Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Expansive clay is a major source of heave induced structural distress. Swelling of expansive soils causes serious
problems and produce damages to many structures. Many research organizations are doing extensive work on waste
materials concerning the feasibility and environmental suitability. Fly ash, a waste by product from coal burning in thermal
power stations is abundant in India causing severe health, environmental and disposal problems. Attempts are made to
investigate the stabilization process with model test tracks over expansive subgrade in flexible pavements. Cyclic plate load
tests are carried out on the tracks with chemicals like lime and cement introduced in fly ash subbase laid on sand and
expansive subgrades. Test results show that maximum load carrying capacity is obtained for stabilized fly ash subbase
compared to untreated fly ash subbase.
Soils, which exhibit a peculiar alternate swell-shrink layer is relatively small, where by the above problems
behaviour due to moisture fluctuations, are known as can be eliminated. Fly ash settles less than 1% during
expansive soils. This behaviour is attributed to the the construction period and not afterwards. Its low
presence of clay minerals with expanding lattice density makes it suitable for high embankments12. Fly
structure. Among them, Montmorillonite clay mineral ash has a tendency to react with lime to form different
is very active and absorbs water many times more lime bearing silicates/aluminates hydrates due to its
than its volume. The soil is hard as long as it is dry pozzolanic properties. These hydrates possess
but loses its stability almost completely on wetting. cementitious properties and are responsible for the
On drying, the soil cracks very badly and in the worst development of strength in fly ash-lime compacts
cases, the width of cracks is almost 150 mm and which are used as structural products13.
travel down to 3 m below ground level1-4. Krupavaram14 had made an attempt to use lime
Fly ash is a waste by-product from thermal power stabilized fly ash subbase course in model field
plants, which use coal as fuel. It is estimated that pavement stretches. Cyclic plate load tests were
about 100 million tons of fly ash is being produced conducted on fly ash subbase and lime stabilized fly
from different thermal power plants in India ash subbase stretches constructed on different
consuming several thousand hectares of precious land subgrades (i.e., Sand and Expansive soil) and
for its disposal causing severe health and observed that lime stabilized fly ash stretch showed
environmental hazards5,6. In spite of continuous better performance in load carrying capacity and
efforts made and incentives offered by the reduction of heave laid on expansive soil subgrade.
government, hardly 5-10% of the produced ash is In another investigation15 an attempt was made to
being used for gainful purposes like brick making, use cement stabilized fly ash subbase course in field
cement manufacture, soil stabilization and as fill pavement stretches, and compared the performance
material7,8. In order to utilize fly ash in bulk with fly ash subbase. Cyclic plate load tests were
quantities, ways and means are being explored all conducted on fly ash subbase and cement stabilized
over the world to use it for the construction of fly ash subbase stretches constructed on different sub-
embankments and roads7,9-11. However, when it is grades (i.e., sand and expansive soil) and found that
used as subbase in flexible pavements, it is cement stabilized fly ash stretch had shown better
completely confined and also the thickness of such performance in load carrying capacity and reduction
—————— of heave compared to conventional stretch, laid on
*For correspondence (E-mail: gvrp_raju@yahoo.com) expansive soil subgrade.
270 INDIAN J. ENG. MATER. SCI., AUGUST 2009
Kumar et al.16 had conducted an experimental fly ash are given in Table 1 and the chemical
program to study the effects of fiber inclusions and properties in Table 2.
lime stabilization on geotechnical characteristics of
fly ash-soil mixtures. From the results it was observed Road metal
that the expansive soil can be successfully stabilized Road metal of size 20 mm conforming to
by the combined action of fibers, lime and fly ash. WBM – III was used as base course material.
Zha et al.17 studied the potential use and the Chemicals
effectiveness of stabilization of expansive soils using Different chemicals, viz., lime and cement were
fly ash and fly ash-lime as admixtures. The test results used as stabilizing materials in the experiment.
