Professional Documents
Culture Documents
DOI 10.1007/s10620-006-9622-2
R EVIEW ARTICLE
Received: 14 September 2006 / Accepted: 14 September 2006 / Published online: 3 April 2007
C Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2007
Abstract Crohn’s disease (CD) and ulcerative colitis (UC), tegrated, pathophysiologic model of the initiation and/or
known as inflammatory bowel disease (IBD), are fairly com- propagation of IBD have not emerged. It is generally hy-
mon chronic inflammatory conditions of the gastrointestinal pothesized that IBD is caused by gastrointestinal tract im-
tract. Although the exact etiology of IBD remains uncer- mune dysregulation, because the disease is accompanied
tain, dysfunctional immunoregulation of the gut is believed by a considerable infiltration of inflammatory cells in gut
to be the main culprit. Amongst the immunoregulatory fac- mucosa [1].
tors, reactive oxygen species are produced in abnormally However, the specific pathways leading to cellular dam-
high levels in IBD. Their destructive effects may contribute age are not completely understood. Oxidative stress is a po-
to the initiation and/or propagation of the disease. We pro- tential etiological and/or triggering factor for IBD, because
vided an extensive overview on the evidences from animal the detrimental effects of reactive oxygen molecules (ROM)
and human literature linking oxidative stress to IBD and its have been well established in the inflammation process [2].
activity. Moreover, the effects of antioxidant therapy on IBD In this review, we assess the evidence from animal and hu-
patients in randomized, controlled trials were reviewed and man literature that links oxidative stress (OS) to IBD and its
the need for further studies elaborated. We also summarized activity. We also evaluate the effect of antioxidant therapy
the evidence in support for causality of oxidative stress in on IBD.z
IBD.
Keywords Animal . Crohn’s disease . Human . Oxidative Stress: Definition and measurement
Inflammatory bowel disease . Oxidative stress . Ulcerative
colitis Reactive oxygen species (ROS), which form as natural
byproducts of the normal metabolism of oxygen, are highly
Inflammatory bowel diseases (i.e., ulcerative colitis (UC) reactive molecules as a result of the presence of unpaired
and Crohn’s disease (CD)) are characterized by chronic electrons. To regulate the destructive effects of ROS, vital
or relapsing immune activation and inflammation within tissues are equipped with an intricate antioxidant defense
the gastrointestinal tract. Despite extensive research, an in- system. Oxidative stress arises when there is a marked im-
balance between the production of ROS and their removal
by antioxidants.
A. Rezaie · R. D. Parker
Department of Community Health Medicine, Faculty Numerous techniques, with varying precision, are avail-
of Medicine, University of Calgary, able to measure ROS or the reduction of antioxidants. Be-
Calgary, Canada cause ROS have short biologic half-lives, attempts to directly
quantify their levels are limited to electron spin resonance
M. Abdollahi ()
Faculty of Pharmacy, and Pharmaceutical Sciences Research spectroscopy [3, 4] and chemiluminescence [5], expensive
Center, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, techniques that are restricted in their application. Histochem-
P.O. Box 14155-6451, Tehran, Iran istry [6] and colorimetric assays [7], which are easily used
e-mail: mohammad.abdollahi@utoronto.ca in tissue studies, lack sufficient sensitivity and specificity.
Springer
2016 Dig Dis Sci (2007) 52:2015–2021
The presence of ROS is generally measured indirectly by glutathione peroxidase. These animals develop a crypt de-
the levels of oxidatively damaged molecules. Lipid oxida- structive colitis similar to UC as early as 11 days of age
tion can be assessed in a variety of tissues and fluids by [12].
measuring levels of thiobarbituric acid reactive substances
(TBARS), diene conjugation, isoprostanes, and breath alka- Human studies
nes [8]. Oxidative DNA damage is usually evaluated by mea-
suring the concentration of 8-hydroxy-2‘–deoxyguanosine Presence of excessive reactive oxygen metabolites
(8OHdG) [9]. Free–radical attack on proteins generates prod- in human tissues
ucts, such as 3–nitrotyrosine, 3–chlorotyrosine, and para-
hydroxyphenylacetaldehyde [8], but the most frequently The presence of ROMs or the molecules damaged by ROMs
used biomarkers of protein damage are carbonyl groups [10]. have been extensively studied in patients with IBD (Table 2).
