You are on page 1of 11

Engineering Geology 88 (2006) 110 – 120

www.elsevier.com/locate/enggeo

Geotechnical properties of tire-cohesive clayey soil mixtures


as a fill material
Hasan Cetin a,⁎, Mustafa Fener b , Osman Gunaydin b
a
Department of Geology, Çukurova University, Adana, 01330, Turkey
b
Department of Geology, Nigde University, Nigde, 51100, Turkey
Received 20 October 2005; received in revised form 1 August 2006; accepted 6 September 2006
Available online 20 October 2006

Abstract

Geotechnical properties of pure fine and coarse grained tire-chips and their mixtures (10, 20, 30, 40 and 50%) with a cohesive
clayey soil were investigated through a series of soil mechanical tests in order to investigate possibilities of their usage as a
lightweight fill material. Grain size and Atterberg limits analysis, permeability, direct shear and compaction tests were performed
on the clayey soil, tire chips (both fine and coarse) alone and their mixtures.
The results indicate that the use of used tire-chips mixed with clayey soils as a fill material is possible. The mixtures up to 20%
coarse grained tire-chips and 30% fine grained tire-chips can be used above ground water tables where low weight, low
permeability and high strength are needed in fills such as highway embankments, bridge abutments and backfills behind retaining
structures especially when they are to be built on weak foundation soils with low bearing capacity and high settlement problems.
They should not be used where drainage is needed to prevent the development of pore pressures during loading of fills under
saturated conditions. In these cases, they may, however, be used by mixing with high permeability material such as sand and gravel.
© 2006 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

Keywords: Rubber tire-chips; Clayey soil; Lightweight fill; Embankment; Abutments; Backfills

1. Introduction less dense than other waste items, so they occupy large
volumes in landfills. Rainwater tends to collect in
The volume of used rubber auto tires in the world is stockpiled tires, which then become a breeding ground
increasing every year and their disposal have, therefore, for mosquitoes that carry dangerous diseases such as
become a major environmental problem worldwide. encephalitis. Producing toxic smoke and oils, stockpiled
Every year, millions of scrap tires are either discarded in tires are also a fire hazard. Several states in the United
huge piles across the landscape or dumped in landfills in States have, therefore, banned the disposal of used tires
large volumes. These tire piles not only cause in the land (Masad et al., 1996).
environmental pollution but also pose fire and health Some of the current uses of scrap tires include rubber
hazards. Generally, weighing between 10 and 50 kg, modified asphalt (RMA) for road construction and
tires are very bulky, and difficult to manage. They are running track, Tire-Derived Fuel (TDF) which is a low-
sulfur, high heating-value fuel, remanufactured tires,
⁎ Corresponding author. Tel.: +90 322 3386084 / 2079; fax: +90 highway crash barriers, alternative playground bases and
322-3386126. playground equipment, fashion accessories such as ties,
E-mail address: cetinh@mail.cu.edu.tr (H. Cetin). shoes, notebook covers, and purses. However, these uses
0013-7952/$ - see front matter © 2006 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.enggeo.2006.09.002
H. Cetin et al. / Engineering Geology 88 (2006) 110–120 111

