, with a choice of either Parallel or Normal
operation. In either mode, each of the five bands has its own gain
reduction/expansion meter and a fader for setting the level of that
band’s contribution to the finished sound. In addition, the five
band-faders link together, with the ability to link/unlink any one of
them individually. I found that this feature, along with being able
to solo any band, made it easy to build a particular tonal “shape.”
The five bands have custom-built crossover filters with non-
harmonically related frequencies centered at 160 Hz, 800 Hz, 4
kHz and 11 kHz. There is a choice between linear phase filters called
Ultra Quality (default) and Low Latency.
Ultra Quality adds a concomitant jump in CPU usage and
increased latency; it measured 4,096 samples at 44.1 kHz, using
256-samples hardware buffer size in Pro Tools HDX 2018.7. The Low
Latency mode had 65 samples latency and much less CPU usage
and was the mode I used primarily on individual tracks in a mix.
With larger track count mixes and many other plug-ins running,
I found myself using larger hardware buffer sizes than I normally bands range from 300 ms to 400 ms.
do—mostly because of my old and slow 2010 8-core Mac Pro tower. When adjusting these settings, the Crest Factor calculation is
considered; it would be great to see a visualization of CF in the GUI
MASTERING THE CONTROLS somehow. New to all this, I found that trying DynOne on individual
Each of the five bands has a separate drop-down control panel tracks in a mix was the best way to teach myself and understand
with its own set of adjustable compressor parameters; you can these controls. There are also 29 presets you can load and modify
type in numeric values as well. Threshold ranges from -60 dB to 0 to taste, and those told me a lot when getting started.
dB, and the continuous ratio slider goes from 20:1 down to 0.80:1. In the Global window you may select either Parallel (default)
(Compression ratios below 1:1 are actually upward expansion ratios.) or Normal operation, and there is a crossfader to set for using
There are also Attack and Release controls for each band—dual either RMS (default) or Peak
faders with upper and lower handles to set a range of optimized attack detection—or anywhere in PRODUCT SUMMARY
and release time settings based on that band’s Crest Factor calculation. between. The Channel Linking COMPANY: Leapwing Audio
Crest Factor is the ratio between peak and RMS values of audio signals, fader sets how much the five PRODUCT: DynOne Dynamics Plug-In v2
and each band in DynOne has its own Crest Factor calculator. bands’ gain reduction actions WEBSITE: www.leapwingaudio.com
For all five bands, attack time ranges from 0 ms to 800 ms, and are linked together. DynOne’s PRICE: $199 MSRP, 30-day trial available
release times range from 5 ms to 800 ms. Leapwing specifies 0 ms five stereo compressors can act PROS: Super clean and clear; precise.
attack time because the plug-in uses a (look-ahead) buffer. The independently in 100 percent CONS: CPU-intensive, GUI needs some work.
initialized default attack time and release times for each of the five Stereo Mode, or you can slide

36 M I X | O C T O B E R 2 0 1 8 | mi x o n l i n e.com

MIX502.tech_section.indd 36 9/19/18 2:10 PM


the Channel Linking fader toward 0 percent for multi-mono (default) linking.
The Weighting fader controls the sum of a weighted combination of the five frequency
bands on total gain reduction. Move the Weighting fader all the way left to Single Band and
none of the bands are weighted. The fader can go all the way right for All Bands contributing.
I left it at 50 percent (default), where all bands have equal weight.
I certainly found Linking and Weighting to be useful parameters when compressing
individual tracks, especially on vocals, kick drum, snares and bass—sources that do not
have the spectral complexity of a full music mix. For example, you can “squash” the low
frequencies of a kick drum and keep the rest of the sound, with the ambience and air intact.

IN STUDIO, IN ACTION
I installed the 64-bit DynOne AAX Native version in my Pro Tools HDX rig. When you first
insert DynOne, it defaults to Ultra Quality, which could be a nagging problem in big sessions
with CPU overloading. I would rather it default to Low Latency.
My first impression on the first track was that DynOne is extremely clean, clear and
transparent, without typical compressor/limiter coloration or artifacts.
The first track was a problematic lead vocal with crazy dynamics and sketchy enunciation.

I used the Low Latency mode. I liked to shift-click for soloing any band(s)—very handy,
although I could use a solo clear button, plus it is hard to see which bands are not in solo.
With some careful tweaking and constant comparison, I got my singer loud, clean and DynOne will do a complete reconstruction of a kick
clear but not dulled-out and squashed-sounding. I used Parallel mode but not Auto Gain. drum. Here, I wish the low frequencies had a switch to put
I also used expansion ratios in the HF and LF bands—an awesome new discovery for lead the 160 Hz band down an octave so the subsonic frequencies
vocals! Dynamically expanding the top and bottom frequencies of a vocal track is my could be better sculpted. But I was able to compress at 160
new secret weapon for getting a compact and controlled midrange for cutting big music Hz and then expand the upper frequencies. Auto Gain was
productions that become “fat” and airy at the same time. useful here, and I tried both Low Latency and Ultra Quality
and found no significant difference.
I then tried my hand at mastering using Ultra Quality
on a country song I had mixed, starting with Auto Gain
Precision Studio Design Featuring the off (but on later), and Normal mode (Parallel mode off)
TEC Award-Winning for my first trials. Generally, I used very low ratios and
auditioned each of the five bands in solo to see if I could
PhantomFocus™ MixRoom™Concept maximize their sound quality.
I was able to make it loud, super clean and clear, bright
and crystalline—even go overboard—yet I never heard
any ugly distortion. I used expansion on the 11 kHz band,
8:1 ratio on the MF band, Global detection was toward
Peak (76 percent) and Weighting was 28 percent toward
Single Band. In the hands of a skilled mastering engineer,
DynOne could be magical. I liked Band Auto Gain but
with all bands on or off.
I found good use for DynOne in cleanly shaping any
source. Thicken up direct guitars, remix the bottom
end of a drum loop in any way without distortion, or