Antioxidants can be categorized into nonenzymatic and Although some conflicting results exist, it seems that pa-
enzymatic ROS scavengers. tients with IBD demonstrate excessive oxidized molecules
Nonenzymatic antioxidants include dietary compounds, compared with healthy control subjects in a variety of or-
such as vitamins (C and E) and minerals (selenium and ganic systems (e.g., gastrointestinal tract, blood, and respi-
zinc) and also glutathione, uric acid, and ubiquinol. Superox- ratory system). Interestingly, this effect seems to be more
ide desmutase (SOD), catalase, and glutathione peroxidase pronounced in patients with CD. Use of imprecise tech-
(GPO) are the main enzymatic antioxidants [8]. The sum of niques, such as a simple TBA test and/or small sample size,
all known and unknown endogenous and exogenous antioxi- could be the source of inconsistency in the studies that failed
dants in a medium is usually called total antioxidant capacity to show any evidence of oxidative stress.
(TAC) and gives a holistic view of antioxidant status.
Presence of an antioxidant imbalance in human tissues
Oxidative stress and inflammatory bowel disease In reaction to mild oxidative stress, tissues often respond by
producing more antioxidants; however, severe persistent ox-
Animal studies idative stress depletes body antioxidant resources and over-
takes its ability to produce more antioxidants, leading to
None of the current animal models of IBD is ideal, and lower antioxidant levels. Therefore, interpretation of antiox-
attempts to create an experimental model of human IBD idant concentrations without knowing the status of ROS and
using toxic chemicals have limited capability in reproducing course of the disease would be biased.
the disease because of complicated genetic, immunologic, Expression of antioxidants has been investigated in sev-
environmental, and psychologic factors that are considered eral studies in various organs (Table 3). Although the change
to contribute to the pathophysiology of IBD [11]. However, in antioxidant levels is conflicting among the studies, the
several studies have been conducted to evaluate the status of imperative point is the presence of an imbalance in antioxi-
ROMs in animal models (Table 1), which unanimously show dant concentration, attesting the fact that vital organs in IBD
abnormal levels of antioxidants or oxidized molecules. patients are oxidatively stressed.
The most striking evidence in animal studies comes from
genetic knockout mice lacking the antioxidant enzyme of
Springer
Dig Dis Sci (2007) 52:2015–2021 2017
Note. nd No statistical difference compared with controls. Only controlled studies are included.
Correlation of oxidative stress with IBD activity effect modifiers influencing the association between the dis-
ease and OS. Therefore, only RCTs could bring us reliable
The majority of studies that examined the relationship be- answers for the effect of antioxidants in IBD patients.
tween IBD severity and oxidative stress markers failed to Aghdassi et al. [22] treated stable but oxidatively stressed
show any significant correlation [13–18]. However, Holmes CD patients (n = 57; CD activity index < 180) with vitamin
et al. [19] observed a 1.7–fold increase of colon oxidized E (800 IU) and vitamin C (1,000 mg) or placebo for a period
glutathione in active UC compared with inactive UC pa- of 4 weeks. During supplementation, oxidative stress mark-
tients. In our recent study of 28 patients with CD [20], we ers, such as breath pentane and ethane output, plasma lipid
showed that CD activity index significantly correlates with peroxidation, and F2 –isoprostane, significantly decreased.
TAC, lipid peroxidation, and their interaction (r2 = 0.625, Although disease activity remained stable during the course
r2 = 0.8, F test P < 0.00005). This novel finding that of the trial, it should be considered that participants had mild
TAC and ROS modify the other’s effects in determination or controlled (in remission) disease, therefore, detecting a
of CD severity may explain the inability of previous studies significant difference in disease activity index would have
to reach a meaningful relationship between oxidative stress been difficult if not impossible in only 57 patients. More-
markers and disease activity because both ROS and antioxi- over, a follow-up of 4 weeks seems to be too short to detect
dant defense condition should be considered in determining a meaningful difference among both arms of the study.