showed that the plasticity index, activity, free swell,
swell potential, swelling pressure and axial shrinkage Table 1—Properties of materials
percent decreased with an increase in fly ash or fly Properties Expansive Sand Fly ash
ash-lime content. soil
Rao et al.18 carried out a study on the performance Specific gravity 2.72 2.68 1.95
of lime stabilized fly ash cushion and found that it Grain-size distribution:
was quite effective in arresting volume changes in Gravel (%) 1
expansive soils. A fly ash cushion, stabilized with Sand (%) 4 96 25
10% lime and with thickness equal to half that of the
Silt (%) 34 70
active zone in an expansive soil bed, reduces heave by
Clay (%) 62 3 5
about 68% initially. With subsequent cycles of 3
Maximum dry density( kN/m ) 15.69 17.0 13.24
swelling and shrinkage the percentage reduction in
swelling is as much as 99.2%. O.M.C. (%) 23 10 24
Research was carried out by Rama Rao et al.19 Liquid limit (%) 75 25
using cement-stabilized fly ash as a cushioning Plastic limit (%) 35
material, on the expansive soil bed. The results Plasticity index (%) 40
showed that it was quite effective in arresting heave Shrinkage limit (%) 12
also fly ash cushion, stabilized with 10% cement with Free Swell Index (%) 150
thickness equal to that of the expansive soil bed IS Classification: CH SW
reduces heave by about 75% in the first instance and Soaked CBR (%) 2 10 8
at the end of fourth cycle of swelling, the reduction in Coefficient of uniformity(Cu) 6.15
the amount of heave is as high as 99.1%. Coefficient of Curvature(Cc) 1.24
In the present work, an attempt is made to study the Permeability (cm/sec) 1.5 × 10-7 2 × 10-3 0.5 × 10-6
performance of lime-cement stabilized fly ash layer in
subbase course of the flexible pavement system in
comparison to the fly ash subbase layer. Table 2— Chemical properties of fly ash (Courtesy VTPS,
Vijayawada)
Materials and Methods S.No. Name of chemical Symbol Range of % by
Expansive soil weight
The soil used for subgrade is expansive soil 1 Silica SiO2 61 to 64.29
collected from ‘Godilanka’ near Amalapuram, East 2 Alumina Al2O3 21.6 to 27.04
Godavari District. This soil is classified according to 3 Ferric oxide Fe2O3 3.09 to 3.86
I.S. classification as inorganic clay of high com- 4 Titanium dioxide TiO2 1.25 to 1.69
pressibility (CH). The properties are given in Table 1. 5 Manganese oxide MnO Up to 0.05
Sand 6 Calcium oxide CaO 1.02 to 3.39
The sand is used as subgrade material for the test 7 Magnesium oxide MgO 0.5 to 1.58
track. The properties obtained from the laboratory 8 Phosphorous P 0.02 to 0.14
tests are furnished below in Table 1. 9 Sulphur trioxide SO3 Up to 0.07
10 Potassium oxide K2O 0.08 to 1.83
Fly ash
Fly ash is used as subbase material collected from 11 Sodium oxide Na2O 0.26 to 0.48
Vijayawada thermal power station. The properties of 12 Loss of ignition 0.20 to 0.85
KUMAR & RAJU : FLEXIBLE PAVEMENT 271
Heave measurements in the laboratory alternative-1: fly ash subbase and alternative-2: lime-
The model flexible pavement system was saturated cement stabilized fly ash subbase is constructed on
completely by pouring water above the base course. expansive soil subgrade and also on sand subgrade.
Heave readings were taken with the help of dial Above all the subbase courses, WBM base course II is
gauges at regular intervals, for the expansive soil laid uniformly.
subgrade pavements. These readings were measured
Construction procedure of test track on expansive soil
until there was no significant change between subgrade
consecutive readings observed. Two alternative test tracks are prepared on
Cyclic load test in the laboratory
expansive soil subgrade, with different subbases the
These tests were carried out on flexible pavements details of which are presented below.
systems in a circular steel tank of diameter 60 cm as Fly ash subbase (alternative – 1)
shown in Figs 1 and 2. The loading was done through Excavation of test pit — A trench of size 3 m long
a circular metal plate of 10 cm diameter laid on the and 1.5 m wide is excavated to an average depth of
model pavement system. The steel tank was placed on
the pedestal of the compression testing machine. A
50 kN capacity proving ring was connected to the
loading frame and the extension rod welded to the
circular plate was brought in contact with proving
ring. Two dial gauges of least count 0.01 mm were
placed on the metal flats welded to the vertical rod to
measure the vertical displacements of the loading
plate. The load was applied in increments
corresponding to type pressures of 500, 560, 630, 700
and 1000 kPa and so on and for each pressure
increment was applied, cyclically, until there was
insignificant increase in the settlement of the plate
between successive cycles. The testing was further
continued till the occurrences of failure to record the
ultimate loads.
For tests in saturated condition, the soil was
allowed to absorb water by providing a thin sand layer
(10 mm thick) at the bottom and also through vertical Fig. 1—Test set-up for the cyclic load test in the laboratory
sand drains. Two inlet valves are welded on opposite
sides of the tank through which water was supplied.
The dial gauge readings were recorded until
maximum heave was obtained and during this
process, proving ring was disconnected. Cyclic load
tests were also carried out in saturated state exactly in
the same manner as for those at OMC. These tests
were carried out at OMC and in saturated states for all
the model flexible pavements.