straighten out a synth pad track to fit into your track.
My only beefs? The plug-in reads both input and
output levels in LUFS, but the values—along with the
frequency bands’ values—are too dark and hard to read.
(They are lighter blue over dark blue background!) The
band fader handles could be a little larger, and the band
meters don’t show gain reduction, only level. Finally,
there are no band mute buttons.
Still, DynOne is extremely clean and clear and, at first
shop.carltatzdesign.com The Upper Deck - Nashville, TN listen, the sound might appear too subtle in its control
and effect. Just remember, it is a precision tool, one that I
carl@carltatzdesign.com (615) 400-5479 www.carltatzdesign.com can highly recommend for both mastering and mixing. n


M I X | O C T O B E R 2 0 1 8 | m ixonline .c om



MIX502.tech_section.indd 38 9/19/18 2:10 PM
AES Preview // new products
RECORDING iZotope RX Standard, Elements
Audio Repair Tools Aimed at Musicians
The seventh generation of RX, a family
of audio repair and enhancement
Universal Audio Apollo X Series software, builds on the company’s
New Range of Thunderbolt 3 Rackmount Audio Interfaces strengths in post-production and adds
Universal Audio has been busy this year, with a host of new UAD RX 7 Standard and RX Elements, aimed
plug-ins announced and an expansion into live sound with the at solving musicians’ unique audio
UAD-2 Live Rack MADI Effects Processor. AES attendees can issues. RX 7 Standard includes: Repair
see the new Apollo X Series of Thunderbolt 3 rackmount audio Assistant (noise, clipping, clicks and more, with three suggestions
interfaces for Mac and Windows. Featuring all-new, elite-class A/D for quick fixes), Music Rebalance (performs source separation
and D/A conversion and HEXA Core UAD plug-in processing— by intelligently identifying vocals, bass, percussion and other
yielding 50 percent more DSP for running UAD Powered Plug-Ins instruments) and Remove/Isolate Vocals (for creating instrumental
in real time—the Apollo X range can run Unison mic preamp versions of songs by removing the vocal elements, or isolating the
models from Neve, Manley, API, Helios and SSL, and includes vocal to prepare a remix). RX Elements has been updated with a
selectable +24 dBu operating levels, and comprehensive Surround streamlined version of Repair Assistant, offering a single repair
Sound monitoring support for 5.1 and 7.1 formats. Each available suggestion with a choice of three intensity levels.
configuration—Apollo x6 (16x22, 2 preamps), Apollo x8 (18x24, 4
preamps), Apollo x8p (18x22, 8 preamps) and Apollo x16 (18x20, with Vienna Symphonic Library Smart Orchestra
16 channels of analog I/O via DB-25)—comes with “Realtime Analog A Full Range of Instruments at Your Fingertips
Classics Plus” UAD plug-ins: 610-B Tube Preamp and EQ, legacy The Vienna Symphonic Library has
LA-2A, 1176, and Fairchild compressors, Pultec EQs, Marshall Plexi released the Vienna Smart Orchestra,
Classic, Ampeg SVT-R Classic Bass Amp and more. a complete package that offers a large
orchestra and additional organic FX
Waves Abbey Road Chambers Plug-In textures, mapped over the entire range
Captures That Legendary EMI Echo of the keyboard. It comes with the new
Waves will no doubt have Vienna Synchron Player for playing all
plenty of eyes and ears on the main sections of the orchestra—
its Abbey Road Chambers strings, woodwinds, brass, mallets,
plug-in, which re-creates a drums and percussion—together or
defining part of the studios’ separately, with the possibility to add
legendary sonic signature: selected solo instruments and adjust the levels of each ensemble.
the echo chamber used A convolution reverb, featuring the acoustics of Synchron Stage
to create reverbs, delays Vienna, is integrated in the player’s multichannel mixer, resulting
and other unique spatial in balanced sound right out of the box. The package provides a large
effects on countless classic 140-piece orchestra with full dynamics, ready to play. Included FX
recordings by The Beatles and others.  Users get the controls to presets provide a source of inspiration elements for creating hybrid
the Studio Two echo chamber, complete with the original valve soundscapes and organic textures.
Neumann KM53 microphones and Altec 605 speaker. Also featured
is a complete re-creation of Abbey Road Studios’ original S.T.E.E.D. Neutrik NA2-IO-DLINE
(Send. Tape. Echo. Echo. Delay.) setup, a system designed to extend Line I/O Dante Interface Brings Analog to a Network
the chamber’s natural sonic palette by splitting the signal and Neutrik keeps putting out quality
creating a feedback loop from the studio’s REDD desk, through connections, year after year. At AES,
a dedicated tape delay, via the RS106 and RS127 filters, and then the company is featuring its NA2-
to the chamber and back.  A second set of filters is included as IO-DLINE Line I/O Dante Interface.
well. The plug-in also includes two other legendary spaces: Abbey A 2-in/2-out device, the NA2-IO-
Road’s famed “Mirror Room,” and the “Stone Room” from Olympic DLINE simultaneously converts
Studios, London. analog signals to Dante and Dante to analog. Genuine Neutrik