the severity of IBD. In another RCT with a longer term but a far smaller dose
of antioxidant nutrients, Trebble et al. [23, 24] investigated
Specific antioxidant randomized, controlled trials the effect of fish oil and antioxidants (i.e., β-carotene 150
in patients with IBD µg, selenium 200 µg, vitamin E 30 mg, and vitamin C 90
mg) vs. placebo on 61 patients for 24 weeks. Supplementa-
In consideration of the strong evidence of OS in IBD, an- tion was associated with reduction in plasma arachidonic
tioxidant therapy deserves a place in its treatment. In fact, acid, interferon-δ, and prostaglandin E2 . No differences
the oldest and most commonly used drug for treatment of were detected in activity of the disease or indices of bone
patients with IBD, 5–aminosalicylic acid, has shown ROS turnover.
scavenging capabilities [21]. Conversely, only a few random- During a 3–month period, Geerling et al. [25] evalu-
ized, controlled trials RCTs have been conducted to examine ated the effects of antioxidants (e.g., selenium 12.4 µg, β–
the efficacy of specific antioxidants in IBD. Given the multi- carotene 150 µg, vitamin E 4 mg, and vitamin C 20 mg)
faceted nature of OS and complex pathophysiology of IBD, and n–3 fatty acids on 25 patients with CD currently in
there are numerous known and unknown confounders and remission. TAC and SOD activity significantly increased,
Springer
2018 Dig Dis Sci (2007) 52:2015–2021
Note. nd No statistical difference compared with controls. Only controlled studies are included.
Springer
Dig Dis Sci (2007) 52:2015–2021 2019
whereas activity of glutathione peroxidase reduced after an- nal permeability without any actual inflammation [32, 33].
tioxidant supplementation. No change was observed between The fact that OS is present before the cascade of colonic
the groups considering lipid peroxidation or disease activity. inflammation starts argues against ROMs as byproducts of
Siedner et al. [26] randomized 121 patients with mild-to- the colonic inflammatory process.
moderate UC to placebo or oral supplement enriched with r The presence of “effect modification” between TAC and
various nutrients, such as vitamin E (72 IU), vitamin C (156 lipid peroxidation in our recent study emphasizes that ox-
mg), β-carotene (1185 µg), selenium (30 µg), and fish idative stress has a role in pathophysiology of CD rather
oil. Both groups showed significant clinical improvement at than a nonspecific marker of inflammation [20].
6 months of follow-up. Patients given the supplementation
Although none of the above provide a rigid basis for
had a significantly greater rate of decrease in corticosteroid
causality, it is likely that OS has an etiologic role in IBD.
dose. No marker of OS was measured in this study.
However, whether the OS markers are useful in monitoring
With the exception of the first trial, all the studies used
disease activity or determining prognosis remains uncertain.
doses of antioxidants far lower than one could expect to
Therapeutic applicability of antioxidants must be elucidated
produce a dramatic change in OS status or clinical course of
in future, randomized, clinical trials. We recommend using
patients with IBD. In addition, all the trials used antioxidants
high-dose potent antioxidants, a long follow-up period, and
with medium potency, which again questions the ability of
emphasis on moderate and severe cases of IBD.
these nutrients to be remarkably effective in chronic disease,
such as IBD.