Table 1 fill material behind retaining structures and highway


Some properties of the clayey soil embankments over weak or high compressibility soils
Properties Clayey Soil and further studies are needed to investigate the use of
Liquid limit (%) 41.6 different tire-chips sizes and percentages with various
Plastic limit (%) 25.7 types of soils.
Shrikage limit (%) 21.3 Conventional highway embankment and retaining
Plasticity index (%) 15.9
wall fill materials in practice may, however, include con-
Specific gravity 2.72
Grain sizes (%) siderable amount of fines. The aim of this study is, there-
Gravel 0.0 fore, to determine geotechnical properties of pure fine and
Sand 7.8 coarse grained tire-chips and their various mixtures with a
Silt 31.5 clayey (cohesive) soil as a lightweight fill material in
Clay 60.7
highway embankments, bridge abutments and backfills
Soil type (USCS) CL
Description Silty clay behind retaining structures. Usage of tire-chips espe-
cially in highway embankments will have a positive
impact on the environment since large quantities can be
are still not enough to consume the large quantities of scrap consumed in these voluminous structures.
tires generated every year. The majority of scrap tires
especially in developing countries are, therefore, either 2. Materials and methods
stockpiled, landfilled or dumped in the country illegally.
Lately, several researchers have been undertaken in 2.1. Sample preparation and index property testing
order to study possibilities of using tire-chips in civil
engineering applications such as highway embankments Samples were prepared by mixing a cohesive clayey
and backfills behind retaining structures over weak or (CL type) soil with 10, 20, 30, 40 and 50% coarse and
compressible soils. According to Humphrey (1999), fine grained tire-chips free of steel belts by weight
using tire-chips in civil engineering applications are (Table 1 and Fig. 1). Percentages of mixtures by volume
advantageous because of their low density, high are shown in Table 2. Fine tire-chips were under
durability, high thermal insulation and in many cases 0.425 mm (No. 40 sieve) and coarse tire-chips were
least cost compared to other fill materials. Previous between 2 mm (No. 10 sieve) and 4.75 mm (No. 4 sieve)
studies have mainly concentrated on determining in size (Fig. 1). This is needed to study effect of fine and
engineering properties of pure tire-chips and/or various coarse tire-chips separately since, similar to fine and
mixtures of tire-chips with sand as a lightweight fill coarse grained soils, they may behave differently. The
material (Ahmed, 1993; Edil and Bosscher, 1994; clayey soil was locally obtained from the Guvenc
University, 1995; Foose et al., 1996; Masad et al., formation of Miocene age (Schmidt, 1961) outcropping
1996; Wu et al., 1997; Lee et al., 1999; Yang et al., in the Adana basin in southern Turkey. The tire-chips
2002; Youwai and Bergado, 2004). They concluded that were obtained from a local tire manufacturing plant.
tire-chips and sand mixtures can be used as a lightweight Effects of tire-chips on the geotechnical properties of

Fig. 1. Particle size distribution curves for the clayey soil, fine and coarse grained tire-chips.
112 H. Cetin et al. / Engineering Geology 88 (2006) 110–120

Table 2 materials used (Cedergren, 1989). Therefore, using falling


Compositions of mixtures by weight and volume head method, permeability tests were conducted on the
By weight (%) By volume (%) clayey soil and mixtures in a consolidation test apparatus
Pure clay (0% fine tire-chips) Pure clay setup. The samples were cylindrical in 2.85 cm height and
10% fine tire-chips 18% fine tire-chips 6.35 cm diameter, and were saturated prior to measuring
20% fine tire-chips 33% fine tire-chips permeability by applying headwater pressure in a
30% fine tire-chips 46% fine tire-chips
graduated glass burette connected to the bottom portion
40% fine tire-chips 57% fine tire chips
50% fine tire-chips 66% fine tire-chips of the consolidometer. The permeability values were
100% fine tire-chips 100% fine tire-chips determined at normal pressures of 46, 93, 185, 287 and
10% coarse tire-chips 25% coarse tire-chips 370 kPa simulating various possible overburden pressures.
20% coarse tire-chips 42% coarse tire-chips
30% coarse tire-chips 55% coarse tire-chips
2.3. Shear and deformation testing
40% coarse tire-chips 66% coarse tire-chips
50% coarse tire-chips 74% coarse tire-chips
100% coarse tire-chips 100% coarse tire-chips The behavior of fills also depends on the strength and
deformation characteristics of the fill materials used.
Consolidated undrained direct shear tests (or consoli-
this cohesive clayey soil were investigated through a dated quick, Qc, tests) were performed to determine the
series of soil mechanical tests. shear strength and vertical or volumetric strain char-
Grain size analysis and Atterberg limits tests were acteristics of the clayey soil and the mixtures under
performed in order to classify both the clayey soil and the various normal pressures. Smaller additional normal
mixtures according to the Unified Soil Classification pressures were used in order to secure the shapes of the
System (USCS). Atterberg limits tests were performed failure envelopes at lower normal pressures for both the
only on the clayey soil and the fine tire-chip mixtures fine and coarse grained tire-chip mixtures alone.
since they are performed only on soil fraction passing The tests were performed under saturated conditions
No:40 (0.425 mm) sieve and the coarse grained tire-chips as described in Lambe (1951) and Liu and Evett (1984)
used in this study would be retained on this sieve. The or similar to the consolidated drained tests (or slow, S,
tests were performed following the American Society of tests) of the ASTM D 3080-98 (2003) except that a
Testing Materials (ASTM) D 422-63, D 4318-00 and faster shear rate (1 mm/minute) was used so that the
D 427-98 (2003), respectively. drainage is non or minimal. Complete prevention of
drainage in direct shear tests is very difficult. Therefore,
2.2. Permeability testing the great majority of so-called undrained tests in direct
shear test machines are not completely undrained; the
The behavior of fills under saturated conditions is larger the applied normal load, the greater the tendency
greatly influenced by the drainage characteristics of the fill for drainage (Lambe, 1951).