40 M I X | O C T O B E R 2 0 1 8 | mi x o n l i n e.co m
input and output XLRs, along with a locking etherCON connector, provide users to plug in a guitar or bass, and feature a 1/4-inch TRS insert point. You
professional-level connectivity. Four LED indicators provide network also get four stereo channels with mono XLR mic and left and right 1/4-inch
status as well as DANTE SYS and SYNC status. Optional mounting line inputs. All 16 microphone inputs sport a preamp gain control and an
brackets and rackmount panels are available for attaching the NA2-IO- overload (clip) indicator for the channel’s premium TASCAM microphone
DLINE to floors, walls, tables or racks. With the ability to transmit signals preamp. Each of the first 20 channels includes mute and PFL solo.
up to 100 meters via Cat 5e cable, the NA2-IO-DLINE functions with
nearly any network switch that provides Power over Ethernet or else a PoE Prism Sound SADiE 6 Software
injector. The NA2-IO-DLINE is AES67-compliant. Workflow Enhancements, 64-Bit Support for CEDAR Plugs
SADiE 6.1 software introduces a
TASCAM Model 24 Recorder/Mixer/Interface number of enhancements for a
SD Card, 100mm Faders for Studio or Live more seamless user experience
The versatile Model 24, equally at and project workflow. Available
home in studio or on stage, offers as a 64-bit version of SADiE 6
24 tracks of 24-bit, 48 kHz audio for native operation and also
capture (22 channels and a stereo for the SADiE BB2 Radio Editor
main mix) and 22 playback tracks system and LRX2 Flexible
via either USB 2.0 or to the unit’s Location Recorder, SADiE v6.1.13 delivers an update to the system’s core
onboard SD Card recorder. The SD so that all are fully compatible with Windows 10. The Mastering Suite
Card recorder offers quick, easy, and Sound Suite versions of SADiE v6.1.13 offer WAV Master, ASIO Direct
one-touch recording and includes transport controls, auto and manual punch Monitoring and native support for timecode. ASIO Direct Monitoring is
in/out, and overdub capability, with a built-in 22-channel mixer with 100mm available in the Sound Suite version, while native LTC support is offered
long-throw faders. The two monitor returns, subgroup bus, and stereo main in the Mastering, Post and Sound Suite versions. Other feature updates
bus also are equipped with dedicated 100mm faders. The Model 24 offers 12 include support for playback and recording to RF64 format and 64-bit
mono channels, each with XLR mic and 1/4-inch line inputs; 1/4-inch channel support for the Cedar Retouch, Declick, Decrackle, Dethump plug-ins. The
inputs 1 and 2 can be switched between line and instrument level, enabling new software is available as a free download to any existing SADiE 6 users.

Built on a Legacy,
Designed to Inspire
P3100 Power Amplifier
Delivering the mix to your ears in
the most musical way imaginable