References
Springer
2020 Dig Dis Sci (2007) 52:2015–2021
15. Genser D, et al. (1999) Status of lipidsoluble antioxidants and 36. Ardite E, et al. (2000) Replenishment of glutathione levels im-
TRAP in patients with Crohn’s disease and healthy controls. Eur J proves mucosal function in experimental acute colitis. Lab Invest
Clin Nutr 53(9):675–679 80(5):735–744
16. Koutroubakis IE, et al. (2004) Decreased total and corrected an- 37. Nieto N, et al. (2000) Experimental ulcerative colitis impairs an-
tioxidant capacity in patients with inflammatory bowel disease. tioxidant defense system in rat intestine. Dig Dis Sci 45(9):1820–
Dig Dis Sci 49(9):1433–1437 1827
17. Wendland BE, et al. (2001) Lipid peroxidation and plasma antioxi- 38. Ghazanfari GMB, Yasa N, Ashtaral-Nakhai L, Mohammadi-
dant micronutrients in Crohn’s disease. Am J Clin Nutr 74(2):259– rad A, Nikfar S, Dehghan G, Shetab-Boushehri V, Jamshidi
264 H, Khorasani R, Salehnia A, Abdollahi M (2006) Biochemical
18. Erichsen K, et al. (2003) Ferrous fumarate deteriorated plasma and histopathological evidences for beneficial effects of Satureja
antioxidant status in patients with Crohn’s disease. Scand J Gas- khuzestanica jamzad essential oil on the mouse model of inflamma-
troenterol 38(5):543–548 tory bowel diseases. Toxicology Mechanisms Methods 16(7):365–
19. Holmes EW, et al. (1998) Glutathione content of colonic mucosa: 372
evidence for oxidative damage in active ulcerative colitis. Dig Dis 39. Ghafari HYN, Mohammadirad A, Dehghan G, Zamani MJ,
Sci 43(5):1088–1095 Nikfar S, Khorasani S, Minaie B, Abdollahi M (2006 Jun) Protec-
20. Rezaie A, Eshghtork A, Zamani M, Dehghan G, Taghavi B, Nikfar tion by Ziziphora clinopoides of acetic acid-induced toxic bowel
S, Daryani N, Abdollahi M. Alterations in salivary antioxidants, inflammation through reduction of cellular lipid peroxidation and
nitric oxide, and transforming growth factor-beta1 in relation to myeloperoxidase activity. Human Experimental Toxicol 25:325–
disease activity in Crohn’s disease patients. Ann N Y Acad Sci (in 332
press) 40. Jahanshahi G, et al. (2004) Alterations in antioxidant power and
21. Miles AM, Grisham MB (1994) Antioxidant properties of aminos- levels of epidermal growth factor and nitric oxide in saliva of
alicylates. Methods Enzymol 234:555–572 patients with inflammatory bowel diseases. Dig Dis Sci 49(11–
22. Aghdassi E, et al. (2003) Antioxidant vitamin supplementation 12):1752–1757
in Crohn’s disease decreases oxidative stress: a randomized con- 41. Barbosa DS, et al. (2003) Decreased oxidative stress in patients
trolled trial. Am J Gastroenterol 98(2):348–353 with ulcerative colitis supplemented with fish oil omega-3 fatty
23. Trebble TM, et al. (2005) High-dose fish oil and antioxidants in acids. Nutrition 19(10):837–842
Crohn’s disease and the response of bone turnover: a randomised 42. Kruidenier L, et al. (2003) Intestinal oxidative damage in inflam-
controlled trial. Br J Nutr 94(2): 253–261 matory bowel disease: semi-quantification, localization, and asso-
24. Trebble TM, et al. (2004) Fish oil and antioxidants alter the com- ciation with mucosal antioxidants. J Pathol 201(1):28–36
position and function of circulating mononuclear cells in Crohn 43. Tuzun A, et al. (2002) Oxidative stress and antioxidant capac-
disease. Am J Clin Nutr 80(5):1137–1144 ity in patients with inflammatory bowel disease. Clin Biochem
25. Geerling BJ, et al. (2000) Nutritional supplementation with N- 35(7):569–572
3 fatty acids and antioxidants in patients with Crohn’s disease 44. Sampietro GM, et al. (2002) Oxidative stress, vitamin A and vita-
in remission: effects on antioxidant status and fatty acid profile. min E behaviour in patients submitted to conservative surgery for
Inflamm Bowel Dis 6(2):77–84 complicated Crohn’s disease. Dig Liver Dis 34(10):696–701
26. Seidner DL, et al. (2005) An oral supplement enriched with fish 45. D’Odorico A, et al. (2001) Reduced plasma antioxidant concentra-