Fig. 2. Changes of liquid limit, plastic limit, plasticity index and clay content as the % tire-chips increases.
H. Cetin et al. / Engineering Geology 88 (2006) 110–120 113

Fig. 3. Relationship between coefficient of permeability and normal pressure for (a) fine-grained, (b) coarse-grained tire-chip mixtures and the clayey
soil alone.

Fig. 4. Relationship between coefficient of permeability and normal pressure for pure fine-grained and pure coarse-grained tire-chips.
114 H. Cetin et al. / Engineering Geology 88 (2006) 110–120

Fig. 5. Shear stress versus horizontal displacement and vertical deformation curves for (a) the clayey soil and (b–f ) fine-grained tire-chip mixtures.
H. Cetin et al. / Engineering Geology 88 (2006) 110–120 115

Fig. 6. Shear stress versus horizontal displacement and vertical deformation curves for (a) the clayey soil and (b–f ) coarse-grained tire-chip mixtures.
116 H. Cetin et al. / Engineering Geology 88 (2006) 110–120

The tests were performed on a direct-shear device becomes 30.35% at the 50% fine tire-chip mixture by
(ELE D-300) with a 6 cm x 6 cm square and 3.5 cm weight. Accordingly, the Atterberg limits are expected
height shear box seated in a pan which was filled with to decrease. Interestingly, the liquid limit (41.55%) stays
water and kept full during the tests. about the same up to 30% then it starts to decrease while
the plastic limit (25.67%) stays about the same up to
2.4. Compaction testing 10% from which point on it shows some amount of
decrease up to 20% then stays about the same (Fig. 2).
Stability and settlement of an earth-fill structure such These results are similar to those of typical fine grained
as an highway embankment and bridge abutment depends cohesive soils with medium plasticity.
on how well the fill material is compacted. If the fill
material, for example, is dumped or otherwise placed at 3.2. Permeability tests
random in a fill, the result will be an embankment with
low stability and high settlement (Holtz and Kovacs, The behavior of an embankment under saturated
1981). Therefore, following ASTM D 698-00a (2003), conditions is greatly influenced by the drainage
standard proctor (compaction) tests were run to determine characteristics of the fill material used (Cedergren,
first the compaction characteristics of the clayey soil 1989). A well-drained material will prevent the develop-
alone, then, for comparison, for both the fine and coarse ment of excess pore pressures during loading of fills and
tire-chip mixtures. The optimum moisture contents (Wopt) also accelerates consolidation of underlying low per-
at which the dry unit weights or densities (γdry), therefore, meability foundation soils by providing a drainage path,
compactions, are greatest were determined. thereby enhancing the stability of structures (Cedergren,
1989; Ahmed, 1993).
3. Results and discussions The permeability tests were conducted on the pure
clayey soil, fine and coarse tire-chips and the mixtures
3.1. Index property analysis under different loading conditions in a consolidation test
apparatus setup. The samples were saturated prior to
The soil indices and grain size curve of the clayey measuring permeability. The permeability values were
soil are given in Table 1 and Fig. 1, respectively. Accor- determined at normal pressures of 46, 93, 185, 287 and
ding to the USCS, the clayey soil classifies as a CL type 370 kPa simulating various possible overburden pres-
soil, with medium plasticity. The majority of the clay sures and the results are shown in Fig. 3. The per-
minerals are smectites and the remainder are palygors- meabilities of the clayey soil alone and all the mixtures
kites and kaolinites (Sayarslan et al., 1997). The clayey are low (x10− 7 – 10− 8 cm/s) which are consistent with
soil alone has 60.70% clay content which decrease typical low permeability clayey soils. Effects of both the
gradually as the tire-chips are added. It, for example, fine and coarse-grained tire-chips and the normal

Fig. 7. Shear stress versus fine-grained and coarse-grained % tire-chips.