The key component of professional recording studios for over 40 years www.hafler.com
Audio-Technica  Series to 15 Hz with output in excess of 130 dB SPL. The 7382 also works with
Third-Generation, True-Diversity UHF Wireless System GLM software to control bass management and solve issues of subwoofer
Audio-Technica will show its placement in unpredictable rooms.
third generation 5000 Series
Frequency-Agile True Diversity Sommer Cable SC-Micro Duo Aramid
UHF Wireless Systems, Shielded Twin-Pair Design for Hanging Stereo Mics
designed for use anywhere from With the advances in networking
touring to houses of worship. technologies, quality cables and
The new dual receiver includes connectors can make a huge difference
the company’s dual-compander in all kinds of situations, including at
circuitry that processes high the mic. Sommer Cable is introducing
and low frequencies separately, the new SC-Micro Duo Aramid shielded twin pair cable for safely hanging
with a tuning bandwidth of 148 MHz: 470-608 MHz and 653-663 MHz stereo microphones. Aramid consists of synthetic polymers, related to
(duplex gap). The full-rack chassis houses two independent receivers and nylon, that yield fibers of exceptional strength and thermal stability.
offers antenna power, frequency scan, IR sync functionality, a ground-lift Compared to steel ropes, the aramid fibers have no negative impact on
switch and a front-panel headphone jack. A second model adds Dante the cable’s audio transmission quality. The low-capacitance SC-Micro Duo
connectivity. Up to eight 5000 Series receivers can be cascaded to a Aramid is AES/EBU and DMX capable (110 ohms), and the concentrically
single pair of antennas. The 5000 Series offers body-pack and handheld braided OFC wires ensure an optimized, neutral transmission.
transmitters, both featuring rugged, ergonomic metal bodies, highly visible
dual-mode OLED screens and switchable RF power (2 mW/10 mW/50 mW). Soundtheory Gullfoss
Intelligent EQ Modeled on the Human Brain
Genelec Two-Way S6A, 2A Sub Soundtheory’s Gullfoss is an
High-SPL Smart Active Monitors Designed to Play Loud intelligent equalizer with a
Genelec will show its new high- sophisticated algorithm that has
SPL Smart Active Monitors— modeled what the human brain
the two-way S360A and the likes to hear. The user can set and
7382A subwoofer. The S360 adjust parameters to the incoming
SAM features a 10-inch signal, utilizing EQ changes in
high-efficiency woofer and tremendous number and frequency
1.7-inch titanium diaphragm (up to 100 times per second) and increase the perception of clarity,
compression tweeter, with space and dimension—and all that without latency, artifacts or phase
a short-term SPL capability destruction. The advanced computational auditory perception model
of 118 dB and a long-throw makes objective processing decisions to make mixes more consistent
capability that can provide reference-quality accuracy at greater than 33 feet. between different listening situations. Additionally, Gullfoss eliminates
The 7382 SAM Studio Subwoofer houses three custom-designed 15-inch annoying resonances and cancellations and retains dynamics and reduces
long-throw woofers, said to deliver precise low-frequency extension down the need for multiband compression.

SOUND REINFORCEMENT with Yamaha CL and QL Series digital mixing consoles.

Steinberg Nuendo Live 2 Lectrosonics SPDR


Multitrack Recording from Corporate to HOW to Festivals All-Day, Dual-Channel Recording at 48/96 kHz
A month before AES, Steinberg Lectrosonics, which made a big splash last year at AES
announced the immediate by announcing its entrance into the live sound market
availability of Nuendo Live 2, with the Duet M2 digital in-ear monitor system, is back
offering intuitive ease of use, rock- again with the SPDR, a stereo version of its acclaimed
solid stability and outstanding PDR micro digital recorder. Designed for use in ENG,
audio quality—32-bit floating- film and video production, as a backup recorder, or
point processing and up to 192 kHz for personal use, the SPDR records to a  microSDHC
resolution. A new meter view shows memory card in Broadcast Wave format (WAV with
32, 64, 96, 128 or 160 meters at once; the enhanced track view feature now iXML metadata) and 24-bit depth, at 48 kHz or 96 kHz
displays the meter bridge on the bottom of the screen, with up to 64 tracks. sample rates. (A 32 GB memory card allows almost 30 hours of recording
Users will no doubt appreciate the all-new Advanced Session Management, time at 48 kHz.) The unit can accept inputs from analog line level and AES
with auto-naming of recorded files, multiple folder creation, easy-to-use digital sources, or from lav microphones wired for standard Lectrosonics
marker track, auto-save and notepad. Nuendo Live seamlessly integrates 5-pin “servo bias” inputs. The SPDR has an external power input with

42 M I X | O C T O B E R 2 0 1 8 | mi x o n l i n e.co m
internal battery switchover (two AA batteries). A high-quality headphone microphones as well as compatible lavaliers. The original lightweight
output is provided for playback and monitoring. transmitter was designed for the top of the boom pole instead of the
bottom, and accepted only condenser, dynamic or ribbon microphones.
Sanken CS-M Shotgun Microphone The Phantom 2 supports 12V, 24V, 36V and 48V balanced microphones and
Small Profile Fits in the Tightest Locations 3.3V lavalier microphones at the same size, weight and power consumption
Sanken Microphones will be introducing of the previous model. The new unit touts 100 percent digital transmission
the new CS-M1 super cardioid shotgun that’s described as rivaling hardwired audio without compander, noise
microphone to AES attendees. From reducer, limiter or compressor distortion.
professional boom pole TV and film location
recording to DSLR camera-mounted Dan Dugan Sound Design Model E-2A
applications, the short-shotgun (4 inches New Automatic Microphone Mixing Controller
long, less than 2 ounces) CS-M1 delivers Dan Dugan Sound
pristine quality audio with sharp directivity. Its small body is unobtrusive, Design will show the
making it ideal for tight mic situations. It is rugged and dependable, with new Model E-2A, an
a wide range of applications where sound clarity and noise rejection are automatic microphone
critical requirements. Its unique components assure optimum resistance mixing controller with
to humidity and adverse temperature changes. analog and ADAT I/O. The E-2A incorporates 28 channels of processing
(12 balanced analog, 16 ADAT) and supports all Dugan algorithms: Speech
Zaxcom ZMT-Phantom 2 System, Music System and Gain Limiting. Channels may be grouped into
Re-Engineering of a Classic Wireless three independent automixers. A six-bus pre/post matrix mixer is also
Transmitter provided, with 56x6 capability. Four switched Ethernet ports are available
Zaxcom will be showing its re-engineered for control. The Model E-2A may be controlled remotely via the Dugan
ZMT3-Phantom wireless transmitter, Control Panel for Java (included) or the Dugan Control Panel for iPad
the ZMT3-Phantom 2. The new model (sold separately); tactile remote control is available via the Dugan Model K
supports both balanced phantom-powered Control Surface, also sold separately. ■