Field Experimentation
In this investigation four test tracks of 3 m long and
1.5 m wide are laid on expansive soil subgrade and on
sand subgrade as shown in the Fig. 3 in the campus of
JNTU Engineering College. Out of the four test
tracks, the two test tracks with expansive soil
subgrade and other two test tracks with sand subgrade
are considered. The two alternative subbases, viz., Fig. 2—Laboratory cyclic load test apparatus
KUMAR & RAJU : FLEXIBLE PAVEMENT 273
steel plate of diameter 0.3 m. A loading frame was heave. It is observed that there is a maximum
loaded with the help of sand bags as shown in Fig. 4. reduction in heave for lime-cement stabilized subbase
The loading frame was arranged centrally over the model flexible pavement system compared to fly ash
test track. A steel base plate of 0.3 m diameter was model flexible pavement.
placed centrally over the test pit. Hydraulic jack of
capacity 500 kN was placed over the plate attached to Load test results
the loading frame with a loading cylinder. Three dial It can be observed from Fig. 6 that load carrying
gauges with a least count of 0.01 mm were placed on capacity is significantly increased for lime cement
the metal flats to measure the settlements. A load of stabilized fly ash alternative in comparison with fly
5 kPa was applied as a seating load with the help of ash alternative for both subgrades. The improvement
hydraulic jack and released. The load was applied in in the load carrying capacity could be attributed to the
increments corresponding to tyre pressures of 500, improved load dispersion through stabilized subbase
560, 630, 700 and 1000 kPa and each pressure on to the subgrade.
increment was applied cyclically until there was Results of field studies
insignificant increase in the settlement of the plate. In-situ heave-time studies
These tests were carried out on all the prepared The influence of different alternatives laid on
stretches in both dry and wet seasons. The process of expansive subgrade in respect of heave is shown in
loading and unloading for each pressure intensity was Fig. 7. From Fig. 7, it is observed that the maximum
continued in a cyclic manner until difference in heave values are 5.96 mm and 2.42 mm for the test
deformation level between successive cycles was track stretches with fly ash and lime-cement fly ash
negligibly small. subbase respectively. It can be seen that there is a
maximum reduction in heave values for lime-cement
Results and Discussion stabilized fly ash subbase with respect to fly ash
Laboratory test results
subbase.
Soaked CBR tests for lime-cement-fly ash mixes
are conducted in the laboratory. Based on the results,
it is observed that mix having 2% lime + 0.5% cement
in fly ash is giving a soaked CBR value of 20%,
which is desirable for subbase material as per IRC
37-200121.
Heave-time studies
Figure 5 depicts the influence of different treatment
alternatives laid on expansive subgrade in respect of
7 Murty A V S R., Utilization of fly ash for Embankment 16 Arvind Kumar et al., J Mater Civil Eng, 9(3) (2007) 242-
Construction, Proc of Experience sharing Meet on Use of fly ash 248.
in Roads and Embankments, CRRI New Delhi, 1998, 15-20. 17 Zha Fusheng, Liu Songyu, DuYanjun & Cui Kerui,
8 Boominathan A & Hari S, Behaviour of fly ash under static J Natural Hazards, (April, 2008).
and cyclic loading Proc IGC-99, Calcutta, 1999, 324-326 18 Rao, Rao & Babu, J Ground Improv, 161 (2008) 23-29.
9 Hausmann M R, Engineering Principles of Ground 19 Rama Rao M, Sree Rama Rao A & Dayakar Babu R,
Modification (Mc Graw-Hill, Publication. Co., New York), J Geotech Geolog Eng, 26(2) (2008) 189-197.
1990.
20 IS: 2720 PART XVI: 1979 “Methods of Test for Soils”
10 Veerendra Singh, Narendra Kumar & Devendra Mohan, Use
Laboratory Determination of CBR, Bureau of Indian
of fly ash in soil stabilization for Roads, Proc IGC-96,
Standards, May 1988, 3-12.
Madras, 1996, 411-414.
11 Boominathan & Ratna Kumar, Lime treated fly ash as 21 IRC 37-2001, Guide Lines for the Design of Flexible
embankment material, Proc IGC-96, Madras, 1996, 523-526. Pavements.
12 Irene Smith, Proc Uses of Coal Fly ash—Benefits and 22 Sree Rama Rao A, Seelam Prasad, Madhuri Manmadha B &
Barriers ccc/96, ISBN 92-9029-411-6 (2005) 30 Dayakara Babu, Use of cement-stabilized fly ash cushion in
13 Maitra, Das S, Das A K & Basumajumdar, Bull Mater Sci, minimizing swell of expansive clays, IGC-2003, Roorkee,
28(7) (2005), 697-702. December 2003.
14 Krupavaram A, Utilization of fly ash layer as subbase course 23 Sudhakar M V, A comparative study on arresting heave of
in flexible pavement construction, M.Tech.Thesis, JNTU expansive soil with stabilized CNS and fly ash cushions,
College of Engineering, Kakinada, 2004. M.Tech Thesis, JNTU College of Engineering, Kakinada,
15 Anil Kumar B, Use of cement stabilized fly ash layers as 2002.
subbase course in flexible pavement construction on different 24 Nanda Kishore Y, Studies on minimizing heave of expansive
subgrades, M.Tech Thesis, JNTU College of Engineering, clays with Lime stabilized Fly ash cushion, M.Tech. Thesis,
Kakinada, 2005. JNTU College of Engineering, Kakinada, 2003.