H. Cetin et al. / Engineering Geology 88 (2006) 110–120 117

pressures on the permeability are similar. The perme- The permeabilities of both the fine and coarse-
abilities increase as the % tire-chips increases and the grained tire-chips alone are high (x10− 3–10− 4 cm/s)
normal pressure decreases. The higher the % tire-chips which are typical of sands (Fig. 4). Masad et al. (1996)
and the lower the normal pressure the higher the dif- found similar results and suggested that such high
ference in the increase is. values of permeability render the use of tire-chips alone
These results indicate that the mixtures can be used or in combination with sand as a useful fill material in
where low permeability and density (or loading) are embankments.
needed in fills on weak foundation material such as
alluvium. They should not be used where drainage is 3.3. Direct shear tests
needed to prevent the development of pore pressures
during loading of fills under saturated conditions. They Consolidated undrained direct shear tests were
may, however, be used by mixing with high permeabil- performed to determine the shear strengths and vertical
ity material such as sand and gravel. They may also be or volumetric strain characteristics of the clayey soil,
used in unsaturated conditions where drainage is not tire-chips (both fine and coarse) alone and the mixtures
needed, for example, in highway embankments and under different normal pressures. The shear stress versus
backfills behind retaining structures when they are to be horizontal displacement curves are shown in Figs. 5
built above ground water tables. and 6. As seen here, almost all the samples showed a

Fig. 8. Failure envelopes of (a) fine-grained, (b) coarse-grained tire-chip mixtures as well as pure clayey soil and tire-chips alone.
118 H. Cetin et al. / Engineering Geology 88 (2006) 110–120

stress-hardening behavior, in other words, there were no negative vertical strains for the clayey soil alone under
clear drops, therefore, no pronounced peaks (failure higher normal pressures such as 327 kPa either decrease
points) on the slopes of the curves. In these cases, it is considerably for the fine tire-chip mixtures or become
suggested that 10–20% shear deformation should be slightly above zero or positive for the coarse tire-chips
taken as the failure point (Liu and Evett, 1984; ASTM mixtures as the percent tire-chips increases up to 50%.
D 3080-98, 2003). Studying soil structure changes In general, the addition of both fine and coarse tire-chips
during drained and undrained shear of a cohesive sandy seem to decrease vertical strains especially under higher
silt–clay soil showing a stress-hardening behavior, Cetin normal pressures. As the % tire-chips increase, the fine
and Söylemez (2004) showed that the failure of such grained tire-chip mixtures seem to behave like fine
soils occur at 15% shear deformation. The shear grained clayey soils while the coarse grained tire-chip
strengths were found by taking the 15% shear deforma- mixtures seem to behave similar to coarse-grained soils
tion (in our case 9 mm) as the failure point. The shear such as sands.
stresses at failure versus % tire-chips (fine and coarse) The direct shear test results indicate that the mixtures
under different normal pressures are shown in Fig. 7. As up to 20% coarse grained tire-chips and 30% fine
seen here, there is a clear increase in the shear strengths grained tire-chips have high shear strength character-
up to at least 30% for fine and 20% for coarse tire chip istics (higher than the clayey soil alone) in terms of shear
mixtures. For example, 110 kPa shear strength of the strengths, cohesion and angle of internal friction;
pure (0% mixture) clayey soil under the normal pressure therefore, can be used as fill material.
of 327 kPa increases to 181 kPa for the coarse and
140 kPa for the fine tire-chip mixtures at 20% and 30%, 3.4. Compaction tests
respectively. Also, the shear strengths increase as the
normal pressures increase. Standard proctor (compaction) tests were run to de-
The failure envelopes, the cohesion and angle of termine the compaction characteristics of the clayey soil
internal friction versus % fine and coarse tire-chip
mixtures are shown in Figs. 8 and 9. Cohesion increases
as the % of tire-chips increase up to 40% for both fine
and coarse mixtures while the angle of internal friction
decrease. In other words, the more chips are added, the
more cohesion and the less angle of internal friction are
achieved until 40% tire-chips content. For example,
19 kPa cohesion of the pure clayey soil (0% mixture)
increases to 54 kPa for the fine and 56 kPa for the coarse
tire-chip mixtures at 40%. The 21 ° angle of internal
friction of the clayey soil (0% mixture), on the other
hand, decreases to 10 ° for the fine and 15 ° for the
coarse tire-chip mixtures at 40%. From 40% on,
however, while the cohesion decreases, the angle of
internal friction increases. The failure envelope first
rotates clockwise until 40% tire-chip mixtures, then it
rotates anticlockwise for both type of mixtures.
Figs. 5 and 6 also show the volumetric (vertical)
strain versus horizontal shear strain characteristics. The
vertical strain values under the selected normal pres-
sures for the clayey soil alone are all negative or com-
pression is taking place which is consistent with typical
normally consolidated clayey soils (Figs. 5a and 6a).
The fine and coarse tire-chips mixtures under the
normal pressure of 54 kPa does not show considerable
vertical strains or volume change during shear; slightly
negative vertical strain (compression) for the clayey soil
alone becomes nearly zero or slightly positive (dilation) Fig. 9. Change of (a) cohesion, (b) angle of internal friction as % tire-
(Figs. 5b–f and 6b–f ). However, originally high chips (fine and coarse) increase.
H. Cetin et al. / Engineering Geology 88 (2006) 110–120 119