B80 BMB4
MOTHERSHIP
WITH WAVES SOUNDGRID
The NEW B80 BMB4 MOTHERSHIP with Waves SoundGrid features an BMB4 SOUNDGRID FEATURES:
Ethernet port for 64 I/O per MOTHERSHIP Chassis. SoundGrid is an • 1 SOUNDGRID ETHERNET PORT
audio-over-ethernet networking and processing technology developed • 2 BNC WORD CLOCK OUTPUTS
by Waves. SoundGrid provides extremely low-latency, high-channel • 1 BNC WORD CLOCK INPUT
count audio processing for studio recording, live sound, and other real- • 64 I/O AT 44.1k, 48k, 88.2k and 96k
time professional audio applications.

BURLAudio.com
AES Preview // education guide

THE MIX GUIDE TO EDUCATION AT AES


AES has always been a great place to meet your peers, see all the new gear and learn from the best in the business. This year is no different,
and the educational program is comprehensive and massive. To help you navigate your way, we’ve highlighted a few select panels that are
of interest either because of the topic or the presenters (both, in some cases).
If you want to see the whole, very large enchilada, you can see it online at www.aes.org/events/145/program.

Photos by johnstaleyphoto.com
ARCHIVING & RESTORATION:
AR—Archiving and Best Practices for Modern Production
Workflows
Wednesday, Oct. 17, 9:30 a.m. – 10:30 a.m.
Chair: Konrad Strauss, Indiana University (Bloomington, Ind.)
Panelists:
• Chuck Ainlay, METAlliance (Nashville, Tenn.)
• Maureen Droney, The Recording Academy (Los Angeles, Calif.)
• Michael Romanowski, Coast Mastering (Berkeley, Calif.);
The Tape Project
While technology has democratized music creation, the abundance
of recording formats and the rate at which technology evolves
present a dizzying array of choices to the artist. Additionally, many
artists are working outside the music industry pipeline, reaching
their audience directly via online portals. In effect, they are their
The legendary Leslie Ann Jones returns to AES
own curators, preserving their artistic output.
this year to share more of what she has learned.
The Producers and Engineers Wing of the Recording Academy
recently revised their “Recommendations for Delivery of Recorded to move close and even around audio sources with a high degree of
Music Projects” and released “Recommendations for High- plausibility to match the visuals. This workshop looks at recording
Resolution” music production. Additionally, they have been a leader strategies that enable 3DOF/3DOF+ and 6DOF for live music
in the development of the DDEX metadata standard that resulted performances.
in the creation of RIN. This panel will discuss technical best
practices and explore the many challenges artists and producers RECORDING & PRODUCTION:
face when creating and archiving music using modern technology. RP—Microphones—Can You Hear the Specs? A Master Class
Wednesday, Oct. 17, 10:45 a.m. – 12:15 p.m.
GAME AUDIO & XR: Moderator: Helmut Wittek, SCHOEPS (Karlsruhe, Germany)
GA—Practical Recording Techniques for Live Music Panelists:
Production in 6DOF VR • Jürgen Breitlow, Georg Neumann Berlin (Berlin, Germany);
Wednesday, Oct. 17, 10:15 a.m. – 11:30 a.m. Sennheiser Electronic (Wedemark, Germany)
Co-moderators: • Eddy Bøgh Brixen, EBB-consult (Smørum, Denmark); DPA
• Calum Armstrong, University of York (York, UK) Microphones (Allerød, Denmark)
• Gavin Kearney, University of York (York, UK) • David Josephson, Josephson Engineering (Santa Cruz, Calif.)
• David Rivas Méndez, University of York (York, UK) There are many microphones available to the audio engineer. It’s
Panelists: not always easy to compare them. Often the choice of the model
• Hashim Riaz, Abbey Road Studios (London, UK) is made on the basis of experience or perhaps just habits—or just
• Mirek Stiles, Abbey Road Studios (London, UK) because it looks nice. Nevertheless, there is valuable information
As virtual and augmented reality technologies move toward in the microphone specifications. This master class held by well-
systems that can deliver full six degrees of freedom (6DOF), it known microphone experts of leading microphone manufacturers
follows that good strategies must be employed to create effective demystifies the most important microphone specs and provides
6DOF audio capture. In a musical context, this means that if we attendees with up-to-date information on how these specs are
record an ensemble, then we must give the end user the potential obtained and can be interpreted. Furthermore, many practical

44 M I X | O C T O B E R 2 0 1 8 | mi x o n l i n e.co m
audio demonstrations will be given to help everyone to
understood how the numbers relate to the perceived
sound.

RECORDING & PRODUCTION:


RP2—Mastering Content for Loudness Specifications:
A Discussion of Best Practices, Pitfalls and Other
Practical Considerations for Engineers and Educators
Wednesday, Oct. 17, 2:30 p.m. – 3:30 p.m.
Presenters:
• Adam Ayan, Gateway Mastering Studios (Portland,
Maine)
• Adam Grover, Sterling Sound A participant a last year’s Live Sound panel.