oil, soluble fiber, and antioxidants for corticosteroid sparing in tions and increased oxidative DNA damage in inflammatory bowel
ulcerative colitis: a randomized, controlled trial. Clin Gastroenterol disease. Scand J Gastroenterol 36(12):1289–1294
Hepatol 3(4):358–369 46. Levy E, et al. (2000) Altered lipid profile, lipoprotein composition,
27. Hendrickson BA, Gokhale R, Cho JH (2002) Clinical aspects and and oxidant and antioxidant status in pediatric Crohn’s disease. Am
pathophysiology of inflammatory bowel disease. Clin Microbiol J Clin Nutr 71(3):807–815
Rev 15(1):79–94 47. Chiarpotto E, et al. (1997) Oxidative damage and transforming
28. Meyer CT, et al. (1981) Hydrogen peroxide colitis: a report of three growth factor beta 1 expression in pretumoral and tumoral lesions
patients. J Clin Gastroenterol 3(1):31–35 of human intestine. Free Radic Biol Med 22(5):889–894
29. Bilotta JJ, Waye JD (1989) Hydrogen peroxide enteritis: the “snow 48. Lih-Brody L, et al. (1996) Increased oxidative stress and decreased
white” sign. Gastrointest Endosc 35(5):428–430 antioxidant defenses in mucosa of inflammatory bowel disease. Dig
30. Riedle B, Kerjaschki D (1997) Reactive oxygen species cause Dis Sci 41(10):2078–2086
direct damage of Engelbreth-Holm-Swarm matrix. Am J Pathol 49. Cao W, et al. (2004) Hydrogen peroxide contributes to motor dys-
151(1):215–231 function in ulcerative colitis. Am J Physiol Gastrointest Liver Phys-
31. Rao RK, et al. (1997) Oxidant-induced disruption of intestinal iol 286(5):G833–G843
epithelial barrier function: role of protein tyrosine phosphorylation. 50. Pelli MA, et al. (1999) Breath alkanes determination in ulcerative
Am J Physiol 273(4 Pt 1):G812–G823 colitis and Crohn’s disease. Dis Colon Rectum 42(1):71–76
32. Fries W, et al. (2005) Intestinal permeability and genetic deter- 51. Hatoum OA, et al. (2003) Acquired microvascular dysfunction in
minants in patients, first-degree relatives, and controls in a high- inflammatory bowel disease: loss of nitric oxide-mediated vasodi-
incidence area of Crohn’s disease in Southern Italy. Am J Gas- lation. Gastroenterology 125(1):58–69
troenterol 100(12):2730–2736 52. Koch TR, et al. (2000) Total antioxidant capacity of colon in
33. Buhner S, et al. (2006) Genetic basis for increased intestinal perme- patients with chronic ulcerative colitis. Dig Dis Sci 45(9):1814–
ability in families with Crohn’s disease: role of CARD15 3020insC 1819
mutation? Gut 55(3):342–347 53. Tsunada S, et al. (2003) Redox imbalance in the colonic mucosa
34. Ding X, et al. (2005) Inducible nitric oxide synthase-dependent of ulcerative colitis. Scand J Gastroenterol 38(9):1002–1003
DNA damage in mouse model of inflammatory bowel disease. 54. Kruidenier L, et al. (2003) Imbalanced secondary mucosal antiox-
Cancer Sci 96(3):157–163 idant response in inflammatory bowel disease. J Pathol 201(1):17–
35. Tham DM, Whitin JC, Cohen HJ (2002) Increased expression of 27
extracellular glutathione peroxidase in mice with dextran sodium 55. Szanto I, et al. (2005) Expression of NOX1, a superoxide-
sulfate-induced experimental colitis. Pediatr Res 51(5):641– generating NADPH oxidase, in colon cancer and inflammatory
646 bowel disease. J Pathol 207(2):164–176
Springer
Dig Dis Sci (2007) 52:2015–2021 2021
56. Buffinton GD, Doe WF (1995) Depleted mucosal antioxidant 59. Fernandez-Banares F, et al. (1989) Vitamin status in patients
defenses in inflammatory bowel disease. Free Radic Biol Med with inflammatory bowel disease. Am J Gastroenterol 84(7):744–
19(6):911–918 748
57. Reimund JM, et al. (2000) Antioxidant and immune status in active 60. Kuroki F, et al. (1993) Multiple vitamin status in Crohn’s dis-
Crohn’s disease: a possible relationship. Clin Nutr 19(1):43–48 ease. Correlation with disease activity. Dig Dis Sci 38(9):1614–
58. Hoffenberg EJ, et al. (1997) Circulating antioxidant concentra- 1618
tions in children with inflammatory bowel disease. Am J Clin Nutr 61. Hinks LJ, et al. (1988) Reduced concentrations of selenium in mild
65(5):1482–1488 Crohn’s disease. J Clin Pathol 41(2):198–201
Springer