alone as well as the fine and coarse tire-chip mixtures. maximum dry unit weight (γdry) of 15.79 kN/m3 is
Optimum moisture contents (Wopt ) at which the dry unit obtained at the optimum moisture content (Wopt) of
weights or densities (γdry) are highest were determined 19%. The dry unit weights for both the fine and coarse
first for the clayey soil alone, then, for comparison, for tire-chip mixtures decrease as the percent tire-chips
both the fine and coarse tire-chip mixtures. The results increase. They, for example, become 13.43 kN/m3 and
are shown in Fig. 10. For the clayey soil alone, the 12.50 kN/m3 for the suggested upper limit mixtures of
20% coarse grained tire-chips and 30% fine grained tire-
chips, respectively. The results indicate that the dry
densities of the tire-chip mixtures are less than the dry
density of typical soils including the clayey soil used in
this study. Such values show a good potential for using
the tire-chips as lightweight fill material.

4. Conclusions

The results indicate that the shear strengths increase


up to 30% for fine and 20% for coarse tire chip mixtures.
The higher the normal pressure the higher the shear
strength. Cohesion increases as the % of tire-chips
increase up to 40% for both fine and coarse mixtures
while the angle of internal friction decrease. After 40%,
however, while the cohesion decreases, the angle of
internal friction increases.
As the percent tire-chips increases, the fine and
coarse tire-chips mixtures under lower normal pressures
do not show considerable vertical strains or volume
change during shear. However, under higher normal
pressures, originally high negative vertical strains for
the clayey soil alone decrease considerably for the fine
tire-chip mixtures or become slightly above zero or
positive for the coarse tire-chips mixtures up to 50%.
Especially under higher normal pressures, the addition
of both fine and coarse tire-chips seem to decrease
vertical strains.
The permeabilities of the clayey soil and the mixtures
are consistent with typical low permeability clayey soils.
The permeabilities increase as the normal pressure
decreases and the % tire-chips increases. The permeabil-
ities of both the fine and coarse-grained tire-chips alone
are typical of sands which renders the use of tire-chips
alone or in combination with sand as a useful fill material
in embankments.
The compaction test results indicate that the dry
density of the tire-chip mixtures are less than the dry
density of typical soils including the clayey soil used in
this study. Such values show a good potential for using
the tire-chips as lightweight fill material.
Finally, the results indicate that the mixtures up to
20% coarse grained tire-chips and 30% fine grained
Fig. 10. Standard proctor test curve for the clayey soil alone and for tire-chips can be used above ground water tables where
fine (a) and coarse (b) grained tire-chips mixtures. The curve for the low weight, low permeability and high strength are
clayey soil alone was plotted on both a and b for comparison. needed in fills such as highway embankments, bridge
120 H. Cetin et al. / Engineering Geology 88 (2006) 110–120