• Bob Katz, Digital Domain Mastering (Orlando,


Fla.)
• Alex Kosiorek, Central Sound at Arizona PBS
(Phoenix, Ariz.)

E
• Jamie Tagg, Indiana University (Bloomington,

T I V
Ind.); Stagg Sound Services

A
Navigating today’s loudness standards can be confusing

V
to young engineers and others who don’t work with these

O
INN TIONS
requirements frequently. This panel of audio experts and
educators will address the justification for these standards,
what they mean for us, and how to optimize our workflow
to accommodate their requirements over a variety of

L U
commercial delivery formats. Particular attention will

SO
be paid to balancing problematic sound sources with
dialogue, the state-of-the-art in metering, formats and
delivery methods, and workflow considerations with RACKNTABLE
which young engineers and interns should be familiar.
MOU

IMMERSIVE & SPATIAL AUDIO:


ED
IS4—STAAG Implementation Expanded: A Practical
RUGG S ING
Demo of STAAG Mic Technique and Its Use in Stereo, HO U
Surround and Height-Channel Capture for Recording
and Broadcast
Thursday, Oct. 18, 10:15 a.m. – 11:15 a.m.
Presenters:
• Alex Kosiorek, Central Sound at Arizona PBS
(Phoenix, Ariz.)
• Jamie Tagg, Indiana University (Bloomington,
Ind.); Stagg Sound Services
While working on location, audio engineers are often ABLE
challenged by insufficient monitoring, making choices LOCKSSIS
that lead to timbral, wet/dry balance and stereo image CHA
problems. This tutorial examines the use of STAAG
(Stereo Technique for Augmented Ambience Gradient)
PUT/
and its established advantages for addressing stereo
2 x INUT
image, acoustic realism and flexibility in the mix. While
originally optimized for immersive headphone listening,
OUTP NA2-IO-DLINE
this technique has proven advantageous when upscaling Connect your legacy audio gear to the Dante® world. The NA2-IO-DLINE
to stereo, surround and even height-channel loudspeaker Line I/O Dante Interface is a 2-channel end-of-network device that
systems and stereo/surround broadcast streams. Also, simultaneously converts analog signals to Dante and Dante to analog
this setup is advantageous when working on location signals. Professional-level connectivity is provided via lockable NEUTRIK
XLR and etherCON® connectors. Designed for both harsh stage conditions
and fixed installations. For more information visit www.neutrik.com

m i x o n l i n e . co m | O C T O B E R 2 0 1 8 | M I X
and in live performance scenarios due to its compact arrangement and for Scoring and Post Audio
compatibility with a wide variety of microphones. This tutorial will feature Thursday, Oct. 18, 11:30 a.m. – 12:30 p.m.
physical configurations and playback of audio examples in a variety of Presenter: Robert Marshall, Source Elements
formats. Market forces and the advent of new technologies and the internet
have greatly altered the world of film scoring, along with other related
SE—Platinum Latin Producers & Engineers enterprises in audio post. Excellent tools exist for collaborating remotely
Thursday, Oct. 18, 10:45 a.m. – 12:15 p.m. on recording sessions. Workflows have built up and developed over time
Moderator: Andres A. Mayo, Andres Mayo Mastering & Audio Post to allow those constrained by budget, or desiring the artistic services of
(Buenos Aires, Argentina) someone who is geographically remote, to conduct full sessions with
Presenters: talkback and good monitor audio. This workshop is an exploration of one
• Rafael Arcaute of the major tools, along with examples of how remote recording is being
• Gustavo Borner, igloo music (Burbank, Calif.) used in scoring and other disciplines.
• Eduardo Cabra, Visitante
• Andres Levin, Music Has No Enemies (New York / Havana); SE—Al Schmitt—On the Record
Habanico (New York/Havana) Thursday, Oct. 18, 2:45 p.m. – 3:45 p.m.
• Eduardo Pereyra (Buenos Aires, Argentina) Presenters:
• Rafa Sardina • Maureen Droney, The Recording Academy (Los Angeles, Calif.)
Every year the Platinum Latin Panel brings some of the finest audio • Al Schmitt (Los Angeles, Calif.)
professionals to AES. The presenters, all multi-platinum record producers Al Schmitt is a multiple GRAMMY Award-winning engineer and producer,
and GRAMMY winners, will tell you all about producing great music for a music legend whose career spans more than six decades. In fact, Al has
the Latin market. received the most GRAMMYs ever awarded to an engineer. He’s worked
with such iconic artists as Paul McCartney, Ray Charles, Toto, Diana
AUDIO FOR CINEMA: Krall, Steely Dan, Bob Dylan, Barbra Streisand, Neil Young, Quincy Jones,
AC2—Collaboration at a Distance: Real-Time Remote Recording Tools Henry Mancini, Tony Bennett, Linda Ronstadt, Natalie Cole and so many

46 M I X | O C T O B E R 2 0 1 8 | mi x o n l i n e.co m
more. In this wide-ranging discussion with Maureen Droney, managing Presenters:
director of the Recording Academy Producers & Engineers Wing, Schmitt • Alex Kosiorek, Central Sound at Arizona PBS (Phoenix, Ariz.)
will share stories from his life in music along with practical tips and sage • Steve Remote, Aurasonic
advice about what it takes to become one of the most in-demand talents • Corey Schreppel, Minnesota Public Radio|American Public Media
in the business. This discussion also commemorates the release of Al’s • George Wellington, New York Public Radio (New York, NY)
autobiography: Al Schmitt on the Record: The Magic Behind the Music (Hal • Eric Xu, Central Sound at Arizona PBS (Phoenix, Ariz.)
Leonard). Artists and engineers are recording more productions on location or
in locations other than the studio. Whether it’s audio for spoken word,
SE—Mastered by Bob Ludwig: An Exploration of his Career and chorus, small chamber ensembles to large symphony orchestra, or complex
Techniques jazz/pop/rock shows involving splits from FOH, pre-production is a critical
Thursday, Oct. 18, 3:45 p.m. – 4:45 p.m. aspect of any remote recording. Moreover, with new forms of immersive
Presenters: delivery on the horizon, surround production is now part of this equation.
• Jett Galindo, Bakery Mastering (Los Angeles, Calif.) Some of the challenges for on-location production include maintaining a
• Bob Ludwig, Gateway Mastering Studios (Portland, Maine) consistent aesthetic across productions, varying venue acoustics, discretion
Jett Galindo of Bakery Mastering hosts a conversation with legendary of microphone placement, monitoring, and redundant backup systems.
mastering engineer Bob Ludwig of the famed Gateway Mastering Studios. In this workshop, today’s working professionals will give relatable and
Ludwig’s career began during an era when mastering technology looked practical methods of tackling production for mobile/on-location events
very different than it does today. The interview explores Ludwig’s and discuss how it differs from studio recording. Topics will include
perspective on all things mastering, including how he has navigated venue scoping, bids and quotes, stage plots, communication with venue
those changes, his observations about what has changed, exploration of or ensemble production managers, talent coordination and other logistics.
technology old and new, and insights into how he approaches his work. Some audio examples (including those in surround) will be included.
We’ll hear a sampling of some of his work and learn what “Mastered by
Bob Ludwig” really means. IMMERSIVE & SPATIAL AUDIO:
IS—D Audio Acoustic Recording Capture, Dissemination and
RECORDING & PRODUCTION: Perception
RP—Music Mixing, Part V Saturday, Oct. 20, 1:15 p.m. – 3:15 p.m.
Friday, Oct. 19, 1:30 p.m. – 3:00 p.m. Presenters:
Moderator: Richard King, McGill University (Montreal, Quebec, Canada); • David Bowles, Swineshead Productions (Berkeley, Calif.)
The Centre for Interdisciplinary Research in Music Media and Technology • Paul Geluso, New York University (New York, NY)
(Montreal, Quebec, Canada) • Hyunkook Lee, University of Huddersfield (Huddersfield, UK)
Panelists: • Agnieszka Roginska, New York University (New York, NY)
• Pablo Arraya, Audio Piranha (Brooklyn, NY); Purchase College This is a panel discussion on recording techniques for capturing and
(Purchase, NY) disseminating 3D acoustic music recordings, with an emphasis on
• Frank Filipetti psychoacoustic and perceptual challenges. The 90-minute panel will be
• Leslie Ann Jones, Recording Engineer and Producer, Director of immediately followed by a 90-minute playback session. There will be Q&A
Music Recording and Scoring, Skywalker Sound (San Rafael, Calif.) during the panel, but after the playback to allow audience to experience
• George Massenburg, Schulich School of Music, McGill University playback without interruptions.
(Montreal, Quebec, Canada); Centre for Interdisciplinary Research
in Music Media and Technology (CIRMMT) (Montreal, Quebec, RECORDING & PRODUCTION:
Canada) RP2—From Studio to Stage—The Impact of Technology on Live
A panel of award-winning expert practitioners from varying backgrounds Production
and genres within the industry will spark interesting discussion and Saturday, Oct. 20, 3:00 p.m. – 4:00 p.m.
debate. Topics will include the process of mixing and methodologies that Presenters:
have yielded successful results in a constantly changing industry. Focus • Erin Barra, Berklee College of Music (Boston, Mass.); MAMMA
will include the different ways to approach a mix, how to improve a mix, BARRA
and how to interpret comments from clients. Balancing, processing and • DJ Nebraska, Jessie Davis Music
listening will also be addressed. There will be lots of time for Q&A so the • DJ Raydar Ellis, Berklee College of Music
audience can engage the panel members. This series has become very • Paul “Willie Green” Womack, Willie Green Music (Brooklyn, NY)
popular with young engineers, educators and seasoned professionals. Advancements in technology and software have transformed the live
performances of DJs, looping artists and producers. DAWs and samplers
RECORDING & PRODUCTION: do not live solely in the domain of the studio; rather, they have become
RP2—Planning for On-Location Audio Recording and Production the instruments of live performers across the globe. This roundtable
(Including Surround) discussion will explore the changing workflows and evolving capabilities
Saturday, Oct. 20, 10:45 a.m. – 1:00 p.m. of technology-based artists. ■