abutments and backfills behind retaining structures Standards, pp. 582–595. American Society For Testing and
especially when they are to be built on weak foundation Materials, West Conshohocken, PA, 04.08.
Ahmed, I., 1993. Laboratory study on properties of rubber-soils. Joint
soils with low bearing capacity and high settlement Highway Research Project, Report No. FHWA/IN/JHRP-93/4.
problems. They should not be used where drainage is Indiana Dept. of Transportation-Dept. of Civil Engineering,
required to prevent the development of pore pressures Purdue University, West Lafayette, Ind. Indiana, p. 384.
during loading of fills under saturated conditions. In Cetin, H., Söylemez, M., 2004. Soil-particle and pore orientations
during drained and undrained shear of a cohesive sandy silt–clay
these cases, they may, however, be used by mixing with
soil. Canadian Geotechnical Journal 41, 1127–1138.
high permeability material such as sand and gravel. As Cedergren, H.R., 1989. Seepage, Drainage, and Flow Nets. John Wiley
also suggested by Masad et al. (1996), proper soil cover and Sons, New York, p. 465.
is needed on top and sides of embankments for safety Edil, T., Bosscher, P., 1994. Engineering properties of tire-chips and
against fire. Usage of tire-chips in this way will have a soil mixtures. Geotechnical Testing Journal 17, 453–464.
positive impact on the environment since large quantities Foose, G., Benson, C., Bosscher, P., 1996. Sand reinforced with
shredded waste tires. Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenviron-
can be consumed in these voluminous structures. mental Engineering 122, 760–767.
Holtz, R.D., Kovacs, W.D., 1981. An Introduction to Geotechnical
Acknowledgement Engineering. Prentice-Hall, Eaglewood Cliffs, N.J.
Humphrey, D.N., 1999. Civil engineering applications of tire shreds.
Part of this study was financially supported by the Proceedings of the Tire Industry Conference, Clemson University,
3–5 March.
Çukurova University Research Foundation (Project No: Lambe, T.W., 1951. Soil Testing for Engineers. John Wiley & Sons
FBE.97YL.96). The authors thank two anonymous Inc., New York, N.Y.
Engineering Geology reviewers for their critical review Lee, J.H., Salgado, R., Bernal, A., Lovell, C.W., 1999. Shredded tires
of the manuscript. Their invaluable comments improved and rubber–sand as lightweight backfill. Journal of Geotechnical
the manuscript considerably. We would also like to and Geoenvironmental Engineering 125, 132–141.
Liu, C., Evett, J.B., 1984. Soil Properties, Testing, Measurement and
thank Aysun Serin and Hikmet Senbayrak for their help Evaluation. Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey, p. 315.
in soil mechanics tests and Mustafa Laman for pro- Masad, E., Taha, R., Ho, C., Papagiannakis, T., 1996. Engineering
viding unlimited access to the soil mechanics laboratory properties of tire/soil mixtures as a lightweight fill. Geotechnical
of the Civil Engineering Deparment at Çukurova Testing Journal, GTJODJ 19, 297–304.
University. Sayarslan, M., Öner, F., Kapur, S., 1997. Chemical and mineralogical
composition of sediments in Güvenç village (Adana) area.
Geosound Yerbilimleri, Official Publication of the Association of
References Geological Engineering of Çukurova University. Special Issue,
vol. 30, pp. 717–724.
ASTM D 422-63, 2003. Standard test method for particle-size analysis Schmidt, G.C., 1961. Stratigraphic nomenclature for the Adana region
of soils. Annual Book of ASTM Standards, pp. 10–17. American petroleum district VII. Petroleum Administration Bulletin 6,
Society For Testing and Materials, West Conshohocken, PA 04.08. 47–63.
ASTM D 427-98, 2003. Standard test method for shrinkage factors of University of Wisconsin-Madison, 1995. Use of scrap tires in civil and
soils by the mercury method. Annual Book of ASTM Standards, environmental construction. Envir. Geotechnics Rep., vol. 95-2.
pp. 22–25. American Society For Testing and Materials, West Selected Publications from the University of Wisconsin-Madison,
Conshohocken, PA, 04.08. Madison, Wisconsin.
ASTM D 698-00a, 2003. Standard test methods for laboratory Yang, S., Lohnes, R.A., Kjartanson, B.H., 2002. Mechanical properties
compaction characteristics of soil using standard effort. Annual of shredded tires. Geotechnical Testing Journal 25, 44–52.
Book of ASTM Standards, pp. 78–87. American Society For Youwai, S., Bergado, D.T., 2004. Numerical analysis of reinforced
Testing and Materials, West Conshohocken, PA, 04.08. wall using rubber tire chips-sand mixtures as backfill material.
ASTM D 3080-98, 2003. Standard test method for direct shear test of Computers and Geotechnics 31, 103–114.
soils under consolidated drained conditions. Annual Book of Wu, W.Y., Benda, C.C., Cauley, R.F., 1997. Triaxial determination of
ASTM Standards, pp. 347–352. American Society For Testing and shear strength of tire chips. Journal of Geotechnical and
Materials, West Conshohocken, PA, 04.08. Geoenvironmental Engineering 123, 479–482.
ASTM D 4318-00, 2003. Standard test methods for liquid limit, plastic
limit, and plasticity index of soils. Annual Book of ASTM

You might also like