48 M I X | O C T O B E R 2 0 1 8 | mi x o n l i n e.co m
Tech // back page blog
Notes on DI Guitar and Mobile Recording
Mike Levine: Mix Technology Editor, Studio Steve La Cerra: Mix Technology Editor, Live
We’re All Gonna DI: My workflow for electric guitar Find Someplace Else to Live: My cousin Frank sent me a
overdubs almost always starts with a DI recording rather message and a link to an online article published last week
than a miked amp. I find it to be quite efficient. that discussed the reorganization of the wireless spectrum
Unless I’m recording a clean rhythm track, I’ll usually and its effects on wireless microphone and instrument
track it while monitoring through an amp-and-effects users. Frank doesn’t work in the audio industry, so the
modeling plug-in. (My current favorite is Line 6 Helix whole thing was news to him. “Will this be a PITA for you?”
Native.) Of course, monitoring through a plug-in brings the latency devil he asked. If only he knew. As someone who participates regularly in church
into the equation, but as long as I’m able to set my record buffer at 256 services (he’s a deacon), Frank and his parishioners would be concerned.
samples or lower, I can deal with it. I’ll bleed in a little direct sound in my Audio pros have been over it ad nauseam: broadband wireless providers
headphones just to help me stay locked with the time if the latency delay with deep pockets want the prime real estate of the 600 and 700 MHz
is making it tough. bands for their own use, and the audio industry is a gnat on the FCC’s
If I’m working on a song that’s already got a ton of tracks and plug-ins, office wall. When presented with the opportunity to “sell” air rights to
and it’s using too much CPU power to allow me to set the buffer that low, companies like Google or ATT for tens of billions of dollars, the FCC
I’ll make a reference mix and open it in a new session. I’ll track my part jumps, and really doesn’t give a rat’s behind if they jump up and down on
along with it, and then import the new guitar track into the original session. the graves of the audio guys, whether we’re working on tours, Broadway
But fear not, this doesn’t mean I use an amp modeler for the final sound shows, sporting events or in houses of worship. We simply don’t have the
every time. I’ll often reamp the DI tone through a tube amp and mic it. But resources to compete.
typically I won’t make the final decision about a tone—whether to keep using What has become evident in the past few years is that the FCC’s
the modeler or whether to reamp and mic—until I’m well into the mix. reorganization is hurting small audio operators like that church with a
few hundred parishioners who can barely keep the lights on or afford to
Mini-Review: CEntrance MixerFace R4: The idea of being able to record fix the roof, let alone fork up a few grand for new wireless microphones.
anywhere is compelling. Wireless manufacturers have been more than gracious by creating trade-
Whether you do field in programs, but they can only go so far. I can just see some knucklehead
recording or just want representing ATT walking in on a service and trying to shut it down
to be able to work on because a minister is using an old wireless system in the 700 MHz band.
music projects outside of Tremendous efforts by Shure, Sennheiser,  Lectrosonics and Audio-
your studio (and I mean Technica have helped get us some concessions from the FCC, but the
anywhere outside of your studio, as long as you’re not underwater), FCC’s message clearly remains “find somewhere else to live.”
CEntrance’s MixerFace R4 Mobile Recording Interface lets you go forth
untethered and record with high quality into your laptop, mobile device, Product of the Month: Bose Panaray MSA12X:
portable recorder or video camera. Intended for use in house-of-worship applications,
The handheld, battery-operated R4 offers impressive-sounding mic auditoriums, lecture halls, theaters and conference
pre’s and converters, and plenty of handy features. Two Neutrik combo rooms, the Panaray MSA12X Modular Steerable
inputs with globally switchable phantom power allow you to connect XLR Array Loudspeaker from Bose Professional is a self-
mics or guitars, basses and other Hi-Z sources. The inputs each have a powered, steerable array. Each MSA12X employs
highpass filter switch and a gain knob. An aux-in circuit, accessed with a 12 full-range 2.25-inch transducers in a columnar
1/8-inch jack, is controlled by a volume knob. line array configuration engineered for high vocal
For outputs, you get a 1/8-inch headphone jack and left and right intelligibility and full-range music reproduction in
1/8-inch TRS balanced outputs for feeding monitors or any other external acoustically-challenged spaces. Bose’s proprietary
gear, with an additional stereo 1/8-inch line out. Articulated Array provides 160-degree horizontal
With an Oktava MK-012 mic, I recorded acoustic guitar, resonator guitar coverage, while built-in DSP enables digital control
and vocals, and all sounded roughly comparable to the quality I get through and beam steering of the vertical coverage patterns.
my desktop interface, which is no cheapy. Through the instrument inputs Vertical coverage for a single MSA12X is 20 degrees.
I tracked DI electric guitar and bass with equally happy results. Frequency response is spec’d at 75 to 14,000 Hz. n

50 M I X | O C T O B E R 2 0 1 8 | mi x o n l i n e.co m
9000

You might also like